A view of Krishan Ji
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 20 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Just this morning i was reading an article on a Hindu site and this was what the writer had to say:
Guru Gobind Singh Ji is incarnation of Krishna.... IS this TRUE ??
All of Us who raed Gur Ji's Banis know and have learned that Guru Ji only worshipped one God and He never ever mentioned being Krishna or anything even close to that in His biography. Guru Ji never believed in Krishna. Guru Ji says:
"I do not accept Ganesha as important. I do not meditate on Krishna, neither on Vishnu. I do not hear them and do not recognize them. My love is with the Lotus feet of God. He is my protector, the Supreme Lord. I am dust of his Lotus feet." (Guru Gobind Singh,)
This means Guru Ji was not incarnation of Krishna. Now lets look at what Krishna did during his lifetime. Was he really a God?
In Bhagvat Purana chapter 10, section 22 says that once Krishna saw women taking bath in the river. So he went there and stole their clothes and made them come outside naked to get their clothes. When they did he forced them to mate with him. What kind of God would do that? Is this the kind of love God gives to his children? In the same chapter section 60 says that Krishna had 16,108 wives and Radha was not one of them. Each wife gave birth to 10 sons and one daughter means that Krishna had 161,080 sons and 16,108 daughters. So all together he had 177188 children. This shows how lustful Krishna was and RSS is trying to compare him with the greatest of all, Guru Gobind Singh Ji?
God is not lustful at all. Guru Ji has taught us to overcome the five thieves including Lust, Anger, Greed, Emotional Attachment and Pride (Egotism). If Guru Ji were incarnation of Krishna, Guru Ji would have never taught us this concept. If we learn the message of the Gurus then we can understand that the Guru Ji were never incarnation of anyone. Guru Ji was one with God and showed us the same path He followed. Dhan Guru Nanak Ji. Gurbani says:
"In the Jujar Veda, Kaan Krishna of the Yaadva tribe seduced Chandraavali by force." (Page 470)
"Even Krishna and Balbhadar meditated on the Lord, falling at the Guru's Feet." (Page 165)
Dear Readers make your own conclusion.... Gurbani quoted in AAng 470 is clearer than crystal clear.
Perhaps some readers can actually GIVE us SOMETHING in Moral Character that we can LEARN and Follow from the Life of Krishan ji....to IMPROVE our own Morality that is. Please give quotations from the relevant books and back it up with GURBANI.
Thanks in advance.
Dass Jarnail singh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Bijla Singh · 21 Nov 2004
good post. authors like Ishar Singh Nara wasted part of his life trying to prove Guru Ji was incarnation of Krishna. that fool wasted his time and money and only hindus liked his work. btw jarnail singh, did you copy this information from http://www.searchsikhism.com/rss.html or somewhere else? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Bijla Singh · 21 Nov 2004
P Singh, a tv serial mahabharta showed all these "leelas" of krishan and do you think Bani is wrong when Guru Ji says "In the Jujar Veda, Kaan Krishna of the Yaadva tribe seduced Chandraavali by force." (Page 470).
it is not one site. RSS is a hindu organization known all over india that preaches this crap. "father of india" gandhi spoke against Guru Ji. hindus in favor of sikhi are very few in numbers. just think how many hindus spoke against 1984 third holocaust and how many were in favor of it. nothing good has ever come out of this "hindu-sikh brotherhood" and nothing ever will. a separate country is the solution to everything. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
ManjitSingh · 22 Nov 2004
Sant Singh Maskeen in one of kathaa tape said some thing like this:
One day when Guru Gobind Singh Jee were sitting in Darbar with the 52 poets (Kavi). At some point of time one of the poet whose name was Sudamaa said to Guru Jee "I know who you were in your last birth". When Guru Jee asked him to tell, Sudama said " You were Krishan and I was same Sudama, you childhood friend.
I am not sure how authentic this sakhi is. Let us see what difference it makes if this true or not true.
If it is not true, do we really care? I don't think it matters what Guru Jee's last birth was.
If it is true, this is very good to me. We should start convincing Krishan Bhagats to be Amritdhari now.
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Veer Bijla Singh ji is right..this is NOT a single website....or even a few websites.... this is OFFICIAL HINDU Propoganda.... and SIKHS so called GYANI NARA SINGH spent an entire lifetime researching, twisting and manipulating everythign from Gurbani to dasam granth etc to "prove" that Guru Gobind Singh Ji was KRISHNA./ or his avtaar
And I wish well to thsoe like veer manjit singh ji above who think we can convinve Krishan Bhagats to becoem Amrtidahree.... the reality is quite the opposite.... we are lsoing more sikhs to krishna bhagats throught he efforts of the derawallahs , Mahapurashs, sri 108s..sanatanists NIHUNGS etc with hindu leanings trying to prove Sikhism is HINDUISM in "Keshas" only.
IF one has taken AMRIT of GURU JI, place all your FAITH in GURU JI and GURU JI ONLY. Only GURBANI can lead us out of this eass of maya and towards waheguru.
Regards to all,
Jarnail singh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Bijla Singh · 22 Nov 2004
Bachittar Natak explains everything but even then Guru Ji said "I do not meditate on Krishna". so clears all the doubts.
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
DIG DEEP ?? You must be joking P singh Ji.
THESE types of LUSTY stories are so heavily scaterred in the Hindu Purans vedas mahabharts ramayna vishnu puran etc... the "good teachings" are like salt in Atta...
Surprising you managed to get hold of a grain of salt in the mound of Atta... you are GOOD. Carry on. Tell us about the "good teachings"..On second thought you ahd better keep them to your self as I have no time..Life is SO SHORT and Naam beckons...
Cheerio
jarnail singh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 23 Nov 2004
re: P Singh
the website you posted is hilarious
they try to establish the holiness of their Mata by showing photography manipulated with special effects
I can make anybody holy in Adobe Photoshop by those standards !
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Caprice Sun · 25 Nov 2004
To be honest I don't think anyone visting this site needs to be conviced that Guru sahib is/was NOT a Krishan Avtar.
Bani is guru and Gurbani (as noted above) clearly disagress with a lot of what Krishna did.
In any case what I find intresting is this.
Hindu people are always trying to convince Sikhs that they are hindus with kesh. That Sikhs were simply created to protect hinduism.
This is highly illogical. If we think it through then even their own arguments don't make sense.
This is why:
1) If Krishan came back as guru gobind singh jee and established the Khalsa wouldn't that mean that all hindus are now to become khalsa too.
2) If hindus are sikhs then isn't it true that since sikhism was established later it would mean that God saw a need to improve hinduism and so established sikhism. Again this would mean that all hindus should become Sikhs and adopt the "improved version" of their religion.
The fact is that you can call anyone a Hindu. Why? Because I don' think there is anyone alive who can define Hinduism.
I have nothing against hindus. We have really close family friends who are hindus and get along with them famously... I only have a problem with people who try to hurt Sikhi.
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Mandip Singh · 25 Nov 2004
Reading the reply P. Singh got from his post on the Hindu forums...
"Both Krishan devotees and Krishan bashers do not understand that you can't take mythological stories as literal history.Just like the Joshua myth...."
...seems to end this discussion for me. Hindus are starting to accept this that the Krishna stories are mythology like the Greek and Norse gods. These are stories written to provide guidance for the public when there were no real life examples of people who they should follow.
We are extremely lucky that we have had 10 wonderful and unmatched examples of how we should try to lead our lives and if anyone still has any doubt they only need to consult Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji which will dispel any doubts or confusion.
Obviously there are elements in the stories that are still useful in providing guidance or explaining certain principles especially when the people you are providing guidance to are familar with those stories. Hence why I think the Guru Sahibs use them to get their message across.
In my uneducated opinion I think the Krishna and Ram mythological stories should be accepted for what they are, ie stories, and we shouldn't really spend too much time trying to argue about them. Instead we should (especially me) spend our valuable energy trying to live our lives as Guru Ji intended.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
singhagainstbling · 26 Nov 2004
manjit its the way your saying things not your message. theres a polite way of just saying stick to bani end of without all the rest of the stuff.
Re: A view of Krishan Ji
Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 18 Dec 2004
It is a misconception that GURU TEGBAHADUR Ji gave shahedeee to save "Hindu Religion"...that is seriously limiting GURU JI's Mahaan Shahedee.
GURU JI gave His head for RELIGIOUS FREEDOM...one of the Hallmarks of the United nations Charter and Human RIghts today.
IF the tables ahd been reversed and a Hindu Raja was forcibly converting MUSLIMS....GURU JI woulkd still have given His HEAD.
Isnt it 100% CONTRADICTORY that GURU NANAK REJECTS janeaus, castes, pilgrimages, sacred baths and sacred pools, brahmins sharadhs etc etc (99.9% of HINDUISM)...and His 9th NANAK "defends" all this as CORRECT ?? and gives His head for its SURVIVAL ?? GURU JI told Aurengzeb...You are trying to make all India ONE religion..my HEAD will ensure you have THREE religions instead.... this is clearly a stand for religious freedom.
SIKHI is a UNIVERSAL religion.. for ALL MANKIND...not just the Hindus. I am not anati hindu per se...but just look aat sikh history and count how mnay MUSLIM helpers on GURU JI's side and How many HINDUS against GURU JI. Baba Banda Singh Ji bahadur's army on Sirhind had 5000 MUSLIM soldiers fighting the tyranny of Moghuls...while GURU Gobind Singh Ji had Pir Budhui Shah and his 4 sons, 700 murids at the battle of Bhangani.
manjit Kaur