Re: Pad Chhed bir
Singh Khalsa · 08 Dec 2004
Obviously Padh Chedh saroops should be given lots of respect, as should every piece of Gurbani.. but there's a difference between "respect" and "considering it to be the Guru".
Only the unaltered, unchanged version that Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee MADE to be the Guru can be the Guru.
There are dozens upon dozens of potential mistakes in Padh Chedh saroops, where splitting words could go either way.
How could Guru Sahib possibly be imperfect? It can't be...
Thus, only the Lareevaar Saroop can ever be Guru.
Re: Pad Chhed bir
Singh Soorma · 08 Dec 2004
Khalsa-
how do u say that Sant Kartar SIngh ji said that. show me proof. thats the most ridiculous thing ive ever heard of. thats absurd taksal doesnt believe in pad ched.
Re: Pad Chhed bir
dhan hamara meet · 08 Dec 2004
What about Gutkas though as A Singh pointed out?
Re: Pad Chhed bir
Singh Soorma · 08 Dec 2004
Taksal Believes in Padched and Lareevar as 1 equal bani. Both as Sggs ji. Lareevar is not higher then Pad ched and Padched is not Higher then Lareevar they are the same. both guru ji.
Re: Pad Chhed bir
respectfully · 09 Dec 2004
I disagree. By not bowing you would be showing great disrespect and that failure to bow would be more indicative of hankaar than anything else.
On the issue of pad ched or larivaar, I am undecided and hope the Panth can come to a resolution as serious discussion on this issue would be beneficial - I would be happy with whatever decision is reached.
In the meantime, both saroops are Guru ji in my eyes and they will be afforded the same respect. This talk of true Guru (as opposed to a fake Guru!!!????) is highly disrespectful and Sikhs should refrain from making such comments.
That is gurbani housed within the physical body, and while the physical body may have some difference, that saroop still deserves every ounce of respect we have and there should be no hesitation in laying down one's head, either in deference to Guru ji or in defence of Guru ji's honor.
If the pad ched saroops are an excercise in manmat, then lets hit that matter in a responsible manner and slowly (or quickly) replace those saroops with larivaar saroops. In the meantime, show whichever saroop, pad ched or larivaar, the utmost respect.
respectfully,
Respectfully
Singh wrote:
> By bowing to pad ched guru granth sahib, you are disrespecting
> the true guru in larivar form which Guru Gobind Singh ji
> accepted.
>
> Why are we so eager to accept a guru which is created by people
> other than the Guru?
>
> Are we becoming like another sect the "Pad ched guru
> believers"?
Re: Pad Chhed bir
Caprice Sun · 09 Dec 2004
Their is an excellent article on this site on the matter...it is highly recommeded that everyone who contributes to this thread read that article.
I think of pad ched saroop as a pothi sahib and afford it the same respect. It is not mandatory to matha tek to pothi sahib but one can do it out of sharda.
If I ever go to gurdwara sahib where they do parkash of pad ched saroop then I matha tek, mostly because I don't want to create a scene.
Now many of you will ask are you not matha teking to gurbani. The message is the same etc. etc.
Well no the message is not the same. Pad ched is done by people and thus there will always be mistakes. Doing pad ched incorrectly changes the meaning drastically. The worst thing is that majority of the people accept pad ched to be correct and never try to learn paath for themselves.
Doing paath from a pad ched saroop breaks the direct connection between Sikh and Guru. You are giving the task of discovering gurbani to someone else. why would somone want to miss the opportunity of discovering their guru?
Think about it. Is it, "EkOankar Satgur parsad" or "Ekoankar sat gurparsad". If we can't even decide on this then how can we proceed on to all the rest of Gurbani?
So to answer your question ... I think ideally we shouldn't go anywhere where they do parkaash of pad ched saroop because that is the only way to force the gurdwaras to revert back to doing parkash of larivaar saroop.
You guys know what the worst thing is.
First we do something (printing pad ched saroops) and then instead of correcting our mistake and asking guru sahib for forgivness for having such overly large egos... we try to justify our actions.
Guru is eternal, PERFECT and complete truth. When we filter gurbani through our limited intellect by printing pad ched saroops then we are taking that quality away from guru sahib.
I think this is a serious mistake. And all people who promote that padched saroop is same as larivaar saroop are equally guilty as those who printed pad ched sarrop in the first place... and might I mention they did it against resolutions passed by SGPC against pad ched printing.
Re: Pad Chhed bir
Jasvir Kaur · 14 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
agreed veer A Singh Ji.
Perhaps we should adopt larivaar in our DAILY LIFE as well. ALL TEXTS..including Guru Ji's Hukmnamas etc are all in LARIVAAR style. It is just an aspect of the way things were then....
Soheregoestherestofmymessageisinlarivaarcanwelivewiththatorisitpractical ???
jasvir Kaur
Re: Pad Chhed bir
Jugraj Singh · 16 Dec 2004
A Singh,
>>>
to argue we should not respect the pad-ched saroop is frankly idiotic - what will it take, the RSS to turn around and begin disrespecting these 'ped-ched' saroops?
>>>
No one has argued that we shouldn't respect pad-ched saroop. No Sikh would.
People are simply saying that the larivaar saroop is the poora guru.
I don't understand the argument. First we think we are intelligent enough to change maraharaj da saroop then instead of admitting we made a mistake (which according to mata passed by the panth we did) we go on to justify that mistake.
I want to know from the people that promote the printing of pad-ched saroop... why? Why do you promote it?
What is your reasoning? Please enlighten the rest of us moorakhs who belive that Guru Sahib knew what he was doing when he wrote Gurbani in Larviaar saroop.
I mean if he only wrote bani in larivaar because that was the style of the time then I guess that Guru Granth sahib jee being in the form of a text also was a reflection of the time and we can go ahead and install a computer on the Gurgaddi. That way we can have both larivaar and pad-ched saroops. Even better huh??? Look, we out did our ancestors!! We improved our guru and made our guru more approachable to the new generation!!
This is sure to give the panth chardi kala in the coming decades.
Jasvir Kaur,
What was the point of your post? What are you trying to convey? Please refrain from wasting board space. It make the theads unnecessairily longer.