Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

Singh · 25 Nov 2004

This slime turned in countless Singhs and had them killed. Now he wants to be a saint and write about Gurbani? And our leaders will honour him? Is there any lack of hippocrites? Cop on hitlist authors book on Gurbani Varinder Walia Tribune News Service [img]http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20041125/pun2.jpg[/img] The cover of “Gurbani Katha Vichar” written by Mr Iqbal Singh, SP. — A Tribune photo Amritsar, November 24 Senior police officer Iqbal Singh who was on the hitlist of terrorists for arresting Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale in 1981 and killing militants in encounters, has been appreciated by the Jathedar of Akal Takht for his new passion for Gurbani. In the preface of his new 544-page book, “Gurbani Katha-Vichar”, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Akal Takht Jathedar, described Mr Iqbal Singh, SP (CID), as a fine police officer who was committed to contribute in the field of Gurbani. “I pray to Guru Hargobind to give more strength to Mr Iqbal Singh so that he could serve the community through his valuable writings”, he said. Mr Iqbal Singh who had earned appreciation from the then DGPs, including Mr KPS Gill, for providing confidential reports which led to seizures of arms and ammunition and killing of terrorists, has provided pioneer information to researchers of Gurbani. Dr S.P. Singh, Vice-Chancellor, Guru Nanak Dev University, described the book as unique work in this field. The book will help preachers of Sikh Panth to interpret Gurbani in the right perspective. Dr Jatinderpal Singh Jolly, a reader of Guru Nanak Dev University, wrote that the Punjab police would “now earn good name”. Dr Jatinderpal Singh Jolly, a reader of Guru Nanak Dev University, wrote that the Punjab police would “now earn good name”. Mr Iqbal Singh was the first senior police officer to enter the Golden Temple after Operation Black Thunder in 1988 for information about the operation. He had been the first police officer assigned to investigate the Sikh-Nirankari clash in 1978 which was the cause of the Punjab problem. He had also retrieved the body of the then DIG, A.S. Atwal, who was shot outside the Parikarma of the Golden Temple in 1983 at the risk of his own life.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

gkd · 25 Nov 2004

maybe he's trying to rite his wrongs? doubt it but maybe otherwise indira style

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

......... · 25 Nov 2004

the book is probably full of RSS ideology. Can you not see a pattern of behaviour?

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

ManjitKaur · 25 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. This si the way we "punish" the wrongdoers... The BOOK is PRAISED by the very person who was blasted for authoring and publishing with Guru Ki Golak a banned book on patshahi Chevin full of anti gurmatt writings..what can we expect from badal cheleh in another town in sangrur there is a mahan agnee yagg going on with amritdharees leading the burning of ghee... In a related development they have found the ashes of the sahibzadehs... so near to the 300th anniversary of their shahedee...and are demanding to have nagar kiretans in which these ashes will be carried.. MK

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

EkAurSikh · 25 Nov 2004

>>maybe he's trying to rite his wrongs? naaah , he is just trying to make more money. He made enough money out of the Sikhs and brough misery u0pon them as a policeman and now he will do the same as a writer and bring more shame and misery on the Sikh nation by re-gurgitating RSS ideology.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

respectfully · 26 Nov 2004

Before jumping to conclusions on the slant this book will have and the anti-gurmat teachings it will espouse, perhaps one should read the book.... otherwise, and please take no offense, any opinion offered is offered in ignorance. Also, while I too may have doubts as to the sincerity of this individual, it is not beyond Guru ji's kirpa to forgive and show a man the errors of his ways. Before we jump on the bandwagon and condemn this book in outright ignorance of it, it would be better to actually read the book and then offer our criticism (or praise). respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

jeevan singh khalsa · 26 Nov 2004

vahe guru ji ka khalsa vahe guru ji ka khalsa! police officers like iqbal singh should be thrown out of the sikh religion by the akal thakt and not praised because their hands are covered in the blood of sikh youths who were brutly murdered by the panjab police during the days of sikh struggle movement !! the whole sikh nation should condem this butcher, and reqeust the jathedars of sikhism to act harshly againts these sikh police officers like iqbal singh, k.p.s gill

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

Singh · 26 Nov 2004

respectfully, He could have written the most profound and knowledgeable book to have been written in the past decade and it still wouldn't matter. He as a person is a traitor and until he asks for forgiveness for turning in Sikh youth and having them killed, he CANNOT be honoured. The content of the book is irrelevant.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

gkd · 26 Nov 2004

i take my comments back kick these mahaa gays outta the panth, singhnia de bachaye maraye.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

S.B.S · 26 Nov 2004

Manjit Kaur bhainji when did that happen in Sangrur & was it in Proper sangur, cuz i used to live there! (2 years ago). Details Plz...

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

A Singh · 26 Nov 2004

Singh, Respectfully is still correct, if the content of the book is indeed irrelevant, then why the posts above accusing it of being RSS? I agree he needs to seek forgiveness, however why bring in other unrelated matters into this, it only weakens your side of the argument. Author: Singh Date: 11-25-04 16:51 respectfully, He could have written the most profound and knowledgeable book to have been written in the past decade and it still wouldn't matter. He as a person is a traitor and until he asks for forgiveness for turning in Sikh youth and having them killed, he CANNOT be honoured. The content of the book is irrelevant.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

singh as well · 26 Nov 2004

Actually A Singh, you and respectfully are both way off. The guy killed many sikhs and was a traitor to the panth. He should not be honoured by any sikh institution until he has asked for and received forgiveness. Regardless of what's in the book. It's a matter of basic ankh self respect. You don't honour the killers of your people just because they write a good book. You guys are trying a bit too hard to be nice liberals here. It's disgusting to even think that such a character is being honoured. People shouldn't start jumping to conclusions about RSS and the contents of the book, but Singh didn't say any of this stuff. Re-read the posts before lumping people into 'sides.' This isn't about sides. It's about a killer being honoured by the institutions of those he slaughtered.

Re: Traitors of Panth Being Honoured

respectfully · 27 Nov 2004

Actually, neither myself nor 'A Singh' are off. If this police officer is guilty of these crimes, then address those crimes and if there is a need for this man to be punished, then address the need for him to be punished - do not bring in ignorant assumptions on the content of what he has written. If you were to carefully read my original post, it was in response to forumites making uneducated assumptions as to the content of his book. I stated it was inappropriate to make such assumptions without having read the book itself. Blindly stating that the book is anti-gurmat or RSS propoganda only makes us look ignorant - if we're going to criticize the book, then do so after reading it. My post had nothing at all to do with honoring this man, or honoring his book and has little to do with being "nice liberals"- please don't make the mistake of thinking I am any less offended by this man than you are - that would be another blind assumption. respectfully, Respectfully O singh as well wrote: > Actually A Singh, you and respectfully are both way off. The > guy killed many sikhs and was a traitor to the panth. He > should not be honoured by any sikh institution until he has > asked for and received forgiveness. Regardless of what's in > the book. It's a matter of basic ankh self respect. You don't > honour the killers of your people just because they write a > good book. You guys are trying a bit too hard to be nice > liberals here. It's disgusting to even think that such a > character is being honoured. > > People shouldn't start jumping to conclusions about RSS and the > contents of the book, but Singh didn't say any of this stuff. > Re-read the posts before lumping people into 'sides.' This > isn't about sides. It's about a killer being honoured by the > institutions of those he slaughtered.