Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

MEAT

MEAT

Singh · 12 Jan 2005

WHY IS THERE A SPLIT IN THE SIKH RELIGION WITH REGARDS TO EATING MEAT! WHY ISN'T THIS SOLVED ONCE AND FOR ALL -

Re: MEAT

hmmm · 12 Jan 2005

both sides believe their right and present evidences, but recently on sikhsangat some singh had a list of old puratan text sources that were all against meat eating. whoever that person is please post that here. It would be interesting to see what the meat lobby say about that as they always defend their stance with old sources too. So this would mean one side has to be right. most people eat meat and few jathebandis dont, big split. personally i been a meat eater years back and i found it harder to concentrate on paat i felt restless mind wandered agitated as if i was looking for something it wudnt sit still. Its not that an average joes mind doesnt wander, but what i mean is no matter how much paat or simran i did i was back to square one and then i ended up asking myself why??? when i stopped meat i felt a load lighter things got better, i felt happier, and closer to sikhi things just started falling in place and i realised from both worlds which one worked for me.

Re: MEAT

Cools · 12 Jan 2005

Let's face it everyone (all the major Jathabandhis) say that an amritdhari cannot eat meat. In the UK Punj Pyaray from the following Jathas groups will blatantly tell you not to eat meat :AKJ, Taksal, Nanaksar,RaraSahib ,GNNSJ (Nishkam Jatha), Most (if not all) Sant related groups. So the only people that promote meat eating are SGPC or Sanatan (Nangs).

Re: MEAT

Dil · 12 Jan 2005

VJKK,VJKF; This has been always a controvercial topic since the sikh relegion came to existance. I my self is vegetarian and complete family from grand parents onwards had been vegetraian. Still I am of the opinion that there should not be any restriction on any body in sikh religion regarding eating meat. 1) There are some references in the past that it had been even served in Langar also. 2) Non of the guru ji gave any strict instruction to stop eating meat, yes every one instructed not to smoke, paan, wine or any sort of nashaa. 3) Even in guru granth sahib it advised repeat advised by bhagats and gurus not to eat meat and also endorsed why it is not good to eat meat but no instruction repeat no instruction has been passed against eating meat. 4) Sikhism is a martial race and khalsa had been sant soldier. So if any one cannot do jhatka of goat or murgi then he cannot kill an enemy at all. Here I would like to mention that I cannot see myself killing some animal in front of me. Eating meat is distinct thing. So how I can say that I can be a good soldier. 5) As we keep moving towards santism and start doing simran we shall realise that we will get an urge from inner concious to stop all these tastes and stop eating meet. 6) It is to emphasize that only northern India is a place in the world where we find cearls and pulses ( vegetarian diet) readly available. Later as I expect that sikhism to grow all over the world. All the people who live near sea, have to depend on sea food only. So if we pass the resolution permanently to stop eating meat, it means we are trying to restrict the growth of sikhism. I hope that I did not hurt any one. I need expert opinion on my views. VJKK,VJKF;

Re: MEAT

Harsimrat Kaur · 12 Jan 2005

Gurfateh I was wondering, if your parents were forcing you to eat meat then what would you do to stop them, because only do i not want to eat meat because of gursikhi but alos i don't like it at all. Thanks Singh wrote:

Re: MEAT

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 13 Jan 2005

Dil wrote, Even in guru granth sahib it advised repeat advised by bhagats and gurus not to eat meat and also endorsed why it is not good to eat meat but no instruction repeat no instruction has been passed against eating meat. So if it is written in sri guru granth saahib jee the nuksaans of eating meat why would you eat it. if somebody told me that by doing this, there will be this consequence, i wouldnt do it.

Re: MEAT

A. Singh · 13 Jan 2005

WJKK WJKF mwsu mwsu kir mUrKu JgVy igAwnu iDAwnu nhI jwxY ] The fools argue about flesh and meat, but they know nothing about meditation and spiritual wisdom. kauxu mwsu kauxu swgu khwvY iksu mih pwp smwxy ] What is called meat, and what is called green vegetables? What leads to sin? gYNfw mwir hom jg kIey dyviqAw kI bwxy ] It was the habit of the gods to kill the rhinoceros, and make a feast of the burnt offering. mwsu Coif bYis nku pkVih rwqI mwxs Kwxy ] Those who renounce meat, and hold their noses when sitting near it, devour men at night. PVu kir lokW no idKlwvih igAwnu iDAwnu nhI sUJY ] They practice hypocrisy, and make a show before other people, but they do not understand anything about meditation or spiritual wisdom. WJKK WJKF

Re: MEAT

Mkhalsa · 13 Jan 2005

I had just recently written something on this topic: Relative Morality Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh! I just went to a chinese store with a Singh and they were selling some disgusting things. Baby Octopus, all sorts of parts of different animals etc.. So this brought up, is morality relative? I say: No. Gurmat says: No. A canibal may think it is perfectly alright to eat another human's flesh, just as a meat eater may think it is moral to eat meat of another animal, letting it suffer in pain. But after leaving that store today, I have come to the conclusion that anyone that eats meat is immoral and heartless. I know that may be a mean thing to say, but seeing the way people can treat animals and chew on flesh that might just as well be their own, I cannot help but say that. To me, one who eats the meat of an animal is the exact same as one who eats the meat of a human. They look the same to me. Do they not bleed the same blood? sweat the same sweat? cry the same tears? Gurmat is on my side on this and my heart is pained (and my mind grossed out) whenever I see others eating meat. I'm not going to bore you with a long lecture on why its wrong or everything guru sahib says about it. So, in conclusion, meat eaters are immoral and heartless and theres no way around it.

Re: MEAT

hmmm · 13 Jan 2005

cools what you say is right in terms of outside india but within it most sikhs do eat meat. i dont think theres many veggies in punjab and delhi ( maybe not many sikhs either). the strangest thing is there are some of the sgpc types my uncle is one and eats meat. He spends all his time at the gurdwara after work, he dedicates 2 days out of the week for projects that he says is giving back to the community, giving hefty donations himself to the gurughar where he could have spent the money on himself, out of his own pay packet, he believes in khoji like studieing what you are, your history, and what it means to be a sikh he feels is over and above naam simran. The guy even has guru granth sahib around his house and reads from it 5am every morning and participates in sikh campaigns over the east coast of america. im not saying its right to eat meat because i dont eat it and dont believe you should but saying the lifestyle of one of my uncles who does, and i cant understand what keeps that kinda people ticking ie how comes he does nitnem everyday without fail amritvela, keeping maryada (except for meat), strongly participating in community development efforts outside punjab. I cant debate with him hes got a temper on him and tried it before. But i remember eating meat and for me it distracted me from bhagti path and prooved destructive, i dunno maybe its different for some people and not for me but i will still be against it especially when you look at the life of a dog you see a jaan inside it, i think if we went to a chicken farm and saw live chickens instread of dead ones we would think twice.

Re: MEAT

Cools · 13 Jan 2005

Meat was NEVER served in Guru Ka Langar. There are various Sikh Historians who make these false claims. People of the SGPC or Sanatan backgrounds make these false claims so they can justify their 'Jhatka' burgers and manmat lifstyle. Read 'Why Kill a Chicken?' by Joginder Singh Talwara. It is a good eye opener. There is also a good Katha on Gursikhijeevan.com by Baba Isher Singh Rarewale about the perils of meat eating. Anyone who has had the misfortune of witnessing the cruel ceremony of performing Jhatka on a poor Goat will question how these people can claim our Gurus allowed this barbaric act. Jhatka is as bad as Halaal. Both are claiming the life of defenseless creature for the sake of fullfilling man's tastebuds. It's MANMAT through and through.

Re: MEAT

Search For Tat · 13 Jan 2005

Can you please provide these refrences, I have never read any? Dil wrote: > 1) There are some references in the past that it had been even > served in Langar also. Also : > 2) Non of the guru ji gave any strict instruction to stop > eating meat, yes every one instructed not to smoke, paan, wine > or any sort of nashaa. There are some, I will have to get them out. > 3) Even in guru granth sahib it advised repeat advised by > bhagats and gurus not to eat meat and also endorsed why it is > not good to eat meat but no instruction repeat no instruction > has been passed against eating meat. Is advising not enough? > 4) Sikhism is a martial race and khalsa had been sant soldier. > So if any one cannot do jhatka of goat or murgi then he cannot > kill an enemy at all. Never stopped the babbars or Binderwalas singhs. This is a really stupid argument and simply not true. Only the meat eaters like nihangs ran off or did not turn up.

Re: MEAT

Cools · 13 Jan 2005

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -'Author: Dil Date: 01-12-05 09:12 4) Sikhism is a martial race and khalsa had been sant soldier. So if any one cannot do jhatka of goat or murgi then he cannot kill an enemy at all. Here I would like to mention that I cannot see myself killing some animal in front of me. Eating meat is distinct thing. So how I can say that I can be a good soldier'- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Does that mean that all the butchers of the world are brave soldiers because they are able to kill a defenceless animal? It's easy to kill a Goat or a Chicken or a Mouse. You don't have much of a fight , just pull out your kirpan and chop them in one go. Does this make someone brave??? Or a coward??? Five Nihangs holding a screaming Goat while one Nihang chops the Goats head off. The act Brave Saint Soldier!? I think not!!

Re: MEAT

J Singh · 13 Jan 2005

MKhalsa wrote: "I have come to the conclusion that anyone that eats meat is immoral and heartless. I know that may be a mean thing to say, but seeing the way people can treat animals and chew on flesh that might just as well be their own, I cannot help but say that. To me, one who eats the meat of an animal is the exact same as one who eats the meat of a human. They look the same to me. Do they not bleed the same blood? sweat the same sweat? cry the same tears?" I agree with you to an extent but we all are guilty. Do you drink milk ? If you do, then you better do some research and see how these animals are treated. You will be surprised. Life or death setense? Take you pick. Do you eat honey, wheat, rice, fruit, vegetables or any other grains? If you do then you better do little homework to find out how much life is destroyed to get these delicacies to your plate! If our eyes can't see billions of lives being destroyed to bring food to our battas, it doesn't mean that it's not happening. Ever heard of pesticides and herbicides? Ever used any medication? Lots of these species also suffer and feel pain! Now on a lighter note, I have never seen a lion (singh) eat grass. He always let's his lioness do most of the work while he just chills, and takes the biggest share of the hunt! (this is meant to be a joke.. not trying to offend anyone!) No, I don't eat meat. VJKK VJKF

Re: MEAT

singh · 13 Jan 2005

Personally, I'm of the view that if you have acheived a high spiritual avastha then the Tamo gun in you, will be noticed if you consume maas. But for people who have not reached a stage where their senses become heightened I do not think it will make much of a difference. Ultimately the maryada is your guide - follow it and you cannot go wrong. There is no point arguing whether it is right or wrong, until the 'Panth' and not individual Jathe pen a new version.

Re: MEAT

Mkhalsa · 14 Jan 2005

End the discussion, Guru Sahib has the final word: Maas Muchee Dae Nerae Nehi Avanaa -Hukamanama Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee

Re: MEAT

singh · 14 Jan 2005

thanks MKhalsa. I was not aware of this Hukamnama. In the end the Panth collectively decided what was right and wrong. True some major figures walked out when the Maryada was being decided, but they are not the collective Panth. So we should follow this as close as possible, until a new draft is compiled.

Re: MEAT

Amar · 14 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf eating meat is a krehit, if u eat meat u can do as much paath, seva, simran as u like but if u continue to eat meat u will inevitably go to hell, Therefore its pretty dumb to eat meat wjkk wjkf

Re: MEAT

ji · 14 Jan 2005

no offence amar but i dont think a meat eater will give a toss about you preaching that their going hell for eating meat when they been eating it all their life. With all due respect i understand where your coming from but it wont work. I reckon its better to look at it from a practical angle let the meat eaters talk about their personal experiences with meat and abstaining from it during periods when they do simran and bani and see the difference. let the experience talk out of them and i gaurantee you they will deep inside know that meat doesnt allow them to spiritually progress it builds a metaphorical heat up inside a person thats hard to explain theres definatly a barrier to eating meat and bhagti. But i wish people try to talk about it more openly so we dont have the usual debates not always about whats right and wrong but what spiritual benefits does one get out of meat if any? if none then is it worth gambling our futures?

Re: MEAT

eye witness accounts · 14 Jan 2005

There are eye witness accounts from the 18th century, some fifty-to-eighty years after Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji left this earth, of sikhs being portrayed as meat eaters. These accounts are by Swiss, English, Mulslim and French men...The choice of meat always seems to be a wild boar, which they would have hunted...? Are we saying that whilst some sikh elders whom would have been alive to have done darshan of Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, would not have been able to tell those that seem to have been eating meat, that this was not the wish of of Guru Ji?Are we to say that the hunting expeditions that some our guru's organised, that those animals would be left for the village dogs? The issue is the BRITISH and the RAJ. Whilst ruling most of india for nearly fifty years, punjab was still under sikh rule, until after the two sikh wars, at which point it was handed over by an eight year old dileep singh...(we all know the story), but it was the british who applauded the sikhs courage and strength/valor in both the wars, knowing too well that without deciet they would have most certainly lost both the wars...so to make sure this nation, which could un-do all the hard work of the east india company, what better way than to weaken them, a tactic the english are famous for. Firstly: the british were firm believes that from eating flesh did one become phyiscally strong, therefore lets us help confuse these people into believing that the eating of the flesh, is against sikh maryada (something which was influenced by the kashmiri brahmins who were converting into sikhi, but refusing to eat meat...!) this way in battle, they would be a negative effect. How much ? Secondly: The Sant/ Baba issue was promoted by the british. For it would be easlier to control these people if they would follow a 'pope' like figure. Both the Bedi and Sodhi's were explored, with baba khem singh bedi took the lead....the rest is history.. To concluded, meat eating i feel is not against true sikhi marayada. I personally am a vegetarian. Lets us not always brush off historical documentation by others as being twisted for some sublime use...lets face the facts that our recent history is not as pretty as some wouls like it to be when told in gurdwara's... Kulbir Singh Dhillon - UK wala

Re: MEAT

jumbo jalandari · 14 Jan 2005

but kulbir singh ji life aint just about being a warrior ? theres so much more than chopping people up or having a fracus. but even looking at that the singhs of post 1984 theve prooved that vegetarian singhs can take on the faujs of entire nation. i herd bhai avtar singh bramha would challenge fauja and police from rooftops, bhai gurcharan singh manochahal and dr singh ji took on summit like 5000 army in one encounter alone. ddt akj singhs were at the front both are vegetarian and believe in sant sipahi role of a sikh. i have herd the line before that if you cant chop the head of a goat how will you chop an enemies head? this is a very vague remark. The radaswami leaders bodygaurd is an undercover hitman hes a staunch vegetarian and renowned by respected underworld figuires of a country. Its all about mindset and pschycology training . Taking the life of an animal isnt the only way. I have met guys bought up on veg diets like mental pchyopaths in a fight the kind that would do savage things if theres no other way to defend themselves. whats inside a person isnt goverened by a principle of chopping a goat or not. Its not essential to eat meat to be a warrior and it wouldnt make meat eaters better unless prooven otherwise. but if a person does eat it thats upto them i wouldnt stop them.

Re: MEAT

.. · 15 Jan 2005

ive also read old eye witness accounts of sikhs ( so called) drinking alcohol in large quantities during the misal periods and that is a stark contradiction to gurbanis instruction to abstain from booze. These eye witness accounts open up a can of worms for those of us who believed people only became sikhs to give their heads. During the rise of sikh political power the north indian and pakistani region was facing a destined revolution and transfer of hands from centuries old aristocrats. Every tom and dick and harinder then setting himself up as a sardar but during the extremities of tight moghul rule, the era when only those who lived by the standards of gurbani were adopting sikhi because only they would have the passion to live and die by something they followed and loved. Just because people were becoming sikhs in the later era didnt mean they totally adopted sikhism fully or eradicated their past cultural habits. We have to stop studieing sgpc history books, related pictures and put two and two together sometimes. Early day converts were not just sikhs who came to the Gurus call surrendering everything, but after the Gurus transfer to Gurbani, sikhs came from many different regions and groups with their own distinct practices and meat was sometimes one of them. Amrit wasnt the sole reason why people would become sikhs in the later periods because thats the way the power was heading. Just like today we have sikhs allowing themselves into dera cults, rss and muslims. People dont just walk over and pick a religion like a new toy they go where the power comes to better their lot. You get very few real genuine practicing people left out of it. And now we realise this is happening around us so and so bedi down the road wants to become a muslim because he fears islam is growing hel get 10 grand out of it helps pay for the new car, a big back up posse and muslims he gets to rely on ( real case i seen). Other examples are deras masiv political financial clout in certain parts of punjab like beas region radaswamis are running the show so now you will get local sikhs ready to give up and walk that way unless they really love sikhi that much theyd die for it. I hope i didnt offend anyone here but trying to decipher that practicing sikhs were and are few and far between compared to cultural sikhs who just affiliate and live off the glorious name. We might not be aware of it but the present day sikhs have a very large number from punjabi muslims and former rajputs who both had strong meat eating traditions like a ritual and believed thats part of a warrior make up . One of the early day accounts state that muslim converts were given hogs legs to eat when they were initiated. I do not know whether this is true or not but whether it is or isnt would not be the issue as far as i can see for we have to measure this act up upon gurbani. If no such rehetnama exists that specifically calls for muslim converts to eat hogs legs then the practice was man made just like we see other fake rituals existing in sikhi today, come 100 years time sikhs of then will say " the sikhs of old drank cans of beer, and danced the bhangra" so maybe it was ok. But wait Guru Granth sahib ji says booze is a bad thing so should i be taking something thats bad for me? or should i look at those old textual sources that say the olde misaldars drank large amounts of shraab so surely its ok i can. You gotto decide which avenue you take when gurbani conflicts with these historical accounts.