Punj
singh · 03 Dec 2004
Was there any bibi in the punj pyaray during the time of Bhai Sahib Randhir SIngh?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
singh · 03 Dec 2004
Was there any bibi in the punj pyaray during the time of Bhai Sahib Randhir SIngh?Balpreet Singh · 03 Dec 2004
Speaking to Singhs from Bhai Sahib's times, one Singh told us that a bibi did do seva in one amrit sinchaar he remembered.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Dec 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. WHY does this question keep springing up. So what if during Bhai Sahib Jee's time there were or were no bibis in the PUNJ PIYARAS.... it doesnt alter that fact that BIBIS can do sewa of PUNJ. ONLY the SANTS/DERAWALLAHS OBJECT to Bibis doing sewa in the PUNJ..in fact any sewa is also frowned upon..if a SANT follower organsises an Akhand Paath in MALAYSIA he is sure to INSIST on ONLY MALE PAATHIS. This is huge BHARAM and anti GURMATT. Bibis are just as GOOD as any Male...ONLY CHAUVANISTIC MALES object...and these types seem to have an upper hand at Harmandir sahib Amrtisar as well, where the bibis are not even allowed cleaning the floor sewa or kirtan sewa among others. Jarnail singhManpreet Kaur · 03 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh This came up in a conversation with my family the other day. I have always been treated fairly the same as my brothers. Always given the same freedom and generally the same rules applied to us. Although, no matter what society has always forced my parents to be "careful" with me. Anyway, we were talking about how women usually had to move into the man's house after marriage. This isn't the case for everybody, but in my family all the pabeeya moved in with my brothers. This is very common. Why is that? Why does the female leave her parents and settle in the man's house? Is this considered Sikh culture? In Sikhi man and woman are equal, so how come the male never moves in with the woman's family? Just a question. My dad told me that even the Guru's wives moved with them. That left me speechless and not able to argue any further. Mainly because I don't have knowledge about it. Some things just aren't acceptable for bibiya. But my question is WHY? I don't have a lot of knowledge, but I've noticed when men wear a cholah/bana, whatever you want to call it. They don't wear the bottom part. Their legs are showing. Yes, their kachera is long and covering everything. But my question is, what if a bibi was to not wear the bottom pajamee? Would this be acceptable? A Singh once argued that its just wrong for a bibi to show her legs. OK no arguement against that! but aren't they the same legs a man is showing? Why is it ok for a man to show his legs? You see the same thing. Women all over the world are put second to men. I'm not saying that no one treats women equal. I'm just saying that I feel as if we constantly preach equality and that both are able citizens to work hard and carry the family name but little things are looked at in a such an absurd way. In China, there is a one child law to control population. Most families prefer a son over a daughter because a son can take care of the parents and carry the family name, while the daughter would have to move into the man's family when shes married. Similar to most Sikh people. Due to this tradition or culture, whatever you want to call it. People are abadoning their daughters. Leaving them in boxes on the streets, killing them when they are born, etc. because they want a son not a daughter. China's orphans are packed with young girls. Due to the large amount of babies that orphanges had and weren't able to take care of, they started leaving the children in "dying rooms" where the young girls were just left to die. If someone doesn't beleive me. Do some research on it. Like Jarnail Singh ji said, even in Harmandir Sahib, Amritsar the bibiya are not allowed to do chor seva, work in the kitchen or do kirtan. This is heartbreaking. Lastnight I coudln't sleep thinking about this. I took amrit because I am so passionate about Sikhi's principles. I grew up with all brothers and have always been big on equality for male and females, mainly due to the fact that my father has taught me this. When I became amritdhari, I was so proud to say I am a Sikh because I felt that Sikhi is one thing that does not discriminate regardless of gender, age, colour, or creed. Even other religions do. Sikhi is really great. The situation at Amritsar is really heartbreaking for me personally. Sikhi has no faults, don't get me wrong. The faults are in us who have accepted these ways without knowing where they come from. Why do we continue to do things that don't maintain the equality that we preach? and continue to let sexist attitudes or behaviors that promote stereotyping of social roles based on gender continue? Maybe this sounds like a whole bunch of stupidness coming from a little angry girl, but I really think its something to think about and a problem that Sikhs have. Not all but MOST. Those that call themselves Guru's Sikhs, but then say a female cannot do punj pyare seva, or like those sexist hypocrites at Harmandir Sahib who don't let women do kirtan or chor seva need to look at themselves and realize the things they are supporting and see if they are really upholding Sikhi's principles. That person who calls himself a Sikh and discriminates against females need to stop pretending to possess beliefs, feelings, or virtues that he does not possess because that just makes them a hypocrite. To pose as a Sikh and say that your sister who is equal to man because she has also taken Guru’s amrit cannot do a seva or needs to do certain things because she is female needs to stop! That is not Sikhi, instead is against Sikhi. The discrimination needs to stop. Manpreet KaurSingh · 03 Dec 2004
actually, Guru Ram Das moved in to his in-laws after he married Bibi Bhani ji. But I don't think it's 'discrimination' if that's how it goes. How many families of girls would want their son in law living with them anyways?. · 04 Dec 2004
well im a boy i wudnt mind moving with my in laws, no mortgage bill stress. · 04 Dec 2004
most of wat manpreet sis says is related to culture, as for who moves in with who after marriage aint a big prob huna? guru ji gave equality to all thats all u gotto remember. our shrines r controlled by people who arent interested in keeping sikhi alive so dont expect much from them. we must educate society about such issues so we can all stand together and demonstrate against the unfairness and demand change for women.GunNidhan · 04 Dec 2004
I have a question for you Jarnail. Do they have bibis in the punj in Malaysia? I would like a direct answer without all of the other loon/mirch/masala please, thank you.Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Gunnidhaan Ji, YES. The SNSM SIKH NAUJAWAN SABHA MALAYSIA the premier Sikh Youth Organsiation for the past 30 years, (Patrons: Sant Baaba Sohan Singh Ji Melaka and Sant Gyani Niranjan Singh Patiala Shiromani Kathakaar) has BIBIS in its PUNJ PIYARAE. The Punj Jatha of SNSM that administered Amrit to me on September 1st 2002 Had a BibI Ji as a Member. The SNSM holds a Annual Gurmat Samelan that has over 2500 Participants from as far as Australia/NewZealand/Thailand/Indonesia/Fiji...as well as the locals Malaysia/Singapore. The SNSM has the active SUPPORT of ALL GURDWARAS and other Sikh Organisations in the region and carries out AMRIT SANCHAAR activities as an ongoing affair..through out the region. Some have tried to "copy" their Gurmatt samelans, and other activities, even oferring FREE bus rides etc but failed miserably to challenge the snsm's domination. MOST IMPORTANTLY the SNSM adheres strongly to the SIKH REHAT MARYADA approved and published by the AKAL TAKHAT/SGPC printed. The SANT/BABAJI/MAHAPURASH LOBBY on the other hand ( i think you KNOW who these people are....naming them just gets their HACKLES UP !! a very UNGURMATT behaviour if you ask me..but what the heck who cares anyway ) effectively FROWNS on BIBIS....in the Punj, in the Akhand Paath..where its MEN ONLY - preferably wearing long cholas without pajamees..) I hope this is "straight enough " for you veer Ji. Jarnail SinghPardeep Singh Bilga · 06 Dec 2004
I read somewhere that this same question was posed to Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale- "Why are there not women in the panj pyare, while you/Sikhism are clearly stating that women are equal to men?" Sant ji's response was that when Guru Gobind Singh ji maharaj asked for 5 heads on that day of the birth of the Khalsa, 13 April 1699, the 5 volunteers were all MALE- from a congregation of 1/4 million. Not 1 bibi came forward. This is not discrimination, but it is just following tradition. An example is- Christians/history know Jesus was male (they have had many films where Jesus is played by an actor)- who is coincidentally also MALE. You would not see a woman playing Jesus, so when we have nagar kirtans etc the "part" of the panj pyare is given to men. I am not saying women are not as important etc (before I get attacked outright by my sisters out there!) but just think about Sant ji's answer, it makes sense. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, sri Waheguru ji ki fateh!Manpreet Kaur · 06 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ki khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Pardeep Singh ji, yes the five that got up were all male but if you look at it more importantly, they are five Khalsas regardless of gender. If a bibi follows strict rehat and is capble of being apart of the punj, why should she be stopped? Just because shes not a male right? That whats it sounds like to me your saying. Now when doing seva of punj pyare, are the punj ROLE PLAYING that they have to be males to fit the part? or are they five Khalsas blessing others with amrit and naam? What I am trying to say is that, when people role play as Jesus thats fine, he was male and therefore, a male acts out his role. The five beloved ones are not role playing. Manpreet KaurJarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhen Ji manpreet kaur Ji is absolutely right. The PUNJ are not "role playing"...they are KHALSAS bestowing on us the Gift of Amrit...and ANY member of the Khalsa that fits the PART ( rehat) can be a member of the PUNJ. What "special" gift that a male punj can give that a "female" punj cannot give...in other words what "value added" to the Amrit comes from a MALE that cannot come from a FEMALE ?? GURBANI also clearly says and we daily hear in Asa DI waar..So kion manda akheyeh jit jammeh rajaan... IF "SHE" is judged capable by God to give birth to KIngs..surely "she" can also bestow on us the gift of Amrit as a PUNJ. jarnail Singh.Caprice Sun · 07 Dec 2004
Guru sahib says, "KHALSA MERO ROOP HAI KHAAS". He didn't say male Sikhs are my khaas roop. He said Khalsa. Khlasa has no gender. In light of this, I do not know how anyone can argue against bibi's doing sewa in punj. However, if you still insist that the original punj pyare were male then let me ask you this: Were they also not from different geographical areas? Were they not all different heights? Were they not all of different build? They had many physical disimilarities... So why choose gender as the dividing line? I think a more beneficial one would be to use kamaiee as the dividing line. IF women can be brahmgianis and have the avastha of "brahmgiani apay nirankar" then why can they not do sewa as punj? If women can give shaheedis then why are they not good enough to do sewa as punj? Infact look at it this way. The first 10 gurus were all male. Guru Granth sahib is in the form of a text. Do we now reject our guru because the body that contains the jot is not a human male body? Are the punj pyare not guru as well? Then how can we require them to have a certain physical makeup. More importantly, lets look inside of us and refelct on what gives us (individuals) the ability to question who the punj can be. We who are so filled with filth, selfishness and greed... how dare we think ourselves wise enough to define for the panth who the guru can be.khalsaa · 07 Dec 2004
I wonder if Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's wife was ever in the punj pyaarey. She would definitely have been worthy considering her grand devotion. If there is no difference between the genders, then why does the sangat sit on opposite sides? Why is there a seperate washrooms? If someone asks me where I received amrit from, I say from Bhai Daya Singh, Bhai Dharam Singh, Bhai Himmat Singh, Bhai Mohkam Singh, Bhai Sahib Singh. I do not say Bhai something Kaur. The punj during amrit ceremony are in fact a representation of the original punj!Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. Veer Khalsa Ji, You write: <Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I read this para on another thread posted by dr Devinder Singh ji: It has relevance here as well. << Dr. Ji quotes from a book on the struggles of Sikh women in the Akali movement and the Gurdwara Reforms Movement...of which Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh ji was also a prime mover: << .......All these reforms have been made possible by the remarkable awakening among the Sikh women. They are working shoulder to shoulder with their husbands and brothers to justify Guru Gobind Singh's baptism, which they receive along with men. In the beginning of the present movement an old-fashioned Sikh happened to remark, before an assembly of Sikhs at the Akal Takht, that women should not be allowed to come upon the sacred Takht, as they did not show the same force of character as men. As soon as these words were uttered, a host of women, old and young, wearing kirpans, came forward and demanded of the Sikh to tell them what the men could do which they, the women, who had received Guru Gobind Singh's Amrit, could not do. They carried children in their arms, and were not ashamed of being mothers. Some of them, in their zeal to work along with men, have taken to tying turbans. The Akali Jathas of Amritsar, Lahore, Ludhiana,. Ambala and Nabha are in favour of this practice. >> Hear Hear all those against women in the PUNJ !!! jarnail Singh.khalistani · 08 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! the day in 1699 out of a crowd of a quarter million not one bibi thought it worthy to give their head for guru je only panj singhs went so till this day the same thing has been going on at amrit sanchaars same maryada as for pyajami, mai bhagos cholas have always a pyajama with them u bcan even check till in india guru gobind singh je had some with pyajama, but also had only cholas too to tell the truth start doing 112 japji sahibs a day all of taksal sundar gutka with nitenm which has sukhmani sahib, asa de vaar, shabad hazare, al ot of other banis :) im sure ull find out the answer then ive realized in the past few weeks perhaps instead of arguing over every little thing, we shud go do this much paat, and find the answers for ourselves bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!Akj'er · 08 Dec 2004
This kid is funnykabaddi · 08 Dec 2004
go read guru gobinds singh jis 52 hukams... manpreet kaur... its also in some rehat namas... a girls parents are not to eat from their daughter after marriage... ppl still do this.... they wont eat at their daughters house unless they b ring over some gift like sweets or something... in anand karaj ceremony the girls parents give her away to the guy, and the guys parents becme the girls new parents... its as simple as that.... read old rehatnamas , dont listen to meharpreet · 09 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki fateh Women and Men are equal, however they clearly play different roles. They are equal, but in different ways because they play different roles. If it was clear cut and it was as simple as men and women are equal no matter what and women should be allowed in the punj because there equal in all ways to men. Than it is ok to let men and women sit together, go to the same washroom, because well there 'equal'. Men and women are equal just in different ways, and nto allowing women in the punj is not being chavinstic at all, it just once again showing that the two genders play different roles. That is my opinion, and remember everyone has ther opinion and when someone goes out and says those people who believe women should not be in the punj are chauvanist, would also be calling me a chauvanist, which i am not. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki fatehkhalistani · 09 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!Caprice Sun · 09 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! >>> the day in 1699 out of a crowd of a quarter million not one bibi thought it worthy to give their head for guru je >>> As I understand it, quater million - 5 peple also didn't give their heads. Why discriminate on bases of sex alone? Why not discriminate on height or eye color. We only disriminate based on the most obvious difference. The body is just that ... a body... the soul is what merges with God. The body is a vessel of decay. Just because no bibi stood that day does that mean no bibi ever stood up? Does guru sahib judge all Sikh bibi's of the future by the inaction of a few? The day in 2004. Many are still lost as to the true principles of Sikhism. KHALSA HAS NO IMPLIED GENDER. GURU SAHIB IS SADA DAYAL. HE DOESN'T JUDGE US BY THE ACTIONS OF OUR FAMILY/FRIENDS. HE DOESN'T JUDGE US BY THE ACTIONS OF OUR ENEMIES. HE CERTAINLY DOESN'T JUDGE US ON THE ACTIONS OF THE REST OF OUR GENDER. HE JUDGES BY OUR OWN ACTIONS. >>> only panj singhs went >>> The 10 gurus were all male. The Guru Granth Sahib is in the form of a text. Do you not belive in the Guru Granth Sahib as guru because the joyt is not embodied in a human male body? >>> so till this day the same thing has been going on at amrit sanchaars same maryada >>> So sorry to tell you the maryada has changed drastically. In many of today's amrit sanchars the punj pyare don't give amrit. Only the 1 pyara gives amrit. This is just the most obvious of many many changes. Also there was an amrit sanchar at WEston gurdwara sahib where a bibi did sewa. >>> start doing 112 japji sahibs a day all of taksal sundar gutka with nitenm which has sukhmani sahib, asa de vaar, shabad hazare, al ot of other banis :) im sure ull find out the answer then >>> I'm not even going to get started on this. Bhai RAndhir did bandagi in the worst of physical conditions for a long long time. He certainly belived the punj sewa could be done by tyar bar tyar khalsa ( which includes women) Khalsa Mero roop hai khaas. What is so hard to understand about this? Let me ask you this. Do you belive in Karma? If so then you would know that those Singhs were destined to be Punj Pyare. Just like the 4 sahibzaaday were destined to be. Now because Guru sahib didn't have any daughters are we to assume that all the amritdhari bibis are not acknowledged by guru sahib as daughters? If Taksali baba's did say that women couldn't do sewa in PUnj. they are wrong wrong. No man is perfect. Get over it. Follow your own advice and take a hukamnama. By the way can a women even be jathedar of taksal? I haven't heard of one yet. Is this because the first Jathedar was a male (baba Sundar Singh jee) Your logic also implies that no bibi has the right to offer her head to the guru. If they didn't do it in 1699 then why are they given the opportunity later on? Only men should be given amrit. But women are given amrit. Then according to you the amrit has a lesser effect on women because after getting amrit they are still lacking... still missing something b/c ppl like you say they can't do sewa in punj? You are insulting the power of amrit. If a choora looses his caste, if all are born into a new family then why do you still insist that half of that family still carry the burden for something they had no control in? Guru Nanak Dev ji's own son didn't give his head to the guru. This is Sikhi. Don't follow what people say ... follow what guru says then you will also have truly given your head..... · 09 Dec 2004
I have a question. Is it chauvenistic for only females to give births?Manpreet Kaur · 09 Dec 2004
Well said Caprice Sun! Excellent points!respect · 09 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh caprice sun, plz dont say stuff like Sant Sunder Singh Ji was the 1st Jathedar of Taksal. They themselves said it was Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj and 2nd was Baba Deep Singh Ji. oh and by the way, this isnt a controversial topic...just cause some ppl make up their own stories, it doesnt make it a topic that is "debatable" so caprice sun, benti hai Ji, plz dont say that. it just offends others. thank youone more"male chauvanist" · 09 Dec 2004
Equality is certainly misunderstood, by the so called "Man Woman equal" patrogonisits. Do not make big statements. See the reallity. Saying they are not equal, never means one is better. They are different and are supposed to be. They are made different. I can go further with my talk; but diversity of gender,age and social set up of the posters restricts me. Anyway, my wife agrees with my views. Yours Rain dropbgt · 09 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh this should question shouldn't even come up!!! because who in the right mind claims "Iwant to be one of the panj" any bibi? any bhai? no. if they do, they clearly aren't fit to be included! if thats the case how on earth did this question come up. unless someone was sat around thinking of the principles of sikhi, when in actual fact he/she shud just be simarring on the almighty. the same goes for most other useless questions. theyre possible useful to an outsider just looking at sikhi through an eye piece but as all would agree, the 'looker' would still never capture sikhi's essence until he/she practised it. if the occassion arose where 5singh were not available, it would be common sense and acceptable to allow a tyaar bar tyaar singhni in. otherwise, my PERSONAL view would be to keep them as singh (unless ABsolutely necessary) because we shud consider our minds as full of mannmatt and any ideas thatWE introduce are PROBably contrary to Gurus and we should attempt to emmulate guru's path as much as possible to avoid dilution. so my answer is JUST to be on the safe side, attempt to do what guru did and not what our minds tell us.Bundha · 09 Dec 2004
Khalistani you have nothing to apologise for , do not listen to foolish people who ridicule you, your views are spot on. Guru-maryadha is guru-maryadha. If the original ceremony was with panj Singhs then that is how it must be. The reason we Sikhs are in the state we are in is due to us messing around with Gurus hukum. We do not follow the Guru but rather we feel we are greater or more intelligent then our glorious Guru. We put tables in the langar hall, we allow chairs inside the Darbar sahib, langars have been turned into cafeterias etc etc The more we mess with the maraydha the further we are from our Guru. Bibi’s in the panj piyaray has nothing to do with chauvinism, the genders have different roles to play. I have the utmost respect for bibi’s but the Gurus maryadha must remain intact. It is our egos that cause the problemsthink about it · 09 Dec 2004
Obviously the genders have differences. But how do these differences relate to spirituality and sevas like panj seva? The stupidest thing I've heard so far is that women and men go to bathrooms seperately and so shouldn't do panj seva. Or that women have kids and men don't. Could one of you please explain how the physical differences related to these issues results in women not being able to do panj seva? What is it about these physical differences that is required to do panj seva? Out of a quarter million people, only men got up, so no women is ever allowed to do seva in panj again. Sort of sounds like the idea of original sin in christianity. In gurmat though, it holds no ground. The panj that got up didn't get up as representatives of the male gender. They got up as gursikhs, period. But for some reason, guys seem to think that the kurbanee of these panj was only for males and not for females and that somehow, guys for the rest of eternity should be rewarded and women punished, regardless of individual kamaee. Of course, hundreds of thousands of men didn't volunteer and many thousands ran away. Some men even went and complained to the Guru Jee's Mata Jee that he had gone crazy. So no women got up. But probably a lot more men than women didn't get up either. So who should suffer for the fact that so many men didn't get up? The most important thing of course is, that Guru Gobind Singh Jee did not indicate anywhere that women couldn't do this seva, or any other seva. The requirement is that the person be a sabat surat, tyar bar tyar khalsa, and that is it. We can't find any indication in Guru Granth Sahib Jee that women are incapable of any seva or of reaching god. If there were, than we could say that having a bibi in the punj will prevent guru jee from being present, since the lower status of women prevents Guru Jee from residing there. Another thing to note is that Guru Gobind Singh Jee never indicated that only men could volunteer. This indicates that Guru Jee didn't see any problem in women being able to do this seva. Then after the fact, when only men got up, Guru Jee also did not put any restriction on women as a punishment for them not getting up. People putting these restrictions on now is just their own mat, not the guru's mat.thought about it · 10 Dec 2004
Those are excellent points "think about it ji". We definately never think about the points you've mentioned. The ratio of men to women has almost always been in favor of men, so the assumption can be made that more men were probably present there than women. Each and every male definately didn't go running up.khalistani · 10 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! when did i say bhai randheer singh je didnt do bhandagi? i know he did mad bhagti and thas y i respect him i never knew bhai sahib said in one of their books its ok for bibis to be in panj pyarae? please give me the name of the book by the way and i dunt know how u think how the maryada has changed taksal has kept the same maryada i dont wanna debate no more this is all i have to say instead of complaining goo and do 115 japji sahib a day, the entire sundar gutka of taksal which has sukhmani sahib channdi de vaar sidh gost aarti asa de vaar and many other banis just do this for a year then ull see on ure own by the way if we go back, only men used to be in the panj for and jatha i dut know bout bhai sahibs time and wat happened there all i know is the 2 purataan jathas nihangs and taksal dont let bibs go into sewa but who am i to say we shud all just read the bani, and well find out :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!singh · 10 Dec 2004
khalistani, why don't YOU go do 115 japjee sahibs and the sundar gutka and then discuss rehit issues. khalistani, what happens to people who "avar updeshai, aap naa karai......." can you finish that off for me? Before going wild and telling everyone else to do this all over the internet, shouldn't you try it yourself? And don't you get it? if the entire panth lived in a box like you and just followed the self proclaimed 'puratan' jathas, we obviously wouldn't be having this discussion (we'd be fighting about other issues that these puratan jathas disagree over... hmm, i wonder if taksal got it wrong or nihangs did about bhang? and kirpan amrit for women?) But fortunately, we don't all live in your little box and use the sooj booj that guru jee gave us and actual gurmat to decide on issues. Before you respond, go do 115 japjee saahibs. And the sunder gutkaa. You might as well add in a few hundred angs of sehaj paat as well. then come back and respond. bhula chuka maafManpreet Kaur · 10 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Khalistani veer ji, I don't do 112 or 115 japi sahibs a day from a sundar taksal gutka like you, so therefore, I guess I'm not enlightened as you are. Maybe I should start though. I haven't looked into old rehat maryadas either, but I definately will look into that and see what they say. With the little knowledge I know about Sikhi and its teachings, it just doesn't seem right that a bibi shouldn't be allowed to do punj pyareh di seva. I might be wrong as you are way more enlightened than I am because you read so much baNi daily than I do. Funny how you just assumed that everybody who doesn't agree with you doesn't read 115 Japji sahibs. And since you do, you know the answer and if everybody read that much baNi they will for sure be enlightened with your conclusion. Anyway, I will take your advice veer ji and try to read more baNi. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehkhalsaa · 10 Dec 2004
It is not male chauvenism as I believe that bibis should be allowed to be granthis and do keertan. There can be jathas of bibis as punj or even as a pehredar, but only the bhais, representing BHAI Daya Singh, BHAI Dharam Singh, Bhai Himmat Singh, Bhai Mohkam Singh, Bhai Sahib Singh, can administer the amrit.another singh · 10 Dec 2004
"singh: Before you respond, go do 115 japjee saahibs. And the sunder gutkaa. You might as well add in a few hundred angs of sehaj paat as well. then come back and respond." are you saying that you do that much paat for telling khalistani to do that much before responding? if you read khalistani's post more clearly you will see that he is talking about a gursikh that did read that much gurbani, and gained the knowledge that they had on this issue. if you can claim to know another gursikh with as much kamaii or if you yourself have that much kamaii to know the answer then please respond and clear up any misconceptions.khalistani · 11 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! i dont claim to read that much bani i never did, im a stupid idiot wat do i know of bhagti? but sant jarnail singh je DID do that much bhagti so im just saying if u wanna challenge their points first at least get to their level and if bhai sahib anywhere said bibis can be in the panj, pleasee show me ive only read one or two of their books bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!JSS · 11 Dec 2004
dea khalistani...and another singh.... just cuz people on this forum may not be doing 115 japji sahib paats everyday...doesn't mean ANYTHING aobut their giyaan and avastha... infact...doing a certain number of paats a day means nothing....it's the love which you do the paat with... and MORE important than doing 115 japji sahib paats a day is doing gurmantar abhiyaas.... a gursikh could just do the basic nitnem as given by panj piyaraay and spend the rest of his/her day doing waheguru gurmantar simran....would you say his/her kamai was any less than the person doing 115 japji sahib paats? in fact..i'd say..that person is doing better..cuz that person would have read japji sahib and UNDERSTOOD that japji sahib TELLS us to do jaaap of waheguru...all of gurbani is telling us to do Jaap of waheguru gurmantar.... so you tell me what is best...i'm in no way saying that reading gurbani isn't good...read as much as you can...but lets not lose focus.... a person can read the manual to drive a car all day long.. ten times a day...a hundred times a day ...but that doesn't mean the person knows how to drive a car....likewise...if we spend all our time reading gurbani and taking maaan in the fact that so and so did such and such amount of paat a day...but then forgot to do what the gurbani paat is tellling us to do, then we would have effectively wasted our time and wasted guruji's time... gurbani is instruction , guidance...next step is to put the guidance to USE.... do simran... i promise you'll spend less time on the net arguing.... k that said... as for the real issue of women being in the panj piyaraay...i have no clue...i have heard both sides of the argument and have made up no mind..actually... that's not true...cuz my heart tells me there is nothing wrong with having a woman in panj piyaraay...especially if that women was more strict in her rehit, more loving in her speech and action, more absorbed in naam simran than the men that were available...after all....both akj and taksal agree that the avastha of teh sevadaars in the panj piyaraay have an effect on the abhilakis....so if we use that as the premise...then it would follow that we need the people with amazing jeevans to be in the panj piyaraay...the issue of the Sex or gender shouldn't enter the picture.... that's just what i feel...i'm not saying it's right...just my take on the issue.Guruvah · 11 Dec 2004
I strongly agree to the participation of bibiji's in the Panj GurrSikh. This is because based our guruji's bani, both singh's and singhni's are refer as the devoted wife of the satguru. In Giani Jarnail singh arshi's reference to the use of singhni in the panj gursikh, He mentions abt what a great job SNSM (Sikh Naujawan Sabha Malaysia) is doing in promoting sikhism they way our guruji wanted. I would not agree because they also allow the panj sikh participating to eat seafood, attend western semagams (Disco), Optional Kechera / boxer pants during swimming sessions. They are so relaxed on the rehat that thier panj sikhs don't really empassise on amrit wela. (They are so many othe shocking things). Well the The SANT/BABAJI/MAHAPURASH LOBBY societies do have thier many short comings but they for example don't encourage ppl to make unnessary killing of other living beings (which is in SGGS ji). Maybe you could try to get SNSM to introduce seafood in the langar. That would be such a breakthrough for advancement of sikhism. Everyone have thier faults, so try not to simply praise one society and put down another.But I don't deny that they(SNSM) do organize many smagamz,keertan programme, and campz.....they do a lot of sewa...BUT the parchar done by them is just very bad. At least societies like Niketan do provide free transportation to help the sangat to get laha from naam jaap and Akhand Kirtan and strong empasis on Amrit Vela. (I am not a member of any society though) For further verification of what i've said, please attend SNSM's semelan in Johor Baru from 19 to 26 December 2004. (Air Ticket will not be provided) Nothing more to say to you giani jarnial singh ji, try to find more time to naam jaap rather then slander or praise where its not due. KOOKAR, Wjkk WJkf **NOTE to admin.This post may be harsh on giani jee but I FOUND THE NEED TO LET OUT THE TRUTH,that the other socitieties in Malaysia are not as bad as he claim.Jasvir Kaur · 12 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. All this "number" of paaths etc stuff is coming from Babehs.. Look at GURU NANAK JI....He travelled four times round the globe, came back at the age of about 71++ and DID KHETEE BARRI, cut grass pandaan for his maal dangaar, made some money, WAAND CHHAKNA out of that Dassan Nahon dee kirt...raised a FAMILY and DID LOADS of Naam Jaap besides.. The modern day BABEHS.... get up at 1.40 am..do loads of naam jaap, then they sleep until ten in the morning ( ask to see them and the sevadaar chelas ji standing around will tell you bab ji si ARAAM kardeh)...their Chelas wont even let them pick up their dirty cups/dishes//and even tie their shoe laces and untie them... they are FED on the BEST Foods, Ride the Best cars and JET AROUND the World.... Aaar Updesah aap na kareh... Show me one BABA JI who has a small FARM/ REGULAR JOB/ a FAMILY which he feeds with his Kirt Kamaii...and also runs a LANGGAR like Guru nanak Ji guru Angad Ji... adn i will show you a REAL BABA. GURU NANAK JI with His own example has shown us thet RAISING a FAMILY, doing a Regular Job and earning a honest Living is Already a LARGE BHAGTEE in itself..... the balance we can do Nitnem/Simran and Naam japp to catch up !!! IF I am a BABA JI who can SLEEP all day, I can do massive amounts of Japji sahib paaths when i wake up and am fed by my chelas. Us regular guys and gals have families to feed and jobs to do.... so leave the 115/1115/11115/11111115/ japji shaib paaths to the babahs !!! Jasvir Kauranother singh · 12 Dec 2004
"gurbani is instruction , guidance...next step is to put the guidance to USE...." Do you mean to say that there is no point in reading Gurbani? If you have already read the instructions and committed them to memory that there is no point in reading gurbani for the rest of your life? That is a blatantly blasphemous. Reading Gurbani is same as doing Gurmanter abhiaas. Gurbani da paat is following hukam! If you want to discuss further then feel free to start another thread on this....... · 12 Dec 2004
I'm not saying that anyone should copy what the Gurus did, but before you say things like that, Jasvir Kaur, you should look at the lifestyle of Sahib Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur. They did massive tap and the people still used to call them Tegha Kamla. Another similar incident was Guru Gobind Singh Ji instructing the brothers of Baba Maha Harnam Singh Rampur Khere to allow their saintly brother to do simran and not to involve him in worldy affairs. We also have people that are paid to do parchar. If there is no parchar going on, then how do you expect people to come to learn of the teachings of Guru Nanak. Some may critisize this as well, but in actuality it is a very honorable profession.Jasvir Kaur · 12 Dec 2004
waheguru jiu ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. another singh ji, I think he means is JUST READING....aimlessly as iF that will do wonders. You are Right on... read...use....improve life...read some more...use some more...further improve life...and so on... Some people's computer hard disk/flopy drive gets stuck on the "read" part...just like a spoilt Hard disk in the computer....it will Flash the "reading light" until the cows come home..... Use the Contl+Alt+Delete !!!..the Computer has "HANGED"..similar to our life. No blasphemy here. Kasvir KaurJSS · 12 Dec 2004
I never said there is no point in reading gurbani.... so don't put words in my mouth or try to twist my words.... and secondly......reading gurbani is NOT the same as doing gurmantar abhiaaas..... i agree reading gurbani and doing abihiaas go hand in hand but are NOT the same thing.... otherwise they wouldn't stress gurmantar abhiaas in the amrit sanchars.... anyhow...i don't care what you do...if you like...don't do any gurmantar abhiaas and just continue to do 115 japji sahib paats a day...if that is what floats your boat...then who am i to stop you or say you're wrong.... have fun and enjoy those 115 japji sahib paats a day...... · 12 Dec 2004
Gurbani is Teaching. Gurmantar Abiyas is Practicingkhalistani · 13 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! bhenji jasvir kaur intresting views so sant je did wat ure saying? he was just another baba? u know that he didnt sleep all day right? he led something called the dharam yudh moorcha against an entire government thas much harder than working i can go and work everyday to fight against an entrie country and demand our rights, thas some hard work and sant je did that much paat everyday STILL and honest living isnt bhagtee bhenji an athiest can have a family, hard work day and night that gives NO BHAGTI AT ALL WATSOEVER by the way a gursikh is encouaged to do minimum of 2 and half hours of bhagti a day nitnem is like 4o min., with reheraas for some it takes an hour, but thas not a lot thas the lowest minumum unless u go hardcore into it for like 6hours, which actually can happen, i know a singh that was doing japji sahib for 4 hours!!! he was into it the main point im getting at is we always say y is our kaum like this y is it in bad shape y arnt we like bhai mani singh je or baba deep singh je y i say one thing about reading more bani,. and i actually get posts AGAINST that!! amazing y dont we just go and ACTULLY READ THE PAAT!! wudnt that be better than arguing over y we shud read more paat i mean were only here for a little while we waste our life away arguing over every little things lets just go and do more paat first before questioning someone who prob. does more paat than us because a sant is one with god himself so perhaps we shud try to reach their level before questiong them remeber theyve already crossed over its us that need to cross over still well, at least people like me bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!Jasvir Kaur · 13 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. That is precisely why the Guru Jyot of Guur Nanak was manifest in TEN Different Bodies... to teach us ten different ways of LIVING. Guur nanak doing Kheti barri, doing dassan nahoan de kirt, Guru Amardass ji doing 12 years of selfless seva even in old age, Guru Ramdass Jibuilding....Guru Arjun JI preparing the GURU GRANTH...Guur Hargobind JiKeeping an army, HUNTING, building Miri Piri TAKHAT, Guru Har rai Ji running medicine stores, Gur Har Krishn Ji doing seva among the sick..Guru Teg bahadur Ji doing Tapp ( to prepare Himself for giving HIS HEAD)...and Guur Gobind Singh Ji doing all that He did in such a short life-time !!! Now DONT retreat into that fox hole of "Did you say SANT JI" is lying/didnt do this and didnt do that/..... I have already said umpteen times that SANT JARNAIL SINGH WAS a SANT SIPAHI who performed his duty well and TRUE. Whether he did massive bhgatee of 24/7 or not is NOT for me to JUDGE...what I know is RIGHT before my EYES... He did an ARDASS to DEFEND harmandir sahib/Akal takhat....and HE DID IT with His LIFE. PERIOD. I am talking about all those other BABEHS.... a dime a dozen roaming through out PUNJAB. You dont have to mention any names.... When I was 15 years old I had heard about a very famous baba ( Baba ji Kharak singh who was short and dark..) and the story about him was that in the HEAT of SUMMER he would WALK BAREFOOTED FROM AMRITSAR RAILWAY STATION to HARMANDIR SAHIB.....Wow I was IMPRESSED..so I went to see him. That day I WAS in harmandar sahib....and a Group of TALL CHELAS came in, completely surrounding a small short dark baba ji..ALL the CHEALS were BAREFOOTED..BUt the baba Ji was WEARING SHOES...and later i found out that..THIS WAS the famous baba Kharak singh who i had come to see. Thats the LAST time I ever beleived any such TALL TALE about any such Baba !!! So now you know what babahs i mean. Jasbir KaurSehaj · 13 Dec 2004
You lot need to take some chill pills - a whole bottle would suffice Everyone to their own - I'd like to see the day when I actually see a Bibi do seva of Punj in the UK of AKJ, as everyone harks on about it, but I've never seen it happen here. I'm against it though - but all those who preach it on forums never actually lag in Punj in the UK.Jugraj Singh · 13 Dec 2004
No man is perfect. We are all bhoolanhar. Baba Jarnail Singh jee was wrong in his understanding that women can not do panj pyare di sewa. This is not a big deal though because people should understand that only Satgur is Poora. Baba Jarnail Singh jee was a natural leader and very charimatic (from what I hear). He got shaheed for what he believed in just as countless other Singhs have throghout Sikh history. We should have the utmost respect for shaheehds but let us not forget our Guru. We become so attached to people that we forget what our guru is saying. Guru sahib states, "Khalsa mero roop hai Khaas". If the panj represent guru sahib and Guru sahib himself has said that Khalsa is my khaas roop then bibian have as much to sewa in punj as Singhs do. If you don't agree then no bibian should be given amrit at Taksali amrit sanchar because according to you they can not be Khalsa. Because if you belive that only Singhs can do sewa in Punj then according to the "Khalsa mero roop hai Khaas" you are interpreting Khalsa as only men and excluding women from the definition. How anyone argue against bibis doing sewa in punj is beyond me. Infact Guru Nanak Dev ji's sister was the first to recognize him for who he was and she was also the first Sikh. According to your logic then only bibian have the right to be Sikhs because no man at the time recognized guru sahib for who he was .... it was his sister who understood him. The body is a vessel. The soul is what matters in Sikhi.khalistani · 13 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! bhenji this topic was on bibis and came to sant je and taksal and now bibi u take it somewhere elsen to baba who have nothing to do with this topic?? y? but im an idiot with no buddhi forgive me and we know many things of sant je, but was everyone actually there to see them?? most of our athiaas comes down verbally we didnt see vasakhi, but we have accounts of it right? people were with sant je that i met enough by now we shud go and ask them by now y dont we just stop this topic if u think sant je was wrong, fine just go and do 115 japji sahibs a day, entire taksali gutka, then ok but we shud at first do that right before questioning sants that we know are not fake, right? first i do benti to everyone to do the paat before calling sant je wrong wats wrong with bani y dont we just read it? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!Rain drop · 22 Dec 2004
By the way can any Veer Ji/Bhen Ji search and quote a Gurbani Pankti to mean "Men Women are equal" Caution: Do not quote "So Kyaon Manda Akhea Jit Jamen Rajan" because that means "Do not talk poor or ill about women-------". It never says both are equal. May be, we will be able to find a new thing from this search?Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 23 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Dear rain drop: Can you give a quote from Gurbani that says: "MEN are SUPERIOR to Women" OR "men are NOT equal to women" OR "Women are Superior to Men".. You will soon realise that not "Everything" is in Gurbani/found in quotes Jarnail SinghI'm_Neutral · 23 Dec 2004
Can someon pls tell me if bhai randhir singh ji has writeen in any of his books that women are allowed to do panj di seva, and wich book?I'm_Neutral · 25 Dec 2004
anyone?<Admin Edit - Inappropriate Name> · 25 Dec 2004
Dear Neutral ji, Will you then start supporting women in Punj....IF this is approved by Bhai Sahib Jee....IF Bhai sahib Ji has not written about it or approved it..then is it NO WAAY. That is the attitude of most Baba ji followers....IF their BABA JI has said it then it is OK..IF NOT then NO WAY. They will argue till the cows come home that BABA JI SAID IT. PERIOD. We Cannot depend on any ONE GURSIKH..No matter as Spiritually uplifted as Bhaiu Sahib Jee. After all he was also a human and humans can make mistakes/omissions...ONLY GURU JI is Abhul. And GURU JI doesnt say naywhere that Women ar NOT EQUAL/to be kept down/away from sewa/cannot participate in this and that. Women have taken Amrit/Fought aongside Singhs during GURU JI's time....a WOMAN was in fact responsible for SHAMING the FORTY MUKTAS back to GURU JI...and she led a JATHA to BATTLE. It is a THROW BACK to Brahmanwaad to REJECT any role for women. SIKHI and GURMATT has REJECTED alal this a long time ago beginnign with GURU NANAK JIGyani Jarnail Singh · 27 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Dear Neutral ji, Gurbani of Guru nanak ji where Guru Ji says: "SO KION MANDAA akhiyeah jit jammeh rajaan..." is not JUST talking ill of women.. What is MANDAA ?? In the WOMEN CONTEXT in all religious texts ( Hindu/Islamic) MANDAA means Woman is Unclean, NOT EQUAL to MAN, LOWER than MAN ( pair dee jutee ) Woman's Akal is behind her gutt, woman has no RIGHT to LAND/PROPERTY, Woman is Forever UNDER MAN - First under her Father/Brothers, then when she gets married she is under her husband/his family.... then she is under her SON..in other words WOMAN in RELIGIONS previous to GURU NANAK had absolutley NO STATUS whatsoever and was considered even LOWER than SHUDRAS. This is the REAL and COMPLETE meaning of Guru Ji's use of the Word MANDAA...and Guru Ji is explaining if WOMAN is SO MANDEE as you state then How can she give BIRTH to KINGS, EMPERORS, SADHUS, RISHIS, SANTS !! The Brahmans and Islamic religious leaders COULD NOT ANSWER GURU JI...and SIKHS still CANNOT ANSWER this as well...even after GURU JI has written it so clearly. What a shame.... GURU JI wrote SO MUCH...and we in our ignorance still want "more quotes"...and ( say dont quote:... so kion mandaa.. what a travesty.... this is the MAIN QUOTE that explains Woman as equal to Man...in GURU ji's Own WORDS. jarnail SinghRain drop · 27 Dec 2004
Dear Arshi Ji, No Pankiti is quoted in reponse to my request. I keep my request on----. As far your mail, my understanding is that "Men are superior to women or Women are superior to men" is not the point. But, you may find in Gurbani, that Superiority is associated with the male gender. God is "Purakh"; you find in moolmanter and is also referred as with this gender (may be always or generally, please check). Guru was also "Purakh" (That happened. Do not why. Certainly, God wished so.). I am A "women" of my Lord.khalistani · 27 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! are u talking bout in asa de vaar,, where guru je says women give birth to great kings, saints, so how can we call them less?? and when sant je said that he was never saying women are lower than men but according to tradition, not one women gave their heads thas wat sant je said and according to tradition, women in the past past never used to be in panj pyaare but, if u dont agree, wat can i do i just urge everyone not to fight over things like thiss :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!kaur12123 · 28 Dec 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh TO ALL, 1. panj pyare were male and there are no historical documnets to prove women were in the panj pyare in Guru Ji's time. This does not make us inferior aswe are equal but by allowing men to shaka amrit we are only abiding by the way Guru Ji made, let us not improvise and bring in own ideas and so change Sikhi. 2. there are many sants that have small piece of land and live peacefully trying to follow the life of Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji in Kartarpur. But phenjis and veerjis, Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Ji started off by travelling to preach Truth, Waheguru , Akal Purakh. Guru Gobind Singh Ji was a Maharaja, He was rich and yet a warrior that killed and yet a Guru. Then why can our sants today not be allowed to have a lot of land. If they have anice car they are slandered, if they have a lot of money they are slandered. How many of us pray like they do? I know some sants and they do not go to sleep after Nitnem Sahib but let me tell you their lifestyle when I spent some time with them: -sleep at 12.00 -awake and be ready to go out by 3.00 having already done Nitnem. -eat whatever they are given but still eat less than me (and no I am not fat) -give out love to all. -are an inspiration for me to pray more. -the cars that they travel in are not theirs but the sangats and sangat even gives them a nice car as a gift. Tell me, you may say that why don't they sell the cars and give the money elsewhere but may I ask that did Guru Gobind Singh Ji give away all His riches? No. There is nothing wrong with us living a good life if we earn it. But these sants are not interested in a high life, they have the money as anyone who is preaching throughouut the world will need a lot of money for all the costs. 3. Men can not be above women in Sikhism as the only man 'Purakh' Is Akal Purakh Waheguru and all else are women. WE are all women, even the men, so there is no inequality BUT maybe panj pyare were male for a reason and if we let this continue that is better than altering Sikhi as we don't like the sound of something. Equality will and is in Sikhism. I am upset that this is where Sikhs have gone to. Moorakhs like me slander the saints as they pray but are not ''perfect'' in our view. We want to change our Guru JIs Sikhi to suit us and we go against Khalistani veerji or bhenji as s/he says that we hould pray more to get answers about Sikhi. Well he is absolutely right. Bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehGyani Jarnail Singh · 28 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. That is just a metaphor. As we all know Akal Purakh has NO GENDER. In this "world " context, where it was generally accepted that MAN is the HEAD of the household and woman is his "companion"..SO GURU JI Gives THAT Honour to WAHEGURU. It was said of INDIRA GANDHI, that she was the ONLY MAN in her cabinet. Everybody knows that doesnt mean she was really a MAN in woman's clothing !!! Gurbani says AKAL PURAKH is the ONLY "MAN" in this World in the SAME CONTEXT. Gurbani also has GURU JI calling himslef Kookar, neech, and a lot of other "words"...thse are words/language used to tell us a message..GURU Ji is NOT those things. In the world of Nature..Male is not always that great.... the LION almost always associated with Khalsa is the LAZIEST and GREEDIEST .....he lets his "women hunt" and he takes the "lion's share" of everything. In Lion Society...male is certainly nothing to shout about. This is just an example that males females are for THIS WORLD ONLY...No value in the Spiritual World...there EVERYBODY IS EQUAL. The PUNJ/KHALSA/AMRIT are all in the Realm of SPIRITUALITY.....and in that realm ALL are EQUAL. Thank You. Jarnail Singh.Rain drop · 01 Jan 2005
"That is just a metaphor. As we all know Akal Purakh has NO GENDER." Dear Arshi Ji, May be you are right. But what Gurbani says; He is He. He is referred as He. Even if He is said to look after us as a mother "Toon Mera Pita Toon Hein Mera Mata"; He is Mera Mata, not Meri Mata. Anyway, Panj Piaray will have to be called as Panj Piarees, if women do this Sewa. How it sounds? By the way, what is wrong, if we also change some other Maryada aspects. For example Panj Piary dress in white, Steel BAATA instead of Sarabloh, Using pure white Sugar intead of Sugar Patasa. Technically, no problem.Jarnail Singh Gyani · 01 Jan 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear rain drop Ji, The KHALSA is GURU...and has the capability to change any man made maryada...EXCEPT GURBANI in the Guru Granth Ji. That is the Beauty of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's Master Plan in 1699 Vasakhi.... doing away with ONE DEHDHAREE SAKSHEE POOJA and giving Power to FIVE KHALSA. But I dont agree with changing just for the fun of changing and so will the Khalsa ji NOT just change..for the Fun of changing. BTW at the MALAYSIA Amrit ceremony in which I took Amrit the Bata is STEEL and WHITE Sugar is used. The SGPC Maryada doesnt say patasha s MUST be used...that is just an Indian Punjabi Sweet thing which is not found in malaysia. Anyway "technically" the patashas/the water/ etc now is different from the one in 1699...so IF NATURE has CHANGED all these FOR US??? through Evolution/environmental changes/pesticides/environmentl air pollution etc etc, fertilisers in the soil/water etc...what do you say about this type of "change"..you tell me where you can get the same original patashas that mata Ji sahib kaur put in the Amrit in 1699 ??..the SAME EXACT WATER... There are people going around bringing water from "sarovars" here and there and mixing them up...PRETENDING that this act somehow does "wonders"??? what these are only they know ?? some went to Pakistan and brought water from Bhai ghaniyas village well and mixed it up in Anandpur Sahib sarovar...what that establishes or ??? i cnat understand ?? The FACT is we are LEAVING GURBANI aside and delving into such superstitious acts...much to our detriment. jarnail SinghBijla Singh · 01 Jan 2005
jarnail singh, if you want same exact water and patasay then why not same exact location and same exact Mata Ji? you keep your missionary thoeries to yourself. no matter what jathebandi all use sarab loh bata and patasay and khanda. the importance is to follow what Guru Ji started. Guru Ji gave significance to sarabloh not steel. to compete with Sikhs hindus built durgyana mandir in Amritsar which looks like Darbar Sahib, but their sarovar had germs in it. they cleaned it so many times and brought water from their many different holy places but germs would show up the next day. then they came to Darbar Sahib. Sikhs gave them water from Darbar Sahib's sarovar to put it in their sarovar. and guess what, no more germs. ask anyone in Amritsar. it is true story not just a fairy tale. in 18th century Sikhs would risk their lives just to get one dip into sarovar of Darbar Sahib and these days so called "educated" missionaries call it blindness just because their faithless eyes don't see any logic behind it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki FatehDharamveer Singh · 02 Jan 2005
technically no problem....??? this is all the problem my veer. technically NOTHING in 2005 is the SAME as in 1699. WAIT a MOMENT...SOMETHING is still the EXACT SAME today as well as in 1699..... That is GURBANI. GURU GOBIND SINGH JI tied us to the PALLA of GURU GRANTH JI/GURBANI for this very reason...gurbani will NEVER CHANGE an iota ALL other things can change, have changed..and WILL CHANGE. Technically...veer that is the TRUTH. To get "original" gurr..one will have to get an "original khet" plant "original ganna seeds". use no fertilisers, Keep the khet covered in air tight atmosphere to keep away pollution from the air/use "distilled" water etc..and I very much DOUBT you can still remain ORIGINAL ????..WHAT is the POINT behind all this ORIGINALITY ?? Did GURU JI ORDAIN us to keep ORIGINALITY 100% in EVERYTHING ?? NO, the only thing that matters is GURBANI and that is ORIGINAL. Drop all this brahminical thinking and superstitions..technically speaking they are excess baggage. Dharamveer singh taksali.Bijla Singh · 03 Jan 2005
I have dropped all bipran ki reet but my request to you is to drop all your fake names and multiple ids. my post was toward jarnail singh and you answer as "dharamveer" and claim yourself to be a taksali. but all these theories are only supported by missionaries. I support originality. Gurbani is same. yes I agree. but rehat should be the same too. no changes. all I know is Guru Ji told us to do something and I try to do it without trying to find "logic". steel was well available in those days and Guru Ji could've used gurr instead of patasay but nooooo....the rehat of 300 years cannot be changed or "modernized" because some guy with "degree" doesn't like it or doesn't understand it. without original rehat Khalsa will not be original and niara. If Khalsa is not Niara anymore then Roop Gobind Ka is simply not there. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is present, Panj Pyare are present in physical form, sarabloh bata and patasay are used because Guru Ji used 'em. Khanda is used (not kirpan) because Guru Ji used it. Sarabloh is given significance and Khanda represents Waheguru and His creation who gives power to Amrit through Bani (same Panj banis---originality) that is recited by Panj Pyare. Panj Pyare are dressed in Bana not in pant shirt or tux. Amrit is prepared the same way in Bir Aasan as Guru Ji started. Amrit is given in the same manner Guru Ji gave not in bottles or glass. Rehat is given the same way. this is all originality because originality is Hukam of my Guru Ji. get that through your thick missionary skull. Bijla Singh "Malaesh Bhann"dhan sikhi · 03 Jan 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh jarnail singh i am disheartened by your post that sugar is acceptable and do not need patashyas. Well times have changed and there is no war so now you will start to say that amrit is not needed. Amrit is not a name for mixing water with anything white. Next you will start using brown sugar, then gur, and then leave the water out and just give out that delicious wite milk powder barfi that is sold in all sweatmeat shops. forget that, next there will be an online signing system to become amritdhari. Please dont say what is not within Sikhism, afterall if Guru Gobind Singh Ji introduced all this then , kucch soch samaj kai hee keeta. So leave everything to the Guru and follow it as a Sikh instead of trying to change it to suit personal needs. Maaf karna but if the SGPC says something that does not agree with Sikhi and yet they have left us with the option to use whatever ingredients to make amrit, then I think that as sikhs we should use only the ingredients that CAN make amrit and that is water and patashe and khanda and nitnem and Guru Jis blessings. we are not trying to give the sikhs glucose , that thye can buy from the chemist.lol. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fatehkookar-Di-Poochh · 03 Jan 2005
veer bijla singh..."thick missionary skull", malesh bhann", ...pretty hard words..but they mean absolutley noithing except shows hankaar and anger. if you read any single line of gurbani you will know a skull - thick/or thin/or nonexistenet is a gift from guru ji....so if a person is demeaned by pointing out his physical deformities..you are assuming you could have done better than guru ji huimself.. go to www.amritworld.com and read the real meaning of malaesh...it is not you think. and why the venom of a snake agaisnt missionaries..why hate them so much.. why they get on your nerves..maybe becasue they tell the truth about the baabas and sants..so called brahmgianis who dont have degrees..having a degree is not a crime and it doesnt make anyone a malaesh....not having a degree is a crime becasue guru ji wants us to study..and be knowledgeable..thats why they went to extraordinary lengths to send sikhs to kanshi also..and set up the real and only Damdami taksaal at Damdama Sahib Talwandi sabo... so whats the big deal about being uneducated ?? kookar dee poocch.... · 03 Jan 2005
"not having a degree is a crime becasue guru ji wants us to study." since when? does this means i am criminals? Parhey Unparhey param gat pavey jo prani gobind dhiavey!!Bijla Singh · 03 Jan 2005
First I would like to say you drop your fake names and ids. I have problems with missionaries because they have problem with Sikhi. I don't care if they question taksal, akj or any other jathebandi but when they attack Rehat Maryada and beliefs that are accepted by the entire panth then I have to step in because I feel it is my responsibility. there are many people out there who would do their best to protect their own jatha like it is their gang but never Khalsa jathebandi. you questioned Amrit which is the core of Sikhi. why wouldn't I have problem with that? yes, I am full of hankaar. I admit it. I would love to have the knowledge to understand Gurbani but if that education means questioning and attacking Sikhi then I rather stay uneducated. I like to have the knowledge gursikhs like Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji, and Bhai Veer Singh Ji had not missionary one. they question gurbani, history and Amrit. I have a problem with anyone who has problem with Sikhi. maybe Taksal says the truth and that's why you have problem with them. maybe it is because they have more influence on people than missionaries. in every single post of your you always attack taksal in one way or another so you are the one with hate not me. who has asked most stupid questions and attacked Sikhi? it is you with a "degree". I will stop now because I don't see the point in going any further on this. learn from your own posts. not a single person agrees with your thoeries. but carry on if you want. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki FatehJarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005
Dear Dhan Sikhi veer, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh. All i did was POST a message stating HOW the AMRIT that is prepared in MALAYSIA.....and in that the sugar used was white commercial sugar and NOT PATASHAY....and that is as per SGPC Maryada and as far as i know it has always been done that way even by those who call themsleves Real Shudh Taksalis/Damdamis etc. IF anyone from that group corrects me and proves that their Amrit is not prepared using white sugar but patashay..but as far as i know that is true. My post in no way says or supports the views that this is what should be done/not done. What I personally think is not at all important and i am in no position to dictate to any jatha or sabha on its amrit preparation or ingredients...And i have never been a member of the panj. The Amrit that I received was prepared using white sugar...and i dont feel that it is inadequate or a loss in any way..maybe that is because i have not taken patashay amrit..so what has not been experienced i can say nothing about. I hope this clears any doubts. No one is perfect...certainly not me. Jarnail singhJarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005
Veer Bijla Singh, Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I am just a regular poster on this forum and on many many other forums for the past 15 years....and I always use my REGULAR NAME as stated above. sad to say on this forum there are a few "misguided" ones who get rattled by my absolutely FRANK views...who having FAILED to answer me, then choose to attack me in different ways..wild accusations are in their armoury as well. Let me tell you and like minded "amateur fbi detectives with thier ou X-Y-Z-ACB files conspiracy theories etc" that I READ ALL posts and answer accordingly...using my bibek budhi..and my one and only name. I dont give two hoots who the "writer" is...( it can be bijla singh, hijla singh, kijla singh whatever...I am INTERESTED in the mESSAGE...what possible use can be a "name" be to me knowing fuly well that i live 20,000 miles away from this Forum)..as long as the Message interest me enough to put my thoughts on paper..i will write a reply. Thats all. may i also remind you to follow your own advice....NO one is forced to read any post by anyone..and no one is forced to write in as "bijla" when he is in fact "Hijla"..who cares anyway?? is there a prize ?? please follow your own advice and dont waste time trying detective work. You are under no obligation to either read/answer/not answer my posts. Thank you. and stay in Chardikala. Jarnail Singh.... · 04 Jan 2005
>> .what possible use can be a "name" be to me knowing fuly well that i live 20,000 miles away from this Forum >> It was Shakespeare that said "What is in a name, A rose by any other name would smell the same." And Jarnail Singh, I would be interested to know what other forums do you post on?Jarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005
I am a regular on Sikh Philosophy Network SPN, Sikh Youth, DAILY and on SikhSangat and SikhAwareness occasionally..apart from that i am amember of Sikhs sydney, Gurmat learning Zone, Gurmat Discussions etc etc which are mailing lists. By "Name" i meant if i am LOCAL to Toronto/Tapoban area, probably a "name" earned would be of some value as i could meet and discuss with t he singhs..but being 20,000 miles away across the ocean i am just a statistic...an "anonymous' writer...even with a name. Why should i becoem even "MORE ANONYMOUS" by using other fictitious names ?? really stupid and i am flabbergasted how many times this mud has been thrown at me but it doesnt stick..but they persevere neverhtless. GOOD LUCK to them. However amng the locals i do have a "reputation" of sorts... those that dont like what i write and say really hate my guts...threats, legal suits and what not have been tried to shut me up..and those that like what i write visit me very often to give me encouragement..and what not. anybody and everybody "knows" me down here..THATS why I always USE my REAL NAME and dont hide behind any aliases..even when I was writing scathing editorials in the Punajbi Press from 1970's in Kuala Lumpur and Singapore. MY ideas are MY own. no offense meant to any with opposing ideas..i wonder why people just cant let others have their say...so one track minds and closed brains. jarnail singh DONT DISCUSS ME discuss the PUNJ TOPIC.anon · 04 Jan 2005
You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life. - Winston ChurchillBijla Singh · 04 Jan 2005
Mir Mannu, Massa Ranghar, indira Gandhi had enemies --- Sikhs. what did they stand up for? having enemies doesn't mean you stood up for something good.anon · 05 Jan 2005
Fateh ji going back to the guru jis seva at harminder sahib, as a women myself, i used to find that offensive until someone explained to me the following.... as we all know, the 5 kakar are under constant debate with some people keeping kes and not keski. So bibia not wearing the panj kakar wuld be doing guru kis seva which would be wrong. Whereas with the guys, amritdhari men all wear keski. And u have to be amritdhari to do specific seva at harminder sahib or something. Still, its a shame. i would LOVE to do seva there, clean the floors, anything !!!! any one heard of this theory ?? Fathe jiJarnail Singh Gyani · 05 Jan 2005
anon bhen ji, your theory doesnt make sense. thsy dont allow any bibi - regardeless of keski etc to do any sewa there. That keski/amrtidharee thing is just DHOOR in your eyes to justify their male chauvanstic stand of NO BIBIAN. so for all i know a amrtidharee bibi with a keski double or triple the size of an amrtidharee man still WOULDNT GET any sewa. IF these thekedaars had their say, mata sahib kaur would have been prevented from putting in the Patashay in the Amrit..one of them would have got up and pushed her out of the way... Jarnail singhjss · 05 Jan 2005
dear anon, i don't know how strict they are at darbar sahib about women not doing seva... my sister was at darbar sahib about three weeks ago...and she was allowed to witness the seva of taking down the chandni and changing all the carpets and rumalllas at the end of the night...while watching, one of the sevadaars handed her a broom and said "bhennay seva kar la"....and she continued sweeping without anyone stopping her.kookar-Di-Poochh · 05 Jan 2005
maybe they are beginning to see the light...go sisters and do the sewa. kookarRain drop · 06 Jan 2005
The topic has drifted a bit. I am not going to touch the views going astray from the main topic. Those may be discussed with new headings. When I said: What is the problem with White Kurta, Steel Batta and Sugar; I meant that if these could not be changed, let us also respect the tradition about Punj men/women. I thought that the answer would be like that "Women issue is different from these aspects". But it was not so. Under new situation, for me the topic seems "Headache". Insisting Sewa for women at Harminder Sahib at midnight, I agree not. But better it is, if that issue is not linked with the main topic. My regards for Arshi Ji and Love for Bijla Singh Ji. Guru Fateh for all Bhen and Veer on this topic. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Ji. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 06 Jan 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. although i genuinely love everybody on this forum some people keep getting on my nerves....people who keep on Discussing "PEOPLE" and NOT ISSUES.. Everybody reads, and answers the posts as they understand the issues..each according to his her own understanding.. but a few babay supporters have been so "conditioned" like Pavlov's puppies, that whatever a baba brahmgiani says they swallow hook line and sinker....what a "thick headed so called missionary" like Js Gyani says is like poison..but even that is quite acceptable..but what irks me most is that they MUST "know" who this and that person really is - his DNA, his GeNETICS/ whether really man or woman/ whether really sikh or muslim..whether this is just one or has multiple personalities ( the many faces of EVE !!) WHY BOTHER ?? and WHO CARES ?? I READ every post and dont spend my time doing mental calisthenics wondering if "Bijla singh" is really "bundha" writing under another name ?? for me BOTH are the same..they can switch ID daily..I will answer each mail as it appears no matter whose name appears on it. ( And with the MASSIVE BHAGTEE/SANTHIYA etc these babay walehs do ( supposedly)..they should be able to tell who is who ( IF that really matters that is..but it doesnt...OR why they DONT ask their all knowing brahmgiani is another 64 dollar question ??) Surely just one small ardass from their all powerful baba ji should be able to demolish these massa ranghars People just stand under a mango tree and enjoy the juicy mangoes... these people must KNOW who planted the tree...IF a babay calls an AAK tree a mango tree they will say How sweet the Mangoes of this AAK tree taste..but the MANGOES of a mango tree quoted by "thick headed misisionaries" taste bitter like AAks. I am 100% sure that if tomorrow i post under another name but "cut and paste from a baba site" some utter nonsnese... these same people will be praising me sky high..not knowing that it is actually the same manjit kaur they hate so much...because they are "conditioned" to look at people not issues. Love for all Bijla singh/bundha ?? which is which..?? Manjit Kaur DISCUSS "ISSUES" PEOPLE...NOT "PEOPLE" People !!Bijla Singh · 07 Jan 2005
Manjit Kaur Ji, please explain which "derawala sant/baba" have I supported? whose name did i mention to support my arguments. just because i keep rehat told to me by Panj Pyare that goes against your beliefs doesn't mean I support any dera. I am not "bundha". i don't even know him. do you have any proof you can provide that shows me and budha is the same person? maybe admins can check somehow. i keep this id on all forums i go to whether it be gursikhijeevan or sikhsangat. i am sorry, i have a life to live and certainly do not have the time to write under different names. i don't see the point in doing that. my every belief has reasoning. I do not need anyone's support. whether one or one hundred people are against me, I do not care. I know my beliefs and rehat. I will follow it always no matter what. i wouldn't discuss issues like raag maala, mool mantar, keski or dasam granth on this site because there is not much freedom on this site and with all due respect i think admins do have one sided thinking on these topics and therefore posts may go biased. i write against one person and he stands against me with multiple ids. with all due respect "bhain ji" i did not write against you then why such "venom of snake"? i wrote against him because i think he is using multiple ids to support himself. not confident enough abt his beliefs or what? and please do tell me which baba i supported? so far I have avoided controversial topics and always request my sikh brothers and sisters to not waste time on these issues. I support patasay, sarab loh bata and khanda-original rehat and always will. how many people agree with your or jarnail singh's views of sugar and steel? not a single person on this site. so what's the solution? multiple ids of course. not a single jathebandi supports these theories. only missionaries do. it is ok to attack words "Sant and Brahmgyani" and it is ok to attack all "derawalas" for the faults of very few but it is not okay to attack missionaries who attack Gurbani, history and want to change original rehat that 99% of the panth agrees on. now another theory is presented on how only "message" is important. to me message and messenger both are important. now what? another new name is gonna attack me with capitalized letters? sorry everyone for going off topic. I believe only Guru Gobind Singh Ji has the right to choose Panj Pyare and only Guru Ji knows who does and does not qualify to do this seva. All Panj Pyare are chosen from Khalsa. now you define what "Khalsa" means. Bibis should be able to do seva at Darbar Sahib but those bibis should be tyar bar tyar and in full rehat. first thing all bibis should do is tie dastaars on their heads not chunni or rumaal otherwise i can't see them tyar bar tyar. time will tell everything. Guru Rakha. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki FatehJarnail Singh Gyani · 07 Jan 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Bijla Singh Ji, i echo your sentiment expressed above..." I dont care if 1 supports me or 100 ".... so how did you "think" or come to the conclusion that I have no support and therefore created it ?? Baseless allegation...which has been made so many times..but now the shoe is on the other foot and you know how it feels ?? You may or may not be bundah etc..and you want "proof"...but you yourself failed to give any such proof...just continued repeating the baselss allegations time after time. Lets drop this silly debate...i dont know you and you dont know me..i dont care if 100 support me or none....you dont care 100 support you or none...so where is the argument?? OF course I would dearly love to have everything as original as possible and no compromises on anything...but that is an ideal world. BTW I am NOT a Missionary (whatever that means to you)..and never went to any missionary school etc...but i do spread sikhi along the way. You are wrong that this site doesnt allow raagmala.dasam garnth/moolmantar debates....all these are currently running and posts as much as 80 are coming in. OF course you as well as anybody else is perfectly entitled to his own beliefs and no one is forcing anyone to listen. For the Record I dont regard ragmala as Gurbani...for me Moolmantar is up to GURPARSAD..and for dasam granth i beleive there are some adulterations and additions. As for Keski I have always worn one 24/7 (on head or around waist) just like the other kakaars and i find it impossible to be properly rehatwaan WITHOUT a Keski..so at the end of the road it is pointless to argue if it is a kakar or kesh is...on Sarbloh- I frimly beleive in sarbloh bibek and try to follow it faithfully as i can...and finally YES i do frimly beleive that Bhai Sahib Bhai randhir Singh Ji was a pooran Brahmgiani ( BUT unlike others who beleive in "brahmgianis".. i dont beleive him to be the "brahmgiani aap parmeshar" type who can be abhull and make no mistakes....Bhai sahib Ji would be the last person to make that claim. Bhul Chuk maaf on all counts. jarnail Singh