Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 14 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. In ALL the Dictionaries of Punjabi including the MAHAN KOSH, and the one published by the Text Book division of Chandigarh 1982 edition that gives 43 meanings of PANGAT...NOT a SINGLE ONE means "SITTING ON THE FLOOR".. PANGAT actually means LINE/COLUMN/ROW. How did the word PANGAT ... as in SANGAT-PANGAT...get the meaning of" to sit on the floor". Can any veer shed light on this. Quotations from GURBANI and Bhai gurdass Ji would be most welcome. Dass jarnail singh

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

ManjitKaur · 21 Nov 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. as far i know there is nothing in Gurbani about sitting on the floor. Pangat is just plain old line/row...and can be anywhere. SO where did the "Pangat" get fixed to Langgar on the floor. I have absolutely no idea. maybe some other informed gursikhs can shed light on this. A hukmnama was issued on this topic. Note: on a personal note I dont need a special reason to have langgar on the floor..as long as the Akal takhat says it is, thats the way it is for me. manjit kaur

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Bhainji.. · 21 Nov 2004

I was wondering if you're eliciting responses from only a "veer" or will a "bhain" with the knowledge suffice? ;)

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 22 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhain Ji, I may be "interfering" here but imho, the word GURSIKHS used refers to Both Bhen Jis and Veer Jis...that is my opinion anyway and manjit kaur may differ but i don think so jarnail singh

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Caprice Sun · 22 Nov 2004

What is the point of your post Jarnail Singh? If you are interested in etymology then you would be better off going through some books. However, if you intention is to eventually say that "it is not necessary to sit on the floor, but only practical and easy" then you should come right out and say it. Khalsa traditions such as sitting on the floor have been around as long as Sikhs have been around. I hope your intention isn't to question this. I am not sure if the reason for sitting on the floor is for humility or what not but I do know that this was the way guru sahib had it and I am sure he had his own reasons for it. If guru sahib himself did the shoe sewa for sangat from Kabul and then massaged their legs all night then please consider that if he wanted to couldn't he arrange for the best of chairs for his beloved Sikhs. But he chose not to. He gave us the maryada of sitting on the floor for Langar. He had his reasons... please leave yours out of it. ( I wrote this post based on the assumption that you would eventually lead to the point that "Sikhs don't have to sit on the floor for Langar". If that was not ur intention then I apologize. I don't want the discussion to go there as such a discussion on the most basic of Sikh tents would only serve to ruin the atmosphere of the message board. No one will gain anything from it. I ask the admin to please close the topic if someone brings up the table chair thing.

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

inquisitive · 22 Nov 2004

caprice please dont think im against sitting on the floor, i am 100% behind it but i like to see things from two sides too. Like what about all those grannis and grandads in their 80s and 90s with zimmer frames arthritus paining through their bodies and joints? is it a compromise or just a natural process to help them with chairs? or perhaps my question should be in the praatan times are there any sources to indicate that elders and disabled people would have had seating arrangements so they too could be part of the sangat? if admin chooses he may close the topic but this one is only dear to my heart because i love old people, disabled, i admire their innocence, and selfless love for sikhi at the stages of life where most of us would moan, but walking that mile on a zimmer frame would be like 10 miles for us. I would also like to say that back in the olden times i havent come across any info on the disabled having special seating arrangements in sangat but today some sikhs want the arrangements for the disables so they too can be part of sangat, but in one american gurdwara where my massar is fighting for this, the orthodox side are saying no because it isnt in maryada. So i would like to seek positive advice from the likes of good sikhs, and i also believe that such arrangements if any should not be taken as an excuse for anyone else who is healthy and able enough to sit on the floor.

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

sikhsinghkhalsa · 22 Nov 2004

haven't any of u ever heard of Shri Guru Amardass's rule which does not exist anymore? "Pahla Pangat, fir Sangat" maenig that no matter what ever ur caste is , u have to sit with other people and eat langar. all of the rajas, ranis, with high caste had to sit with people with low caste and really poor. then they they could go see the Guru. this helped sove problems about high and low castes.

Guru Granth sahib Ji goes speeding

Himalaya Di GOD ton · 23 Nov 2004

There was a time when the Guru Granth sahib ji was carried about with much do-dholki,shenne and with great shaukat and shaan, in simple words. Has anyone wondered why these days such does NOT happen?If we observe we will see the Guru Granth Sahib ji being transported in great speed along the roads in modern day cars! It is sat upon the lap of the Guni giani carrying it in the front seat! No body seems to be worried about this.Is this NOT a beadbhi? What do the learned gurmukhs upon this net think of such act ? Himalaya Di GOD ton

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Moninder Singh · 23 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh This whole issue you all are discussing has its roots deep in the British Columbian problem of Gurudwara politics. Since the early 1980s and especially during the height of the Khalistan movement, two very bitterly divided sides have been fighting over the Gurudwara's in the Vancouver/Surrey region of BC. The ISYF (International Sikh Youth Federation) lost the elections in the Surrey BC Guru Nanak Sikh Temple to the rival group (who at the time was not against any maryada and over all was not that bad; even Balwant Gill used to be on stage promoting a separate homeland for Sikhs in India). It is obvious that the current group running the Gurudwara is not following anytype of Panthic Maryada. The ISYF used "pangat" through Balwinder Singh Rangeela to create this problem. The Sikh sangat in the Vancouver region never was split the way it is today. In the "famous" Gurudwara class in the late 1990s which saw Police enter the Gurudwara with their shoes on, it was essentially the ISYF members who started the fight. They created this issue to rally support among the sangat so they could gain control of the Gurudwara again. They were running the Gurudwara for well over a decade before they lost in the elections, why didn't they ever remove tables and chairs during their "reign?" Possibly a question only they can answer. In 1986, Bhai Jasbir Singh Rode issued a "benti" from the Akal Takht that tables and chairs be removed from the Surrey Gurudwara, this benti was ignored by the ISYF (the original copy is still available and is directed to a notable member of the ISYF). This benti was ignored from then interim Jathedar Jasbir Singh Rode but then after the Gurudwara was lost to their rivals, the ISYF plead with Jathedar Bhai Sahib Ranjit Singh to order the removal of the tables and chairs. The whole situation was mishandled because of lies and false information being fed back to the Akal Takht. If you want to know what Jathedar Ranjit Singh thinks of the ISYF and those who were controlling Dasmesh Darbar at the time, simply watch the video in which he is interviewed on this topic (it came out two years ago). I don't know why the question was asked or what someones motive was behind asking it. What I do see is too much hatred and animosity between individuals on most Sikh websites. I have posted before and usually I try to stay out of most discussions because one way or another, some Gursikh who is probably much more capable than I may get their feelings hurt. I am not bashing the ISYF in no way, I have a deep respect for all Panthic organizations, not just the ones that I happen to belong to. I do have one question if some Singhs or Singhanees care to enlighten me. Was Guru Gobind Singh Ji a Sarbloh Bibeki and did he only eat out of the hands of an amritdhari? If the answer is yes, why would Gangu Brahmin be his rasoyi (cook)? Once again, just a question I have, I am not for or against Sarbloh, simply trying to understand the concept. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 23 Nov 2004

Waheguur Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Dear SIKHSINGHKHALSA ji, No one is questioning Guru Amardass ji's Pehleh SANGAT..peechheh PANGAT"..rule. This was Followed even by Emperor AKBAR. The ORIGINAL query is...PANGAT as a Word DOES NOT MEAN "sitting on the floor"...PANGAT actually means... ROW/COLUMN/... as in.... Children.. Line up in a Single Row/File/Que Up. ALL ROWS/COLUMNS/FILES/QUES for buying tickets, boarding buses, planes etc.....are JUST one person BEHIND the next.....and so on. Rows and columns can be HORIZONTAL/VERTICAL.... as in a GRAPH/Worksheets like Excel... IN all the 45 MEANINGS of PANGAT in PUNJABI DICTIONARIES..not one single time is it written that pangat means: SIT on the FLOOR. That is the question....HOW and when did "pangat" change from row/columns to ..."sit on the floor" ??? 2. I read somewhere that since "SANGAT" is held in the darbar Sahib and all sit on the FLOOR at GURU jis Lotus Feet.... so same should be done in LANGGAR HALL ( but in kanggar hall GURU JI is NOT PARKASH) BUT I would like to see "PANGAT" in the SANGAT !!. What is this ?? In the darbar sahib the sangat all usually sit anyhow they like...so distribution of degh is difficult....BUT if we follow the PANGAT...Neat Lines/Rows as the MUSLIMS do in the Masjids.... then it will be neater, more people can be fitted in, easier to distribute degh, pamphlets etc without stepping on godeh/feet of sangat members !!! Thst is my suggestion of Pangat-in-Sangat. As for the tables-Chairs controversy.... I am leaving that alone...it has NO RELEVANCE to my original query...which is linguistic. Dass jarnail Singh.

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

Himalay di GOD ton · 23 Nov 2004

Some good insight into the problem.However Bhai sahib,Moninder Singh ji the issue of the tables and chairs did not have roots in Vancouver,though this time round it appears to have triggered off from Vancouver Gurduaras. You say ,"even Balwant Singh jI advocated for Khalistan from the stages",well that means nothing in the issue of the tables and chairs in langger.That does not qualify him to be an authority on the issues of langger. The issue of the tables and chairs was already simmering from the 1920s,from time to time it surged its head,but not much happened.BUT this time round ,from vancouver it reared its head and caused such an uproar,that the whole community was split into TWO.The rest is HISTORY. Yes, you are right,Sikhs these days are full of JOSH and no HOSH ,and ever ready for name calling and arguments,instead of a civilised discussion. I am new to this group and can already see some JAJBATTI singhs moving the fingers to shout abuse and name calling!! SINGH-KULIM

Re: Guru Granth sahib Ji goes speeding

fff · 24 Nov 2004

singh ji, at all sadhsangat samagams in north america, Guruji's sukhaasan and parkash processions are led with the drum of either a dholki or a dhol, and with chennay, if not even MORE insturments, like taliyaan, chamtay and so forth.. you should see it in montreal, it's beautiful, guruji is treated with incredible respect and is taken in exactly the method you talk about. just thought i would throw that in, to reply to singhji's/singhneeji's post.

Re: PANGAT ??? line/row/column !!!

ManjitKaur · 24 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. But what my veer Gurcharan Singh Kulim meant was in olden times GURU JI being taken to an INDIVIDUAL SIKHS house for Anand karaj/akhandpaath/sehajpaath etc would also be taken this way. I had the opportuniuty to see this in RURAL Villages where the Gurdwara and the houses would be quite near......BUT now a days the Car is sent to teh Gurdwara to bring both the Granthi and the GURU JI sroop...sometimes it is just the granthi and the driver witht the sroop. Manjit kaur