Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Searching for Tat · 08 Nov 2004

Out of complete shock and amazement at mail on another thread. I am writing this to dispell once and for all lies that are spread against Bhai Sahib just to push the Pro-raagmala agenda. Bhai Sahib did not have a difficult death. He suffered from problems in his legs due to being in prison in a very small cell. So small that he could not straighten his legs. Otherwise, he was fine. His companion singhs who were young then, but now old. They all state he was always going to smagams. In the late years singhs would carry him, lifting him by his arms and shoulders. He sat in smagams which his hazooria covering his face, because he was often in Baaraaag. From his humility, he did not want people to see this. Bhai sahib never met baba Gurbachan singh. These stories made up by Taksalis are complete lies, and very shameful on them. No jatha singh ever puts down there jathedars. We show complete respect to them. We do question the supposed lineage, and poeple who say Sant Jarnail singh is still alive. But if we were to say their jathedars had feaces in their mouths, then there would be Uproar! So why are they saying such things baout Bhai sahib? For taksalis to make up these lies against Bhai sahib, and pump these lies into youth. This is not what Taksal is about, and not what Sant Jarnail singh is about. He would have slapped them big time! If they do not accept this, you can speak to Giani Amolak Singh, Dr Darshan Singh, and the many singhs who were with Bhai sahib. On this website there is a picture of Bhai sahib when he passed away. It was taken moments after he passed away. He is in complete Anand. I wish I look like that when I go! I cannot express the disgust I feel when I read these lies spread about any proper sikh.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Sant Ka Marag Dharam Ki Paurhi · 08 Nov 2004

I would like to say that you cannot a blame a group for this actions. This is strictly the work of an individual out to cause trouble and tensions.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

daasan daas · 09 Nov 2004

could you specify the site? I would like to see the picture and could you elaborate more on when they passed on? do you know which singhs were with him at the time. was Bhai Jeevan singh, Bhai Joginder singh(Talwara) Giani Amolak Singh, Bhai Mohinder Singh(patiala) Giani Nahar Singh, Chanee Ji Bhai Bau Mal Singh, his son, daughter, present at the this time doing his seva? and is there any written account of these puratan Gursikhs all doing sangat togther whether it be an akhand path, raensbai Naam Abhiyaass amrit vela session. If anybody knows of anything as such please could you share this with the sangata...

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 09 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. To say I am shocked to read such lies about Bhai sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji is an understatement.... on the other hand I am releived I never came across such "filth" as I am sure I wouldnt be able to stomach that. This type of behaviour is "classic" of morons who cant put across their arguments so they attack personalities in an attempt to score points...reminds me of the story of the Wolf and the Lela...when the Wolf failed to pin any blame on the lela he conveneintly started putting the blame on the lela's dead father.( tere baap ne menu galaan kadhiyan see !!) As far as I am concerned Bhai Sahib Jee is my inspiration for the reasons below: 1. He wrote more than 40 books..each one a Pricelss Gem ( Paras) that can make the reader Paras... SANT PART. 2. He spent more than a QUARTER CENTURY in the most horrible prisons for the GURU KHALSA PANTH - that is SIPAHI part. He could have easily said I am only SANT/Parchaarak and the Govt would have let him go at once. 3. He travelled all over the country doing Akhand Paaths, Akhand Keertan and spread SIKHI - Sant part . 4. He was and stll IS the ONLY person to be HONOURED by ALL the FOUR TAKHATS of Sikhism. This UNIQUE HONOUR has not been bestowed on any one else in our entre history. ( SANT SIPAHI part) 5. Bhai Sahib Jee GAVE his ALL to the PANTH instead of "taking"..NO DERAS, no Properties, NO lineages..NOTHING except his SACRIFICE and BOOKS for the coming genrations to join Sikhi... Jarnail Singh

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

singh · 09 Nov 2004

>>instead of "taking"..NO DERAS, no Properties<< Bhai Sahib may not have had a dera, although he did have a house. Or was he living in a Gurdhwara? Bhai Sahib did sacrifice just like the singhs from earlier times that we all remember everyday in ardas. Jinnah Ne Sikhi Kesa Swasa Nal Nibhahee Tina Da Dhian Dhar Ke Bolo Jee Vaheguru.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Searching for Tat · 09 Nov 2004

click on link for the picture [img]http://www.tapoban.org/pics/BSBRSJ-Charraaee.jpg[/img] as for his last moments. I will find soora article and post it. Blaming a group - this rubbish has come up on a few occasions. It always happens when people get obsessed by raagmala debate. Pro-raagmalias bring it up when all their other points fall flat.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Garja Singh Panjab · 09 Nov 2004

Searching for Tat, that was an excellent post made me cry!

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Singh · 09 Nov 2004

look at his final picture. Does it seem like he died a horrible death? The final expression on one's face at death stays on the body. If that expression doesn't say anand, I don't know what does. [img]http://www.tapoban.org/pics/Filebhaisb.JPG[/img]

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Garja Singh panjab · 09 Nov 2004

searching for tat ji. please do post a soora article. that is a humble bentee from the saadh sangat. please try and have it translated if possible for the youth, it would be of great spiritual significance to the sangat, especially the youth.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

sikh · 09 Nov 2004

it looks as if bhai sahib is having forty winks waheguru

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

S Singh · 10 Nov 2004

I agree with Searching for Tat Jee, It’s very unfortunate the immoral tactics some Singhs are using such as the lies that ‘Daas’ wrote about Bhai Sahib’s death in order to convince non-Ragmala supporters. I really wish that such people have some fear of Jamdoots because they will not be forgiven in the Dargah when they will be crushed in Jampur. May Dharam Rai have mercy on their souls.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

respect · 10 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Searching for Tat, dont get me wrong. I personally have the utmost respect for Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji Khalsa. they are a Mahapurkh. recognized by all. the only thing is that guy who posted those terrible things about Bhai Sahib, there is no proof that he is Taksali or is from the Taksal or anything. Please do not think that it was a Taksali person who posted that. It was posted on the thread on this site about BABA HARNAM SINGH JI. that guy who posted had his own individual comments and opinion. i hope he changed thru KIRPA of Maharaj. but plz do not think that Damdami Taksal or their Singhs have any of those views. I have never ever herad of that and ive discussed with some senior Taksalis about Bhai Sahib and they have the utmost respect. bhul chuk maaf karo Ji ............................................... Waheguru Gurmantar Hai Jup Homai Khoee ||

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

khalistani · 12 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! just a question who wrote stuff against bhai sahib? ive read lots of stuff on this site, but notin against bhai sahib je but it is in sant kartaar singh jes bio that bhai sahib accepted raag maala before their accesion to sach khand so, if a singh says this is wat taksal says, then its true but taksal never has said that bhai sahib je died a painful death many taksal have respect for bhai sahib je, even if they dont agree with all of their points bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 12 Nov 2004

What's the name of the book Khalistani? Who wrote it?

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

why?? · 12 Nov 2004

If taksal have respect for bhai sahib, then why write things in books which are not true? Was Sant kartaar Singhs biography actually written by Sant kartaar singh? I heard katha in Calgary on staghe where a taksali kaathakaar said these things on stage when doing katha on raagmala. The stage secretary had to tell him off. That post could have been written by anyone. Where do these stories orginate from? Everyone knows.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Singh · 12 Nov 2004

No, Sant Kartar Singh Jee's Katha was not written by Sant Jee, I read some parts of his a while back. It was written by some katha wachak. I forgot his name. Maybe someone here knows.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Bijla Singh · 12 Nov 2004

""What's the name of the book Khalistani? Who wrote it?"" I have the book but this book cannot be called "Taksali" because it was not published from Mehta. It does not say "Damdami Taksal" on it. It was written by someone who accompanied Sant Gurbachan SIngh JI and Sant Kartar Singh JI and had the responsibility of writing everything that was going on in the Jatha. Jathedar Kirpal SIngh JI wrote jeevani of Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji but it cannot be called Taksali. just like that jeevani book of Sant Kartar Singh JI cannot be called Taksali. The person who wrote the book lives in UK and I think the best thing to do would be to ask him directly. I am not sure if I have his address. Taksal has never published anything about Bhai Sahib that caused fights. it is only when people say "i heard" or "taksalis told me". but no need to get into these things. waste of time. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 13 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. This is why one should never TRUST "second hand, third hand, fourth hand..." books. 1. it gives many an opportunity to "write" but then "deny" things if anything serious does crop up...if the poison slowly and surely goes on taking its toll on those "not in the know" about the origin of this type of book...then this serves the writers and distributors..but when they are cornered they will say " i dont know" "this is not by me" etc. 2. Buy and read books that have the publishers name and address and are written by the author.( dont accept any third handaccount of katha etc) 3. PRECISELY why our GURU Sahibaans took so much trouble to WRITE GURBANI and put it in a Sroop/Bir bound and sealed. dass jarnal singh

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

khalistani · 13 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! jathedar kirpal singh je? i asked a singh je and he said that sant kartaar singh jes bio was written by giani preethum singh je, a top giani in taksal and stayed with the mukhis of taksal but taksal doesnt say tuff like baba je was a pakhandi or anything bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

singh · 14 Nov 2004

I think the book is called 13th jot of the damdami taksal sant kartar singh It really shows how the jot from Guru Gobind Singh went into baba Deep Singh and all the Taksal People lineage and how Sant Kartar Singh became the 13th Jot.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

daasan daas · 14 Nov 2004

>>instead of "taking"..NO DERAS, no Properties<< >>Bhai Sahib may not have had a dera, although he did have a house. Or was he living in a Gurdhwara?<<< Bhai Sahib's father was a High Court Judge of the state. What idea do you get from that about the family. They were very well off. Bhai Sahib studied when most boys only did 5 classes, went into agriculture or started earning lively hood in what ever trade. He went to college. When he finished graduation he was employed as a District Revenue Officer and was fluent in English (just for those who may think he lived in some underdeveloped famished country). Left his job because was against the corruption in the government. When he resigned the District Magistrate commented that the Govt. has lost a golden sparrow. Rest all is history if you have read. Otherwise I will suggest you read Jail Chitian. Father passed away. Bhai Sahib being a part of freedom movement went to jail. All the land and material possesions were confiscated and the family endured penury through all those years keeping their sikhi rehat. He was released after 16 long years came back to Narangwal (his village) straightway took to Keertan Smagams. The house was like a gurdwara where any premi gursikh could come and stay(irrespective of panthic leanings; master tara singh has been a welcome guest there), be a part of the satsang and make most of the time. The gurpurab of tenth patshah ji was always celebrated in this havelli when the gursikhs from far and near would congeregate for 7-10 days make the perfect use of their time with gurbani naam and satsangat and carry home the sweet memories though not wanting to leave. The scences described from those times are of immense bairaag. He did both. Had a house and lived in a gurdwara doing satsangat.

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Bijla Singh · 14 Nov 2004

<> provide page numbers please. The book I have has different title and does not show this thing of Jot being passed on. again, the book is not officially from Taksal. and khalistani, I wrote "Jathedar Kirpal SIngh JI wrote jeevani of Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji but it cannot be called Taksali" Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Dispelling Lies spread about Bhai sahib

Kulbir Singh · 19 Nov 2004

Few years ago a Singh told me a childish story that when Bhai Sahib departed for the next world and as he was approaching Sach Khand, the doors of Sach Khand were shut for him. When he asked why they were shut the doormen told him that since he did not read Raagmala, he would not be admitted to Sach Khand. I heard the story was laughed so much at the pitiful and pathetic intelligence of people who create such pathetic stories. They don't know what Sach Khand is and if they had done a little bit of research on Gurbani they would have known that only those Singhs who have access to Sach Khand during their lifetime can access it afterlife. Bhai Sahib used to live in Sach Khand even while living in this world. His consciousness always stayed in Sach Khand and he always stayed in the divine colours of Naam. Who could have prevented him from going to Sach Khand? Others claim that he had a very horrible death because he did not read Raagmala and then Sant Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranwalay told him to read Raagmala and only after reading Raagmala, he was able to die in peace. Again, this story is full of lies. Actually it is not only full of lies but it is 100% ficticious story. There is not even an iota of truth in this story. Bhai Sahib did not have an horrible death. Dr Trilochan Singh has written his last moments and writes how chardi kala he was when he left for Sach Khand. He was fully aware of the time of his departure. He said fateh to all Singhs and then uttered Vaheguru Vaheguru two times with Swaas Swaas and his aatma left his body with "Guru". Daas, Kulbir Singh