Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sarees and bindhis

Sarees and bindhis

Question · 14 Nov 2004

Gurfateh! Can anyone on this message board enlighten me on whether it is permissible for an Amritdhari Singhnee to wear a saree or to adorn her forehead with a bindhi? I believe that such manmat adornments like this is bipran kee reet. Also are non-Amrtidhari "Sikh" females allowed to wear such clothing/accessories? I see many Hindu and "Sikh" women in the Gurudwara Sahibs dressed in Sarees and wearing bindhis on their forehead. I do not believe that this is the proper conduct in front of our beloved Guru Sahib. I suggested to the pardhan that we should make it clear that sarees and bindhis and other such manmat/brahmanic behaviors should be strictly prohibited in the Gurudwara Sahib, however I have been unsuccessful my arguments. Are there any writings in the Sikh literatures that I can use to back up my concerns? Does the sangat think I am going too far? I look forward to your responses.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 15 Nov 2004

"Sarab sanjhi gurbani" Guru ji's message is for all mankind - His door is open to everyone. Will you now limit it to only those from Punjab? Only those willing to wear traditional Punjabi clothing? It wasn't that long ago when regular, everyday clothing for Punjabi women, including Sikhs, consisted of wearing long ghagre. There are non-Punjabi Sikhs living in areas like Orissa and Assam who have little connection with traditional punjabi clothing. There are still others, Hindus mostly and some few Muslims who, in addition to their own beliefs, find peace in Guru ji and Guru ji's message - should they be turned away because of differing dress codes/traditions? As long as the clothing is RESPECTFUL AND CHASTE, then I don't think there is anything wrong with different forms of clothing, be they pants, long skirts or saris. Regarding bindis - forget about restrictions. Imposing restrictions like these does very few people any good. If there are Sikh women wearing bindis - oh well - they're most likely wearing it as something cultural rather than anything religious. If you have serious concern over this trend, and I'm not discounting that there may be room for serious concern, then address this concern by getting on the stage, and doing katha or speeches with pyar and nimrata. Teach the sangat with pyar, drawing upon Sikh history and gurbani to make your point - let the bibian decide to stop wearing bindian (if that is your goal) on their own accord, having made that decision themselves. You'd be amazed at how much impact katha/speeches done with honest pyar and nimrata can have on people. And finally, consider this question: Is it a greater evil to be wearing a bindi or is it a greater evil to turn away someone who comes seeking Guru Maharaj ji's darshan, Gurbani, kirtan, simran, sangat? Who will Guru ji be displeased with? A bibi for having a piece of plastic glued to her forehead or that Singh/Singhni who has just denied that bibi the chance to listen to kirtan, do simran, have darshan? Look at the big picture and decide for yourself. respectfully, Respectfully Question wrote: > Gurfateh! > > Can anyone on this message board enlighten me on whether it is > permissible for an Amritdhari Singhnee to wear a saree or to > adorn her forehead with a bindhi? I believe that such manmat > adornments like this is bipran kee reet. > > Also are non-Amrtidhari "Sikh" females allowed to wear such > clothing/accessories? > > I see many Hindu and "Sikh" women in the Gurudwara Sahibs > dressed in Sarees and wearing bindhis on their forehead. I do > not believe that this is the proper conduct in front of our > beloved Guru Sahib. I suggested to the pardhan that we should > make it clear that sarees and bindhis and other such > manmat/brahmanic behaviors should be strictly prohibited in the > Gurudwara Sahib, however I have been unsuccessful my arguments. > Are there any writings in the Sikh literatures that I can use > to back up my concerns? > > Does the sangat think I am going too far? I look forward to > your responses. >

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Mkhalsa · 15 Nov 2004

I agree with you 100%! its disgusting!

Re: Sarees and bindhis

singhnee · 15 Nov 2004

um...i've never seen a singhnee with a bindi or saree, which part of the world are u from?

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 15 Nov 2004

Dear Singhnee, Read my post again - I never mentioned anything about singhnees wearing bindis or sarees. But if an amritdhari women, say from Sri Lanka or Tamil Nadu, whose traditional dress consisted of the sari, wanted to go to the gurudwara, are you advocating she should be denied? Why? Because her clothes don't match with your stereotype of what is traditional and respectful ie Punjabi clothing? Consider a bibi born in the west and to a catholic family but drawn to the Guru - do you turn her away for wearing a long skirt to the Gurudwara, even though her clothing is completely chaste? As to what part of the world I'm from - Canada, born and raised. My family is from Punjab. Would you also like to know what district I'm from? The pind I'm from? Would you like to know what I wear to the gurudwara? Almost always a chola and dumalla. Is my point somehow more valid because of these facts. Would my point have been any less valid if I was non-Punjabi Sikh living in Maharastra? Please stop thinking that only Punjabis are or can be Sikhs. If Guru ji's messsage is for all of humanity, then you have to broaden your acceptance of differing styles of clothing. As long as that clothing is respectful and chaste, that clothing is fine - it doesn't need to fit with some concept of traditional punjabi clothing, be that a chola or salwar kameez. Regarding bindis - please reread my post as you seem to have missed the point. I am not saying bindis are good or bad - at the most, I am implying that outright restrictions are counterproductive. Instead of demeaning an individual by barring them from the gurdwara (how un-Sikhlike) with a restriction based entirely on a small piece of plastic, teach them with pyar and nimrata why they shouldn't wear bindian and make sure to back these teachings with Gurbani and/or history and/or rehit. Much better this route than a restriction which will only hurt the sentiments of well-intentioned individuals, Sikh or non-Sikh. Again I ask: Is it a greater evil to be wearing a bindi or is it a greater evil to turn away someone who comes seeking Guru Maharaj ji's darshan, Gurbani, kirtan, simran, sangat? Who will Guru ji be displeased with? A bibi for having a piece of plastic glued to her forehead or that Singh/Singhni who has just denied that bibi the chance to listen to kirtan, do simran, have darshan? Look at the big picture and decide for yourself. respectfully, Respectfully singhnee wrote: > > um...i've never seen a singhnee with a bindi or saree, which > part of the world are u from?

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 15 Nov 2004

Dear Singhnee - Please take no offense at my last post - I reread it and there is always a danger that such posts will be taken the wrong way. I realize your question was not sarcastic (at least I hope it wasn't) and my post was not meant as an attack, only as a clarification. I apologize for any offense that may have been taken. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Question · 15 Nov 2004

MKhalsa Ji Thanks for concorring with me. Can you direct to some resources that I can use to back up my stance on this matter. After looking at the pictures of the wedding in Tapoban Sahib etc, I am finally convinced that such adornments are stricly forbidden in the darbar of Guru Sahib Ji. But can I conclude from your answer that such dressing is stictly forbidden for Khalsa females? What about nose rings? I also find those questionable too. Singhnee: I have seen plenty of "Sikh" females wearing bindhi's and sarees in Gurudwaras especially at weddings/receptions etc and to be quite frank it disgusts me. It makes me want to puke. If they want to dress like that they can go to the mandir but not in the Gurudwara Sahib. I believe such attire is improper for a Sikh female (amritdhari or not).

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

I think that for some non-Sikh people to wear their traditional clothing and bindis is not wrong. As long as it is "modest" and not provocative. For an amritdhari to wear a sari and a bindi is of course completely out of the question.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 15 Nov 2004

Let's forget the bindi for a second because there may be some religious connotations to it which are counter-productive to the Sikh identity - I'm not saying this is true because I don't know - but let's assume it is 'wrong'. You also seem to assume that an amritdhari's traditional clothing would not consist of a sari - that is an incorrect assumption; not all amritdharis are Punjabi. Then you say "For an amritdhari to wear a sari....is of course completely out of the question." Please tell me why it is 'of course completely out of the question'? That is a very bold and definitive statement. For all I know, there may be something definitive on this issue, and if so, I'd like to hear it. I'd like to hear why a sari, or a dress, or a pair of pants is 'completely out of the question' if such clothing covers the body properly and is respectful and chaste. respectfully, Respectfully Singh wrote: > I think that for some non-Sikh people to wear their traditional > clothing and bindis is not wrong. As long as it is "modest" > and not provocative. > > For an amritdhari to wear a sari and a bindi is of course > completely out of the question.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Guru Sahib has said that "khalsa mero roop hai khaas". So if someone is Khalsa, male or female, they attempt to take on the form of Guru Sahib. We may make exceptions like wearing pants, etc. but ideally a Sikh should always remain in bana. Now what's wrong with a sari? A sari exposes the midriff of the wearer. That is NOT appropriate for a Sikh woman.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 15 Nov 2004

The issue of what exactly 'bana' refers to may be contentious - I don't think it is one type of clothing. Bana, in my humble opinion, refers to the panj kakaar. Also, I concede here that I may be wrong on my take regarding bana but I have not heard anything substantive regarding there being one type of clothing which IS bana but that is not something I wish to get into - we can leave that for another discussion. You state we can make exceptions to pants - why pants and not saris? What about a sari that covers absolutely everything and pants which look like they're painted on? I think the distinction we are looking for is not the style of clothing but the respectfullness and chastity of such clothing. I agree with you - if the sari is overtly exposing the midriff, it may not be considered respectful, but the same goes for modern punjabi suits that some women wear which seem more designed to reveal then conceal. Also, I have seen older hindu women wearing Saris which exposed next to nothing and were very respectful looking. I think the key here is not that saris are bad/wrong, or skirts are bad/wrong but whether such clothing is respectful and chaste (I keep saying that phrase). As long as an individual's clothing remains respectful and chaste, there is, in my humble opinion, no reason to bar them from the Gurdwara. respectfully, Respectfully Singh wrote: > Guru Sahib has said that "khalsa mero roop hai khaas". So if > someone is Khalsa, male or female, they attempt to take on the > form of Guru Sahib. > > We may make exceptions like wearing pants, etc. but ideally a > Sikh should always remain in bana. > > Now what's wrong with a sari? A sari exposes the midriff of > the wearer. That is NOT appropriate for a Sikh woman.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Singh · 15 Nov 2004

I said that pants were an exception people made, not that it was right. But that is an exception that at least is modest. Can you see a Sikh bibi with a dastaar or dumalla in a sari?

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 16 Nov 2004

Forgive me if I'm mistaken, but you seem to be confusing saris with immodesty. Saris are a form of clothing - I don't particularly care for them - but whether they are modest or immodest is dependant on how the person wears it. Sari does not automatically equal immodest. I have seen a Sikh bibi with a dastar wearing a sari - it looked odd since I had never seen an amritdhari woman wearing a sari (in fact, I haven't seen very many women wear saris period) but there was nothing immodest at all about her or her clothing - she looked dignified and very respectful. As I mentioned, it struck me as 'weird' at first but I quickly realized that feeling was due almost entirely to my not having seen very many people wearing saris - I'm not sure whether she was Punjabi or not and I had no reason to talk to her. Just because you or I think something looks 'weird' does not automatically make it wrong. I think a bibi wearing a flourescent green chola with blue polka-dots would look a little 'weird'/'different' but that doesn't make it 'wrong' and it certainly would not be a justifiable reason to bar that bibi from the Gurdwara. If pants are not right, that would make them wrong - why are pants wrong, if they are worn in a respectful and chaste manner? How about wearing a long kurta baring the legs? Is that 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? What about a short chola, tight pajami - is that 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? Forget the rights and wrongs when it comes to types of clothing. The only discriminating factor should be whether the clothing is respectful and chaste. Is there anything in Gurbani, Sikh history, or rehit which says only one type of clothing is allowed in the Gurdwara or that clothing from only one culture (the Punjabi culture) is allowed in the Gurdwara? If there is, please let me know. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Sarees and bindhis

sad so sad · 16 Nov 2004

I see the point that "respectfully" is trying to make. Sikh bibi's wear Western clothing, (pants, jeans etc.) so why not Indian clothing? Well I don't know about you but Khalsa is supposed to be tyar-bar-tyar... I don't know how a bibi will be able to take care of herself in a situation if she is concerned with holding the pala of the SAri, concealing her midriff and trying to prevent herself from tripping over her sari. Also, no one is banning anyone from the gurdwara over clothing. What are you talking about? >>>> If pants are not right, that would make them wrong - why are pants wrong, if they are worn in a respectful and chaste manner? How about wearing a long kurta baring the legs? Is that 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? What about a short chola, tight pajami - is that 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? >>>> Jholi wala pajama conceals a lot more then any pant that you can find. If you know what I mean. if your sitting against a wall with your knees up you want to be wearing a jholi wali pajami, especially in a gurdwara otherwise it's just obscene. SEcondly, when you go to the darbar you have to go in proper attire. As per Sikh TRADITION the bana involves chola, kurta, jholi wala pajama and hazooria. How did the Sikh bibi's fight in wars wearing saris? Obviously they were given some sort of dress by guru sahib as were the Singhs, infact it is the same dress. I remember reading a description by some British guy about the clothing of the Sihs... i'll look it up for u.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Answer · 16 Nov 2004

This dilema reminds me of a famous saying, and I hope that it is of some assistance for you: "Before you criticize someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticize them, you are a mile away, and you have their shoes!" - Anonymous

Re: Sarees and bindhis

lakhvir singh · 16 Nov 2004

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!! KhalsaJi, GuruJi has blessed his Sikhs with a unique identity. There is nothing wrong with wearing a sari or bindhis but in my understanding, these adornments are the identities of Hindu culture. Sikhs have had their own culture since the time of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, and I am more humbled by a Sikhni who is adorned in the Bana of the Guru. But at the end of the day, I leave it to the womenfolk to decide what suits them, and the matter it is between them and the Guru. The ultimate question would be, is what I am wearing acceptable to the Guru? The best answer comes from within the self. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!! L*

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 16 Nov 2004

Yes - the sari does pose a problem when it comes to being tyar-par-tyar. That said, I wonder how many of our bibian, amritdhari and non-amritdhari know even the basics of combat - also an aspect of tyar-par-tyar. Regarding banning people from the gurdwara - please see the very first post in this thread - I would think it would be obvious what I am talking about. We differ on the point of tradition, as it seems do many jathebandian, even when it comes to attire. There are definitely some things which are essential but others which are optional. The tradition you speak of, regarding cholay, pajame is more a cultural phenomenon than anything else. Cholay, kurta-pajama, salwar-kameez - these are all items of Punjabi clothing. Considering that most Sikhs are Punjabi, it is clear to see how easily something pertaining to culture can become integegrated as religious tradition. My opinion on the matter - as long as a Singh or Singhni is rehitvan, it matters not whether they are wearing western clothing or punjabi clothing. Clothing is clothing, it need only be respectful and chaste, especially in the Gurdwara. But if I was to go by only my opinion, there would be no point in carrying on discussions on this forum - I'm here to learn just as much as I am to share what little I know. Correct me if I'm wrong, but there isn't anything in Gurbani or rehit promoting one type of clothing. If you are looking to tradition to back you up, please keep in mind there exist differing traditions even amongst rehitvan Gursikhs. respectfully, Respectfully sad so sad wrote: > I see the point that "respectfully" is trying to make. Sikh > bibi's wear Western clothing, (pants, jeans etc.) so why not > Indian clothing? > > Well I don't know about you but Khalsa is supposed to be > tyar-bar-tyar... I don't know how a bibi will be able to take > care of herself in a situation if she is concerned with holding > the pala of the SAri, concealing her midriff and trying to > prevent herself from tripping over her sari. > > Also, no one is banning anyone from the gurdwara over clothing. > What are you talking about? > > >>>> > If pants are not right, that would make them wrong - why are > pants wrong, if they are worn in a respectful and chaste > manner? How about wearing a long kurta baring the legs? Is that > 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? What about a short chola, tight > pajami - is that 'right' as opposed to 'wrong'? > >>>> > > Jholi wala pajama conceals a lot more then any pant that you > can find. If you know what I mean. if your sitting against a > wall with your knees up you want to be wearing a jholi wali > pajami, especially in a gurdwara otherwise it's just obscene. > > SEcondly, when you go to the darbar you have to go in proper > attire. As per Sikh TRADITION the bana involves chola, kurta, > jholi wala pajama and hazooria. > > How did the Sikh bibi's fight in wars wearing saris? Obviously > they were given some sort of dress by guru sahib as were the > Singhs, infact it is the same dress. > > I remember reading a description by some British guy about the > clothing of the Sihs... i'll look it up for u.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

singhnee · 16 Nov 2004

dear respectfully no my post was a response to the original post. when i read it there wasnt any responses to him yet, mine was the first, and no i was being serious. anyways, i agree with all your points

Re: Sarees and bindhis

sad so sad · 17 Nov 2004

well bibian don't know combat ... does that mean that they should begin to wear clothes which will hinder them in a combat situation or should they attempt to learn combat? I think the answer is obvious. One should work to strengthen their weakness rather then introduce another weakness in light of existing ones. Also, guru sahib prescribed the same kakkars for both men and women. He prescribed the same rehit. Which would mean that if it is okay for women to wear sari's to the gurdwara then it would also be okay for men to wear saris to the gurdwara? I think not. Their is such a thing as "bana" wether you believe it or not is up to you. Their is a dress code in Sikhi. Look at the sewadars at Darbar Sahib. In any case the most convicing proof you will find is to go up to a bibi and ask her what her opinion is on wearing sari. She will most likely tell you that it just feels wrong. Many times guru sahib speaks in our hearts and lets us know right from wrong. But you must be dedicated to following guru sahib's hukams. if people just want to follow their own matt then it is up to them. as long as we think we are clever we are lost... in our cleverness.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 17 Nov 2004

dear 'sad so sad' Are you purposely trying to misunderstand what I have written? Please re-read what I have written and hopefully you will realize that I am not advocating the wearing of saris - in fact, if I am advocating anything, it is that there is no room for one set of prescribed clothing and the only discriminating factors should be respectability of the clothing. Again, you seem to be making your own arguments and then answering them yourself. I did not say women should not learn combat and I did not say they should wear saris to further hinder them. If you read the paragraph I wrote, it should be abundantly clear to you that I am in fact agreeing with you! but you seem to be looking for an argument.... Your argument regarding men wearing saris since Guru ji gave both sexes equality is, and I apologize in advance for the offense, simply ridiculous. 1) You state Guru ji gave both males and females the 5 kakaar - fine so far. 2) You state Guru ji gave both males and females the same rehit - fine. 3) And then, you conclude that this means if women are allowed to wear saris so are men! That is one giant leap in logical reasoning. You may as well say that if 1 and 2 are correct, then since women are allowed into women's bathrooms, men should be allowed into women's bathrooms too. Or that since women wear bras, then men should be allowed to wear bras too. There is no connection between point 1 and point 2 with your point 3. You are comparing apples and oranges. While point 1 and 2 go to Guru ji's hukum and the equality of our spiritual being, point 3 refers to clothing which is a function of culture. Of course whether I believe in something is up to me, especially since you have only offered your own beliefs as argument; you have not mentioned anything sourced to Gurbani or rehit which dictates that there is one type of clothing called 'bana' which must be worn. A bibi's opinion on saris or anything else is going to be just that - her own opinion. It proves nothing. But let us assume that you are right in this, and that it will prove something - I've already seen an amritdhari bibi wearing a sari - if I asker her for her opinion on the matter, unless she was a hypocrite, she would probably say it is fine. Do I win the argument now based on this opinion? Or should we conduct a survey as to the opinions the majority of bibian hold on this topic? Should there be a 50% plus 1 majority to decide what is right or should we aim for a 2/3rds majority? But wait, what's the point in doing all this? What if 99% of all bibian are against the wearing of saris, does this mean that the opinion of the majority must be shoved down the throats of the 1% minority? I think not. Opinions are just that, opinions - let's look elsewhere for our guidance. (note: saris are one example that was offered - it isn't, and has not been the crux of my argument or opinion - clothing should be respectful and chaste - that is the discriminating factor.) Yes, many times Guru ji does speak in our hearts if we are dedicated. And yes, some people are just going to make up their own mat and follow their own mat and try to present is as the definitive truth. Let's look to Guru ji for guidance instead of reveling in our cleverness. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Jugraj Singh · 19 Nov 2004

>>>And then, you conclude that this means if women are allowed to wear saris so are men! That is one giant leap in logical reasoning. You may as well say that if 1 and 2 are correct, then since women are allowed into women's bathrooms, men should be allowed into women's bathrooms too. Or that since women wear bras, then men should be allowed to wear bras too. There is no connection between point 1 and point 2 with your point 3. You are comparing apples and oranges. While point 1 and 2 go to Guru ji's hukum and the equality of our spiritual being, point 3 refers to clothing which is a function of culture. >>> Actually the comments make perfect sense. Here is why. There is one Khalsa rehit. Wearing appropriate clothing is a part of Khalsa rehit. Therefore one can conclude that wearing chaste clothing is a part of Khalsa rehit. However, who defines chaste? What is chaste according to me isn't necessairily chaste to you? So we have as many definitions of chaste as we have people. That is why the key is to follow gurmat. Guru sahib gave us the bana so that we can all know what chaste is. Guru sahib's bana is for both men and women. Think about it. If someone thought that wearing tight jeans and a tank top was appropriate and chaste then would it be okay for that person to show up in maharaj's hazoori with such clothing? Now you will ask how do you know what bana is? If you care to look you will notice that their is a strict dress code enforced at darbar sahib for sewadars. Infact if you think about it, Singhs like Bhai Randhir Singh jee, Bhai FAuja Singh jee etc. always wore Khalsa bana. I doubt bhai Randhir singh jee was much into following cultural traditions so we can safely assume that him wearing bana proves that their is such a thing and that it is clearly defined in gurmat what bana is. You said it yourself... let's not get lost in our own cleverness. Frankly if you are okay with people wearing saris, jeans, or whatever else then that is up to you. However, if a Singh/bibi wants to go to maharaj's hazoori then one must be respectful and show proper sharam. >>>> Or should we conduct a survey as to the opinions the majority of bibian hold on this topic? Should there be a 50% plus 1 majority to decide what is right or should we aim for a 2/3rds majority? >>>> No survey is necessary. My point was that many times people instinctively know right from wrong. To me denying the fact that Khalsa uniform exists outside of the kakkars seems wrong based on what I have said above. >>>> That is one giant leap in logical reasoning. You may as well say that if 1 and 2 are correct, then since women are allowed into women's bathrooms, men should be allowed into women's bathrooms too. Or that since women wear bras, then men should be allowed to wear bras too. >>>> What do you mean allowed to? My point was that bana is a part of rehit and as such applies to both men and woman equally. WEaring a bra is a personal thing and is clothing worn underneath bana. It is the same as someone wearing a sweater over the chola or wearing something for back support. It does not in anyway interfere with khalsa dress. My point was that if it is gurmat rehit then it applies to both men and women. For example dastaar, kakkars, kesh. Then why not bana as well. I'm not trying to make my own arguments... simply trying to clarify my points so that readers can understand them better. Also please don't be so quick to call others stupid. It shows immaturity and haumai. Your own shortcomings in understanding does not make my points stupid. >>> While point 1 and 2 go to Guru ji's hukum and the equality of our spiritual being, point 3 refers to clothing which is a function of culture. >>> So isn't kacherra clothing? I mean culturally it would be acceptable to wear calvin klein wouldn't it? Why do you say that clothing is a function of culture? Please explain. The way I understand it is this: Khalsa is above culture. Khalsa only knows rehit. When we become the Khalsa we give up our previous cultural ties, we give up our previous caste, we give up our own minds and adopt the lifestyle as showed by guru sahib. We adopt guru's mat and give up our own. If we are told what time to wake up, what to eat, that dastaar must be worn, that certain people should be avoided, that certain professions must be avoided, why could bana not be specified. Now again don't say that I'm making up some argument about caste, I'm not. simply clarifying my points. Hopefully you found this post to be more clear. Daas, Jugraj Singh

Re: Sarees and bindhis

respectfully · 19 Nov 2004

Dear Jugraj Singh - I have not called you, or anyone else for that matter, stupid. I had a problem with your reasoning and pointed it out. Criticising your argument is not the same as saying you are stupid - it is done with the hope that some clarification or understanding on an issue will further develop. As to the rest of the argument, I am sorry, but despite the greater care in clarifying your point, I do not agree with it. I do agree that determining what is chaste is a subjective assessment, but at least some degree of reasonableness can be adopted. I don't see the wearing of certain clothes as being on the same level as Guru ji's command to keep the 5 k's on our person; I draw a fairly sharp distinction between the 5k's (and the turban as an article of faith) than I do with the clothes you put forth as mandated by tradition. We will have to disagree on this point. As I do not see anything fruitful emerging from further discussion on this topic, I will refrain from posting anything else on this thread. Thank you for the discussion - it has been worthwhile and educational. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: Sarees and bindhis

very sure · 19 Nov 2004

the salwar kameez has nothing to do with religion and has existed prior to sikhi. I am trying to understand two viewpoints here respectfully says because sikhs are not entirely punjabis which is true so they would wear their cultural dress which predominantly in india is saris from my understanding for women. But the bindi is going too far but then again its more important to get the message of gurbani across with pyar but i havent seen any amritdari woman wear bindis so that would apply to people who are less educated than sikhs here. Now you take a reverse step back when you knew nothing about sikhi and someone tells you that bindi is against sikhi, you shudnt wear it as a sikh or in gurdwara. The difference is that of minds one is a practicing sikh who wants to devote their life towards gurmat, the other is cultural who follows their own mind with parts of sikhi and feel confident in what they do and dont like to be told and many times i have met outsiders in the wider community who have this picture that amritdharis are raving gianis who try to impose rules on us. The point im making is we are talking about grown up people who in my eyes are lost to culture but can be bought back to sikhi with pyar. We can either tell them dont do this, but from my experiences that is counter productive because gianis whos responsible position it is in religion have created this persona about sikhi with use that kind of dominant tone when they address people who know nothing about issues in sikhi that it hits the wrong way and we loose more and more people instead of gaining people with love. Its this love that radaswami groups use on our confused punjabi brothers and sisters and wooe them in, and we sit there getting depleted of our martial stocks. One of my old school friends was a mona wanted to lern sikhi from his heart, ( i knew him as a 5 year old), from a cultural family, but when he was 15 some kesdaris decided to have a dig at his cousin because he was dark skinned with cut hair shouting the hindus have arrived get them out of the gurdwara. these were other 14 15 year old kids. They shouted many obscenities at these two cultural punjabis from sikh families that the two boys were in a dilemna when their parents were given abuse and taunts they beat up the kesdari boys outside, but felt disgusted at themselves. These two boys were very passionate about khalistan through thjeir relatives, but after that incident they have never been back to a gurdwara. Beacuse of these two guys even the musalmaan gangs shivered to hit singhs. This gurdwara was renowned at the time for telling women off for wearing bindis too, now that gurdwara stands empty whgereas in the 90s it was rammed. The only time it fills is with a rensbhai or wedding. I remember as far back as 1982 the gurdwara was rammed everyday those were the days when we stood together. Now i also understand the other viewpoint punjab itself and sikhs here are being overcome with a hindi culture, through means of language many girls especially prefer to speak hindi over punjabi. But at this point we need to ask ourselves why? why would a punjabi want to wear sari? the majority of girls at weddings i seen with saris are cut haired with little exposure to real sikhi through gurmat. Its not alone about knowledge but whats being practicied for a reason. I dont know about you guys but come across many youth who complain about older sikhs telling them off for trivial things in gurdwara. This can be very off putting where someone is trying to show their authority, a perfect example i went to gurdwara with my mother who has over 7 ilnesses that can kick in like a snow balled effect under a bad nervous system. Now she was very ill, i took her gurdwara with me to give her sukh and shanti from listening to gurbani, at langar time she was happy that she wanted to be part of a community the britgh smile on her lit up and took away all the problems she had. she sat opposite me, an older sevedar comes over and shouts at her saying men and women have to sit apart, i explained to him she is ill and didnt know, he still didnt have it. I myself went to get langar in another gurdwara after listening to guru sahib from which i felt peace. downstairs a sevedar starts shouting at me for not holding my plate in the right position lol. i couldnt understand what he said, when i did i almost flipped i was like why are you shouting at such a small thing? we are not kids we r grown people. Now i didnt loose my cool but the peace and sukh i gained from listening to gurbani at the gurdwara i lost that day. Now i hardly enter langar and keep myself to darbar of Guru ji and then walk out home. Its not always about what the message is but how you choose to deliver it.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

c'est simple · 19 Nov 2004

"Khalsa is above culture. Khalsa only knows rehit. When we become the Khalsa we give up our previous cultural ties, we give up our previous caste, we give up our own minds and adopt the lifestyle as showed by guru sahib." Nicely said veerji. That is exactly what I was thinking while reading this thread. Culture shouldn't influence your rehit.

Re: Sarees and bindhis

? · 19 Nov 2004

then why are people still leading doubles lives in caste after taking amrit?

Re: Sarees and bindhis

Jugraj Singh · 20 Nov 2004

>>>> I do agree that determining what is chaste is a subjective assessment, but at least some degree of reasonableness can be adopted. >>>> Who decides what is reasonable? Do we have some sort of a panthic vote on the issue? Like I mentioned before, we will have as many definitions of reasonable as we have people. That is why guru sahib defined "reasonable" for us by giving us bana. >>>>I don't see the wearing of certain clothes as being on the same level as Guru ji's command to keep the 5 k's on our person; I draw a fairly sharp distinction between the 5k's (and the turban as an article of faith) than I do with the clothes you put forth as mandated by tradition. We will have to disagree on this point. >>>> I didn't say that wearing clothes is the same level as wearing panj kakkars. You don't have to get peshed for wearing jeans. However, just because the kakkars are mandatory doesn't make the Khalsa bana any significant. We should try to keep as much rehit as we can. All rehit is important. The first panj pyare all had their own previous cultures, beliefs etc. but gave it up all up when they got amrit because that was the condition for getting amrit. WE are reborn and as such give up all previous ties. Infact if you want to use the cultural argument then the only culture we should be looking to are the Khalsa traditions and rehits. Which clearly show that such a thing as bana exists. Jugraj Singh