Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Atamsaroop Singh · 06 Jan 2005

I hope admin/moderators guys let this message to appear on the board its a reply to bhai kulbir singh ji on bhramgyani thread..i also posted this message on there but unfortunately that thread was closed. If you have guys decided not to post this message for some personal reasons (so much for freedom of speech) even though my post have no nindya but clarification then please email me kulbir singh email adress so i can send him a reply via email. My email adress is - [address removed] . Thanx in advance. Guru Rakha. Gurfateh all, First thing first, I m not in any kinda dwara. Whatever I m writing is from the books. Reading something and expereincing something is two different things soo please spare me the scarisitc remarks. Kulbir Singh Ji, First of all I like to appolize that you missunderstood my post. I wasn't clear enough. What i m saying is this. To get to Nirankar. - Bhagti starts from two- Sikh and Guru. After bhagti is done there is only Guru and you merge with Nirankar via shabad roop (Thats one way) or you merge with with Nirankar via sargun saroop. Both ways are correct. They are equal. One is shabad Surat Marg with prem off course and second is only and only prema bhakti (like bhagat dhana did). Baba Nand Singh Maharaj did sargun pooja. And its not manmaat. That just another way ..just like in siri guru granth sahib bhagat dhanna did sargun pooja..it wasnt only the stone because he got darshan it was a faith that made. It was his faith that made Vishnu bhagvan gave him darshan. Baba Nand Singh was a Nit Avtar. He didn't need do anything of this. He was brother of Siri Ram Chandar Ji- Bharat (3rd brother) in his previous reincarnations. Guru Nanak Dev Ji send baba nand singh ji to teach people how to have faith in siri guru granth sahib Ji. refer to sau sakhi (Baba Nand Singh, Baba Attar Singh and Baba Ram Singh ) names are beautifully mentioned in sau sakhi. His devotion towards Siri Guru Granth Sahib as "Jagadi Jot" made Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji pragat from Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When that happened he didnt need to do anything or shabad surat marg because he got Gurparsad. Thats a main thing. I am not saying people who do nirgun pooja don't get gurparsad. They get it off course but if there is other bhagti marg and aim is one then what's a problem? He set this example for sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Ji how to serve Guru Ji full prem and devotion. He never ever ever advocated Sargun pooja is the only way or was just only way in Gurmat. You are quite right in dasam dwara there eventually there is only anhad shabad and roshani(parkash) however what i meant to say is this, i appolize for confusion- In dasam dwar you do get darshan of his creations (Guru, Sant, Avtars, world prophets, millions of bhramands and its creations) in form of mental picture. (see- Guru Gobind Singh Ji giving updesh to Mata jeeto kaur regarding dhayans in Soraj Parkash granth) Neyji, its not a sin to ask a sikh for darshan of his Guru in sargun . If it was a Sin (Guru baba nanak wouldnt gave darshan to baba nand singh, Guru Har Rai Ji wouldnt give darshan to Baba Nihal Singh Ji, Guru Ji WOULDN'T give darshan to satkar jog bhai rama singh ji who i beleif affilated with akj, Guru Gobind singh ji wouldnt give darshan to sant baba gurbachan singh ji bhindvanvale sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvale and many many more sants) You story of meeting between sant baba isher singh ji rara sahib and sant baba nand singh ji is quite correct kulbir singh ji however there are two mistakes. That story did happen in Nau Ratan page- 235 1. Debates is for us manmukhs, Bhramgyanis don't debate they do bachan billas with pyaar. 2. Sant baba isher singh ji rara saib didn't back off from the debate as you say because baba nand singh ji was old. They didnt have any debate at the first place it was bachan billas. At the end both sirimoni sants have accepted each other ways because sant baba isher singh ji knew other way also leads to Nirankar. In my previous post, I have used words like "must" which i appolize. Even though i beleive in shabad surat marg but I think Sargun prema bhakti is valid marg as well as soo many sants have used this marg to get gurparsad.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Atmasroop Singh Ji, Can you please post the relevant Shabad from Guru granth Ji that says Bhagat Dhanna did prema bhagtee of a STONE Sargun Pooja and got Partakh darshan of Nirankaar from it. As far as I am aware the Shabad by GURU ARJUN mentions exactly HOW Bhagat Dhanna Ji attained Bhagat Status..and IT wasnt by any stone sargun pooja but by Following the PATH to Bhagtee laid down by the famous Bhagats like Ravidass...etc etc etc. Maybe I am missing something. Thanks jarnail Singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. even though the admin have not said anything about this matter i cannot keep myself quiet. Time and again people like these have sent in posts ( which they themselves know to be objectionable/rude/stupid/out of context...etc ) and then they write in an disclaimer that they KNOW FOR SURE ADMIN will NOT ALLOW their Post in. How do I know this..becasue the poster himslef will write......"I am aware admin wont allow this blah blah blah..." And time and again admin have allowed all these posts through...never once has anyone then had the guts to apologise for their earlier anti- admin remarks. These people forget that the readers are discerning enough to separate TRUTH from FICTION...admin need not do any "editing" Banning. This is the only Forum where topics can go up to 70 over replies in a short time...I have been to other "santbababrahmgiani supporter sites/ and they dont allow any opposing posts/shut down and ban people who dont agree with their official version. The only editing i see is "language" and that is absolutley right because in my case my young children also read the posts..and i think it may be the case for others as well....what I dont want my child to read should not appear here ( language)..ideas of any hue are OK. So here..KUDOS to Admin. Keep it up veero. Manjit kaur

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

.... · 06 Jan 2005

Thank you for that wonderful post Atamsaroop Singh!! Waheguru Waheguru

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

kaur · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh Brilliant post Atamsaroop Singh Jee Gyani Jarnail Singh Jee, the shabad that Atamsaroop Singh refers to about Bhagat Dhanna is a Vaar by Bhai Gurdas Jee on Pannaa 10. The STTM link to it is as follows: http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5771 The basic story is that some Brahmin was praying to a stone. Dhanna asked why are you doing this. The Brahmin replied that I am praying to God. Dhanna asked to give him a stone, so that he could also pray to God. Of course the Brahmin was doing it for ritualistic purposes to make money. But Dhanna, the simpleton Jatt, did not know this. He revered the stone as God. He went to great lengths to prepare langar for it. People laughed at him for worshipping a stone. But Dhanna Jee showed complete devotion to the stone as a form of God and through this devotion, God came before Dhanna and ate the Bhojan prepared by Dhanna. Bhagat Dhanna refers to this story (I think) in Gurbani on Ang 695: Gopaal Thaeraa Aaruthaa O Lord of the world, this is Your lamp-lit worship service. Jo Jun Thumuree Bhugath Kurunthae Thin Kae Kaaj Suvaaruthaa You are the Arranger of the affairs of those humble beings who perform Your devotional worship service. ||1||Pause|| The moral of the story is that if anyone does enough Bhagtee with full devotional worship and true love, then Waheguru will fulfil their Kaaj/worldly affairs Himself. Guru Ramdas Jee says in Gurbani on Ang 451 says: Har Jug Jug Bhuguth Oupaaeiaa Paij Rukhudhaa Aaeiaa Raam Raajae In each and every age, He creates His devotees and preserves their honor, O Lord King. How does this relate to Baba Nand Singh Jee? Baba Jee was convinced that if Waheguru can come to preserve the honour of Bhagat Dhanna Jee when he worshipped a stone, then it would surely help to attain Waheguru if he fully worshipped and respected Guru Granth Sahib Jee, as the Guru Granth Sahib Jee contains the Word of God within it; it is the Jaagdee Jot or the Living Guru. This is the reason why Baba Nand Singh Jee treated the Guru Granth Sahib Jee with such respect; it is the living embodiment of the Gurus’ spiritual teachings. Since the Guru is Parmeshar, “Gur Parmeshar Eeko Jaan”, Guru Granth Sahib Jee should not be treated as any old book. If Guru Granth Sahib Jee is disrespected, then Waheguru is himself being disrespected. With this belief, Baba Nand Singh Jee then had the Langar Bhog done of Guru Granth Sahib Jee, as this is how a Living Guru should be treated, as well as providing Guru Jee with the best Rumallas, etc. Baba Jee’s shardha in Guru Granth Sahib Jee was such that the Langar Bhog would actually be consumed: people laughed at Baba Jee at the time for believing this was possible, but Baba Jee had such shardha in the Gurus and Sikhi, that he believed this was possible. Indeed, Guru Nanak Dev Jee actually came before and had the Langar prepared by Baba Nand Singh Jee. The Gurus came and preserved the Honour of their devotees: “Har Jug Jug Bhuguth Oupaaeiaa Paij Rukhudhaa Aaeiaa Raam Raajae” and “Jo Jun Thumuree Bhugath Kurunthae Thin Kae Kaaj Suvaaruthaa”. Sangat Jee, whether you believe all this is possible is an issue of faith and whether our Living Guru/Jaagdi Jot Guru, Guru Granth Sahib Jee can make this happen. I cannot comment on this for you – this is for the individual to decide. All I can say from Daas’ experience is that Guru Jee works miracles in my life all the time; it is me who is Akirat-Ghun and Paapi that I forget Waheguru. Think of it this way – if you think about things enough during the day, they come in your dreams at night. Now imagine those Gursikhs who think of the Gurus and Waheguru Jee 24/7: will the Guru not come to meet them? In my humble opinion, OF COURSE THEY WILL. This hopefully puts a rest to those who equate Nanaksar and Baba Nand Singh as forming his own cult, equating them to Radha Soamis. The very reason for Baba Nand Singh’s greatness within the Khalsa Panth is that he showed the Sikhs what is possible if one respects and loves the Living Guru Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Seeing as this post is already so long, I might as well add another few inspirational stories about Baba Nand Singh Jee’s jeevan. Baba Nand Singh Jee always used to live in a very small hut and he used to smash it up whenever he left and moved on, so that the Sangat would not worship the places where he did his Bhagtee. Further, whenever he was in the Sangat and in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj, he always dug a pit at a level where he was below Guru Granth and Guru Panth; he always wished to be the dust of the Sangat, such was his humility. Of course, I am not defending those who may today misuse the name and Bhagtee of Baba Nand Singh Jee and Baba Isher Singh Jee for their own personal gain. These two Sants of the Khalsa Panth attached to and made the Sangat realise the Eternal Glory of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karnee _/\_ PS Atamsaroop Singh Jee or anybody else in the sangat, can you please clarify or correct any mistakes made in this post. Waheguru

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

kaur · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh I heard the story about Baba Nand Singh's Prema Bhagtee at a very early age. Atamsaroop Singh's posts brought the memories back. However, I am a bit unsure and cannot remember whether the Brahmin referred to in Bhai Gurdas Jee's Vaar was just a normal Brahmin making money, or another Bhagat (such as NaamDev or Ravidas) - this has escaped my memory and I have a feeling that I may have mixed stories somewhere along the line!!! If it was a Bhagat, then they would have given the stone to Dhanna just to get rid of Dhanna, and obviously not for financial purposes. PLEASE can the Sangat clarify. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karnee _/\_ Waheguru

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Bhen Ji,(kaur) Stone/idol worship by whomsoever is NOT advised or encouraged in GURBANI. This story about Bhagat dhanna Ji is a very popular one...so popular in fact that GURU ARJUN JI wrote this shabad in Raag Assa Panna 487 to DISPELL any such WRONG IDEAS that a person could get "Akal Purakh" out of a stone...in that case idol worship is not wrong !! The Shaabd by Mh. 5 details exactly HOW Dhanna the Jatt heard stories of how formerly so called low castes like chimba...Namdev who was worth only half a shell- Aadhee kaurri - utterly worthless !! became worth MILLIONS and was known the World Over....the low caste calico printer Kabeer also gained world class popularity..so did Ravidass the chamaar who used to carry dead cows and was now above the power of maya.. sain the lowly barber also attained hari darshan and became respected.. THUS HEARING this "BIDH"...way to Fame as a saint/God Lover Dhanna the Jatt also got up and followed this BIDH..the Path to fame as a Bhagat. The word to watch out here is BIDH..Bidhi..METHOD of attaining Bhagatee fame that the rest had gained before Bhagat dhana Ji got on the road to bhagtee...and NO STONE WORSHIP/IDOL WORSHIP/ etc is mentioned anywhere in this shabad....how could Guru ji mention any such thing as it goes agaisnt the grain of the entire GURBANI in the GURU GRANTH JI. IF you have doubts as to why it is mentioned in Bhai gurdass Ji vaar..well firstly the Vaars are NOT GURBANI, they are mostly "historical/mythological" repetitions of popular stories meant to "explain" and elaborate..and certainly not of the same spiritual levle of Gurbani. Secondly the Vaars may have been adulterated...while we know Gurbani is Pristine Pure...the way it was written is the way we have it today in the Guru Garnth Ji. IF I have to weigh my options as to which to choose..GURU ARJUN JI's testimony...OR Bhai gurdass Vaar..my VOTE goes to GURU ARJUN JI. And GURU ARJUN JI leaves absolutely NO DOUBT as to which BIDHI or METHOD was used by Bhagat Dhanna jI to attain that Status...it was exactly the SAME as the other Bhagats. Jarnail Singh. Note: the relevant shabad is: This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 487 mehalaa 5 || Fifth Mehl: gobi(n)dh gobi(n)dh gobi(n)dh sa(n)g naamadhaeo man leenaa || Naam Dayv's mind was absorbed into God, Gobind, Gobind, Gobind. aadt dhaam ko shheeparo hoeiou laakheenaa ||1|| rehaao || The calico-printer, worth half a shell, became worth millions. ||1||Pause|| bunanaa thananaa thiaag kai preeth charan kabeeraa || Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Lord's lotus feet. neech kulaa jolaaharaa bhaeiou guneey geheeraa ||1|| A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1|| ravidhaas dtuva(n)thaa dtor neeth thin thiaagee maaeiaa || Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya. paragatt hoaa saadhhasa(n)g har dharasan paaeiaa ||2|| He became famous in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, and obtained the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||2|| sain naaee buthakaareeaa ouhu ghar ghar suniaa || Sain, the barber, the village drudge, became famous in each and every house. hiradhae vasiaa paarabreham bhagathaa mehi ganiaa ||3|| The Supreme Lord God dwelled in his heart, and he was counted among the devotees. ||3|| eih bidhh sun kai jaattaro out(h) bhagathee laagaa || Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat applied himself to devotional worship. milae prathakh gusaaeeaa dhha(n)naa vaddabhaagaa ||4||2|| The Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed. ||4||2||

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Mahal · 07 Jan 2005

waheguroo jee kaa khalsa waheguroo Jee kee fateh Veer jarnail Singh has made an excellent comment. No where in Siri Guru Guru granth Sahib Jee some can find that STONE WORSHIP is recommended. Sabad by Mahalla Panjwan attests to this that Bhakat Dhana Jeeo did Naaam Abhias, by learning BIDH (formula) from Bhakat Naam Dev Jeeo. "Gobind Gobind Gobind Sange Naam Dyoe Man leenha....IIRahaaoII .................. ..Eh Bidh Sun Ke Jaatroo Uth Bhakti Laagaa" The Sabad is refering to Naam Abhias/ Simran/ Gurmantar. and not STONE WORSHIP. "Guru Arjan Partakh Har..." waheguroo Bhul Chuck Muaaf

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Bijla Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Although idol worship is against Sikhi but Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars are 100% correct. Bhai Sahib Ji does not support it. His vaars follow Sikhi which is why it is called "key to Gurbani" (Sikhs like Jaswant Singh Parwana may disagree). it is another way to understand Gurbani. It is not gurbani but a simple way to understand Gurbani. there has been no alteration in his work unless someone can provide a solid proof. His vaar about Bhagat Dhanna Ji does not support idol worship. people have misinterpreted it. Bhai Sahib Ji says that people say Bhagat Dhanna had darshan because of idol worship but in reality it was his prem or "Bhola Bhau" that got him the darshan. there is a big difference between narrating a story and supporting a story. Bhai Sahib Ji only narrated it but his real purpose is in last lines. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. couldnt have said it better myself. This popular story was certainly popularised and propogated by the crafty "brahmins/Bippars" to make a fool out of the Honoured Bhagats who inspite of being so called low castes managed to get so much fame and love among the common people... the thekedars of dharam..were absolutely mad at this. see how the crafty brahmin is shown as so clever...he is worshipping the "real Thakur idol" while the "stupid/simpleton /jatt" dhanna (Ji) is satisfied with just about any stone... Now listen to what Gurbani says about these Stones ( idols) and "any stone ( supposedly given to dhanna ji to get rid of him)... Gurbani says: One stone...is Prayed to ( Thakur Idol !!) while the Other is Stepped upon... the Real THAKUR meaning Akal Purakh is NOT in either of these.. The Stone Mason who Carves the Idol, puts it under his FEET while carving it and working on it ( see the supreme IRONY - the Stone Mason is a LOW CASTE...putting the stone Idol UNDER HIS LOWLY FEET...while the High caste Brahman prays to the same stone idol hoping to get GOD out of it !!!) Such could only happen in Brahmin/BIppar LAND... And how can Sikhs of the FORMLESS NIRANKAAR "import" such utter fairytales into SIKHI and try to justify worshipping the "sargun" roop of NIRANKAAR. Anybody care to know why GURU NANAK is called NIRANKAREE and not SARGUNEE !!! EACH word of the SACRED GURBANI....Bhagat bani included says again and again NAAM ABHIYAAS/SIMRAN/BHAGTEE/LOVE/PYAAR will please Waheguru.....and tilaks on foreheads, on stone idols, washing idols in milk and honey, janueaus, external rituals, bathing at pilgrim centres, asceticism, sadhism, going off to forests, jungles, mountains, yogism, fasting..whatever WONT WORK one little BIT. WITH GURU JI's own WRITTEN COMMAND to worship only the NIRGUN NIRANKAAR, why do sikhs insist on seeking to worship His sargun Roop/pictures/darshans/and what not. Whoever is in favour of this sargun worship is definitley wrong and going against Guru ji's writings. Our GURUS were TRUE SACHAE PATSHAHS..there would have no dearth or shortage of the Best Painters/artists/mussavars/stone Masons/carvers to MAKE IMAGES and PICTURES of these TRUE PATSHAHS...just as there are so many of the False Moghul Patshahs !! Anybody cares to ponder why NOT a SINGLE painting/idol/image art etc of the GURU Sahibaans exists ?? Because those GURU KAAL SIKHS knew exactly what the True Message of GURBANI is..we dont. And no offense meant to anyone...the "picture" of Guru nanak publicised by Nanaksar is absolutely the worst one of all the ones available in the market...no "soul" at all. THis is NOT to imply that Giving TRUE and UTMOST SATIKAAR to Dhan Dhan Guur Granth Ji is "wrong"....absolutely NOT. GURBANI and GURU GRANTH is the SACHA PATSHAH and commands the utmost respect a sikh can give to anyone/anything/???...NO amount of respect is too much..LOVE as much as you possibly can/respect even more than that...what else can a human do...BUT NO PICTURES/IDOLS/IMAGES/ whatever means. Any "brahmgiani" that says otherwise is wrong. Manjit kaur

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

a little doubtful · 07 Jan 2005

vaahe guru jee ka khalsa vaahe guru jee kee fateh i can not speak about baba nand singh himself, but the influence and maryada of nanaksariyas is not only very troubling, but also very anti-panthic. it has always been clear in panthic tradition that the GURU KHALSA PANTH was the "deh" or body of the guru. there is an old saying attributed to guru gobind singh jee maharaj contained in old texts which says, "panchin meh nit bartunt hoo panch milai bin peer un peer" when we take amrit from the guru, we recognize the panj as our visible form of the guru. similarily, when the panth was still carying out the tradition of sarbat khalsa, an amazing democratic legislative institution begun by guru gobind singh himself, the decisions of the sarbat khalsa would be called "gurmatta" meaning the decisions taken by the guru. for a further clarification, the rehitnama of bhai nand lal singh (goya multani) would be good to read. in the rehitnama, bhai sahib asks guru gobind singh sahib jee several questions about the nature of the guru. bhai nand lal singh asks the guru what a sikh should do on a day to day basis. the guru answers that one of the main things to do is to do darshan of the guru. bhai sahib goes on to ask how can sikhs do darshan of the guru if they are not in close physical proximity to the guru. guru jee goes on to answer that the he has three forms. sargun, nirgun and gurshabad. sargun form is the guru himself, sitting at anandpur sahib, nirgun is without qualities, or akal purkh, and gurshabad is the granth sahib, which was not yet formally installed as guru jee. it should be clear that guru gobind singh sahib jee diferentiates between sargun saroop and guru granth sahib. guru granth sahib is not sargun saroop of guru jee, but instead is a seperate aspect of vaaheguru, that is bani. the sargun form of the guru is contained in the panj, and also in the khalsa as a whole. guru jee's shabads on the khalsa make this pretty clear. there is a fine line between treating the guru granth sahib as our soevereign and our emperorer and idol worship. treating the guru jee as our sachai patsha means using rumallai and a chaur sahib, palki, takhat istaan, matha dheking, putting weapons infront of guru jee, giving offereing to guru jee when bowing, etc, all of things done to kings not only in ancient times but even today in many countries (see traditional forms of conduct around the kings/emperors of japan, bhutan, thailand, cambodia and other asian countries that still have monarchies). idol worship though is another thing, and many of these practicies in modern day sikhi can be traced to nanaksariya practices. putting a heavier blanket on guru jee in the winter, putting a fan on in the summer, believing that the karah parshad put under the manji sahib is for guru jee and not for the granthi sahib as it should be, massaging the legs of the manji/palki/takht sahib, etc. bringing langar to be "tasted" by the guru would also be a part of this since the maryada for langar and karah parshad are different and there is no evidence that historicly the ten "human" guru sahibs ever checked and tasted langar before sangat could eat it. this is all part of the larger historical trend of taking respect away from guru khalsa panth that can said to have begun under "maha"raja ranjit singh and was later even furthered under the british. the panth is by its very nature a very political entity and other competing political forces do not want to share political power. another part of this anti-panthic bent that the nanaksariyas have is their practice of not flying the nishan sahib. there can be NO execuse for this. this is the nishan sahib that guru gobind singh jee fought for! this is the nishan sahib that countless sikhs carried into battle and got shaheed trying to keep up! and their gurdwaras wont fly them. why not? another affront to the power of the sangat and panth is the lack of a real langar at nanaksariya gurudwaras. why is this done? there can no be real execuse for this either. langar is AS important as sangat, and has been since the time of guru nanak sahib jee! the nanaksariaya practice of changing bani is also very troubling. the way they read sukhmani sahib is incredibly disrespectful to guru jee. didnt guru arjun sahib know how to write the bani? there is no panthic tradition or sakhi at all to justify this addition and changing of bani and it seems the nanaksariayas do it just to be a little "different" as many anti-panthic groups tend to be. its strange that everyone's been so obsessed with the split in the taksal recently with the fact that the nanaksariyas have been splitting into dozens of different groups since nand singh. its insane how many there are now! like a plague across punjab sucking up the resources of the panth (human, ecnonomic and socail). finally. the nanaksariyas have more than any other so called panthic group, been strangely absent from most panthic causes over the last 80 years. their contribution to the independance movement was minimal. their response to punjabi suba was not really very dramatic (especialy compared to other panthic groups) and the post 1978 situation... they have been totally absent. imagine that, over 500,000 innocent sikhs killed in the last 30 odd years and not one nanaksariaya baba has gone to jail protesting these crimes... just whose side are they on?????? if you were to look at it from the outside, it would seem that many nanaksariya babas are getting away with a lot more than we realize. just because they're not calling themselves gurus, they get away with acting like "dehdharee gurus". pretty much the same thing mr. yogi bhajan pulled off for the last 40 years too (before he finally kicked the can.). i just wonder that if baba nand singh is right and the guru granth sahib is the "body" of the guru, then what is the role of panth??? then what good are the panj pyarai? are they not suppose to be visible form of the guru that you can consult, ask advice from etc. that's what panthic tradition seems to tell us, right untill these "innovations" of the nanaksariayas. FATEH! singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

perhaps · 07 Jan 2005

It was not the act, but the shardaa behind the act. Bhagat Jee had so much sharda that God had to be pargat there and then!

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Premi · 07 Jan 2005

-------- guru granth sahib is not sargun saroop of guru jee, but instead is a seperate aspect of vaaheguru, that is bani. ---------- "Gurdev Satgur Parbrahm Parmesar" ----------- One and the same Gurdev (Guru Granth Sahib) and God That was before Guru Granth Sahib was givin gaddee, at which point Guru jee passed his jot to Banee formally. "Sab sikhaan ko hukum hai Guru maneoo Granth" Does this not clear up that Guru Granth Sahib is the the same sargun saroop as Guru Jee, only in bani form? The Sikhs are to take there Guru as Guru Granth Sahib. On the Nanaksar points. I think you need to read up on them before generalizing about them. Baba Nand Singh prayed to Guru Granth Sahib to get Guru jee to eat the parshada he had made for Guru Jee. Such was his love that he did not eat for I think it was 7 days before Guru Nanak came to eat that parshada he had made. Ever since then he took Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Nanak. As far as I know that is accepted in all panthic factions i.e that Guru Granth Sahib is the same as Guru jee's in human form. Baba Nand Singh never made any buildings etc to his name, this was all done after his death.And as you well know Sevaks tend to make major mistakes. You can see the same in AKJ, Taksal, and others. Idolizing the person who was the head at the time. I mean look at AKJ - we have Tapoban which are more strict, than others who are not so strict, then there are these panchchyataee guys etc, etc. Same thing in all factions of the panth. You can't just ignore a faction because you don't think they have done anything for the panth. How do you really know? Maybe they just don't do it in the public eye like everyone else does, and go crazy saying I am taksali, AKJ er. etc and look what I have done for the panth! Adding extra blankets, doing bhog is all a part of a persons devotion to Guru. To show respect. Then why not just do parkash on a table? no need for rumala's, etc, etc. Guru Arjan Dev jee gave Guru Granth Sahib there own bed, that is respect and devotion to bani. He showed us to try and live "below" Guru Granth Sahib i.e in humility I have never been to Nanaksar, but I have read up on Baba Nand Singh life and you are absolutly wrong in your assumptions. At a time when the Sikh were falling in numbers he did parchaar and motivated people to become Amritdhari in the thousands. As did other great Mahapurkhs of the time. I am just waiting for Arshi's and Sidhu's, comments on this one. Somehow you will tie this back to burning all Sants etc, etc HAHAHA Why can't we just try and respect each other and the places we learn from??? I mean all factions in the panth are trying to get people into gurmat, one is not better than the other. We do not posses all the knowledge.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

are you trying to tell me the HINDUS praying to the idols in the mandirs have "less" SHARDHA ??? SO IF you have enough of SHARDHA it is OK to pray in a Mandir to kali mata/Shivji/Confucious/Jesus/Mother Mary/whatever ??? Perhaps Ji, PERHAPS GURU JI forgot to mention this SHARDHA??? when they wrote GURBANI saying all those things already mentioned...about pilgrimages, bathing at sarovars, going off to the jungles, mountains, piercing the ears and becoming Yogis, remaining Celibate, Fasting, sleeping on nails, walking on fire, standing upside down,..etc etc etc etc.. DONT WORK ?? WAHEGURU IS NOT OBTAINED BY ALL THESE ?? then what about SHARDHA ?? factor ?? why did Guru Ji leave out this collosal SHARDHA FACTOR ?? Surprisingly this SHARDHA factor is brought up so much...shrdha hai jee kion rokdeh ho ?? shardha ?? Do YOU have this shardha ?? have you sat before a stone hungry and thirsty waiting with shardha for GOD to come out ?? is this a practical thing...and if it is why didnt the GURUS RECOMMEND IT....it doesnt require any rehat, any naam abhiyaas, any gurbani, just shardha..shardha loads of it.... wonderful..perhaps ?? Manjit Kaur

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

A Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Bhai Nand Lal "Singh"? hmmm...oh of course, just like the Bhagats were ALL contempories of Guru Sahib...yes, well...I guess we can all agree to disagree on some points, but reading all sides of the above arguments...it's clear to see that everyone likes to put forth their own biases.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Bundha · 07 Jan 2005

<<< I say PRETEND because IF GURU NANAK does come out and eat the DEGH, He shoudl DO it PUBLICLLY in every nanksaria Gurdwara around the world and not do it SECRETLY >>> BhenJi, I believe that Baba Nanak Dev Ji does come and eat the degh, in person. But O'papi am I that I have not the eyes to see him.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Veer Atamsaroop Singh jeeo, Thanks for your detailed answer on Sargun Pooja Vs Nirgun Pooja. This debate will definitely clear up many Gurmat points for all of us. Let me begin by saying that Nirgun or Sargun, any pooja is better than no pooja. I personally don’t advocate Sargun Pooja and believe that Gurmat is against Sargun Pooja but nevertheless, all people who are seekers of Param-Pita jee – Vaheguru – are worthy of respect. As mentioned previously, in Sikh Panth, with the exception of Nanaksar Samprada, no other Sikh Samprada believes in Sargun Pooja. Taksal, Nihung Singhs, Rarewala Taksal, AKJ etc. all propagate Nirgun Pooja i.e. advocate meeting Vaheguru through Shabad Surat way. Gurmat does not advocate Sargun Pooja. --------------- - Bhagti starts from two- Sikh and Guru. After bhagti is done there is only Guru and you merge with Nirankar via shabad roop (Thats one way) or you merge with with Nirankar via sargun saroop. Both ways are correct. They are equal. ------------ Where in Gurbani does it say that both ways are correct and equal? Sach (truth) can only be one and not two. There is only one Vaheguru and there is only one way to him – Gurmat way of Shabad Surat. ------------ One is shabad Surat Marg with prem off course and second is only and only prema bhakti (like bhagat dhana did). ----------- Prema Bhagti does not mean the so called Dhanna Way. Prema Bhagti in fact means to stay absorbed in doing Kirtan and Naam. In other words to do his Bhagti through Prem. If one has prem, then alone one can japp Naam and do Kirtan. -------------- Baba Nand Singh Maharaj did sargun pooja. And its not manmaat. That just another way ..just like in siri guru granth sahib bhagat dhanna did sargun pooja..it wasnt only the stone because he got darshan it was a faith that made. It was his faith that made Vishnu bhagvan gave him darshan. -------------- It is totally untrue that Bhagat Dhanna attained Vaheguru through praying to a stone. Perhaps he did get to Vishnu (as you write) by placing his shardha in the stone but no one can get to Vaheguru or our Guru Sahibaan by shardha alone. Shardha alone cannot do anything if one does not follow the proper methodology to attain Vaheguru. The fact of the matter is that Bhagat Dhanna heard about the greatness of Bhagat Kabir jee, Bhagat Ravidaas jee, Bhagat Naamdev jee and Bhagat Sain jee; and resorted to doing bhagti. (as per Guru Arjun Dev jee's shabad on Ang 488). He met Saadh Sangat and only this way did he meet Vaheguru. Bhagat Dhanna himself writes in his baani that he attained Vaheguru through Saadh-Sangat: dhha(n)nai dhhan paaeiaa dhharaneedhhar mil jan sa(n)th samaaniaa ||4||1|| Dhanna has obtained the Lord, the Sustainer of the World, as his wealth meeting the humble Saints, he merges in the Lord. ||4||1|| ------------ Baba Nand Singh was a Nit Avtar. He didn't need do anything of this. He was brother of Siri Ram Chandar Ji- Bharat (3rd brother) in his previous reincarnations. ----------- It is of no relevance as to whether Baba Nand Singh was a brother of Siri Raam Chander. In any case, how do we know he was his brother Bharat and even if he was, how does it relate to Gurmat? ------------- Guru Nanak Dev Ji send baba nand singh ji to teach people how to have faith in siri guru granth sahib Ji. refer to sau sakhi (Baba Nand Singh, Baba Attar Singh and Baba Ram Singh ) names are beautifully mentioned in sau sakhi. ------------- Why would Guru Nanak Sahib send someone (Baba Nand Singh as you write) to teach people how to do Sargun Pooja? Why did not any of our 10 Guru Sahibaan do Sargun Pooja? ------------- His devotion towards Siri Guru Granth Sahib as "Jagadi Jot" made Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji pragat from Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When that happened he didnt need to do anything or shabad surat marg because he got Gurparsad. Thats a main thing. I am not saying people who do nirgun pooja don't get gurparsad. They get it off course but if there is other bhagti marg and aim is one then what's a problem? ------------ One can get Gurprasaad (Guru’s kirpa) only if one follows the hukams of Guru Sahib. Naam is the foremost hukam of Guru Sahib and japping Naam is Nirgun Pooja. No other Bhagti Maarag has Guru Sahib’s approval. ------------ Neyji, its not a sin to ask a sikh for darshan of his Guru in sargun . If it was a Sin (Guru baba nanak wouldnt gave darshan to baba nand singh, Guru Har Rai Ji wouldnt give darshan to Baba Nihal Singh Ji, Guru Ji WOULDN'T give darshan to satkar jog bhai rama singh ji who i beleif affilated with akj, Guru Gobind singh ji wouldnt give darshan to sant baba gurbachan singh ji bhindvanvale sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvale and many many more sants) -------------- I had wrote earlier that at initial stages, it is possible that gursikhs may see sargun saroop of Guru Sahib but gursikhs are never satisfied with such darshans. Gursikhs only go for Nirgun Jyot Roop Darshans of Guru Sahib that are only possible through the Shabad of Satguru jee. Some one else wrote about Shardha. Shardha alone cannot do anything. Shardha is an important component but it is not the only one. In the Shabad Surat Maarag that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee gave to his Gursikhs, immense shardha is required. How can one japp Naam without shardha. But to have shardha on a stone can never ever give any Sidhi as written by Siri Dashmesh jee: KAHA BHAYIO JO ATT HITT CHITT KAR, BAHU BIDH SILA PUJAAYEE|| PRAAN THAKAY PAAHAN KEH PARSAT, KUCHH KAR SIDH NA AAYEE|| Siri Guru jee writes that “So what if one does pooja of a stone with extreme love (shardha) and concentration (chit). One can do pooja of such silaa (stone, idol) till one gets drained out but no sidhi (reward) would come out of it. Att Hitt Chtt – Extreme Love and concentration Bahu Bidh – Doing pooja in different ways. Silaa – Stone, idol Praan Thakay – Totally fatigued doing pooja Paahan keh parsat – doing pooja of a paahan i.e. pathar i.e. sila i.e. idol. Now in the light of the above Gurbani pankiti, which Gursikh has the courage to support idol worship or believe in the story of Dhanna Jatt? Siri Dashmesh jee clearly states in his baani that no one can get anything from a stone. Who should we believe? Siri Guru jee or mythology? Now the question arises, how did Baba Nand Singh get darshan of Guru Nanak Dev jee while doing Sargun Pooja? There are two possibilities. The possibility that he got Guru Sahib with shardha alone or using the so called Dhanna Technique does not exist as proven above. The only two possibilities – either he did not get darshan of Guru Nanak and the story tellers are lying or he did get darshan of Guru Sahib but by japping Naam. I am more inclined to the second possibility because I know that Baba Nand Singh jee used to spend hours and hours japping Naam. There are pictures of him observing extreme penances while japping Naam. He used to tie his hair to the top of the tree branch so as to avoid sleeping while japping Naam. This is what would have given him darshan and it seems that rest of the stuff that the story tellers are telling us is false. Baba Nand Singh jee like Baba Raam Singh jee is a victim of false sto5 Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

.. · 07 Jan 2005

Sorry could someone explain what is "Sargan saroop" and "nirgun"

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

jss · 08 Jan 2005

I'm going to leave the sant subject alone ...cuz it seems everyone is stuck in their stance...and i'd rather just respect that we all have differing views... i did want to comment on the sharda aspect...i think it's probably one of the MOST important aspects of bhagti....and at one time i thought it was EVERYTHING...but it isn't....because if a person claims to have sharda, that person will follow the hukams of their guru ji....that person would do everything said by their guru ji without thinking twice... To those like Manjit auntie ji...you ask for where sharda in gurbani is...off hand...sach kaho sun layho subhai, jin prem kio tin hi prabh bhaiyo... i've always taken that to mean sharda/prem/love.... Interestingly...i was reading Spirit Born People by Prof. Puran Singh ji...he was commenting that every religion has it's practices has it's symbols...and he said that all these are very important...BUT if all this is done without feeling, love (sharda)...than these are all dead symbols and dead practices... HOWEVER....he also issued a warning to those who believe solely in sharda that they too were mistaken...he said those who think they can love without wearing the symbols and carrying out the practices are also wrong for the Bride would never take off the ring of her Husband... reading this passage really cleared up stuff for me...hope it helps you guys...

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 08 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. a one liner explanation.... Sargun...when the 10 GURU SAHIBAANS were here on Earth from 1469-1708 NIRGUN...the Roop sketched in Mool mantar..Ek onkar, satnam kartapurakh. Nirbhau, Nirvair, akal moort ajoonee sai bhang..GURPARSAAD. The AAD GURU NANAK came from NIRGUN into SARGUN..stayed in SARGUN until 1708..and LEFT us BACK INTO NIRGUN..for all time. Guur Granth Ji is the embodiment explanation of Nirgun Attainment. For a better or more detailed explanation..wait for our esteemed walking encyclopaedia..none other than Kulbir Singh Ji. manjit Kaur

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Atamsaroop Singh · 08 Jan 2005

Gurfateh Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, After reading your post, it all comes down to the two questions I shall ask you before that I like to clarify Baba Nand Singh Ji did immense Naam Simran..at the end prem towards siri guru granth sahib was soo much that after not eating for weeks. Guru Nanak Dev Ji pragat from Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. There was soo much light, its in-describle. Upon request of Baba Nand Singh ji, Guru Nanak Dev Ji decreases his parkash so baba nand singh ji can see him (his pritam pyara). Its interesting to note when Guru Nanak Dev Ji asked baba nand singh few times - what do you want?? He replied and said - Guru ji apnai Bana Lauo forever. Then he had gurparsad and thats it. Kulbir Singh Ji, just because he prefered to get darshan of Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji doesnt mean he didn't had any vishvas in guru shabad- Wahiguru..that will be almost nindiya to say he didnt any shardha in Guru Shabad..because he used shabad guru to get there...even it's been beleived that Shabad Guru merges with nirankar but in this case to get darshan of Wahiguru in sargun saroop..but i ask you kulbir ji. [b]- is sargun form of Wahiguru really separated from nirgun?[/b] Please answer with lot of thoughts. How can it be anti-gurmat to ask darshan of Wahiguroo in sargun form? If its really anti-gurmat as you say it then i must say merging with Nirgun is also anti-gurmat. I ll tell you why..because "you can't never ever ever separate nirgun from sargun and sargun from nirgun". If sargun darshan was soo anti-gurmat as you say it or as you say it that above gurmukhs (mentioned in my post) are not satisfied with sargun darshan of Wahiguru only.. then I must ask you - When Baba Budda Ji about to go sachkhand, why did he request Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji to be infront of his face? Baba Budda Ji is a bhramgyani (we all agree with that, hopefully yes?? ). What's a need for a bhramgyani to ask Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji to be infront of his face at his last breaths?? Why did he do that?? Even though he was in bhram (bhramgyani). He still needed an sargun saroop (not nesscarily pyaar with deh but prem towards Guru Avtar Jot in Sargun saroop). I am not saying baba budda ji didn't had any gurparsad. He had gurparsad long time ago even then pyaar was too much towards Guru Ji that he wouldn't even rest until he gets darshan of Guru Sundar Saroop who was a face of Akaal Purkh. Surely deh is a mitti anyway but this doesn't apply to sargun saroop of Wahiguru. I ll end up my post with strong beleifs that both paths are valid. Kulbir Singh Ji, first our duty we keep inspiring the youths to take amrit agree?? And if one youths takes amrit..then we keep insisting certain ways are only way to gurmat then If one luckily gets on bhagti marg by rise above from karam khands then we keep discouraging them by saying "oh this way is wrong in bhagti marg" "that way is right". Kulbir Singh JI, asal vich gal aih hai ki- Bhagti Marg itself is free from manmaat/Anti gurmat. Bhagti marg have more than one way to get to Nirankar shows diverse creations of Nirgun Wahiguru. Last thing we want Kulbir Singh Ji, is make an table and distguinsh between Bhramgyani's that bhramgyanis who have followed shabad surat marg is more gurmat than bhramgyanis who have followed prema bhakti marg with immense naam simran however at the last seek darshan of Sargun saroop of Wahiguru to merge with Nirankar. Sargun saroop of Wahiguru is also Nirgun. They can't separated. It's like this just an example- one party like certain part in a cake, and second party like other certain part in a cake...at the end - ITS A CAKE !!!!!!!!!!!!!! Nirgun and Sargun can't be separated. now main question to you is this- [b]- Kulbir Singh Ji, do you really think gurmukhs who get pratak darshan of Guru Sahiban still have lot more to do in their sadhna?? ie- go through shabad surat marg ...trikurti, dasam dwar etc??? [/b] I think not needed ji. Thats final. Darshan of Guru Maharaj Ji is not easy. Lot of good karams and sadna(gurbani abhayas) with mountain of bairaag is needed to have darshan of Guru Maharaj...so gurmukhs who are seeking darshan of Guru Maharaj..for them Guru Maharaj is both nirgun and sargun. They have understood that concept. Sargun and Nirgun are one. To think sargun and Nirgun are different is our avidya. Bhul Chuk Maff Karna Ji.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

SarblohholbraS · 08 Jan 2005

Jarnail Singh ji could we please see a picture of you? That would be great.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 09 Jan 2005

what ? are you serious ??? Here am I trying to discourage the use of even Guru sahibaan pictures..and you want my picture ?? whatever for ( i hope not to put out a "hit" on me...i have enough local "enemies" putting them out already !! he he he he ) Seriously, we have been trying for ages to get rid of this pictures of Guurs from Our Darbar sahib..we managed to bring them down to the langgar hall..small victory. then along came a nanaksari baba/one nanaksari family/ akhand paath with the nanaksari baba smiling from infront of the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE..--- CLEVER WAY of forcing people to matha tek to the baba !! even those not wanting to had no choice as matha tek to Guru Ji is a must..and now that has PROGRESSED... at a recent akhand paath for a deceased..had HIS PHOTO placed stretegically IN FRONT of GURU JI so that the snagat matha tek to GURU ji and Deceased sikh at the same time... soon more will follow ?? Just as the LIVING nanaksari babas "use" Guru Garanth Ji in reality...their dead baabs use it in Matha tekkaaing by force...and now the rigfht to matha tekaaing is passed on to ordinary dead sikhs as well... I HATE PICTURES....he he he..so no way !!! jarnail Singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

pic · 09 Jan 2005

>> Jarnail Singh ji could we please see a picture of you? That would be great. >> I agree, 8x10 will be fine!

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

oh please · 09 Jan 2005

Whats to hide Gyani ji? Come on, we wont be worshipping it. I dont think you have that much of a following just yet. Its always nice to see a face to words seeing your a regular poster and contributer to debates on this site. Once again, Please from me too. That would be great.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

hai · 09 Jan 2005

Why does everything have to go back to issing/cussing 'baba's' for some people eh? Can't you just answer questions or put your point across without going off on a tangent just so you can have yet another shot at someone? If you are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO against all tricks people pull just so that the sangat can bow down at them, then why don't you do something about it? If you don't want to bow down to a picture infront of Guru Sahib Ji then have it removed or get up and remove it if its against GURMAT, make some noise about it where this is happening.. Don't worry Gyani Ji, I don't think anyone is planning on bowing down to your picture..

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 10 Jan 2005

Hai ji, No offense but these people seem to be doing it on a regular scale.. Look at the Front Page of Daily Ajit Jalandahr..( web edition too..in pdf file) and there is an advertisement by Nanaksaris about the 99th birthday of their long gone baba.. The First anti Gurmatt thing is the HEADING..IT just says: SATGUR PARSAAD...when everybody knows GURBANI is : Ek Onkar Satgur Parsaad. This has to be DELIBERATE because no way there can be such a huge error in alarge ehading especially with Gurbani. Interfering with GURBANI is bigger than a Bajjar Kurehat. The idea behind LEAVING OUT "EK ONKAAR" is to PROMOTE the WORD "SATGUR...PARSAAD" as the Namdharees already have "SATGUR" instead of EK Onkaar satgur Pasaad of GURBANI.. Secondly inside the advertisement are lines of KACHI BANI... The entire advert has Glowing praises over nanaksari Sampardai, uchi suchi Nanaksari maryada..as if the SIKH REHAT MARYADA is NOT those things. further on in bold it says: Post Bhang afeem amd uttar jai parbhaat, NAAM KHUMAAREE NANAKA charreee h rahen din raat [[ Jarnail singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Kulbir Singh · 10 Jan 2005

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! Veer Atamsaroop Singh jeeo, ------------- - Kulbir Singh Ji, do you really think gurmukhs who get pratak darshan of Guru Sahiban still have lot more to do in their sadhna?? ie- go through shabad surat marg ...trikurti, dasam dwar etc??? --------------------- I don’t know what you describe as Partakh Darshan but if you just wanted Partakh Darshan i.e. Sargun Darshan, then is not the darhan of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and Punj Pyaaray the sargun darshan of Guru Sahib? You say that if one gets partakh darshan of Guru Sahib i.e. dehdhaari darshan of Guru Sahib then one need not go through the Shabad Surat Maarag. In this case, how do you explain the following pankiti: SATGUR NOO SABH KO DEKHDA, JETA JAGAT SANSAAR|| DITHAI MUKAT NA HOVAYEE, JICHAR GURSHABAD NO KARAE BICHAAR|| (The whole world looks at Satguru but just by looking or getting darshan of physical form of Guru Sahib one cannot get mukat. One gets mukat only and only by doing Gurshabad Bichaar i.e. doing Shabad Surat bhagti). By darshan of Satguru here Guru Sahib is referring to physical darshan of Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib is making it clear that by just getting physical darshan of Guru Sahib one cannot get mukat. It is a must to do kamaayee of Shabad. What more can you say in the light of this pankiti. Clearly, Guru Sahib has said that the sargun darshan i.e. physical darshan of Guru Sahib will not give mukti until one obeys hukams of Guru Sahib and do shabad surat maarag. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 11 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. This is exactly what I ,meant when I asked whether anyone, in the Presence of GURU ANGAD JI even wnated /asked fro/or got Partakh Dehdharre darshan of GURU NANAK JI? No body can answer YES because it didnt happen. What exactly did GURU ANGAD JI DO ? Was GURU JI just SATISFIED with the PARTAKH DARSHAN of GURU NANAK JI;s DEH ?? NO NO NO..BHAI LEHNA JI KAMAII KARO the SHABAD ( NAAM ) that GURU NANAK JI gave Him....he kamaiied it so much that Guru Ji made Him GURU ANGAD...the others like Bhai Buddha Ji, etc were NOT up to MARK in that "department"..thats why they DIDNT get GURGADDHI. BUT they ALL had PARTAKH DARSHAN of GURU JI ALL the TIME 24/7..didnt they ?? Although I frimly beleive that from Sri Chand onwards even the Guur's sons were not up to standard in naam kamaii in spite of having Partakh darshan of Guru DEH, Prithia Chand crosed all bounds of human decency in treating PARTAKH HAR..shantee de punj Guur Arjun sahib Jee..the Bhatts can SEE "partakh har" but Prithiya the evil one can only see ???? they were all seeing the same DEH of Guru JI ?? werent they ?? Similarly ALL of us SEE the DEH of GURU GRANTH JI..but we see NIRGUN according to our SHABAD KAMAII...IF after doing "massive bhagtee/kamaii" etc we just have Partakh darshan of a SARGUN HUMAN DEH....we are no better than Baba sri Chand, Prithiya etc and the thousands of humans who saw Guru Ji in deh form years ago. IN His GURBANI GURU JI has TOTALLY NEGATED the HUMAN DEH..as of any importance...the ONLY thing is Naam Kamaii...more NK and MORE NK..more NK..and nothing else. BUT the FAKE sants and babas. satgurs and Maharajs etc sorely WANT this DEH POOJA to be revived ( for OBVIOUS REASONS)..and so they and those who "want to but for the time being "HIDE" their feelings behind GURU GRANTH JI...pretending gurbani is all they care about..THEY are the ones who stress on DEH/HUMAN GURU NANAK/GURU GOBIND SINGH JI/etc etc and partakh darshan etc/eating degh/etc etc..some how hoping agaisnt hope that their own DEH will then start to get "POOJAED" by simpletons and they will be :guru/satgurs..in their own right. NO one has the right answer ( or any answer) to the Panktee Kulbir Singh Ji has given above.... Partakh darshan of human deh is of no use..even partakh darshan of shabad guru wiothout any vichaar of shabad/kamaii of naam is of no use. jarnail singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Atamsaroop Singh · 11 Jan 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, Gurfateh, Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a shabad Guru and its link between you and nirankar (either sargun or nirgun saroop both are ang of each other ). This above pankiti given by you in the above post is an updesh given to Sikhs that time, that just because you have got darshan of Guru Maharaj does not mean your are a mukht. This pankiti does apply to us also as in "having just darshan of siri guru granth sahib ji" won't give you mukhti. However you missed, where i was coming from. Guru Maharaj (das jot's) are present in darbar and every-where. Our eyes(spiritual state) is not there to see it. That's why Baba nand singh maharaj proved this world after having soo much devotion towards Siri Guru Granth Sahib that made Guru Nanak Dev Nirankar pragat in sargun saroop from Siri Guru Granth Sahib and bless him with "GURPARSAD". If you have doubts that he didn't get Gurparsad after having darshan. Then it's your buddhi and ahankar. And also You should go infront of maharaj and take a hakumnama. We all know how many slaps we get after getting Hakumnama when we think we have atam gyan and we have buddhi to doubt different bhagti margs & also if you have read bhai randhir singh ji books doesn't mean thats a final way for everyone.that just one way out of many..have some tolerance my freind. I agree kamaye of shabad is must but its up to you if you want to follow shabad surat marg or with that kamiya you WANT to get darshan. Both ways are correct. And Nobody can claim monaply on ways to get to God. Bhai Lehna Ji (in his life) became Nirankar just by doing nishkam seva of Guru Nanak Dev ji where in his life seva becomes simran and bandageee. This is my last post on this subject. I like to say this much- When you say "shabad surat marg" is only way to naam jap and get gurparsad then you are under -estimating Nirankar and when you do that then all your bhagti life went in vain. There are sakhis OF sants like for examples Sant baba jawala singh ji harkhowaley got bhramgyan/gurparsad in one single day- don't ask me how?? This is a beauty of Nirankar.

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Kulbir Singh · 12 Jan 2005

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! Veer Aatamsaroop Singh jeeo, ------ This above pankiti given by you in the above post is an updesh given to Sikhs that time, that just because you have got darshan of Guru Maharaj does not mean your are a mukht. This pankiti does apply to us also as in "having just darshan of siri guru granth sahib ji" won't give you mukhti. ------ I think you are just assuming that the pankiti I quoted in my previous post applies to Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee only. I think it applies to any sargun saroop darshan. You write that this pankiti was written by Guru Sahib for Sikhs of old times. If Sikhs at that time did not get mukti just by getting physical darshan of Guru Sahib, how will the Sikh today get mukti by getting the same physical darshan (sargun) of Guru Sahib. What has changed today? Please think about this and answer this question. ------------ However you missed, where i was coming from. Guru Maharaj (das jot's) are present in darbar and every-where. Our eyes(spiritual state) is not there to see it. ---------- As soon as you talk about jyot darshan or jyot, you are talking about Nirgun saroop. Jyot is Nirgun. Physical darshan are sargun. --------- If you have doubts that he didn't get Gurparsad after having darshan. Then it's your buddhi and ahankar. ---------- I did not say anytyhing about him getting Gurparsad or not getting it. All I said was that he could not have got gurparsad from worshipping like the so called Dhanna way. And talking about Dhanna, what do you have to say now about Dhanna, after reading my earlier email on Dhanna Bhagat? Do you still believe that he got darshan through stone? Even after reading Guru Sahib’s pankiti that clearly condemns pathar pooja, would you still believe in Dhanna style bhagti (so called)? --------- And also You should go infront of maharaj and take a hakumnama. We all know how many slaps we get after getting Hakumnama when we think we have atam gyan and we have buddhi to doubt different bhagti margs & also if you have read bhai randhir singh ji books doesn't mean thats a final way for everyone.that just one way out of many..have some tolerance my freind. ------- Okay my friend, I will have tolerance. Hehe! I don’t know where I showed intolerance to you. I am only trying to discuss a very important issue of Sikhi with you and have always been addressing you as politely and respectfully as possible. What intolerance are you talking about? --------- I agree kamaye of shabad is must but its up to you if you want to follow shabad surat marg or with that kamiya you WANT to get darshan. -------- Now you have totally lost me. What are you talking about? In your earlier postings you wrote that the two ways of bhagti were Shabad surat maarag (which means shabad dee kamaayee) and so called Dhanna style sargun bhagti, now you are taking about shabad di kamaayee but wanting different rewards from it i.e. darshan and shabad surat. Nirgun Pooja too aims for darshan but only Dib-Jyot Lateefi Darshan as opposed to physical darshan. Once you do shabad surat or shabad dee kamaayee, then there is no point in asking for physical darshan. If Guru Sahib in his divine will blesses the seeker with his physical darshan, nothing wrong with it but to ask for physical darshan as opposed to the real darshan i.e. darshan of Guru Sahib as he appears in Sach Khand (Nirgun Darshan) is a very naïve thing to do. Coming back to Baba Nand Singh jee, I have already proven to you that he did do shabad surat dee kamaayee and that too very heavy and intense kamaayee. ---------- Both ways are correct. And Nobody can claim monaply on ways to get to God. Bhai Lehna Ji (in his life) became Nirankar just by doing nishkam seva of Guru Nanak Dev ji where in his life seva becomes simran and bandageee. ---------- Who says he did only sewa and no simran? Where did you get this idea from? My friend, there is not a single bhagat, Brahmgyani or Guru Sahib who did not do extremely intensive kamaayee of shabad. ------------ This is my last post on this subject. I like to say this much- When you say "shabad surat marg" is only way to naam jap and get gurparsad then you are under -estimating Nirankar and when you do that then all your bhagti life went in vain. ---------------- I am not saying that but Guru Nanak Dev jee has said that the essence of Sikhi or Gurmat is “Shabad Guru, Surat Dhunn Chela”. Please read the baani of Sidh Goshth for more details. Shabad Surat Maarag is the only way to Vaheguru. So says Gurbani. ------------ There are sakhis OF sants like for examples Sant baba jawala singh ji harkhowaley got bhramgyan/gurparsad in one single day- don't ask me how?? This is a beauty of Nirankar -------------- Baba Jawala Singh Harkhowal waalay was a great proponent of Shabad Surat maarag because he and Baba Ishar Singh Rarewalay both belonged to the same samprada – the Samprada of Baba karam Singh Hoti Mardaan. They both advocated only Nirgun Pooja. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Atamsaroop Singh · 12 Jan 2005

Gurfateh Ji, My intention behind comparing bhagat dhanna story was beacuse i was always under impression he also did shabad surat marg but his intial stages was to worship the stone with full faith...so i m sorry for comparing bhagat dhanna story with baba nand singh life. But having said that, i still hold even though full sargun pooja is not gurmat. I still hold only sargun pooja with great devotion, full bairaag and prem can get you gurparsad...may be little longer than gurmat way..may be not jivan mukht avasta. But it will get you there. Aim in nirgun pooja can be also changed if there is a foorna(thought) in the surat in an final intial stages to have darshan of Guru Maharaj ji in sargun form if that happens. As Guru Maharaj is both nirgun and sargun will come and give you darshan. Thus, you will get gurparsad. so let me ask you, would u say that is incomplete as well????

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

khalsaa · 12 Jan 2005

One time Baba Nand Singh Maharaj put forth the question, What would you ask for provided you had the opportunity to meet Guru Nanak? One person responed with what he would ask for. Another responded with his wishes. After listening to a few replies, Baba Nand Singh remarked, If you meet Guru Nanak, What else is there to ask for? In gurbani it is stated: bhee paraapath maanukh dhaehureeaa || This human body has been given to you. gobi(n)dh milan kee eih thaeree bareeaa || This is your opportunity to meet Gobind. Does this simply mean going to the gurdhwara and looking at Guru Granth Sahib? No, it implies something further.... When Bhai Bala was asked with what type of sharda did he serve Guru Nanak, he replied that he served Guru Nanak with the sharda that Guru Nanak was a great mahapurkh. And the response was that is why you have become a great mahapurkh as was your sharda! When the question was put forth to Bhai Lehna, tears welled up in his eyes and he replied that his sharda was that Guru Nanak was GOD incarnate and that is with what sharda he served Him. And the response was that is why you have become GOD, Guru Angad Jee, according to your sharda you have received the gurgaddhi!!

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Search For Tat · 12 Jan 2005

This is a really good debate, and i am more convinced by Veer kulbir singh ji. "Why would Guru Nanak Sahib send someone (Baba Nand Singh as you write) to teach people how to do Sargun Pooja? Why did not any of our 10 Guru Sahibaan do Sargun Pooja?"

Re: Reply to Kulbir Singh post on thread bhramgyanis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 12 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Kulbir singh ji writes: <<>>> Call me paranoid or just plain suspicious....but blindfod me in sangat listening to katahwachak...and I can easily pick out those who STRESS so MUCH on "nishkam Sewa"...etc of GURU ANGAD JI and GURU AMARDASS JI..as IF THAT was all Guru Ji did and they got Gurgadhi....these will go on and on about how Guru Amardass ji in late life went about walking backwards and forwards to fetch water in the dead of night...and the BHAGTEE of NAAM KAMAII is left in the background as a vague "after thought" These are the Kathawachaks of those who beleive very sincerely in DEH POOJA/SARGUN DARSHAN...to them POOJA/SEWA of the Human DEH is PARAMOUNT.. these are the promoters of living humans who want us, their sewaks to do shaksee pooja of their own DEH...and there are no shortage of Youthful SEWAKS who will spend their time doing muthee chapee/massaging their legs to "gain Instant Naam/salvation... from these holy/holies.. The "obvious tress is on Guru Amardass Ji's sewa of the deh of Guru Angad Ji ..the "background/sub conscious" stress is ..on "DO such sewa of ME..and you will get saved." I think they are sadly mistaken. SEWA has its rightful place in Sikhi and Gurmat...nishkam sewa is even more important..BUT the MOST IMPORTANT thing that the GURU JI's did was NAAM ABHIYAAS/SHABAD BHAGTEE. This was waht got Bhai lehna ji get transformed into GURU ANGAD..and what got a simple old amn called Amru transformed into GURU AMARDASS JI, Nithavian da Thaan, nimanniana da maan, nitannia da taan, niotian dee oat, niasrian da aasra....just "sewa" alone wouldnt have achieved that transformation....a lot of others did sewa but didnt get transfomred into GURU JI. I read somwwhere ( off hand i cant recall)..that when Bhai lehan Ji first met Guur nanak Ji, Guru Ji gave Bhai Ji the Naam Waheguru/Satnam to JAPP. Bhai lehna ji obeyed Guru Ji, but came back after some time and said "what you asked me to do is very tasteless...boring..." but Guru Ji told bhai ji to carry on never the less....and Bhai lehna Ji japped this Naam so much that finally He attained Gurgadhi. Guur nanak Ji's final choice of Bhai Lehna ji for gurgadhi was highly dependant on this Naam factor....sewa etc came a far distant second. Jarnail Singh