Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

lakhvir singh · 07 Dec 2004

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! KhalsaJi, I do not intend to create animosity between any Jathas or religious groups, but have posed the question on Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom in purely good faith. I think it is such a controversial issue, that many will not even want to discuss it. But like sibling rivalries, the best solution is to to talk it out like brothers and sisters and dig out the truth, and not live in doubts or misbelief. It is a humble bentee to the online Sangat to please refrain from accusations, insults and defamation of the players involved in this controversy. The general mission of this post is to simply iron out the falsehoods and rake in the truth, accept it and move on to continue building our great Khalsa Panth. Let us all respect each one's beliefs and stand, but understand that to stay united, we must have one resolution, now two. I am one of the thousands of those who admire the personality, works and sacrifices of SantJi to the Khalsa Panth. It is in this perspective that I, too, seek understanding that there is about SantJi. Tomorrow, when I have my own family and my kids will ask me questions, I need to be prepared for them. I need to gather all the answers that I can that they are bound to demand. I need them to continue in the path of GurSikhi and be preapred for all that our Panth is yet to face. For that, I wish to begin learning now. I'm also requesting the Sangat on this forum to help us all in clearing the mist surrounding SantJi. We must do this in a calm and humble manner. Ultimately, it is truth that will triumph, so thump our chest to prove our points? Some day, these questions must be answered. It has been over 20 years and we are still divided on SantJi. Let's end that division here. Enough. The Guru has blessed us all with enough wisdom to weigh the truth against the untruth and choose only truth. I have heard SantJi speeches and seen his videos. I have also read as many books as I could lay my hand on and it is no doubt, to begin with, that I think SantJi was indeed a true Sant-Sipahi. Where we all stand divided is on not only about his life, but on his death, too. From my understanding, this is what I have to say about SantJi, that many Sikhs do not concur with. I may be wrong, and where I am, please do correct this moorakh. And where we are right, let's accept it and move on. • If SantJi is not Shaheed, why the curtain of secrecy, when even in this era, we sorely need a leader like him? • If SantJi is shaheed, why has two decades elapsed and yet we have not another leader like him? • SantJi defended the Khalsa Panth with his life. After the massacres and desecrations, is it not strange that if SantJi is not shaheed, he would have re-emerged to seek account for the crimes leashed out on his beloved peoples? • Those that do not accept SantJi's ways, I only wish to ask them to what level their Sikhi is. If SantJi must be questioned, then why have those who have questioned, not become our leaders? If they did have differences with SantJi, and they were right, that would make them better than SantJi, right? • If SantJi is shaheed, why is his leadership not being emulated by those that he represented and inspired? These are only some of the questions circling my mind. There will be many more, as we discuss them further. I look forward to learning from you all. Please let us keep this discussion clean and positively progressive. If at any stage, the discussion does take a wrong turn, I humbly make a bentee to Admin to close the thread. But please let us give these questions our thoughts. They are plaguing us now and we do not want the plague to carry forward to another generation. Twenty years are enough to live in doubt, misbelief and division. Let us please help ourselves in understanding those that selflessly served the the Khalsa Panth's cause and also disassociate ourselves with that which is false and against the teachings of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and our Sikh Rehat Maryada. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! L*

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

khalistani · 08 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! veer je, for ure first question i dont know y only baba je knows where sant je y in this era? i dont know, i aint a bahm giani but as we know a bahm giani dont go around telling everything watever hukam comes to baba je, he does that and if there wasnt secreacy, the india gov. wud be after sant je sant je has been in bandagi ans still is they will only come out on the hukam of akal veer je or ure other question, and a one asked a lot wudnt sant je come during the attacks on sikhs like i said, it all works according to hukam if guru je wanted they cud have made khalsa raj in a blink of an eye, and made it so nothing ud ever happen to sikhs but they didnt dont u think they wud know in 84 this wud happen so y didnt guru je come down and save harimander sahib and akal takht, or in nov. save the sikhs? of course its possible, but it all runs according to hukam of paremesuar vaheguru i answered ure, if sant je isnt shaheed, questions i hope it helps to me the main thing is to the people who say they love sant je sooo much, but then say hes shaheed, and we say it to honour him how are u honouring him? sant je in a recorded speech told sikhs to listen to baba je if anything happened for someone who LED the kaum in a tragic time, with no sikh like him arising since guru jes times and awakened the kaum in such power, the least we can do is listen to one of their bentis, right? and baba je says sant je isnt shaheed, he will come back and raise the flags of khalsa raj bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Singh Khalsa · 08 Dec 2004

I'm sure people out there have "answers" to all those questions. Far-fetched, uncredible, unbelievable answers, of course. For some people, only a corpse could put to rest their claims. Baba Jarnail Singh Jee was born 57 years ago.... so I suppose certain people can continue believing with blind faith for another 30 years or so.

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

....... · 08 Dec 2004

What difference does it make to your life. Are you going to spend the rest of your life asking if there are other life forms in outer space? which there are. the truth is out there.....

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 08 Dec 2004

<<<<>>> What makes you so sure ?? Only 30 years ?? According to the namdharis Guru Gobind Singh Ji lived on for 130 years after 1708.. According to the diehard followers of Neta Ji Shubash Chander Bos...he is coming back any time soon...his plane crashed in 1944 and he was about 40 then.. And best of all...JESUS is coming back also...after 2000 years... He also walked out of his tomb..remember SO we do have historical evidences....IT is not all hocus pocus.. You just have to have the SHARDHA in Baba Ji....time will tell. jarnail Singh

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

lakhvir singh · 08 Dec 2004

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! VeerJi, It does make a difference. I am a Sikh and just like I read about my Gurus and our great GurSikhs, I also seek to know as much as I can about Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, so that I can inspire myself and our coming generations and become a better Sikh. A Sikh's thirst for knowledge, especially in the need to become better and worthy Sikh of the Guru, is ever burning. So VeerJi, it does make a difference to my life to seek answers, because we share the same Sikhi of the Guru. I am not interested in anything else more at this point. Is asking questions about my Panth equivalent to wanting to know 'other life forms in outer space'? The truth is out there, as you so rightly say. So please tell me what it is then. I do not know, that is why I ask. I place my bentee at your humble feet, VeerJi, please do quench the thirst of this poor Sikh who wishes nothing more than simple understanding. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! L*

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

respect to shaheeds · 08 Dec 2004

baba jarnail singh promised many times in his speeches that he would ONLY leave the darbar sahib complex if a. the dharm yudh morcha was succesful and therefore the Anandpur Sahib Resoultion was passed. b. or dead, on the back of an army truck. he also promised to weigh the killer or killers of gurbachana in gold. he also promised to personaly compensate every family that had sarificed for the panth in the morcha. he also promised to get two jeeps back from the government in place of the one jeep of the sangat's destroyed by the government back in 1982. these are just some of the promises he made. baba jarnail singh was not a liar. he could never dare to lie. he made these promises to his GURUS, the Guru Granth Sahib and the Khalsa Panth. he considered himself nothing more than a slave of the sangat and would never dare to lie to them. so, those who say baba jarnail singh is alive are in fact saying that he was a liar. that he was a fraud and that he was a coward. he made these promises... what happened? noone was weighed in gold. the familes were not compensated and the ASR was not implemented. Baba jee did say that IF he did die he would make sure to pay all his debts back in the next world, meaning that he would fulfill his promises in his next life, that is how seriously he took his promises. dont disrespect this great sikh. it is in him that we can learn so many lessons of what it means to be a sikh and how to live like a khalsa. shaheedi is the HIGHEST honour a sikh can ever recieve. it is the greatest title a sikh can aspire to. to take away a true shaheed's title of shaheedi is a great disrespect and you should seriously worry about the disrespect you are doing to this beloved sikh of the guru. baba jarnail singh would NEVER EVER EVER have left the darbar sahib complex. he would never have let bhai amrik singh and general shabeg singh die and leave them there to run off to who knows where. he was never a coward and was never afraid to face death. he knew that in SHAHEEDI, his power and influence would be even GREATER than in life. by saying baba jee is going to come back, you are falling into judeo-christian messianic traditions. meaning, you are all waiting for someone else to come back and solve all your problems. this is exactly what the government wanted when it made up this straight up and stupid lie. jarnail singh wanted to show sikhs they were slaves in india! he wanted us to wake up to the truth of the situation! he wanted us to rise up and take a stand ourselves! he didnt want to be a leader. he didnt want to lead us, he said he was just our watchdog, barking to warn us off danger. that was how humble he was. even if he was alive, everything he said and did in life show that he didnt want sikhs to think of him as their saviour. the guru is our saviour, and we are the the GURU KHALSA PANTH! we, the sikhs, have the power to do anything as long as we live by the principles of the gurus. we dont need leaders! that is what baba jee tried to show us. he desperatly wanted sikhs to ALL WAKE UP and see the truth. he knew that maybe in death he stood this chance. and yet still many of us wait to be lead into heaven, like sheeps being lead by a sheppard. remember, guru gobind singh said that his sikhs were not sheep, but lions, proud and strong, and could not be lead by anyone anywhere. guruFATEH! singh

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

respect to shaheeds part two · 08 Dec 2004

even in a hundred years those who believe that he is coming back will continue to. this trick has been played on sikhs before. study your history!!!! when baba ram singh (later used by namdharis for their fake religion) was sent away to burma, rumours were created to say he would come back one day to lead the panth... some still believe he will come back and namdharis still say that ram singh never died but is still alive, somewhere out there.... waiting in the jungle for the right time... that was over 150 years ago!!! baba ram singh would be over 200 years old!! but stupidity knows no bounds

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

(((:>>> · 08 Dec 2004

I do not think the Indian Gov would be bothered if Sant ji came out now. He would be no real threat to them. Instead most sikhs who respect as a Shaheed would turn on him, and ask him after all of these sikh youth dieing. Why did you disappear and stay quiet?

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

10th regiment · 08 Dec 2004

this is silly topic as it all boils down to PERSONAL opinion generally taksalis will say hes alive because baba thakur singh ji 'says so' others will say he isnt because of 'proof' ie pciture his own brother identifying his body etc

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

shaheedkhalsa.com · 08 Dec 2004

there is so much other stuff we could discuss, we do not need to get involved in discussion like this. Each to there own

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Singh Soorma · 08 Dec 2004

ok then since u guys dont believe sant jarnail singh is alive. for my sake just suppose he comes back. how will u feel after some of u dis believing bramgiani baba takhur singh ji and some go to the extent of doing his nindya. how will u react when sant ji comes back or in ur minds IF he comes back?

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Singh · 08 Dec 2004

good

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

S Singh · 08 Dec 2004

>>how will u feel after some of u dis believing bramgiani baba takhur singh ji and some go to the extent of doing his nindya Sant Ji's own brother said he saw the body after Bluestar and that he is dead.

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Singh Soorma · 09 Dec 2004

this argument is stupid only a fool argues with another fool

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

I DON'T KNOW ANYHTHING · 09 Dec 2004

lakvir singh...your post subject reads "Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom" but....where is the proof?...all you really are saying is "he would never do that" YOUR POST SUBJECT IS VERY UNCLEAR, AND DOES NOT INFACT GIVE ANY 'PROOF'

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

singh · 09 Dec 2004

This is from another forum posted by khalistani: ---- this is a modern day story of a true singh who is still alive this singh is quite invloved with taksal singhs, but lives in a normal house, kurta pyajama, etc. this singh is a really good singh heres the sakhi this singh used to be a normal keshdhari singh, who used to have kharkoo singhs, taksalis, tyar par tyar singhs come to his house and eat langar one day the punjab police comes with a lot of people to arrest him for "helping the enemy", or in truth, doing sewa anyways, he found out and saw them coming and did ardaas to guru je to save him, and if guru je did he will only meditate on guru je forever and never forget him so, when the police comes, the find out theres an emergency in another place, so they just slap him around a bit and go so, this singh starts does 40 days of bhagti at hazoor sahib, of mool mantar patt then he does this again at taran taran sahib and he does it at a couple of more places well, this singh had achieved great amounts of bhagti in his dreams, sant kartar singh wud come and visit him once, his car broke outside of tarn tarn sahib so, he decided to go inside and rest then in his sleep, sant jarnail singh je comes and tells him not to beg for money, we will help u out so, a singh sees this singh out on the street, car broke then the singh goes up and says whos ure guru this singh says guru nanak dev je then he said do u have full faith in ure guru this singh said yes then the singh takes some money out and gives it this singh and says dont say no, u need it so, sants jes words came true so, this singh starts thinking sant je is shaheed he says in a group of people that he thinks sant je is shaheed too the same day in his sleep, sant jarnail singh je comes to him in his dreams and says y did u say i was shaheed sant je says i dont care if the entire world says im shaheed, u cant say it cause u know the truth sant je says i am gupt right now, when the time is right i shall return this singh accepts sant jes bachan bhula chuka maf

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

khalistani · 09 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! veer jes, i dunt understand one thing u compare sant jarnail singh je to namdharis??? and to fake gurus he did so much for the panth, no one like them has awakened the kaum since guur je times, and this is the respect u give him? as for the weiging in gold time, first ud like to go and talk to people who were with sant je and fin out y then ull know y u all forget one of sant jes last RECORDED SPEECHES WHERE THEY SAY TO LISTEN TO SANT BABA THAKUR SINGH JE! intresting how even bani says that the word of a sant wil come true even if the moon mus tbe destroyed and we cant belive the bachans of someone like baba je who devoted their entire life to the khals apanth and sewa simran bani, and someoline sant je who awokened the kaum from a deep sleep, someone like sant je hasnt been born in so many yhears since our gurus who awakened the kaum in such a force i know fake sants bachans are always false but at least give true sants their respect bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

respectfully · 09 Dec 2004

Dear Singh Soorma - Are you a brahm-giani? If not, then you have absolutely no idea whether Baba Takhur Singh ji is or not. I never had a problem with the word brahm-giani and, in fact, used it often myself when referring to sants and the like but the fact of the matter is, unless you yourself have brahm-gian, you have no idea whether someone else does or not. The truth of it is, you can't even tell if someone is a good gursikh or not, let alone if they are a brahm-giani. If you get enough people saying something, in time, everyone seems to unquestioningly start to believe it - if I was to get 10 or 15 people calling me a brahm-giani, a few years from, it would almost be a bona-fide fact. Don't believe the hype about anyone - learn what you can from them, take the good, leave the bad and work on improving myself are the hard earned lessons I've learned over the years - we have no idea who or what people truly are - that is the domain of Akal Purakh. respectfully, Respectfully Singh Soorma wrote: > ok then since u guys dont believe sant jarnail singh is alive. > for my sake just suppose he comes back. how will u feel after > some of u dis believing bramgiani baba takhur singh ji and some > go to the extent of doing his nindya. how will u react when > sant ji comes back or in ur minds IF he comes back?

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

respect · 09 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Jarnail Singh Arshi Giani Ji, in your last post on this thread, im a little confused by it....are you being sarcastic....about saying: >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> What makes you so sure ?? Only 30 years ?? According to the namdharis Guru Gobind Singh Ji lived on for 130 years after 1708.. According to the diehard followers of Neta Ji Shubash Chander Bos...he is coming back any time soon...his plane crashed in 1944 and he was about 40 then.. And best of all...JESUS is coming back also...after 2000 years... He also walked out of his tomb..remember SO we do have historical evidences....IT is not all hocus pocus.. You just have to have the SHARDHA in Baba Ji....time will tell. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

10th regiment · 09 Dec 2004

i agree with respect to shaheeds

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

harpreet · 10 Dec 2004

If sant ji returns how many people will be pissed because he did not actively fight in the movement while others died, and how many will support him in belief that it was hukam of Guru ji?

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

i wonder why · 10 Dec 2004

i wonder why people keep trying to prove this? what are you gonna get out of it? how will your life be fulfilled by creating stupid political threads that boil down to group differences? the truth wil be revealed with time, until then, everyone should stop talking so much

Re: Proof of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's martrydom

Admin · 10 Dec 2004

This discussion isn't going anywhere useful. Thread closed.