Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Chand Tora??

Chand Tora??

Quest4Akal · 22 Jan 2005

I'm confused about the Chand Tora. Some singhs told me not to wear it because it originated from the nihang singhs and it has somethign to do with shiva. I stopped using it because i wasn't sure if they were right or not, so i wanted to be safe. Now I came across this http://www.shastarvidiya.org/htmls/misappropriations_realdeal.html as you have probably guessed its the website that belongs to our friendly neighbourhood u.k nangs. So after seeing this i'm determined not to wear this symbol especially because its on their website. What does the sangat think of wearing this symbol.

Re: Chand Tora??

Anon Singh · 23 Jan 2005

Just because the UK Nangs do some weird stuff it doesnt mean you do the opposite of them. There is nothing wrong with wearing Chand Tora. Bhai Fauja Singh wore it. Many Gursikhs have.

Re: Chand Tora??

Mkhalsa · 23 Jan 2005

The uk nangs have twisted the meaning of chandtora, this doesnt mean its against gurmat!! they just have no idea what it means and make up all this rubbish to support their pro hindu agenda. There have been many discussions on the meaning of chandtora both here and on sikhsangat. I suggest you do some research. I saw a very good post awhile back I think it was on sikhsangat, I cant quite remember it. The point of it is that chands were not made by jewlers but rather by blacksmiths. It was easier for them to make a chand shape rather than two small kirpans and weld them together, it would have also created issues for strength and durability.

Re: Chand Tora??

me · 23 Jan 2005

these days we are becoming a bunch of followers....all we say to back anything up is "So and So did it, so it's ok"....i'm not saying its wrong to wear one or not...i'm saying don't just say that because someone wore it, then its ok

Re: Chand Tora??

Mandeep Singh · 23 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf sorry, im the ignorant one here: what is 'chand tora'? Bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh

Re: Chand Tora??

BirRaas Singh · 23 Jan 2005

Mkhalsa wrote "The point of it is that chands were not made by jewlers but rather by blacksmiths. It was easier for them to make a chand shape rather than two small kirpans and weld them together, it would have also created issues for strength and durability." if the "shape" is indeed 2 kirpana welded together, why is it called a chand??

Re: Chand Tora??

Mkhalsa · 24 Jan 2005

>>why is it called a chand??<< because it looks like one?

Re: Chand Tora??

Quest4Akal · 24 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh I would like to thank the sangat for its thoughts and comments. Mkhalsa I will check out the section on this topic, thank you for your help. I would also like to respond to annon singh wrote: "Just because the UK Nangs do some weird stuff it doesnt mean you do the opposite of them. There is nothing wrong with wearing Chand Tora. Bhai Fauja Singh wore it. Many Gursikhs have." I'm not not wearing the chand tora because they wear it. I said i'm gonna stop wearing it cause the reasoning that i heard was proved right by their website. And I believe wearing a chand tora cause its linked to shiva is totally wrong. Thats why i said i wasn't going to wear it. However after reading some of these responses i will check the section on Chand toras and then make my decision.

Re: Chand Tora??

Anon Singh · 24 Jan 2005

If wearing the Chand was Anti-Gurmat, why would so many Gurmukhs wear it? Do you think at their level they did not know what was Gurmat and what wasnt? If the Chand represents the power of Shiv, so what? Are you going to remove all references to Hindu Gods from Guru Ji? Are you worshipping Shiv by placing this on your Dastar? Or is it symbolic of the destructive power of Guru's Singh?

Re: Chand Tora??

Mkhalsa · 24 Jan 2005

Here is the thread I think I mentioned: [url]http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=8421&st=0[/url] you want to especially read the replies by navjot singh (i think end of 2nd page, some of 3rd page)

Re: Chand Tora??

Quest4Akal · 25 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Annon singh maybe its just me but i sense a little hostility in your post. I never said it was wrong to wear the Chand Tora. I am only searching for answers. If great gurmukhs wore it thats fine i didn't know bhai fauja singh wore this symbol. So if i have offended you in anyway (can't see how i did) I apologize. As for your comment "Are you worshipping Shiv by placing this on your Dastar? Or is it symbolic of the destructive power of Guru's Singh?" I don't know maybe you are worshipping shiv by putting this on your dastar IF THATS What the symbol means. And if that is the case (not saying it is) I believe its wrong. Anyways thank you so very much Mkhalsa for the link, you have been very helpful and i apreciate that. I will check it out. Waheguru Ang Sang

Re: Chand Tora??

Anon Singh · 25 Jan 2005

There is 0 "hostility" in my post I am trying to make you think by posing questions to you since I asked myself the same questions a while ago. Singh you need to realise there are so many parallels between attributes of Shiva and the Khalsa Singh. If you reject these you are ignoring the truth. You do not need to be part of the "UK Nangs" to notice these. Perhaps we should change Khalsa colour of blue (since it is Shiva's colour) remove the Farla from Nihangs (parallel with fountain from Shiva's joora) remove all shasters from Sikhi since they are also representative of the destructive aspect of God. Sikhs need to stop being so paranoid of so called "Brahmin" concepts and Hinduism in general. Why don't you read Dasam Granth and read Chandi Di Var. By placing the symbol of Shiv on the Singhs dastar Guru Ji is placing the Singh on the level of Shiv, not making him worship Shiv.