Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

carbon steel and cast iron

carbon steel and cast iron

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Nov 2004

what is the difference between carbon steel and cast iron? which is sarbloh? thanks.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

RSingh · 24 Nov 2004

Generally, both are acceptable as sarbloh. Most carbon steels are usually over 96% Fe (iron) (actually, it might be about 97-98% iron, I can't recall the exact figures right now). The remaining couple of percent is made up of carbon and trace amounts of other alloying elements. Cast iron contains much more carbon than carbon steel and some silicon as well, to aid in the castibility properties. Off the top of my head, I remember it being something like ~90-95% iron and several percent carbon, contained mostly as carbon or Fe/C precipitates. Both of these metal groups (there are many, many types of carbon steels, with slightly varying compositions and many types of cast irons as well) are generally accepted as sarbloh, as iron is by far the main element (well over 90% usually). Perhaps more importantly for sarblohee purposes, the iron content in these metals is readily available for surface interactions, whether it be during cooking, eating or cleaning. This is in contrast to Stainless Steel, in which the iron is not readily available for surface interactions. It also contains much less iron (typically 65-80%, although it might be higher or lower for certain applications. These figures are just ballpark figures. I haven't actually looked at the exact compositions in some time). Stainless steel also contains large amounts of Chromium and/or Nickel.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Nov 2004

in punjabi does loha = iron and does sarbloh = carbon steel does iron rust? carbon steel rusts, right? pure iron - are there even utensils made of that?

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

RSingh · 24 Nov 2004

I'm not sure about the linguistic background of this term. Iron rusts and carbon steel (and cast iron) rust due to the iron content. Pure iron (100% Fe) would be next to impossible to make. Even in labs, you won't find 100% pure anything. 99.99% or 99.999% purity iron in my lab was considered very high purity. You wouldn't make utensils or anything else out of this though. It would be too weak and brittle. You need some carbon impurities to strenghthen it (less than 1% carbon or even 0.3% will do the trick quite well).

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

sarbloh dhay naal moh · 25 Nov 2004

Regarding the linguistic background of the term, I believe a 'sarblohee' is khalsa bolla for one that prepares and eats food in iron utensils, which would then make 'sarbloh' iron or high carbon steel.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

EkAurSikh · 25 Nov 2004

Please excuse my ignorance, however, if 'sarbloh' is so important to Sikhism then why do all the Gurdwaras use alluminim and steel pots/pans and utinsils? They even use plastic items (sppons, cups and glasses etc) in may gurdwaras.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

ManjitSingh · 25 Nov 2004

The following is a brief information about iron and steel found from a website: The alloys of iron are steel, manganese steel, stainless steel and titanium steel. Steel is a mixture of iron and carbon. The amount of carbon may range from 0·1% to 1·5% giving steels of different properties. Low carbon steel (less than 0·25% carbon) is called mild steel. High carbon steel (more than 0·5% carbon) is stronger than mild steel but it is more brittle. Manganese steel is an alloy of iron (84%), manganese (15%) and carbon (1%). Stainless steel is an alloy of iron (80%), chromium (15%), nickel (4%) and carbon (0·5 to 1%). Titanium steel may contain 0·5 to 2% titanium with varying amounts of other metals including chromium, nickel and vanadium. Here a question arises, if iron is the major part of steel, then isn't steel better to store the food(if it has to be) than other thing like clay utensils or wood utensils etc. ??? Please share your opinion.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

Singh · 25 Nov 2004

The disuse of sarbloh is like the many other rehits that aren't followed anymore, like lareedaar saroop, dastaar for women, etc. If you look at all old langars, they will all have sarbloh pots and deghas. Even if they aren't used anymore, they will still be in the langar and were the original utensils.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Nov 2004

Dear RSingh, wouldn't you say that Sarbloh is pure iron ? because why would Guru Sahib say "sarbloh kee rachhaa hamnai" if Sarbloh is not pure? could you explain to me the metaphor / philosophy behind it ? thanks Dear EkAurSikh, I think even the use of aluminum and steel pots and pans was inspired and motivated by the "metallic" theme and they were rip-offs from sarbloh batas and karaahees used in the olden days perhaps due to lack of rehit (like myself), or lack of convenience, people began substituting and this pattern of substitution became institutionalized vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

EkAurSikh · 26 Nov 2004

Thank you "kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa " ji. However, please all, again excuse my ignorance as I am a somewhat ingonrant Sikh and seek your forgiveness. But is it possible that a great importance was given to LOHA as in Sarbloh at the time because it was deemed as the strongest element available (readily available that masses could afford) in the form of metal at the time and Guru Ji were building a "strong" Kaum of Sikhs and hence the relationship. Could it be that Guru Ji may have selected Steel or some other metal if one was 'readily availabe' for the 'masses' and yet strong and versatile?

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

Singh · 26 Nov 2004

Guru Sahib could have picked brass or somethign else as it was just as easily available and affordable. Guru Sahib has given special recognition to Sarbloh for some reason. Otherwise he would not have written "sarbloh kee rachha humnai".

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

Caprice Sun · 26 Nov 2004

EkAurSikh jee, Guru sahib says that, "Pragtayo Khalsa parmatam key mauj". Also, "Aagya bhaee Akal Key tabhee chalaio panth" I think it is clear that Khalsa was created by Akal Purakh. Khalsa was not created as a consequence of social/economic/religious atmosphere of the time. I think the atmosphere was created for the Khalsa but that's another discussion altogether. In anycase, Guru sahib created the Khalsa per God's hukam and thus all the rehit that Khalsa has is per God's hukam. God's hukams are atal. Meaning they are unchageable. The world changes. Our society goes through 100's of fashion and social trends within a single season. Morals also change. What was unacceptable behaviour 40 years ago is now the norm. There is no element of permanency in today's world. Guru shahib gave us something to fall back on. He gave us something to strenthen us, to discipline us and to unite us. Something permanent. He gave us rehit. Sarbloh is a Khalsa rehit. Rehit is inhrently unchangeable. But we have so many different versions of rehit out there don't we? It is because people decided they were smarter then guru sahib and decided to act according to their own mann (also known as manmatt). For example those who do amrit sanchars without dastaar for bibis. (This is also another discussion altogether.) WE have gained factions in the panth because we strayed from Sikhi rehit. We are so strongly affected by proganda created by RSS and RAW etc. because we have lost our rehit. Look at what has happened when people decided to change rehit? Guru sahib gave us rehit and if we had kept it, we would have avoided a lot of pain and suffering. Could you imagine if all Sikhs were sarblohi... the panth would be unshakeable. My point (finally....) is that Sarbloh is Khalsa rehit and is unchangeable. Guru sahib could have used gold (known to be beneficial to one's health) or any number of other metals (copper etc. etc.) but he chose to make amrit in a sarbloh bata. Do people really entertain the thought that they can understand guru sahib's reasoning... that they can deduce guru's sahib's reasons for doing thigns? If you want to see what guru sahib saw... you've to be standing next to him. Meaning you have to have the same avastha. I think the point is clear. It should be good enough that Guru sahib used sarbloh to make amrit. It wouldn't be amrit if it wasn't made in sarbloh. Singhs have Gurbani which is unchageable. It is permanent. We have naam which is also unchageable and permanent. HOWEVER we can not benefit from these if we dont' have rehit. We need rehit to become attached to Gurbani and naam. I've heard a Singh call Sarbloh rehit the backbone of the panth. I agree completely.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

R Singh · 26 Nov 2004

I can't really answer the question about whether to use clay or stainless steel for storage. However, stainless steel should definitely not be used for cooking or eating by sarblohees. It contains a fair amount of iron (~65-80%) but it has a surface layer which prevents the iron from interacting with its surroundings. This leads to its 'stainless' character and is the reason it won't rust. It's also hard for me to say anything about the metaphorical meanings behind that tuk and its relation to 'pure' iron. What I can say is that the sarbloh used in Guru Saahib's time was not pure iron. This is seen from the artifacts that we have from that period. I think the problem could be with our idea of a 'pure' metal. We're thinking elementally pure and assume that sarbloh should be pure iron. However, pure iron is impractical to use and is next to impossible to obtain outside of labs. It is weak and brittle and can't be fashioned into any useful utensil. In my thinking, sarbloh refers to that group of iron alloys in which the great qualities of iron are available in a usable form. Adding Carbon doesn't make it 'impure.' It simply increases the strength and makes the iron capable of being used, while maintaining the desirable effects of iron. Alloying simply allows the practical use of iron. Don't consider the tiny amounts of carbon to be impurities but as an integral part of sarbloh, without which we wouldn't be able to access the desirable properties of sarbloh. Iron definitely has some special properties, that can only be known by those who've experienced it. Carbon steels, sarbloh, is the form in which this iron is available to us, and so, Guru Saahib has done it's upmaa.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

vivek · 28 Nov 2004

i have spoken to a proffesional blacksmith who makes copys of antique ornamental items. He uses the same process of iron extraction which was used in the 1700s. The result is 'puddled iron' which is approx. 99.99% PURE IRON (0.001% mineral content NO CARBON). Puddled iron is described as being DULL in appearance, malleable and rusts very rapidly when left wet. Steel is NOT sarbloh; carbon is added to iron in process. This process was NOT available in 1700s hence carbon steel isnt sarbloh.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

R Singh · 29 Nov 2004

vivek, what you are talking about is wrought iron. It is produced using the puddling process and can produce very low carbon irons. It is mostly used for ornamental items and furniture. However, it is definitely not 99.99% pure iron. 99.99% is very high purity in metallurgical terms and it is highly improbable that a blacksmith could even accurately measure impurity content at this level, much less produce it. Iron produced using the puddling process (wrought iron) is very weak and can't be used for shastars. It basically can't keep an edge. None of the old shastars from our guru's period are made with wrought iron. They are made with carbon steel. Damascus, Wootz and other such metals are all carbon steels. You can take puratan shastars and get them tested and you will be told that they are in fact carbon steel. The carbon steel making process is quite old. Adding carbon simply involves firing the iron using charcoal. Simple coal also works. These are your carbon sources and firing the metal with these either on the metal or even outside the crucible containing the metal, will result in carbon diffusing into the metal and creating carbon steel. It is also worth mentioning that India had some of the most advanced steel production (you could also call it iron production) in the world at that time. Steel used for Damascus weapons and other high quality weapons came mostly from India. European steel making technology didn't catch up until later. I just did a basic search using google to provide some references to support what I'm saying. This site gives a pretty good overview of the history of iron and steel. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steel I think one point of confusion is that we are mixing up the terminology. A lot of people refer to stainless steel simply as steel. Stainless steel is a fairly modern innovation, while carbon steels are quite old. The term 'iron' is quite often used to refer to most steels as well, so this causes even more confusion.

Re: carbon steel and cast iron

EkAurSikh · 29 Nov 2004

Caprice Sun Ji, Thank you very much indeed for your explanation. Isn't it great that there are people like you and other Singhs and Singhanees here who are so helpful. May Waheguru help us all be like folks like you.