< Violence or Non-violence? >
jagroop singh · 29 Dec 2004
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, i replied to a work colleague regarding 'civilised society and how it treats its enemies'. This particular colleague believes in non-violence so i have tried to respond to her bias which although not immediately apparent in her original email, is nonetheless something she feels the need to tell me about; because i once shocked her when i said that the assassination of Indira Gandhi in my opinion was justified and not an act of terrorism or 'unjustified'. Thought it might be useful to post fyi; i know we Sikhs get 'strange questions' asked of us all the time! ps - have a Chardi Kalaa New Year! VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hi xxxxxxx, You’ve got me in the mood for ‘spiritual discussion’ – i.e. the office is quiet and I’m in today! It’s worth considering that to stand aside when others are being slaughtered is not spiritual – in particular situations pacifism can lead to the same outcome as cowardice i.e. the ongoing and ‘accepted’ slaughter of many innocents. Therefore, practising unconditional non-violence in all situations is not always the ‘spiritual thing to do’ no matter how much one tries to justify to themselves. In terms of all the goings-on in this world, ultimately God is All-Powerful, so one can state that all happenings are ultimately ordained. The Spiritual person accepts this – they do not find recourse in cursing or finding fault in The Perfect i.e. God. Instead they realise that this world is a wonderful drama and that God is The Ultimate Director. Ultimately, it is God who has ordained that this Tsunami would occur. Now it is for us to choose the part we will play; but even then, our destiny is already pre-ordained! How wonderful is God! The concept of time and space doesn’t apply to God who instead created them! The intellect is far to gross a tool to fathom the intricacies of God’s related attributes! This brings us to the crux of the issue… Regarding defending the oppressed innocent men, women and children who are slaughtered in this world, the Guru says: ‘When all other means have failed, it is just and righteous to draw the sword’. This philosophy of the Sant-Sipahi (Saint Soldier) – The Perfectly Enlightened Human-Being, is difficult to grasp unless one realises that the True Saintly Human Being will only ever use physical force as a last resort in defence of the oppressed; it is not reactionary in the sense that it is fuelled by anger or a need for vengeance…such a person will have risen above these snares. Here the ‘sword’ represents recourse to measured physical action which manifests not through hatred and a lack of self-control but through the deepest compassion and righteousness. The (10th) Guru says: ‘Only when I have taught the sparrow to hunt the hawk will I call myself Gobind Singh’. He refers to the situation whereby the hawk (Mughal rulers) naturally lived-off the sparrows (ordinary disempowered citizens). However, it was imperative that the usually meek and submissive sparrows must go on to hunt and defeat the hawks if they were to win their freedom which is a God-given right. Only the truly pious, humble and Saintly can present a righteous physical response to the amoral tyrant; not some paid mercenaries or those with an axe to grind. According to the Guru, such an approach is within Hukam i.e. it is not un-spiritual; indeed it is intensely spiritual! With this in mind let us also consider that the judge of a civilized society is in how it treats its enemies or those it perceives as its enemies. In fact individuals can rise to a level whereby their emotions remain un-affected by others’ positive/negative will towards them. In such a state of equipoise, enemies and friends essentially appear one and the same and are treated as such. This Avastha (spiritual state) is gifted to those who constantly meditate/remember God…they literally see the Divine within all Creation. For instance, it is a historical fact that when the Sikhs were forced to confront the Mughal armies upon the battlefield, medical treatment was given to all soldiers where possible regardless of whether they were Sikh or Mughal. There is also a historical reference which describes how the 10th Guru would personally use golden-tipped arrows so that when the wives of fallen soldiers would come to collect their dead husband’s bodies, there would be enough gold for them to pay for the funeral rites and to support them regards their immediate future. Mughal writers of the time wrote quite profusely about the nature of the Sikh Soldiers they encountered and heard stories about. One very well-known and rather zealous author while on the one hand referring to them as ‘infidels’ and ‘cursed dogs’, nonetheless goes on to begrudgingly state the fact that they treated every ‘Mughal’ woman and child they encountered as though they were their own and did not exact any bounty or rape women (which is an endemic trait as far as latter day and even contemporary battlefield/guerrilla warfare is concerned). i tell you all this in order to illustrate how ‘physical force’ finds its defining characteristics and conceptual framework within the Sikhi ethos. It can be concluded that Sikhi sees withdrawal as denial and at worst, cowardice. After all, if the ‘Saints’ of this world (i.e. ascetics, mendicants, pirs, faqirs) see the fulfilment of their path as a complete detachment from the temporal affairs of this world, are they really meeting God’s expectations? Of what use are they in this world except to be fattened from the food offered to them by those who toil by the sweat of their brow, only to withdraw and keep their ‘spirituality’ devoid of any progressive action when these very same people are oppressed? Who is the True Saint…s/he who would rather ultimately die than be oppressed along with her/his fellow citizens or s/he who knowing that the tyrant will not compromise, unconditionally continues to adopt a submissive and pacifistic stance. As I once mentioned to you, would Mahatama Gandhi have lasted in Hitler’s Germany and would he have secured a rosy future for the Jews and other non-Nazis through his approach? Better to practice pacifism through a Satvic (Truth Inspired) lifestyle. To not harm any fellow sentient and non-sentient beings unnecessarily; i.e. to not hurt human nor animal through our diet, lifestyle and ethics. Afterall, good effects come from positive causes. However, if the conditions warrant it, the True Saint is always ready to defend the oppressed and if necessary, shield them behind the double edged sword that represents God. That is the sharp edge that protects the oppressed…and the sharp edge that awaits the oppressor if they continue oppressing. Hence, the Perfectly Enlightened Human Being is the Saint Soldier. Sorry to sound preachy but I found a lot of food for thought in your response. See you, I guess, tomorrow or Friday or Monday… Jagroop Singh -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----Original Message----- From: xxxx [mailto:xxxx] Sent: 17 December 2004 18:28 To: 'Jagroop Singh' Subject: RE: < Dead end in Punjab - By Brad Adams, Executive Director, Asia Division, Human Rights Watch (London) - > Thanks for info, there are many communities around the world that are being killed daily. It is a tragedy that in the information age of the 21st century that we still find that killing is used as a solution for some groups to hold on to power money resources, when there is enough for all. God has provided a great bounty for all to share. We can never take anything with us to the after life only, our good deeds and prayers. Indeed we must not ever forget these tragedies and travesties of the oppressed, ignored and isolated communities. that is why human rights are so important for all people. The judge of a civilized society is in how it treats its enemies or those they perceive as their enemies. If we can treat our enemies well then what a great world we could live in. Regards xxx xxx xxx