Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Mandeep · 13 Jan 2005

Hey, i would like to know the views and opinions of caste based alliegences in Sikh gurdwaras. I would like to know where you think Sikhism is heading in the 21st century and whether you think what is happening is a good thing or do Sikhs need to change? I am covering this topic for my disseration and would appreciate your views, thank you

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Cools · 13 Jan 2005

Another 10 to 20 years and the caste based Gurdwaras will not exist in the West. Once the present Gurdwara Committees die then the future non-amritdharis will not be interested in running the Gurdwaras. So that leaves the present amritdhari youth most of all do not accept the caste system anyway. But in answer to your question, the unfortunate answer is 'Yes'.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 13 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. imho..dont wait 10 30 years....take over the gurdwars NOW and demolish the caste system. Waiting never solved anything. IMHO the "caste" is not in the Gurdwaras..it is in the Committees who run them Jarnail Singh

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

singh · 13 Jan 2005

Singh Sabhas have already abolished the caste system. The Gurdwaras mentioned are few and far between.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

_JoDhA_GuRdAsPuRiA · 16 Jan 2005

the ravidas gurdwara in wolves advertised in punjab times do not allow any sant to sit on stage or preach in their gurdwara. They have good and bad points. We should do kirtan in all gurdwaras this helps break caste down, gives others a sense of belonging, and allows opportunity to meet rehetvan sikh, give them sangat, give them kirtan laha, so they know what it means to be a sikh and maybe one day work toward amrit and take caste name off the gurdwara. Wishful thinking perhaps! But the sikh spirit is never say die! Ramgharia gurdwaras i attend, , i think most akj england sangat do too on samagams. Caste exist more in our brain through ignorance and manmade boundary than in gurdwaras. Some bzurg tell us so and so caste dont keep to khalsa rehat, we then end up basing stereotyped casteified assumptions due to the rehat created by a caste gurdwara, but because other castes are extremely low numbers the social exposure of amritdharis from other castes will be limited with no centralised structure .They will be overlooked and their gurdwara constitutions, manifest existance of the caste name on the gurdwara door will form the end picture without any real substance to the people coming from those caste. I can confirm many punjabi durkhan do go singh sabhas whichever is convenient. Gurdwara is gurdwara. Best way to get rid of caste is to marry in different castes provided the partner is following what you follow. I am the lowest of the low jheer who will b marrying a high caste jatt gurl next year, we havent taken amrit yet but have talked about it and will take steps towards it. I one day wish to perform kirtan on stage with my wife and children, i hope this dream can come true and we can show the world mixed marriages will be a success in sikhi and send out a strong message to destroy caste system into tiny little tookrai shred by shred into the bin where it belong. At first her family didnt like the idea of me and her marrying because they had impression jheers were not leading clean lives, and werent proper sikhs. When they actually met me in person i explained to them what i want in life, how i live, how my family are, amongst other things then they actually came to like me for who i was and realised that not all jheers are backward. The family could have been mistaken to be castist but they were not they just wanted their daughter to marry a person who lived a sikh life and not just in name and when they met me they took a liking to me. So i would suggest we socialise more with other castes and help break the misconceptions down. The more people have held onto caste the more it has actually started to crack. All the youth i know dont care about caste, the only people that hang onto it are either old people, those trying to preserve religion with culture and strangely enough some religious people. Society is different now if we cared to get out of our small ghettoes.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 17 Jan 2005

Jodha Gurdaspuria- you wrote "the ravidas gurdwara in wolves advertised in punjab times do not allow any sant to sit on stage or preach in their gurdwara. They have good and bad points". If this is the Ravidass gurdwara on Dudley Road (Blakenhall), I can give you some of their bad points- they regularly have guys standing right outside the front door smoking cigarettes. These people aren't just passers by (as the temple is on a main road), but people who have "popped out for a quick one." This particular temple has a "community centre" of the same name, right opposite, which is hired out for weddings, parties etc, where meat, alcohol is consumed. How can any Gursikh go to one of these so called gurdwaras anyway- the FLAG is NOT a nishaan sahib. There is NO khanda in sight, NO ik onkaar. Correct me if I am wrong, but don't we believe in BHAGAT Ravidass, not GURU Ravidass? Baajan Wale Da Chela

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

.. · 17 Jan 2005

pardeep singh jio the exact same thing you describe happens in ramgharia gurdwara slough, yet the annual samagam is usually slotted here for a day ever since i can remember. Quick question is there any singh sabhas with halls used for weddings? What should be the solution in your eyes dear veerji? should we totally cut the minority gurdwaras off or establish talks with them directly on maryada?

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

uk singh · 17 Jan 2005

'Best way to get rid of caste is to marry in different castes provided the partner is following what you follow' I do not agree with this statement. To eradicate caste, you need people to follow Sikhi. Best thing to do is to marry a person who is right for you. Caste is irrelevant.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

hayr · 19 Jan 2005

i thenk we should only marry in caste. Your blood must be pure you need to know who you are and pass it to your children. We have proud tradition, jatt marry jatt you terkan stick to terkan it how it is you are what you are born dont try to mix the two just accept yourself. I will never let my daughter marry other caste well son its mazboori but i would not like it.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

caste is wrong · 19 Jan 2005

why is caste a mans thing? i never seen or heard of a kaur into it or even pay attension to it. maybe bhenjis see something men do not, we could learn more!

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 20 Jan 2005

Hmmm...am I "Ramgharia"? No, a "Republican". But I didn't vote for Pres. Bush if that's what you are asking. Oh, no, you didn't mean Republican you meant Ramgharia? Hmm...No, not Ramgharia...perhaps you meant "redhead"? Yes, I have reddish color hair. My dad was red, you know. I have his color hair. What, you still meen Ramgharia? Hmmm...I looked that up on Dictionary.com and couldn't find a definition. References to the Caste system are ludicrous for someone like me, who is very dedicated to Gurbani and Sikhi and Seva but is not of Indian origin. As more of us westerners of all colors and backgrounds discover the TRUTH that is Sikhi, this will make Casteism even more irrelevant. My Panjabi is limited, but I think Guru Nanak's message is perfectly clear.

Re: do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia)

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 20 Jan 2005

In response to .. "What should be the solution in your eyes dear veerji? should we totally cut the minority gurdwaras off or establish talks with them directly on maryada?" How can we call these Gurdwaras? Like I said, they do NOT believe in the basic principles of Sikhi- 10 Gurus, and jyot of 10 Gurus, dhan dhan sahib sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaj. They are NOT minority Gurdwaras because there are no minoritites in Sikhi. Trying to have talks with them would be a bit difficult- imagine how many "Guru Ravidass Temples" there are in the UK- would they really change the name of the temple for a start? It would be like telling a Church or Mandir to change their name to "Guru Nanak...." or "Singh Sabha..." I am sure the Gursikhs out there who hail from the non-Jatt castes go to the usual "Gursikh Gurdwaras" i.e. mainstream Sikh beliefs. Bhul chuk maaf