Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

singh · 22 Dec 2004

I was thinking, most of us do compromise when it comes to taking off our sri sahib for a flight. We say "what choice do we have? we have to do it." but is this any different than other situations where some people have compromised with kesh? Maybe they were hiding from the police or maybe they needed to come to Canada to save their lives? Aren't both compromises and both wrong (although clearly not in the same measure)? I don't know.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

....... · 22 Dec 2004

Ok its intresting what you say. .... REMOVING Kes is a bujjar kuraet, removing kakars can also be said to be a kurrteh however not a bhujjar kuraet. We have to accpet the kakars has body limbs. How ever, kes are held in such a high postion in Sikhi itself that there is no question about it. Kes are even above all kakars....

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Dhan sikhi · 22 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, i think that is an excellent excellent point but it has made me very very confused. well yes we are compromising our sikhi for that flight even though some may argue that wearing Sri Sahib round neck is enough but is it enoughn when u need to protect youself? u truly have point but i think kesh is worse if u cut it cos it so connected with spirituality. i think we could totally equate the 2 if we could remove our hair and then put it back on again once we had reached canada but we cant cos we lose those kesh forever and have to wait for new growth. not a good point iknow, but ...........i have nop idea i dont think anyone can say that one kakkar is better or more important than the other kakkar. Bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,,

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

respectfully · 23 Dec 2004

There is no way around it - it is a compromise. As much as we may cry about how it is terrible that we have to take off our kirpans in airplanes, we always have the choice of not flying. I could care less what justifications are offered - ie. "A train/bus isn't possible, it takes too long".."It's too expensive (and long) to travel by ship" etc. So what is more important - our Guru ji's hukum or the realities of modern life? The answer is obvious yet we fold like accordians on Regardless of the other rehits or maryadas we argue about and push as authentic and disagree on, there is no doubting that the kirpan is an essential part of rehit. That the vast majority of us compromise on our kirpans says a fair bit. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

harpreet · 23 Dec 2004

You want us to swim to india.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

hhmm · 23 Dec 2004

haha harpreet has a point

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

I Say Go For The Boat · 23 Dec 2004

Swimming? Hahahaha that's impossible - you'll be eaten alive by a fish or something - other else drown. hahahaha. try taking a ship full of other sikhs like they did back in the times of the komagatamaru Go for the boat people ... that way when you touch ground in the country you started from you can officially be called an FOB.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

of course · 23 Dec 2004

It is alright if you wear a small Sri Sahib for the flight, and then you can do an ardaas afterwards. Bhai Kanehya sakhi provides answer to the second part of your question.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Dhan sikhi · 23 Dec 2004

i dont think it is funny but im glad that u guys see the funny side to it. swimming or not going , we all have the option, if our brothers and sisters have died for kesh then its not much to ask to swim there or hire out ur own plane etc etc. i think that kirpan is very important and not something to joke abt. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

respectfully · 23 Dec 2004

Funny but I could care less whether you go to India or not, and care even less than that as to your manner of travel. However, you've missed the point entirely. By choosing to fly to India, you compromise on your kirpan. Is flying to India more important or is your Guru ji's hukum more important? Is swimming to India with your kirpan not a better option than flying to India without your kirpan? The answer depends on whether the realities of modern life are more important to you or Guru ji's hukum is more important.... The only way to resolve this dilemma is by justifying the removal of our kirpans and stating, in one form or another, that sometimes, it is ok to remove our kirpans and that we don't have to keep this kakkar on our person at all times. I'm not sure I buy this line of reasoning. I too travel via airplane and have to remove my kirpan when doing so and even though I wear a small one on a necklace, I don't consider that to be a kirpan - its something there to soothe my guilty conscience more than anything else. The fact of the matter remains, if my Guru ji's hukum reigned supreme in my heart (and the fore-mentioned justification isn't applicable) than I would forego the removal of my kirpan at the cost of my own life in order to maintain Guru ji's commanded rehit. I don't have any answer but this is an excellent question, and one I think many of us have been dodging for a while. It may be that someone more learned can offer an acceptable justification or historical precedent or maybe there is a need for self-reflection or maybe we simply have to face the fact we're blatantly disobeying our Guru ji's hukum. respectfully, Respectfully harpreet wrote: > You want us to swim to india.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

AnotherSingh · 23 Dec 2004

It is different b/c kesh is the most important kakaar. Without kesh the other kakaars mean nothing. -I'm sorry, I've forgotten the reference for this. Either Dasam Granth Sahib or Sarbloh Granth Sahib. Also, once kesh is cut, it takes a long time to grow back. Kirpan can simply be taken off and put back on. Cutting kesh is a kurhait, taking off kirpan is not (not that I'm saying we should). In addition, I remember reading Bhai Nand Lal ji's writings where he said that a Sikh family loses their honour if their children have cut hair and a family with cut hair regains honour if they grow kesh. bhul chuk maaf.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

.............................. · 24 Dec 2004

If you doing something like seva or going to India to visit historical gurdhwaras then it would be alrite to temporarily wear the necklace kirpan on the airplane.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

khalistani · 24 Dec 2004

vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!! ure talkin bout the shabad nishani sikhi bhula chuka maf vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!!

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

g · 24 Dec 2004

who has enough money to hire out their own plane? can you please introduce me to these people... good contacts you know... that is the most unrealistic thing i have ever heard... Im sorry but I Dont know any gursikhs not a single one that can afford a private flight to india... the question is do you want to wear your kirpan or do you want to go to india I dont think you have much choice between the 2... personally I have no problem with taking my kirpan off infact im sittin here without my kirpan or kanga... man I must be a really bad gursikh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

sarjit singhkhalsa · 24 Dec 2004

look at khalistan.com if we have our own country we would have khalistan air line then wewould have not troubles which we facing today so please support council of khalistan

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

<Admin Edit - Inappropriate name> · 25 Dec 2004

choree lakh di choree kakh dee... a miss is a good as a mile... a fail grade due to just half a mark.....or due to 99 marks less is still a FAIL a compromise is a compromise. Fateh Singh could have compromised,,escaped the wall of death...and kept hsi kesh again...after all kesh never stop growing !1but he didnt compromise

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Dhan sikhi · 25 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, to g, I am so happy that you do not place much respect in Guruji, maaf karna, I thought I was a moorakh but you hit the bull's eye. How can anyone even joke about taking off their kanga and kirpan. People like you, in my view are a disgrace to our Sikh Panth. Maaf karna there was no intention to put you down but to state the facts and I dearly apologise to God that I am making this comment about one so called Sikh that I have not met. There are rich Sikhs that can afford a plane but yes that does not apply to all of us. I think you missed my point entirely , my point being that true Sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Ji would not take off their kakkars as per Guru Gobind Singh Ji's hukam. If panj kakkar are too much for you to wear then that is your individual choice and an unfortunate one too. Bhulla chukan maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

ms · 26 Dec 2004

but that is somethign totally different im sure Guru Jee would understand our situation and if you take pesh im sure it is fine

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

g · 26 Dec 2004

I guess I fail to see the importance of wearing them all the time... I guess I dont have that much respect for Guru ji... you know I dont really know what it is all I know that Ive been both ways strict gursikh... and not strict at all and nothing has changed except when I tend to be not so strict I have more love for people... but not really for Gursikhs I stay away from them completely they have caused so much pain in my life and continue to and I dont think its so much that they are Gursikhs... its just that they cant seperate their faith from their culture and the culture is what really hurts people... I Guess you should be able to understand this... I feel that I am not worthy enough to wear all my kakkars I Would be disrespecting them... but whatever I dont care... and you say their are rich sikhs out there... that can afford their own planes... you obviously do not know how much it costs to operate your own plane and how much it would be to hire a plane especially to india.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kakaree · 26 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh This is a hard question. I had to remove these for an MRI - they actually had to redo it for something metal fastening in the clothing I was a unaware of was there. Before 911 if I flew I secreted kirpan. Now they will strip search and send you to prison when they find it. So haven't flown since, but need has not arisen. If you think like 5th kakar is keski but altering kes is karahit than all kakar are removable and kirpan cannot possibly be compared to kes. Quite likely when bhai Taru singh gave his life for his kes - his kakar had already been stripped from him. I don't think he was allowed to wear his kirpan while in moghul custody. So he didn't give his life to keep his kirpan on his body, or any of his other kakars, although maybe they left him his kachhera?

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

The Rehat Maryada · 27 Dec 2004

If the Kangha, Kara or Kirpan are separated from your body, it is forbidden to eat or drink until they are replaced. Upon the replacement of your missing Kakkar, an Ardas must be performed for the loss and beg for forgiveness. The Ardas may be performed either in a Gurdwara or the place where you are replacing your Kakkar. Having done this, you may eat and drink. The Rehat Maryada http://www.damdamitaksal.com/lit_rehat_13.htm

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kaur12123 · 28 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh, 'g' are you a Gursikh? have you taken amrit? If not then I can understand why you talk the way you do. Let me tell you something, I pray sometimes and most of the time I do not but I used to think that it made no difference to me. I used to think it was all the same and path was a waste of time. Now I see the time not spent in contemplation of God as time wasted. It is when you do what is required of you as a sikh, with love for God, not with a show on the top or as if it wasa chore. For me kirpan or no kirpan was the same but now that has changed.And when one thinks like you then they cannot realise the true value of the great kakkars. I am not insulting you in this post as I was in the last one. Now I am simply explaining that I have been past or perhaps I am still partly at the stage you are at. But there is one thing I realised that changed me, and that is that when we die, Akal Purakh will look at sewa and simran. You may do the sewa and I the simran but can either of us please God with lack of the other. You say that Gursikhs have only brought you pain, 'g' Gursikhs can bring no one pain, I'm sure they must have been Sikhs. The true sangat of the saints can never leave someone disheartened. I have met many people that claim to be Gursikhs but show no internal sign so find the right sangat and then you will realise what benefit a Gursikh can be. Good luck with Sikh way of life Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

g · 28 Dec 2004

well I guess I have yet to meet a Gursikh then... and yes I have taken amrit... and I guess the way I feel now is that I dont care about nothing because weather its my own fault or not all I feel is pain everyday and I hate living so I feel like im already in hell... and I just dont care anymore maybe one day I will come around... but that day is not today

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Javir Kaur · 28 Dec 2004

all this talk of private air planes and all make me laugh. SO Ok you have your own private air plane.....or we have Khalistan where we dont need to remove kirpan...BUT what about when your "private plane" lands at DELHI AIrport...and they can even ask you to remove your kachhera...let alone kirpan?? What you going to do ?? Its NOT your Plane/your country ??? so what can you do ?? What happens if your plane wants to land in Riyadh ?? Baghdad ?? Dubaii ?? I have My own Private HOUSE.... I can wear any length kirpan...carry any number of spears, swords, whatever I like.... BUT when I COME OUT...its different. So either you "compromise" or you DONT. I DONT... I NEVER FLY and hope never have to...leave home "without it". may Guru ji Bless Me. jasvir Kaur

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kaur12123 · 29 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh btw i also wrote under dhan sikhi name tag ''g'' I used to think the way you do and then I started praying more than I normally did and trust me I hardly prayed. But it changes you. And I used to wander why something bad used to happen to me but now I have realised that tit is our past lives karm and to wash away the sins we have to pray to God each day to have them washed away. Read abt Sikhism and do not get put down by gursikhs that did not live upto the expected standard. read Guru Granth Sahib Ji in parts and I think the best thing to do is go to the panj pyare at the amrit sanchar and tell them that life is not going as good. They can tell you what prayers to do. Don't expect a miracle but do expect gradual changes bu then dont doubt a miracle w=either. keep away from some of the biggest sins that are so easy to commit, the one that is so easy and tempting is salndering sants. All this moorakh knows is that Guru Ji are merciful to all and we have to pay for our karm but have faith and do not treat Guru Jis kakkars that He has blessed us with as meaningless. For this moorakh they werre the most important part of taking amrit. I now have a right to wear the kakkars and I never realised their value until I read a lot about Sikhism. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji are inspiring but also if you want to read the stuff by Baba Narinder Singh Ji on Baba Nand Singh JI then that is really great to make one feel closer to realising some Truth. Im not perfect or even a good sikh for that matter, maybe Im not even a sikh as a sikh should be better than me. BUT sitting there and waiting to die does not help anything. if anything you are wasting this life and after it you do not die but your soul lives on and is either tortured or blessed. But if you have a chance to save urself now then why are u sitting around. Pray now and pray as much as you can and play kirtan in the house in praise of the Gurus teachings. It is fcourse your choice whther u want to try to save urself or not. i personally think that anyone would go for the former. Do let me know what u decide. Take care and bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,,,,,

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

g · 29 Dec 2004

well I used to read alot of paath and I went and did pesh with the panj... I guess I have tried everything and at this current stage in my life it is not working... and as far as my soul being tortured I guess that just doesnt scare me... I feel like its bs that this is even said it an easy way to control people and make them believe what you want them to believe... every religion says this... and its all made so the people fear this and they do whatever the religion says... so I guess I dont believe god is soo mean that he would punish me for making me the way i am

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Manpreet Kaur · 29 Dec 2004

g veerji I'm definetely not the greatest Sikh maybe thats the reason I get down sometimes but when stuffs not going well, nobody understands but God. He knows everything, our deepest feelings, who better to depend on and have love for than Him? He always hugs his children close. Maybe you don't feel the closeness right now or the love, but you will. Gods very close and waiting to love us. Always remember Waheguru. He will support you in everything. Remebering Him and doing your pathe and listening to kirtan will all help bring chardi kala into your life. Guru ji blessed his Khalsa with kakkars for a reason. You say that some people have caused you pain and my only advice to that is to keep to yourself, do as much seva, and build your relationship with God. It doesn't matter what you did in the past, God always forgives his children. Your an amritdharee Singh, God's devotee! Don't forget what you are here for in this world! Always remember our Waheguru and He will embrace you and take all the pain away. You have been given this wonderful life from Guru ji to brake away from pain that your feeling right now and the cycle of birth of death to attain peace. Don't let it go away in waste. Singh ji, you are Guru Gobind Singh ji's son and hes always waiting for you to surrender to him so he can show you the way of truth and peace. Listen to Guru ji's hukam, keep your kakkars on at all times, and don't worry about what others think. Always try to remember our Guru ji. Keep focussed and don't let life bring you down. Dukh and sukh are both blessings from God. Singh ji, I have been at rock bottom in my life, well thats what it felt life and Guru ji changed it around completely :) who knows what you been through or are going through right now, but Guru ji will be your support if you listen to him waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kaur12123 · 30 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh g sorry i did not say the torture part to scare u but thought it might help in some way. the greatest thing we can do is love God and when we love God then God shows His love for us EVEN MORE. loving and being loved by the greatest of the greatest Akal Purkh is the greatest feeling. Im not saying force yourself to follow Sikh way, if you don't want to follow everything that the Guru teaches then don't, not yet , but at least go to the gurdwara or if not then sit at home and do simran. dont just pray and leave it at that but communicate with God in everyday language, in your mind. God listens to us all the time and He can take away the pains. If you dont want to do all else like Nitnem etc then at least talk to God in other ways like an ardas. If not that then at least remember God when you are on the bus or waking up or going to bed. Im no good Sikh myself and maybe my advice is not good. Im not trying to scare you so that you become a good sikh, that is not my motive, in fact there is not motive. on this forum we are all sikhs and we are here to share our thoughts and so if one is unhappy we want him to be happy and that is why I am posting. Saying God's name and praying and wearing kakkars is a way of asking for happiness. at least try to remember God for a week and then come back and tell us how u feel. Waheguru ji is not there to scare people about hell so they love Him but God WANTS us to love Him so that He can show His love even more. Please just try to remember God for a while, you have nothing to lose by saying Waheguru.= so go and try it, in fact try it now, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh,

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Anon · 30 Dec 2004

Has anyone ever thought of getting a LARGE number of Gursikhs together to hire a plane together to go to Amritsar once a year (say in Summer or Xmas) that was it would be financially viable?

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Dhan sikhi · 30 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh thants a great idea abt hiring a plane and then we can travel as we want but they would have to ensure that the cockpit is secure as there is always the danger that we can use the kirpans to threaten a pilot and hijack a plane. the idea will take time to think up but it is excelleng and i guess it was my dum idea abt going on ur own plane that inspired u??lol regardless, we need to put this plan into action and i will try to suggest it to my local gurdwara sahib ji committee as soon as i can bump into someone i think might want to listen. Dhan Guru Nanak will help us in this if Guru Sahib chooses to bless us. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

amar · 01 Jan 2005

KES IN A NOT A KAKAAR, its way above any of the 5k's, all of the other 5k's are man made whilst kes is god made, we have no power over it and its status in sikhi is already so high that making it a kakaar will acheiev nothing apart from lowering that status (paap)singh wrote:

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kaur 12123 · 02 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh yes i agree amar but nevertheless is it right that we take off the kirpan for covenience sake//////? waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

amar · 03 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf i completely agree that the kirpan should never be taken off by an amritdhari sikh as the panj pyare have given us the 5k's to keep on us until our soul departs our body (and then we are cremated with our 5k's still on us). Therefore i think under no circumstances should we remove ANY Of the 5 k's vjkk vjkf

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Manpreet Kaur · 05 Jan 2005

My brothers wedding is going to be long distance. This is the first time I ever have to remove my kirpan. I don't feeel to goood about this:( Im dreading the whole plane ride already and its 3 months away. im already starting to feel guilty and weird inside about it. Something really has to be, own Plane for Sikhs, something!!!!!:(:(

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

erm · 05 Jan 2005

Manpreet Kaur, accept it as hukam, there is nothing u can do to change it

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Binny · 05 Jan 2005

Removing kirpan is not a kurehat. Removing kesh is a kurehat.

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

erm · 05 Jan 2005

feeling guilty is not gna help u in anyway, bt plz feel free to do so

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

Maybe I can sneak it in on the plane ride!

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Mkhalsa · 06 Jan 2005

>>>Removing kirpan is not a kurehat. Removing kesh is a kurehat.<<<<< CORRECTION: Removing kirpan IS A kurait Removing kesh IS A BAJJAR kurait

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

kaur id · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I went to India with a kirpan on b4 sept 11 and heathrow let me through but when i landed they were shocked and this sikh uncle ji gave me attitude saying how can anyone wear a kirpan on the plane when they know it is not allowed...i told him nnicely to shut up and so he did and then i went from there. but now it is rather risky as they may think u did it on purpose but maybe try and then do ardas. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

Manpreet Kaur · 09 Jan 2005

Before Sept 11 it was allowed depend on its size or something. Its no longer allowed to be worn though:(

Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise

harpreet · 10 Jan 2005

For those who do not remove their kirpan on a flight, how do you get to india?