Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kes the kakaar?

kes the kakaar?

amar · 02 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf It has been a controversial issue for many years and up to this day some people are in confusion to what the 5th K is. It is obvious from various sources (bhai uday singh's book) that kes is not the 5th K as it is way above the other kakaars and keskhi being man made like the other 4 kakaars is the correct 5th K. Therefore people, please review ur opinion on the 5th K if u think its kes and read bhai uday singh' book, 'keski, not kes, the 5th kakaar', (its a GREAT book) vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

Confused ? · 03 Jan 2005

Correct this fool, but I always thought that unshorn hair, Kes was the kakaar and not a keski. <<<< that kes is not the 5th K as it is way above the other kakaars >>>> what are you talking about ? the kunga is kept in the hair is this not way too above the others also??? It is either the unshorn hair or the keski, you cannot have it both ways. So you could shave your head and as long as you wear a keski then it is alright? I see, it doesn't matter about the unshorn hair it is about the "manmade" keski, got yer!

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 03 Jan 2005

Does a kakar have to be man made? Is that which defines it as a kekar, I doubt this to be the case. For instance look at thew World, although potentially everyone can be Keshdari how many people are. Very few people have got this gift as ordered by the Guru (only mainly Amridhari's), while more non sikhs have Keski ie Muslim people such as in Afghanistan. Therefore by simply argueing that Kesh is natural does not mean it is not a kekar. Kesh is simply not a gift which all people have, but something which people obeying the Guru's hukam decide to keep, just like the other kekars. We also need to figure out what Keski is, especially as no where in any of Guru ji's writings which we have has he mentioed the word Keski, unlike Kesh. Is a piece of material drapped on the head while the Kesh is open still a keski ie after isnaan. Also is a piece of cloth wrapped around the stomach while washing the hair still defined as a Keski? I hope that if this debate is allowed to continue the admin will respect the views all posters, and unlike in the past not block posts which argue with evidence that Kesh is the kekar.

Re: kes the kakaar?

--->akharinaam<--- · 04 Jan 2005

where can i get this book

Re: kes the kakaar?

1699 · 04 Jan 2005

wahaguru je ka khalsa wahaguru je ke fateh fateh singh sahib jee. dass has heard alot of ppl saying yes and no to a keski but lets remember that if a singh has kes then he will be tying a dastar rite. therefore the keski comes with the kes its like the total package.hahahaha. i duno but lets try to remember that bani has al the answers if we ask with enough love and devotion guru ji will answer any question for us. wahaguru kirpa kara. maf kario ah murak de murakhtai vastay. wahaguru je ka khalsa wahaguru je ke fateh fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Manpreet Kaur · 04 Jan 2005

"So you could shave your head and as long as you wear a keski then it is alright? I see, it doesn't matter about the unshorn hair it is about the "manmade" keski, got yer!" Confused jee, the first requirement for a gursikh is to have unshorn hair. That is why when you cut your hair you become an apostate. How come when you accidently drop your kanga you don't have to get peshed? is it not also a kakkar? but with the hair case you would have to get peshed......HAIR has a much higher status than our punj kakkar. When i took amrit i was told that the 5th k was kes but i also read Bhai Uday Singhs Book and he has made some really good points and changed my view. im not saying that at amrit sanchars where they tell the 5th k to be kes IS WRONG or anything cuz wow who the heck am I to even think anything like that. BUT FOR MYSELF. the rehit i choose to follow it makes sense and thats what i follow and encourage others to follow. I do truely beleive it is the RRS slowly doing these things to the Sikh Koam. Sighni's back in the days used to support dastars too..what happen today? anyway rehit is important. but its more important to clean the inside and those that don't wear keski's aren't any less. they are also Guru waley so we should respect them all the same. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf confused, you appear to be very very confused. Keski being the 5th K in no way at alll is suggesting that one can cut his or her hair. For a sikh, unshorn hair is a fundamental requirement and one of the most important things in sikhism is the long hair. Therefore i am saying, where is the need to add the kes to the 5 kakaars if its importance is already underline in sikhi. By doing this we are not increasing its importance as removal of any of the 5 kakaars can be dealt with by a simple ardaas but if one removes his or her kes they will have to go pesh so therefore by naming kes as the 5th k you are lowering its status. The kanga is man made and if it should come out of the hair and fall on the floor, one can make ammends by offering an ardaas so therefore you cant compare one of the kakaars to the kes as it is reagarded way higher in sikhism. Cutting your hair is one of the 4 krehits (major sins) and therefore it is already outlined that they are a requirement for a sikh without putting them as one of the 5 K's. please reply with any SENSIBLE comments vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf akharinaam what country do you live in? If you live in canada send bhai uday singh a letter requesting a book, and you will receive free of charge. Bhai uday singhs address is 13277 Centreville Creek Road, Bolton, Ontario, Canada L7E 5S1 vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 04 Jan 2005

Will anyone define Keski as per my earlier questions, is a piece of material drapped on the head while the Kesh is open still a keski kekkar ie after isnaan. Also is a piece of cloth wrapped around the stomach while washing the hair still defined as a Keski, kekkar?

Re: kes the kakaar?

amarjeet singh · 04 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf you dont know what a keski is you must be rather dim. A keski is a piece of cloth to protect the hair and should be worn at all times like the other 5 k's however whilst washing, combing and drying the hair the keski should be tied around the waist, this doesnt make it any less of a kheski just as kachera arent made any less of a kachera when you are changing from one pair to another. It is stupid to say that a kheski changes when its not on the head as it doesnt its just not possible to keep a kheski tied on the head while washing and combing the kes. Also, about a muslim wearing a 'kheski' this is a pointless and flimsy arguement. Many people have long hair all over the world many people cover thei heads and many people wear daggers, combs and long shorts but to call these kakaars of a sikh one should also wear them all of the time and abide by the sikhi rehit. and the dastar is mention in gurbani and guru gobind singh ji specifically asked for a smaller kheski to be worn underneath the larger turban. vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

* · 04 Jan 2005

Singh, I don't see your point. Whether a keski is wrapped around your head or around your stomach during kesee-ishnaan, it is still a keski. Similarly, when your kirpaan is worn on a gatraa from your shoulder to your waste at all normal times and then wrapped around your head during ishnaan, it is still a kirpaan, and still a kakaar. Keski isn't just any old piece of cloth wrapped here or there. It has specifications (length, colour, etc) which define it as a keski. You can't call a 1-meter long, green piece of cloth which is wrapped around your knee a keski.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh 2 · 04 Jan 2005

"Singh" with regards to your question, I do not quite see the point in it. If the particular kakkar is not performing its main/usual "purpose" (in the case of keski, covering the KES) it does not mean that it is no longer counted as what it is is a kara still a "wrist ring" once it is taken off the wrist? Surely then it just becomes a circular piece of metal? When the Kachere are pulled down the leg when changing during Ishnaan, is this a piece of soggy stitched cloth and no longer a kachere? Because a keski is untied it does not cease to be a keski. If you tie it round your waist during Ishnaan it does not suddenly stop being a keski. It is a keski tied around your waist (duh). Is an iron wring that you found (for example in some type of machinery or something) that you pick up count as a kara? If a tree falls in a forest and no one is there to hear it, does it still make a sound?

Re: kes the kakaar?

ij · 05 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh in my view and knowledge, kes is not kakkar but keski is. now let us see: kanga: cleans the hair kara: used as a weapon and has other deep meanings that i wont list. kirpan: protects . kacchera: protects us as reminder of being 'good'. keski: protects our hair. now the hair must be covered so it can be clean. i have heard a story of one sant that had darshan and was told by Guru Ji Himself that keski is the other kakkar and not kes. but keski is only woth kes as kanga is only with kes so accepting keski as kakkar does not mean cut ur hair. it means respect it even more cos we have a kanga and a keski to take care of hair!! hair is God's gift and the 5 kakkars we are given to protect ourselves. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

erm · 05 Jan 2005

bhai nand laal clearly states Nishan-e-Sikhi ast in Panj har kaf Hargiz na bashad azin panj muaf Kara, Karad, Kacha, Kanga bi dan, Bina kesh kes hech ast jumla nishan. These five letters of K are emblems of Sikhi. These five are most incumbent, Iron bangle, sword, shorts and a comb; without unshorn hair the other four are of no significance so kesh is clearly the kakar, however the need for dastaar is also clearly stated naapaak paak kar hadhoor hadheesaa saabath soorath dhasthaar siraa Saabath soorath meaning to keep your body unaltered Dhasthaar siraa - turban on ur head Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 05 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Not knowing what is defined as a keski is not being dim, as some people may think. As Guru Ji has never mentioned the word Keski in any of his writings its common sence to get a definition, otherwise we have no grounds to argue its the kekar without knowing really what it is. Just thinking it is this or that with blind faith is really being dim. "Also, about a muslim wearing a 'kheski' this is a pointless and flimsy arguement. Many people have long hair all over the world many people cover thei heads and many people wear daggers, combs and long shorts but to call these kakaars of a sikh one should also wear them all of the time and abide by the sikhi rehit." The above is exactly my point. No one can say Kesh is not the kekkar as argued by some on the grounds that everyone has it. Only those who keep Kesh and live within Rehat have Kesh as a Kekkar, while those very few who naturally keep Kesh does not mean its a kekkar, just like those who are non sikhs who wear Keksi's. "and the dastar is mention in gurbani and guru gobind singh ji specifically asked for a smaller kheski to be worn underneath the larger turban." Please provide a ref. There is no where, where Guru Ji ever has writen down Keski, please let us know where Guru Ji has noted the word Keski down. Pagri is mentioned in Gurbani but unless you think pagri begins with K it does not make it Keski. "i have heard a story of one sant that had darshan and was told by Guru Ji Himself that keski is the other kakkar and not kes." The above is almost funny. What about all the other great "Sants" who are known to have met Guru Ji. Why would Guru Ji tell one beloved Singh what the Kekar is, and not the other? I think all have agreed that a Keksi wrapped around the waist or slung on the head open is still a Keski. As mentioned by singh 2 Because a keski is untied it does not cease to be a keski. This leads to the question, therefore does a chunni/Keski worn by Amridhari woman to cover their head count as a Keski. WHy not? If a piece of cloth wrapped around the stomach or drapped on the head while drying Kesh is still a Keski, surely a piece of cloth of exacatly the same material lenth etc drapped on the head is still a Keski. How can a piece of material drapped on the head while the Kesh is open be regarded as the Kekar, and the same material drapped on the head of Amridhari woman suddenly stops being a keski? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

amarjeet singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf firstly, a chuni being a keski?? I have explained already that in order to wash ones hair one must tie the keski around ones waist to keep it on. It is still a keski. If any one wears a keski draped around their head all of the time they are not wearing dastaar as gurbani says one should do 'saabat soorat dastat siraa' so although a keskhi is still a keskhi no matter how it is worn there are specifications to how a kheski should be worn (under the larger dastaar). The rehit naama of the smaller dastaar being worn under the larger one is so widely known that keskis were given to soldiers in the war as well as a larger turban. Just because guru ji has not written down keskhi doesnt mean that it is not one of the 5 K's, similarly where in gurbani is there the mention of kachera. If kes is one of the 5k's why is its removal considered as a krehit whereas the removal of any of the 5k's can be excused with an ardaas??????? vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

vivek · 05 Jan 2005

Kes is FUNDAMENTAL in sikhi, Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji told us to keep our Kes. Kes is more MORE important then Kara, Kirpan, Kangha, Keski (eg) If Kes is the 5th K, are you saying before taking amrit we can cut our hair? As you only have to wear 5Ks after taking amrit. Why is cutting hair a krehit, but taking your keski, kangha, kirpan, kara off not? Corruption is everywhere in this age (kaljug), don't be fooled by it.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon · 05 Jan 2005

I thought Nishani Sikhi Shabad was Dasam Granth supposedly? Now it is claimed as Nand Lal?

Re: kes the kakaar?

Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

When I too amrit they refered to keski as the ramaal thing some bibiyan wear. Not in a top not. I'm a bit confused. But the keski I wear is a chotee dastaar under a larger one.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Tarrandeep Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

''singh'' vahiguru ji ka khalsa vahiguru ji ki fateh draping achunni on the head at all times is not acceptable. A keski should be tied with the joora on top of the head, when the hair is being washed or combed then obviosly the keski should still be kept on you (therefor tie it round waist) but u cannot tie it on the head if ur hair is soaking wet after just being washed. After hair is dry and combed then the keski is tied again. Wearing a chunni, is completely different it is not being tied and their is no joora on the top of your head (dasaam duar). If that your arguement why dont u take ur dastaar off and wear a chunni with a plait at the back? Go on you seem to think its the same as wearing a keski so go and wear a chunni. If a singh walked into the gudwara with a bun at the bak of his head and a patka tied on top of it (like many girls wear) or if he had a chunni on, every one would laugh at him. However its acceptable for a woman to do this, what happened to equality. Keski (with joora on top of hed not at bak of hed) should be tied. vahiguru ji ka khalsa vahiguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 06 Jan 2005

I think most people are now making their own rules up as to when and how a keski is a keski and not. “The rehit naama of the smaller dastaar being worn under the larger one is so widely known that keskis were given to soldiers in the war as well as a larger turban.” The above does not prove keski to be the kekar in any way. To think so is like saying a gatra is the kekar, as it was given to sikhs in the Biritish Army. Most sikhs were 2 turbans for practicality etc, and not because it’s a kekkar. Gurbani does say 'saabat soorat dastat siraa' however this is referring to the dastar, ie turban and not a keski, which had been defined as a smaller cloth under the dastar. Please do not change the meaning of Gurbani. IF Guru Ji was referring to a Keski wouldn’t he have used the word ie for a small under cloth rather than dastar which represents a full turban. Now it is being argued (or made up) that there is a specific definition of the Keski ie it must be worn under the turban. However when people tie a single Keski at home while chilling out and sleeping is it no longer a keski than. If not worn under a turban does it stop being a keski, as is being preached, how? Who makes all these rules up about keski having to be tied in this way, and the joora and dhasm duar etc. If this has been detailed by Guru Ji than fine, but it really appears that people have made there own rules up, and are following them in blind faith. On the one hand examples were given of a kirpan being worn on the gatra or kumalkesa still being a kirpan, and therefore a keski drapped on the head or tied round is still the same thing. Now it appears this has changed as its obvious that there is no fixed definition of Keski, and it can incorporate a chunni.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Amrik singh · 06 Jan 2005

wjkk wjkf i agree with veer amarjeet singhs view. kesky is the kakar. some ppl have already pionted out that the other kakars have a meaning behind them - what signifcance does kes have with kakars? by wearing kakars u are following rehit, how can u wear kes? u cant so therefore a keskhy must be there to cover it. bhai sahib bhai rabdhir singh a braham giyaani him self has said that keskhy is kakar. and in sukhmani sahib it talks about a brahamgiyaani being GOD HIMSELF so how can bhai sahib be wrong. my advise to my fellow brothers and sisters is to do review there views on keskhy and get more educated. On PANNA 1084 it is written SAABAT SOORAT DISTAAR SIRAA. THIS MEANS THE ENITIRE BODY MUST STAY UN-TEMPERED AND THAT ON THE HEAD (MEN AND WOMEN) MUST ALWAYS COVER THERE HEADS WITH A DISTAAR. in bhai Chaupa singh rehitnamas it says : Kachh, Kada, Kirpan, Kangha, Keski. Eh Panj Kakaari Rahit Dhaarey Sikh Soyee. THAT CLARIFIES EVERYTHING THAT KESKHY IS KAKAR. i ask for forgiveness if i have sed anything wrong. wjkk wjkf amrik singh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

"If that your arguement why dont u take ur dastaar off and wear a chunni with a plait at the back? Go on you seem to think its the same as wearing a keski so go and wear a chunni." Tarrandeep bhen jee, I don't kno who that was directed towards but since I was the one who mentioned the amrit sanchar where they explained the ramaal thing without the joora in the back I THINK IT WAS DIRECTED TOWARDS ME. I do wear keski under a larger dastaar with my hair in a top not. I don't know about the dasam duar part. I've heard some people say "your joora should be on the dasam duar". I have no idea where that is on my head. I thought it was more a spiritual thing. How does a joora being there help in anyway to open the dasam duar? These might sound like dumb questions to you, but I am confused. Anyway, people who are not convinced about keski being a kakkar. READ PROF UDAY SINGHS BOOK and see if your view is changed.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh "by wearing kakars u are following rehit, how can u wear kes? u cant so therefore a keskhy must be there to cover it. " This has already been dealt with. Supporters of keski have themselves admitted that a kekkar is only such if it is kept according to rehat and under the advice of the Guru, otherwise all people who keep knives have a kirpan, and all who wear shorts are wearing kachera's. Kesh can be kept as a kekkar if it is kept under rehat and according to the Guru's hukam. To say just becouse Bhai Randhir singh beleived it so it must be true is pure sant beleiving narrow minded mentality. What about Sant Jarnail SIngh, Sant Pooran Singh, Sant Ishers Singh the list goes on and on who did not preach keski was the kekkar. TO rely on the bit from Bhai Chapa SInghs rehat nama is also floored. Have you ever read the actual Rehata Namah, it is full of anti Gurmat and is well known to have been tampered with according to people on this very site. If you are to accept it regardless you also have to accept other anti gurmat things it contains and not pick and choose what suites you. One more point the words Nishan-e-Sikhi ast in Panj har kaf Hargiz na bashad azin panj muaf Kara, Karad, Kacha, Kanga bi dan, Bina kesh kes hech ast jumla nishan. These five letters of K are emblems of Sikhi. These five are most incumbent, Iron bangle, sword, shorts and a comb; without unshorn hair the other four are of no significance is infact in Dhasm Granth. According to a Singh who is almost finishing his phd in Dhasm Bani in the UK this extract is only found in the oldest and authentic saroops of Dhasm Granth. WHile the word Keski never appears in Dhasm or Sarbloh Granth, and I have simply heard no evidence of females in Guru Ji's household wearing them, unless you know otherwise.

Re: kes the kakaar?

SINGH · 06 Jan 2005

WJKKWJKF!! My Brother Bhai Saahib Amrik Singh Ji Stated: >> bhai sahib bhai rabdhir singh a braham giyaani him self has said that keskhy is kakar. << I was always under the notion that the Akhand Keertani Jatha was totally AGAINST calling people Sants and Brahmgiani's...maybe times are changing.. My point is this...Out of ALL the Jathebandi's and Sikh Organisations it is only the ones that have been set up by MEN that oppose 2 parts of the Rehat. 1. Kes 2. Sri Raagmaalaa Jathebandi's and organisations such as Akali Nihangs and Taksal that were started by Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Himself all believe that Kes is the Kakar and Sri Raagmaalaa is Gurbani ...Think about it...Hope i didnt cause offence...Satguru Rakha! WJKKWJKF!

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 06 Jan 2005

Singh your comment about the Nishani Sikhi shabad is very interesting. Elsewhere it is claimed as Bhai Nand Lal's works! It is found as a "Gagga" appendix allegedly in Dasam Granth. I may be wrong but didn't Piara Singh Padam say it was found literally as a loosepiece of paper/"bookmark" in an old Dasam Granth Bir? It seems no one is exactly sure where this shabad has appeared from. I would be extremely interested to know exactly which Dasam Granth Bir it was found in since from what I have heard the langauge within it is nowhere near Persian of 17th/very early 18th century (Guru Jis times) I would also be interested to know who this UK Singh who is getting his PHD on the Dasam Granth is. Possibly Nihang Kamalroop Singh. What this tends to conflict with is the fact that many of the UK Nihangs reject the entire concept of the Panj Kakkars for that of the Treh Mudreh. You wrote: "According to a Singh who is almost finishing his phd in Dhasm Bani in the UK this extract is only found in the oldest and authentic saroops of Dhasm Granth." This statement is very vague and unhelpful. Please be a little bit more specific since hearsay, rumours and "only the most old and authentic" do not go down well in a debate on history. I would like to ask you, if you reject Chaupa Singh Rehatnama on the basis of a few parts of it, exactly which historical source you use that you do not "pick and choose" as you state. You have not studied Sikh historical documents in any detail to make such a statement. NO text other than Guru Ji can be relied on 100%. Every other source I have come across will conflict slightly with every viewpoint on one point or another. It is naive and historically blinkered to take your stance. Perhaps a better place to look is Guru Kian Sakhian by Bhai Sarup Singh Kaushish. This text was finished in 1790. It states when describing the Amrit ceremony of 1699 "First you must wear a blue keski, a kangha, a kirpan, a sarbloh kara and a white kachira." Since it is has remained within the families of the Bhatts this is a reason why it has remained unaltered and tampered with. It is the only source to my knowledge which actaully mentions the surname "Kaur" given to women and elsewhere mentions the Keski again as a kakkar being tied on Banda Singh Bahadur by Guru Ji himself. Internal factors such as the dates of Vaisakhi, a source of debate through the 18th century, prove it to be without a doubt a Praatan 18th century source. If this was not enough Bhatt Vahi Bhadason Paragana Thanesar lists the panj kakkars as "kangha, karad (kirpan/knife), keski, kara and kachira" in his contemporary account of the Vaisakhi ceremony. It should be noted that these two above sources are even quoted on the infamous $hastarvidiya.org website, which if my assumption on the identity of your "Dasam Granth scholar" is correct, would surely contain a set of opinions which are very much inline with that of Kamalroop Singh. Thanks for your time.

Re: kes the kakaar?

kaur id · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Singh rethink that , I am not AKJ sikh but just a sikh and i believe kesh is not kakkar but still vital, even more in fact. I believe Ragamala to be part of bani. lol but i agree with you as that is the case inmany of sikhs Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Tarrandeep kaur · 07 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf manpreet kaur my earlier mesage wasnt aimed at you i was replying to wat ''singh'' sed that wearin a chunni is same as a keski-so i told him if he thinks that then he shud wear a plait and a chunnit insted of a keski. lol vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

Search For Tat · 07 Jan 2005

This is the funniest post I have read in ages. Guru Gobind singh started the Khalsa panth, not any nihangs or taksal. The real Khalsa nihangs like banda Singh bhahdhur followed tat gurmat maryada, not niddars mish mash maryada. Taksal has never been able to prove its history before sant Sundar singh. It lives in a world of hearsay like Binderwale still being alive. AKJ, Nihangs & taksal are all man made, only KHALSA PANTH is Guru Made! Live in the real world dude! SINGH wrote: > WJKKWJKF!! > > My Brother Bhai Saahib Amrik Singh Ji Stated: > > >> bhai sahib bhai rabdhir singh a braham giyaani him self has > said that keskhy is kakar. << > > I was always under the notion that the Akhand Keertani Jatha > was totally AGAINST calling people Sants and > Brahmgiani's...maybe times are changing.. > > My point is this...Out of ALL the Jathebandi's and Sikh > Organisations it is only the ones that have been set up by MEN > that oppose 2 parts of the Rehat. > > 1. Kes > 2. Sri Raagmaalaa > > Jathebandi's and organisations such as Akali Nihangs and Taksal > that were started by Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Himself all > believe that Kes is the Kakar and Sri Raagmaalaa is Gurbani > > ...Think about it...Hope i didnt cause offence...Satguru > Rakha! > > WJKKWJKF! > >

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh “Perhaps a better place to look is Guru Kian Sakhian by Bhai Sarup Singh Kaushish. This text was finished in 1790. It states when describing the Amrit ceremony of 1699 "First you must wear a blue keski, a kangha, a kirpan, a sarbloh kara and a white kachira." Since it is has remained within the families of the Bhatts this is a reason why it has remained unaltered and tampered with. LOL you have really no idea. If you accept this account you have to also accept that Guru Ji used 5 goats in 1699, that all Sikhs who do not wear a BLUE Keski including Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh, Bhai Jeevan Singh and numerous other great Sikhs in the Panth went around with only 4 Kekkars, that only sex with muslim woman is a kureht and that there was no such ritual as naam dhri. All these are backed by this account if you care to read it, so therefore once again you are picking and choosing what suites you, unless you also accept the above. For your information the account itself has been re-written many times and is not the original scrolls used. It has been retranslated into modern louguage and there is no way of verifying what the original scrolls written decades earlier actually said. Concerning Dhasm Granth having not spent the last few years of my life travelling to India, and the Biritish museum where old saroops of Dhasm Granth are kept like everyone else here, all I can say that from someone who has, and has seen and studied more puraatan saroops of Dhasm Granth than us all put together the section about the 5ks is found in the oldest and most authentic saroops, interpret that as you will. “''singh'' sed that wearin a chunni is same as a keski-so i told him if he thinks that then he shud wear a plait and a chunnit insted of a keski.” The above is a typical response from someone who believes in word of mouth BS, and has no answers. No one has been able to explain the simple fact that technically a chunni is also a keski. LOL In terms of what I believe in the simple fact is that the only Rehat is the Sikh Rehat Maryada, stamped and made by the Guru Panth. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Amrik singh · 07 Jan 2005

>>>Jathebandi's and organisations such as Akali Nihangs and Taksal that were started by Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Himself all believe that Kes is the Kakar and Sri Raagmaalaa is Gurbani<<< the taaksaal u see was created by guru gobind singh? the nihangs who eat meat were created my guru gobind singh? the problem is u classed me as an akj and not a khalsa, why did u class me under akj? cuz i used bhai randhir singh? i think u need to re-think what u just said - akali nihang singhs were created by akali guru hargobind sahib ji. IF GURU GOBIND SINGH CREATED NIHANGS AND TAKSAAL - THEN WHY DO NIHANGS BELIEVE IN RATTANMALA AND TAKLSAL DONT!!!??? i think these issues bring hatred for each other - theres no love in our khalsa brothers

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 07 Jan 2005

"Singh" Bhai Sahib wrote: "LOL you have really no idea. If you accept this account you have to also accept that Guru Ji used 5 goats in 1699, that all Sikhs who do not wear a BLUE Keski including Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh, Bhai Jeevan Singh and numerous other great Sikhs in the Panth went around with only 4 Kekkars, that only sex with muslim woman is a kureht and that there was no such ritual as naam dhri. All these are backed by this account if you care to read it, so therefore once again you are picking and choosing what suites you, unless you also accept the above." Bhai you clearly did not read my post. You saw the words "Guru Ki Sakhian" and you immediately jumped to point out the mistakes you have found within this text. You need to thoroughly read this post and my past post before you reply again. Otherwise you will be wasting your time. You are not a historian and you appear to know very little about history. I am showing you an old historical account, to prove to you that "Keski" is mentioned in an old and Praatan text as one of the Kakkars. I will reiterate what I have said - if we take an ALL or NOTHING approach as you do, then please tell me one text, other than Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Bani, you place faith in. I would be greatly suprised if you could find me a Praatan account of 1699 which is more reliable and detailed than Guru Ki Sakhian - because it is the best one we have! If you take old Birs of Guru Ji as 100% can I assume you also accept the Rattan Malla as Bani? If you take the old Birs of Dasam Granth as 100% can I assume you accept all of Sau Sakhi as Bani? Because in this Sau Sakhi there are some interesting comments. eg in Sakhi 8, MuktiNama it says "Do not wear Saffron" (Pauri 10), "Treat all Muslims as a disease" (Pauri 20). Pauri 32 says one who makes friends with a Muslim is an offender of the Guru. Sakhi 65 also has intersting comments such as "do not sit and eat with a Muslim" (Pauri 11) talks about Charan Pahul even after 1699 (Pauri 12) and says Japji and Anand as the morning prayers only, "sometimes less and sometimes more" (Pauri 29), a Brahmin shold organise a shraddh for Sikhs ancestors (Pauri 31), learning Persian is bad (Pauri 34) when some BANI is even written in Persian! Again I could go on and on about this. If you accept this Dasam Granth Gagga appendix, I am assuming you also accept the above (and probably more widely accepted) sections of Sau Sakhi too. Is this the case? Do you honestly think Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrote the above? Anyone with minimal intellect knows Guru did not write this. He condemns Persian when his own Bani is written in Persian? Sure! Guru Ki Sakhian was finished in 1790. Bhai Sarup Singh was NOT present in 1699. He has written how the actual beheading (either of the Panj or the Bakra) happened in a small tent I believe, not openly. So he is guessing at what happened. BTW Nihangs mostly believe in the goat story, perhaps you could ask your Dasam Granth PHD researcher about that. For your information the account itself has been re-written many times and is not the original scrolls used. It has been retranslated into modern louguage and there is no way of verifying what the original scrolls written decades earlier actually said. Your comments on Naam DriRh are interesting. Where does Bhai Sahib say Naam Dridh did not happen? And may I tell you that it is not just the Jatha which do Naam DriRh. Sant Attar Singh, Nihang Baba Mitt Singh, current Nihang Jathas are a few who we know 100% received Naam DriRh. Bhagat Ratnavali (attributed to Bhai Mani Singh) also mentions this. Perhaps you personally have not been blessed with Naam DriRh before. Those who are (tragically) against Naam DriRh often try to cite historical documents but tend to end up discrediting themselves. Let me give you an example: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=9131&t=9053 Regarding adultery with a Muslim woman (or Musali as mentioned in the text) you should read all the old Rehatnamas and learn about the colloqualisms at the time with regards to language. It is quite clear you have not studied any of them. On the contrary, all the older documents tend to match with Guru Ki Sakhian whilst newer ones do not! Perhaps you would like to explain why Bhai Sahib gives the first date of initiation as 1698 rather than 1699. If you had a broad historical knowledge you would probably tell me that during the 18th century (and the 18th century ONLY) a debate occured whereby many people believed the actual date was 1698, and you would be correct. This is just one of the many factors that points Guru Ki Sakhian to be a Praatan text. You appear to be complaining the original Guru Ki Sakhian script does not exist - neither does the original Damdama Bir, or any of the Rehatnama scripts. Even the oldest TanakhahNama script of 1718-19 is a copy of another script. Do you doubt the integrity of your Guru because it has been "copied and rewritten" as you so cleverly put it? Pinds in India where I have heard the Bhatt families still retain copies of scripts, probably including that of Bhatt Vahi Bhadason Paragana Thanesar (in the Bhatakshri script, like a family code) which you can use to cross reference with the evidence I have given which will prove Keski is a Kakkar. "Concerning Dhasm Granth having not spent the last few years of my life travelling to India, and the Biritish museum where old saroops of Dhasm Granth are kept like everyone else here, all I can say that from someone who has, and has seen and studied more puraatan saroops of Dhasm Granth than us all put together the section about the 5ks is found in the oldest and most authentic saroops, interpret that as you will." Bhai Sahib you are ignoring what I am saying. I am asking you for the NAME of your "PHD scholar" (I am assuming he is Kamalroop Singh, perhaps you are not telling me and avoiding the issue because as my previous post has highlighted, it will make your argument fall flat on it's face) I am asking you to give me hard evidence, not hearsay or "please trust me" claims. Give me the name of Saroops which have Dasam Granth in it. Does it appear in the "oldest" Saroop (which I believe dates back to 1696)? I know the very old Delhi Saroop does not have this, and I have been told by many it does not appear in any of the old Birs. Prof Piara Singh Padam who has studied all Rehatnamas in detail has proved it is NOT part of the Dasam Granth. Could you tell me where these Saroops are now, and any evidence they do actually contain the Nishani Sikhi Shabad? How exactly can you be sure what the "Nishani Sikhi" Shabad says, since it is written in Persian, and Guru Ji has told us in Sau Sakhi (part Dasam Granth allegedly) that if you learn Persian you will go to hell? The reason why I am asking you this is because pretty much everyone else takes the Nishani Sikhi Shabad as "attributed" to Bhai Nand Lal and it is only very recently people are claiming it as Dasam Bani. Even if we take it as Bhai Nand Lal's Persian works it does not appear in any of his collections and the language is too modern. Please explain. Thanks for your time.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 07 Jan 2005

Anon Singh. LOL while you try and talk like a historian you cannot accept the facts. I have shown how Guru Kia Sakhia as mentioned is full of things which most sikhs do not acceot as gurmat. However rather than accept this truth you avoid the question, and also the fact that a chunni tachically is a keski anyway. I have already explained how in my opinion the only acceptable Rahat is the Sikh Rehat Maryada. "I am showing you an old historical account, to prove to you that "Keski" is mentioned in an old and Praatan text as one of the Kakkars. " But you seem to forget or avoid the facts that if you accept this account you have to also accept that Guru Ji used 5 goats in 1699, that all Sikhs who do not wear a BLUE Keski including Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh, Bhai Jeevan Singh and numerous other great Sikhs in the Panth went around with only 4 Kekkars. As for the term musli everyone knows it refers to a muslim woman and to argue in those days it did not is loughtable. If it does mean all woman than the account is saying its a kureht to have sex with any woman (including a Gursikh wife), therefor it is exactly what is says, musli ie muslim woman. "Where does Bhai Sahib say Naam Dridh did not happen? " The account goes into details, even of Guru Sahib himself sprinkling Amrit into his own mouth (which contradicts what we know any way, ie that he took Amrit from the 5 Pyarai). If the account is reliable a major thing like naam dhri would have been recorded. Why would he leave out such a major thing, unless of course it did not happen, or the account is unreliable and does not mention the full story. The fact is Naamdhri is not mentioned in any account of 1699, by any person at all. Hence simply accepting your sant with no historical facts is blind faith. If it happened at least one account would mentioned it (if not more), which is simply why it is not included in the SIkh Rehat Maryada. I am not against naam dhri but there is NO EVIDENCE for it happening at all. The fact is that the account has been rewritten and is not even in the original louguage, the only thing we have is what was lyeing in a sants dhera for decades, and even that was re-written once found. The account itself is not a first hand accounts but a rewrite of the old scrolls, which is unique to this account unlike other rehatnamahs, which although have been re-written and are not the original themselves were not initially created by rewriting and translating scrolls which do not exist to check against. Hence the account you mention is rather unique in being unchecked and altered, and being a recreation of old scrolls who no one can check against. It's true that controvery's exist over all historical text, ultimatly anyone who beleives in a single account is fooling themsleves, hence the reasion for the SIkh Rehat Maryada. "Bhai Sahib you are ignoring what I am saying. I am asking you for the NAME of your "PHD scholar" (I am assuming he is Kamalroop Singh, perhaps you are not telling me and avoiding the issue because as my previous post has highlighted, it will make your argument fall flat on it's face)" How exactly will my arguments fall flat on it's face depending on who the phd student is. I am not asking you to beleive me. If it is Kamalroop Singh how exactly is his research floored, and unreliable? Has he not put in years of study on Dhasm Grath etc to phd level, exactly how does this affect things? Also will this change the fact that a Keski includes a chunni anyway, no it will not. In an older post a Bibi who could not wear a keski was adviced to wrap it around her waist instead as its important to have it on your "ang", lol. "Prof Piara Singh Padam who has studied all Rehatnamas in detail has proved it is NOT part of the Dasam Granth" I have never heard of the above, I have not read him saying its fake anywhere on the contrary he mentions it in his book.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Mkhalsa · 07 Jan 2005

I have not read teh whole discussion, but the last few posts. Yes keski should be blue, kashera should be white, kanga should be wooden, kirpan and kara should be sarbloh. Does this mean that people that have a slightly purple kashera (guilty) or people that wear a kanga made of plastic (which is wrong) are not sikhs or are not wearing a kakkar? no. perhaps they do not know any better or do not have an alternative (or in my case, do not have strong enough bleach). Just because someone does not wear a blue keski does not mean they do not/did not keep keski as a kakkar, it just means they did not have all the material available to them to know that it should be blue.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 07 Jan 2005

Bhai Sahib you are not reading my posts so I will phrase them more succintly. You have yet again not read anything I have said in regards to Sau Sakhi or historical sources. * Your argument: Guru Ki Sakhian is a flawed historical source because it contains some aspects that do not tally with your modern maryada. * My argument: Every historical source has information that does not tally. I am challenging you to find a better source that Guru Ki Sakhian for the description of 1699 and you are unable to. I do not "accept" Guru Ki Sakhian in it's entirety. The only thing I "accept" in it's entirety is Gurbani. * Your Little Challenge: Please find me a source on Rehat more than 100 years old which you personally agree on *EVERYTHING* in, that is longer that 2 lines ;) * NaamdriRh is not mentioned in the account of 1699 because the method is GUPT. It was not done publicly on stage. How can you describe something in an account that you did not see. Just as the Panj Pyare/Bakra were "GUPTLY" beheaded in the tent. NaamdriRh is still kept GUPT today just as it was. Bhagat Ratnavali gives evidence for it. It is also implied throughout various Rehatnamas subtly and even Bhai Gurdas's Varan. Read these yourself. * Guru Ki Sakhian is indeed an amalgamation of Bhatt Vahis. Bhatt Vahi scrolls still exist today with their families. Guru Ki Sakhian was completed in 1790. Bhai Sarup Singh's work in Bhatakshri was translated into Gurmukhi in 1869 by his descendant Bhai Chajju Singh. This is the work that Giani Garja Singh used. If you do not trust Piara Singh Padam then you may find the remaining manuscript copy in Department of Punjab Historical Studies at Punjab University in Patiala. * You talk about the "Sikh Rehat Maryada" yet this Rehat Maryada was based on the very sources that you are against! It is based upon "Rehatnamas" and other historical documents in addition to Gurbani. In Gurmat Martand by Kahan Singh Nabha these are listed as documents such as Prem Surag, Chaupa Singh, Daya Singh, Desa Singh Rehatnamas, Panth Parkash, etc. If you would like me to quote anti-Gurmat articles from each of the above sources I happily will. * You are in part admitting that Kamalroop Singh is your "PHD researcher". Kamalroop Singh follows Nihang Maryada not your Sikh Rehat Maryada. Nihangs do not even beleive in the Panj Kakkars they believe in the Treh Mudreh. Furthermore on the aforemented Nihang website, both my above sources - both Bhatt Vahi Bhadason Paragana Thanesar and Guru Ki Sakhian are quoted as reliable sources. So again there are contradictions in what you are saying. * Your argument: The Bhatt Vahis are unauthentic, Manmat sources which should not be trusted. You say, If you accept one thing from them you must accept it all. * My argument: You do not accept the Bhatt Vahis as authentic, but the dates for Gurpurbs were edited by the "Sikh Panth" using this very text due to it's reliability! The Nanakshahi Calendar, which I am sure you believe since you follow the Sikh Maryada of Akal Takht/SGPC, bases itself partly upon the texts you are attempting to criticise. Most importantly: * Your argument: Nishani Sikhi Shabad is Dasam Bani since my anonymous research scholar says so. However I cannot give you specifics on names of saroops. * My argument: If you accept the Nishani Sikhi Shabad as Dasam Bani you must also accept the Sau Sakhi. Sau Sakhi, as I have already said, contains anti Gurmat elements such as hatred against Muslims which cannot possibly be the words of Guru Ji. Furthermore Sau Sakhi tells us it is a huge Paap to learn how to speak Persian - the very language your Nishani Sikhi Shabad is written in!!! Why not ask your PHD scholar whether or not Sau Sakhi is Dasam Bani too? You may be in for a shock ;) And if you couldn't be bothered to read all that just read this: So in conclusion, my dear "Singh", it is actually you who is being inconsistent with what you accept and reject. You accept the "Sikh Rehat Maryada" which is based upon the very sources you criticise. You reject the "Bhatt Vahis" which has been used for the Nanakshahi Calendar which technically you should follow. You reject the Sau Sakhi (I am assuming) but you accept the Nishani Sikhi Shabad. PS - Son, writing "lol" or "LOL" in your posts does not make them any more convincing. Please attempt to make some new points next time rather than rehashing the same thing.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 07 Jan 2005

1 more additional point - with regards to Piara Singh Padams stance on Nishani Sikhi Shabad, in his book "Rehatnamae", this Shabad was found on a piece of paper inbetween two pages of a Bir of Dasam Granth, unbound to the book serving as a "marker" in the Bir. He tells us how it is a 19th century composition by a Persian poet. You can find this on p35 to p36 of his book.

Re: kes the kakaar?

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 08 Jan 2005

What is Treh Mudreh?

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 10 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Anon SIngh You keep on suggesting that I do not read your posts, but I do which is how I reply. It seems that this appears to be the only thing you keep repeating although I have in each case read your posts, which has led me to reply. For instance you argue in favour of the Bhatt Vahi for Keski, and in kind I have shown how this is largely manipulated etc, hence I have/do read your posts so please get off the you have not read my posts BS for a second. Any way "* My argument: Every historical source has information that does not tally. I am challenging you to find a better source that Guru Ki Sakhian for the description of 1699 and you are unable to. I do not "accept" Guru Ki Sakhian in it's entirety. The only thing I "accept" in it's entirety is Gurbani. " I have in no way argued I know of a better source, simply that Guru Kia Sakhian is not entirely reliable, and that in is a second hand historical source. Unlike other sources it has been translated away from its original Bhatt language, and re-written since. It is not even a primary source and is a re-write of old missing scrolls of a different language. Therefore like you I would not accept Guru Kia Sakhian as a reliable source, and as you know there is no 100% reliable account, however Guru Kia Sakhia is unique as being re-written away from the original language, and itself being a re-write of scrolls. "Your Little Challenge: Please find me a source on Rehat more than 100 years old which you personally agree on *EVERYTHING* in, that is longer that 2 lines ;)" LOL it appears now that you have not read my posts, or think its best to ignore points. As I have said before anyone who thinks a single source is 100% reliable is fooling themselves, therefor I have already answered your so called challenge before you raised the question. Like I have said the ONLY reliable Rehat is the SIKH REHAT MARYADA made and confirmed by the Guru Panth, using Gurbani and all historical sources of the time. "* You talk about the "Sikh Rehat Maryada" yet this Rehat Maryada was based on the very sources that you are against! It is based upon "Rehatnamas" and other historical documents in addition to Gurbani. In Gurmat Martand by Kahan Singh Nabha these are listed as documents such as Prem Surag, Chaupa Singh, Daya Singh, Desa Singh Rehatnamas, Panth Parkash, etc. If you would like me to quote anti-Gurmat articles from each of the above sources I happily will." Once again your stupidity is astounding. The SIkh Rehat MAryada took all available accounts etc into consideration, and from that with Gurbani formulated the Sikh Rehat Maryada. The anti-Gurmat inputs were simply not included after discussion and consideration. You obviously cannot see the beauty of the SIkh Rehat Maryada, how it used all existing accounts and from that extracted the SIkh Rehat Maryada with the aid of Gurbani and scholars in the Panth which we have not seen the likes of since. "* You are in part admitting that Kamalroop Singh is your "PHD researcher". Kamalroop Singh follows Nihang Maryada not your Sikh Rehat Maryada. Nihangs do not even beleive in the Panj Kakkars they believe in the Treh Mudreh. Furthermore on the aforemented Nihang website, both my above sources - both Bhatt Vahi Bhadason Paragana Thanesar and Guru Ki Sakhian are quoted as reliable sources. So again there are contradictions in what you are saying." The nihang webiste is made by Jagdeep Singh from Houslow, and not with the contribution of your named person in the first instance. Secondly any individuals rehat is there own business, I’m simply pointing out the fact that a person who has spent years doing a phd in Dhasm Bani agrees that the extract is in the older and most genuine Granths. His own rehat is has nothing to do with the issue, only his research. "* My argument: You do not accept the Bhatt Vahis as authentic, but the dates for Gurpurbs were edited by the "Sikh Panth" using this very text due to it's reliability!" Proves once again you know very little. The Nanakshahi Calendar used a number of sources, just like in all research everything available is taken into account. "* My argument: If you accept the Nishani Sikhi Shabad as Dasam Bani you must also accept the Sau Sakhi. Sau Sakhi, as I have already said, contains anti Gurmat elements such as hatred against Muslims which cannot possibly be the words of Guru Ji. Furthermore Sau Sakhi tells us it is a huge Paap to learn how to speak Persian - the very language your Nishani Sikhi Shabad is written in!!! Why not ask your PHD scholar whether or not Sau Sakhi is Dasam Bani too? You may be in for a shock ;)" LOL. Do you really think that just because Dhasm Granth has Bani's in it which are in line with Gurmat and obviously from Guru Sahib that we have to accept sections which are arguably blatantly not. Let me ask you, do you accept Jaap Sahib, Chapai Sahib, Tav Prasad Sweyai, Akal Ustat which are all from Dhasm Bani. If so do you also accept Sau Sakhi etc?? The section about 5 ks is not against Gurmat in anyway, therefor it cannot be ruled out as being from Guru Sahib, unlike things which are. "* Guru Ki Sakhian is indeed an amalgamation of Bhatt Vahis. Bhatt Vahi scrolls still exist today with their families. Guru Ki Sakhian was completed in 1790. Bhai Sarup Singh's work in Bhatakshri was translated into Gurmukhi in 1869 by his descendant Bhai Chajju Singh. This is the work that Giani Garja Singh used. If you do not trust Piara Singh Padam then you may find the remaining manuscript copy in Department of Punjab Historical Studies at Punjab University in Patiala." Perhaps you have now taken to lying as the scrolls used by Sarup Singh DO NOT EXIST today. Get your facts right the scrolls which the account is based on does not exist, although the account which you accept was written from them almost 100 years later. It was further translated away from it original language which is quite unique into Gurmukhi, an ideal time for mistakes and changes to be made. If I remember correctly a written copy version of this and not even Sarup things original was what Garja Singh used anyway. "* NaamdriRh is not mentioned in the account of 1699 because the method is GUPT. It was not done publicly on stage. How can you describe something in an account that you did not see. Just as the Panj Pyare/Bakra were "GUPTLY" beheaded in the tent. NaamdriRh is still kept GUPT today just as it was. Bhagat Ratnavali gives evidence for it. " LOL once again you are fooling yourself. What else was Gupt, anything can be argued as being gupt which justifies why it has never been mentioned in history. Strange how not a single account exists which talks of Naam Drhi but you can always hide behind it being gupt, just like Guru Ji did this and that but when questioned oh yeah it was done secretly. Don't you know that only the method of naam Dhri is gupt, not the actual giving idea. The method of doing "it" apparently cannot be passed on, but it existing is no secret, not now and not in 1699. Therefor if it was done even if the method is gupt it still would have been mentioned, why has not a single account done this? Probably because it never happened, which also makes sense as no mainstream group in the Panth do it. Let me now ask you. Do you accept taking into account the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh that Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh Ji and many other great Gursikhs only kept 4 of the k's as they did not keep blue keski's. How did they reach us high avestha's with only 4 k's and not the full khalsa rehat. If all you need is 4 k's why not go down to 3 or just the kera. I trust you now accept that the term musli refers to Muslim Woman. I take it than you accept that only sexual relations with Muslim woman is a kureht according to this account. As if you still can't even see that Musli refers to Muslim woman but still argue it means all woman in general than you must accept that this account is saying sikhs should be celibate, although the Guru's themselves were not. Do you also agree now that 5 goats were used. Or are you going to try and argue that the respected and genuine Bhatt Vahi is saying that Guru Ji kept 5 goats as pets in the tent. Intersting how you seem to put all your attention into a small detail as a blue keski, but avoid the fact that this account does not even mention Guru Ji taking Amrit from the 5 Pyarai. Why pick a little bit, and miss how its obviously not complete as it does not speak of a major incident of 1699. Further to the above points you have not even touched on the point that if FOR ARGUMENTS SAKE keski is the kekar, technically there is no problem as even woman who use cloth openly to cover their head have a keksi. Just like a kirpan strill being such despite it being kept around the body in a gatra or on the waist in a kamalkesa, likewise cloth wrapped on the head, or drapped is still the same thing. If not why not, with refernce to facts and Guru Ji rather than hearsay. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Amarjeet Singh · 10 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf u are not so bright, if some walks around with a bag with the 5k's in it would u say that person is wearing the 5k's? NO. furthermore a chuni cannot be worn as a keskhi as a keskhi is normally longer and thicker. The kheski has to be tied around the head just as kara has to be worn on the wirst, but if i put my kara in my bag although i am not wearing on of the 5 k's it doesnt make it any less of a kara. SO CUD U PLZ STOP BRINGIN UP THIS DUMB ARGUMENT OF A CHUNI vjkk vjkf

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 10 Jan 2005

Hello Youngun. Few points: Guru Ki Sakhian is not a contemporary source. But no other contemporary sources say what the Kakkar is (other than Bhatt Vahi which I have quoted, which says KESKI). The only other contemporary source I can think of is Sri Gur Sobha (doesnt mention Kakkars) You have admitted you cannot find a more reliable source than Guru Ki Sakhian, yet you believe because a few scholars got together and formulated a Rehat (which Nihangs, Taksal, AKJ, Nanaksar, etc ALL disagree(d) with) from a vast majority of historical sources which are less reliable than Guru Ki Sakhian (by your own admission) you take it as the word of God. Yet you are only able to quote a single source that says "Kesh" which I have shown is not Bani. Ref - previous post re Piara Singh Padam. Bhatt Vahis is clearly reliable since the "Guru Panth" scholars took it into account when making the Nanakshahi Calendar. Please state what other sources they also used when making this calendar. Sau Sakhi is in all the Praatan Birs that your Nishani Sikhi Shabad appears in (and to be honest I doubt if it appears in any, you still have given NO evidence) and all you can say is "WELL ITS NOT GURMAT". I can easily argue Kesh as a Kakkar is "not Gurmat" since there is NO evidence for it before 1883. The copies of Guru Ki Sakhian Garja Singh used are in the previously mentioned place. Go check it out yourself if you don't believe me - Reference - WH McLeods Rehat Book, Piara Singh Padams Book (who has studied these sources, esp Chaupa Singh Rehatnama). And the Bhatt Vahi scripts still exist with the families - I have read this in a (non Keski) related essay and I will try to find you the pind names. Do not confuse Guru Ki Sakhian with Bhatt Vahis. References for Naam Dridh - Bhagat Ratnavali, Sant Teja Singhs book (quoting MANY Praatan sources), Bhai Gurdas's Bani implied in. Plz note AKJ is not the only Jatha which gives Naam Dridh. Also Nihangs today and of past (Ref - Baba Mitt Singh) You say "the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh " Do not confuse yourself there is no such thing. There are 2 things - Praatan Bhatt Vahi accounts - which state Keski is a Kakkar (and are used for Nanakshahi Calendar) and Guru Ki Sakhian based upon them. I use them to prove that the concept of Keski as a Kakkar has been around for much longer than the concept of Kesh (finally formulated in 1883). I do not care about Muslim women or Goats. I see much more Manmat in every other historical source. If you claim it is unreliable because the original does not remain, you must also claim our Guru Ji to be "unreliable" since the original Damdama Bir does not remain either. Are you doubting my Guru also? Please clear up this confusion! WE DO NOT HAVE THE ORIGINAL SCRIPTS OF ANY REHAT MATERIAL!!! WHY CAN YOU NOT UNDERSTAND THIS YOUNG MAN! Just as the SGPC scholars have used their Bibek Buddhi to discriminate the Gurmat from Manmat in old sources, I am doing the same with Guru Ki Sakhian. The mentions of Muslim women and Goats only strengthen its claim as a late 18th century source - read other sources from that time and you will see what I mean. You are telling me Guru Ki Sakhian has been rewritten with new times, why does it have so many features within it that are particular only to a late 18th century source. Read around the subject a bit (helpful hint: reading around does not count as reading the SGPC Maryada or SGPC website) Unfortunately Bhai Sahib if you do not take the above on board you will have to agree to disagree. You have unshakeable faith in this SGPC Maryada which promotes meat and 3 Banis in the morning. Meat is BANNED in Guru Hargobinds Hukamnama (Ref: Ganda Singh Hukamnamae) I do not see a few scholars as my Guru (please give evidence the entire Guru Panth approved SGPC Maryada) as enough. The SGPC Maryada is based on historical souces. And NONE of these say Kesh is a Kakkar. Full stop. In the early 1900s Nishani Sikhi Shabad was seen as Bhai Nand Lals work not Dasam Bani. In a way I respect you for this unshakable faith. In another way I feel sorry you are not able to break out of your mindset and realise that the scholars who formulated the SGPC Maryada have used sources which are available to you. This debate will not go anywhere unless you prove to me Nishani Sikhi Shabad is Bani - this is all you are basing your argument on. And as I have said numerous times, "THE SIKH MARYADA SAYS SO" and "MY PHD SCHOLAR SAYS SO" is not acceptable in a formal discussion. Women must wear a Jurra also with their Keski not just Keski as Chunni. Ref - JD Cunningham History of the Sikhs - he saw Sikh women himself and said they had a topknot on their head to distinguish them from Hindus. I look forward to hearing from you again after you have done your homework. PS Please no Krodh here with comments such as "your stupidity". Why be mean?

Re: kes the kakaar?

jagmeet singh · 11 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Iam not a giani nor a scholar but what from my knowledge is that Guru sahib told us that the keshs are Guru ki Mohar, and to preserve them Guru sahib made it mandatory to keep them by including in one of the bajjar kurehats not to cut them. So if cutting kesh is a bajjar kurehat then why to add kesh as one of the kakkars, this isnt a dual thing. So to keep them safe a sikh has to wear a keski. This principle holds same for both brothers and sisters. So keski is a kakkar thats why AKJ includes it as a kakkar and rest of the sikhs should agree with this. Bhullan chukan di maafi Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 11 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Thank you for once again avoiding to answer my points, never mind I guess you have yourself failed to read my posts. I take it hypocrisy is another feature of yours, “PS Please no Krodh here with comments such as "your stupidity". Why be mean? While you continue to call ma a boy, strange, never mind. “The copies of Guru Ki Sakhian Garja Singh used are in the previously mentioned place. “ I am not getting the Bhatt Vahi’s as a whole and the account by Sarup Singh written in 1780 mixed up as you imply. The account of 1780 which was based on scrolls written in a different lounguage does not exist today, accept this simple FACT. Perhaps you need to do your home work and read the recent Sikh Review article on the Bhatt Vahi’s which specifies how the scroll from which this Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh was created years after 1699 no longer exist, infact the only versions we have and you are referring to are further re-writes not the Scrolls. “Bhatt Vahis is clearly reliable since the "Guru Panth" scholars took it into account when making the Nanakshahi Calendar.” The Guru Panth did not single mindadly use the account you mention, and keep on implying as being the only source. Just because this was one document used it does not make it completely reliable simply based on that. The Guru Panth also took into account the Nishaani section when discussing and deliberating over the Sikh Rehat Maryada, are you now claiming that just because it was one of the sources discussed and used that it is now geniune in the same way. Can't you see you see your futile argument . Just becouse the Sarup Singh account was an account used does not make it 100% reliable, unless you are now willing to accept the Nishaani section, or just contradict yourself. “References for Naam Dridh - Bhagat Ratnavali, Sant Teja Singhs book (quoting MANY Praatan sources), Bhai Gurdas's Bani implied in. Plz note AKJ is not the only Jatha which gives Naam Dridh. Also Nihangs today and of past (Ref - Baba Mitt Singh)” LOL, Bhagat Ratnavali DOES NOT reveal that NaamDri occurred in 1699, you are now trying to grab any source, as none exists. Which Sant Teja Singh’s book are you referring to, as none which I have read ever state the giving of Naamdrhi as given by akj was a part of 1699 (BTW Sant Teja Singh was one of the scholars involved in the Sikh Rehat Maryada, so why use him if you seemingly have no faith in it). It is only Jatha which gives naamdhri, no other groups do it so don’t kid yourself. Baba Mit Singh may have had it as you claim with no evidence but than again Bhai Randhir Singh didn’t, which shows it was not a major feature even in his time. “If you claim it is unreliable because the original does not remain, you must also claim our Guru Ji to be "unreliable" since the original Damdama Bir does not remain either. Are you doubting my Guru also?” I am not doubting your Guru, as he is also my Guru. The comparison with Guru Granth Sahib Ji and the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh CAN NOT be made. Was the Guru Granth Sahib Ji originally written in a secretive language which only a hand full of Bhatts knew and than translated from an un-checkable scroll. NO it wasn’t. Was the Guru Granth Sahib Ji left for years unchecked in a sants dhera away from the Sangat, and when found re-written. NO it wasn’t. Was the Guru Granth Sahib written nearly 100 years after the Guru, No it wasn’t. We may not have the original Guru Granth Sahib Ji, but what we do have is clearly more reliable than the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh. I suggest you read Guru Granth Sahib Ji and if you still feel it is not genuine and are not satisfied stop calling yourself a Singh, especially when you clearly think you can get to become an excellent Singh like Bhai Randhir Singh with only 4 kekkars. As for you Sikh Rehat Maryada bashing rather than have to repeat myself for the likes of you, please read this thread http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=20765&t=20235#reply_20765 “Women must wear a Jurra also with their Keski not just Keski as Chunni . Ref - JD Cunningham History of the Sikhs “ Appears that just giving references is all you know, without having read them yourself. What Cunningham says is "chiefly by a higher topknot of hair." I am sorry but Keski does not even appear here, so what are you talking about. Does having a higher top knot of hair ie a joora now also tranlsate as Keski. The fact is that the Keski which you beleive in also can be a chunni and vice versa, and arguing that it sould be tied on the head in this way or the other without any FACTS or Guru Ji's bechans is just like saying its a sin and wrong to wear a kirpan in a kemelkesa around your waist rather than in a gatra around your body. In Amrajit Singh's own words "put my kara in my bag although i am not wearing on of the 5 k's it doesnt make it any less of a kara", likewise a cloth used to tie on the head is a keski, and in the same way drapped on the head much like a chunni has not stopped being a keski, so we all have Keski's anyway. Or does it now always have to be on the head in a certain way, just keep u turning. I look forward to hearing from you again after you have done your homework. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 11 Jan 2005

"I am not getting the Bhatt Vahi’s as a whole and the account by Sarup Singh written in 1780 mixed up as you imply. The account of 1780 which was based on scrolls written in a different lounguage does not exist today, accept this simple FACT." You are mixed up. There is no text written in 1780. There is a text written in 1790. Guru Ki Sakhian was written during the 18th century. It is a reflection of Sikhi of the 18th century as such. What is this different language you talk of? I am interested. I am aware of a different Bhattchakri script but no of particular language. I have already told you what remains. Chajju Singh Kaushish transliterated Sarup Singhs work into Gurmukhi from it's original script in 1869. A copy of this was used by Garja Singh who has now passed away and the copy remains in the previously mentioned University Library. The fact that the work remained within the family and in essentially a cryptic script (whilst containing ALL the hallmarks of an 18th century text) as I have said makes it more reliable. ALL historical sources are copies of copies of copies - so "ITS COPIED TOO MANY TIMES" is not a valid argument! Having read the Sikh Chronicle section (and I am under the impression this is all you actually know about the Bhatts and Guru Ki Sakhian) I have found they seem to have nothing but PRAISE for Guru Ki Sakhian. http://www.sikhreview.org/april2001/chronicle1.htm It seems the author has admitted Guru Ki Sakhian as the first one to mention the 5 Ks. Why did they forget about the Nishani Sikhi Shabad? I am reffering of course to Sant Teja Singhs book on Sant Attar Singh. Please have a good read of it and return with your results. And have you read Bhagat Ratnavali? Within trying to offend you I get the impression you are not particularly well rounded on the subject of Rehat. Sections of Buddha Dal still give Naam Dridh today. I know this for a fact. Why do you not go to India yourself and Pesh, you will have a first hand experience then :) If you are convinced Guru Ki Sakhian is unreliable please provide an alternative. It is the BEST history we have full stop. No other historical accounts remain in their original form. I believe TanakhahNama dates back to 1718 as our earliest source, but this does not mention the 5 Ks anywhere. Again I ask you, find me a better source than Guru Ki Sakhian. I have never sugested Cunningham's account proves Keski is a Kakkar. But it does prove women previously wore their Jurra ontop of their head - they cannot have it loose with just a Chunni to cover it. 1. You still have not shown me how Nishani Sikhi is a Praatan Source. So far all your posts have had absolutely no factual content, rather just anger filled circular arguments relating to nitpicking on old Historical sources. Please prove it is Praatan with facts. 2. You need to refute Piara Singh Padams comments on Nishani Sikhi. I have already given you the page reference from his book. If you are going solely on the word of your PHD researcher you must also accept his other beliefs on Sau Sakhi which squarely contradicts your Nishani Sikhi Shabad and is far more widely regarded as authentic. Please refute the authenticity of Sau Sakhi if you wish to take Nishani Sikhi as Bani. 3. Please also state what other sources were used for Nanakshahi Calendar, and why you consider the original Bhatt Vahi scripts (as quoted in Padams Book again) as unreliable also. 4. If you accept the Sikh Rehat Maryada as true how do you reconcile this with the fact that is contradicts Guru Hargobinds Hukamnama on Meat and Bhagat Kabeers Bani on Meat. Do not expect a reply if you have not addressed the above 4 points with hard evidence. Moaning about copies of Kaushish's work does not refute Keski and prove Kes. This is the subject of discussion. And do not reply if you cannot either - you will be wasting your time!

Re: kes the kakaar?

Kulbir Singh · 11 Jan 2005

"Singh" and "Anon Singh" have been doing excellent discussion here and I think this thread is one of the best threads on Keski Kakaar issue. I personally think that veer Anon Singh has made some excellent points that are hard to refute. I request "Singh" jee to not try to discredit Bhatt Vahees as unreliable source because they are not. Great deal of history is written in these Bhatt Vahees and if anything, a Bhatt had no motive in misstating Keski as a Kakaar instead of Kesh. If anything Keski provides chardi kala to Panth. We should not be suspicious of such reliable sources just to prove a little point. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Search For Tat · 11 Jan 2005

I have heard these conversations many times. I am now completely in favour of keski. I am now so used to wearing a keski, I would feel naked without it. Those who do not believe it keski: 1) do you go to sleep with kesh uncovered? 2) do you tie a thin strip of cloth, ribbon like underneath your dastaar? 3) How do you ensure your kanga does not fall out, when not wearing a keski? 4) Do you think bibian look more like Khalsa in a keski/dastaar? 5) How is wearing a keski a threat to sikhism? 6) If we all supposed to cover our hair at all times, this is only done with a keski?

Re: kes the kakaar?

Harpartap Singh · 12 Jan 2005

VahegurujikaKhalsa, vahegurujikiFateh! Just a correction of fact: Buddha Dal DOES believe in Panj Kakkaar rehat and that they consist of: 1. Kes 2. Karha 3. Kanga 4. Kacchera 5. Kirpaan I am not connected with the Buddha Dal but have in front of me a Rehatnama from them... A Benti to the Sangat, watch your language please. Referring to all Nihnags in derogatory terms benefits no one. If you do not have facts to substantiate statements about Panthic Jathebandhi's, please do not make them... If making reference to Nidar's Jatha, please be clear about this. Bhul Chuk Maaf karni

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 12 Jan 2005

Anon Singh it appears that while I keep answering your questions you continue to avoid my'yne. Let me copy and past a few sections which you have decided to overlook, although I have specified them again and again. *Do you accept taking into account the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh that Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh Ji and many other great Gursikhs only kept 4 of the k's as they did not keep blue keski's. How did they reach us high avestha's with only 4 k's and not the full khalsa rehat. If all you need is 4 k's why not go down to 3 or just the kera. *I trust you now accept that the term musli refers to Muslim Woman. I take it than you accept that only sexual relations with Muslim woman is a kureht according to this account. As if you still can't even see that Musli refers to Muslim woman but still argue it means all woman in general than you must accept that this account is saying sikhs should be celibate, although the Guru's themselves were not. With regard to the Nishani shabad as mentioned again I am not asking you to accept it as true. When it was quoted here I merely mentioned it, which is what you have grabbed hold of, and can not get over. Don’t accept it if you want. As for the Guru Hargobind Hukamhnama I suggest you search on this very site, where I have posted questions about its being genuine. Please do this first rather than making me repeat myself for you benefit. The shabad from Bhagat Kabir Ji is always being taken out of context, or do you also believe that those who eat rotti with butter on it are going to suffer pains. Read your bani first; slok mÚ 1 ] (1289-11) salok mehlaa 1. Shalok, First Mehl: pihlW mwshu inMimAw mwsY AMdir vwsu ] (1289-11, mlwr, mÚ 1) pahilaaN maasahu nimmi-aa maasai andar vaas. First, the mortal is conceived in the flesh, and then he dwells in the flesh. jIau pwie mwsu muih imilAw hfu cMmu qnu mwsu ] (1289-12, mlwr, mÚ 1) jee-o paa-ay maas muhi mili-aa had chamm tan maas. When he comes alive, his mouth takes flesh; his bones, skin and body are flesh. mwshu bwhir kiFAw mMmw mwsu igrwsu ] (1289-12, mlwr, mÚ 1) maasahu baahar kadhi-aa mammaa maas giraas. He comes out of the womb of flesh, and takes a mouthful of flesh at the breast. muhu mwsY kw jIB mwsY kI mwsY AMdir swsu ] (1289-13, mlwr, mÚ 1) muhu maasai kaa jeebh maasai kee maasai andar saas. His mouth is flesh, his tongue is flesh; his breath is in the flesh. vfw hoAw vIAwihAw Gir lY AwieAw mwsu ] (1289-13, mlwr, mÚ 1) vadaa ho-aa vee-aahi-aa ghar lai aa-i-aa maas. He grows up and is married, and brings his wife of flesh into his home. mwshu hI mwsu aUpjY mwshu sBo swku ] (1289-14, mlwr, mÚ 1) maasahu hee maas oopjai maasahu sabho saak. Flesh is produced from flesh; all relatives are made of flesh. siqguir imilAY hukmu buJIAY qW ko AwvY rwis ] (1289-14, mlwr, mÚ 1) satgur mili-ai hukam bujhee-ai taaN ko aavai raas. When the mortal meets the True Guru, and realizes the Hukam of the Lord's Command, then he comes to be reformed. Awip Cuty nh CUtIAY nwnk bcin ibxwsu ]1] (1289-15, mlwr, mÚ 1) aap chhutay nah chhootee-ai naanak bachan binaas. ||1|| Releasing himself, the mortal does not find release; O Nanak, through empty words, one is ruined. ||1|| mÚ 1 ] (1289-15) mehlaa 1. First Mehl: mwsu mwsu kir mUrKu JgVy igAwnu iDAwnu nhI jwxY ] (1289-15, mlwr, mÚ 1) maas maas kar moorakh jhagrhay gi-aan Dhi-aan nahee jaanai. The fools argue about flesh and meat, but they know nothing about meditation and spiritual wisdom. kauxu mwsu kauxu swgu khwvY iksu mih pwp smwxy ] (1289-16, mlwr, mÚ 1) ka-un maas ka-un saag kahaavai kis meh paap samaanay. What is called meat, and what is called green vegetables? What leads to sin? gYNfw mwir hom jg kIey dyviqAw kI bwxy ] (1289-17, mlwr, mÚ 1) gaiNdaa maar hom jag kee-ay dayviti-aa kee baanay. It was the habit of the gods to kill the rhinoceros, and make a feast of the burnt offering. mwsu Coif bYis nku pkVih rwqI mwxs Kwxy ] (1289-17, mlwr, mÚ 1) maas chhod bais nak pakrheh raatee maanas khaanay. Those who renounce meat, and hold their noses when sitting near it, devour men at night. PVu kir lokW no idKlwvih igAwnu iDAwnu nhI sUJY ] (1289-17, mlwr, mÚ 1) farh kar lokaaN no dikhlaavahi gi-aan Dhi-aan nahee soojhai. They practice hypocrisy, and make a show before other people, but they do not understand anything about meditation or spiritual wisdom. nwnk AMDy isau ikAw khIAY khY n kihAw bUJY ] (1289-18, mlwr, mÚ 1) naanak anDhay si-o ki-aa kahee-ai kahai na kahi-aa boojhai. O Nanak, what can be said to the blind people? They cannot answer, or even understand what is said. AMDw soie ij AMDu kmwvY iqsu irdY is locn nwhI ] (1289-19, mlwr, mÚ 1) anDhaa so-ay je anDh kamaavai tis ridai se lochan naahee. They alone are blind, who act blindly. They have no eyes in their hearts. mwq ipqw kI rkqu inpMny mCI mwsu n KWhI ] (1289-19, mlwr, mÚ 1) maat pitaa kee rakat nipannay machhee maas na khaaNhee. They are produced from the blood of their mothers and fathers, but they do not eat fish or meat. Sri Guru Granth Sahib page 1290 iesqRI purKY jW inis mylw EQY mMDu kmwhI ] (1290-1, mlwr, mÚ 1) istaree purkhai jaaN nis maylaa othai manDh kamaahee. But when men and women meet in the night, they come together in the flesh. mwshu inMmy mwshu jMmy hm mwsY ky BWfy ] (1290-1, mlwr, mÚ 1) maasahu nimmay maasahu jammay ham maasai kay bhaaNday. In the flesh we are conceived, and in the flesh we are born; we are vessels of flesh. igAwnu iDAwnu kCu sUJY nwhI cquru khwvY pWfy ] (1290-2, mlwr, mÚ 1) gi-aan Dhi-aan kachh soojhai naahee chatur kahaavai paaNday. You know nothing of spiritual wisdom and meditation, even though you call yourself clever, O religious scholar. bwhr kw mwsu mMdw suAwmI Gr kw mwsu cMgyrw ] (1290-2, mlwr, mÚ 1) baahar kaa maas mandaa su-aamee ghar kaa maas changayraa. O master, you believe that flesh on the outside is bad, but the flesh of those in your own home is good. jIA jMq siB mwshu hoey jIie lieAw vwsyrw ] (1290-3, mlwr, mÚ 1) jee-a jant sabh maasahu ho-ay jee-ay la-i-aa vaasayraa. All beings and creatures are flesh; the soul has taken up its home in the flesh. ABKu BKih BKu qij Cofih AMDu gurU ijn kyrw ] (1290-3, mlwr, mÚ 1) abhakhbhakheh bhakhtaj chhodeh anDh guroo jin kayraa. They eat the uneatable; they reject and abandon what they could eat. They have a teacher who is blind. mwshu inMmy mwshu jMmy hm mwsY ky BWfy ] (1290-4, mlwr, mÚ 1) maasahu nimmay maasahu jammay ham maasai kay bhaaNday. In the flesh we are conceived, and in the flesh we are born; we are vessels of flesh. igAwnu iDAwnu kCu sUJY nwhI cquru khwvY pWfy ] (1290-4, mlwr, mÚ 1) gi-aan Dhi-aan kachh soojhai naahee chatur kahaavai paaNday. You know nothing of spiritual wisdom and meditation, even though you call yourself clever, O religious scholar. mwsu purwxI mwsu kqybˆØI chu juig mwsu kmwxw ] (1290-4, mlwr, mÚ 1) maas puraanee maas kaytaabeeN chahu jug maas kamaanaa. Meat is allowed in the Puraanas, meat is allowed in the Bible and the Koran. Throughout the four ages, meat has been used. jij kwij vIAwih suhwvY EQY mwsu smwxw ] (1290-5, mlwr, mÚ 1) jaj kaaj vee-aahi suhaavai othai maas samaanaa. It is featured in sacred feasts and marriage festivities; meat is used in them. iesqRI purK inpjih mwshu pwiqswh sulqwnW ] (1290-5, mlwr, mÚ 1) istaree purakh nipjahi maasahu paatisaah sultaanaaN. Women, men, kings and emperors originate from meat. jy Eie idsih nrik jWdy qW aun@ kw dwnu n lYxw ] (1290-6, mlwr, mÚ 1) jay o-ay diseh narak jaaNday taaN unH kaa daan na lainaa. If you see them going to hell, then do not accept charitable gifts from them. dyNdw nrik surig lYdy dyKhu eyhu iD|wxw ] (1290-7, mlwr, mÚ 1) dayNdaa narak surag laiday daykhhu ayhu Dhinyaanaa. The giver goes to hell, while the receiver goes to heaven - look at this injustice. Awip n bUJY lok buJwey pWfy Krw isAwxw ] (1290-7, mlwr, mÚ 1) aap na boojhai lok bujhaa-ay paaNday kharaa si-aanaa. You do not understand your own self, but you preach to other people. O Pandit, you are very wise indeed. pWfy qU jwxY hI nwhI ikQhu mwsu aupMnw ] (1290-7, mlwr, mÚ 1) paaNday too jaanai hee naahee kithhu maas upannaa. O Pandit, you do not know where meat originated. qoieAhu AMnu kmwdu kpwhW qoieAhu iqRBvxu gMnw ] (1290-8, mlwr, mÚ 1) to-i-ahu ann kamaad kapaahaaNto-i-ahu taribhavan gannaa. Corn, sugar cane and cotton are produced from water. The three worlds came from water. qoAw AwKY hau bhu ibiD hCw qoAY bhuqu ibkwrw ] (1290-8, mlwr, mÚ 1) to-aa aakhai ha-o baho biDh hachhaa toai bahut bikaaraa. Water says, "I am good in many ways." But water takes many forms. eyqy rs Coif hovY sMinAwsI nwnku khY ivcwrw ]2] (1290-9, mlwr, mÚ 1) aytay ras chhod hovai sani-aasee naanak kahai vichaaraa. ||2|| Forsaking these delicacies, one becomes a true Sannyaasee, a detached hermit. Nanak reflects and speaks. ||2|| Your comments are really funny. The original scrolls is what I keep referring to which were written in the Bhatts own language. I have already given my alternative, that no one account is 100% reliable and the Sikh Rehat Maryada is the only Rehat, can’t you get your head around this simple fact. Please can you tell me where the script Chajju Singh Kaushish transliterated from into Gurmukhi in 1869 is. Where are these scrolls now, were they even the right scrolls or changed as they were written decades before, were they translated correctly, why were they not kept etc. Also how do you know the copy from the copy of the scrolls was itself geniune and unchanged. BTW why don’t you give the threads for the other parts of the Sikh review articles which clearly show how sketchy the history of the Bhatt Vahi you mention actually is. Interesting how if anything Cunninghams account actually backs Kesh as the Kekkar. Why does he not mention Sikh Woman wearing Keski’s, and top knots instead? He is describing how Sikh Woman looked different from Hindu woman, but rathert than talk of the Keski which is the obvious difference he does not mention it, unless unless they did not wear them. Your own source contradicts you. As for Nihangs doing NaamDhri LOL, as you obviously cannot find any historical evidence is this what you now rely upon. Is this all you have to back up your claim that it was a part of 1699, although no Bhatt Vahi or any other source mentions it, lol. Interesting how no major Nihang group do this, perhaps a akj group who try and look like or act like nihangs do. “Please refute the authenticity of Sau Sakhi if you wish to take Nishani Sikhi as Bani.” Are you incapable of reading my previous posts. I will simply cut and paste for you, once again. “Do you really think that just because Dhasm Granth has Bani's in it which are in line with Gurmat and obviously from Guru Sahib that we have to accept sections which are arguably blatantly not. Let me ask you, do you accept Jaap Sahib, Chapai Sahib, Tav Prasad Sweyai, Akal Ustat which are all from Dhasm Bani. If so do you also accept Sau Sakhi etc?? The section about 5 ks is not against Gurmat in anyway, therefor it cannot be ruled out as being from Guru Sahib, unlike things which are.”

Re: kes the kakaar?

someone · 12 Jan 2005

I believe that in Dasam Granth the 5 k's are mentioned and in that kes is the 5th k not keski. fateh ji

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 12 Jan 2005

Singh, since I am assuming you are a meat eater I will leave this issue to you, if you choose to eat meat and promote it that is your choice and a result of your past karams. With regards to Muslim women and Keski colour, I am not sure how many times I need to say it. I will state again - the content of Guru Ki Sakhian suggests it to be a 18th century source and the content is a product of late 18th century Sikhi. As I have mentioned in nearly every post, I do not take any historical source as authoratative on Rehat, and I have challenged you since my first post to find one, which you have not taken up since there are none. I use Guru Ki Sakhian and Bhatt Vahis to prove the concept of Keski as a Kakkar has been documented much earlier than Kes as Kakkar. Kes as a Kakkar is the whole thing we are talking about here. So far the only piece of evidence you have actually posted for Kes as a Kakkar (and notice the title of this topic: "kes the kakkar") is Nishani Sikhi and since it has been essentially torn to pieces (and references have been given). You should not be quoting lines and saying where they come from if what you are saying is untrue and unreliable. The only reference you are left with is the SGPC Rehat Maryada - what a Praatan source this is! What evidence do you have that this SGPC Maryada was agreed upon by the entire Panth. Could you present me with signatures from the leaders of all Jathebandia and representatives of Sikhs who have approved this SGPC Maryada that preaches a 3 Bani Nitnem and Meat. And finally because you personally do not see Sau Sakhi as "Gurmat" you cannot discount it. "It's not Gurmat" is not a valid refutation of the existence of Sau Sakhi in old Dasam Granth birs. Ratanmalla contains nothing "Anti Gurmat" neither does many other Kacchi Banis in old Adi Granth Saroops. Please explain. My first 3 questions are still waiting to be answered. Question "4" I will accept your answer as "I see nothing wrong with eating meat". This is an acceptable answer and I will leave this for the Sangat to ponder over.

Re: kes the kakaar?

interested reader · 13 Jan 2005

Boy, that was a long read! Keski seems like the logical solution. Why is its colour such an issue? All Khalsa colours are fine. The argument by Singh about blue seems to be a cover for his lack of argument on issue. His argument for only kurehit is done by muslim women resonates with crap pushed by UK nangs, Sikh student lot. What makes a muslim women so different. The kurehit is about the act of lust, not if she is muslim or not? I notice how Singh is also pro-meat. Enuff said...... The comment about akj being wannabee nihangs by wearing bana. After 1978 & 84, I think it is nihangs who are wannabee akjs actually. Why are Uk nihangs so offended by anyone else wearing bana? India nihangs love anyone who wears bana. At my last india AKJ smagam, I saw alot of nihangs come and listen to bani. They had a lot of love with the akj singhs. Just UK nangs and thier manipulated website accounts of india nihangs are protraying this image. Harpratap, why do have such divided loyalties? Are you pro Uk nangs or not?

Re: kes the kakaar?

Singh · 13 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh "Keski seems like the logical solution. Why is its colour such an issue? All Khalsa colours are fine. The argument by Singh about blue seems to be a cover for his lack of argument on issue. " Its actually the defined as a BLUE KESKI according to the Bhatt Vahi of Sarup Singh, therefore its not my opinion. This is the source used to argue for Keski, but it contradicts this basic issue. If you are going to accept this account and that it has been not tampered with and is a solid historical source you have to accept the fact that most people even in the jatha only keep/kept 4 kekkars, as the account shows Keski alone is not the Kekkar as it specifies BLUE Keski. "His argument for only kurehit is done by muslim women resonates with crap pushed by UK nangs, Sikh student lot. What makes a muslim women so different. The kurehit is about the act of lust, not if she is muslim or not?" You are indeed need to read the posts. The account is what says Muslim woman not me. I beleive lust is bad muslim woman or not, which is why once again if you are accepting the account of Sarup SIngh you must accept that he specifies sex with Muslim woman being the Kureht, and therefore other relations are ok. I don't beleive this but that is what the account states. Anon Singh "With regards to Muslim women and Keski colour, I am not sure how many times I need to say it. I will state again - the content of Guru Ki Sakhian suggests it to be a 18th century source and the content is a product of late 18th century Sikhi. " Will you ever get to the point. You still have not bothered or purposly avoided my questions. Now the source is a product of late 18th centuary sikhi, and not an account of 1699. If Sarup SIngh changed the account from WOman to Muslim WOman and Keski to BLUE Keski as in the current account to match 18th centuary Sikhi as you now appear to be suggesting what else has been changed to match 18th centuary SIkhi. Did the actual scrolls illusive scrolls which described what happened in 1699 say Woman or Muslim WOman as the one now, did it say Keski or Blue Keski. If you accept that must have been changed or mistakenly altered when translated by Sarup Singh into Gurmukhi you have to also accept that this is note entirely reliable, and that other things caouls also have been accidentaly changed, ie Kesh to Keski. Or if you are confident that the original scrolls said what is in the Sarup Singhs re-write than you have to accept it contradicts your own rehat. "The only reference you are left with is the SGPC Rehat Maryada - what a Praatan source this is! What evidence do you have that this SGPC Maryada was agreed upon by the entire Panth. Could you present me with signatures from the leaders of all Jathebandia and representatives of Sikhs who have approved this SGPC Maryada that preaches a 3 Bani Nitnem and Meat." Have you bothered to read the thread I gave. All the evidence is there, even if people like you got a signed letter every single person in the Panth if it did not include your own Baba, or Bhai Sahib you still would not accept it. Read the thread all the points are in there. "you personally do not see Sau Sakhi as "Gurmat" you cannot discount it." Excuse me but where have I said sau sakhi is not bani. You seem to use this again and again to get off the issue. All i've said is that if anything is blatantly against the basic tenants of sikhi and contradicts Gurbani and Gurmat you can use your own common sence. You were trying to say that I have to accept the Sau Sakhi if I accept the Nishani section as they are both from Dhasm Bani to which I made it clear that Jaap Sahib, Akal Ustat, Chaoupai Sahi all come from Dhasm Bani so using your futile argument means that you have to accept sau sakhi if I accept the Nishaani section as you have to accept it if you accept Jaap Sahib, Akal Ustat, Chaoupai Sahib. As for your questions, if you care to read my posts for once you would see that they have already been answered. In respect of Nishani Sikhi when someone quoted it I merely mentioned that I was informed that it was in the most oldest and authentic Dhasm Granth Saroops, by a phd student. Did I ever say it was authentic?. Infact I have again and again made it clear that it is almost impossible to accept any source as 100% genuine. You can accept or not accept it. Rather than show me how Keski according to the Bhatt Vahi is the kekkar you have seized on this, while I have never used it as an authentic source or to back up the argument for Kesh. Why do you keep argueing that it is fake when I have never used it in the first place as a source? Does it change the fact that the Bhatt Vahi translated by Sarup SIngh is full of hitoric floors, and contradicts your own rehat, and that a keski is the same as a chunni, no As for the Nanakshahi Calendar I am not going to waste my time listing its History and what different sources were reffered to for your sake. Its a fact that NO ONE SINGLE source was used, hence why do you need them all to be listed. Do you really think that this was the one and only historic source used and referred to,lol. As for meat you can open a new thread on it. People need to first read Bani. In the same section it states that those who eat Choppery Rotti (rotti with butter on one side) will have to have to suffer pains. Why do you not practise this, and accept eating rotti with butter on one side will send you to pains and sufferings. Therefore why do you take the Shabad by Bhagat Kabi Ji about meat literally, and with no insight and not follow this and not the sloak mentioning chaperi rotti? Anyway open a new thread. If you want proof of Keski not being the kekkar you yourself have provided it with Cunninghams eye witness account "The Sikh women are distinguished from Hindus of their sex by some variety of dress, chiefly "The Sikh women are distinguished from Hindus of their sex by some variety of dress, chiefly by a higher topknot of hair."22 Why had Cunningham who is talking about the distinguishing features of Sikh woman from Hindu’s not mentioned the obviously most distinguishing feature of all, the keski or turban. Why has he seemingly blind to this most distinguishing feature and instead tells of a higher top knot on the head, and not a turban. Did he not see them wearing turbans, if he did why when talking about how Sikh woman were distinguished did he fail or forget to mention this, the most distinguishing feature of all? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: kes the kakaar?

Harpartap Singh · 13 Jan 2005

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! lol ''Interested reader' I have no divided loyalties. I was simply saying that people should make clear who they are talking about. I do not follow the UK Neo Nihangs or Budha Dal or whatever... I was simply stating the facts. The Nihang Dals in India believe in the 5 K's as does the majority of the Sikh nation...

Re: kes the kakaar?

Anon Singh. · 13 Jan 2005

"Singh" Bhai this discussion is going nowhere and has become far too long. Any questions you have posed have already been answered and I feel the last section of this discussion has been a complete repetition. Although I do question your statement "I am not going to waste my time listing its History" when you have wasting collossal amounts of time recycling the same fact-less material in most of your posts. To alleviate your doubts on the style of the Praatan woman's keski, may I ask you to look at Praatan paintings and old photos to see the style of the woman's Keski in the past as opposed to today. Here is a beautiful photograph of Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh with his wife, Bibi Amarjit Kaur. http://www.tapoban.org/pics/bhai-fauja-singh.jpg I will now leave it up to the Sangat to read this discussion carefully and decide whether Keski is a Kakkar, based on 18th Century Praatan Sources, or Kes, based on the 20th Century SGPC Maryada and a single Persian verse of unclear origin which, as I have referenced on more than one occasion, contains 19th century language and was found as an unbound "bookmark" in a Saroop. Unless "Singh" or anyone else has any additional evidence they would like to bring forward, either pro Kes or anti Keski, I urge Admin to close this thread.

Re: kes the kakaar?

Admin · 13 Jan 2005

Topic Locked. Admin