Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Dec 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
Is it true that the entire "maryada" at Takhat hazoor sahib is based on a book written by a Singh sahib Joginder Singh who himself bases his arguments etc on a SINGLE book called Khalsa Dharam Shastar which is a far from "puratan" or ancient text but a newly written text.
How is it possible for a Takaht Maryada to be written by a SINGLE PERSON ?
and the daleels/reasons given by Singh sahib are next to ridiculous. In the chapter on Khoon da Tilak..Blood Tilak to Weapons... the JHATKA of helpless bakras is compared to Shikar of Guru Ji. I fail to see how a poor Bakra tied hand and foot can be compard to GURU JI hunting a full grown LION in the Jungle.
It is well known and respected view that MEAT is not served in a Gurdwara Langgar.... so how can Live Bakras be murdered in a Gurdwara ??
Visit www.amritworld.com for Punjabi/English articles on thsi subject. we need to publicise this.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
well actually · 17 Dec 2004
sorry A singh,
but the reason many of us do not go on sikhawareness any more is they ban members who rip them up for no reason at all!
post and threads disappear who challenge their thinking!
101 discussions thread reappear with only their views on them!
It is a heavily nang bias, they right everything anti-gurmat and people get banned for calling thems nangs!
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Singh Ji,
Unlike many in your region of the world I ( and most malaysians/Singaporeans/Australians etc in this region) DONT have any hangups about the Nangs/sanatansikhs/taksalis/akjs etc etc. In fact i doubt if any of these are even mentioned over here.
I visited www.amritworld.com..and I liked the article on Amrit as prepared at hazoor sahib...and as I read along I added many points of my own to add and explain/expand on some matters. This is SIKH MARYADA we are talking about and is general SIKH MATERIAL. I am just writing a short message as here on this forum..there is no need to write a Biography/index/appendices/copyright etc etc as this Forum is not a PHD Thesis or something like that. Sikh history/Itihass/Maryada/gurbani vichaar etc are all public domain knowledge to be discussed freely. many many of my writings appear on other forums under other names...no problem..as all this cannot be and should not be controlled. Critical analysis is NOT anyone's ownership.
But no matter..i think I get what you mean. I should have given due credit to Amrtipal Singh on SPN as I have done on this Forum. My Mistake and I apologise.
And YES I did enjoy all the rest of his writings and agree with him on most points regarding the Hazoori maryada. I have written him an appreciative email message from my gurbani class students as well. I hope waheguru Blesses him with more energy and bibek budhee to carry on more such works.
Perhaps you can enlighten us ( i mean me) on the "authentic hazoori maryada"...from what I read the HOLES in it are as big as the Ozone Hole and getting bigger.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Niranjan Singh · 17 Dec 2004
In Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's book "Gurmat Lekh", on page 191, he calls those people who put tillak on Shastars "Dhur to'n BigRRay Hoe Hindoo Khialla'n waley" and labels their practice "Niree Manmat".
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
open minded · 17 Dec 2004
A singh, I took your advice and checked out the messageboard. I had stopped over 2 years ago, Because I saw there was no Gurmat being discussed, just wierd stuff, and slagging of other groups.
In a 50 minute session just going from thread to thread. I witnessed widespread slagging of BOSS, who seem thier current enemy No1. Occasional swipes at tapoban/akj, SGPC, & Damdami Taksal, and these were from the moderators.
Blantant lies from the usual Bhahadur, Jagdeep (narsingha) and Uk nihang group. An example of their kind of rubbsh is a post written by one of the Uk nihangs.
He comments that rehitvan singhs who he calls Wahabis, not realisng they are Singhs and not muslims. He says -they just get frustrated by us (UK nihangs, snaatanists), because they have built up frustration. They need to masturbate more, and read my thread on masterbation. This will release their tension.
Really A Singh, if this is the kind of advice they are giving on thier messageboard, then do not disrespect Sikhism, by attaching it to them. For all the rubbish they have calling Singhs wahabis, it seems they are the ones full of hatred for others.
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Ranjit Singh Jit · 18 Dec 2004
Gur Fateh to all,
Just half an hour ago, I was talking to bhai sahib amritpal singh amrit ji in his house. I told him about this thread. He smiled and said, 'make a post on tapoban.org and say my thanks a lot to all'.
dear 'disturbed' ji,
You wrote, "Check out bottom of this article about his really stupid arguments slating AKJ and SGPC is true UK nang style. His only argument is they are anti-raagmala. Nothing to do with kirpaan da Amrit!!"
Please check this link : - http://www.amritworld.com/hazooree_maryada_prabodh/article_kirpan_da_amrit.pdf and tell this forum where bhai sahib amritpal singh amrit ji criticised akj or sgpc. It was first time in the history of sikh websites that someone has written on sri hazuri maryada parbodh in such a beautiful language. Please do not spread lies.
bhai amritpal singh ji is a hazuri singh, even then he criticised the hazuri maryada. it proves that he is an open minded gursikh. not just a writer, he participated in many-many 'amrit sanchars' as one of five beloved ones. it is surprising for me that a person lied against him, and a sikh website allowed such a post on its message board.
I think he is the only person in our region, who is always available to answer our questions on sikhism/sikh history. People like me often go to his house to get the answers to our questions.
bhai sahib does not come online, because his father passed away recently, and also he is not having good health. I hope that bhai sahib ji will come online very soon, and we will see his new articles.
a student of bhai sahib amritpal singh amrit ji,
Ranjit Singh Jit
[address removed]
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
JSDhillon "Arshi" Gyani · 19 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
I am flabbergasted to read "premis" mail above...just as i was about mails flaying other forums as anti this and anti that. The very fact that his/her mail got through shows "holes" in the box theroy..the light is getting through..eh ??
I am NOT an AKJ...not by a long shot...and neither am i a Taksali- ddt/bhai mani singh taksal, etc etc..and neither am i a nihung/nang whatever... ( i dont think anyone one is really because a Gursikh is a Gursikh - period)..yet I dont have a clue as to what is an "AKJ-BOX"..and so far not a single mail by me has been "rejected" ?? How come ?? Did all my mails really "fit" the akj box ?? i dont think so because on many matters I disagree with many others on this forum...the exact same mails appear on other seemingly anti-akj forums as well ( so they must be fitting other "boxes" as well !!)..in that case since all boxes are the same whats the problem ??
Every Forum has its own rules of decorum. ( sensible ones" will reject "personal/jatt paat caste promoting/vulgar posts..) This may be what premi percieves as a "box"..IF so I support the BOX theory as children also read such forums and we must promote GURMATT...it cannot be a free for all to have slanging matches. THAT type of Forums soon close down anyway as everyone fells the stink.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Ranjit Singh Jit · 20 Dec 2004
Dear spectator Ji,
I have again read the English article by bhai sahib amritpal singh amrit ji. These are the lines, where he mentioned AKJ: -
"Bhai Randhir Singh organized 'Akhand Keertani Jatha'. Most of the members of this Group do not read the 'Raagmala'. Other accept it the Gurbani. Bhai Randhir Singh was once a member of 'Panch Khalsa Diwan, Bhasaur'. I did not see any article against the 'Bhagatbani' and 'Raagmala' written by Bhai Randhir Singh. Even if he was against the Raagmala, it has nothing to do with 'Kirpan Da Amrit'."
Where has he slandered the AKJ in this article? Please quote to the original article. He has just replied to the points raised by Singh sahib bhai joginder Singh ji. Singh sahib Joginder singh wrote something about bhai randhir singh, and bhai sahib amrit ji replied to that point.
You wrote, "I suggest you apologise for calling others liars, as all gurmukh do in these situations".
Would you please follow your own statement?
As far Sri Raagmaala is concerned, his views are well explained in his article, which is coming in future. As we know, bhai sahib will come back online very soon.
ranjit singh jit
sikhismguide.com
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 21 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Can anyone..( maybe Ranjit Singh Jit or A. Singh) please enlighten me as to what exactly is a "pooran HAZOORI Singh" ? How do you become one ?
Is he different from an "Akaltakhtee Singh"/SGPC singh" as I am called because I took Amrit from the Panj Jatha that follows Akal Takht Maryada...or is there something else involved as well.
I have heard of "Hazoori raagis" because these have worked for some time as paid Ragi jathas at some important shrines..and so get the "self declared cert of Hazoori raagi to differentiate themselves from the ordinary joe raagi..but thats about it.
BTW this is not a "toungue in cheek" query or an attempt to put down anybody. I need to learn more about this so that i can answer my students as well.
Thank You.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
ranjit singh jit · 21 Dec 2004
Dear Dhillon Sahib Ji,
If you want to know about 'Hazuri Singh', please do write to [address removed] . On sikhawareness.com, once amrit bha ji explained the term 'Hazuri Singh'. I will try to find his that post and let you know the definition of this term.
You wrote, "Is he different from an "Akaltakhtee Singh"/SGPC singh""
So you think there is term 'Akal takhtee Singh', and also 'SGPC Singh'. Hmmmm. I think bha ji is not SGPC Singh. He is Singh of HAZUR Sri guru gobind singh ji, so he is a HAZURI singh.
Your explaination of Hazoori raagis is not acceptable. Even PAID raagis, who are NOT doing seva regularly in any Gurdwara Sahib, are NOT called 'Hazuri Raagis'. Bhai randhir singh was a kirtani singh, but NOT 'Hazuri Raagi' or 'Hazuri Kirtani'. Please learn more on the topic, before you start to teach students. To learn more on the topic, please contact any student of bhai sahib amritpal singh amrit.
You wrote, "BTW this is not a "toungue in cheek" query or an attempt to put down anybody".
Even if it was such an attempt, you failed in your mission.
Regards,
Ranjit Singh Jit
www.sikhismguide.com
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
open minded · 22 Dec 2004
what does it have to do with the subject matter? He states it himself, so why mention it?
Also A singh, you have not answered the quert about suggesting masterbation to Sikhs on this site as a sensible release of tension. Even if said in mockery, it does demonstrate non-Gurmukh mindset.
Ranjit Singh Jit wrote:
> Dear spectator Ji,
>
> I have again read the English article by bhai sahib amritpal
> singh amrit ji. These are the lines, where he mentioned AKJ: -
>
> "Bhai Randhir Singh organized 'Akhand Keertani Jatha'. Most of
> the members of this Group do not read the 'Raagmala'. Other
> accept it the Gurbani. Bhai Randhir Singh was once a member of
> 'Panch Khalsa Diwan, Bhasaur'. I did not see any article
> against the 'Bhagatbani' and 'Raagmala' written by Bhai Randhir
> Singh. Even if he was against the Raagmala, it has nothing to
> do with 'Kirpan Da Amrit'."
>
> Where has he slandered the AKJ in this article? Please quote to
> the original article. He has just replied to the points raised
> by Singh sahib bhai joginder Singh ji. Singh sahib Joginder
> singh wrote something about bhai randhir singh, and bhai sahib
> amrit ji replied to that point.
>
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 23 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
dear ranjit Singh Jit ji,
You wrote:
<<<<
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
ranjit singh jit · 23 Dec 2004
Dear Dhillon Sahib Ji,
I have loved your post. Sach puchho ta maza aa gayaa ji. Please continue to visit our site sikhismguide.com. Lots of matter will be coming on that site. Amrit bha ji was not having good health and his father expired, so he was not able to work on his website www.amritworld.com, and Paramjit singh was too busy in his personal matter, so he could not work on our site www.sikhismguide.com . Now both the sites will be updating regularly, I hope.
This thread was dedicated to hazuri maryada. I think no one is able to say anything more than bhai amrit ji already wrote in his 'ik adhian'. If you are interested to know more on the topic, please and please continue to visit amritworld.com .
And yes, also have a visit to http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ramgarhiasikh/ . Please be a member of this yahoo group. Thank you very much.
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
<Admin Edit - Inappropriate Name> · 25 Dec 2004
looks like the billi is out of the bag eh ranjit singh jit ?? YES why Ramghariah..indeed ?? what is so special about them that we should visit their website ? they are just another caste based gurdwara followers.
Everyone who is a somebody...knows about sikhi etc knows that "Hazoori" refers to hazoor Sahib...especially the Maryada thing...and here jit ji is trying to play with words and misdirect the exact question.
Every Singh is a Hazoori singh IF he is a singh of Guru Gobind Singh Ji..BUT that is NOT a true answer...hazoori singh refers to those who took amrti from hazoor sahib and they consider themselves EXCLUSIVE !! better than all others....and hazooruii maryada is not true maryada of Guru Gobind Singh ji but heavily brahmansied hinduistic rituals.
Re: Hazoori maryada - full of HOLES !!
ranjit singh jit · 29 Dec 2004
Dear Jasvir kaur bhen ji,
I have asked this question to bha ji through email, because he is out of station for few days. He replied me that he will give the answer when he returns to his home in two or three days, on this page: - http://www.amritworld.com/questions/ask_your_question.html .