GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 19 Nov 2004
WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH.
Can it be possible for "GURBANI" to be written by ...
Bhai Lehna Ji... ( as an example) or ONLY By GURU ANGAD JI ??
Some points to consider.... maybe some esteemd reader can comment.
1. ONLY GURU NANAK is AAD GURU.... from WAHEGURU. Therefore His GURBANI is from his entire life...becasue even as a child of five sitting in front of the Panda/Pandit/maulavi...GURU JI Ucharred Gurbani.
2. But from Bhai lehna Ji onwards...GURBANI is ONLY recorded when Bhai lehna Ji became GURU ANGAD Sahib Jee...
3. Bhai Amardass Ji was bestowed Gurgadhi at a very advanced stage after nearly 22 years of sewa/naam simran.....and His Anand Sahib and other Gurbani comes after Gurgadhi.
4. Guru Amardass Ji is said to have lifted up the CHILD Arjun ( Guru Ji's grandson) and sat him in his lap and prdicted that this child was Guru Ka Dohta..GURBANI ka BOHITHA... the grandchild of the Guru..SHIP of GURBANI. And that was Exactly what GURU ARJUN JI was to become later as His GURBANI is the MOST PROLIFIC after GURU NANAK sahib jee..
5. The Words MEHLA Pehla , dooja, teeja, choutha, panjvaan, nouvaan etc is already an indication that this GURBANI is written by the respective GURU JI SAHIBAAN.
6. We have Gurbani Pharmaan that declares GURBANI is DHUR KI BANI.... as such it is imperative that DHUR KI BANI can ONLY come to a GURU...and not to a "person" who is not yet GURU...THAT wouldnt classify as "DHUR KI BANI"
7. The same criteria applies to Bhagat bani...MOST if not all the "bani" written by the bhagats especially kabir BEFORE he attained "GURMATT" is REJECTED by GURU JI. ONLY when Kabir Ji attained that special stage in life when whatever he wrote was TOTALLY IN LINE with GURMATT..is accepted fro inclusion in GURGU Granth JI. ALL prior bani is REJECTED as unfit....and the proof of this is that the Kabir panthis have a tremendous amount of kabir bani bhajans etc OUTSIDE of Gurbani recorded in Guru Granth ji under Kabir's name. Some other Bhagats have only a SINGLE LINE of "GURBANI" included in Guru Granth Ji...surely if a person can write a single line..he must have written a lot more...BUT then that doesnt meet GURU ji's strict criterion.
The SAKHI that I am referring to is the one connected with GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE about writing Shabad Hazare when he was just a child and the GURU was GURU RAM DASS JI. IS it "possible" for the child ARJUN to write GURBANI when He was not yet GURU ?? How could DHUR KI BANI come to a person who is not yet GURU ??
SAKHIS are creations of very imaginative minds....some are so obviously weird and anti-GURMATT that we can dismiss them instantly ( YET even these have their adherents who religiously quote them again and again in their parchaar/katha etc...and look very askance at anyone who even suggests that their sakhi is anti gurmatt) Thus we have KALYUG personified and talking to GURU JI... as if time is a person....when we have GURU NANAK JI's personal testimony in a SHABAD that ( to BLAME a YUGG ?? is displaying ones own weaknesses)... WHEN in SATYUG/DWAPAR etc, it was the SAME SUN, the SAME MOON, the SAME STARS, ( and by implication the same water/air/trees/earth/ etc etc) THEN why do people "blame" KALYUG for their SINS...surely GURU JI SAYS: IT is the PEOPLE's MANN that is changed...NOT the YUGG. TIME (YUGG) is the SAME...people change...Kalyug is just a conveneint SCAPEGOAT. (The sakhi attached to this shabad is that once Bhai mardana and Guru JI arrived at Bhagwaan Krishan ji's Birthplace...and in the HOLY Mela/Pooja etc..some BRAHMINS were caught doing something very very "inappropriate"....and the People's excuse for this was: THIS IS KALYUGG ...WHAT else do you expect ?? When GURU JI heard this..He Uchaared this shabad about the yuggs.) and perfectly right all this is. How many times have we heard people saying things like : Kalyug hai jee, thats why people are stealing the Guru's Golak, raping children, murdering friends and blood relatives for money,mothers killing daughters, Mothers in law seducing their sons in law...etc etc...KALYUGG is a pretty good SCAPEGOAT for our own FAILINGS and CRIMINAL MINDS ??? SO while this particular sakhi looks ok.... the one about kalyug personified and trying to seduce Guru Ji is totally out....
Prof sahib Singh Ji's Guru Granth darpan concentrates solely on GURBANI aarths. There is not a SINGLE sakhi included....unlike the various teekas of Sants/ and earlier Gyanis...which contain not one or two but sometimes several sakhis attached to each shabad....and almost all of these are taken from HINDU TEXTS and MYTHS. Most of these are so obviouly anti-Grmatt that they can be dismissed out of hand.
I am not dissing ALL sakhis...just saying we MUST use GURBANI as a TOUCH STONE to judge each sakhi. Personally, I NEVER attach any sakhi to my gurbani santhiyas as GURBANI by itself is SO GREAT that it needs no "ADDITIONS" to make it "interesting"..I have found the sakhis DISTRACT from the DIVINE MESSAGE of GURBANI rather than help....BUT if any reader more into Sikhi can help me change my mind...Please do.
Dassan dass jarnail Singh.
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Bijla Singh · 20 Nov 2004
Interesting points. never really thought about the sakhi of Guru Arjan Dev Ji but makes sense. and kalyug, Gurbani says "Ik Gharee Na Miltay Tan Kaljug Hotaa" now that is a real kaljug in Gurmat. when majority people believed Waheguru they only followed the Truth and all were free from the circle of life and death. that time was called Satyug or Time of Truth. now, people have forgotton Waheguru, so this is kalyug or time of kaal (death) because most people are not free from this trap which is why Guru Ji says "Now, the Dark Age of Kali Yuga has come. Plant the Naam, the Name of the One Lord." (1185). Only true Gursikhs are free and only because Guru Ji saved them. The following Shabad is very beautiful. Ang 902
Raamkalee, First Mehl, Ashtapadees:
One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru:
The same moon rises, and the same stars; the same sun shines in the sky.
The earth is the same, and the same wind blows. The age in which we dwell affects living beings, but not these places. ||1||
Give up your attachment to life.
Those who act like tyrants are accepted and approved - recognize that this is the sign of the Dark Age of Kali Yuga. ||1||Pause||
Kali Yuga has not been heard to have come to any country, or to be sitting at any sacred shrine.
It is not where the generous person gives to charities, nor seated in the mansion he has built. ||2||
If someone practices Truth, he is frustrated; prosperity does not come to the home of the sincere.
If someone chants the Lord's Name, he is scorned. These are the signs of Kali Yuga. ||3||
Whoever is in charge, is humiliated. Why should the servant be afraid,
when the master is put in chains? He dies at the hands of his servant. ||4||
Chant the Praises of the Lord; Kali Yuga has come.
The justice of the previous three ages is gone. One obtains virtue, only if the Lord bestows it. ||1||Pause||
In this turbulent age of Kali Yuga, Muslim law decides the cases, and the blue-robed Qazi is the judge.
The Guru's Bani has taken the place of Brahma's Veda, and the singing of the Lord's Praises are good deeds. ||5||
Worship without faith; self-discipline without truthfulness; the ritual of the sacred thread without chastity - what good are these?
You may bathe and wash, and apply a ritualistic tilak mark to your forehead, but without inner purity, there is no understanding. ||6||
In Kali Yuga, the Koran and the Bible have become famous.
The Pandit's scriptures and the Puraanas are not respected.
O Nanak, the Lord's Name now is Rehmaan, the Merciful.
Know that there is only One Creator of the creation. ||7||
Nanak has obtained the glorious greatness of the Naam, the Name of the Lord. There is no action higher than this.
If someone goes out to beg for what is already in his own home, then he should be chastised. ||8||1||
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 20 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Thank You veer Bijla Singh Ji. I really and thoroughly enjoyed your post.
Added to my knowledge quite a lot. Thanks.
jarnail singh.
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
dear Singh and P singh Ji,
I read and reread Manjit Bhen Ji;s post about ten times and failed to see where according to YOU .. she says:
Gurbani is "simple" street wise language, must be literally translated, word for word etc etc. twisted and distorted translations etc.
These are your observations...NOT hers. What she says ( i think..if not she can explain herself).... is that GURBANI is COMPLETE in itself...and that is correct. Thaal wich teen vasthu paiyeoo... the THAAL of GURBANI iscomplete...no salt/masallas ned to be added to "improve" its taste.
TRUTH needs no "embellishment".... LIES and Half truths need that.
Prof sahib singh has translated GURBANI...it is Not word for word translation, simplified, literally translated or all of what you say....I must say it is the BEST Translation yet...and all accomplished without any sakhis/fairy tales/ condiments and salt to embellish thetaste of the TRUTH in GURBANI.
This is what Manjit means. ( If she differs then I am sorry to be presumptive)
Dass jarnail singh.
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
AnotherSingh · 24 Nov 2004
When we look at Gurbani from a higher avastha we are able to understand it better. This does not mean it has contradictory meanings.
For example, if you are learning english grammer you may have a kacha understanding of it at one point. However, later on in life when you are more mature, your understanding may be much deeper and more profound. This is not to say that there are numerous and often contradictory ways of understanding it.
This applies to Gurbani as well. The great Gurmukhs with high avasthas are much more spiritually mature than us. The understand Gurbani at a much deeper level than we do. And yes, even with a lifetime of study, we will not be able to understand Gurbani at their level because much of it is intutional and comes directly from their advanced spiritual height. We would need their explanation to be able to understand it at this deep level.
In my opinion, a person with a higher avastha can experience Gurbani in a deeper way. So they would not be able to verbally impart this entire understanding to us. May times people write that Gurbani is to be experienced, there are many things in this world that can only be FULLY understood through experience. Gurbani is one of them.
Bhul chuk maaf.
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 25 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
1. Gurbani has a clearly defined GRAMMAR...grammar is the VERY BASIC thing you need to understand.
2. You have to start with the most basic meanings according to this Grammar.
3. As you get more and more "into" GURBANI.... avstha...intuition "kicks" in and you get more in tune with the writers of Gurbani..
4. As Guru Ji has already stated: Taste of Gurbani is like ............asking a GOONGA (MUTE) to tell you how the sweets he just ate taste like. The GOONGA thta ate mathiyee WILL NOT be able to TELL YOU A SINGLE WORD about its taste...similalry NO ONE can tell you anything..IF you havent tasted Gurbani YOURSELF. No one can ESCAPE this step/ or take a SHORT CUT through some SANT/BABA/BRAHMGIANI etc....ALL of them are GOONGAS. Any "goonga" who tries to "tell" you how gurbani tastes to him..will be through SAINATAAN/ooohs and aahhs....and THAT is WHY so called "multiple" meanings come about...each GOONGAS saintaan and oohs and aahs will SOUND DIFFERENT to different people.... so there you Have it.
5. START BASIC GRAMMAR/READINGS/slowly start tasting the NECTAR....and ENJOY BLISS.... no short cuts/formulas/meanings/sants will do.
Jarnail singh
Re: GURBANI and Sakhis..- SOME OBSERVATIONS
Bijla Singh · 25 Nov 2004
"ALL of them are GOONGAS. Any "goonga" who tries to "tell" you how gurbani tastes to him..will be through SAINATAAN/ooohs and aahhs....and THAT is WHY so called "multiple" meanings come about...each GOONGAS saintaan and oohs and aahs will SOUND DIFFERENT to different people.... so there you Have it."
Giving or writing meanings of Gurbani is very different than experiencing it and enjoying it. without any "oohs and aahs" Bhai Veer Singh Ji gave different meanings. Read Se Kineheya of Baba Harnaam Singh Ji and read the section about meeting Bhai Veer Singh Ji in hospital. that will clear up everything. Sometimes kathavaachaks give different meanings with same sounds and meanings never contradict. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh