Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
HardeepSingh · 27 Jun 2003
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
I was recently conversing with my brother about the disease which is homosexuality.
Surprisingly he took a very weak stance against this deviant practice, saying that there was so much manmat around us anyways, who cares if the government allows for same-sex marriages and the promotion of homosexuality in schools.
In Canada we are currently facing the prospect of having same-sex marriages become mainstream. It will not be long before so-called Sikhs join this practice and do the same. With the liberalized judicial system, 20 years from now we will be seeing Gurdwaray being sued for discrimination, because they didnt allow for a same-sex marriage ceremony to take place.
The Supreme Court of Canada has condoned the practice of having homosexual themed books allowed in classrooms, even against the wishes of a school board.
As Sikhs should we not be standing up with the rest of the Canadian religious communities in opposing these outrageous things from happening to society?
Hardeep Singh
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
Kulbir Singh · 27 Jun 2003
I don't think this kind of behaviour is acceptable in Sikhi.
I am not arguing whether this behaviour is natural or not. It is possible that it may be natural to some but in Gurmat, we are not supposed to follow on all urges of Kaam. Taking the help of gur-shabad, we are supposed to fight the evil kaamic urges. Just because some kaamic urge is natural does not mean that it is okay to do so.
Some people have incest urges and they too are natural to them. Should they follow those urges or subdue such urges through extensive paath and naam abhyaas? Some are pedophiles and have such evil urges. Does it mean that the pedophiles are supposed to follow on their urges just because they are natural to them?
Anand Karaj can only be of a male and female. We don't care what the court of law of Canada says with this respect. No law can force the Sikhs to do anand karaj of two people of same sex. Sikhs will never let this happen.
This is ghor Kalyug. May Guru Sahib protect his faith from the evils of Kalyug.
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
Hardeep Singh · 27 Jun 2003
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Kulbir Singh wrote:
> We don't care what the court of law of Canada says with this respect.
I dont agree with this statement at all. We cannot sit quietly as society burns around us. We cannot be isolationists on this and other issues where our voice may be able to help. By actively telling politicians and other concerned individuals of where the Sikhs stand on homosexuality, we will only be helping society.
This activism of being against anti-gurmat practices is also a form of broad, more generalized parchar.
Hardeep Singh
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
Japnaam Singh · 27 Jun 2003
Vaaheguroo jee kaa Khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee Fateh!
I really do not understand why the thought of Gay Marriages or the idea of homosexuality being openly discussed in society causes so many people to become appalled. I agree that being gay is against Gurmat, simply because all Sikhs should strive to direct Kaam towards the purpose of reproduction. But why do Sikhs, who expect Canada and other western states to be “Secular†when it comes to multiculturalism, Christian prayer in schools, and many other issues, not expect Canada to avoid using personal religious and moral convictions when it comes to the issue of gay marriage?
Should Sikhs lobby the Canadian government to ban meat since that is such an important Sikh principle? Should we also lobby the government to outlaw adultery, pre-marital sex and the cutting of hair? The idea of supporting the current ban on Same Sex marriages is ridiculous. Sikhi is a religion of personal choice. If a couple chooses to be gay and if a religion chooses to sanctify their marriage, as many protestant Christian denominations have done, why wouldn’t a “secular†state grant them the full rights accorded to married couples? Are they not equal human beings?
Don’t misunderstand me, I do not support Anand Karajs for homosexual couples because as I stated above, I believe homosexuality is not according to Gurmat since it defeats the purpose of Kaam which is reproduction. But if other religious institutions sanction homosexual weddings, what place does the state have in enforcing its morals on a religion and group of people?
Research shows that openly discussing homosexuality in society does not cause more people to become gay or for society to lose its values. And hypothetically, even if it did, what’s the big deal? If we were to support bans on books in schools which talk about homosexuality, we should ban books in schools which mention ANY sort of manmat.
Homosexuals are humans too, and although they commit acts of manmat, they are no worse than many other “normal†manmukhs. They deserve the same rights, including marriage rights as everyone else. Homosexuals have been persecuted enough.
Enforcing moral beliefs through laws or through any other means accomplishes nothing.
Also, all legislation tabled so far in any country, does not force any religion to sanction these marriages, it is the religion's choice.
(I probably made a lot of mistakes in this post.)
Japnaam Singh
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
HardeepSingh · 27 Jun 2003
Japnaam Singh wrote:
> Research shows that openly discussing homosexuality in
> society does not cause more people to become gay or for society
> to lose its values.
Japnaam Singh, my dear brother please provide references to this mythical research you refer to. Actually... i bet there is some sort of research out there, the homosexual lobby groups spend lots of money trying to persuade us to believe there is nothing wrong with homosexuality, they must have funded some sort of research paper.
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
jaspreetkaur · 28 Jun 2003
wjkk wjkf
um isnt there already a group of gay "sikhs"?... they call themselves the British Gay Sikhs Organization ( ...pure manmat!
wjkk wjkf
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 29 Jun 2003
mKhalsa, i don't agree with u on the amritdhari anand karaaj relation...but i do say that u can't be sikh unless ur amritdhari and shasterdhari.....
but gay ppl?? (admin cut).............. no place for them in sikhi. or society....dont' bow to no jhooti sarkaaar.........only sarkar is guru granth sahib ji maharaj.......
Re: Same-sex Marriages, Promotion of Homosexuality in Schools etc.
conspiracy theory · 01 Jul 2003
Dear "Gabroo Khalistan Dah,"
I found your comment about "no place for them" (gay people) "in society" to be very condescending, egotistical, insulting, hateful, and anti-gurmat.
For starters, Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Maharaj said, "maanas kee jaat sabhai aykai pehchaanbo"
Are gay people not members of "maanas kee jaat" ? They are members of the human race.
Secondly, Dhan Bhagat Kabeer Jee says, "Ayk noor thay sabh jag upjiaa kaun bhaallay, ko mandhay"
Who are we to judge the level of somebody's manmat with regard to their way of life?
Let me make clear that I think, the only way for a person who naturally is homosexual to be a Sikh is for him/her to take khanday-kee-pahul and never have any relationships. Obviously because he/she does not have the natural will to marry somebody of the opposite sex, he/she will probably not do so. Nonetheless, ghristhee jeevan can be practiced - if you have to - without getting anand kaaraj. Anand kaaraj is a part of Sikhi, but it is not necessary like khande-ke-pahul. Many mahaan gursikhs have gone all their lives without getting married; and some have adopted children rather than have their own.
I agree with MKhalsa - we should remain clear about this in our amrit sanchaars, in the new revised rehit maryada after the next sarbat khalsa (yes i'm dreaming of it now). We can't let another dhil get into the Khalsa's rehit. I admit I am not even the dust under the shadow of the feet of Guru Gobind Singh's blue horse. I know nothing about ghiaan and dhiaan and bibek and rehit. I have no wisdom and honour; but I will not stand here and allow the Guru's khalsa to be insulted in such a way that the rehit itself is changed.
It is already such an injustice and insult to the Anand Kaaraj that patits and pakhandees can take part in this mahaan blessing.
Anyway I do not think a homosexual person is a patit or a pakhandee, so long as he/she does understand that they cannot have a partner of the same sex. The anand kaaraj is for a male and female, and relationship outside that constitutes adultery, which is a bujjer kurehit.
I would go so far as to say, however, that Hardeep Singh is a little off on his interpretation of gay people. Brother, please get off your high horse and sit with the common folks. See the light of God within them. "Gabroo Khalistan Dah" I think you should also follow this advice.
A gay person is normal, and can be a mahaan Gursikh, as long as he/she does not give in to his/her kaam and have a relationship with somebody of the same sex.
This conversation is very good - we need to discuss this issue with our youth - please continue vichar of topics that are controversial in society so that we can come to some decision about how Gursikhs should respond, as per the teachigns of the Guru.
Dhan Guru Dhan dhan Guru ~
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh !