Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 09 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Our Paavan Satgurus chose the medium of KAVITA ( POETRY) to write Ilahi Gurbani...because in many ways POETRY is a much better medium to express one's thoughts than VAARTAK ( Essay type of Composition) Also poetry gives the writer something called "poetic License" to express ideas in alangkaars, mystical flavours, use similies and metaphors, use "exaggerations" etc etc...something whcich is not alolowed in dramatic or other forms of writing. The heights to which apoet can fly are always higher than any other writing style... Guur Ji have made Gurbani "interesting", in many ways...Gurbani is to be "memorised by heart", Gurbani is meant to be "lessons of life", Gurbani is meant to be "instructive, constructive" as well as Enjoyable to read for hours on end. The most important thing about GURBANI is however that it is Never meant to be LITERALLY INTERPRETED...that is Word for Word interpretation.. Example: When Satguur Ji says: Sir Dhar tali gali meri aao...YOU are NOT expected to PHYSICALLY cut off your HEAD, Place it on Your PALM and walk towards the GURU JI.... The intended meaning is : GIVE UP YOUR MANMATT ( your HEAD ) If you want to Walk my Path ( Accept GURUMATT) Many beleive that the Original PANJ PIYARE literally Gave their HEADS. ( Physically CUT Off by GURU JI and then REJOINED BY GURU JI ) I will NOT go into that part of History as I also beleive in GURU KIAN GURU JANEH...BUT I will Hold on to my Solid Belief that OUR BELOVED SATGURU, GURU GOBIND SINGH JI GAVE us, the KHALSA 100% of WHATEVER HE HAD.... WE the KHALSA are HIS KHAAS ROOP, We the KHALSA are property of WAHEGURU just as GURU JI is the Sut Tohe NIVAJA Son of Waheguru...The KHALSA today is 100% GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...THEN WHY may I ask are we SIKHS not expected to get our heads PHYSICALLY REMOVED at Amrit Sanchaar. Literally hundreds of thousands of Amrti sanchaars have taken place all around the World since Vasakhi 1699..has there been even one case of a Sikh's HEAD BEING "PHYSICALLY CUT OFF" and then REJOINED to his Body after Amrit. IF we say THAT was GURU GOBIND SINGH JI and THIS is the Modern KHALSA..then we are not being TRUE KHALSA as GURU JI has Given us HIS ALL - He has NOT kept anything however small BACK . WHY do I say this. Look at our History..GURU NANAK ji showed the way ( by refusing to treat the Gurgadhi as a personal property ) and GURU Angad Ji followed suit. GURU ARJUN JI showed us the way by sitting Calmly and Peacefully In Bhaaana on a Hot plate, Boiled alive...and Sikhs like Bhai Dyala got boiled alive in Bhaana .. sitting calmly and peacefully in a pot of boiling water reciting Japji, Bhai Mati dass ji got sawed alive in TWO calm and peaceful serenly reciting Japji....Bhai Sati dass gets Burned ALIVE reciting Japji without a single word of anger or maiyuusee on his lips... Guur Teg Bahadur Ji sat in Chnadni Chowk and gave His Head for Freedom of religion....literally hundreds of thousands of SIKHS did exactly the SAME, in the SAME unflinching manner.... Guur Gobind Singh ji happily sacrificed His FOUR SONS....Baba banda Singh ji followed suit by happily swallowing the beating heart of his infant son reciting Japji...Bhai mani Singh had his limbs cut joint by joint...even reminding the jalaad to do his job properly..The Chhoteh Sahibzadeh showed the way and Five Year Old Harkirat Singh followeed suit..jumping for JOY at Shahedeee and even telling his mother off for trying to "save him".. THAT is mY POINT. Our SATGURUS loved us so much that they MADE us LIKE THEM..our satguuru is the ONLY TRUE PARAS that makes us NOT "GOLD" BUT another PARAS like Himself. Now we proceed to the main topic of this mail... that is why GURBANI should NOT be literally translated. The Word Charandhoor has been mentioned many many times in Gurbani....and the FAKE SANTS ( those of you heavily into SANTISM...will groan and say..there he goes again sant bashing....sant hater...mahamoorakh.... BUT please bear with me and read through before making up your mind )..have grabbed hold of these TUKS to translate that Charandhoor is LITERAL DUST of their FEET that the sangat MUST EAT/SWALLOW for Salvation. I just received a sealed plastic package from a famous Sant dera that contains" Holy Charan Dhoor" which on being put in water and drunk will remove all my diseases, make me successful etc. This comes Hot on the heels of the HOLY MUD packages that people took home from the MUD that was cleaned out of harmandir sahib Sarovar during Kaar sewa some time ago. Devout Gursikhs keep thsoe plastic packages of "holy mud" wrapped under RUMALLAHS and treat it with reverence as it came from the House of Guru Raamdass. And then I came across a picture of Harmandir sahib and I saw a Signboard placed prominently at Har Ki pauri which says: Amrit ke chuli Parranh door hatke lao ji.... and I also saw the photo of a BERI TREE that is supposed to REMOVE all "DUKH" ( Dukh Bhanjani Beri).... Never mind that all this while I thought that GURBANI is theat which is supposed to REMOVE DUKH and not trees.... and AMRIT is GURBANI and not water in a sarovar ( that needs to be CLEANED periodically which DIRECTLY CLASHES with the meaning of AMRIT - soemthing that is ever clean and pure and never needs cleaning but cleans !!! ) Never mind never mind....thats the way things are. Back to Charandhoor. Lets see what GURBANI says. Charandhoor is the ULTIMATE "description" of HUMILITY. That is the meaning Satguru Ji want to give us. Satgur Ji says: Kar ishnaan simar prabh aapna, Mann TANN bhaiyeh AAROGA (611). Guur Ji is very very clear - Physical Bathing is to Clean the TANN ( for a Healthy body) and SIMRAN is for the healthy MANN. How can anyone in his right mind advocate "drinking water polluted with Charandhoor...dust...bodily gand mand.." and say that is HEALTHY. but it is a FACT that many many SANTS give such water - Body bath water, water from washed kachherras, water they have dipped their feet in.. to their chelas..FOR SPIRITUAL CLEANLINESS !!! In the New tetament JESUS is shown WASHING the FEET of his disciples... as a sign of HUMILITY and humbleness...BUT he doesnt DRINK that water !!! The SANTS are mixing their JHOOTH into Langgars for the sangat...and people are happy to lap it all up..when an AMRITDHAREE is ORDERED NOT to take the JHOOTh of ANY ONE ELSE..no matter HOW HOLY !!! Mann jhooth hai, Tann jhooth hai, jihba jhoothee hoi, MUKH JHoothe JHHOOTH bolana, kio kar soocha hoi ??BIN abh SHABAD na manjeeyeh... Sacheh te sach hoi. (55) Our Mann is JHOOTHa, tan is Jhootha Mann is jhootha because it is full of VIKAAR, the tann is jhootha because we use it ot tell lies ( jeebh tongue), hands to steal , eyes to look at others property, lust after it, legs to walk towards kaam situations bad places, etc. so HOW do we CLEAN all this RUBBISH out? Guur Ji says only SHABAD can wash us CLEAN.... So do we beleive in SHABAD or.... drink water given by so and so as "holy" ??? Here is another example of Humility shown By saguru Ji: Mein badhi sach dharanmsal hai, gursikhaan laendhaah bhaal Ke, PAER DHOVAAN, PAKHA FERDAAN. TIS niv niv lagaan pai jeeo .( 73) IS this to be taken literally... do we expect SATGURU JI to wash our feet, serve us hand and foot ?? Satguru Ji also calls Himslef NEECh, KOOKAR, NIMANA, PAAPII, MOORAKH, KEET etc.. Are we to tehn say YES GURU JI IS all that ?? NO of course NOt. Every Sikh Knows that SATGURU JI is Mahaan, the Ocean of GYAN, the Ganga of humility, calm, peace, all things Good and Pure The Sun of Akaash ganga..BUT in His HEART SATGURU JI is so humble that he is the slave of the Sangat !!! Gursikhs who are ever ready to give their life blood if Satguur Ji even asks us for our SWEAT..WILL NEVER in their wildest dreams even think of asking SATGURU JI to do "sewa" of washing our feet, pakhaan ferean !!! is that imaginable?? Bhai lehna Ji once accidentally ( before he knew Guur nanak ji) sat on his horse and let GURU NANAK ji walk before him holding the reins of his horse...BUT when he found out who had held his horse and walked before him while he rode..Bhai lehna Ji was full of REMORSE at the ghor paap he had unwittingly committed. Can any Gursikh "knowingly" committ such a paap even though satguur Ji is humble enough to serve him . Our satguur Ji's took on 10 jamaas, served humanity selflessly for 250 years, did such KAARNAMEH that even today are shining examples - model villages, towns, baolis, khoos, sarovars, schools... AND best of all the SHINING PATH oferred by GURBANI...but sadly Sikhs today have taken the village footpath of "charandhoor", charanpahul, Jall amrit, sarovar amrit, kumbh jall, chubacha amrit etc way of BHARAM and Naash of Jeewan instead of Jeewan muktee given BY GURBANI. Satguur Ji declares fearlessly: Nanak AMRIT EK HAI...DOOJAH AMRIT NAHEHN ( 1238)....There is ONLY ONE AMRIT and NO OTHER. This One and ONLY AMRIT is GURBANI-NAAM-.... Bhul Chuk Maaf karni ji, dass jarnail Singh Part TWO follows soon.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

???? · 09 Nov 2004

is it ok to clean the dirt on the sangats shoes then?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Believer · 09 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Giani Ji, thanks for your comments, it does make sense. i mean for example if charan dhoor was to clean one's inner beung then Sri guru Gobind Singh Ji could have given the Panj Piare water from his feet right- but Guru Ji didn't- Bani was recited whilst stirring the amrit with a kirpan. Bhul Chuk Marf Karni Ji. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 09 Nov 2004

everything is manifest and physical and real and true and felt when there is full, innocent, stainless love and divine respect in the heart and soul when this happens all outward shows are done outwardly but have serious inward significance outward shows are not the enemy the enemy is shallow-mindedness, lack of love, apathy. karam is one thing karam kaand is another.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

???? · 10 Nov 2004

"Author: kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa" thank you, that does make a whole lot of sense.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. TO: ??? Ji, The act of "cleaning sangat' s shoes jorreh" etc is an exercise in HUMILITY. That is a "physical action" but if properly done makes the Mann humble This is SEWA to train us in being humble...IT is very very difficult to be so humble....BUT BEWARE..the very act of "jorreh sewa" if done to attract attention to ones "humility" can be damning to your self because haumai will be manufactured wholesale !!. But I firmly beleive just the act of washing shoes will NOT WASH our MANN of vikaars...ONLY NAAM can do that. This SEWA just like langgar sewa, cleaning toilets in the Gurdwara, washing floors, dusting carpets, planting flowers, keeping the car parks clean etc etc is all a form of SEWA that helps us in our JOURNEY towards the GURU...BUT ONLY NAAM and Darshan of GURU JI and following his UPDESH can clean our Mann. Dass Jarnail singh.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

uk singh · 10 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani Ji - Alot of sangat who come to Amrit Vele programmes clean shoes with a cloth they tend to keep on them at all times and wipe this on their matha after this excercise. I myself believe the real dhoor is naam itself, but am baffled by this act. Like you stated, if they are doing this seva to attain humility this is fine. I've heard that a person once mopped the floor of a langar and proceeded to drink the dirty water. Na bheejai kete hovahi dhoorr: The Divine is not won over by becoming the dust of the masses (1237).

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

disgusted · 10 Nov 2004

please stop this unwarranted attack on premis of waheguru if somebody drinks sangat's dhoor that is a stage of their life everything the guru said is not metaphorical if that is the case then maybe we should wear metaphorical 5 k's and do metaphorical nitnem.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Justice SIngh · 10 Nov 2004

you people are insulting gursikhs who just do seva from their heart and ther'es nothing wrong with it so i don't see the probnlem i mean i understand if somebody is doing something for SHOW or to have ego but if they do it from their heart then it's understandable another thing guru granth sahib jee says : you can't get god from karma, ghaal, seva, dhoor, daya, dharam, etc. etc. but then guru granth sahib jee tells us to do seva, become dhoor, practice daya, practice dharam. the point is the these things are the MEANS and MEANS ARE GOOD, as long as we know they are means and not end. please don't ridicule the means if they do help some people reach the end / goal.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. To each his own.....what members of the sangat, premis etc do to learn humility is their own business.. but the really disgusting part is when such "stories" as told above about the premis drinking mopped water off the langgar floor, another "cleaned" the faeces on a gurdwara toilet floor with his bare hands....another dusted the carpets and mixed the vacuumed dust in water and drank that.... NOW IF these PREMIS had done all this in TOTAL SECRECY ( so NO one except they and their GURU even got a tiny BHINNEK of their actions)..then NO ONE WOULD BE DISGUSTED.... but when these "stories" get around...that means something is seriously wrong... its all a exercise in FUTILITY as HAUMAII is manufactured . So the next time you feel the urge to drink the mopped water in a langgar clean up exercise please do it PRIVATELY. Gurbani is clear: NA BHEEJEH ketee hoveah DHOOR...HE ( WAHEGURU ) is NOT IMPRESSED with those trying to become the DHOOR of the Masses ( obviously because that ACT is PUBLIC KNOWLEDGE. Daan given publicly, NAAM japped ostentatiously, ardassan done to show off, etc are all useless. NO offense to premis doing sewa.. Just trying to understand the real meanings of Gurbani.. jarnail singh Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 11 Nov 2004

""Many beleive that the Original PANJ PIYARE literally Gave their HEADS."" "Satgur Mera Maar Jiwalay" Nothing is impossible for Guru Ji. He is the death of death, Mahan Kaal of Kaal. He gives life and takes it away. He controls everything. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Manjit kaur · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Bijla Singh Ji, Satgur mera maar jiwalleh.... is right. ( by the way this is also metaphorical as the AMRIT is a REawakening - BORN AGAIN....NEW LIFE... We "give our head ..that is OLD HEAD full of Manmatt to the Guur and GET a NEW HEAD full of GURMATT and thus we get a NEW LIFE.... MArreh hoi nu navin jaan milee.) I beleive Jarnail singh was saying that since SATGURU NANAK-GOBIND SINGH JI Bestowed GURGADHI of SHABAD to GURU GRANTH overseeing the GURU KHALSA PANTH.... there is NOT an IOTA of DIFFERENCE between the SATGUR NANAK-GOBIND SINGH JYOT that was on Earth from 1469-1708..and THE KHALSA MERA ROOP HAI KHAS...revealed in 1699. THE Shabad GURU JYOT that came from SACH KHAND with GURU NANAK is STILL with us in SHABAD GURU GRANTH JI..OR is it ?? ISNT this the same "SATGUR MERA MAAR JIWALLEH"... so SHOW me where and in which country and at what time...at any AMRIT SANCHAAR were all the HEADS of the AMRIT ABHILAKHEES CUT OFF, PUT on the GROUND and then REJOINED..after All their BLOOD had flowed out of their bodies.... BUT on the other hand the SIKH HISTORY is FULL to OVERFLOWING of marreh hoi jeewan mukt SINGHS" created by the Amrit of Khanda Battah..that CARRIED their HEADS on their PALMS..... First of ALL GURU NANAK led the way by calling the Rulers Rajen Shhen Mukaddam KUTTEH, and PUT LIFE into ZOMBIES DEAD for 1000 YEARS..so that by the time of GURU Arjun Sahib Jee's Shahedeee, these same ZOMBIES but now gone through the SATGUR MERA MAAR JEWALEH ceremoney of NAAM AMRIT..PUT to FLIGHT in FOUR BATTLES the well trained Moghul Soldiers of Shah jehan.. Those that move about with a KAFFAN on their heads are the ones referred to in the Gurbani line you quoted.... COWARDS DIE a THOUSAND DEATHS..Brave die once ( after Satgur has made them ALIVE !!_ Read how these same Kaffandharee- Amrtidharee-Singhs like General Avtar Singh Brahma, Gen Sukhdev Singh babbar, Sukha Jinda, General Subegh Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh, Jathedar manochahal, Gurdev singh kaonke..were the LIVING DEAD that struck TERROR in the GOI Forces that are the Strongest Army in Asia.. This is SATGUR MERA MAAR JIWALEH in TRUE ACTION..and the AMRIT TODAY can MAKE this REALITY happen just as it did in 1699 !!! TO stick to the point that ONLY "GURU GOBIND SINGH JI" is the SATGUR Mera Maar Jiwaleh..and that the GURU KHALSA PANTH and GURU GRANTH cannot do this is a false premise ( This is precisely what is meant by those who relate stories of vasakhi 1699 to Satgur Mera Maar Jiwaleh) BUT who CANT provide any such "EVIDENCE" about the Amrti Sanchaars thta happened afterwards...till TODAY. IF we stick to that story, we will be saying OUR KHANDA BATTAH DE AMRIT IS "different" from the one GURU JI prepared in vasakhi 1699 .. IS that so ?? NO it is NOT SO. The AMRIT TODAY is the SAME 100% as in 1469-1708...and the AMRIT we get from the PANJ today is also SATGUR MERA MAAR JIWALEH.... PROVEN by hundreds of thousands of SINGHS...1708 and after.. And let me also reiterate here that our GURU SAHIBAANS were 100% WAHEGURU/NATURE adherents...meaning thy NEVER interfered in Waheguru's NATURAL LAWS.... I think its no big deal anyway for someone to "cut off" someone's head and rejoin it ( Scientists are going to be able to do this in an few decades looking at the way science is advancing HEAD TRANSPLANTS are due any time soon )...BUT to MAKE a ZOMBIE DEAD for 1000 YEARS into a FULL Fledged INDEPENDENT INDIVIDUAL like the KHALSA is a MIRACLE that not anyone can do ( ONLY a GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND SINGH JYOT could have done it) Heart transplants have already taken place...BUT GURU JI changed the "birdy" hearts of Hindostani ZOMBIES dead for 1000 years into EAGLES and LIONS...NOW THAT is what i call a TRUE MIRACLE...and 100% IN TUNE WITH NATURE and WAHEGURU's LAWS of PHYSICS. The zombies who "opened their mouths" to full extent when the MUSLIM LORDS wanted to SPIT...suddenly turned into LIONS that kicked some ass so hard it ran all the way to TURKEY... the Zombies that "dutifully gave their daughters and virgin brides" to the MUSLIM LORDS..suddenly started RESCUING daughters and brides in the thousands to be sent back to their Hindu parents... THESE are the REAL MIRACLES that our GURUs Showed....Please let go of those silly fake stories that are in reality a gross insult to the Gurus. ( IF we had rejected these from the very beginning we wont be having Bakre Katteh ke Singh ?? types of arguments ?? IF we continue to do "wrong " parchaar we are going to be stuck with those who will continue to spread Bakreh katteh stories..and who are we to stop these...BUT the Correct PARCHAAR concentrating on what the GURUs really accomplished will soon have everybody on our side as there is NO DOUBT as to what GURU Ji really accomplished as the SOLID ROCK HARD EVIDENCE is in our HISTORY... Just my random thoughts No offense to either singh katteh or bakreh katteh beleivers...I beleive NEITHER happend. Dassree manjit Kaur

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. With all due respect Veer Bijla Singh Ji...that also is metaphorical...or we will end up in a fruitless debate. Why ?? let me explain. I firmly believe that The SHABAD GURU - JYOT that came from Waheguru in the Form of Guru nanak Ji - Guru Gobind Singh Ji 1469-1708 is the SAME SHABAD GURU JYOT now resident in the GURU GRANTH Ji and in the GURU KHALSA PANTH. IF we say Heads were PHYSICALLY cut off and REJOINED ( Satgur mera maar jiwaleh) in Vasakhi 1699 at Anandpur Sahib.... then Has this been REPEATED anywhere else where HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of AMRIT SANCHAARS have taken place since 1708. TO say this was done by GURU GOBIND SINGH Ji ONLY means we are admitting that the GURU GRANTH and GURU KHALSA PANTH "DO NOT" have the POWERS of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI as SATGUR. Secondly this gives ammunition to the BAKREH KATTEH brigade to spread their version of distorted history. I SAY, NO. The AMRIT of SATGURU GOBIND SINGH JI at Vasakhi 1699 is the SAME as at any Amrit Sanchaar held anywhere since...and the SATGUR MERA MAAR JIWALEH..means SATGUR's AMRIT makes us give up our "metaphorical head of Manmatt" in place of GURUMATT ( the NEW HEAD) and thus NEW RE-BIRTH as a KHALSA. To change someones MINDSET is much harder than to rejoin a cut head physically - scientists will be able to do head tranplants soon...BUT no scientist can make a COWARD into a LION KHALSA. Jarnail Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 11 Nov 2004

Yet again Giani Ji you seem to be barking up the wrong tree. The Berri tree is where Guru RaamDas Ji and Baba Buddha Ji and Bhai Gurdas Ji used to sit under while the seva of the construction of Harmindar sahib was taking place. Gurbani tells us : “Saw dhart payee hariavali, jithay mayra Satgur betta avay...” Wherever my Satguru sits the land turns green with life. And this is absolutely true, wherever Guru Nanak Dev Ji walked in the jungles and forests the bare barren land would turn green and flower, that is the shakti of Guru Sahib Ji. And does it not follow that that place would also become ‘pavitar’ where Guru RaamDas Ji also sat ??? I hope you do not mind me saying but you have a Gianiship and yet you think at a very low level, you seem to have a very low opinion of all people. One shouldn’t judge other people by one’s own standards. In the court of Guru Gobind Singh Ji there was a lady (whose name i forget). She was of a very high ‘avasta’ she would be absorbed in Naam all the time, even forgetting to eat or clothe herself. She was at such a level that she saw everyone the same and saw Akalpurkh in all. One day she came into the darbar of Guru Sahib Ji half clothed , Guru Sahib Ji addressed her “ Mata Ji I know your avasta and you are pure of heart and mind, but those people around you are not of the same level and will look at you with accusing eyes, please go and clothe yourself properly.” The point being, bad nasty people like me would look at Mata Ji and start doing nindhia. “Oh, she is just doing this to show off” “ People like her only do this to draw attention to themselves” etc etc. Papi people like me do not know the avasta of Gursikhs and we just stand back and do nindhia. <<<<< and AMRIT is GURBANI and not water in a sarovar >>>>> Doesn’t jall get changed to amrit upon the recitation of Gurbani? And isn’t gurbani recited next to the sarovar all the time ? How exactly would you interpret the following : “Raam Das sarovar nattay sabh uttray paap kamatay.” If a person wants to clean shoes at Gurdwara, does he/she have to scuttle around in the dead of night so that no one will see them? It is not they who are at fault it is us, we are the fools who stand in judgment. True Gursikhs will lower their eyes and carry on with their seva regardless of those around them, it is us who point the fingers. This is known as shardhaa, something you know little about. It is shardhaa when a person does mutha-take for five minutes. It is shardhaa when a person does a full mutha-take and lies on the ground prostate. It is shardhaa when a person does seva of the shoes. This is people having a personal relationship with their Guru, who are we to point fingers? If someone wants to putt dhoor on their foreheads – “ tayra sir kio dukhda ???” Shame giani ji, shame.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 11 Nov 2004

First of all can we establish one thing, giani Ji, do you believe that the heads of the Panj Piyaray were separated from thier bodies by Guru Sahib Ji in 1699 ? The Amrit is the same, the Guru is the same, it is we the Khalsa panth who have changed, we now do not follow the true path of our Guru. Rather we point fingers at our fellow sikhs and worst still we point fingers and question our Gurus. The amrit is the same and heads were separated in Vaisakhi 1699 and if we had enough 'vishvaash' (faith) is our Guru it could be done NOW, no doubt about it.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Bundha Ji, MY interpretation of Ramdass Sarovar nahteh is availble in Guru Granth Darpan by Prof Sahib Singh. The entire Darpan is availble ONLINE. Please do read the entire shabad. This Sarovar is NOT of "Ram Dass the Fourth GURU JI"... this Sarovar is of the NAAM AMRIT of the DASS ( followers) of RAAM (Sabh wich Ramiya Hoiayah - WAHEGURU).. Nahteh in Sarovars, Teeraths, Khoos, Baolis is all CONDEMNED IN GURBANI. Please quote one tuk which RECOMMENDS bathing at any teerath/sarovar for SALVATION/MULTEE instead of Naam Japping. You will find many many SHABADS telling you Bathing at Sarovars/Teeraths is akin to FROGS bathing in Water 24 hours. Gurbani makes it very very clear that one needs to BATHE IN NAAM ONLY to attain MUKTEE/Oneness with Waheguru..NO OTHER WAY. IF just sitting makes trees and places give us muktee....then the whole of PUNJAB is full of these places.. Chappa chapa dhartee has the footmarks of Gurus.. there is NOT an INCH of dhartee in PUNJAB that has NOT been touched by the GURU Ji's Charan...abd it follows every PUNJABI should already be MUKT just by being in PUNJAB...but sadly Punjab has the highest number of drug addicts, lazy people, wehlarrs, bogus sants, derawallahs, beggars what not.... with SO MUCH SAROVAR AMRIT available all over PUNJAB why arent ALL PUNJABIS HOLY ?? EACH punjabi can bath in "amrit" everyday... no need to wait for Amrit sanchaars like us poor outsiders GURU's Charan pawan dhartee is all over PAKISTANI PUNJAB too ?? NOTHING there is Harra Bharra....in fact Paki Punjab is way behind in everything Eastern Punjab...Does our GURU's Charan pawan work only for SIKHS and NOT MUSLIMS ?? WHY are NOT the beris and trees in nankana Sahib etc helping the Pakis attain MUKTEE ?? SHARDHA is a very doubtful word.. everything is shrdha.. and fake sants and agianis use this word to its fullest extent... AANHI SHARDHA is BLIND FAITH... and the BLIND never reached anywhere. GURBANI tells us to use our AKAL to SEV the SAHIB.. that is use our intellect to UNDERSTAND the SAHIB...NOT have BLIND SHARDHA in HIM and just hope everything will be ok. IT is just this stuff that has SINGHS throwing Water ( paani chhirrkanah) INSIDE the GURU's DARBAR when a sawari is being taken out or brought in... the WATER SPRINKLING is meant to STOP DUST from flying up and should be done on Public Roads etc...BUT right NEXT to Paraksh Saroops of Guru Ji INSIDE the DARBAAR also people with SHARDHA want to sprinkle water !! SHARDHA HAI JEE na roko Ji ??? MY younger brother went to Mehta to study some years back... when he returned he had a large bottle of "sarovar amrit" with him. He had been brainwashed to such an extent that he wanted to stretch this bottle as far as possible... so he poured a few drops into the bath/drinking water....as the years went by the amrit was getting less and less and he was panicking..and then his baba ji told him dont use the amrit like that..keep the bottle CLOSED and just sort of shake it over the bath water and the bath water would be transformed into Ramdass sarovar !!! Such is blind shardha... imagine a GURU da SIKH beleiving such utter rubbish. MY late dad got so angry and threw the damn bottle away..and luckily my brother got the RIGHT MEANINGS of Raam Dass sarovar nahteh. Sorry to disappoint you bundha ji, BUT I have NO SHAME telling the TRUTH about my GURU JI. AANHI SHARDHA is for the AANEH..not the sighhted... THOSE that have eyes yet dont see. Shamelessly Yours dassan dass jarnail Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bundha Ji your question is amply and clearly answered in my posts. I dont like to repeat my self. Secondly the KHALSA has NOT CHANGED....neither has the GURU, Shabad, Amrit and everything else... Whatever happened in the Battles of Guru hargobind Ji, Guru Gobind Singh Ji... was REPEATED in Banda Singh's time, maharaja ranjit Singh's time, IT was REPEATED EXACTLY in 1984. There are ENOUGH SOLID AMRITDHAREE REHATWAAN KHALSA JI alive TODAY to do EXACTLY what was done during the GURU Ji's times. Although I DONT BELIEVE IT, are YOU NOW telling me NOT A SINGLE SANT JI /BABA JI /BRAHMGIANI JI that you rave about is REHTWAAN ENOUGH to REPEAT what the KHALSA DID all along. AT which Amrit Sanchaar of any SANT JI etc were HEADS chopped OFF and REJOINED ?? HAVE ALL the SANT JIS CHANGED ALSO ?? WHY CANT these so called BRAHMGIANIS do this ?? WHY do they do the SAME things other khalsa do at Amrit Sanchaars ?? Surely they are BETTER/More qualified/more BHAGATEE shaktee/whatever ?? Dass jarnail Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 11 Nov 2004

Giani Ji, I think if you read my post again I say nothing about MUKHTI, I said the ground becomes pavitar. You are right all over the Punjab there have the Charan of Guru Sahibs and that land is indeed pavitaar, but again I say that it is US who have not reaped the benefits. We have not reaped the benefit, the mussulmans of pak-punjab have not reaped the benefits.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Balpreet Singh · 11 Nov 2004

I feel that it's pointless to comment any further on whether heads were cut or not. We can't ever know it. I personally believe they were. But debating the point isn't going to bring anymore clarity to the issue.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 11 Nov 2004

I am very sorry to say Jarnail Singh that you are insulting my Guru Ji and this is the third time. First time, you called my Guru Ji lower than sangat, second time you said Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not move mecca and this is the third time. there is nothing I haven't heard. you talk like missionaries who say there is no need to cover Guru Ji in rumalas etc. and no need to put blankets because Shabad is Guru so there is no way Shabad can be hurt and Shabad Guru doesn't need us to cover it......blah blah blah. let me come back to your Amrit arguments. Okay, Amrit is the same. agree. Now, we all know at the first Amrit Sanchaar, Mata Ji put patasay in the Amrit so at which amrit sanchaar is this being done? Mata Ji must put patasay in the batta also otherwise it is not the same, right? There was no Guru Granth Sahib Ji parkashed at first Amrit Sanchar so why is this being done now? Panj Pyare have the same powers as Guru Ji so why do we need to have Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Which Panj Pyare call themselves roop of Guru Ji and declare that they have all powers of Guru JI? anyone?? Guru Ji recited Panj Banis at Amrit Sanchaar and history says that about 80,000 people took Amrit. obviously, Guru JI had to prepare more Amrit and maybe first Panj Pyare prepared it and took part in giving Amrit but how many of those Pyare knew Jaap Sahib by heart?? I can go on and on with these idiotic questions and this is exactly what you are doing. One time you apply some physics laws to prove that Guru Ji didn't do this or that then you apply your "rational" thinking to disapprove something that is well accepted by the Panth. My Guru Ji can do everything. Where your "rational" thinking and laws of physics end that's where Choj of my Guru Ji start. You have more knowledge than me but you lack faith. More knowledge doesn't mean more faith. Sant Kartar Singh Ji once said "Panth is endangered by two kind of people - illiterate and very educated ones". Illiterate ones know nothing about Sikhi and educated ones apply their "rational" thinking to Guru Ji. Guru Ji is not human so don't try to bring Guru Ji to your level of human thinking and then try to prove something. if this debate was fruitless then why did you have to mention it in the first place? If all Gurbani is metaphor then what is real? when you were getting your degree did you spend awful lot of time studying metaphors to understand Gurbani or did you actually study Gurbani little bit?? You are distorting our history and I am not gonna tolerate anyone insult my Guru Ji. Khalsa or Panj Pyare are not Guru. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Guru. Panj Pyare are given the rights to lead Khalsa under the command of Guru Ji. They are given the rights. They have the powers but not Guru Gaddi. How many Panj Pyare are really absorbed in Naam Simran and really fit the definition of Khalsa given by Guru Ji? Bhai Randhir Singh Ji wrote that some Singhs had darshan of Guru Ji and started to float. I guess that is wrong also because our thinking cannot explain it and nor can any scientific laws. When Bhai Mati Das Ji was cut in half, the sound of JapJi Sahib still came out from the two halves. He did not receive Khanday Battay Da Amrit. or is this another metaphor also? what made it happen? My Guru Ji Di Kirpa. He can do everything. just because it is not happening today doesn't mean it is not true. Furthermore, before Guru Gobind Singh Ji, Amrit was in form of Charan Pahul then why didn't Guru Ji keep it the same? had Guru Ji kept it the same, Panj Pyare would be giving their Charan Pahul today. besides, what banis did other nine Gurus recite to prepare Charan Pahul? or did it never happen? Well known Naami Gursikhs believed that Guru Ji physically cut the heads. no need to give names here. but I guess they were wrong cuz they didn't have the degree and did not know how to think rationally. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 12 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. NO one has a MONOPOLY on Guru Ji...He is MY GURU JI just as much as anyone else's. Period. Only a fool will insult His GURU JI. BUT we can agree to disagree about "how" we "insult"???? or REVERE Guur Ji....Each person has his own way...Some Matha Tek like "greased lightning"....split second bowing of head and they are up....some lie prostrate before GURU JI for Half an Hour ( and cause a JAM bumper to bumper traffic like of the Sangat waiting to matha tek ...and then people start cutting the que etc...) soem just stand there with eyes closed..lost in Guru Ji.... let everyone do what he wants..NO COMMENTS as this is Between GURU and His SIKH. NO one has the exclusive RIGHt to tell some other Gursikh how to Talk, write, think, say, about GURU JI.... PERIOD. I think you have got it all WRONG about the GURU KHALSA PANTH.... GURGADHI was Bestowed on the PANJ when GURU JI KNELT before them to RECEIVE AMRIT..Aape Gur Chela. Solid PROOF that GURU JI completed a PARADIGM SHIFT by making His PANTH as equal to Him and said Khalsa Mera ROOP hai KHAS... Here to interpret "ROOP" as just the outer Grab Bana etc is sheer ???? because GURU JI NEVER gave any IMPORTANCE to just OUTER GARB and proved it by dressing KHOTA in Lion's skin. REHAT to GURU JI is BOTH INSIDE as well as OUTSIDE..Each without the other is NIL VALUE. SO if KHALSA is GURU ROOP then the kHALSA is EVERYTHING the GURU IS or GURU Ji wouldnt be BOWING BEFORE an INCOMPLETE entity. Anyone JUST LOOKING LIKE GURU JI ( bana) is NOT a COMPLETE KHALSA..he may very weell be a KHOTA in LION''s DRESS...He got to be REHATWAAN inside as well...ands then there is NOT an IOTA of difference bwteen GURU JI and hIS KHALSA. GURU JI has GIVEN us PROOF when He gave us His FATEH.... WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA.... GURU JI is WAHEGURU JI's SON ( AApna sut tohe Nivaja)..HOW can anyone IMagine this KHALSA of the WAHEGURU is anything less than His SON the GURU JI. ?? Has GURU Ji given us the Title WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA knowing fully well that the KHALSA is WANTING ?? NOT COMPLETE ?? NOT FIT ?? absolutely NOT. That is an INSULT to Both GURU Ji and His KHALSA and to WAHEGURU as well. GURU JI "obeyed" the Khalsa at Chakaur Gharri, also at a Pir's Grave... that was a test to see if His KHALSA was READY to take His Place. ( GURU NANAK ji and subsequent GURU Jis also had these TESTS...BUt they passed on Gurgadhi to single GURU Ji....GURU GOBIND SINGH JI knew no SINGLE person was to be GURU after Him....it was going to be COLLECTIVE KHALSA.... such a REVOLUTIONARY PARADIGM SHIFT has never happened in His tory..ONLY a GURU GOBIND SINGH JI could have done this...THAT is why many even TODAY cannot comprehend or understand how such a thing can happen and DENY it. I reiterate that GURU JI LOVED us so well and so much that HE has GIVEN US EVERYTHING..100% ++++++. GURU JI taught us everything...kept nOTHING back as a "secret"... WHATEVER GURU JI can DO His beloved KHALSA CAN and HAS SHOWN IT to the World. Cant you see ?? IF GURU JI sat on a Hot Plate and said Tera Bhaana Meetha Lageh.... so did Bhai Dayala in a Boiling POT.. so did Bhai mati dass being sawn into TWO... so DID HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of BELOVED SIKHS being skinned ALIVE, cut from limb to limb, Broken on the Wheels...NOT a SINGLE SIKH begged for His life, said sorry, recanted, converted, regretted being a SIKH...FROM as YOUNG as FIVE to as old as 80++ ISNT THAT PROOF ENOUGH. Indira thought the SIKHS ahd "changed"..just like you think the " Khalsa" has changed and is not like GURU JI.... well 1984 SHOWED Indira and everybody else that the KHALSA is still the SAME OLD KHALSA...not an iota has changed. The GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE was NOT PARKASHED at the Vasakhi 1699 for the simple reason that GURU GOBIND SINGH JI WAS THERE in PERSON. Guru granth was also NOT yet GURU.... But this changed in 1708... GURU JI bestowed His GURGADHI to GURU GRANTH and the GURU KHALSA PANTH is IN TABIAH of GURU GRANTH...neither can FUNCTION without the OTHER.. Simplistically put the GURU GRANTH is our "constitution" and IT CANNOT BE CHANGED under any circumstances...BUT the ACTUAL day to day administration is to be carried out by the GURU KHALSA PANTH. This entitiy has the powert o set REHAT etc as long as it is in CONFORMITY with the "unchangeable" GURBANI in the Guru GRANTH Ji. From your "anti" Guuru Khalsa panth "thinking".... i can see you belong to the Sant baba derawallah GROUPS... these are AGAINST the GURU KHALSA PANTH because then they cannot survive...IF there is a FREE FOR ALL then their FIVE fingers are in GHIO ( panjeh ghio wich)...every sant can make his own maryada, do whatever he wants..thats is already happening BUT this GURU KHALSA PANTH thingy is getting in their way and messing up their plans... so they ATTACK this at every opportunity, preferring to "give " all their so called "RESPECT" to "Guru Granth Ji ONLY" because they know very well that GURU GRANTH can be manipulated any wchich way, carried anywhere they like...interpreted anyway they like....BUT this GURU KHALSA PANTH is a whole new "force...it is not so easy to manipulate, carry about, twist and turn it. WHY do you think the Nanaksaris give "so much respect" to GURU GRANTH but thumb their noses at the GURU KHALSA PANTH and reject the Maryada of Nishan sahib, Gurdwara, Kirpans Kakaar , Guru Ka Langgar etc. WHY do the Naamdharees "attack" the GURU GRANTH" ?? because they already have their own PANTH...so they dont need the Granth..wait until the Nanaksaris have their own "Panth" then they too will go the way of the Namdharees, radhasoamis etc. EVERY WANNA BE sant brahmgiani derawallah LOOKS at these "panths" and licks his lips...IF only the GURU KHALSA PANTH were to disappear it will be heyday for me !!! IT is our own failings when we "bring down" the PANJ to our own level. Is there any PANJ member anywhere in the World, who doesnt have an "enemy" who thinks lowly of him. IF you go to Akal Takhat even....you can always "find" someone who "knows" that this a particular "Panj" is a granthi who sleeps late, never does nitnem...etc etc..that particular Panj is this and that... BUT I beleive that wehn a person takes on the PANJ ROLE, GURU JI does KIRPA on HIM and all his "failings" kamjorian etc are COVERED UP by GURU JI and He is GURU ROOP....100% and MORE. IF you still "look at him as an ordinary human being and doubt him" that is your own funeral. You will NEVER find a PANJ that everybody has faith in all the time... SHUCKS even GURU JI didnt inspire FULL FAITH in His SIKHS all the time...Remember the CHALI MUKTEH who DESERTED GURU JI at the MOST VITAL TIME of BATTLE ??... so who are the Panj we see and meet everyday ?? IN conclusion.. the Amrit is the SAME, the Guru Khalsa Panth is the SAME, the GURBANI is the SAME...even the YUG is the SAME....people doubted then and they doubt now... Dassan dass Jarnail Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 12 Nov 2004

With all due respect Giani Ji (and I am trying to adhere to Admin Saab’s request of non-negative comments), you seem to contradict yourself with every posting. Earlier you was bashing all those Gursikhs who do seva, and that they should do it privately, and yet now you say <<<<< some just stand there with eyes closed lost in Guru Ji.... let everyone do what he wants..NO COMMENTS as this is Between GURU and His SIKH. NO one has the exclusive RIGHt to tell some other Gursikh how to Talk, write, think, say, about GURU JI.... PERIOD >>>>> You cannot have it both ways ! <<<<< GURU GOBIND SINGH JI knew no SINGLE person was to be GURU after Him....it was going to be COLLECTIVE KHALSA.... >>>> I may be a fool here, but I recollect that Guru Gobind singh Ji bestowed the Gurgaddhi to Adh Guru Granth Sahib Ji as our eternal Guru ! Earlier you were complaining that Guru Sahib Ji separated the heads of the Panj Piyaray and who has done that since ??? But now you say <<<<< WHATEVER GURU JI can DO His beloved KHALSA CAN ... >>>> <<<<< The GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE was NOT PARKASHED at the Vasakhi 1699 for the simple reason that GURU GOBIND SINGH JI WAS THERE in PERSON. Guru granth was also NOT yet GURU.... >>> What ??? I beg to differ my dear Giani Ji, Adh Guru Granth Sahib Ji was parkash at Vaisakhi 1699. With your line of thinking Adh Guru Granth Sahib Ji was never parkashe’d until 1708 because there were Guru’s until then. Do you think that once Guru Arjun Dev Ji had installed Adh Guru Granth Sahib Ji at Harmindar Sahib 1704, that is was never parkash’d until Guru Gobind Singh Ji passed on Gurguddhi in 1708 ? <<<<< GURU GRANTH is our "constitution" >>>> I find this quite insulting. It has nothing to do with constitution, Guru Granth Sahib Ji is my EVERYTHING. Never miss an opportunity to Sant-bash, Giani Ji I am sure it will come in very useful in-front of Dharam Raja. However, for once I do agree with your sentiments on the Nirankari / Namdhari / Radhaswami’s (bash as much as you like here!) But there again your let you prejudices get the better of you, MOST Sant/Mahapursh plead with the sangat to take Phual and become Amritdhari and have ‘janam saffle’. I have seen many Mahapursh say to individuals with such piyaar “Bhai Ji amrit shak lao, janam suffla kar lao” and the Sikhs shy away and say nothing. How does this sit with the picture you paint of lickin’lips etc ??? I think we are loosing the plot with this thread by now.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 12 Nov 2004

<<<< Adh Guru Granth Sahib Ji at Harmindar Sahib 1704, >>>> Sorry I meant 1604.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 12 Nov 2004

You failed to answer my question. According to you Khalsa and Guru is the same so why do we need to have Guru Granth Sahib Ji parkashed at Amrit Sanchaar since this was not done at first Amrit Sanchaar? If Amrit Sanchaar has to be exactly the same then we need a Mata Ji to put patasay. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the true Guru and is our Father. Khalsa is Son of Guru Ji. Guru Ji gave Khalsa equal rights and Panj Pyare has all the powers to lead Khalsa as long as they are under command of Gurbani. Even Panj Pyare need guidance from Guru Granth Sahib Ji which clearly shows that there is a difference. Khalsa cannot function without Gurbani because no one can become Khalsa without Gurbani but Gurbani can function without Khalsa. I don't know why you said ""neither can FUNCTION without the OTHER"". Gurbani is not dependent on Khalsa. Gurbani does not need Khalsa, Khalsa needs Gurbani. Great Gursikhs who were one with Guru Ji always prayed to Guru Granth Sahib JI for Sikhi. It be very foolish of someone to call himself equal to Guru Ji. Guru Ji gave us equal rights but that doesn't mean we become "The Guru" and take place of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. A Gursikh does Naam Simran and then becomes Khalsa and becomes one with Guru Ji but this all becomes possible only because of Gurbani. Gurbani is Highest. Khalsa becomes Highest because of Gurbani. As long as Khalsa stays under the command of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Khalsa has all the powers (Jab Lag Khalsa Rahay Niara) otherwise Khalsa has nothing. I am not a follower of "Sant". I believe Khalsa should unite and appoint Panj Pyare that will lead the Panth under the command of Gurbani. According to you (I agree also) Panj Pyare can do everything Guru Ji can as long as those Panj are one with Guru Ji. Then if Guru Ji could cut the heads and rejoin them then so can Khalsa. Just because this is not being done doesn't mean it is impossible. Guru Ji never kept any secret from Khalsa so I don't know what you are implying there by saying no "secret". Guru JI openly chopped the heads off and Sangat saw the blood. it was easy thing to do for Guru Ji and Khalsa can do it too. But it was the test for Sikhs which Sikhs passed and became Khalsa Panth, an army of God. Since Khalsa became army of God in 1699, there is no need to do it again. Guru JI knows if you have offered your head or not. If you have not then you are simply not Khalsa and not part of the army. simple as that. <> yeah so either stop doubting or at least stop putting doubts in other people's heads. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

just curious · 13 Nov 2004

I have a question for Arshi Gyani. Do you believe in reincarnation and the transmigration of the soul?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Nov 2004

veer bundha ji, if you read my posts carefully you will see no contradictions. i have said all i wanted to. I also think this particular post has exhausted its plot. i intend to begin another one soon. dass jarnail singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

khalistani · 13 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! guru je was NOT gods son they were god himdelf int he avtaar of satguru je guru jes the best :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 13 Nov 2004

Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa, Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!! Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji, The sixth person to take khande-ke-pahul was whom? Let's refresh our memory. Guru Gobind Singh jee himself was the sixth person to take khande-ke-pahul. I believe since he was not required to have his head physically cut off, this is why thereafter the millions of Sikhs who partake of khande-ke-pahul are not required to have their physical head removed. The method was five times actualized by Guru jee, and the punj pyares heads were physically cut off, and the Punj Pyare were covered in a white clothe and then the amrit was sprinkled in their eyes and Guru Sahib said "BOL VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA, VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH" and Bhai Sahib Bhai Daya Singh Jee "Pyara" stood up and said Fatheh. The rest is history, and fact. This is according to the records of employees of Aurangzeb who were working as spies and stood witness to Baisakhi 1699 and took accounts. And these accounts are available in some Sikh libraries around the world. Just because Guru Gobind Singh Sahib and the Gursikhs thereafter were not required to physically remove their heads does not prove, in any way shape or form, that in fact the situation was the same with the Punj Pyare. The real reason for the physical sacrifice was because Khalsa was not becoming Sikhs. They had all taken charan pahul and therefore they were already Sikhs. They needed a challenge like those that Bhai Lehna got. They needed a challenge that was as testing as Bhai Jetha jee's test. They were being fitted for becoming the physical body of the Guru. Guru Gobind Singh was going to take khande-ke-pahul from the Khalsa. You can only get Khande-ke-pahul from the Guru. The Khalsa is the Guru physical. The Granth is the Guru spiritual. Since the body is dead without the soul, you cannot say Punj Pyare are Guru Suroop without being in the hazoori of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. But when they are in Hazoori, they are body, Khalsa, and soul, Granth. And this only happeneed because of the serious test for the Khalsa - they passed it and that is why Guru Gobind Singh Jee said KHALSA MERO SATGUR POORA. In Sikhi, we don't try to ban people or shut them up. However, your parchar of the "never take gurbani literally" ideology is not helping Sikhs, rather it is making them cynical and sucking the "bhola bhaau" and "nirmal bhau" from their practice. Please forgive my mistakes. vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

dust of dust · 13 Nov 2004

also just like to say that khalsa is not an automatic title you get after amrit but a very devoted spiritual state one achieves after bhagti. But the title is collectively used to adress each other so we inspire towards our goal of being true khalsa.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

dust of dust · 13 Nov 2004

only an amritdhari can hope to achive that state but not all amritdharis are khalsa in spiritual state

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Nov 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Bijla Singh ji, I have no evidence that "Guru" Granth Ji was Parkashed at vasakhi 1699 - i beleive this wasnt done as GURU GOBIND SINGH JI was GURU and Physically Present and GURU GRanth Ji wasnt declared Gurgadhi Guru yet. Veer Bundha Ji beleives Guru Granth was Parkashed..so there is a second opinion for you... 2. Secondly IF you beleive that AMRIT can only be REAL and EXACT If we have Mata Ji, and Patashwy, and...a, b, c, d,.. I am fraid that is like findiing the bird's milk. There is NO MATA JI in the Guru Khalsa Panth ( the NARAKDHAREE KUSANT ahd tried this Chhochha by having Sat Sitarae, Panj Sahibzadeh, Mata Ji etc to prove he was as ORIGINAL as 1699 and one up on Guru Gobind Sigh Ji..he is narak now)...and NO way can we get the EXACT SAME WATER that Guur Ji put in His Bata, nor the Exact SAME Bata that GURU JI used...or the Exact same Khanda etc ec..a,b,c,d... NO WAY. AMRIT is NOT THE "PHYSICAL" water+khand mixture....that you think it is and that is why you are looking for the EXACT this and That. 3. GURBANI in the Form of GURU GRANTH JI is complimentary to GURU KHALSA PANTH....GURU SAHIBAANS spent 250 YEARS in this huge "project". To say that GURBANI "doesnt need" the Khalsa ?? makes no sense. THEN WHY was the KHALSA Created....it could have ended with GURU ARjun Sahib jee as the Guru Granth had been compiled in 1604. FIVE MORE GUru jis followed and Guru Gobind Singh Ji created and finished the whole Khalsa Project in 1708.....and Passed on His Mission to US. To carry on the Human Guru system would have been a complete and utter dissater as the 22 "guurus" at baaba bakala had proved...and Guur Ji was here to present something new and never seen before - the KHALSA. BOTH - Guuru Granth and GURU Khalsa Panth are necessary to complete the equation...NEITHER can do without the other. I have said all I wanted said on this subject. I have not contrdicted or failed to answer any questions. all my beleifs are already in my mails. please read again to make sure. Thank You. dassan dass jarnail singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Speachless · 13 Nov 2004

thanks Bijla Singh for this wonderful post earlier posts DID confuse me and mess me up totally :S

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Manjit Kaur sidhu · 13 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khala Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Not only is a lot of metaphorical language used in Gurbani.. a lot of mythological stories are used as illustrations which a lot of people make the mistake of believing as TRUTH. The myth of Narsingh for example. Guru Ji just wants to use this popular myth as an example that Waheguur is always there for his bhagtas...BUT this doesnt mean GURU JI wants us to beleive that an actual Narsingh ever existed...Becaue such a creature has never been seen or heard of . His very existence is AGAINST NATURE of WAHEGURU. Just for a moment consider this.... there is this small time king and a bhagt Prahlaad.....and to SAVE prahlaad NARSINGH is created to teach the people a lesson that Waheguru must be feared and worshipped.... What happened in RUSSIA... LENIN and STALIN and the Communist Rulers after them MURDERED nearly 60 MILLION PEOPLE, closed down Churches BANNED the Name of GOD and RULED BY TERROR for DECADES...YET NO NARSINGH appeared to SAVE the bhagats in Russia ??? WHY ?? Wasnt there a single bahgat in Russia among all those 60 million murdered ?? HITLER burnt to death 6 MILLION JEWS...NO NARSINGH appeared to TEAR HITLER APART ?? Wasnt there a single bahgat of GOD among the 6 million Jews incinerated in the Gas Ovens of Germany ?? Shanti dee moorat, Shanti de poonj Mere SATGUR GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE are seated on a SIZZLING HOT PLATE being roasted alive....NO NARSINGH appeared to tear apart Jehangir ?? Was there any less bahgtee in Guru Ji ? There was no need for Waheguru to even become a KIRRI and walk on the Hot Plate to show to Guru Ji that it is actually COLD ?? NO dear Jio, the PLATE was HOT and BURNT MY SATGUR Ji's SOHAL BODY to a CRISP.. GO ON through every BLOOD SOAKED PAGE in the THICK BOOK OF SIKH HISTORY... WAHEGURU' S BHAGATS are being BURNT ALIVE, ROASTED, BOILED, CUT FROM LIMB to LIMB, SMASHED , SAWN ALIVE, THEIR MAAS PULLED WITH HOT PINCERS., SKINNED ALIVE, BRICKED ALIVE,,,, YET NOT ONE SINGLE TIME DID ANY SUCH THIG as a NARSINGH BEAST appear to SAVE these BHAGATS ??? 1984..AMRITSAR... THOUSANDS of BHAGATS..men women and children are being BOMBED and BLOWN APART by the INDIAN ARMY TANKS and Cannon...NO NARSINGH Appeared to TEAR INDIRA APART ?? Can anyone tell me where is NARSINGH ?? He is just a MYTH created by story tellers to lead people towards GOD..thats all. NO such thing ever existed or will do in the future. Just another Fairy Tale with a LESSON.. and Guru Ji quoted it to teach us a lesson...DOESNT mean we have to Believe it to be TRUE and that GURU JI beleived it..... or are WE to WAIT for NARSINGH to give us JUSTICE ??? Comments welcome with proofs. Manjit Kaur

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 14 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh, when I say Gurbani doesn't need Khalsa, I simply means something like this-----whether we become Sikhs or patits does not harm or benefit Sikhi. Sikhi stays the same. if we become true Sikhs becuase of Gurbani, it is only for our benefits because Gurbani does our "Lok Sukhiye Parlok Suhelay". Now, if I become true Gursikh, does that benefit Gurbani or make it better? I don't think so. Gurbani stays the same whether I become a true Sikh or a person like "Ajamall". wouldn't you agree? Now, if I become patit, would Gurbani change or stop functioning? I don't think so. Gurbani cannot change and will never change. Gurbani is what is keeping this world alive including Khalsa. Powers of Khalsa come from Gurbani. What is Gurbani getting from Khalsa in return?? utmost respect I would say but still if someone did not respect Gurbani, Gurbani would still stay the same. So Gurbani is always in function. Gurbani has the power to make someone Khalsa but Khalsa Panth has no power to make Gurbani. Which is exactly why Khalsa requested Guru Ji to leave Chamkaur Di Gharri. Guru can make more Sikhs but Sikhs cannot make a Guru. hope this makes sense. Forget about making Amrit Sanchaar exactly the same. just think about it for a sec, Guru Granth Sahib Ji was not parkashed at first Amrit Sanchaar because Guru Gobind Singh Ji was present there and now at Amrit Sanchaar, Guru Gobind Singh Ji is present as a Roop of Panj Pyare so no need to have Guru Granth Sahib Ji. but this is being done which means your theory is wrong. Khalsa does not forget the roots it came from. Gurbani is our roots and Khalsa very well knows that He/She cannot take place of Guru Ji even though my Guru Ji did too much Kirpa and gave Khalsa equal rights. the way this works is like, Guru Granth Sahib Ji, a true father, is sitting there and saying to Khalsa to carry out His responsibility of giving Amrit because Khalsa have the equal rights GIVEN by Guru Ji. This is like a Son is carrying out all the responsibilities of his father and father is blessing his son for being responsible. Father, Guru Granth Sahib Ji will always be in function. Shabad is Guru and always was. Body was never Guru. There was no Khalsa before 1699 and yet Gurbani (Shabad Guru) was in function. Khalsa Shall rule the world and shall teach the world how to setup a True, Peaceful country but it will be Guru Ji doing everything and still Gurbani will be in function. What/who is Khalsa without Gurbani?? Khalsa cannot become His own roots. anyways, I am done. Manjit Kaur, you are being mistaken. Just look at our history of 18th century. When Gursikhs were being hunted by mughal armies and Sikh children were thrown in the air just to be landed on the sharp spears, where was Guru Ji? Guru Ji was always there in the Khalsa. It was Guru Ji fighting through Khalsa to free the country. According to you, Guru Ji or a God needed to come down to save His Bhagats. But why? Guru Ji taught us that Waheguru helps His Bhagats always and Waheguru is everywhere. Guru Ji taught His Khalsa to hold a sword in His hands and fight the oppression, and injustice. and tell me who is fighting in reality? It is the Truth Waheguru fighting through Khalsa. Sword of Khalsa is Waheguru Himself. many historians believe that Guru Ji's dream of freeing country could not come true in His lifetime but He left a freedom movement that ended mughal empire. I totally disagree, Guru Ji entered His Jot in Guru Granth Sahib Ji which gave all the power to Khalsa and whenever Khalsa fought mughal armies, it was Guru Gobind Singh Ji Himself. So my Guru Ji freed the country. he did not need to be there in physical form. Had the Jews learned little bit from Sikhi and fought the Nazis, the outcome would've been different. Sikhs fought in 1984 otherwise we would've suffered more than we did. Guru JI made us Sant Siphais and we are taught that, it is Guru JI Himself fighting when Khalsa fights in the battlefield. Hindu, Muslims, Jews are mistaken and according to Sikhi we do not need an "avtaar" when humans are unjustly being killed. Sikhi teaches to fight back while being on the side of the Truth. Khalsa always won the war being in less number, because Waheguru helped. One has to be foolish to just sit there, get killed and not fight back thinking an "avtaar" would come to save him. Real Bhagats become one with Waheguru and when Bhagats fight, Waheguru Himself fights. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 14 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The post by veer Kar Kirpa sabh rayn theevan is the best on the subject. Thank you veer Ji. This is not to say that veer Bijla Singh is far behind...in fact I read both posts with full concentration. Yes that idea behind the SIXTH peron to take Amrit is beautiful. I am impressed. All in all this is a beautiful debate and i hope we have all benefitted... I sure have benefitted quite a lot. Thank You to all the veers who contributed to my learning process. Learning, un-learning and Re-Learning... Dass Jarnail Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

___ · 14 Nov 2004

what next? baba deep singh didnt have his head chopped off because we dont hear about it today? arent we going to change the course of sikh history and making new sikhs doubt their sikhi heritage? just because science cannot do it does that mean bhagti cant? then what is bhagti? what are its effects? Do we only tally sikhi as far as science goes? but Guru sahibs jot infused from one jot to the next how can science explain that? The Eternal jot of Guru sahibs were infused into Gurbani how can science explain that? So is science or sikhi our path? Is dukh banjan just a story for metaphor description now? How far are we going to go with this use of metaphors? where does it end how do we draw that line? then what is sikhi?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 14 Nov 2004

Benji, I think a lot of people make the mistake of thinking that the sakhis in gurbani are myths, but infact they are facts. There is nothing mythical in gurbani. Guru thi bani speaks the truth, ALWAYS. Why do you say that NaraSingh is against nature? What is to say what is against nature ? If NaraSingh is a myth then is ShivJi a myth ? is Vishu a myth ? is Krishan Bhagwan a myth? Is Sri Ram Chandar Ji a myth ? Is Dusht Daman a myth ? Guru Sahib Ji has written in Bachttar Natak that he did tapasia at Hemkund Sahib. This was in the form of Dusht Daman. Dusht Daman took over the fight against the dhents from Durga and destroyed them. Was Durga a myth And was Dusht Daman a myth. Dusht Daman did tapasia at Hemkund Sahib for 3.5 yuga, is this a myth ? <<<<<< YET NO NARSINGH appeared to SAVE the bhagats in Russia ??? WHY ?? Wasnt there a single bahgat in Russia among all those 60 million murdered ?? >>>> <<<<<< HITLER burnt to death 6 MILLION JEWS...NO NARSINGH appeared to TEAR HITLER APART ?? Wasnt there a single bahgat of GOD among the 6 million Jews incinerated in the Gas Ovens of Germany ?? >>>> You are now questioning the will of AkalPurkh. Only he knows when and why he sends his sevaks to this earth. For hundreds of years India was invaded by outsiders again and again and the people suffered untold horrors and then Guru Sahib Ji came to save us. Who knows when the next saviour will come (Kalki Avatar anybody ?) <<<<<>>>>> Why would Guru Arjun Dev Ji need the help of a Narasingh when Guru Ji himself was akalsaroop. When Mian Mir Ji asked Guru Arjun Dev Ji if he should speak with Jehangir Guru Ji said "this is the will of God, we cannot alter it". <<<<<<< GO ON through every BLOOD SOAKED PAGE in the THICK BOOK OF SIKH HISTORY... WAHEGURU' S BHAGATS are being BURNT ALIVE, ROASTED, BOILED, CUT FROM LIMB to LIMB, SMASHED , SAWN ALIVE, THEIR MAAS PULLED WITH HOT PINCERS., SKINNED ALIVE, BRICKED ALIVE,,,, YET NOT ONE SINGLE TIME DID ANY SUCH THIG as a NARSINGH BEAST appear to SAVE these BHAGATS ??? >>>>> You are looking at this in a very childish level if you do not mind me saying. This is the will of God and only he will do what he likes, if he wishes he will send down an avatar, if he wishes that the people who are moving towards bad and kalyug things then he will let them suffer. You cannot just point your finger at history and say why didn't God send some one down then and why did he let this happen and why did he let that happen. This is the WILL of God. So many Shaheeds gave their lives / Mati Das Ji/Sati Das Ji/Dyala Ji/ Mani Singh Ji/Baba Deep Singh Ji Baba Bhunda Singh Ji on whose blood rose the Khalsa panth. If we go by your thoughts and ask why didn't God send someone to help them then where would the Panth be ??? we needed their sacrifices to be where we are now. <<<< Just another Fairy Tale with a LESSON.. and Guru Ji quoted it to teach us a lesson... >>>> With all due respect you need to go and do a bit more studying and research. Guru Gobind Singh Ji states : "You O'Lord created Durga to kill off the dhents..." Do you think that Guru Sahib Ji was telling us lie here ??? <<<<< Comments welcome with proofs. >>>> Rather childish. No one can prove NaraSingh as they can prove Jesus. It is a matter of faith and what you believe your Guru tells you., or twist it to suit your modern thoughts and say it is all a myth,

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

___ · 14 Nov 2004

i would request manjit kaur sidhu to study bhai gurdas ji vara before she spreads disinformation about gurmat. Correct me if i am in anyway wrong and i apologise beforehand but i have just researched on sikhitothemax and have found bhai gurdas ji vara conflict with what you say. Who do i believe bhai gurdas or you? manjit kaur "Can anyone tell me where is NARSINGH ?? He is just a MYTH created by story tellers to lead people towards GOD..thats all. NO such thing ever existed or will do in the future. Just another Fairy Tale with a LESSON.." This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 12 bishan leae avathaar dhas vair virodhh virodhh jodhh sa(n)ghaarae|| Visnu incarnated ten times and decimated his opposing warriors. mashh kashh vairaah roop nar si(n)gh hoe baavan ba(n)dhhaarae|| The incarnations in the forms of fish, tortoise, swine, man-lion, dwarf and Buddha etc. HAVE HAPPENED. parasaraam raam krishan ho kilak kala(n)kee ath aha(n)kaarae|| vaar 10 bhai gurdas prahlad thha(n)m paarr paragattiaa nar si(n)gh roop anoop anaadha|| At the same moment Lord God in the form of man-lion came out of pillar. His form was grand and majestic. baemukh pakarr pashhaarrian sa(n)th sehaaee aadh jugaadha|| That wicked demon was thrown down and killed and thus it was PROOVED that the Lord is kind to devotees since the time immemorial. jai jai kaar karan brehamaadh ||a|| Seeing this Brahma and other gods started eulogising the Lord. On humility sabhadhoo(n) neevee(n) dhharath hai aap gavaae hoee ouddeenee|| The earth is the most humble which eschewing ego is firm and steady. dhheeraj dhharam sa(n)thokh kar dhirrh pairaa(n) haet(h) rehae liv leenee|| Deeply rooted in fortitude, dharma and contentment it remains tranquil under feet. saadhh janaa(n) dhae charan shhuhi aadteenee hoeae laakheenee|| Touching the holy feet of the saints, it earlier being worth half a penny now becomes worth lacs. a(n)mrith boo(n)dh suhaavanee shhehabur shhaluk raen hoe reenee|| In the rain of love the earth gets satiated with delight. miliaa maan nimaaneeai piram piaalaa pee patheenee|| Only the humble get adorned with glory and the earth, quaffing the cup of the love of the Lord gets satiated. jo beejai soee lunai sabh ras kas bahu ra(n)g ra(n)geenee|| Amongst variegated flora, sweet and bitter tastes, and colours on earth, one reaps whatever one sows. guramukh sukh al hai masakeenee ||a|| Gurmukhs (in their humility like the earth) get fruit of delight. Maybe some enlightened gursikh can tell us about russia and the world and why no narsingh came for them. But bhai gurdas ji vara have prooved thet narsingh is not a myth. Perhaps you could tell us how science allows a decapitated head seperated from a body to fight on a battlefield. How limited is our brain? how infinate is God and gurbani? Will we start denieing the benefits of gurbani next?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

hrumph · 15 Nov 2004

Manjit Kaur on one hand you are saying that sakhis of Guru Granth Sahib ji are not all physically real - and to some extent you might be right While on the other hand you are saying that sakhis of Shahadat are real - and there you are right too but i don't really see the point of your post except for a lot of capital letters i am starting to become exhausted by yours and jarnail singh's long tyrades on subjects that people don't even feel bothered by (and subjects that are not hurting peoples sikhis as much as other more serious issues)...

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguur Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Hrumph ji, Then lets get the "serious" issues going... shall we ? Sikhi is being HURT and we must get going.... sweeping things under the carpet like charadhoor will NOT do Ji. As to my "tirades" IF they were really just tirades, they would be ignored. Thanks Jarnail Singh.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

___ · 15 Nov 2004

Sewa The Gurmat Tradition Of Selfless Service (pages 141 and 142) "Performance of sewa ( selfless service) makes the mind humble. It generates humility. For this reason whenever you go gurdwara start by doing sewa of cleaning the sangats shoes. Egotism is opposed to the name of the Lord the two do not dwell in the same place. In egotism selfless service cannot be performed and so the mind goes unfulfilled. (Sri Guru Granth Sahib p560)" "Guru Arjun Dev Ji started the sewa of cleaning the sangats shoes in the gurdwara." "The Jathedar of the kabul sangat seeing the revered Baba Budah Ji arrive asked " Baba Ji where is Guru Ji? little realising that he had left Guru Ji outside looking after the sangats shoes. Guru JI was cleaning the shoes in humility and saying the following shabad from Sri Guru Granth Sahib " The True Guru meditates on the Lord, the Primal Being. The Sat Sangat loves the True Guru. Those who join the sat sangat and serve the True Guru, the Guru unites them in the Lord's Union. This world, this universe is a terrifying ocean. On the ship of the Naam, The Guru carries us across. The sikhs of the Guru accept and obey the Lord's Will; the perfect Guru carries them across. O Lord bless me with the dust of the feet of the Guru's sikhs, that I a sinner may also be saved. Those who have such pre ordained destiny written upon their foreheads by the Lord God, come to meet Guru Nanak. The messenger of Death is beaten and driven away; we are saved in the Court of the Lord. Blessed and celebrated are the sikhs of the Guru; in His pleasure the Lord unites them in His union." (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji p1424) Baba Budah Ji returned to the sangat and said that Guru Ji was doing sewa of the sangats shoes. The whole sangat apologised to Guru Ji and asked for forgiveness. This sewa requires total humility and for that reason, is the most difficult; few are prepared to do it because most people suffer from a sense of false pride. The spiritual satisfaction of this sewa is therefore the greatest. If any individual does sewa in humility then the beneficial effect is felt sooner. The sewa of cleaning the sangats shoes is of the highest order because this can only be done with humility. Ordinary people think that this is the lowest form of sewa and it is not popular. People wander what would others think if they were seen cleaning shoes. Some mistakenly think that those cleaning shoes were perhaps being punished by the Panj Pyarey for breaking some rules of the Rehet and for that reason they do not do this type of sewa. But such sewa washes the dirt of sins from the mind. Bhai Rama Singh - In Search of The True Guru

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Rain drop · 16 Nov 2004

Arshi Ji, you appear convincing, when you show the magnitude of Karam Kand associated with Charan Dhoor. But you do not convince me when you say; it is simply, to teach Humility. I do not get convinced, when at some Gurdwara they are making packets of Charan Dhoor and place it in a box labelled " Charan Dhoor for Devotees". But I do find logic when my wife, rubs some dust on the face her ailing children. I think, a dividing line, needs to be defined. Similarly, of course Gurbani is the healer, that removes ailments. But why reject baths in Amrit Sarovar. History says, sikhs preferred death than to avoid bath at Harminder Sarovar. Sorry, if you have already discussed about these points. I find difficulty in reading long posts so I may have missed some points.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. Veer rain Drop Ji, I DONT reject "baths" per se...in the Sarovars at Amrtisar, Taran taran, Damdama sahib, Mukatsar. These SAROVARS were built by our beloved GURUS for the purpose of BATHING. BUT what i DO REJECT is the notion actively promoted by many , especially sants/baabas is that a BATH in the SAROVAR is a BATH in "AMRIT" and that is SUFFICIENT to REMOVE our PAAPS." Physical bathing in the sarovars is NOT going to remove any paaps...ONLY GURBANI and SADH SANGAT can do that...and Gurbani is amply clear that the One and ONLY AMRIT is GURBANI. I do collect the Charandhoor at the Daleej of the darbar sahib to rub on my forehead when I visit the gurdwara every morning for darshan and Matha Tek. This is akin to touching the "feet" (charan" of my GURU JI/SADH SANGAT) without actually "touching" any one person's feet !!! One action seves two purposes...I MATHA TEK to the SADH SANGAT without actually "matha teking" to any LIVING PERSON as matha tek is only for GURU JI....and i find no contradiction if your wife is rubbing that charandhoor on the mathas of your sick children who CANT go to the Gurdwra themselves.... a sort of bringing the SADH SANGAT CHARAN to them. WHAT i do find objectionable is "sale/promotion" of charandhoor/holy mud as a CURE/AMRIT/ etc in place of GURBANI. The promoton is in line with HINDUISM's Vibhutee/holy ash/ that "WASHES" all paaps etc BUT is NOT in LINE with GURBANi which says all Paath MUST be done by you if you want any benefit...simply getting hold of this charandhoor and rubbing on your forehead vibhutee style is rubbish. I hope this clarifies any doubts. Thank you. dass jarnail singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 17 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh, I don't get you. If you know that only true Gursikhs are real Sants and others are pakhandis then why do you use "sant/babas" when you talk about pakhandis? why are you misusing these words? the first baba ever came to this world is Baba Nanak Ji "Babay Tareh Chaar Chakk" and Dera Baba Nanak Gurdwara Sahib is the first Gurdwara. So please show some respect to these words. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

ManjitKaur · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhai Gurdass Ji vaar..Bishen laeyee avtar.... VERY GOOD SHABAD.....almost EVERYBODY from A to Z is LISTED... BUT what does Bhai Ji have to SAY about them ?? Does anybody evr bother to READ and UNDERSTAND ?? Every SINGLE Person/MYTH/Monster/King/Devta/god/devi etc etc listed by Bhai gurdass Ji in this SHABAD...has the following "qualities"... LUSTY, GREEDY, KAAMI, kRODHEE,NEVER VISITED SADH SANGAT, NEVER LEARNT any HUMILITY, ... ALLL ..EACH ONE...lited from VISHNU, Raam Chander Krishan, NARSINGH, etc etc etc have all these "wonderful qualities" definesd in the MOST IMPORTANT LINE in Bhai Gurdass Ji's vaar pauri above... WAH WAH WAH what wonderful ROLE MODELS for US eh ?? The BOTTOMLINE is whether Vishnu reincarnated ten times or ten thousand times...HE FAILED to conquer his greed, kaam , krodh, never gained the benefits of SADH SANGAT...absolutely as GOOD a role model as HANNIBAL in the Silence of the Lambs....in fact hannibal seems to be an ANGEL compared to these people we are supposed to respect/honour/obey/look up to ?? Come on people... BHAI GURDASS is just using all these as " Characters in the Historical Tradition of Hinduism/vedas/simrtis/puranas/ramayana/mahabharat etc etc"...HE DOES NOT CATEGORICALLY STATE " I BELIEVE IN THEM... THEY ARE GOOD PEOPLE and GOOOOOOD ROLE MODELS FOR YOU >>>>... Everyone who was a somebody in HINDU INDIA "knew" about these characters... to TEACH us..the GURUS, Bhai Gurdass Ji, the Bhatts..all had to fall back on MENTIONING THEM...in order to tell us that ALL of them are NO GOOD...NOTHING can be LEARNT from them or their actions.... That much is pretty clear. THESE SAME PEOPLE are mentioned in GURBANI....but their actions are NOT CONDEMNED as CLEARLY ...as in BHAI GURDAS Vaaran.....and that is precisely why Bhai Gurdass Vaaraan are called KUNJI ( Code Breaker) to HELP us UNDERSTAND GURBANI by making things much much clearer. I have "mentioned" Hannibal in my mail.... a lot of people have seen the Movie Silence of the Lambs....and the "point" I want to make is "22scerfe334" ( about Hannibal)...and everybody who has watched the movie will know what point i am making....BUT where DOES it say I have to BELIEVE that HANNIBAL is REAL, He LUVED, He EXISTED??? I KNOW he is just a mythical character in a mOVIE... i am just using his name to make a point because everybody knows about him..... EXACTLY why Bhai Gurdass Ji "mentioned" all those vishnus and krishan raam etc... EVERYBODY in India KNEW about these peole....and WHAT they REPRESENTED - "GODS, DEVTAS, with exceptional qualities powers avtars etc ec.... BHAI GURDASS JI and GURBANI also "mentions" them to MAKE the POINT that ONLY the WORSHIP of WAHEGURU, NAAM SIMRAN and SADH SANGAT can Save YOU.....all these people DID NOT DO any NAAM JAPP, NEVER had Sadh sangat, were not able to conquer the FIVE CHORS...etc etc...and thus are failures and not role models fro sikhs. Whereever GURBANI also MENTIONS these people, IT is NOT to PRAISe them as ROLE MODELS, to be worshipped, followed...they are mentioned to expose them as FAILURES...on the TRUE PATH to WAHEGURU. Otherwise Guur Gobind Singh Jii wont sayy so CATEGORICALLY..Raam rahim Puran Kuran anek kahen Matt ek na maniyohn...ISNT THAT INSTRUCTION clear enough ?? MATT EK NA MANIYOHN....DO NOT BELIEVE IN ANY OF THESE.I rest my case. manjit kaur

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 17 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Veer Bijla Singh Ji...what is there not to get ?? I have to use the word ......sant/baba/brahmgianai/maharaj/satguru/mahapurakh/shri 1008 ji etc etc BECAUSE these "self given titles are USED....by the very people who SHOULDNT be using them. The MOMENT they DROP the title... the problem goes away. Like "SANT" Niranjan Singh Raagi...dropped this title and began to use BHAI. PROBLEM SOLVED.....no one including myself will NEVER use the Word SANT to describe Bhai niranjan Singh ji again... ALL so called SANTS etc should FOLLOW the excellent example set by Bhai niranjan Singh Ji. Do you get me now ?? jarnail singh.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

singh1984 · 17 Nov 2004

"sant/baba/brahmgianai/maharaj/satguru/mahapurakh/shri 1008 ji etc etc BECAUSE these "self given titles are USED....by the very people who SHOULDNT be using them. " Sant jarnail singh bhindranwale used 108 to describe sant baba gurbachan singh ji bhindranwale in his barsi. If you want i can show it to you as proof. Do you know more than sant ji?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Singh · 17 Nov 2004

"Do you know more than sant ji?" That is the most IDIOTIC argument out there. When you lose a debate, always go to "are you smarter than sant ji???" I dont' agree with Sant ji on women in punj pyaaray, ragmala nor keski as a kakaar. Am I smarter than sant ji? No. Do I think I'm right despite his beliefs? Yes. If Sant Jarnail Singh used 108 in a title, it doesn't automatically make it right. Either use proper arguments or shutup.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh1949 · 18 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. 1984 ji, I may not know "more" than sant ji....BUT is sant ji absolutley RIGHT 100% on EVERYTHING ?? In that case sant ji is no more sant ji.......... BUT SATGURU JI SACHA PATSHAH. Every human is BHULLANHAAR..ONLY SATGURU is ABHUL...and if you beleive sant ji is not human.....then i definitely know more than YOU at least. I too disagree on Women in panj piayare, Raagmala not Gurbani and Keski as Kakaar......and that may make me less in your eyes....but i dont care much for that either. I loved the post on Sri 108 you have posted as "proof" of sant ji knowing everything...BUT I loved the replies even more.....especially 420-312=108. Jarnail1949

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

kaur · 18 Nov 2004

Veer Bijla Singh and Bundha Ji....very very well said...i agree with both of you. I think that we shouldn't argue anymore with mooraks .....this guy has his own philosophy about our sikh history and he has confused a lot of sikhs who reads his posts and if we argue with him...he always has his ways of giving a point which will make him as always right. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bijla Singh · 18 Nov 2004

"I may not know "more" than sant ji....BUT is sant ji absolutley RIGHT 100% on EVERYTHING ??" we are not talking about "everything". the post was on Sant Jarnail Singh Ji calling His teacher a "Sant". so now tell me if he was wrong then who do you call a Sant? Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji never called himself a "sant" and this is not a "self given" title. word "Sant" is also used for Gursikhs in Gurbani. a true Gursikh is a true Sant. if you cannot tell who a real gursikh is then i think you have a problem there. one who calls himself a sant cannot be a real sant obviously and plus you have to look at their jeevan and naam simran. Sant Attar Singh Ji was called a sant by people because of His naam simran and jeevan. tell me, was he not a sant? seems like you have a problem with this word "sant" more than the misuse of it. ""If Sant Jarnail Singh used 108 in a title, it doesn't automatically make it right."" so tell me who would you use this title for besides Guru Ji? Sant Jarnail Singh JI didn't call everyone a "sant". he used it for true gursikhs only. if you think Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji wasn't a true gursikh then prove it. true gursikhs one with Guru Ji are also sants and you can totally tell from their jeevan and naam simran. yeah I know, a brhamgyani knows who is a brahmgyani but this way I can question every single gursikh out there and say "how do you know Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was a true gursikh or how do you know Bhai Veer Singh Ji was a true Gursikh?" jeevan and naam kamayee of gursikhs clearly shows if they are sant or not. all the true gursikhs were/are true sants. Bhai Randhir Singh Ji has used "Sant" for many Gursikhs, so that doesn't make it right either or what? Bhai Sahib Ji knew who real sants were and Sant Jarnail Singh Ji knew too. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Bundha · 18 Nov 2004

Thanks Kaur Ji, The only reason why I persist (and bang my head against a wall most of the time) is that the opposing view should be put from these 'Modern Sikhs' who seem to think that everything that cannot be touched/seen/proved is a myth or that all Sants are crooks.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

_____ · 18 Nov 2004

manjit kaur ji first you stated narsingh is a MYTH, this very bold statement is conflicting with Bhai Gurdas ji vara which state they have happened thats my only point. Nor Bhai gurdas, anyone here or me has stated that we should worship any avtars or devte. so i am troubled to understand why you have bought that up which is irrelevant to your claim that narsingh was a myth. If i have given the wrong impression then i am sorry. If gurbani says anywhere that narsingh was some fairytale please show me so that i may learn and better understand. If he was a myth then did bhagat prahlad exist or is that a myth? then what about bhagat dru?

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Jasvir kaur Thind · 18 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Kaur Ji, I really loved the "argument" you put forward..... "this "moorakh" always has his ways of giving a point which will make him as always right.." I beleive NO ONE can make SUN into MOON or DAY into NIGHT no matter how much he/she "argues" or has "ways of making arguments" Just admit that you have GIVEN UP.... Read all the POSTS..they always HANDS UP with : SANT JI said SO ...Do you know more than sant ji ??..Are you calling sant ji a LIAR ??..How dare you say sant ji is lying ?? Look carefully bhen ji..THESE are the "arguments" of LOSERS and MOORAKHS..at the end when they have no more to say..they will fall back on SANT JI/threaten dire consequences/beat up people/get a jatha and go make a big noise dholian wajeh and bir rass bani.....Reminds me of tv documentary scenes of HITLERS Brigades/Lenins Red Army/Mao's Red Guards Marching... BUT i really cannot apply the above to Bijla Singh and Bundha Ji.....they have BOTH written very well and have merit.....just like gyani ji. Our esteemd readers can make their own choices..... as to "CONFUSING" some one....I think YOU are already CONFUSED and BAMBOOZLED by sant ji types and have a closed mind...no one can "confuse" you any further !!! Please GIVE some "STANDARD" to the intelligence of our readers...these are NOT small children so easily "confused" or "brainwashed". Thank You for your "confidence" in calling yourself a NON-MOORAKH. Tell me how you recognise a MOORAKH ?? Does he/she have Horns ?? jasvir - Daughter of Guru Gobind Singh Ji...and loving it.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

mrsinghsahib · 18 Nov 2004

Jarnail Singh Gyani wrote this: "SHARDHA is a very doubtful word.. everything is shrdha.. ... AANHI SHARDHA is BLIND FAITH... and the BLIND never reached anywhere. GURBANI tells us to use our AKAL to SEV the SAHIB.. that is use our intellect to UNDERSTAND the SAHIB...NOT have BLIND SHARDHA in HIM and just hope everything will be ok. ... AANHI SHARDHA is for the AANEH..not the sighhted... THOSE that have eyes yet dont see." Sorry Jarnail Singh Jee - I am a little bit confused by this - could you please clarify the role, according to your views, that Shardha has to play in Sikhi. Much obliged, GurFateh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

_____ · 18 Nov 2004

bhai rama singh was an elightened gursikh with an amazing avasta, i have had the fortune of meeting such a beautiful soul. It is from people like that who did nam kamai seva all their life who to me are the sikhs i would learn from, his take on charan door has settled the issue for me.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

Admin · 18 Nov 2004

Enough has been said on this topic now. Topic closed.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

At the charan of Gursikh pyare · 26 Nov 2004

Please allow this last post up. SANGAT`S DUST IS YOUR CURE Over time, Giani Amolak singh ji noticed that his kesh on one side of his moustache and beard where falling out. They had thinned significantly and it had become noticeable. Giani ji became quite concerned. He tried various medication, but to no avail. Giani ji decided to write a letter to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh ji. Bhai Sahib wrote back telling Giani ji that the only cure is to everyday to “Joorian De Seva” (clean the dust of the shoes of the sangat), and wipe it on that area. Bhai sahib said that dust is your medication. Soon Giani ji`s kesh returned as normal.

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

___ · 28 Nov 2004

Extract from - Gurmat Discussion Reply to question " Bhai sahib what is the difference between doing simran at home and doing simran in sangat at the Gurdwara?" (please note i have only taken out 2 lines of the answer specifically linked to the topic, if sangat wishes whole chapter please request) "One has to make a special effort to go to the gurdwara. If a person walks to the gurdwara, his feet are purified." " When a person goes to the Gurdwara then the dust of the feet of Sangat touches one's forehead. The spiritual fruit of cleaning Sangat's shoes early in the morning is great". page 367 In Search Of The True Guru - Bhai Rama Singh

Re: CharanDhoor ? ?? Use of Metaphorical language in Gurbani

mirch · 29 Nov 2004

veer jarnail singh is your mind also changed on this topic? Ample evidence from chardi kala sikhs ( Bhai Rama singh, Giani Amolak Singh) with high avasta has been given. These beloved panth rattan gursikhs not only had belief in sikhi with whole heart but put their life to it. They would serve perfect role models for us veer ji. I am sure we can learn a great deal from their jeevans and help eradicate doubt. all the best