Re: Gianis?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 23 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
This is ebcause like the word SANT/BRAHGIANI this word "GYANI" is much MISUSED.
In GURBANI the GIANNI is a person who "knows" and is in "touch" with Waheguru...and elevated soul...
IN "common" parlance every "man who is connected with anything to do with a Gurdwara/kirtan/degh preparation/Katha/Tabla player/ etc etc" is a GIANI JI... a "honoriifc term" used by people to describe these people..
In history there is a tradition of the GIANNI SAMPARDAA - whereby great academicians, writers, elevated souls like Bhai Veer Singh, for example were referrred to as GIANNIS.... the KNOWLEDGEABLE, the VENERABLES...The RESPECTED LUMINARIES...etc
The Last case is that this "word" is also used by the PUNJAB UNIVERSITIES - the earliest.... Punjab University Lahore...to the latest Guru nanak university Amrtisar, Punjabi University etc etc AWARD a "GYANI DEGREE" ( Academic Degree equivalent to B.A HONS - in PUNJABI). This last case scenario is applicable to myself as well. I went through teh Three Year Budhimani course/GYani Course of Punjab University Chandigarh ( from lahore- Simla- Chandigarh..as Punjab changed its status..)..and passed and got this "Gyani" title after my name !!... The earlier generation of GYANI JI's in MALAYSIA all sat for and passed this Degree Examination...now a days many ex- tabla players who graduate to "Giani Ji" ( after becoming paid Granthis in Gurdwaras) cant even write simple Punjabi..
The SANT/BRAHMGIANI is another category all together...everyone on thsi forum is all to familiar with this category.
Dass jarnail Singh
Re: Gianis?
Search for Tat · 24 Nov 2004
in gurbani it says, Hindu is blind, a muslim has one eye open, but a giani is more wise than both.
A hindu is blind because he is caught in idol worship and ritualism. A muslim recognises one God, and no idol worship, so has one eye open. But a Giani is a person who is wise and spiritual. i.e. a Gursikh. He is above both because he has developed a high avastha by searching the truth.
So I think a Giani can only be a person like Giani Amolak Singh or Giani Nahar singh.
Re: Gianis?
LuMMa Padhey Singh · 25 Nov 2004
The granthis are also called giani and i don't see anything wrong with that.
It has become a common term and is very suitable for a good granthi. Perhaps the people more sianei can give a better explanation.
Re: Gianis?
please clarify · 25 Nov 2004
Dear Jarnail Singh Ji,
Could you please clarify your following statement? Do you have a negative viewpoint on "ex-tabla" players? I'm very confused by the relevance of your statement to any subject. Infact is sounds like a blatent and gross generalization.
I understand the point you are trying to make, but a statement like that just isnt right!
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani wrote:
>...now a days many ex- tabla
> players who graduate to "Giani Ji" ( after becoming paid
> Granthis in Gurdwaras) cant even write simple Punjabi..
Re: Gianis?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 25 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
To Please clarify ji.
NO Ji, I dont have a "negative perspective" on ex-tabla players per se.
It is just a term..stemming from the fact that the "tabla player" in a Typical Ragi jatha is always the least important...in most cases he is the first to 'desert" the jatha and become a paid granthi in any gurdwara that keeps him on...and usually in 99% of the Jathas that come on a second and third or fouth visit, the Tabla player is always a new one..with both lead and second waja player the same persons....that is proof of the high "turnover" of tabla players..... almost ALL the low paid temporary granthis we have are ex-tabla players and NOT the LEAD Waja Players of any Ragi jatha. Also a lot of youths can manage to play "tabla" but not as a LEAD Waja Player..who obviously has to have Gurbani background/shabads punjabi language skills etc. I persoanlly know of amny such ex-tabla players who just joined the jathas to get an opportunity to go abroad...their first priority is to get a job ( not tabla playing)...and they have very LOW education even in Punjabi. THATS ALL.
I could have used any term...like ex-punjabi schol teacher/ex-gardner/etc but that wont sync with the statitistics on gurdwara employees i am referrign to.
Of course there are excellent tabla players, very good ones whose career is tabla , my younger brothers are two of the best tabla players in the country...one of them is in the USA at the moment doing his Doctrate..and so on.
I hope you get the clarification you wanted.
jarnail singh
Re: Gianis?
singhagainstbling · 26 Nov 2004
manjit
"there are a lot of YOUNG unemployed ex-Farmers (Jatts) from Punjab who have migrated illegally to countries like Cyprus, Malaysia, singapore, european countries . italy etc etc and who unable to find jobs become keshdharee and "giani ji" "
disagree, most gyani jis in uk at least seem to be either mazbhi or bhappey. most jatts in the new waves i noticed are cut haired and stick with sangats that r more inclined towards building works, construction, socialising in non religious circles wanting to settle in new life to own houses n get married. Becomign a gyani in the west isnt the way to go about this. Please leave caste out of this when it isnt the issue.
Re: Gianis?
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 26 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
I think it is not a question of "caste" per se... I am in MALAYSIA..and 99% of the ILLEGAL immigrants from PUNJAB claim they are PUTT SARDARAAN DE...and were enjoying life as SARDAR JI on their Farms...they ahd to SELL off so much LAND/ or put it on Mortgage etc...and pay the AGENTS etc to get out.... so everybody is passing off as "jatt"...no one wants to say eh is actually a mazabhi/choorha/mwrassi/whatever and had no land etc to sell/mortgage back home.
ALL of these invariably end up as unskilled labourers doing poorly paid labour work/not gettign apid by unscrupulous employers who know they are illegals and then paying off the police etc and finally get deported after serving time in horrible jails...and they are then BACK AGAIN under a different passport/new name etc..
Those among these who know a bit of Punjabi/paath/tabla playing/waja etc soon REVERT to keeping kesh/dahree/ and then wear cholas etc and get work in gurdwaras...
This is the Malaysian story..i am not in the know about what Bhen Ji manjit Kaur is actually talking about in other countries she mentions..
jarnail singh