Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

umm · 16 Nov 2004

I have two questions which Im very confused about, hoping someone will answer? 1. Who gave the Sikh women the name 'Kaur'? Where is the proof? 2. Who gave Amrit to Sikh women for the first time? I have heard some Namdharis claim it was them, and some people claim it was the Nihungs at Hazoor Sahib (Kard da Amrit). How do we know who gave it to them first? Seems to be no sources in which women are mentioned in all this. Thanks

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Balpreet Singh · 16 Nov 2004

Prem Sumarag is one of the oldest rehitnamas out there. The most common edition is the one found in the Piara Singh Padam "Rehitnamas" but I've also got a copy of the complete version as edited by Randhir Singh the research scholar, first published in 1953, titled "Prem Sumarag Granth". According to Randhir Singh, the oldest copy available of this work is from 1701. Prof. Pashaura Singh has a copy of an older copy, dated 1815CE. So even if we don't accept the 1701 date, 1815 is still MUCH before any Singh Sabha movement. Prem Sumarag states the following about giving women amrit: "Fayr, Sikh kareeai, jougat naal paahul khandai kee deejeeai. Ar Ardaas kareeai: "Jee! Eh jee man bach karam kar Khalsay kaa jama pehar kay SikhNee hoee hai. Khushee karho! Jo Sree Akaal Purakh apnay marag kaa rang bakhshay. Anand saath rahai" Meaning, "Then, make her a Sikh, by giving her Khanday Kee Paahul with the proper method. Then do ardaas" "Lord! This one has by word and action taken on the form of a Khalsa and become your Sikhnee (female Sikh). Be pleased! May Akaal Purakh give her the divine colours of his path. May she live in bliss." In the work by Sarup Singh Kaushish, I recall Sikh women being called Kaur as well. "Kaur" has been a common name amongst Sikhs ie. Guru Har Rai Sahib's daughter Bibi Roop Kaur. After the Khalsa, all Sikh women were given this name. By the Misals and Raja Ranjit Singh’s time, there are many more records and you’ll note that all Sikh women do have the name “Kaur” so the belief that this was invented by Singh Sabha also holds no water. Chand Kaur, Jind Kaur, Sada Kaur, etc.

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

................ · 16 Nov 2004

I guess that finishes silly nihang arguments that women are inferior and only worthy of kirpan de amrit.

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Mandeep Singh Khalsa · 18 Nov 2004

now, this will be a post with no evidence to back it up except what numerous books i have read and what teaching i have been taught by various people. Everyone says one thing about the Kaur issue: Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave the 'Kaur' title to ALL women who took amrit. Yes there may have been women before with that title but it wasnt a generic-for-all name. The second question: whats the point even having this answer! For arguments sake and for the purists, Guru Gobind Singh Ji and the orginal 5 panj pyare gave women amrit. bhul chuk maaf karni, daas, Mandeep Singh

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Mohan Singh · 18 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have also read some of Prem Surag Granth and it does mention Khanda Da Pahul for women. The Rehat it talks about is definately what many would consider the "Sanatan" interpritation but it was not written as early as the early 1700s. Sarup Singh Kaushish's work (Guru Kian Sakhian) does mention Kaur for women and internal evidence does set it out a strong case that it was composed during the mid 18th century. McLeod says this is because of the debate that went on in the 18th century as to when the Amrit Sanchar in 1699 took place (some disagreed it was a year different) and Guru Kian Sakhian takes the other date, suggesting it to be a very old text) However it is not usually quoted outside circles which believe Keski is a Kakkar because it states Keski is a Kakkar in more than one place. Other than that there is no mention of Kaur explicitly mentioned as a name given to women in other places. Alot of Sikh history has been destroyed by the Muslim invaders, British and Hindus. So there are many gaps and vague areas. So Paji/Penji there should be no doubt that Kaur was the name given to women and Amrit was given to women by 10th Guru Ji. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Bijla Singh · 19 Nov 2004

Guru Ji gave women equal rights so no doubt about Guru Ji giving Amrit to women. any proofs He did not and gave Amrit to men only? When He held sword in His hand, He asked for a head not a man's head which clearly shows that men and women both were being tested and doesn't matter who stood up, Amrit was given to all. If Amrit was not for women then Guru Ji wouldn't have allowed Mata Ji to put patasay in the batta and Mayee Bhago Ji wouldn't be called Mata Bhaag Kaur which shows She took Amrit. Mata Jeeto Ji became Mata Ajit Kaur Ji, Mata Sahib Devan Ji became Mata Sahib Kaur Ji and Mata Sundari Ji became Mata Sundar Kaur Ji. (whether one wife or three wives please don't start this debate). men and women both are Khalsa, both are given same rehat, bani, and bana and both have same father Guru Gobind Singh Ji showing the equality. Same Guru Ji in third saroop gave manjis to women and duties of parchaar, and Guru Ji going to hindu holy places to prove how women are equal and root of the continuation of the existence, now why would the same Guru not give Amrit and contradict Himself in tenth saroop? He would never. Whenever Guru Ji talks about Khalsa in Gurbani, He never specifies "men" or "women", just Khalsa. Read the definition of Khalsa first and then see if not giving Amrit to women makes any sense. These doubts are being put into people's minds by our enemies. now you got to figure out who our enemy is? someone else outside of Sikhi or we are our own enemies who are harming Sikhi by not teaching ourselves about Gurbani and Guru Ki Rehat. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

A Singh · 19 Nov 2004

Why are we so paranoid again??? This question is NOT disputing the present day rights of a woman to have Khanda da Amrit or use the title/surnam kaur. It is simply asking about history. In addition to the above mentioned references, it is clear that there appears to be variations evident amongst the 6 main puratan rehits on this front. Either the rehitnama will specify a separate section for woman or be referening men only in its terminology -one even indicates naming a "Sikhni" Devi upon initiation. These are all parts of our "tradition", however nowadays it is evident that 99% of Amritdhari woman receive Khanda da Pahul. The discussion on 'Kard da Amrit' seems to always fall foul of "this isn't fair, because it isn't the same, it's sexist blah blah blah"...well, reading what is available on 'Kard da Amrit' it is clear that this isn't ONLY for women! Whilst I am not supporting or disowning notions of Kard Amrit and Charan Amrit, from what little I have managed to gather from available readings, it is clear that during the pre-Singh Sabha period, or what is nowadays being termed the 'sanatanist' period, that Sikhi was preached in a 'staged' format. By this I mean, with various establishments and schools (taksals) around Punjab and elsewhere, Gurmat would have been have been imparted, however rather than the present day factory type mentality employed by the SGPC (i.e. give Amrit out to all and sundry regardless of their level of prepardness), the Ustads and Gurdevs at these taksals would have essentially guided individuals through a staged format. It seems to me at times that whilst Khanda da Amrit was clearly the Khalsa Initiation proper, Kard Amrit and Charan Amrit were used to initiate effectively Sehajdharis and Keshdharis into the wider Sikh community. I am only speculating and in no way supporting this practice, however if indeed this was the case, one can try and reconcile the approach as a means of drawing say one generation into Sikhi using Charan and Kard Amrit (i.e. have them keep Kesh and learn Gurbani) with the few that subsequent generations would naturally gravitate towards Khanda Amrit and Khalsa initiation. Only a theory, I can already spot many holes in it myself, however given the mentality of the time, I wouldn't be surprised if this is, if only to a limited extent, something along the lines of thoughts of those who propagated such rites. Problems with it are clear, just as they are with the present method of dishing it out to all and sundry. As has been mentioned elsewhere on this forum, people fail to remember that the 5 Pyare actually gave their heads to Guru Sahib and didn't simply go in for a swig of Amrit!

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Balpreet Singh · 19 Nov 2004

Could you please let me know which rehitnama says to name Sikh women "devi"? Kirpan Amrit was used, not to initiate adults, but for newborn sons and their mothers. This is what is found in the only text that mentions any details of this practice. Otherwise it is not found anywhere. Do you have any sources which say kard amrit was given to any others?

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

foolish person · 20 Nov 2004

what is 'kard amrit' ? Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Manas Singh · 21 Nov 2004

WJKK WJKF A Singh Which rehatnama states that Sikh women should be named 'devi' ??

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

Mohan Singh · 21 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Prem Surag Granth mentions the surname "Devi" for women after Amrit I believe. (p25) I personally see it as having alot of Hindu influence in it. But it still mentions Khanda Da Pahul for women. So there is no doubt there. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Please answer/Kaur/Amrit

um · 22 Nov 2004

yeah theres a lot of hindu influence in some of our texts..