Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Images on this web site

Images on this web site

blech · 15 Dec 2004

Just wondering... Why are there no pictures of any of the Gurus on this website. When you enter the main site, you are treated to a picture of Bhai Randhir Singh Jee (who I agree was a great Gursikh). But, I was thinking of this issue in the context of jathebandis, and sectarianism in Sikhi, and when I visit other sites, I notice the same thing (i.e. other "jathas" have the picture of someone other than a Guru on the main page). When you think about it, isn't this what has happened to Christianity, where a central figure is seen to be God, and is seen as important as their prophet. Examples of these central figures include the Pope - Catholic, the Archbishop of Canterbury - Anglican, Martin Luther - Lutheran, Joseph Smith - Mormon). A person with no knowledge of Sikhi visiting this site would be a little confused as to who the prophet of the Sikh religion was.

Re: Images on this web site

omg · 15 Dec 2004

Blech, with all due respect, there ARE NO PICTURES OF GURUSAHIBS!.

Re: Images on this web site

Kaur · 15 Dec 2004

I was just wondering, but when you actually look at a picture of one of the Gurus, do you actually believe THAT is how our Guru Sahibaan's looked? These painted images and drawings of our Guru's are not even close to being real to how our Guru's looked. Why give people fake and unreal images to look at when they aren't even our real Guru's? People are not going to learn about our Guru's by looking at the pictures and paintings of them. They learn by reading about our history and all the posts and articles on this site (and others). With regards to the pictures of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji, at least these pictures are actually the TRUE image of how Bhai Sahib Ji looked. And if any person with no knowledge of Sikhi were to visit this site, there's no reason why he/she can't just ask about what they don't know. That's what this site is here for - to provide helpful information and help others gain knowledge about topics they know little or nothing about.

Re: Images on this web site

Binny · 15 Dec 2004

If you look carefully, the pictures are there... maybe not the way you think ie not in the form of a painting - which is an artist drawing and not a real picture. The real and original "picture" of Guru Ji is Ek Ong Kaar. You fing this on the home page of this and alot of other website

Re: Images on this web site

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Gurmatt and Gurbani has no place for "pictures". pictures are the stepping stone to IDOLS..and idol worship...which is condemned as ritualistic in Gurbani. Commercially produced "pictures" of Gurus are just made to make money for the printers.....and now we have progressed to idols of Gurus as well...next there may be an "idol" of Guru Garanth Ji as well !!!( for the convenience of thsoe who cant do "proper" sewa/sambhaal/parkash etc of the real GURU JI Sroop !!! get the point..Commercial adverts !!! Do you realise the way we have already REDUCED the PALATIAL PALKI or THRONE of GURU JI, to a TINY WOODEN cubicle...a small manji with four small posts and a roof made of a Rumalla...this is how we PARKASH GURU JI at most Homes during Akhand Paaths/home samagams... the pathi cant sit properly in the confined space, cannot do chaur properly and when ardass is offerred, the Chaur Sewaks Hands are ABOVE the so called Chandni !!! WHAT A HUGE JOKE..but it is SO COMMON now a days....even those "RESPECT FOR GURU JI" jathawallahs dont say anything about this GHOR BEADBI...everything is so commercial..money is the main objective. Sorry to have strayed away from the topic...just couldnt help it. jarnail Singh

Re: Images on this web site

Kulwinder · 16 Dec 2004

Dear Blech, Important to remember is that Sikhs do not believe in any thing other then knowledge ( Shabad Guru) and it is only come to as Guru if you read, understand or at least try to understand (Khoj), so Pictures no pictures, text, symbols all are to help you in getting the knowledge and if you do anything else other then acquiring knowledge you are on some other path then sikhi, though knowledge can be attained by Servicing Humanity (Sewa), study, Love, working professionally ( what ever you do for turthfull living), understanding and listening carefully to Guru. Thanks

Re: Images on this web site

fauji · 16 Dec 2004

The painting of Guru Nanak that is from Nanaksar is the most acurate portrait of Guru Sahib available. Baba Nand Singh asked Guru Nanak to bless them with their darshan so that the painter could bring out a portrait for the sangat. And that is the one available and displayed at Nanaksar gurdhwaras. It is similar to this one: [IMG]http://img157.exs.cx/img157/1477/guroobabananakdev6xo.jpg[/IMG]

Re: Images on this web site

bgtsingh · 16 Dec 2004

one of the first pictures on the site is IK OAN KAAR. BAANI GURU GURU HAI BAANI

Re: Images on this web site

A Singh · 16 Dec 2004

The response on this thread are so predictable! "blech" has raised a valid point. It is clear from this site and others affiliated with the Damdami Taksal, 3HO etc as to who they really turn to for a final say, albeit all claim Guru Granth Sahib as their centrally authority. In Yuba city, we have a Gurdwara Sahib with a high picture of Sant Jee at the entrance -the message is loud and clear. As per the pictures not being 'identical' pictures of the Guru Sahibs -how come the Sikhs, a people akin to symbolism and symbolic thought have now sought to judge everything on mere 'face value'. This does explain why so many Singhs and Singhnias of today are described in the following way: "man, s/he "LOOKS" so chardi kala"

Re: Images on this web site

singh · 16 Dec 2004

>>As per the pictures not being 'identical' pictures of the Guru Sahibs -how come the Sikhs, a people akin to symbolism and symbolic thought have now sought to judge everything on mere 'face value'.<< Since when did the sikh people use guru's pictures as their symbols? was this prevalent during the guru's times? Are there any stories in sikh history of the guru's giving anyone their picture to use as a means to worship or as a sikh symbol?

Re: Images on this web site

moortee · 16 Dec 2004

Bhai Gurdas Ji says, "Gur Moorat Gur Shabad Hai....." I think that answers everything.

Re: Images on this web site

pictures · 17 Dec 2004

how do you know that is a likeness to Guru nanak dev ji, maybe Sobha singhs is better? Just because some said baba Nand singh ji name, suddenly it is right. Maybe the painter just used that name to promote his picture. What happened to Guroo Mooraat Guru Shabad Hai ( the image of the Guru is the shabad)?

Re: Images on this web site

khalistani · 17 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!! that nanaksar pic is a very accurate one but, just get darsahn ureself to find out sant gurbachan singh je also told an artist to draw guru gobind singh jes pic, and sant je told him how guru je looked the pic, i think sant je said it was 90 percent true this picture is kept at hazoor sahib but POOJA of it is wrong but that doesnt mean we cant keep pics just to remind us of our histroy, etc. bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!!

Re: Images on this web site

A Singh · 17 Dec 2004

Dear Singh, Please do not distort my words, I have never indicated that we should worship these pictures. One does one have huge pictures of Bhai Sahib or Sant Jee in their homes and in Gurdwaras? Oh becuase that;s what they really looked like? Or, perhaps, because these great persons mean something, when one sees their picture, it inspires one to think of what they have done etc. Likewise, Gurdwaras bearing the pictures of the 10 Gurus etc do the same, what is so wrong with this?

Re: Images on this web site

blech · 17 Dec 2004

Look, people have taken this post totally wrong. Im not surprised at some of the responses. I wasn't remarking on whether or not the picture of Guru Sahibs are accurate or not. I dont care about that. My intent in the post was to highlight that the main images on sites are now of individuals (i.e. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale). Im not saying that these people are not great Gursikhs. They are great Gursikhs. We should all strive to reach that level. But sometimes I wonder whether or not we put some of these individuals at an iconic level. We say that we are following the Rehit of XXXXXXXX "Put a name in here" Singh of XXXXXXX "Put a name in here" Jatha. We only think of ourselves as members of one group following a certain individual's rehit.

Re: Images on this web site

....... · 18 Dec 2004

"how do you know that is a likeness to Guru nanak dev ji, maybe Sobha singhs is better?" An artist can draw a lot better of a picture with the person sitting in front of them than from their imagination. A picture reminds you of something. There is nothing wrong with remembering Guru Nanak. And gurbani says that if you say Dhan to the Guru, jamdoots cannot come near to you.

Re: Images on this web site

pic · 18 Dec 2004

A singh, the reason so many sikhs do n't like piics of gurus in gurdvaras is cuz people start worshipping them;. most of these pics are simple portraits. maybe if they showed some history, they r beter, but what's the point of portraits of gurus? specially when they aren't even correct. we already have too much moorti pooja going, there's no point for guru pics. you go to gurduara for gurdarshan, which is gotten from gur shabad, guru granth saahib jee, not some fake paintings. if you at a gurdvara, you should already be remembering the guru just by being there. otherwise there is something big time wrong with you, if even at guruduara you need fake pics to rmemeber guru ji. thas all i gotta say. thanks.

Re: Images on this web site

.. · 18 Dec 2004

The picture is always in every gurdawara sahib. How comes no ons noticed? Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji Mahraj! guruuuuuuuuuuuu

Re: Images on this web site

** · 19 Dec 2004

People hang up pictures of their family. Daas hangs up photos of Dhan Guru Nanak!

Re: Images on this web site

Rain Drop · 20 Dec 2004

Dear blech ji, I agree, that there should be no individualism or jathaism as a label, when we are discussing the religion/sikhism for its spirituality. We are sikhs first and then "of any sikh group", if at all necessary. Saints belong to the world and every sikh is a Saint. (But please note, groups are a necessity generally, may be a necessary evil.) But as far the main site of this website, is concerned; I like it. It is very simple. Having decided that no picture of Guru Sahiban is "True"; what are the options? Gurdwaras, Sikh rituals, Sikhs? Kirtan is the most important activity of sikhism. It is personal, social, ritual, spiritual, every thing. A group of sikhs doing rather enjoying Kirtan, as shown in the picture, conveys a lot. It looks great {just watch it again}. Interestingly and wisely enough, they have given no mention of Bhai Randhir Singh in the text on the main site. New visitor, will not get confused to see this picture. There is no particular focus on any person. "There is a group of religious singers" it conveys to the newcomer. With regards and Bhul Chuk lai Khima Rain drop

Re: Images on this web site

A Singh · 20 Dec 2004

Dear "pic", I note your comments, but the situation is not the occurance of having pictures, but the ignorance of people, which is what needs to be tackled. By saying no to pictures, we have lost out much in the way of great arts in Sikhi and left with cheap photo relics based on Sohba Singh's works. The issue you outline is tackled by Parchar and encouraging Sikhs to activitely promote their own education. Even if we read the writings of Baba Gurbachan Singh Bindrawale, we will note that he encouraging keeping photos of the Gurus and other historical figures in one's home and else where, whilst clearly stating these are NOT to be worshipped. It is no different as stated to keeping pictures of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh or Sant Jarnail Singh, Baba Nand Singh, Baba Deep Singh Shaheed etc -we are not to worship these photos, however I would't be surprised if someone somewhere was stupid enough to start doing that -not the fault of the photo, but of their understanding. Taking the photo away is not going to solve the issue.

Re: Images on this web site

Dhan Dhan · 21 Dec 2004

Dhan Guru Nanak Tuhi Nirankar Tuhi Nirankar Baba Tuhi Nirankar Tuhi Tuhi Tuhi Tuhi Tuhi Tuhi Tuhi Tu Tuhi Tu Tuhi Tu Tuhi Tu Tuuuuuuuuu Tuuuuuuuuuu dharasan dhaekh jeevaa gur thaeraa || Gazing upon the Blessed Vision of Your Darshan, I live. pooran karam hoe prabh maeraa ||1|| My karma is perfect, O my God. ||1||