Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Conflicting Views

Conflicting Views

Singh Ji · 03 Apr 2003

I am aware of the rehit that Akhand Keertanee Jatha follows. But I am also aware of other rehits that other people follow such as the SGPC. For example when SGPC does amrit sanchar they only read 3 banis i believe. Is this right? I don't understand how they can do that while everyone else reads 5? Who is right? When doing an amrit sanchar what are the requirements for the panj pyare and how are these requirements set? Most importantly why do some panj pyare say one thing and other panj pyare say something different. If panj pyare are supposed to represent guru sahib shouldn't they say the same thing? This all confuses me and i start to question things. Does anyone else ever have similar questions? I'd appreciate a detailed answer. * While answering please explain all uncommon punjabi terms.

Re: Conflicting Views

Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2003

Singh Ji wrote: > For example when SGPC does amrit sanchar they only read 3 > banis i believe. Is this right? I don't understand how they > can do that while everyone else reads 5? Who is right? First of all, I am pretty sure that in the SGPC amrit sinchaar they read 5 baanis for the preparation of Amrit. The difference is that the requirement of everyday nitnem is 3 baanis according to the SGPC rehit maryada. Everyone else believes in 5 baanis nitnem. This is a minor problem. The ones who read 5 baanis cover the 3 baanis required by SGPC. > When doing an amrit sanchar what are the requirements for the > panj pyare and how are these requirements set? The ones who do sewa in Punj should be tyaar bar tyaar singhs or singhanis. They are chosen from the sangat of tyaar bar tyaar Amritdhari singhs and singhanis just before the amrit sinchaar. Most > importantly why do some panj pyare say one thing and other panj > pyare say something different. If panj pyare are supposed to > represent guru sahib shouldn't they say the same thing? This > all confuses me and i start to question things. Does anyone > else ever have similar questions? Different punj pyaare say different things because they are related to different panthik organizations. The reason why this happened is because some sants and organizations have given way to dhill (weakness) in order to increase the number of members in their organizations. Some of the weaknesses are as follows: 1) Amrit is now administered to bibis who don't wear a dastaar. If there is equality in Sikhi, then why are the bibiyaan not blessed with dastaar. In olden times all bibiyaan were blessed with dastaar. The writings of old English historians are witness to this. Please read the literature section of this. 2) Amrit is administered in the hazoori of pad-chhed saroop. This is the biggest weakness in panth. Who gave us right to change Guru Granth Sahib. What baffles me is that the Hindus still have laRidaar saroop of Geeta and 4 Vedaas. Muslims have not changed a single thing from Koran. Why did the Sikhs change the laridaar saroop to Padchhed? By changing the saroop to Padchhed we have changed the message of Gurbani in many places. Some saroops say "Uttar soo kheh" others say "Utras kheh". Some say "Jo mar jammeh so kach nikach" others say "Jo mar jamme so kachan kach". Which saroop should we believe? We have committed a blunder and we are getting punished for this. Look at the present state of our Panth. I think we the Sikhs have committed a major blunder by creating the different saroops of Guru Granth Sahib. Are we worse than the Hindus who have kept their Vedas, Puran, Simiritees and Geeta still laRidaar? Are we worse than Muslims who have not changed anything in Koran. Jews have not changed a single thing from Torah. They don't even allow publishing and only hand-written Torah are allowed. They have hundreds of writers writing Torah in Israel. I believe we are worse of all in this respect. On one hand we matha tek to Guru Sahib, keep it in expensive rumaalas and do sukh aasan and parkash, unlike any other religion. On the other hand we have the audicity to take the laRidaar gurbani and cut it into pieces. This is worse than actually tearing off the angs of Guru Granth Sahib. At least if we tear the angs, we are not tearing off Gurbani but when we do padd chhed, we are tearing apart Gurbani. Everyone out there should get a clear understanding that the jyot of Guru Sahib is in the Laridaar saroop only. Laridaar saroop alone has the original message of baani. Padd chhed saroop has many versions. Each organization has its own version. Taksal has its' own version and SGPC has its own. By doing padd-chhed we have destroyed ourselves. Today too there is hope. There is hope if you all wake up. If we wake up and do parkaash of only Laridaar saroop at our homes and our neighbouring gurdwaras, we can restore the lost pride of our Panth. Since we have teared apart our Guru, we have been punished with so much dhehindi kala. We have been living like slaves for the last 100 years or so. We lost so many youths in the last 20 years but we did not gain anything. What is the matter? We have given up our Guru and have committed contempt by tearing apart our Guru. We have now become slaves. Let us recognize the greatness of the laRidaar saroop and then alone we can get in chardi kala. There has been no panthic resolution to pass the padd-chhed saroop. Look how hard it has been to change the calender to Nanakshaahi. How come no one protested when they tore apart our Guru???? Why are we silent spectators of this maha-be-adabi. Let there be no mistake that all mahapurakhs have only endorsed Laridaar saroop. In Taksal, to this day only laridaar saroop is parkashed at Mehta chowk and they give santhiya only from laridaar pothis. We greatly appreciate this. Similarly the sidaqwaan singhs of Akhand Kirtani Jatha do kirtan, Akhand Paath and Amrit Sinchaar in the hazoori of onlyu Laridaar saroop. We are sacrifice over such gursikhs, million times. I am sorry that this topic got off-topic. Sangat baksh lave. 3) Naam should be done drirh and the technique too should be taught at the amrit sinchaars. 4) Amrit should be given by 5 pyaare and not by 1 or 2 pyaare as is the case with most amrit sinchaars. Daas, Kulbir Singh