Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

interesting · 11 Nov 2004

I came across an album of a Western Sikh wedding. It's pretty different than what we all have seen. It's pretty weird seeing people in bana do some of that stuff. But here's the link: [url]http://kiwishark.net/emAlbum.cgi?cmd=show_thumbs&path=2003_Archive/2003-12-20_Ardas_and_Kulwant's_Wedding!&tn=1[/url] Another thing that I want to say that really doesn't fit here, but I'm too lazy to start a new thread: the last name Khalsa DOES have serious problems. Just look on the internet and you'll find tonnes of people with the last name Khalsa whose parents were involved in 3H0 but left and now these regular people have the last name Khalsa. When they are anything but. In fact, there's even a rock band with a singer with the last name Khalsa and he's got the punk identity going. I don't know if there's a solution to this problem. This album is from the blog of "Hari Khalsa". She's really not a Sikh though.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

singhni · 11 Nov 2004

vaheguru... glad they seem happy. just hope they are progressing towards vaheguru. yea weird seeing all the dancing and kissing (actually that made me feel quite horrible) but i guess its just cultural differences. but then sad to see the women dancin with crop tops - now that cannot be explained. they are sort of mixing sikhi, western culture and punjabi culture definitely couldnt relate to ANY of the photos. all those dasthars, singhnees and singhs in cholay and sri sahibs... and dancing, women and open physical contact.. anyways...if they would give their heads for sikhi if 1984 was ever repeated then good for them

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

sikh · 11 Nov 2004

um interesting............! but yes i also cant understand how white sikhs have names like guru khalsa, waheguru kaur etc.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

A Singh · 11 Nov 2004

Hari "Singh" Khalsa is a man!!!

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Seaching for Tat · 11 Nov 2004

you cannot blame people. they are doing as much as they can. They need more eduaction, and more sangat. I am always proud of American sikhs. They have a real deep commitment to sikhi for keeping that saroop. They need to be brought more mainstream. Do not criticize them. Just explain to them why we do not do certain things like dancing.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

singh · 11 Nov 2004

no, Hari Khalsa is a girl. That's her in the banner along with her boyfriend "eric".

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Mkhalsa · 11 Nov 2004

oh my god I do beleive I am scarred for life... that is the first time in my life I have ever seen a singh or a singhnee kissing someone... i know it sounds prudish to westerners, but its just not bloody apropriate.. that is disgusting.. disgrace to bana... ok, im going to go scream.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

A Singh · 11 Nov 2004

This thread is the most patronising set of opinions I have ever seen...gosh!

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

respectfully · 11 Nov 2004

Dear Sangat - Perhaps we can kill this thread here - nothing really beneficial comes out such a topic and discussion descends into explicit or implicit comments oh how "we" are better than "them". Moreover, there is the difficulty some have in differentiating between culture and religion. In Punjabi culture, a husband holding his wife's hand is taboo! The same is not true in many other cultures and a kiss is no real cause for alarm, especially considering that none of us are forced to do the same - we each have the freedom to choose. Re dancing, I think why this strikes us as 'wierd' is seeing men and women wearing cholay and dastara doing bhangra - a sight we definitely do not see in Punjabi culture. However, it is not uncommon for amritdhari Sikhs to be doing bhangra while wearing suits and ties. Again, a function of culture in determining what clothing is appropriate - since many American Sikhs tend to wear cholay in all aspects of their life, they have no problem dancing in that same, everyday style of clothing. note:lets not get into whether dancing is evil or not - the issue has been discussed ad nauseum in many threads in this forum and others. I fear that this thread will devolve into yet another akj vs taksali type battle of egos....except that in this case, the american sikhs will have no one to back them up and the entire discussion will be a petty display (implicit or explicit) of how we are better Sikhs. Final note - a forumite implied that these American Sikhs were somehow less for not having died in 1984, for not having given shaheedi in 1984 - please! How many of us were there in 1984? How many of our parents gave their lives for the Panth? Was your dad martyred in Harimander Sahib? Yet, we still feel we are more justified in making such statements because what - we share the same culture, the same color of skin as those great shaheeds? Why can't white Sikhs link themselves to those great men and women like we do? Because those shaheeds were brown like us and not white like them? That, my friends, is outright racism. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Singh · 11 Nov 2004

Nice pictures, except the Gidha part.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

g · 11 Nov 2004

I cant relate to the wedding either... but why badmouth them? they are just people having fun oh no! they are dancing... you guys are soo hilarious sometimes explain to me why we do not do certain things like dancing please I still have never heard a good explanation... I dont think we should go out to clubs and dance because personally I think its stupid but from a sikhi point of view I have not seen it say anywhere that dancing is against sikhi, and as far as the names go.... whats the big deal? do you think its some sorta disrespect to have a name like Guru khalsa or Waheguru kaur... I Was born with the name Gurumandir Singh Khalsa... do you expect me to change the name I have had my whole life? I go by the name Guru am I disrespecting Guru ji somehow and If I am please tell me how? Ive had both western culture and punjabi culture influence my whole life... I even at a point in my life droped all my "western values" and adopted the punjabi culture for awhile I thought just like all of you and acted just like all of you... but it got old real quick... now Ive droped both western culture and punjabi culture cuz they are both messed up... I cant see eye to eye with any of you punjabi people your so set in your ways you think your punjabi culture is your sikhi... you cant differinciate one from the other... sikhi is messed up... I Find it funny how you all try to move to the same place becauset there's a big community of sikhs but then you all hate eachother ive never seen so much trash talking being done... sikhi does preach about equality... and thats true because in sikhi the men and women do the same amount of trash talking... Im happy where I live away from other sikhs I have to drive an hour to see another sikh its nice I can go around my town not feeling like I am being watched or spied on... very nice I guess its just that I hate 99% of all sikhs now and its funny because I am sikh and will remain sikh I just cant stand other sikhs... its not hard to see why though... I mean look at this post all you did was go look at somones wedding photos and decided they are wierd and bad and are not real sikhs... how am I supposed to have love for somone who the first thing they do is judge and decide I am bad... Im sorry I Can not keep up an act of being a "good sikh" just to impress you... Im sorry I like to have fun hang out with my non sikh friends Watch movies play video games listen to music Im sorry vaheguru ji gave me this name... Im sorry I cant be fake for you I dont like being fake I can go to the Gurdwara and see a building full of fake people all tryin to impress eachother wutever you guys are wrong in so many ways take your culture to the grave with you the next generation of sikhs do not want it we are actually intelligent enough to see how wrong and messed up it is...

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

A Singh · 11 Nov 2004

Dear 'g' Don't you get it, having 'fun' is absolutely wrong, so is holding hands with your wife...I guess Gursikhs can't kiss their wives either!!! Explains the state of family relationships and couples amongst Punjabis...especially given the level of Domestic Abuse that features amongst even "AMritDhari" Sikhs!!!

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

respectfully · 12 Nov 2004

Dear g, It seems that you have, unfortunately, had many negative experiences with the Sikh community. It is unfortunate because the actions of some, even many, do not reflect on the whole. While I, and many on this forum as well, have had negative experiences with other Sikhs, I have had more than my fair share of positive, uplifting and encouraging experiences too. In your post, you are angry (and justifiably so) at how some Sikhs judge others without knowing them and generalize about groups of people. Sadly, you seem to have fallen into the same mindset. respectfully, Respectfully

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

harpreet singh · 12 Nov 2004

Enough respect to all the white singhs/kaurs around the world. Can't put into words how much I respect all of you.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

g · 12 Nov 2004

your right where you say I have fallen into the same mindset about generalizin groups of people... I dislike sikhs very much now... but I still have my close sikh friends... so its not all of them... but its not the same mind set... the reason I am mad is because these people try to ruin other people... they look at them find anything bad that they can and spread rumors about them aimed at ruining their reputation but yes I am very mad... because anytime somone is just tryin to have fun and enjoy life... you have somone who comes along and tells them they are doing something wrong dirty's their names instead of just sayin oh they look happpy its nice to see Gursikhs keeping bana and keski instead we try to find something wrong... of course im angry I cant have sangat because I cant trust my fellow Gursikhs I feel alone in this world I cant be my self and be accepted everyone would think im bad and tell people not to speak to me... I liked it alot better before I got into sikhi I was innocent I didnt see the things we do to eachother I thought everyone was good and looked up to fellow gursikhs... but then I saw what really goes on and it... it was just sad... I got nothing more to say its just sad and I see it everyday... sorry If I get upset about it but I cant help it

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

jss · 12 Nov 2004

"g" bhenji i want you to know that not all Punjabi sikhs are the same... the sikhi you've seen growing up..isn't sikhi...it's the politics that have been played out by people who are not interested in sikhi...but are interested in themselves...and i'm truly sorry that you experienced such negative things... feel free to email me if you want to talk about it further.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

vickysingh · 12 Nov 2004

hmmm.. How about respect other ppls privace?? shall we??

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

sikh · 12 Nov 2004

guys its ok to love your wife in private etc. but not in public where is the decency in that? what are we trying to project by openly displaying these types of actions? guru ji stood above and for more of this

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 12 Nov 2004

Having looked at these pictures, I can't see these so called 'Sikhs' giving even a drop of blood for the Panth, let alone their lives. They look like a load of hippies who think looking like a Sikh is trendy/cool this year. What did they do after the ceremony? Smoke pot? As for kissing your wife/husband, there's nothing wrong with that as long as it is done in privacy, i.e. with nobody else present. This is not being prudish, but just respectful. I can only ask- what is to come next? - 'you may kiss the bride' in the Gurdwara after anand karaj? I suggest people get a grip and stick to the traditional values of Sikhi and keep our faith - the Sikh religion and Gurbani are as relevant today as were 300 years ago- Sikhism will never be outdated as it is one religion that is way ahead of it's time. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, sri Waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

god is watching · 12 Nov 2004

i can see exactly where g is coming from and he does have a point. Some of my experiences mirror somehwhat that way and i have seen close ones affected too. Its very hard then to decipher pyar for gurmukhs and watch out for the political gup shap chugal masters who love to spread nindia. we shud be finding ways to ruin other people but to help them grow as better sikhs. There are some singhs who may act very strict in samagams and have a real strict regime but some of the ones i have come across will after many months have a chill out break and have a laugh amongst themselves (ie dancing to bhangra for a laugh in private with 4 5 friends at a weekend after a pasta pizza session). Now when its gorey sikhs we kick up a big fuss. One of my amritdhari veers is married and his wife wants to hold his hand when they go to town centre, he didnt feel right about it because of the way punjabi culture reared him up, but now shares his feelings with his wife more openly which has helped bond their relationship more. Their both happy, Im not mad about the kissing part on the pics but i do feel it is inappropriate and not very khalsa like and should be thus avoided maybe going too far. But you have to understand and not hold their culture against the white sikhs. We too have culture creeping in even at times where we try it not to such as someone in the family wants to have a party, do a dj, give the relatives some dhoom, dhaam. Instead of cursing our brothers and sisters who have taken amrit why dont we try to form ekta and keep the unity? and love for all? what harm is it? they seem secure in their sikhi to have come this far and are still progressing, we seem secure enough in sikhi to have battled kal yug so far, so why the need to look down? look up look to the future, try to build on what we have, now as i write this due to the atmosphere sometimes i kno someones gona come back and cross examine my words against their so called logic, but come on dont u just get tired of all these pitfalls, arguments, condemning that just seem endless? nobody is perfect, not me or you we have to try to aim higher and one day be better. white sikhs are not on pedestal nor are we. Now i wana say something from some of the experiences i have had with some sikhs i have grown distant because of the nindia chuglia hunting and info gfathering they were doing. Now i find more trust fellowship and love between sikh and non sikhs. This is what experiences like this do veers so please dont push your family away more. A true sikh is one who is warm, loving compassionate, caring understanding and their aim would be to help another sikh to one day be minimum like them and maximum towards Gurus feet regardless fo their position at the moment. What G has said in his final line is exactly what i felt, its heartbreaking enough where it almost destroyed my faith. Go ahead and call me weak, i dont care, im no longer interested in sangat, i do my own thing and i am responsible to vaheguru, guru granth sahib ji our eternal guru and all our satgurus who have given us rehet . I have had enough of being the end butt of nindia with both my relatives and sangat, then we wonder why people convert out of sikhi. When i was new to sikhi and before i too was innocent, when you see what happens, it brings you crashing down to reality this is no better than non sikhs do. when are we going to wake up to the qualities of a gursikh? and if we dont are we going to see more divisions and people leaving sikhi? il give u one example, if you say something with pyar to someone they respond to you and know that with affection you say something and care for them. If you scold others or do nindia chugli to attack or pull people down, you will probably never see them again. tThen what sikhi do we represent? Je koi pyar hani what is left?

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

kaur · 12 Nov 2004

'A Singh' theres nothing wrong with kissing ur wife, but get a bloody room no need to do anything in public, its inappropriate ..is that my culture speaking? i dunno, i just think a singh or singhnee should behave as khalsa and i dont think khalsa would be kissing, whats next? full on snog (sorry i hate that word too), pinching butts in public? no way. husband &wife can do whateva they want after anand karaj but in private..thank you.

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Searching for Tat · 12 Nov 2004

admins - please stop this thread. i do not think it is right to critice somones pictures on a public thread. It will really hurt them if they read it. Education is the best way. Gursikhs should just explain to them about aspects of our behaviour. I think they are wonderful for doing as much as they are doing...

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

god is watching · 12 Nov 2004

i agree with searching for tat

Re: An..umm..interesting "Western Sikh" Wedding

Admin · 12 Nov 2004

This thread is closed.