Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Karah Parshaad

Karah Parshaad

Believer · 18 Nov 2004

wjkk wjkf. Dear sangat ji, is it wrong to go away from a gurdwara without havingtaken karah parshaad? or what if you wasn't given it?? wjkk wjkf.

Re: Karah Parshaad

someone · 19 Nov 2004

What if the parshad is made by monas or the langer is made by monas, should you skip it or eat it if you are an amritdhari Sikh? fateh ji

Re: Karah Parshaad

Mkhalsa · 20 Nov 2004

>>>Dear sangat ji, is it wrong to go away from a gurdwara without havingtaken karah parshaad? or what if you wasn't given it??<<<< Was the degh made with proper maryada? if not, then is it really degh? if it isnt degh, but is something masquerading as degh made with maryada, then is it right to take it? interesting questions.

Re: Karah Parshaad

ManjitKaur · 21 Nov 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Arent we jumping the gun here ?? What I mean is... WE can "SEE" the Degh being made by a MONA and so can confidently say..wah this is NOT DEGH just Gaffeh we can buy at any Punjabi Restaurant !! BUT wait a minute ?? WHAT about the GRANTHI doing the PAATH/Taking Hukmnama/Doing ARDASS??? Did he take his Morning Amrit Vela/Ishnaan/Did his Nitnem.... SO IS HE DOING the Paath/ardass/as per MARYADA ?? Is His HUKMNAMA VALID ?? WHAT if the ardassia/paathi/ is "SELLING HORSES IN KANDHAAR" as GURU NANAK JI proved 500 years ago at Namaaz ?? IS HIS ARDASS/Paath/Hukmanam VALID ?? IS the ardassia wearing a clean freshly washed kachhera ?? is Maryada fully followed ?? Whoi did the checking ?? I have seen granthis who ?????wake up and just do panj ishnana before sitting down to Asa Di war..??? then do paath hukmnama ardass ?? What happens if the granthi is wearing yesterday's kachhera ?? We JUMP on Karah parshaad/Langgar because it is visible ?? what about the invisible ?? why do we accept the ardass/hukm/paath etc done by a NOn_maryada person ?? but REFUSE his Karah parshaad ?? IF GURU JI "accepts" the Paath/hukm/ardass/Karah parshaad then we should accept the karah parshaad/paath/hukm/ardass as well..why pick and choose ?? IF the Karah has been ACCEPTED by GURU JI as per Kirpaan Bhet/Panj Piyara offering taken out then who are we to SAY NO to it ?? manjit Kaur

Re: Karah Parshaad

foolish person · 21 Nov 2004

Vah Vah Manjit Kaur - i loved your post! very thought provoking! Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Karah Parshaad

Caprice Sun · 22 Nov 2004

>>> Arent we jumping the gun here ?? What I mean is... WE can "SEE" the Degh being made by a MONA and so can confidently say..wah this is NOT DEGH just Gaffeh we can buy at any Punjabi Restaurant !! >>> This is true. >>> BUT wait a minute ?? WHAT about the GRANTHI doing the PAATH/Taking Hukmnama/Doing ARDASS??? Did he take his Morning Amrit Vela/Ishnaan/Did his Nitnem.... SO IS HE DOING the Paath/ardass/as per MARYADA ?? Is His HUKMNAMA VALID ?? >>> No his hukmanama is not valid. A Singh/bibi who does guru sahib di sewa must be a tyar bar tyar khalsa. If I were to ask my gora friend to be a granthi he would probably do what you illustrated above. He wouldn't care, to him it would just be a job. What you have said above is exactly how he would act. What is the difference between such a person and a keshadari who wears a pajama kurta and a dastaar but lives the same lifestyle. Not much difference. It is the rehit that makes a Singh. >>>WHAT if the ardassia/paathi/ is "SELLING HORSES IN KANDHAAR" as GURU NANAK JI proved 500 years ago at Namaaz ?? IS HIS ARDASS/Paath/Hukmanam VALID ?? >>> What you are referring to is someone's avastha. If the Singh/bibi lives the Khalsa lifestyle but insn't a brahmgiani where they are one with God and do ardaas with 100% concentration then I think their ardaas is manjoor. Otherwise what is the point in any of us doing ardaas? >>> IS the ardassia wearing a clean freshly washed kachhera ?? is Maryada fully followed ?? Whoi did the checking ?? I have seen granthis who ?????wake up and just do panj ishnana before sitting down to Asa Di war..??? then do paath hukmnama ardass ?? What happens if the granthi is wearing yesterday's kachhera ?? >>> If we knowingly do something against gurmat then guru sahib will give us tankah accordingly. If we do it to hurt Sikhi then we get it even worse. We should try out best as the sangat to weed out such people. Gurus sahib will give people exactly what they deserve. Especially those that are two faced, who say/write one thing but their intentions aren't pure. >>> We JUMP on Karah parshaad/Langgar because it is visible ?? what about the invisible ?? why do we accept the ardass/hukm/paath etc done by a NOn_maryada person ?? but REFUSE his Karah parshaad ?? >>> We do what we can. We can't all have the avastha of knowing the other person's jeeven just by looking at them so we do as much as we know. That's all guru sahib asks. >>> IF GURU JI "accepts" the Paath/hukm/ardass/Karah parshaad then we should accept the karah parshaad/paath/hukm/ardass as well..why pick and choose ?? IF the Karah has been ACCEPTED by GURU JI as per Kirpaan Bhet/Panj Piyara offering taken out then who are we to SAY NO to it ?? >>> I'm kind of confused as to what your point is? Are you trying to say that we should accept degh or are you trying to say that we should improve the overall situation in our gurdwaras. I hope it is the latter. The only thing that is parvaan to guru sahib is rehit. If something isn't done with proper rehit it is not parvan. It is that simple. "Rehit pyare mujh ko" If we have one weakness, is it then okay to introduce more weaknesses or does a Sikh try to strengthen his weaknesses? To answer the original question: Some Singhs get up and leave before the degh is served (if it is not prepared with proper maryada) and some other Singhs take the degh but don't eat it and give it to someone else later. They do this as to not create a scene in the Sangat.

Re: Karah Parshaad

someone · 01 Dec 2004

But once ardaas has been done and the Vaak has been taken, that parsad/langer becomes holy. It doesn't matter who made it or didn't make it before, once it has been pravanned in the Ardaas and sangat it is holy, not matter who made it. fateh ji

Re: Karah Parshaad

Singh · 01 Dec 2004

Really person? So meat or "maha parsaad" is also acceptable once a kirpan is put through it as some Nihangs do? There was a sharabi in my pind who on a whim took amrit. He then used to do ardaas and put his kirpaan through liqour. There's a gurdwara that gives liqour parshaad. Is this all "holy?". Baba Nand Singh used to reject degh that was made using dishonest money and had it thrown away. Why wasn't that "holy"? Degh must be made according to rehit. Otherwise it is not acceptable to Guru Sahib.

Re: Karah Parshaad

someone · 02 Dec 2004

There are exceptions to every rule. BUT I would say that once degh, I mean the brown parsad has been pravaaned then it is holy. Also, you can't look at parsad and tell if it was or wasn't made according to rehit. The person who made it only knows. At my local Gurdwara all langer/degh seva is done by monas or Sardars that shave their beards. What to do then? Not go to Guru Ghar? Don't eat there? fateh ji

Re: Karah Parshaad

Manjit Kaur · 02 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Singh Ji, Arent we taking on the responsibility of "judgement" away from GURU JI and putting it on our shoulders... You mention Baba Nand Singh Ji....and his amazing ability to "see" dishonest money.. Do we all have this "dishonesty checking meter" ? We in our local gurdwara would sure like to buy one such meter..to check our daily GOLAK/Matha tek cas/cash donations/ rumallas/chandanii/pardehy/degh/rashan/langgar proviisons and a hundred and one things like carpets/airconditions/bhandey etc given to the gurdwara by the sangat. We too THROW AWAY lots of DEGH daily....but not because a local Baba Ji can "see" something we cannot..BUT because it is EXTRA (left over)..but the interesting thing is no one objects ( because it is such a CHEAP STUFF to throw away... now if you had given examples of Baba ji "throwing away" a Rolls Royce given by a Premi..I would have been impressed..our local Gurdwra com also has NEVER "thrown away" anything really valuable like a airconditioner/fridge/ etc presented to the Gurdwara ( even from obvioulsy criminal elements who want to beg forgiveness !!! About thirty years ago, a group of people took over an institution set up in memeory of Sant Sohan Singh ( our local Baba Ji who is totally respected by the sangats of Malaysia/singapore/indonesia/thailand/australia/newzealand)..and they were the "first totally SHUDH SINGHS in Malaysia... they REJECTED langgar/Degh in the local gurdwaras...raising a lot of controversy...BUT Baba Ji SOHAN SINGH lived in this country for over 75 years and NEVER rejected any DEGH/LANGGAR in nay Gurdwara/sevadars house etc..NOT a Single incident of such is mentioned in his BIOGRAPHY....but a few chelas took over this Rejecting Job in His Name !!! Wah Wah. The surprising thing is they took over the Institution to TRAIN GRANTHIS...but not a Single GRANTHI came out of the Institution.... their Group retains the same old original members...and they soon left and are now privatised kirtani jatha on their own still using the Sant baba Name while his original institution has its own jatha. I have read an account whereby GURU GOBIND SINGH JI while passing through Moghul Forces as UCH da Pir carried by the Muslim Brothers on a Manja sahib....instructed His SINGHS to present the KIRPAN to any food and eat it without any SHANKA. ( there is no doubt - shanka as to what type of food would be available in the Moghul Forces..so IF GURU JI INSTRUCTS SINGHS to PRESENT the KIRPAN and eat such food..who are we to QUESTION the Degh already Kirpan Bhet and Ardass done in the Presence of GURU JI with His HUKMNAMA and ACCEPTANCE. My stand is LET GURU JI JUDGE.... we just cannot judge anybody as we ourselves are just as GUILTY as anyone else...ONLY GURU JI is above all this. Your younger sister MK

Re: Karah Parshaad

another singh · 02 Dec 2004

manjit kaur, or jarnail singh or whoever you are, Guru saahib gave us the ability to be able to judge. We judge right from wrong all the time. If we weren't supposed to make this judgement, then what responsibility would we have for comitting wrong acts? So why can't we judge if proper marydaa is being followed or not? In fact, I would say it is our duty to make this judgement. Something doesn't become holy simply because you pass a kirpan through it and do ardaas. And how do I make this judgement? Probably using the same processes that you, bhainjee manjit kaur, used to make judgements throughout this post and the many other posts you've made. Baba Nand Singh's amazing ability to see dishonest money... usually, simply asking the donors about where the funds came from is enough. Why do you try to complicate things so much bhainjee? It's too bad that most committees don't have the guts to turn away dirty money. You shouldn't try to mock Baba Nand Singh Jee for doing what these many others don't have the strength to do. Could you provide a proper reference for the story of Guru Saahib telling singhs to make food acceptable simply by passing a kirpan through it? This seems quite ritualistic to me. Food could be stolen or whatever, simply pass a kirpan through it and it fixes everything. This is definitely not something that the gurmat of Guru Gobind Singh Jee advocates. Knowing whether degh or langar has been made according to marydaa doesn't exactly require an FBI investigation. You can usually take a quick look around and know. At most, you can ask.

Re: Karah Parshaad

Singh · 02 Dec 2004

There is a maryada for degh. That is for a tyaar-bar-tyaar Singh/Kaur to make it. That person must keep kakaars, do nitnem, give dasvandh and has avoided all kurehits. The materials used for the degh also should be given by someone who gives dasvandh and earns money through honest means. If such a person does not make it, it is not karah parshaad. In fact, degh must be made in sarbloh as well. You can see all these things and check if they are being done. If you don't think that degh is being made according to maryada, then you have the right to not eat it. As for the kirpan-bhet story: if you think that you have the power of Guru Gobind Singh Sahib and like him can turn the food given to the Singhs into karah parshaad, then yes, you too can use this maryada. Don't say "that's not possible, Guru Sahib didnt' do that." Because if you accept that story, accept all of it: the story says that the food turned into karah parshaad. Can't accept some of the story and reject the rest.

Re: Karah Parshaad

Caprice Sun · 02 Dec 2004

Lately I've been reading and seeing a lot of people promoting compromise on gurmat rehit. This is radiculous and must be stopped. Here is why. Singh has outlined the maryada for preparing degh. If the maryada isn't followed then one does not have to take degh. Many Singhs however do take it and gave it away to someone else b/c they don't want to cause a scene. We ask for "Bibek daan" everyday during ardaas do we not? We are asking guru sahib for the ability to know right from wrong. What is the use of such ability if we don't use it? It is our reponsbility to take a stand on gurmat. If we don't then how can we show our face to guru sahib? Everytime we counsciously allow for a slip in rehit we are simply setting ourselves for a greater slip in the future. If we lose rehit then we have readopted "bipran key reet"... the thing that guru sahib explicitly warned us about. In my understanding REHIT IS NOT JUST GURU SAHIBS HUKAM BUT REHIT IS ALSO HOW GURU SAHIB SHOWS LOVE. Think about it. Rehit attaches us to Sangat and Bani and naam. Rehit prevents us from making mistakes. Rehit creates love between gursikhs. So I say rehit is guru sahib's special gift for his beloved Children. Only very special and beloved are blessed with it. Jarnail Singh said, >>> "responsibility of "judgement" away from GURU JI and putting it on our shoulders... >>> This is a sorry excuse for not taking a stand. If we see something wrong happening we should try to change it... if we are not able to do so then we at the least shouldn't go along with it. Guru sahib is the ultimate judge. And it is guru sahibs direct hukam that we not compromise on rehit. Everytime we choose to follow rehit we are establishing a closer link with guru sahib.

Re: Karah Parshaad

S.B.S · 02 Dec 2004

ok Sangat ji , as Now we are talking about DEG (karah parshad)!! CAN SOMEONE plz put a light on this topic that HOW 'DEG' was intoduced' or started into SIKHISM, and WHAT was the reason behind it!? can someone plz answer it, m waiting for the answer!! :) Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: Karah Parshaad

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Dec 2004

all of you seem to have the powers of your babeh...I have NOT written a SINGLE mail on the subject as I DONT prescribe to this sort of debate. Such things dont interest me. IF a member of the sangat indicates" swaiyah" .- i give him a BIG PORTION of degh because swaiyah means one and a quarter 1.25...that always set their eyes rolling upwards - children get double whammys...and whoever doesnt want any degh doenst get any..simple as that. I just cant see the problem. SO folks this is the FIRST and LAST mail from me on this subject. Please have the courtesy to answer the writers and dont just put any names you hate. Why on earth would guuru ji turn every dish into karah parshaad ?? should we follow that and eat karah parshad ONLY. But the worldwide trend is to eat as little of karah parshaad as it causes heart attacks...what a dilemma. Personally I eat as much as THREE SINGHS...and dont have the slightest BP..I even bring the extra home and eat at my pleasure - due to my beleif that GURU JI would never hurt his Singh. jarnail singh

Re: Karah Parshaad

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Dec 2004

caprice sun... is the bright light too bright ?? sometimes the brightness makes us see things.. you quote from an NON-EXISTANT mail : <>> "responsibility of "judgement" away from GURU JI and putting it on our shoulders... >>> I have not written a single mail on this subject because to me its a non-issue. I dont discuss such mundane issues as whether people take or reject karah parshaad/guru ka langgar is their business. We cannot force anyone to eat..and shouldnt...I also DONT JUDGE others on their rehat and dont go about checking up on them - Guru's Rehat-Sikhs' rehat is a commitment betweent he Guru and His Sikh - none of my business. ON COMPROMISE... I think i hold the exact same ideas as you - NO COMPROMISE....that is no shorter banis, no shorter nitnem, no shorter amritvela, no shorter kacchheras, no shorter kirpaan, etc etc - FULL BIBEKI REHAT should be every Sikh's ULTIMATE OBJECTIVE..."drop-outs" are failures in my eyes. ( no apologies to ghonas/half way singhs etc) Thank you. jarnail Singh. ( its MY mail if you see my name at top and bottom where i sign it to take full responsibility for what i write. SO please excuse me from this topic.

Re: Karah Parshaad

someonesingh · 02 Dec 2004

At my local gurdwara everything is done my monas, langer/degh seva. Should I stop going all together? Please answer. fateh ji

Re: Karah Parshaad

Balpreet Singh · 02 Dec 2004

you shouldn't stop going, you should start doing seva there. You can choose not to eat the langar and degh if it is not made according to maryada. Please have a look at the following story. ________ Bhai Jeevan Singh jee's 1978 Canada Tour & Controversy From Soora Feb 1979 Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh jee was one of the first Gursikhs who did parchaar of tat-Gurmat in Canada and helped bring people into a Sikh way of life. In 1978, Bhai Sahib visited Toronto and a controversy erupted when he refused to take parshaad or langar in the Gurdvara. Khalsa Samaachaar newspaper condemned Bhai Sahib for this "violation" of Gurmat. Bhai Sahib was then a Hazooree Ragee at Patna Sahib and the accusation was levelled that Bhai Sahib does not eat Karah Parshaad nor takes Langar. It was also said that Bhai Sahib was doing "different" amrit sinchaars which were not normally done in the Panth i.e. insisting on keskee as kakaar and doing naam driR. Here's what the Soora magazine had to say about the entire issue: ********* Respected Sardaar Jeeo (editor of Khalsa Samaachaar), We are astonished to see that a learned man like you, without knowing the truth, in Khalsa Samachaar's December 28, 1978 issue published the news that Bhai Jeevan Singh's not accepting Parshaad and Langar is against Gurmat. Before publishing this, did you even try to find out why Bhai Jeevan Singh jee, while preaching in Canada does not accept parshaad in those people's langar? According to the Gurmat Rehit Maryada, the langar prepared by a patit or non-amritdhaaree is not acceptable and this food cannot be called "Guru Kaa Langar". In "Nirguneearaa" 1977, Prof. Pooran Singh jee writes in the article "Satguru's Divine Langar": "In the Baba's langar, there is not un-touchability over caste and class, but this langar is hidden from plain view. This is the langar of an Emperor. Not just anybody (Lundee Buchee) can come here…"tithay jodh maahbal soor" Guru's totally prepared Singhs who are tyaar-bar-tyaar, are the Soldiers (workers) here" etc. The meaning of this writing is that in the Pangat (area where langar is eaten) there is no caste or class distinction or discrimination, but in preparing the langar, it is the Guru's specific maryada that not just anyone can prepare the langar. For this task, it is necessary to be "guru vala" or amritdhaaree. That is the Guru's Langar where the food's preparers and servers are Guru's Singhs. "Vaydeenaa(n) kee dostee vaydeenaa(n) kaa khaaN" i.e. according to the Guru's orders eating the food of those without the Faith is restricted in Gurmat. According to the Sikh Rehit Maryada, a Sikh should have food and social relations with other Sikhs only. We've found out that Bhai Jeevan Singh jee in last year's Canada tour did keertan in a Gurdvara. After the keertan, that Gurdvara's Committee President was about to give Bhai Sahib a Siropa. That President was a Patit Sikh with no kesh or beard. Bhai Sahib in the Deevan said "Daas cannot accept a Siropa from the hands of a Patit Sikh, so please forgive Daas for this." The disease of Patit-ism is very big in Canada and many Gurdvara organisers are Patits. In this situation, if Bhai Jeevan Singh jee refused to eat the parshaad of a Patit individual, then this is following the Guru's orders. Is it a crime to remain steadfast in Gurmat Rehit and obey the Guru's orders? If our other preachers and ragis in an attitude of greed go to those countries and eat the food of these sharabee-kababee (meat/liquor consuming) patit individuals, it does not mean that one should start pointless propaganda against such a person who remains firm in Gurmat maryada and refuses to eat this food. We can expect this from the patit individuals but it's beyond our understanding when a Panthic Newspaper does this propoganda. It's regrettable you haven't bothered to know the truth about how Bhai Jeevan Singh has gone there without any greed and is humbly preaching Gursikhi. So we request you try to find out the reality and make the Sangat aware of this reality and Gurmat. Soora Parivar ********** Despite all the controversy and pressure, Bhai Jeevan Singh jee remained firm in his bibek, and took a stand, even where it alienated some people who refused to accept or understand Gurmat. This episode teaches us that no matter what, we must take a stand when it comes to following the rehit of Guru Sahib.

Re: Karah Parshaad

halo 2 singh · 02 Dec 2004

I know for a fact that Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji travels alot and visits alot of people even stays over at people's homes. And all of these people are not Amritdhari, I know that he has stayed at one Bibi's home and she was having a kirtan and she is not Amritdhari. Does he eat at their homes? Does he make the food himself? Bul Chuk Dee Khima, maaf karna jeeo, I just want to know. fateh ji

Re: Karah Parshaad

khalsa4ever · 02 Dec 2004

My 0.02 on this would be ~ langar / degh should be prepared by Amritdhaare Singhs and Singhnees. However - it would be interesting to note that once the 'bhog' is done with Siree Sahib after doing appropiate Ardaas ~ the food becomes 'Parshaad' I am still confused... hopefully Guru Saab will bless us with more Naam Simrann - so that we can stick to His Rehat more firmly. Vaaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh !! dass

Re: Karah Parshaad

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Khalsa4ever ji, your 0.02 cents is worth a million. We shouldnt bring in our own personal prejudices into the picture. NO ONE is PERFECT except the GURU. I have a young gursikh on my tail for the past few months..He is an Amrtidharee, but has comitted some bajjar kurehits that require PESHI before the Punj. BUT what he keeps bugging me with is: Gyani Ji, I "personally KNOW all the PUNJ...they are all family friends... so HOW to tell them everything ?? how to PESH in front of your "friends ??"... This is a PERENNIAL DILEMMA we all face.... NO PUNJ anywhere in the world is absolutley FREE of any "blame" whatsoever ( at least in EVERY SINGLE PERSOn'S MIND !!)..some one some where "knows" this PUNJ personally !!! and knows his "secrets" "misdeeds" whatever imaginary or real..SO HOW do we FACE this PUNJ ??? Will HE divulge our secrets at PESH ?? How can we be absolutley sure none of the PUNJ will divulge /tell the world about us ?? WHERE do I send this young man to PESH ?? and HOW do I ASSURE him his secret will be SAFE ?? CAN I ASSURE HIM ?? REALLY ?? I am in Malaysia...he is in the UK/Canada/USA/EUROPE..Thousands of miles away..HOW can I ASSURE him the PUNJ will keep his secrets safe ?? what will I say to him IF the secrets come out ?? These are real people, real dilemmas, and need real solutions. I am STUMPED. Similarly in degh preparation.. we can ONLY " see" the OBVIOUS....ONLY GURU JI can see ALL...and I respectfully SUMBIT, GURU JI has NOT given US INDIVIDUALS the POWER to JUDGE others....that power is collectively of the GURU KHALSA PANTH...and ONLY the Guru Khalsa panth. When we decide not to take degh...that is a PERSONAL decision based on PERSONAL judgement - USURPING the RIGHT of the GURU. Jarnail Singh

Re: Karah Parshaad

Singh · 04 Dec 2004

I think we do have the power to judge. If we see in the langar hall that the guy making degh is doing so in a big aluminum pot while talking to his buddy about Akali politics, we have a right to refuse to eat it. I mean, lets say we go to a gurdwara and in the gurdwara they ring bells and do arti with divas and apply tilaks: do we not have a right to judge? In the same way, if the degh maryada is not being followed, we totally have a right not to eat it. Let me give you an example of a Singh who I know. He said that when he first stopped taking degh at Harmander Sahib Amritsar, he felt pretty bad about it. He decided that he would begin to take the degh again that day. So as he was going into Darbar Sahib, he saw a white couple. They saw a lot of people buying degh at the counters and taking it in, and perhaps they thought it was the necessary protocol. They too bought a thaal of degh to take in. Now as they were walkign with it, they began to taste the degh with their hands. The Singh saw this and realised that although it might feel bad to refuse degh at Darbar Sahib, it is right according to maryada. Who knows with how much cleanliness people handle the degh they bring in? Who knows how many ignorant people decide to taste it themselves? So if maryada is not being followed, you can choose not to take degh.

Re: Karah Parshaad

Jasvir kaur · 04 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Singh Ji, I think i know where you are coming from. you have stated the obvious...but when we see a big aluminium pot and the sewadaar yakking away chuglee ninda instead of Japji Sahib.... then our first duty is to bring this up in the sangat.. if it doesnt help ??? I will tell you all a personal experience with this. My late Dad Gyani Waryam Singh used to be a granthi at a famous Gurdwara. Somehow he made an enemy of someone influential in the sangat. That man tried every which way to discredit my dad but each attempt failed. Then in one incident, during a major GURPURAB, what he did was THROW a LARGE 1 KILO bag of SALT into the Prepared Degh. He was seen doing this by a child who told my dad that a man had put in a powder into the degh and he ahd the empty bag..dad tasted it and found it was salt. At first he thought of telling the President and preparing another karahi of degh, then he decided to do an ardass and leave it all to Guru Ji. When the Parshad was distributed in the sangat everything was as per normal..i and a few other children followed the man...and he kept telling people: Doesnt the degh taste funny today...like it is salty...but not a single person acknowledged that the degh was salty....and when we tasted our share it was just as sweet as normal. The next day this man was in the gurdwara early. He didnt approach my dad but told the second granthi to offer an ardass for him as he was sick..everything tasted so salty and his blood pressure was shooting very high and the doctor ahd told him to reduce his salt intake...and his BP was shooting sky high with every passing hour...even though he was not taking any salt at all. I presented the salt bag to him as he was waiting for the ardass to take place... the moment he set eyes on it he broke down and confessed everything to the second granthi. After the ardass he felt the pain go away instantly and he promised never to mess with Guru Ji's degh ever again. The lesson for me in this episode is that GURU JI takes care of His Own. We need not be very concerned..we can only see the OBVIOUS... GURU JI sees ALL. as for the rest I respect your decision to not take degh..makhee dekh ke niiglee nahin jandee...eh ?? Jasvir Kaur

Re: Karah Parshaad

everpresentdevils · 05 Dec 2004

everpresent devil no.3 says: degh...yum..yummy!!!! karah prasad...yum...yum...YUMMY!!!!!! yum!!yum!!yum!!yummmmmmYYY!! Can i have a real big second helping...Sir Sardarji? everpresent no.2 says: i go to my gurdwara with my mommy & most enjoyable part...deep within me is ...when i receive Guruji's degh in my the cup of my tiny little hands from the giant hands of my giani ji... i say Satnam...&.. feel so good inside of me & then i eat degh...sometimes i also steal some of my mommy's or daddy's degh..no..no..i don't steal...they give me half their portion..yummy...yummy..i m so happy..our guruji..created degh......yummy...yummy...its more enjoyable than even the jelebis..mithai..ladoo...they serve me.... everpresent devil no.1 says: i go to gurdwara to matha tekh and say hello to my guruji and then he rewards me with degh. i don't really care if the gurdwara is run by sants/mahants/pure Sikhs/Mona Tona sikhs or Mona Liza Sikhs/Japanese Sikhs/Eskimo Sikhs.... if some superspecial people don't want degh..the don't have take degh...cuz then we kids will have our own portion, half of our mommy's portion and also the full portion that wuz supposed be the superspecial person's portion!!!!wow!!thats gonna be a real big (1+0.5+1.0=2.5)portion!!....Yummy!! vjkkvjkffromtheeverpresentDevilsDreamingofDeghinDisneyland!!! p.s. if only Mickey Mouse was a Sikh, then there would be a gurdwara in Disneyland and they would serve ''Degh in Disneyland'' and that's a real whammy we wouldn't wanna miss!!

Re: Karah Parshaad

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Dec 2004

everpresent devils.... devils after my heart..gave me a big laugh. Sikhi is safe as long as we have everpresent devils..waheguru. THIS is EXACTLY what I see in the small eyes as they look up at me distributing degh in gurdwara...and some small hands keep tugging at my cholaevery now and then..and i see the same child umpteen times..more degh more degh... Keep it up everpresent devils. jarnail singh

Re: Karah Parshaad

Caprice Sun · 06 Dec 2004

>>>>everpresent devil no.3 says: degh...yum..yummy!!!! karah prasad...yum...yum...YUMMY!!!!!! yum!!yum!!yum!!yummmmmmYYY!! Can i have a real big second helping...Sir Sardarji? everpresent no.2 says: i go to my gurdwara with my mommy & most enjoyable part...deep within me is ...when i receive Guruji's degh in my the cup of my tiny little hands from the giant hands of my giani ji... i say Satnam...&.. feel so good inside of me & then i eat degh...sometimes i also steal some of my mommy's or daddy's degh..no..no..i don't steal...they give me half their portion..yummy...yummy..i m so happy..our guruji..created degh......yummy...yummy...its more enjoyable than even the jelebis..mithai..ladoo...they serve me.... everpresent devil no.1 says: i go to gurdwara to matha tekh and say hello to my guruji and then he rewards me with degh. i don't really care if the gurdwara is run by sants/mahants/pure Sikhs/Mona Tona sikhs or Mona Liza Sikhs/Japanese Sikhs/Eskimo Sikhs.... if some superspecial people don't want degh..the don't have take degh...cuz then we kids will have our own portion, half of our mommy's portion and also the full portion that wuz supposed be the superspecial person's portion!!!!wow!!thats gonna be a real big (1+0.5+1.0=2.5)portion!!....Yummy!! vjkkvjkffromtheeverpresentDevilsDreamingofDeghinDisneyland!!! p.s. if only Mickey Mouse was a Sikh, then there would be a gurdwara in Disneyland and they would serve ''Degh in Disneyland'' and that's a real whammy we wouldn't wanna miss!! >>>> This is by far one of the worst posts to be put up on this forum. If you like Disneyland so much try visiting that site instead, and stop wasting everyone's time here. Please copy and paste this to your browser: http://www.disneyland.com If you have nothing to add that is in line with gurmat or what you believe to be gurmat then please don't post aything at all. What was the point of your post? Did you know that Purataan Singhs considered any food that wasn't made with proper maryada poison. I wonder how wide the kids eyes will go when he realizes he just had his mommy and daddys share of poison too!!! Sikhi rehit is nothing to joke about. If you want to go to a mahant's dera and eat "parshad" then by means eat to your fill. Just don't expose us to your lack of bibek budhi. A Sikh who doesn't take a Stand against anti-gurmat practices is Guru SAhib's tankhaiya.

Re: Karah Parshaad

idiot · 08 Dec 2004

The bottom line is when it comes to following rehat no one is perfect. We can tell others do this don't do that, don't eat this degh that degh because it was not made in a certain container. So on and so on. This is all a waste of time. Because when the time comes for us to leave this world, we will be asked how much bakti, naam simran, paat we did. Rehat is a must, I am not saying that it isn't. But at what level someone follows it is up to Guru Sahib, not the individual. Whatever level is accepted by Guru Sahib for that individual is the level at which that person will follow it, no more, no less. Some people follow higher levels of Rehat, some follow lower levels. That is not in your control. Neither is it where if you accidently do something wrong in your rehat, and I use the word accidently, then that is his doing aswell, not the individual's. I can say that I have tried to follow the fullest full blown rehat I could follow, knowing inside that I was not ready for it yet, but I had accidents, in my rehat, and that kept me at a lower level, I have yet to reach a high level of rehat. This is his hukam and I am happy at this level. You learn from your mistakes and move on. We should NEVER force others to follow our level of Rehat, because who are we? This is the Guru's job. If a mistake does occur in someone's rehat, then you do Ardaas in front you Guru Sahib and ask for forgiveness and move on. Don't stay in the past. Bula Chuka Di Maafi Jeeo........................... Gurfateh

Re: Karah Parshaad

:- · 09 Dec 2004

Caprice sun, i think everpresentdevil is trying to get a point across. Being a sikh doesnt mean you always have to have an upright and uptight personality. You can have a sense of humor also. Even Baba jarnail Singh had a sense of humour, Bhai jeevan singh has a sense of humor and many others. so please just chill, it was hidden message within the message. It seems you are an intellegent person, im sure you could have seen the hidden message. anyway im SORRY if MY post also insulted you, please forgive me Gurfateh

Re: Karah Parshaad

Caprice Sun · 09 Dec 2004

>>>>> to gurdwara to matha tekh and say hello to my guruji and then he rewards me with degh. i don't really care if the gurdwara is run by sants/mahants/pure Sikhs/Mona Tona sikhs or Mona Liza Sikhs/Japanese Sikhs/Eskimo Sikhs.... if some superspecial people don't want degh..the don't have take degh...cuz then we kids will have our own portion, half of our mommy's portion and also the full portion that wuz supposed be the superspecial person's portion!!!!wow!!thats gonna be a real big (1+0.5+1.0=2.5)portion!!....Yummy!! >>>>> Calling Singhs superficial is not funny to me. Especially when they follow maryada and stand up for Sikhi rehit. Also mentioning that it doesn't matter who a gurdwara is "run" by wether it be sants/monas etc. is also not funny or cute in any way. Perhaps you can share the joke that I apparently missed .... besides sounding childish (perhaps while trying to be "cute") his post had no substance.