Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Tension in village over place of worship Tribune News Service [img]http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20041114/ldh2.jpg[/img] Ludhiana, November 13 Tension has engulfed Bhaura village since last evening after members of two communities threw stones at each over the issue of ownership of a religious place. Heavy police force from the Salem Tabri police station has remained posted in the village since the incident to prevent any fresh outbreak of clash. Five persons had suffered injuries in the stone-throwing incidents. A team of police was also allegedly attacked by members of a particular community. The police had rounded up some persons who were later released. The controversy surrounds the ownership of a religious place where villagers have been performing the path of Guru Granth Sahib since Independence. However, the Muslim community living in the village and elsewhere has been claiming that the religious place used to be a mosque. It has been demanding that its possession be handed over to them. Both parties have been fighting the case in a local court. However, last evening a strong group of 100 persons allegedly stormed the place after breaking open the locks. They also allegedly injured Avtar Singh, a granthi. The group attempted to offer Namaaz there when villagers gathered at the place. After a bitter exchange of words, the groups started throwing stones at each other. The Salem Tabri police separated the groups. The Muslims were claiming that they had been empowered by a court order to offer Namaaz at the place. However, they were not able to show the documents to the police. Salem Tabri SHO Arvind Puri said the district administration would decide on Wednesday the course of action regarding the old dispute over the religious place. He said the two groups were already locked in a legal battle. He said the district administration was the right authority to verify the veracity of the court orders, as claimed by one group. The police has called the leaders of both parties to support their claims through documents by Wednesday. The leaders have been asked to sit and talk about the solution of the controversy. He said, in any case, the district administration would take a final decision and the police would go by it. Meanwhile, an organisation, the Vishwa Guru Ravi Dass Mission, speaking on behalf of the villagers,. has condemned the alleged attempt by a group of persons to possess the religious place. Mr Shiv Ram Saroay, president of the mission, said the mission was fighting the case and had been warning the administration about such an incident.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

It's very possible this is a former mosque. Many unused mosques were turned into Gurdwaras and called "mastgarh". But if you want to play this game of turning gurdwaras back into mosques and mosques back into gurdwaras, it is a big job. Many historic gurdwaras in Pakistan today are mosques. This is not a historic mosque and if this place has been used as a gurdwara for almost 60 years and all of a sudden a few Muslims want to use it again, I don't think it's fair. Make a new one.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

................. · 15 Nov 2004

muslims have half the world to themselves, and they are still not satisfied. They want to make UK a muslim nation by 2015. Are they going to give Gurdwaras in Pakistan back to sikhs? They just think they are above anything. All these places in India were snatched by them from Hindus and Buddhists in the first place. In 1947, there were 50 million muslims in India. Now in one generation there are 200 million. No wonder hindus are against the. They just re-produce and take over. They only believe in human rights when their ones are threatened. But they give no human rights to anyone else. They just think they are beyond the rest of the human race. They have to learn to live and let live.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

S Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Why should the muslims make a new mosque ? If there is proof that it was a mosque prior to independence then the Sikhs should vacate the building. As for many historic Gurdwara in Pakistan being mosques. We are not lemmings who follow the approach (stupidity) of others.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

no · 15 Nov 2004

By that logic, then Sikhs should also vacate all the land they inherited from Muslims. Where would that leave the Sikhs? Homeless. 1947 saw shifts in land and irreversible changes in ownership. The new Muslims from UP and Bihar cannot move in and demand Muslim property be returned to them.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

singh_is_king · 16 Nov 2004

does anybody know about Panja Sahib? has anything bad happened to it in thepast few years?

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

S Singh · 16 Nov 2004

Nothing has happened to Panja Sahib I was there is April and it is still a Gurdwara.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

S Singh · 16 Nov 2004

>>By that logic, then Sikhs should also vacate all the land they inherited from Muslims. Where would that leave the Sikhs? Homeless. 1947 saw shifts in land and irreversible changes in ownership. The new Muslims from UP and Bihar cannot move in and demand Muslim property be returned to them. Big difference between a place of worship and individual personal property. No one is demanding return of personal property but the Sikhs of the village concerned should have the decency to restore the mosque back to the muslims if there is proof that prior to independence it was a mosque and not a gurdwara.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

. · 16 Nov 2004

i heard ludhiana now has a very big muslim population due to the influx of migrants. If sikhism continues to dwindle in punjab its just a matter of time everyone else throws their weight around. I now wonder what "dark cloud" bhai rama singh used to talk about that loomed over punjab.

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

Manas Singh · 16 Nov 2004

WJKK WJKF Most of the Muslims in Panjab today are Bhaiyas from UP. They have been using land that is still held by the wakf board in order to set up homesteads there. In our own village in 1947 the Sikhs destroyed the mosque and there is no trace of it left but many villages did not and many were converted into Gurdwaras. The same happened to the thousands of non-historical Gurdwaras in pakistan which were converted to mosques. Only about 150 odd historical Gurdwaras remain as Gurdwaras in Pakistan. The historic mosques in Panjab are still there such as the ones in Kapurthala and the mosques in Malerkotla. These Bhaiyas are guests in Panjab and have no right to the mosques that have been converted to Gurdwaras. Next they will be asking for the lands that Muslim vacated in Panjab in 1947. Islam through immigration is a threat everywhere. You only have to look at at happened in the Netherlands a few weeks ago. The Muslims want to impose their religion and culture everywhere. We Sikhs should be backing the Dal Khalsa campaign for stopping migration of Bhaiyas into Panjab. GurFateh

Re: Muslims Attack and Stone Punjab Gurdwara!

:)))) · 16 Nov 2004

i totally agree. I do not support bush and cronies, but I think muslims are a growing world problem. They have no respect for human kind who are not muslims. Migration and popualtion growth through reproduction has long been a tool used by them to take over vast lands. This why they are allowed 3 wives, so one man can make as many children as possible.