Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

raagmala

raagmala

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vahiguru ji ka khalsa vahiguru ji ki fateh Raagmala has been a subject of debate for many years. Raagamala is part of a love story written by a muslim poet called Alam. It has been added into the back of the sri guru granth sahib ji. If compared to the rest of the sri guru granth sahib ji, one can easily see that there is something wrong with raagmala. It contains many gramatical mistakes and the true guru cannot make a mistake so therefore raagmala cant be gurbani. Also the context of raagmala is completely differnet to the rest of the sri guru granth sahib jee with not one mention of god or how to obtain god, all is in the raagmala is a story of raagis and raaginis. also raagmala contains only 6 raags whilst the guru granth sahib ji has 31. In conclusion it is clear that raagmala is NOT gurbani. Whilst many people realise this fact they seem to think that it doesnt matter and its only a trivial matter and they can just ignore it. Well to sit back and let your guru be deformed by rubbish such as the raagmala is a sin itself as a sikh our duty is to worship our guru and therefore try our best to see it is not disrespected or deformed in anyway and by adding raagmala to the sri guru grsnth sahib the true form of our guru is being deformed. Just think, would you feel comfortable making up a poem and writing it into the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? vahiguru ji ka khalsa vahiguru ji ki fateh

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005

but since the "Sants and brahmgianis" have declared that raagmala is "gurbani"...what can mere mortals lke us do.. BTW have you read Sukhmani Sahib....Brahmgiani AAp parmehsar...and if a number of such brahmgianis declare raagmala to be "gurbani" do you DARE to say NO ?? IF you dare to say NO, then you havent read Sukhmani Sahib..lol....really terrible things happen to those who doubt brahmgianis. Of course following the above "logic " anybody who says Raagmala is NOT GURBANI cannot possibly be a Brahmgiani..and you can therefore diss him good and proper without any fear of Sukhmani sahib. Thats th crux of the matter. The Brahmgianis CANNOT admit they are wrong...how can a Brahmgiani be wrong in the first place ??..then he wouldnt be a brahmgiani..right ? YES. SO who is going to point out to the "brahmgiani" that he is like the King who wore "new Clothes" that no body could "see" but no body would admit that because to admit one cannot see is saying I am Stupid..it took the innocence of a CHILD to set things right...the Child looked at the Naked King on his horse and exclaimed..BUT the KING is NAKED !!! and instantly everyone saw that the king was really naked... The Matter thus lies in the hands of the YOUTH and coming generations..they MUST see the Brahmgiani is not wearing any clothes.... Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

Bundha · 04 Jan 2005

BhaiJi, Do you think for one moment that Guru Sahib Ji would let the Sikh panth bow down in-front of Aadh Guru Granth Sahib Ji if there was even one letter incorrect in it ? No, Guru Ji would not therefore I have total faith in Guru Ji and total faith in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I am no expert but when I listen to Raagmala at the end of an Akahnd Path I can count more then six raags. From the top of my head I remember – Bilawal, Hindol, Khamod, Kaafi, Bharavi, Asawari, Maulkauns, Deepak, Bharairo, Todi - That’s 10 already, so your argument of 6 does not hold from the outset. The order of rags that appear in Ragmala are irrelevant to the writing of it, as it is not an index of the rags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Ragmala and Gurbani in general have deeper mystical meanings, if we don’t understand or can’t comprehend these deeper hidden jewels, that does not mean we should simply disregard Gurbani we don’t understand. Nobody argued that Ragmala is a mere rosary of the rags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, Guru Jee decided what rags to include in Ragmala and it is not for us to doubt/question this decision. In Gurbani the word rag also means prem (love), so Ragmala is also a rosary of love it is not merely a rosary of rags (this is in reference to the deeper mystical meanings of Ragmala mentioned above). This Alam point is a fallacy, it was a poet named Jodh who wrote Madhvanal Kamkandla in 1583 AD - Ragmala or anything even resembling it, is not present in the original version of this book. The poet Alam lived from 1655 to 1717 AD and after listening to/reading Ragmala, he wrote a book called Madhvanal Sangeet that was mostly copied work from other poets including Jodh. There is also a poem in this compilation which doubters of Ragmala believe is Ragmala, but it is actually very different to Ragmala. In the past century people have mistakenly linked the work of these poets’ as one and the same, because Alam plagerised much of his work from Jodh, and they try to prove that Ragmala is not Gurbani with this mistaken line of argument. Historically there are 11 different versions of Ragmala they all differ from the one which is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. BhaJi don't for one minute think that Sikhs take this lightly.

Re: raagmala

Bijla Singh · 04 Jan 2005

First you people need to think about it. what does love story have to do with Raags in the first place? nothing. secondly, how and when did raag maala get added into Guru Granth Sahib Ji? don't even give me the theory of Shamsher Singh Ashok as it is total nonsense. who added it? what year? why? which saroop was it? where was it? how did it appear in other saroops? you don't think there was only one saroop at that time? Khalsa Panth was divided into groups and each group kept saroop of Guru Granth Sahib Ji with it all the time even in jungles. raag maala couldn't magically just appear everywhere. Gursikhs in 18th century knew exactly what was bani and what was not. they won the battles with power of Bani. they kept more rehat than all of us and very more chardee kala singhs. my questions are about the roots not numbering system or anything else. All the arguments come after the questions I have asked. if you have answers with solid proofs then please post 'em otherwise refrain from attacking each other. I am sure this will turn into pointless debate just like the other one and i don't know why admins keep allowing these topics. what a way to begin a new year. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf jarnail singh, you are correct in saying you cant argue with a brahm gyani and you cant argue with bhai sahib randhir singh who was a brahm gyanni who sed raagmala wanst bani so all people who think it is bani are NOT brahmgianis. Also alam wrote the peom in 1583 so bundha u are confused u must be thinking of some other Alam and if brahmginis didnt get any benefit out of it then it cant be bani. raag mala contains mistakes of grammar and since the guru is perfect the guru woudnt have made mistakes. Raagmala was added after mundavni and mundavni is the seal of the guru granth sahib and as it is the end when guru gobind aingh added guru tegh bahdhur's bani he added it BEFORE mudavni, therefore any thing after mundavni is not bani. raagmala is part of a love story called Kam Kandlan. There are 6 main raags ''So all together, they sing the six Raagas and the thirty Raaginis, and all the forty-eight sons of the Raagas'' (from raag mala). Why is there is mentino at all of god or anything to do with god in raagmala, it is obviously not gurbani that some intefering person decided to put into the back of the guru granth sahib vjkk vjkf

Re: raagmala

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf if you want to use the argument ''Guru Sahib Ji wouldnt let the Sikh panth bow down in-front of Aadh Guru Granth Sahib Ji if there was even one letter incorrect in it then how do you explain rattan mala and all of the kachi bani in the old hand written birs such as recipies on how to make ink. The fact is that kuchi bani has managed to find its way into the guru granth sahib ji and although the majority of the panth mow agree that rattan mala and other kachi bani is not gurbani, raag mala still has supporters for the pure reason that its in the guru granth sahib ji. This is because when people were typing up the hand written birs which contained loads of kachi bani they didnt question what was contained in the birs so kachi bani managed to appear in type out birs of the guru granth sahib ji. Also would you care to tell me any spiritual benefit i can obtain from the raagmala because i am certain that there is none at all. You are confused about the author of raag mala as you are mixing alam from the guru jis court. professor surinder singh of raj academy who is an EXPERT on all types of classical indian raags and teaches clasical raag vidiya in UK has said raagmalla raags do NOT correlate with raags in bani properly. vjkk vjkf

Re: raagmala

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf Firstly in response to your 'Guru Sahib Ji wouldn't let the Sikh panth bow down in-front of Aadh Guru Granth Sahib Ji if there was even one letter incorrect in it' ho9w do you explain rattan mala and ink recipies and all the other kachi bani found in the old hand written birs? Secondly raag mala got into the guru granth sahib the same way as all the other kachi bani that used to be in the birs of the sggsj did. This is by people copying the hand wirtten birs into typed up birs and not bothering to edit or remove the kachi bani. However most of the kachi bani such as rattan mala has now been widely reagrded by the panth as kachi bani whereas some of the panth seem unable to grasp the fact that raagmala is also kachi bani. You are confused about the author of raagmala as you are mixing up the alam of guru ji's darbar with the alam who wrote raagmala. Also professor surinder singh of raj academy who is an EXPERT on all types of classical indian raags and teaches clasical raag vidiya in UK has said raagmalla raags do NOT correlate with raags in bani properly. Tell me waht spiritual benefit can anyone gain from reading raagmala it contains no mention of god or anything in similarity to the rest of the guru granth sahib ji it looks just like a mess of incorrect grammar added into the end of guru sahib AFTER mundanvi which is the seal of the guru granth sahib and therefore anything after this is kachi bani. RAAGMALA AINT BANI! vjkk vjkf

Re: raagmala

another learner · 04 Jan 2005

How do you explain rattan mala, and the other compositioins that the whole panth removed, all of which were before raagmala? We all have faith aswell, but the reality is compositions were added at the end. The whole panth knows this, and this why all but raagmala where removed. Only raagmala remains, because of supersititious so-called bharamgianis.. bundha wrote Do you think for one moment that Guru Sahib Ji would let the Sikh panth bow down in-front of Aadh Guru Granth Sahib Ji if there was even one letter incorrect in it ? No, Guru Ji would not therefore I have total faith in Guru Ji and total faith in Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: raagmala

kaur id · 04 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I find it quite worrying that people take the mick out of wot is written in the sacred Sukhmani Sahib. Yes we should not speak against Brahmgyanis so why laugh at that?? I think that if the sants and Bramgyanis are for Raagmala then there must be some reason. Afterall we do not understand a lot of wot God does and we do not know the story behind Raagmala. None of us were there when Guru Ji compiled so what right do we have to fight against the brahmgyanis? and that too successfully? The great Brahmgyanis know God and they know why God did what God did when putting Raagmala in Guru Sahib. So why not just allow it, does it say anything against God? there must be a reason why we bow down to Guru Ji with Raagmala, God does not misdirect us and nor does He misdirect the Bramgyanis. Whether some of us question their existence is our own choice but then it is to say that Guru Ji lied when they wrote Sukhmani Sahib. I do get upset that ppl take the mick out of Sukhmani Sahib. Even Guru Ji knew that there was going to be ninda of God's bhagats and that is why Guruji warns us not to do ninda. please take note of that Bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,,

Re: raagmala

anon · 05 Jan 2005

fateh ji 1st off, we don't know who is a brahmgyani and who isnt. Secondly, look at bhai randhir singh and bhai rama singh (uk), brilliant gursikhs who had done amazing amounts of bhagati . did they not both passionately tell everyone the raagmala is not bani?

Re: raagmala

singh · 05 Jan 2005

why does everyone keep getting into brahmgiani this and sant that? how do any of us know who a pooran bhramgiani is? someone will say baba thakur singh, another baba mohan singh bhindraa, another baba nand singh, someone bhai rama singh uk, somebody else baba harnam singh ram pur khera, another bhai jeevan singh, sant gurbachan singh bhindra, bhai sahib randheer singh, etc, etc. these people all had different views on different issues. so who was right? are any of us big enough to rank avasthas? so why bring up 'bramgianee and sant so and so'. debate the facts. that's one thing I like about the anti ragmala side. i rarely see them use the argument that bhai randheer singh said it wasn't, so it isn't. they base their points on the actual composition and historical references. also, i guess the vast majority of anti ragmala people don't even associate with the jatha of bhai randheer singh (mostly sikh missionaries) and so they wouldn't use that argument anyway. but even the ones who are with that jatha, don't use that. which is good. the pro ragmala side should follow suit and try basing their arguments on the actual issue, and not personalities. if they insist on using personalities, there will be no solution.

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 05 Jan 2005

waheguru Ji ka khalsa waheguur ji ki fateh. The on line newspaper www.badhni.com has an excellent article by Sarvjit Singh on the raagmala issue ; The following link in Dasam Granth also mentions this Madhav nal kamal story. http://www.gobindsadan.org/institute/dasam/pdf/v4_3.pdf . The Origina rargamala in the Poets' book has the numbers 34/35/36/37/38 and so on..and this order is correctly followed from the earlier compositions and then continued after atharaan das bees... But the fellow who "copied" this portion of the raagmala from its original book tried to DISGUISE the numbering by putting in just the numeral [[1]] AFTER EACH COUPLET... the SAME number 1 is written from beginning to end This is such a HUGE ERROR that it alone is solid proof that this si not by GURU JI because GURU ji was very very careful about the numbering/totals/sub totals/ etc through out Guru granth Ji... HOW on Earth could we have GURU JI making this Colossal MISTAKE in numbereing. This is beside the many may Gramattical MISTAKES, wrong raags, names of raags, places, spelling mistakes, giving prominence to the wrong raag contrdictory to Guru Ji and Bhai gurdass Ji' writings.... in short there are so many HOLES in Raagmala..no sane minded can beleive it is guru kirt. The Entire 1429 AAngs of Gurbani do not contain a SINGLE ERROR of spelling/numbering/sub totals/totals....and the LAST Aang is FULL to the BRIM of errors..after errors.. Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

Guldeep Singh · 05 Jan 2005

For those actually interested in the opposing view can see what taksal has to say. Baba Deep Singh Ji's handwritten birs all include raag mala. Would all the brahmgiani bashing views posted on this thread have the guts to use Baba Ji's name in their sarcasm? http://d256081.u30.infinology.net/media/video/index.php

Re: raagmala

amarjeet singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf kaur id your arguement is weak as it involves making a decision on who or not is a brahmgyani which can be argued about all day. You say brahmgianis say that raag mala is gurbani so it must be but i can say that brahmgians say its not gurbani and therefore the people you think are brahmgyanis cant be because brahmgyanis all beleive the same thing as they are all untied with the same truth vjkk vjkf

Re: raagmala

no body · 05 Jan 2005

Sukhmani sahib, also says that only a brahmgyani can recognise another brahmgyani.... how is it that every 14 year old kid, thinks that so and so is a brahmgyani........ I think only the guru's were true sant/brahmgyanis! At least with chrisianity they have to be dead and proven to have done at least 3 miraculous events before they can be declared a saint of god! In our religion it seems like every tom dick and harry is calling themselves a sant, and then everyone runs around after them calling them sants tooo!!! And pro-ragmala people shouldn't say that sants say it is bani therefore it is! as there are just as many "sants" saying it isn't!

Re: raagmala

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

Please state these so called grammer mistakes. If Mudavani is the seal of closure then technically we cannot accept Salok Mahalla 5, as this is a separate Shabad which comes after Mudhavani Mahalla 5. and yet you have no objection to this. In fact the word Mudavani is present on two other occasions in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, on Ang 645 within the same Shabad in Vaar of Sorat(h). So if we follow this line of argument anything after this Shabad is not Gurbani – how ludicrous is that! It would be very easy to make a list of Gursikhs who were held in high regard that believe Ragmala is Gurbani. The other point to note is that Sikhs throughout the world read Ragmala and it only a minority who question or doubt it’s authenticity, there are only a few Gurdwaras throughout the world where Ragmala is not recited and it is recited at Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib and Sri Harimander Sahib.

Re: raagmala

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

No body, I wouldn't site Christianity in your argument, their way of cannonising a saint is very dubious indeed, with them it is all politics, who can push whose name further to get them sainthood. They are even trying to get a pope to sainthood and this person never spoke out against the holocuast and issued instructions never to reunite jewish children with thier parents after the war. Guldeep singh Ji you are right, which person is going to say the Baba Deep Singh Ji's hath-likhet saroops are incorrect ?

Re: raagmala

Dissapointed at ignorance · 05 Jan 2005

1. Example of grammatical error : the word Jabblidhar in raagmala is actually Jallandhar as in the city in the original work by Alam. Please conslult the work of Prof. Surinder Singh Kolhi for a more exaustive list of errors in raag names etc. 2. I think we all know how and under what (gunpoint) circumstances the reading of raagmala was started at the Akaal Takhat less than 20 years ago. 3. I would suggest that people should consult the works of people like Pr. Kolhi who in no uncertain terms, as part of his PHD thesis on the literary analaysis of the Guru Granth Sahib (in which he definately probes the inner/hidden meanings) concludes that Guru Arjun Dev Jee could not have written raagmala. Another interesting point he raises is that inthe 1850's there was a panthic gathering at a dera of a baba near Amritsar where the decision was taken to not read raagmala. This decision was documented in the Lahore Sikh Gazzette of 1906. 4. I have not believed in Raagmala for over 20 years. In that time I have attempted to read as much of the arguments for and against in the hope the Guru Jee gives sojee to make he right decision. I can safely say that I am more than comfortable that Guru Jee has guided me to the right answer. 5. Clearly this issue has been around and will be around for some time. Its a lot older than AKJ and Taksaal. Taksaali Singhs may argue with that. But if you do your research you will see that origins of this issue lie in the same time era as the completion and reproduction of the Kartarpur vali Bir. 6. I would suggest to modern naujawaans, please study the subject with open minds. Don't let anybody/sanstha/group/jatha and dare I say it Brahmgiani give you any pre-conceptions. Do ardaas to your Guru and go with a free mind. 7. People like Pr. G S Mann (California) have studied in detail the formation of the Sikh Scripture and have with hard evidence shown how the proliferation of the Aad Bir took place where the recenssions were done and exactly what bani additional to the accepted was present. It is clear from their research that from the very early copies that there was some people adding raagmala and some leaving it out. Please read the book for more detail. 8. I have personnaly questioned Prof. Mann about his view on raagmala. To which he answered that he does believe it as Guru Jees kirit. But did go on to say that the Panth has made a decision that printed Saroops should contain it so it would be wrong to do otherwise. I have attempted to avoid criticising people/branches of the panth. Apologies if I have unknowingly done this. Pleae accept the some of the details may not be 100% correct as I am writing this from memory in my lunch break. Gurfateh!!

Re: raagmala

UKSingh · 05 Jan 2005

Raag Malkauns which appears in Raagmala, doesn't even exist i the guru granth sahib? So how can Raagmala be a complilation of raags in the guru granth sahib, when there is a conflict in the raags? Its like a book having the wrong contents.

Re: raagmala

A Singh · 05 Jan 2005

The Sri Raagmala is obviously a mala of 'Raags'. Hence, it would be logical to assume that you would need knowledge of raag sangeet in order to grasp its essence. How many people that object to it being bani know or study raag? If you know not the complexities involved then, how can you comment? Maharaj, has catogorised most of Sri Guru Granth Sahib into Raags, and not subject matter, in places going as far as to indicate Partaals (different rhythams) as well for particualr shabads. Obviously, these project a particular mood , feeling, and hence it is foolish for people to sing these in any other raag or hindi or sangat orientated tune. Who are we trying to please here? People or the Satguru? Do we now discount the headings for each shabad as that indicate which raag it is to be sung in - this the hukam e.g. Asa Mahala 1 - here the raag 'asa' is indicated upon which the shabad is to be placed or sung. So if we now, ignore raags, and since Asa is not 'gurbani', should we now have a new version of Maharaj where the raags are removed?

Re: raagmala

kookar-Di-Poochh · 05 Jan 2005

The Raags in Gurbani are just Raags.... those in Raagmala have wives and sons,..this is a big discrepancy....too big to just sweep under the carpet of brahmgianism. Bundha Ji questions the Shlok Mh 5 at the Conclusion of Guru Granth Ji..he forgets that the Shlok Mh 5 is a THANKSGIVING SHLOK by the Author after the completion of such a huge undertaking. Such an "acknowledgement" ALWAYS comes AFTER a Granth is Completed and dGuru Arjun Ji has followed literary precedence. Bundha JI must also rememeber that GURU GRANTH Ji BEGINS with a SHLOK "AAd Sach..Jugaad sach.."( which the Sants/Brahmgianais group continues to stubbornly and agaisnt all gurbani rules and conventions call MoolMantar which actually ends at GURPARSAAD)....and therefore it is only right thet the Granth should END with a Shlok to keep to the Perfect Symmetery followed through out the Granth Ji. Guur Nanak Ji calls Sri Raag..as PREMIER RAAG,,Raagaan wich Sri Raag hai..and BHAI GURDAS ji in his Vars echoes this same sentiment...can GURU JI then go ahead and CONTRADICT himslef and say BHAIRO is SUPREME as in Raagmala..This alone is enough to prove raagmala comes from outside...it just doesnt belong. SRI RAAG as Supreme fits GURBANI as it is Spiritual..while Bhairo fits the POEM of a Court Darbar where dancing and drinking debauchery takes place as Premier Raag just as raagmala says it is. Kookar panth Da

Re: raagmala

Bundha · 05 Jan 2005

<<<<< while Bhairo fits the POEM of a Court Darbar where dancing and drinking debauchery takes place >>>> Cooker, this so called raag, Raag Bhairao appears in Guru Granth Sahib Ji from ang 1125 so please be careful what you say. I am pointing out a tchnicality, if like you lot say that Mandhavani is the seal, then technically EVERYTHING after it should be discarded, you cannot pick and choose and say this is symmetical or whatever, also Mandhavani appears in Guru Sahib Ji earlier so again you fail in your point. As said before Raagmala is not meant to be a rosery of the raags in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Please study Sangeet Raknikhar and other ancient texts, the Raags and Ragni system was a way of classifying raags and Guru Sahib Jis were well aware of this.

Re: raagmala

amarjeet singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf technalities??>? if u look in raag mala ull find a lot like the many gramatical errors it makes. and alam wrote raag mala like ive sed b4. Also like kooker sed, salok mehala 5 is after mudavni bcos it follows the perfect symettry of the guru the last thanks if you like whilest the mundavni is the the end to all of the bani written before this point, this perfect symettry exists in our perfect guru and raag maala looks like a messy scrawl when its numbering system, its grammar and its content is compared to the sri guru granth sahib ji vjkk vjkf

Re: raagmala

B Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Response to *A Singh*: >The Sri Raagmala is obviously a mala of 'Raags'. Hence, it would be >logical to assume that you would need knowledge of raag sangeet in >order to grasp its essence. You are corect by the traditional interpretattion of raagmalla. And as amarjeet singh has already pointed out, an expert in the field of raagsangeet is Professor Surinder Singh Raj Academy (don''t confuse with Prof Kolhi) Perhaps you should ask him about his views on raagmalla Because he is certainly not pro Raag Malla last time I checked. And secondly the modern interpritation of raagmalla (and I say modern since this interpretattion has only popped up in modern times) is that raagmalla is not about Raags at all. Acording to these people there are countless spiritual meanings and hidden gems within raagmalla. I would be interested to see how many spiritual meanings can be derrived from the line of raagmalla "First comes Raag Bhairo." :O) gurfateh!!!

Re: raagmala

singh ji · 05 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf i agree with amarjeet singh, his views on raagmala are quite true, i have studied raagmala for a long time, and so far it makes no sence to me, it dusnt make sence that it is at the bak of the guru granth sahib if it is the so called "contets of the raags" 1st of all all the raags in guru granth sahib ji are not in raagmala, so how can it be the contents. In the time of guru arjan dev maharaj EVERY 1 wanted there bani in the guru granth sahib because guru asked for other bhagats bani. and at the time the BRHANS thought that if there bani was in there ppl wud follow us and not the sikhs. THATS WHY THERE IS KUCHI BANI GURU DASAM GRANTH. All the main kuchi bani like raatanmala, hikayat, ink recipies where at the end and were taken out and are no longer known as gurbani so why is raagmala still in there? MAHAPURASHES AND BRAHAMGIYAANIS like Bhai sahib bhai randhir singh have told us that NO IT IS NOT BANI, so why turn ur bak on a brahamgiyaani. This is a big issue and we cant just leave it becuase if we dont solve these issues then problems will get worser and worser. thank u WJKK WJKF

Re: raagmala

A Singh · 06 Jan 2005

'Professor' Surinder Singh of Raj Academy may have some knowledge on Raag, but as he sings besura and is sometimes incorrect in his raag renditions (grammatically speaking), then how does this make him an expert? It would be better to ask his accompanists such Bhai Sahib Surjit Namdhari the sarangi ustad, who actually play and know more than him! There are far more knowledgeable people out there such as rababis, mirasees, sufis, pandits who are true Raagees (those who know raag), that know and sing far far better than Surinder Singh. You want to hear someone of rababi (the original kirtania in the Guru's durbar), then go to this address and check his tabla: www.taritabla.com There is far more to music then just 'sa re ga ma' and 'dha dhin dhin dha' !! Bheron is a taat aswell as a specific raag, also, is an incarnation of Shivji Maharaaj. So, now think why it comes first?

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Technically inclined bundha ji, do you technically READ the First FEW pages or so of the GURU GRANTH JI...those that occur BEFORE Ek Onkar Satnamm..Japji sahib... all the Sehaj paaths and Akhand Paths I have wtnessed begin from JAPJI SAHIB ?? are they all technically in ERROR. Since all that stuff is NOT GURBANI and NOT READ....anything after the Slok Mh 5 Thanksgiving Slok is NOT GURBANI and should NOT be read. Is this technically correct or you need some more techicalities ?? Thank You. Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Bijla Singh Ji writes: >>>>>>>>>First you people need to think about it. what does love story have to do with Raags in the first place? <<<< Wasnt it Shakespeare who said it: IF MUSIC be the Food of LOVE..Play on...in the Merchant of Venice.. Where do we find "music" the MOST ( by this I mean GURU Kaal..times of the Gurus....until the invention of radio/TV Any two year old will tell you... 1. In the GURU DARBAR... and in.... 2. IN the MUJRAH DARBAR of the Prostitute ( have a look at Hindi Films like Mughle Azam....and show me one MUJRAH/Prostitutes dancing session where drink/debauchery/sex is NOT accompanied by MUSIC..in fact the Harmonium WAJA and TABLA are the instruments most used by the musicians who perform there. Gurbani from Aang 1 - 1429 Shlok Mh 5 Tera Kita Jatoh nahin...is From the FIRST GURU DARBAR above... That is Why SRI RAAG takes Prime Spot here...and Raag bhairo is No. 24 out of 31 Raagmala is from the MUJRAH DARBAR second one above. That is WHY raag BHAIRO takes PRIME SPOT here....sri raag comes much later.. ponder: The most widely musical instruments in GURU DARBAR in GURU KAAl were string instruments/rabab.tanpura/ etc which are soothing soulful music types...fit like a glove to Gurbani- Spirituality.. How as time went on the Coarse WAJA harmonium and loud Tabla of the Mujrah darbar came and took centre stage even in the GURU DARBAR..adn led to the eventual total DEMISE of the stringed instruments. Now take a leap to the present..see how some DISCO types of "SIKH musicians" are taking GURU DARBAR GURBANI KIRTAN to Stage Halls/Disco Shows/Bhangra Performances.... In the First instance only the MUJRAH INSTRUMENTS invaded GURU DARBAR...now our people are EXPORTING GURBANI wholesale to the Mujrah darbar...the MIXING of RRAGMALA from the mujrah darbar into the Pristine Shudh Dhudh of GURBANI-GURU DARBAR was such an attempt in the late Guru Kaal.to MIX the two..done cleverly by vested interests...and now being done by senseless sikhs who should know better. The FASTER we SIKHS DROP RAAGMALA, RESTORE stringed instruments their place of HONOUR in Guru Darbar.....and kick out the WAJA..the better we will be. Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

Harbhajan · 06 Jan 2005

Raagmaala bani hai! Raagmala is in old birs so it must be bani I know Alam wrote it and that he wasn't a bhagat, and its part of a love story but who says bani can't descend on someone who isnt a bhagat? Bani can descend on anyone even a paapi. Taksal rehit maryada is original and hasnt been corrupted by hindu influence, like not eating meat. Sikhs can eat meat as long as its not halal. Taksal follows Akal Takht, and they say chatka meat is ok too. so vivek its Taksal who are the only jatha who are uncorrupted.

Re: raagmala

kaur id · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh so taksaal is right, how can that be when it is clear that signed hukamnamas by Guru Jis (at least 2) clearly say that not to eat meat to the sikhs. There is one word in Guru Ji that has been misinterpreted to mean halal is not allowed, but there is no mention or even suggestion in sikh history that we can turn to that says other meat is allowed. and wot of the shabad where it is said that the dish of rice etc is preffered? Please dont coonfuse things, read bani, meat is not allowed, whether u want to interpret it to mean halal is another matter and quite wrong too. Bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,

Re: raagmala

Bijla Singh · 06 Jan 2005

Jarnail Singh Ji, there is a big difference between raags and just simple bhangra or mujra music. whenever Guru Ji spoke new Bani, He sang it. He went to Baghdad, sat down and started singing Gurbani in raags not in type of music you are referring to. also, does names of raags appear in heer ranjha, sassi punnu, mirja sahiba, romio juliet and any other love story? the answer is no. then my question is what does names of raags have to do with love story of madhwanal kaamkandlan? how are these names of raags in raag maala related to their love life? I have studied madhwanal kaamkandlan written by Alam and raag maala is very different than the one in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Raag Maala includes names of raags which means someone who has the knowledge of raags could write Raag maala (Guru Ji) but Alam was a poet not musician. therefore, it is not his work. there have been more than one Alam but none of them was a musician. anti-raag maala scholars have different theories on Alam. Shamsher Singh Ashok says something else and Pandit tara Singh says something else. at least have one solid theory about alam, his work, his origin and his religion etc. my other questions are still not answered about how it got added into Guru JI's saroop. if you guys want to discuss this topic then why not start from the beginning (roots)? i have heard, read and examined all the arguments presented so far. unless a new theory or argument is presented that needs to be examined I will stay out of it. but i would like to ask if anyone has changed his/her mind after reading these posts? if no, then why carry on? if yes then how did it benefit your jeevan? we all are Sikhs and brothers and sisters. we have the same father and mother. parents never want to see their children fighting because it doesn't benefit anyone. there have been great gursikhs within the last 100 years. if this matter couldn't get solved during their time then what are we in front of them? we have no jeevan, no sikhi. all we know is how to fight and then we wonder why Panth isn't in chardee kala. NOTE: Read Guru Granth Sahib Kosh by Bhai Veer Singh Ji and Raag Maala Bani Hai by Jaswant Singh for more info on Alam and different types of raag maalas. Guru Rakha. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

ns · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Excuse me is there anyone here from the sarbat khalsa Akal Takt or representing them on this debate. if not then please close this debate as it 's a pointless ivory tower discussion. If raagmala is bani or not bani is decided tomorrow it;s not suddenly going to bring about Khalsa Raj and all the problems that exist in the current sikh climate going to go away as if kalyug is going to turn into satyug for the Sikhs overnight. Come on very knowledgeable people exist on this forum surely you know it makes sense to discuss the upcoming problems for our next generations,I'll start mentioning them on this debate if this debate goes on and on and on. "IF YOU CAN'T HAVE THE FACTS WITH THE THINKING , THEN HOW CAN YOU HAVE THE THINKING WITHOUT THE FACTS" People KNOW on this forum that at the Akal Takht this issue was resolved , by hukam from SGGS ages ago, whether you read RAGMALA or not even GURU ji has answered us, IT DOESN;T MATTER and we STILL go no and on.

Re: raagmala

Guldeep Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Bhai Bijla Singh Ji. Well said. We are all the children of one Guru Pita, Guru Mata. The bikering is pointless. I was disturbed at what language administration was allowing in these posts. Imagine if Raagmala is Gurbani. Allowing posts to call Raagmala "rubbish" and ridiculing its proponents with malicious sarcasm exposed administration's bias.

Re: raagmala

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

Veer Guldeep Singh Ji, Continuing your line of reasoning.. Imagne... IF raagmaala is NOT GURBANI....and we insist on calling it GURBANI...isnt that Bad in your eyes ?? Isnt Gurbani being ridiculed by equating a poem with the DIVINE MESSAGE Dhur Ki bani Ayee jin saglee Chint Mitayee ( can you enlighhten me on what CHINT does raagmala mitah in a person ??)..and you are not afraid of committing this sin ?? No body is biased here...and yes ALL of us are biased !! get my drift ? So why point fingers.... I am sure there are a lot of forums where only those posts that say raagmala is GURBANI are allowed ( that wouldnt be "bias" by any standard ??)here at least all posts get aired. Manjit kaur

Re: raagmala

A Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Mudhavani means seal? emmmmm..... I heard it actually means riddle - and it would appear as if quite a few 'Ramraeeay' (those who disregard any portion of Gurbani) here on this forum are baffled by this riddle!

Re: raagmala

veer · 07 Jan 2005

http://www.amritsar.com/media/Slok%20Mahla%20Naunvan.wma

Re: raagmala

Mundavani · 07 Jan 2005

"Meaning of Mudavani or Mundavani: According to Mahan Kosh of Bhai Kahan Singh, page 986 both mean the act of stamping and closing ,muMdRx, bMd He explains it with a system of sealing and stamping of food by a Food Officer after preparation for presenting to kings in India. This food is then opened in the presence of the king after examining the seal or stamp. He compares this idea with Mundavani in Sri Guru Granth Sahib." If you read Mundavani yourself you see the food stamp idea fits in with the meaning of the Shabad perfectly. Bhai Mani Singh says in Bhagat Ratnavali (which is generally considered one of his unaltered/relatively reliable texts) that Mundavani does actually mean "Stamp". I hope you are not claiming Bhai Mani Singh has been baffled also :O :O :O Also A Singh I hope you read the "Rattan Mala" (a piece of kacchi bani completely disregarding by most the modern Panth) otherwise many "Praatan" Groups would call you "Ramraeeay" too! Ramraeey are those who twist Gurbani for their own selfish motives eg / Guru Har Rai's son. Not those who have unshakeable faith in a Pooran Guru, believing *everything* their Guru does is *perfect*. Would twisting the meaning of "Ramraeey" qualify you as a "Ramraeey" by your own standards also :) :) :) Fateh!!!

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 08 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Singh..I am surprised. usually you are balanced and logical..even when you oppose an idea. Coining "ramraiyeeas...for the opposing camp is out of character !!! maybe you are too involved or one sided. A little bit of research would have told you words can have multiple meanings ( BTW thats how the taksalis get 72 different meanings of gurbani words..dont they ??) A "STAMP" means, postage stamp, push with feet hard, seal of approval, kill off, rushing herd of elephants etc... Ponder this: IF Mundawni and closing Thanksgiving slok mha 5 is NOT the Closing SEAL by GURU JI....HOW are we to KNOW where GURU GRANTH actually ENDS....(you are aware that there were many other additions as well..ink recipes, shah muhamada etc etc kachhi banis which were SO OBVIOUSLY ADDITIONS that everybody UNANIMOUSLY AGREED to throw them OUT of GURU GRANTH long ago.) How can you be SURE..there are NO MORE AANGS after 1430...since GURU SEAL is NOT there ?? Could there be say 2460 AAngs ?? GURU JI just wouldnt leave the ENDING HANGING OPEN like that ?? or would HE ?? ISNT this what has happened to DASAM GRANTH ?? That was NOT compiled by GURU Ji, NOT SEALED by GURU JI...and so we have it..an OIPEN granth !!! Even Ordinary Granths books have a logical end....and IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS have SEALS to indicate END ( otherwise unscrupulous people might add some pages later on...this is why all LEGAL Documents are Numbered, signed on each page, last page is indicated on each page..GURU GRANTH was TOO IMPORTANT for GURU JI...look at how much trouble he took in the numbering, arrangement of banis, rags, mahalls bahagats, sub totals,totalks, shudh remarks etc...after taking so much precautions against TAMPERING..GURU JI would LEAVE the BACK DOOR WIDE OPEN. Perfectly reasonable dont you think so ?? to SEAL and LOCK the BACK DOOR with His personal SEAL. jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 10 Jan 2005

I agree 100% with jarnail singh jee

Re: raagmala

hmmmmm · 10 Jan 2005

HAHAHAHAHHAHAthis thread is funny what's even more funny is thta no1 has been able to Answer Bijla SInghs posts!!!

Re: raagmala

..... · 10 Jan 2005

can taksalsi clrify whether they are pro meat or not. All the ones I know are anti meat. Plus they do not follow akal thakht maryada, which 3 morning banis, shorter rehras, etc. Whether they have hindu influence is open to debate. What jots, use of coconuts, and current split due to govt interference. I do not know any taksalis who can say it is perfect and uncorrupted. Harbhajan wrote: > Raagmaala bani hai! > Raagmala is in old birs so it must be bani > I know Alam wrote it and that he wasn't a bhagat, and its part > of a love story but who says bani can't descend on someone who > isnt a bhagat? Bani can descend on anyone even a paapi. > Taksal rehit maryada is original and hasnt been corrupted by > hindu influence, like not eating meat. Sikhs can eat meat as > long as its not halal. > Taksal follows Akal Takht, and they say chatka meat is ok too. > > so vivek its Taksal who are the only jatha who are uncorrupted.

Re: raagmala

amon · 10 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh depends on whether one can successfully argue , Jarnail Singh Ji , that Ragmaala is like the end....afteral you would expect the last ang to be like an index page with raags mentioned. i agree that the raags do not refer to the Guru Sahib's Raags, as far as we are aware, but nevertheless it seems to be a good ending to me with a mention of raaags and not abt Gurbani in the strict sense. It depends on our views and how we choose to view raagmala, if u dont agree than u wont and if u do then u'll continue to do so. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: raagmala

b singh · 10 Jan 2005

bijla you cannot have studied alams poem if you say "how can a story of love have a index of raags in it?" it is crystal clear to anyone who has read it how it fits in. even if you have not read it, it is obvious from madan singhs essay. as for all your questions on how ragm alla got in, first you answer the same on rattan malla, and the numerous other kacchi banis in old birs. even the kartarpurwale bir had rattan malla in it, but this was removed when the bir was laminated. show me how rattan malla got in old saroops, because even some taxalis still think its bani today. you say the antiragmalla group are not consistent, look at the pro ragmalla group! they cant even decide who wrote it! some admit alam, some say a bhagat, some say guru arjun, i ever heard one guy say guru tegh bahadur :O. some people say it is an index of raags bas. some people say it is not about music at all and it just has spiritual meanings. some people say it has both. jokers! i will respect u if u accept everything in old birs as bani and take the stance of 100% belief whatever is in these saroops is bani. that stance i can respect. and believe me many people do have this stance. they beleive rattanmalla and whatever else too. but how can you be sooo contradictory, on one hand reject some old kacchi banis because "the panth" has said they are kacchi bani but then a big hoo-haa when people want ragmalla out too! your taking the biscuit mate!! NOTE: read mundavani by giani gurdit singh. it has plenty of photos of old birs and more study on alams poem.

Re: raagmala

Harpartap Singh · 10 Jan 2005

VahegurujikaKhalsa, Vahegurujiki Fateh! Following the logical line of reasoning that if the Mundavani and the following slok together are the seal, would not Guru Sahib have numbered them consecutively i.e. 1 and 2? All the contents of a granth/book is usually evident in the contents page or Tatkara so it is immediately apparent where the end of the book is...

Re: raagmala

Bijla Singh · 10 Jan 2005

b singh ji, kartarpuri bir sahib does not have ratan mala or any other kachi bani. only raag maala. but even if i assume that this bir sahib did have all these kachi banis that were removed afterwards (pages were ripped off or some other way??you explain) except raag maala, even then my question remains unanswered. how did all those kachi banis get added? I am simply asking questions not trying to prove raag maala is bani. and singh ji, I did study the poem but I could not see the relationship because this fool doesn't have very bright thinking like yourself. so please explain this in full details. original poem was written in sanskrit in 991 hijri which does not include raag maala. funny, how not a single anti-raag maala book mentions this. alam is considered a muslim (Shamsher Singh’s book) but his mangals are praising ganesha, a hindu lord. not a very consistent theory. i do not want to go into this, whether i am wrong or right, just please explain what raag maala has to do with this love story because none of the other love stories have raag maala. alam was a poet not a musician so how could he write raag maala? I do not care which taksalis believe in what. not all pro-raag maala people are taksalis. most jathebandis are pro-raag maala but not taksalis. and singh ji please show some respect to Guru Ji. it is Guru Arjan Dev Ji not "guru arjan". kindly provide names of scholars who think some bhagat wrote it and what is name of this bhagat? and who says Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji wrote it? this is false because Ninth Nanak Ji didn't even write His own Bani. no pro-raag maala scholar says raag maala was first written by alam unless you can provide name of the book and author. I have read so many different stories about alam from anti raag maala books that are totally nonsense. and purpose of raag maala (spiritual meanings or whatever) is a different issue I do not want to get into. I do not require your respect but as a Sikh I do respect you and your beliefs. I do not need to know who believes in what and I know all about these "meetings" at Akal Takhat Sahib. also, I did not write which is a kachi bani and which is not. not my single post says Raag Maala is Gurbani. again, I am not trying prove it is bani, just simply asking questions to gain some knowledge. if you know the answers then please provide 'em, otherwise stop attacking. you failed to provide names of the scholars, books, page numbers, year etc. just generalizing "all pro-raag maala people" doesn't cut it. provide details. my request to you. harpartap's last argument is pretty strong. Please answer that. if Mundavani book is correct then Gurdit Singh Ji should go to Patna Sahib and show them which birs do not have raag maala. Please do not try to give me any reasoning on mundavani, numbering system, siri or bhairo raag, etc. to prove raag maala is not bani. Just simple answers to my questions directly would be very helpful. Thank you very much. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 10 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. Harpartap singh ji, 1. The Mundawni also occurs inside Guur Granth Sahib Jee ( Sorath Ki Vaar AAng 645) but its written by Guur Amardass Ji, and its Title is NOT Mundawnai..But Slok Mh 3. And there is a slight difference in words althought the overall emaning of the shabad is same. 2. GURU Arjun Ji however Wrote the TITLE of this Shabad as MUNDAWNI MH 5....and its numbering system goes with the other SHABADS as usually followed in Gurbani. 3. The Slok Mh 5 that follows is ALONE and its numbering is accordingly {1} also as per Gurbani rules followed through out the Guru Granth Ji. 4. Now look at the NUMBERING in Raagmala.... the numeral {1} is used through out which is not only ridiculous even as per ordinary poetic traditions..but totaly against the numbering syytem so sytematically used in the entire Guru Granth ji. The SAME POEM in Alam's Book has the CORRECT NUMBERS !!! evidence of a copy cat trying to change "something" so that he can escape the charge of hoobhoo copy (100% copy)/or mistake/ehatever..the end result is the numberign is not consistent with the rest of gurbani. 5. The Contents/tatkara Page is NOT LOCKED....any one can add as amany titles as he pleases or delete a few..deleting is difficult..adding is definitley a piece of cake...even anovice can do. Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

hmmm · 11 Jan 2005

this is false because Ninth Nanak Ji didn't even write His own Bani. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>><<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< what do you mean Salok Mahala nauva isn't bani :S

Re: raagmala

Thousand Knives · 11 Jan 2005

Fateh Bijla Akbar himself was married to a Rajput Hindu, he encouraged marriage between Hindu Rajput and Mughal aristocracy. I think he would only ever drink water from the Ganges. His tastes in art were far more Hindu (read - indigenous Indian) rather than Persian. Thus large amounts of Hindu imagery in Madhav Nal KamKandla is not suprising. You should read Ain-i-Akbari - it details everything about court life - down to the food he ate. However, I am already sure you have done this, since you are so well read on the subject. If you do not understand how Ragmalla fits in with the story read Madan Singhs book he describes it very briefly. If you haven't read this then you haven't even begun to research Ragmalla. People have theories as to how Rag Malla got into Bani but the same theories apply to Rattan Malla, Kuchi Bani in the Banno Wale Bir, etc. Any scholar knows there was plenty of Bani being circulated as Guru's own in those days. You know this. How it actually got into Birs is difficult to explain - but people don't seem to have any problem removing Rattan Malla from old Birs. And Yes B Singh is correct Kartarpuri Bir did used to have much Kuchi Bani. If you knew alot about old Saroops you would have know this yourself. KulbirSinghJi just recently told us of a Saroop that has had Ragmalla with other Kuchi Bani added at the back clearly it was not in Tatkara. Bijla I Am beginning to wonder how knowledgable you are on this subject after all.

Re: raagmala

Bijla Singh · 12 Jan 2005

I have seen many old saroops with only raag maala. some have signatures of Guru Sahib and some don't. but I don't want to go into full details of all those saroops. and please try to do some study on kartarpuri bir sahib. it was studied, ink was checked and even report was published (book:Raag Maala bani hai). this happened during bhai kahan singh nabha who had no replies afterwards and even published his reports that contradicted with each other (Kartarpuri Bir De Darshan by Prof. Jodh Singh). Bir Sahib of Bhai Banno Ji includes Raag Maala although an extra Shabad of Bhai Surdaas, one Shabad of Miran Bai and other stuff like Ratan Mala, Hakkikat Rah Mukaam etc. was added into it afterwards. It also has signature of Guru HarGobind Sahib Ji but right after raag maala and before the two extra Shabads start. kartarpuri bir sahib had no kachi bani. if it did then please tell me how these kachi banis were removed? they simply ripped off pages or what? i have never read this in any book. so please provide a source that goes into some details. I don't know what Akhbar has to do with raag maala but if you are implying that alam was his poet then I will have to disagree. in his "book of law" akhbar mentions all the names of his pirs, wazirs, musicians, scholars but "alam" does not appear anywhere. just because akhbar was married to a hindu woman doesn't mean he was very much influenced by hinduism. even if he was it still doesn't mean that all his poets, musicians etc. were influenced the same way. the worst thing a muslim could do at that time was to go in favor of kafirs and their beliefs. all muslim writers used to write in Persian and arabic not in sanskrit. and a muslim writer praising some hindu lord in his writing is just impossible to believe. one scholar says alam wrote it 91 years before Kartarpuri Bir Sahib was compiled and someone else says alam wrote it 21 years before Kartarpuri Bir Sahib was compiled. anti-raag maala people are not even too sure about alam and his work. There was only one poet Bhai Alam in Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Darbar who wrote the story of Kaam Kandlan (not original one). Alam was one of the poets in Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Darbar who copied Guru Ji's Raag Maala. He wrote his Raag Maala in 1717 which is 1774 Bikarmi. This Raag Maala is very different than the one in Guru Granth Sahib Ji (Guru Granth Sahib Kosh shows both raag maalas along with couple more). Guru Gobind Singh Ji had 52 poets in his darbar and their names are: 1) Udeyar 2) Anirai 3) Amritrai 4) Allu 5) Aaasa Singh 6) Alam 7) Iswardas 8) Sukhdev 9) Sukha SIngh 10) Sukhia 11) Sudama 12) Senapat 13) Sheyam 14) Heer 15) Hussain Ali 16) Hansraam 17) Kallu 18) Kuvraysh 19) Khan Chand 20) Guniya 21) Gurdas 22) Gopal 23) Chandan 24) Chanda 25) Jamal 26) Tehkan 27) Dharam Singh 28) Dhanna Singh 29) Dhayan Singh 30) Nannu 31) Nishchal Das 32) Nihal Chand 33) Nand Singh 34) Nand Lal (Gurbakash Singh) 35) Pindi Das 36) Ballab 37) Ballu 38) Bidhi Chand 39) Bulland 40) Brikh 41) Bridge Lal 42) Mathura 43) Maddan Singh 44) Maddan Gir 45) Mallu 46) Maan Das 47) Malla Singh 48) Mangal 49) Raam 50) Rawal 51) Roshan Singh 52) Lakha Alam's work is very similar to some of the charittars and other banis in Dasam Granth but not a single scholar says that is also work of alam. I have read his poem and his raag maala and do understand it but you guys have failed to answer the questions. Instead you are just giving me names of some books without even giving me some info on it. have you read them? if you are so confident about mundavani and madan singh's book then why not give me the answer they wrote in their books. maybe its because you haven't read anything yourself and just pointing me to some books. alam's work is copy of Guru Ji's work and many other poets like Tehkan Singh. read them both and see it yourself. alam's work makes much less sense. how raag maala got into the saroops is not difficult but impossible for you guys to explain. gursikh in those days knew exactly what was bani and what wasn’t. each jatha kept a saroop. they simply wouldn't have let anyone add anything to it. they lived in forests and they lived hard lives. not a single spy from hindus or muslims could live with singhs. saroops weren't available everywhere. even Punj Granthi used to cost 500 coins. you can read Satwant Kaur by Bhai Veer Singh Ji to find out more. sikhs were willing to pay any cost to someone to write Punj Granthi and Satwant Kaur Ji wrote one for free from memory. this was their avastha. if punj granthi and other pothis were hard to find then how do you expect me to believe some spy or foolish person got hold of Guru Ji's saroop and added some stuff to it? and how it appeared into many other saroops in those days is just a mystery for anti-raag maala scholars. according to anti-raag maala scholars (ashok, sher singh etc.) it was work of some naive sikh who just wanted to memorize raags and wrote it down on the last ang of the saroop because he didn't have any blank piece of paper. what a nonsense. gursikhs in those day were so chardee kala. not a single sikh would think of writing anything in Guru Ji's saroop just because he can't find a scratch paper. and please don't wonder about my knowledge. i learn from educated people like you and many others. i have no knowledge. and why hasn't kulbir singh provided us with history of this saroop in details? no pictures, no history, who wrote it, when?? a saroop in Bhai Buddhu Shah's family and saroops written by Baba Deep Singh Ji (seen ‘em myself) would also be a good way to study this matter. hmm ji, Ninth Nanak Ji's bani was added by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. what I meant to say was, He did not keep any book of His Bani like Guru Nanak Dev Ji. after some 47 posts, no one could provide some good answers. Just same 100 years old arguments found in old books. all we know how to do is to attack each other and write some fairy tales. I do not expect anyone to answer my questions now. Don’t beat around the bush and give some names of the books without any detailed information. This is not a competition. If it is then you win. Raag maala isn’t bani. Happy now? This is over for me. You all have fun. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

Navjot Singh · 12 Jan 2005

WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh ! Gurmukh Bijla Singh wrote : [i] ---------------------------------------------------------- just because akhbar was married to a hindu woman doesn't mean he was very much influenced by hinduism. even if he was it still doesn't mean that all his poets, musicians etc. were influenced the same way. the worst thing a muslim could do at that time was to go in favor of kafirs and their beliefs. all muslim writers used to write in Persian and arabic not in sanskrit. and a muslim writer praising some hindu lord in his writing is just impossible to believe. ---------------------------------------------------------- [/i] Bhai Sahib, just because you believe something is impossible does not make it so. Anyone who has read a bit about Akbar knows that one of his most trusted ministers was the wise Birbal, a Brahmin. You might find it impossible to beleive but he even allowed Hindu Puja inside his palace. Below are a couple of sources stating Akbar’s interest in Hindu culture and literature. It is even said that Akbar had Hindu literature translated. How can one truly translate Hindu literature without mentioning their devis and devtas ? [u]http://www.pbs.org/treasuresoftheworld/taj_mahal/tlevel_2/t1mughal_2akbar.html[/u] Quote : [b]...he was the first Muslim ruler to win the trust and loyalty of his Hindu subjects. He had Hindu literature translated, participated in Hindu festivals, and realizing that a stable empire depended on strong alliances with the Rajputs, fierce Hindu warriors, he married a Rajput princess. [/b] [u]http://www.kamat.com/kalranga/mogul/akbar.htm[/u] Quote : [b]This was the most notable in a series of measures to recruit the Hindu majority and others to the cause of unifying and expanding his empire. He defeated an impregnable Hindu fortress in Rajasthan and went on to marry the Rajput princess Padmini, who was permitted to conduct Hindu rites in the harem.[/b] The Nine gems of Akbar. [u]http://www.boloji.com/history/022.htm[/u] Read in particular about Mian Tansen, his court musician & Birbal, the Brahmin minister. [i] ---------------------------------------------------------- one scholar says alam wrote it 91 years before Kartarpuri Bir Sahib was compiled and someone else says alam wrote it 21 years before Kartarpuri Bir Sahib was compiled. anti-raag maala people are not even too sure about alam and his work. ---------------------------------------------------------- [/i] I believe Shamsher Singh Ashok, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, Bhai Mandan Singh, and Bhai Gurdit Singh are consistent about who Alam was and when he wrote RaagMala. The same can not be said about the pro-Raagmala people’s explanation about the origins of Raagmala. Who was the author, when was it written? Guru Nanak Dev Ji ? Bhai Gurdas Ji ? Guru Arjan Dev Ji, Guru Gobind Singh Jee ? Different people have had different explanations. No surprise here. [i] ---------------------------------------------------------- There was only one poet Bhai Alam in Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Darbar who wrote the story of Kaam Kandlan (not original one). ---------------------------------------------------------- [/i] Bijla Singh Jee, can you please provide some hard evidence that proves that there was ONLY ONE Alam ? [i] ---------------------------------------------------------- not a single sikh would think of writing anything in Guru Ji's saroop just because he can't find a scratch paper. ---------------------------------------------------------- [/i] Quite the opposite, it has happened in the past and it occurs even now. Yes there are saroops with lots of extra text and kachee Bani added to them. Anything from “Siaahee di Vidhee” to believe it or not : paintings and sketches of Hindu dieties. Even today, some of our Gutkays contain so much Kachee Banee that in about 100 years from now everyone will be saying “oh the Puratan Singhs used to read this and since it is part of this Gutka it must be GurBanee. I have a Gutka in my possession called “Sabh ton Vadha Beant Banniaa da Sundar Gutka” published by Chattar Singh Jiwan Singh (CSJS), and it is supposedly proofread by Giani Mohan Singh Ji (Orlana) who was the Head Granthi of Gurduara Manji Sahib in 1992. He states that this Gutka’s sudhai was done in accordance to the Santhyia attained at DamiDami Taksal (Mehta Chauk). One first things I noted was that Chandi-di-Vaar was ”Ashudh” (wrong) in this Gutka. So much for the sudhai of Mohan Singh Orlana. Anyways, this Gutka first contains advertisements of CSJS’s other publications, and many questionable “Bannees” right in the middle of actual Gurbanee, including : Naseehat Nama : under the misleading heading of Tilang Mahal Pehla Hajar Nama : under the misleading heading of Tilang Mahal Pehla Karni Nama : from Sau Sakhee Deohra and Chaupais from Gurpartap Suraj Ratan Mala : under the misleading heading of Rag Ramkali Mahala 1 Pentees Akharee Katha Tayeeay Tap di : Sakhi Bhai Lalo Ji, etc. This is going on now! There are hundreds and thousands copies of these Gutkays available. If “Sikhs” are doing this now, what makes you think it could not have been done with saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Gurbani Pothis in the hands of Dhirmaliays, Nirmalas, Udasees, Masands, and Mahants ? [i] ---------------------------------------------------------- saroops written by Baba Deep Singh Ji (seen ‘em myself) would also be a good way to study this matter. ---------------------------------------------------------- [/i] Bijla Singh, even Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji has mentioned that there are scores of differences in the Aad versions and the Damdami versions of the Birs of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, this includes the much debated Kartarpur valee Bir. Moreover, there are further differences among the Damdami versions also. That is why scholars such as Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara and Bhai Joginder Singh Vendantee spent a good part of their lifetimes researching old saroops so we as a Panth can reach a consensus for printing ONE UNIQUE SHUDH version of Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s saroop. If we have the original saroops as you state, then Talwara Ji's last 30 years of research was nothing more than a meaningless exercise. Why would have Talwara Ji spent three decades researching, when the real Damdami Saroops written by Baba Deep Singh Ji were readily available to people such as you? Wow ! Would you care to reveal a bit more information about the whereabouts of those original saroops, and why they have not been used as templates for printing of all modern Saroops nowadays? - Navjot Singh

Re: raagmala

Halo Singh · 13 Jan 2005

Literature Ragmala is Gurbani When reciting Gurbani it is very hurtful to our Guru if we make what we may call a minor mistake by mispronouncing a lagaa maatar (Gurmukhi vowel), knowing this then how can we totally disregard an ang of Guru Sahib. Guru Jee tells us: “Jin Bhae Adab Na Bani Dhaaraa | Jaanhu So Sikh Nahee Hamaaraa ||20||” “One who has no fear and respect of Gurbani, know him/her to not be a Sikh of mine.” We must all question ourselves to see if we really have fear for our Guru, who is manifested in Gurbani – can we call ourselves a Sikh of the Guru in this light? The Bani contained in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jeee is the truth as Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee tells us in Mool Mantar, it was true at the start of the ages, true throughout the ages and will be true forever more. “Sat(i)gur Kee Bani Sat(i) Sat(i) Kar(i) Jaanhu Gursikhu, Har(i) Kartaa Aap(i) Muhhu Kadd(h)aaea|| (Gauree Kee Vaar Mahalla 4, Ang 304) “Recognise the Bani of Satguru as the Truth, Oh Gurskihs – Lord the Creator has uttered it himself.” We as Sikhs should therefore recognise Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as the living embodiment of the 10 Guru’s and respect each and every letter of the 1430 angs from Ik Oa(n)kaar to At(h)aarah Das Bees. The following is a point-by-point reply to an article “Ragmala The Undeniable Facts” (RTUF’s from now on) that has been distributed, which questions the authenticity of God’s Gurbani – Ragmala. “In reply to those who evangelize venomously that those who do not read Ragmala are not Sikhs. Even though it clearly states in the Sikh Code of Conduct that a Sikh can chose to read Ragmala or not read it according to their preference.” (RTUF) The so called Sikh Code of Conduct (being referred to above) was originally published in the early 20th century after the leading Gursikhs of the time came together to try and agree a standard code of conduct. Many of these Gursikhs left the original meeting as it was obvious that some unscrupulous individuals would want to include things within this code that were obviously against Gurbani. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh Jee and Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale are just two of these Sikhs that didn’t agree and that didn’t actually sign to the final draft of the Code (which coincidentally took many years of deliberation to form and proof of who actually agreed the final version has never been provided those who published the document). Some of the points included in this Code are: · Consumption of meat and alcohol are not cardinal sins · Sikhs need only read 3 Banis (namely Japji Sahib, Jaap Sahib, Tva Parsad Svaye) in their morning recital · Sikhs need only read shortened versions of certain Banis If a Sikh is to use this Code as an arguing point then they should be prepared to abide by it, in its entirerity, not just picking and choosing what they feel is correct, for example this Code clearly states that Kes is a Kakkar and not Keski and in praise of the Code it must be stated that it also says that a Sikh should recite one Sehaj Paath (whole of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee) monthly or the equivalent. If one is to use this code as a basis for arguing then they must be willing to abide by the stated previous points and practise what they preach. As shown this Code has many discrepancies and if Sikhs abided it they would actually be violating the eternal edicts of Gurbani. “(1) Ragamala being the heading does not indicate which of our Great Gurus wrote Ragmala, and since there is no mention of the word Nanak in the writing, it is comprehensible that our Great Gurus had no hand in writing Ragmala.” (RTUF) Ragmala has something in common with the most frequently read Bani around the world by Sikhs and non Sikhs alike, Jap(u) Jee Sahib. Both do not indicate which of our Gurus wrote them, in fact ‘Nanak’ doesn’t appear in 7 paurees (verses) of Jap(u) Jee Sahib and ‘Nanak’ doesn’t appear in several other Shabads in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Arguing that Ragmala is not Gurbani due to the lack of the word ‘Nanak’ appearing in it is thus a fallacy and miscomprehension. “(2) The order in which various rags are mentioned in Ragamala do not correspond to the order in which the same rag appears in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The first rag in Sri Guru Granth Sahib is ‘Sri Rag’ while in Ragmala it is ‘Bhairo.” The order of rags that appear in Ragmala are irrelevant to the writing of it, as it is not an index of the rags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Ragmala and Gurbani in general have deeper mystical meanings, if we don’t understand or can’t comprehend these deeper hidden jewels, that does not mean we should simply disregard Gurbani we don’t understand. “(3) The following rags which are contained in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee do not emerge in Ragmala, i.e. rags Maajh, Bihagra, Jaitsri, Ramkali, Mali Gaura, Tukhari, Prabhati and Jaijavanti. Therefore the assertion that Ragmala is a mala (rosary) of the rags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is not true.” Nobody argued that Ragmala is a mere rosary of the rags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, Guru Jee decided what rags to include in Ragmala and it is not for us to doubt/question this decision. In Gurbani the word rag also means prem (love), so Ragmala is also a rosary of love it is not merely a rosary of rags (this is in reference to the deeper mystical meanings of Ragmala mentioned above). “(4) In Ragmala the counting system of phrases is totally different to the system used in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, i.e. in Ragmala ||1|| or No. 1 appears after each phrase and the end of Ragmala. In Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee the totalling system is 1,2,3,4,5,6, etc and this can be clearly seen in the first hymn in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, i.e. in Jap(u) Jee Sahib the first pauree has 1 and the last has 38.” This statement is incorrect as Jap(u) Jee Sahib actually has two ‘1’s’ at the start and a ‘1’ at the end after the Salok. The 1,2,3,4,5,6, etc numbering system is present in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee but is not consistent throughout. Just as in Jap(u) Jee Sahib there are other verses of Gurbani that have the No. 1 after paurees that follow each other – do we then also discount these as Gurbani, as they are not adhering to this stringent numerical system. “(5) Mudavani the word means the seal of closure therefore anything after Salok Mahalla 5 really cannot be accepted as Gurbani and since Ragamala is after Salok Mahalla 5 it cannot be sanctioned as part of Gurbani.” If Mudavani is the seal of closure then technically we cannot accept Salok Mahalla 5, as this is a separate Shabad which comes after Mudhavani Mahalla 5. In fact the word Mudavani is present on two other occasions in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, on Ang 645 within the same Shabad in Vaar of Sorat(h). So if we follow this line of argument anything after this Shabad is not Gurbani – how ludicrous is that! The meaning of Mudavani is not ‘seal of closure’ but on the contrary it means ‘riddle,’ a riddle that Guru Jee is stating in this Shabad. Guru Jee states in Mundavni, Thaal Vich In this platter there are three things – they are truth, discussion and discourse of the Shabad. In the next line Guru Jee states that Amrit Naam has been placed, Amrit Naam … The riddle is understanding the true meaning of these lines, which is that in the platter of Sri Guru Granth Sahib the Amrit Naam of Shabad has been placed by contemplating and studying this Shabad one attains truth and contentment. “(6) In some hand written versions of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee the following works appear: · Salok Mahalla 1 Jit Dhar Lakh muha(n)madha… · Salok Mahalla 1 Bia aatas aab · Rag Ramkali Ratan Male · Hakikat Rah Mukam Raja Sivnat Ki In all the handwritten Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jees Ragmala appears at the end of all other works. Since it is acceptable that the works are not Gurbani, how is it that pro Ragmala accept Ragmala as Gurbani and that the other works are not Gurbani even though they come before Ragmala this seems a very illogical attitude on their part. “ In 1945 the SGPC set up a sub-committee to investigate whether Ragmala is included in the original Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Saroop that was compiled by Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee. The following is from their: “We can most definitely say that nobody other than Bhai Gurdas Jee, who was the scribe, included Ragmala in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Ragmala is an ang of Sri Guru Granth Sahib.” They also stated that they the ink, paper and handwriting of Ragmala was consistent with the rest of the saroop. When this first saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee was compiled many had made supplications to Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee to include their writings but Guru Jee rejected many, only those who had merged with God could utter Gurbani, as it is the word of God Himself. The final Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee as we know it today was compiled by Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee, and Baba Deep Singh Jee compiled 4 other Saroops of this final version and they were sent to all Five Takhats. All these Saroops have Ragmala in them, again it is written in the same handwriting, ink and upon the same paper. The above mentioned works are not present in any of these Saroops and they unanimously accepted not as the writings of the Guru and only few Saroops have these works in them. “(7) Ragmala which comes after Mudavni in the printed versions of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, was not written by Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee. It is part of a book called Mudhavnal Kamkandla written by poet Alam in 1640 Bikramee (1583 AD), 21 years before Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee was compiled by Sri Guru Arjan Dev Jee.” This point is a fallacy, it was a poet named Jodh who wrote Madhvanal Kamkandla in 1583 AD - Ragmala or anything even resembling it, is not present in the original version of this book. The poet Alam lived from 1655 to 1717 AD and after listening to/reading Ragmala, he wrote a book called Madhvanal Sangeet that was mostly copied work from other poets including Jodh. There is also a poem in this compilation which doubters of Ragmala believe is Ragmala, but it is actually very different to Ragmala. In the past century people have mistakenly linked the work of these poets’ as one and the same, because Alam plagerised much of his work from Jodh, and they try to prove that Ragmala is not Gurbani with this mistaken line of argument. Historically there are 11 different versions of Ragmala they all differ from the original which is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, different writers over time have gained inspiration from Ragmal in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and then gone on to write their own versions of Ragmala. In Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee there are 2 different versions of Barah Maha, one in Raag Maaj and the other in Raag Tukaree. There are also many versions of Barah Maha written by various authors, should we then argue that these two Barah Maha’s are not Gurbani? “(8) Ragmala Bhagats preach that whatever is contained in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee should be read. Then why don’t they read the 11 pages containing the index to the contents of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, or the publishers name on the first page or the seal of certification? Why the hypocracy?” Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not a book and it is blasphemous to suggest so, it is God’s word and should be respected as such. This line of argument is obviously of one who does not view Sri Guru Granth Sahib with reverence and it may be pointed out that such people also argue that you don’t have to do Bhog to food in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee or even doing Bhog is a mere ritual. The faithful offer food to Guru Jee to bless, and Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the living embodiment of the 10 Guru’s, thus it is logical to offer food in the presence of the Guru. “(9) The following great Sikh and non Sikh scholars believed that Ragmala is not Gurbani: · Great Poet Bhai Santokh Singh · Pandit Tara Singh Nakoola · Giani Dit Singh · Professor Gurmukh Singh · Giani Gian Singh · Sadhu Gobind Singh Nirmala · Pandit Basant Singh · ...” It would be very easy to make a list of Gursikhs who were held in high regard that believed Ragmala is Gurbani. The list would include great scholars, freedom fighters, spiritualists and selfless servants of the Khalsa Panth. The other point to note is that Sikhs throughout the world read Ragmala and it only a minority who question or doubt it’s authenticity, there are only a few Gurdwaras throughout the world where Ragmala is not recited and it is recited at Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib and Sri Harimander Sahib (Golden Temple). Giani Sobha Singh who lived at Takhar Dyal Singh’s Dharamsala in Amritsar, was one of the first Sikhs to start the debate over the authenticity of Ragmala over a 100 years ago. He even compiled a Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee without Ragmala in it and he took it to Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib for approval. The senior Sikhs of the day decided to offer an Ardas to Guru Jee, in this Ardas they said, ‘If Bhai Sobha Singh has done right then nothing should happen, but if he has done wrong then punish him accordingly.’ After just a week he became ill and his mouth was full of ulcers and he was in much pain, to the extent that he could not even speak. He wrote a letter begging for forgiveness and brought it to Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib and he said that no-one should ever make the same mistake again. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Jee has told us of the greatness of reading Ragmala in his work Gur Bilaas: Bhog Paavhu …. Ragmala is read at the end of a complete recital of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, by doing this all your sins are eradicated. Ragmala Parr … By reading Ragmala the recital is complete, without it’s recitation it is incomplete. We can only pray that Guru Jee brings the people who don’t believe in Ragmala to their senses, in this life as who knows what they will have to endure if they die doubting the authenticity of Ragmala. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

??? · 13 Jan 2005

As per veer Navjot Singh's post I have also read from scholars that the Kartaarpur Vali Bir has been "messed with" by the Dheermalias when they had it re-bound. I can't rememberthe exact reference where I read it. But he felt that this was trickery on the part of the Dheermal family just to keep people in the dark about exactly what they have.

Re: raagmala

Harpartap Singh · 13 Jan 2005

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! The vast majority of the Panth has a consensus that Sri Guru Granth Sahib is as per the Damdami bir and thus all printed versions are based on the 4 copies made of it by Baba Deep Singh ji Shaheed...

Re: raagmala

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 13 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. IF ALL Sroops are based on ONLY the 4 birs copied by Baba deep Singh Ji then why are there numerous differences between the thousands of printed copies..are these 4 "original" birs signed by baba Ji and where are they kept. In that case the Ragmala question couldnt have arisen at all. It is an established fact that Raagmala WAS NOT READ at AKAL TAKHAT until Bhai jasbir Singh Rode became a "short term" jathedar and forced this damdami taksaal maryada on Akal Takhat. It should be noted that even Baba Jarnail Singh ji did not commit this grave error even though He gave his life for the Akal takhat. The Numeral {1} at the end of GURPARSAAD in japji Sahib indicates the Mool mantar. Therefore the Next Number {1} indicates the SLOK. It are the raagmala supporters who intentionally IGNORE this NUmeral {1} and insist the Moolmantar is ONE with the SLOK. No other Bani goes on REPEATING numeral {1} line after line line after line from beginning to end as in Raagmala. It is NOT the listing of Raags as First or second..It are the Words of GURU JI..Raagaan wich SRI RAAG HAI..which indicate how Guru Ji regards Sri raag as SUPREME and begins Guru Granth Ji with this Raag....unlike the author of raagmala who insists it is Bhairo that is PRITHAM..the Two statements are self contradictory. The Japji was so well known during GURU JI's time that it was recited by many many Sikhs..in fact Bhai lehan Ji came to look for Guru nanak ji after having heard this bani being recited.... so it is pointless to argue that since this bani doestn contain NANAK in it it cannot be bani of Guru Ji.. NO such thing can be said about raagmala. The Slok in Vaa r srath just has the word mundawni in it...and it is riddle..BUT the SHABAD at the conclusion of Guru Ji is TITLED MUNDAWNI MH 5...this is not the same thing. The Particular SHABAD is sepecially written as a SEAL and here mundawnai is clearly SEAL..on the Spiritual Food of Gurubani..tested and passed by guru Ji. Surprising that the list of Prominent ANTI-Raagmala GURSIKHS EXCLUDES Bhai sahib bhai Randhir Singh Ji... And the list of PRO Raagmala is just a vague statement of freedom fighters etc etc... IS there any other "GURBANI" from the Guru Garanth ji copied by some poet like Alam/ or whatever and INSERTED into his poems etc...or is it ONLY RAAGMALA ?? Why werent other Gurbanis copied by other poets ?? The Truth is Raagmal is COPIED INTO the Guru Garnth and not the other way around. Convinved more by navjot Singh arguments Jarnail Singh

Re: raagmala

Bijla Singh · 14 Jan 2005

I thought this was over but surprisingly no. Well, hopefully I can learn something from educated Gursikhs like you. 1) I agree with you on akbar but according to your sources he only did it to expand his empire and to stabilize it. It does not mean he was influenced by Hinduism. I do not see akbar’s relevance to this subject. I do not question that he had many scholars translate hindu texts but I do question Alam translating Madhavnal kaamkandlan. No anti-raag maala scholar believes that Alam translated it. There have been many people named Alam. One Alam is even mentioned in Bhai Gurdas Ji’s vaars who lived in Lahore area. Ashok talks about two Alams. One was student of Mohammad Gosh Kutab Kadri (Gurmat Sudhakar) and other one poet of Guru Ji’s darbar. (Raag Maala Nirnnay, 7). Shiv Singh Seroj also says Alam was one of the poet in Guru darbar. If this is not so then please tell me which poet replaces Alam? According to what book? If Alam was poet of Akbar then why is his name not mentioned in Ainay-Akbari? I have a list of Akbar’s poets but Alam does not appear anywhere. According to Shamsher Singh Ashok the original story in Sanskrit did not include Raag Maala. Alam had heard the original story in Sanskrit and he had also heard some raag maala in Sanskrit. Later on he wrote the story on his own and added raag maala to it (Raag Maala Nirnnay, 20). This proves that Raag Maala has nothing to do with love story because it does not mention a single thing about madhawnal, kaamkandlan, or any of the kings. Also, kaamkandlan singing all raags at the same time is considered impossible in all hindu and muslim music schools. It also implies that Alam was so stupid to mix up raag maala with a love story. He himself admits that he copies other people’s work. What exactly did he learn from his teacher then? Translating is a different thing. But according to anti-raag maala scholars Alam wrote the story and then added Raag Maala in his own words. His teacher was a muslim. Muslims only wrote in Persian and Arabic not in Brij. Thus he simply could not have written in Brij and praised hindu lords. His mangals are praising ganesha and last lines of his raag maala are also praising ganesha. If raag maala in Guru Ji’s saroop was in fact work of Alam then how come last lines that praise ganesha are missing? Alam’s raag maala includes “Dohras”, “Sorathas”, and “Chaupais” which do not appear anywhere in any saroop’s Raag Maala. Ashok Ji says some naïve Sikh could not find a scratch paper and unintentionally wrote it on the last Ang of Guru Ji’s saroop. If I assume this is true then why did he not copy exactly the same raag maala? There existed many different raag maalas but how did he find this particular one from a love story? Alam was in fact poet of Guru darbar who copied raag maala and other banis. For example, some of the alam’s work is copy of charittars found in Dasam Granth. Whether or not it is bani is not the issue here but why have the scholars except Piara Singh Padam been quite about this? In “Raag Maala Baray Vichaar” Piara Singh says charittars 91 are work of Alam and were later inserted but in “Dasam Granth Darshan” page 121 to 132, he does not mention such thing and says all of Dasam Granth is Bani and provides some hard evidence. Then why is it not possible that he copied Raag Maala from Guru Ji? some of the raags in his raag maala are fake and do not exist in any music school. 2) “I believe Shamsher Singh Ashok, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, Bhai Mandan Singh, and Bhai Gurdit Singh are consistent about who Alam was and when he wrote RaagMala.” Bhai Kahan Singh Ji says 1641 Bikarmi and Ashok Ji says 1640 Bikarmi. Madan Singh just repeated the same work found in Ashok Ji’s book, same quotes of Dr. Moujamdar and Dr. Heera Laal. Bhai kahan Singh Ji says Raag Maala is from 63 to 72 but Ashok Ji says it is from 33 to 38. I do not know which scholar says Guru Nanak Dev Ji is the real author of Raag Maala? Please provide name and source. If you are pointing toward Bhai Veer Singh Ji then which book? In Guru Granth Sahib Kosh, this is not mentioned. 3) “If “Sikhs” are doing this now, what makes you think it could not have been done with saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Gurbani Pothis in the hands of Dhirmaliays, Nirmalas, Udasees, Masands, and Mahants ?” please tell me which one of these groups added raag maala the first time? Any proof? According to the theory raag maala was added when Khalsa Panth stayed in forests which means we can assume up to the year of 1765 (unless you can tell me which year did this happen) because by then Punjab and Lahore was under Sikh rule. First of all, there is a big difference between Sikhs of today and 18th century. Khalsa Panth was divided in jathas. Each jatha kept a saroop. According to Ashok Ji’s theory, we will have to assume that Khalsa Panth had no saroop of Guru Ji because ashok ji says Khalsa Panth was too busy in fighting. But Gursikhs fought mughals with power of Gurbani. They weren’t just “busy” in fighting. They had many banis memorized and very well knew Bani. It is foolish to believe that Khalsa Panth only stayed in jungles without any knowledge of what was going on in Gurdwaras. Some Sikhs always stayed in cities. How else was Bhai Taru Singh Ji and Bhai Shabegh Singh Ji Shabaz Singh Ji were captured? Bhai Mani Singh Ji was in Amritsar city because he was granthi of Darbar Sahib. Bhai Mani Singh Ji became Shaheed in 1738. so if raag maala was added before that he would’ve sent letters to Sikh jathas. After his death there were still many Gursikhs in the cities like Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai taru Singh Ji, Nawab Kapoor Singh Ji etc. these Gursikhs did not stay together. They lived far from each other. Baba Deep Singh Ji and Nawab Kapoor Singh Ji’s jatha had saroops so surely there wasn’t just one saroop kept by someone. Nawab Sahib Ji passed away in 1757 and by 1765 Punjab was under control of several Sikh jathas. So when did this incident of adding raag maala happen? It could not have happened after Sikhs had control of Punjab. Furthermore, Sarbat Khalsa was called many times to discuss what was going on in the Panth and future plans were made. Therefore, Sikhs were always around and they would’ve found out if anyone had inserted Raag Maala afterwards. Even if I assume someone added raag maala to one saroop then what about the other saroops that each jatha kept with them? If there was only one copy then how did this unknown person get it and why is the name of this famous Sikh, who had the only copy of Guru Granth Sahib that existed at the time, is unknown? If there were more copies then why did Sikhs make copies of that particular Guru Granth Sahib? Saroops of Mangat, Damdama and Bohat Tehseel still have raag maala and no other kachi banis. 3) “even Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji has mentioned that there are scores of differences in the Aad versions and the Damdami versions of the Birs of Guru Granth Sahib Ji” sure there is difference. Some birs have “Patshahi 10” before the dohra and saroop at Takhat Hazoor Sahib has raag maala with pauris numbered 1..6. I do have a book that shows many of the word differences between these saroops but the issue here is whether raag maala exists in these saroops or not. I am not ignoring Talwara Ji’s research. But other Gursikhs like GB Singh and Tehal Singh spent lot of time in searching for old saroops too. And would Vedanti Ji care to explain why old saroops are not being taken care of. Instead their saskar is done. Bhagwaan Singh is a witness who still works at Akal Takhat Sahib. According to Bhai Balbir Singh Ji and Giani Chait Singh Ji there is no kachi bani in Kartarpuri saroop. Only raag maala is written. Ang left blank by Guru Ji are still blank. No bani of Ninth Guru Ji. If I assume some sikh added it later then why didn’t he add other banis (in that blank space) that Guru Gobind Singh Ji added later on? He did not want to memorize anything else so he could not write on those extra “pages”? 4) “Would you care to reveal a bit more information about the whereabouts of those original saroops” in summary, there is one saroop at Darbar Sahib, one saroop of Boore Sandhu Bir samat 1662 with signature of Fifth Guru Ji. saroop in Gujrat, village Pindi Lallan, samat 1732 (written month after Ninth Guru Ji’s shaheedi) and there is a second one of samat 1918. three saroops in Jammu, two in Panchait Dharamshaals and one in dharamshala of Nanak Chand Ganesh Das Thakural. Oldest one is samat 1780 (1723 AD). Other two written afterwards. two saroops in Dehradoon samat 1716 (1659). This saroop was sent with Baba Raam Rai by Guru Harrai Ji. second one is a copy of the first one and samat is written 1742. one saroop in Kangarh samat 1718, written during eighth Guru Ji. one saroop of samat 1786 in family of Bhai G.B. Singh Ji. one saroop in village Sarnkay samat 1728. one saroop in Dhaka samat 1732, completed 17 days after Ninth Guru Ji’s shaheedi. It also says “Patshahi 10” before dohra of “Ball Hoaa…” So Singh Ji, this is the information I found in book by Bhai Jaswant Singh Ji. I have seen one saroop at Darbar Sahib and other one 1” X 1” printed by British in late 30s. both are ladivaar and only raag maala after mundavani. Nothing else. Other than that I have picture of a saroop kept in Buddhu Shah’s family. Raag Maala starts right after mundavani. Prof Jodh Singh provides picture of last Ang of Kartarpuri saroop and his book “Kartarpuri Bir De Darshan” does not mention any kachi bani. Raag Maala is an index of Raags that represent Gurmat Sangeet which is why it shows up after all the bani and it should. I do not have book mundavani which I think deserves some attention but the way things went with Patna Sahib it raises many suspicions. When I go to Punjab, I would definitely go see some old saroops, find out their history and take pictures. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

Himat Singh · 14 Jan 2005

I know a Gursikh who's life is fully devoted to sewa simran and sarbat daa bhalaa.He is now 85 year old and in india and We saw he did lot of bagatee in his whole life and he loves to everyone jathaa and taksal and when we ask him if the ragmaalaa is bani or not he said its not my openion or my thinking and he said,"We asked this question from Soksham maahaapurash shaheed singh who halped him a lot in naam simran, They said The raagmaalaa is baani.

Re: raagmala

intresting read.... · 14 Jan 2005

Sikh Rehit Maryada Points of Contention Guru Granth Sahib: Raag Mala The Fifth Guru Nanak, Sahib Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji, finished compiling the Pothi Sahib, now commonly known as Sri Guru Granth Sahib or Adi Bir in 1604 A.D. According to the prevalent procedure followed by authors of religious literature, Sri Guru Granth Sahib was started with the praise of the Almighty God in the form of Mool Mantra. After completing the Volume, the closing Shabad of Mundavani M.5 was put at the end as the closing Seal (the word Mundavani is derived from the word Mundana, i.e., to close), and was, of course, followed by the last thanksgiving shabad: Tera Kita Jaato Nahin... While compiling the contents of Sri Guru Granth Sahib, Guru Sahib devised and adopted a very meticulous system of checks and balances so that no extraneous material could be interpolated anywhere without being discovered. Each entry herein is numbered and subtotals of each part are carried forward to form the grand total. It was thus not possible for any miscreant to introduce any extraneous matter in the main body of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. However, it appears that certain people, including some devout Sikhs, started writing in the Birs in their possession certain pieces of information which they considered to be very important for the purpose of preserving their posterity. This is not unlike how some devout Christians reportedly recorded important family matters in their family Bibles so that on-coming generations may benefit from them. It seems very probable that some people may have added some extraneous material which they considered harmless though important for them and their families, at the end of the Birs in their possession. Thus, in some (NOT ALL) of the hand-written old Birs, including the one at Kartarpur Sahib, one or more of the following material has been found at the end of the last Thanksgiving shabad: 1. Jit dir likh Mohammada... 2. Baaey Aatish Aad... 3. Raig Ramkali Ratinmila 4. Hikikat Raah Mukaam of Raj Shivnibh 5. Raag Mala 6. Dates of Jyoti jot (ascension) of the first six Gurus are given in the beginning on spare pages in the Kartarpur Bir. There is also mention of year of 'fire in Kartarpur' as also the year of Maharaja Ranjit Singh's visit. 7. In certain cases the technique of making special ink (Ink formula) used for writing Sri Guru Granth Sahib, has also been written. The remarkable thing is that in all such Birs wherein extraneous material has been added at the end, Raag Mala comes last of all. It is surprising that while all other items have been disapproved and excluded, only the Raag Mala, which was at the end of such material, has been pressed for inclusion, creating unnecessary controversy. Some supporters of Raag Mala assert that when the original volume of Sri Guru Granth Sahib was completed, some Sikhs petitioned to the Satguru, to bless them with some prem maala which would help them in their deliverance from the cycle of birth and death.25 Acceding to their supplication, Guru Sahib himself composed Raag Mala and put it at the end! What logic! What a clever justification constructed by Raag Mala supporters! The whole of Dhur-ki-Bani contained in Sri Guru Granth Sahib, which is all full of praises of the Lord and Naam, could not help the Sikhs attain salvation. And, Raag Mala, wherein not an iota of Naam or God's Praise exists, should help them to reach the highest State of Divinity! Then why take the pains to read the whole of Sri Guru Granth Sahib when we can achieve our ultimate goal by reading Raag Mala alone? Is not the presentation of this reasoning itself a sacrilege of Dhur-Ki-Bani? The true authorship and authenticity of Raag Mala has always remained dubious: i. According to well-known historian Gyani Gyan Singh, in a Sarbat Khalsa Samagam held in 1906 Bikrami (1853 A.D.), it was declared that Raag Mala is not Gurbani. His actual words are: (English Translation) "In Samvat 1906 Bikrami, during the month of Katak, at the Dera of Sant Dyal Singh, a large Panthic gathering took place. On the Divali day, after detailed exchange of ideas and considerations, it was concluded that Raag Mala is not Gurbani."26 ii. In 1900 A-D. - at the time of the founding of the Chief Khalsa Diwan, Sri Guru Granth Sahib was printed without containing Raag Mala. One such Bir is reported to be present now at Gujarwal in Ludhiana District. Again another printing of Sri Guru Granth Sahib took place in 1915 without Raag Mala in Gurmat Press at Amritsar - one of which is also present in Singh Sabha Gurdwara at Gujarwal. At that time the two top Sikh organizations, Tat Khalsa and Chief Khalsa Diwan, propagated zealously against reading Raag Mala. iii. In the early 1930s, a special committee was constituted by the newly formed S.G.P.C. to draft Gursikh Rahit Maryada. This committee, after detailed deliberations declared unequivocally that Raag Mala is not Gurbani. As a result, the first 1938 edition of the RAHIT MARYADA published by the S.G.P.C. clearly stated: Guru Granth Sahib's reading should end after Mundavani and Raag Mala should not he read.27, 28 iv. As a result of all these clear cut directions of the leading Sikh organizations, the reading of Raag Mala was stopped in many Gurudwaras. AT SRI AKAL TAKHT SAHIB, IT WAS ALREADY NOT BEING READ, AND IS NOT READ EVEN NOW. (Recently, for obvious reasons when there is no stable management authority at Sri Akal Takht Sahib, some pro-Raag Mala people are reported to have started reading it there. This is not based on any Panthic decision.) v. However, in the later editions of the Gursikh RAHIT MARYADA, published by the S.G.P.C., the wording in this respect was changed without consulting even the members of the original Committee and without giving any explanation as to the basis of this change, to read as follows: "...reading of Guru Granth should be concluded with the reading of either the Mundavani or the Raag Mala, depending upon local practice." So now, it his been left to the Sangat whether to read it or not. vi. It may be noted that while all 'shabads' in Sri Guru Granth Sahib, without exception, exhort directly or indirectly, the importance of the Divine Naam for spiritual enlightenment, there is not even a trace of this divinity in the whole of Raag Mala. It is just a glossary or genealogy of some raags and sub-raags and their branches. In fact, it is not complete even in this respect so far as raags and sub-raags included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib are concerned, as shown below: (a) There are 31 pure raags and 6 mixed raags in Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Out of 37 raags, 12 raags do not find any mention in Raag Mala. (b) There are as many as 59 raags and raaginies in Raag Mala which are not included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib.29 vii. Another very important but rather basic point to be considered in this respect is that Gurbani is the Divine Word. In spite of the fact that the whole Gurbani has been composed to be read in certain musical measures, it is not wholly dependant on these musical measures so far as its impact on the mind is concerned. Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not for teaching musical measures or raags but is meant to uplift the soul of one who reads it, sings it, or listens to it. In short, the only objective of the Gurbani is Spiritual Enlightenment. That is why Guru Sahib has not written anywhere on the intricacies of the various raags or on the so-called Gurmat Sangeet. The true Gurmat, and not the correct understanding of the raags, is the True Way of Life; though the latter is certainly very helpful and productive. In the closing Shabad of Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib, Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji himself clearly summarized the contents of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. According to him, this platter (thaal) (Sri Guru Granth Sahib), contains the following three things: (a) Amrit Naam. (b) Resultant Contentment and Satiation of all desires; and, finally (c) The true understanding of the Divinity by constant meditation or Simran of the Amrit Naam. Further, it is stated that in reality these are the three aspects of the only ONE THING - AMRIT NAAM. He has not made any hint regarding the presence of various raags and their wives and offsprings, etc., as they are only subsidiary to the major content. viii. The following quotations from Sri Guru Granth Sahib in this perspective are worth considering: Raag Naad Sab Sohney Jau Laagey Sehaj Dhyan Raag Naad Chhod Har Seviay Taa Darghey Payeeay Maan. (pg. 849) Beauteous are the melody and music, if through Guru's word, one fixes his attention on the Lord. One attains the honor in the Lord's Court only when one rises above and gives up the means of the worldly melody and music. Raag Naad Man Dujaay Bhayey. (pg. 1342) Singing and learning temporal music makes one's mind attached to duality. Sabhna Raagaan vich So Bhala Bhai, Jit Vasya Man Aaye. Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai, Keemat Kahi Na Jaaye. Raagey Naadey Bahraa,Inni Hukum Naa Boojhya Jaaey. (pg. 1423) Amongst all the musical measures, that alone is sublime, O Brother, by which the Lord comes to abide into the mind. The melodies in which Guru's word is sung are all true; their worth can be told not. The Lord is beyond the melodies and sounds. Merely through these, His will cannot be realized. ix. Mr. M. A. Macauliffe, who spent about 20 years in studying the Sikh history and scriptures at the end of the 19th Century, published his monumental work entitled The Sikh Religion in six volumes, in 1902. In discussing the completion and contents of Sri Guru Granth Sahib, he states: "A Muhammadan poet called Alam in AH 991 (AD. 1583) wrote a work in 353 stanzas, generally from four to six lines each, called Madhava Nal Kandala. The Raga Mala, which forms the conclusion of the Sri Guru Granth Sahib and contains a list of the raags and raaginis and their subdivisions, is a portion of Alam's work extending from 63rd to 72nd stanza. It is not understood how it was included in the Sacred volume. The Raags mentioned in it do not correspond with the Raags of the Granth Sahib." x. The Mahan Kosh (Encyclopedia of Sikh Literature) of Bhai Sahib Bh. Kahan Singh refers to Raag Mala as under: "Raag Mala: The 63rd to 72nd meters from the Hindi version of Madhavanal Sangeet composed by Alam poet and includes six raags, with five raginis and eight sons of each."30 In his other well-known authoritative work: Gurmat Sudhakar, he has commented in greater detail in this respect: "Many people finish the reading (of Sri Guru Granth Sahib) at Raag Mala. Raag Mala is not Gurbani. It was composed by a poet named Alam, a contemporary of Emperor Akbar - in the year 991 Hijri or Bikrami 1641 - about 20 years before the compilation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib as is evident from the text of the SANGEET...Besides the fact that it is NOT Gurbani, Raag Mala is also against Gurmat because it makes no reference to Devotion, the True Knowledge and Love for God. The Raags in Guru Granth start with Sri Raag. Gurbani also says 'Sri Raag' is blessed among the Raags. It is further supported by Bhai Gurdas Ji who places Sri Raag on the top of the raags. As against this, the Raag Mala starts with Bhairav Raag. All the Raags contained in Guru Granth Sahib are not mentioned in Raag Mala. Also, all the Raags mentioned in Raag Mala are not contained in Guru Granth Sahib. "In the Index of Guru Granth Sahib of Kartarpur, it has been indicated: 'All the leaves of Guru Baba: 974' (in that volume). Mundavani is written on leaf No.973 and 974th is blank. Some Sikh has inserted Raag Mala on additional leaves after 974 at the end of the Guru Granth just as Bhai Banno has inserted many additional Shabads and the anecdote of Sangla-deep without the permission of the Satguru....Many old volumes of Guru Granth Sahib are available at Buij of Baba Ala Singh, Patiala and Sri Abchal Nagar, etc., which do not contain Raag Mala..."31 xi. Professor Sahib Singh, in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Darpan, states as under: "Those people who have made some additions in Guru Granth Sahib, could do so only after Mundavani M.5 and Slok M.5."32 Therefore, according to him, Sri Guru Granth Sahib really ends at Slok M.5, inferring thereby, that whatever is written therein after Slok M.5, is not a part of the original volume and is thus not Gurbani. His other comments and certain points raised by him are also very noteworthy and relevant in this respect: (a) In Raag Mala, the word 'Pun' which is a derivative of the SansIrrit word Punch - has been used while in the rest of Guru Granth Sahib the word is Phun. From a literary view point, it is very strange that none of the Gurus have used this word anywhere in their own compositions. (pg. 693) (b) The heading 'Raag Mala' has not been prefixed or suffixed by the name of its author, contrary to the system followed in Guru Granth Sahib. (pg. 693) (c) The system of putting numerals (1, 2, 3, etc.) in Raag Mala is absolutely different from the system followed in Guru Granth Sahib. Why so? (pg. 694) (d) Raag Gaund has been shown first as the son of Raag Sri Raag and then as the son of Raag Megh! (pg. 697) (e) The use of the numeral '1' twice in Raag Mala is confusing. (pg. 697) (f) It is very astonishing to note that certain Raags contained in Guru Granth Sahib have not been mentioned in Raag Mala, and a number of Raags not mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib, are included in it. (pg. 697) xii Similar references to Raag Mala have also been made by some other renowned scholars: "Raag Mala is not the composition of the Satguru" (Gur Partip Surya by Mahan Kavi Bhai Sahib Bhai Santokh Singh Ji) "Mundavani was kept at the end of the Granth Sahib as the Closing Seal. Raag Mala was inserted by someone later..." (Guru Tirath Kosh by Pt. Tara Singh Nirotam.)

Re: raagmala

;) · 14 Jan 2005

*************************************************** Oh suksham singh shaeed taksali hovega....just kidding... *************************************************** 1. Tell me which Guru sahib ji wrote Ragmala? 2. Where is the manglacharan of this baani? Every Guru sahib's baani have manglacharan at starting. Guru sahib ji always manlacharan Akaal Purakh before reciting major baani.(Ik onkar....gur prasaad) 3. All baani has "Kahou Nanak" or bhagats name mentioned at the last "Tuk" which indicates whose baani it is. Why it is missing in Raagmala? 4. Whole gurbaani tie us to Akaal purakh sahib not "Raags" I can give you numberless example from gurbani where its said Akkal Purakh cannot be achieved with raags its "Naam Simran" which will get you united with "Ik Jot" . None raags of the world have this power and I challenge any brhamgayyani or suksham singh sahhed if he attaned any thing with raags....its only in "Naam" that everything dwells.... Whole baani get us close to "Naam"...in fact persons(so calles brhamgyaanis) and taksaalis should realize one minor but biggest thing is Gurbaani is hazra hazoor Guru Sahib. How guru sahib can be in ALAM KAAM KANDLA Book. You should feel shame saying this is gurbaani otherwise you make gurusahib sit in KAAM KANDLA Book also...have some shame and take guru sahib ji out from such a bad place....... If I am there I will ask suksham singh shaheed to have his brain work and free guru sahib from a narki book(alam's Book) and stop saying its baani... I am not brhamgyaani or sant but I challenge any body saying himself sant or bhramgyaani to have that power to take us to the time and show us Guru sahib wrote this....

Re: raagmala

Halo2 Singh · 14 Jan 2005

Giani Sobha Singh who lived at Takhar Dyal Singh’s Dharamsala in Amritsar, was one of the first Sikhs to start the debate over the authenticity of Ragmala over a 100 years ago. He even compiled a Saroop of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee without Ragmala in it and he took it to Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib for approval. The senior Sikhs of the day decided to offer an Ardas to Guru Jee, in this Ardas they said, ‘If Bhai Sobha Singh has done right then nothing should happen, but if he has done wrong then punish him accordingly.’ After just a week he became ill and his mouth was full of ulcers and he was in much pain, to the extent that he could not even speak. He wrote a letter begging for forgiveness and brought it to Sri Akhal Takhat Sahib and he said that no-one should ever make the same mistake again. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Jee has told us of the greatness of reading Ragmala in his work Gur Bilaas: Bhog Paavhu …. Ragmala is read at the end of a complete recital of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, by doing this all your sins are eradicated. Ragmala Parr … By reading Ragmala the recital is complete, without it’s recitation it is incomplete. We can only pray that Guru Jee brings the people who don’t believe in Ragmala to their senses, in this life as who knows what they will have to endure if they die doubting the authenticity of Ragmala. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: raagmala

;) · 14 Jan 2005

Bhai Sahib jio, Aap ji noo guru diyan assesan lagan ....Guru savarey kadey bhi eh bejti nahin bardaash kar sakdey ki ohna dey guru sahib noo Alam kavi di kirt naal jorya jaavey...its as good as Alam mullyey noo matha tekna.....daso hun taksaliyey taan ehda paath kardey hann tey kehndey hann ki jo nahin paddey oh narakan vich jaangey.... apni karni kar narak hoon naa pavon thour....dey mahavakk oh gursikh bhul gaye hann tey aap noo karta purakh samajh baithey hann...Pata nahin guru sahib kad kirpa kar key eh kalank "Raag mala" apney saroop ton kadngey......"jo ki hoshi matt valley lokan ney laa ditta hai tey taksaaleye akhan kann band kar key brahmgyaniyan di poonch fadi firdey hann...asal brhamgyaani taan guru aap hain ... baaki sabh kachey haan...jinna marji naam japp lain ...guru tul nahin ho sakdey....

Re: raagmala

Akal purkh di fauj · 14 Jan 2005

singhs i think u should stop waistin ur time on these messages and carry on wid wat u can do, wats da point on fighting bout raag malla or any other subjects and just carry on wid folowin the jap ji sahib 4 once. i recon if we folow the guru teachings by readin gurus bani we will get sme where in life wid al these arguments u are just goin around and around. lets al do ardass that sikhi panth cmes more stronger and al of us singhs nd singhnis become more chardikala. so stay charikala and keep out of this arguments if i said anytin wrong den forgive me. wjkk wjkf

Re: raagmala

singh100 · 14 Jan 2005

those are nice fairytales, halo2singh. Kavi santokh singh talked about raag mala not being banee well before the fairy tale you mention. Nothing happened to him. Bijla singh, could you please explain when ratan mala was added to saroops? And why didn't any singhs stop this from happening. It's not in just one or two saroops, but many saroops. Please explain this. There are also a lot of myths about kirtarpuri veer going around. Some people say ink tests were done, some even say ink tests were done on the ragmala part showing it is different ink, otheres say the opposite. Try doing some proper, unbiased research on it. You try to discount Kahn Singh Nabhas account with more myths. It's not that easy. Kahn Singh wasn't a fool. I keep hearing about Baba Deep Singh's saroops... yet nobody ever tells where they are. Bijla lists a bunch of other puratan saroops. I could mention a bunch without raagmala or where it is clearly added in afterwards. So what? The fact is, the saroops written by Baba Deep Singh are no longer available. If they are, explain where.

Re: raagmala

Admin · 15 Jan 2005

Topic Locked Admin.