Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

I just feel that...

I just feel that...

Singh · 06 Nov 2004

people should stop arguing so strongly AGAINST another Jatha. I just wanted to say honestly. I have seen Mehta and have spoke to Singhs from there. I have spoke to Taksali Singhs from Toronto as well, and very low-key hidden Singhs that keep on the downlow but follow DDT fully, from B.C as well as the UK. In all my experiences with doing veechar and learning so much from Taksali Singhs, never in my whole life have I heard one Taksali Singh bashing the AKJ or making jokes, or even saying anything like "the AKJ and its principles are false, or they're doing such and such wrong." They aren't like that. Why would one Gursikh deliberately try hurting another Gursikh? If I happen to believe that Rag Mala is Bani, I wont come on a forum saying "Rag Mala is Bani and that's the truth - you guys who don't believe in Rag Mala are ridiculous, that's a joke, you're living a lie, etc." But very sadly I've heard many brothers making such statements about the Taksal, ie. "how can you even dream that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji is alive?? That's ridiculous, that's a joke, grow up and wake up." Now how does such a statement make a Taksali Singh feel? It crushes my heart. Just to see another brother saying something so hurtful, it's disturbing. It ruins my simran, which is why I don't attend to these forums often. There's no need to say such statements, so why would you say it, if you know it will hurt another Gursikh? Just to prove a point? So would we rather just try to prove ridiculous points, at the risk of hurting a son or daughter of Guru Gobind Singh Ji? It's not worth it. The best option is to spread love, not hate. Another point, majority of REAL Taksali Singhs barely even use the internet, let alone go on forums or anything. Most real Taksali Singhs are concerned with other things. These issues don't concern them. If something about the Taksal bothers you, you should arrange to meet with one of those real Singhs, in person, not behind a computer screen. Just a humble opinion - Gursikha Eko Pyaar..

Re: I just feel that...

khalsa · 06 Nov 2004

"Just to prove a point? So would we rather just try to prove ridiculous points, at the risk of hurting a son or daughter of Guru Gobind Singh Ji?" I dont see how questioning the lineage of taksal is ridiculous? Alot of people dont belive that Taksal's lineage is true. The only problem I have is when Taksali singhs claim lineage to Guru Sahib to prove any points that are conflicting with Taksal Maryada. Whenever anybody says anything thats against the views of Damdami Taksal, alot of Taksali's say "Guru Sahib started taksal, so we are right, and you are wrong" I cant even count the number of times I have seen posts stating "well akj was only started 50 years ago...and taksal was started by Guru jee"..implying that whatever marayda that Taksal has Now is the ultimate and anything else is false. well I for one dont belive it. Im sorry if i offend you but i just dont. The lineage has too many holes and too many questions for me to believe. I also belive that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji is shaheed, why should that upset you? We are all entitled to our opinion. The day I see Sant Jarnail Singh Jee in person, I will believe what Baba Takur Singh Jee says. That doesnt mean you cant keep beliving he's alive. Go ahead. Just dont get upset when you hear other people who dont belive it.

Re: I just feel that...

jss · 06 Nov 2004

khalsa veerji... i think you missed the point....you are ALLOWED to believe what you want to believe and have every right to state your belief.... i think he's just saying that we should all have enough class to at least respect the opposing beliefs and stances...you can disagree but don't put others down for disagreeing...unfortunately in some recent threads there was a lot of putting down...and i'm sort of glad that the admins let the posts go through cuz now when people look back at those threads, they can see how ridiculous some of the statements made were. We can all learn something from the experience of the last couple of days... at the end of the day...Bhai Parminder singh ji said in a katha once... that if a gursikh cannot look at another gursikh and feel his eyes welling up with tears of love for a fellow brother/sister then he hasn't truly understood gursikhi....whatever our differences are, we must remember that the the people we disagree with, they are also the sons/ daughters of the same guru, matha tek to the same guru, read the same bani, do jaap of the same gurmantar...we shouldn't let details cloud the love b/w gursikhs... we all cry about discrimination against sikhs in today's world....how can we expect anything else..when we all discriminate against each other????...when two singhs walking on a sidewalk cannot even smile at each other and wish each other fateh...how do we expect respect from others? a great mahapursh once said that the problem today is that when we listen to gurbani, read gurbani...we are very quick at putting those lines on other people...saying "yes...that's what is wrong with so and so" ...instead we need to read gurbani and say "oh..that is waht is wrong with me, my guru ji is telling ME what I have to work on"...i believe if we all use gurbani for our own self-improvement instead of using gurbani as "EVIDENCE" for arguments..only then will we experience real tabdili in our lives... waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: I just feel that...

umm · 06 Nov 2004

Sigh, Khalsa you missed the point made by Singh Ji, Singh Ji I sympathise and agree with you, what happened to 'Jo disey gursikhraa, tis niv niv laago paye jio'..

Re: I just feel that...

Singh · 06 Nov 2004

Waheguru Jee, I believe Rag Mala is Bani and Kes is a Kakaar. However, I wont go around announcing that everywhere, simply because I know people who disagree with my opinion, and may even be offended by it. Thus, rather than hurting another Gursikh, I think it's better to keep my opinion to myself. There are several other Gursikhs who do that as well, and thank God, because if there weren't, everyone would be having conflict all the time. It doesn't "upset" me Jee, because I know the truth and I believe what I believe, so other people's beliefs don't bother me. The only thing that upsets me is that other Gursikhs just say those things in the open, without considering that it could offend and hurt somebody. In Guru Ji's Bani, it says that we should not break anybody's heart. It's that simple pyaario. With regards to lineage, teek ya jee. Believe what you want, but there's no point in announcing it. I disagree with several things other groups do, but I don't have to announce it, because I don't feel the need. >>alot of Taksali's say "Guru Sahib started taksal, so we are right, and you are wrong"<< Waheguru!!! Firstly, just because Taksal was started by Guru Sahib doesn't mean it's more superior to the AKJ or any other Panthic group. That's just a difference, it doesn't mean it's better. A Gursikh is judged based on thier love. Secondly, I'm surprised I've never heard any Taksali say something like that, because I've spoke to Waheguru knows how many. Perhaps the real Taksali Singhs don't care about these things. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Veerjeeo at your feet, your brother

Re: I just feel that...

.. · 06 Nov 2004

singh does have some points, i say fools argue, a sikh carries on doin his bhagti. This wont progress us debating. if we really want to talk about issues, then what about apostacy, dating, kes cutting, western influences, the things that are really screwing the sikh panth up more than anything else at the moment? and what are we doing for that?

Re: I just feel that...

sarp jaisay · 06 Nov 2004

Dear Singh, "people should stop arguing so strongly AGAINST another Jatha.... I wont come on a forum saying "Rag Mala is Bani and that's the truth - you guys who don't believe in Rag Mala are ridiculous, that's a joke, you're living a lie, etc." But very sadly I've heard many brothers making such statements about the Taksal" I believe you are referring to a thread started by a "Taksali Singh" (khalistani) saying exactly what you have just given an example of (referring to taksali lineage instead). I think you should spread your message to fellow taksali's before coming on a forum and doing parchaar of it to others. Just a suggestion.

Re: I just feel that...

Singh · 07 Nov 2004

Thanks JSS Jee and the other Singhs for your pyaar. ek gurmukh pyare ne kiha >> if we really want to talk about issues, then what about apostacy, dating, kes cutting, western influences, the things that are really screwing the sikh panth up more than anything else at the moment? and what are we doing for that?<< I agree with this completely. You are so right. That was one reason why I posted. Being caught in group conflicts people are not focussing on the more important issues. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Jee

Re: I just feel that...

respectfully · 07 Nov 2004

Dear sarp jaisay - I found your post to be in poor taste. In your short post, you have seperated fellow Sikhs into "us" and "them" - now, this "us" and "them" phenomenon seems to be prevalent in many threads in this forum, and from individuals on both sides, but frequency does not make it any less distasteful. The RSS is doing a great job in destroying Sikh unity, we don't need to help them. I, for one, have lessened admiration for Sikhs seperating themselves into "AKJ Singhs" and "Taksali Singhs", "Fulanay Singhs" and "Thumkanay Singhs". One would hope the distinct privelage of belonging to the Khalsa Panth, the honor of belonging to Sikhi as a SIKH, would be enough. Why this need to label oneself with name-brand organizations, in the same fashion that kids today brand themselves with Nike and Adidas? respectfully, Respectfully. sarp jaisay wrote: > Dear Singh, > > "people should stop arguing so strongly AGAINST another > Jatha.... > > I wont come on a forum saying "Rag Mala is Bani and that's the > truth - you guys who don't believe in Rag Mala are ridiculous, > that's a joke, you're living a lie, etc." But very sadly I've > heard many brothers making such statements about the Taksal" > > I believe you are referring to a thread started by a "Taksali > Singh" (khalistani) saying exactly what you have just given an > example of (referring to taksali lineage instead). I think you > should spread your message to fellow taksali's before coming on > a forum and doing parchaar of it to others. Just a suggestion. >

Re: I just feel that...

Daas · 07 Nov 2004

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee kee Fateh. (The Khalsa belongs to God, Victory belongs to God.) Isn't it funny how people everyday say Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee kee Fateh , yet they're so attached to their Jathaa that they don't even know the meaning of Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee kee Fateh. The Khalsa belongs to God. There is only One God, and there is only One Khalsa. Victory belongs to God, God is Victorious, the Khalsa belongs to God so it too is Victorious. Those who wish to be part of the Khalsa, pray before the True Guru take Amrit and only seek guidance from their Guru. It is so simple, you're either in or out, yet it is so difficult. Those who take great pride in belonging to a specific Jathaa are not part of the Khalsa. They belong to that Jathaa. Those who distinguish themselves by asking other Sikhs "where did you take amrit from," are not part of the Khalsa. They belong to whomever they took amrit from. Those who seek guidance from humans rather than their Guru will obviously not be victorious. Would you call him wise who perfers donkeys over Horses??? Why would you want to be part of anything other than the Khalsa??? The Khalsa is Victorious, victory belongs to God, God is one, Khalsa is one. You see how simple it is. Then why is it so difficult for people to grasp this??? Please Khalsa Jee forgive me if I said something wrong. "Aapae Beej, Aapae hee Khaae" Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa, Vaheguru jee kee Fateh.

Re: I just feel that...

Mkhalsa · 07 Nov 2004

>>>the real Taksali Singhs don't care about these things. <<<< Exactly. I have spent some time here and there with some beloved taksali singhs, and let me tell you, they impress me. Their gursikhi is something to aspire to. But all these little kids in taksal and AKJ, acting like gangsters, thinking they are the pillar of gursikhi, when in reality their minds are full of kaam and their hearts are filled with selfishness and pride, they ruin the image of such great panthic jathebandis by bashing each other. Its unfortunate they will all grow up to be the leaders of these jathebandis and in the end lead to their demise, as we can already see happening. Singh, you may not have seen taksalis bashing akj people. But I have. There are many "taksali" kids that even to this day I have never met and do not know, but they have bashed me from when I was first interested in gursikhi, to now, only because my free thought and logic led me to the AKJ, and from there I guess I was seen as a voice for the AKJ by them (of course if this ever was true, it definitely isnt anymore). They attacked me in such horrible ways that even today many people beleive these gross and disgusting things about me. Frankly, I dont care, but because of them, I spent a good 2-3 years despising taksal and everything it stood for, because of besharam kids like them. I know I didnt help the view of AKJ much, not that I ever asked to be their representative. We have a big problem in the panth today, yes in the west kids are starting to be interested in sikhi, but what sikhi are we introducing them to when we fight like a bunch of dogs every chance we get?

Re: I just feel that...

khalistani · 08 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! HAHAHAH dont make me laugh mkhalsa, first name the singhs from taksal, ill ask metha if they actually studied there also veera ive met taksalis who are actually like sants, do bani 24/7, etc. eat little, sleep little, etc. for real im not overexagerating and when i said some people are goin around saying messed up stuff about taksal, they were like WAT??? seriously there wrong i remeber once someone started talkin bad stuff bout taksal, and about a taksali singh, and once this was showed to baba je and the singhs, and allt he singhs were like this aint good NO TAKSALIS from metha or not, likes it when u say lies like guru je didnt create taksal no taksali at aaalll likes it and taksal is a part of the khalsa if were not a part of the khalsa, wat are they, hindus? amd i need to clear on thing up i dont hate akj i got some good friends of mine who are "akj" but i dont like people who go around telling lies about taksal thas wat it dont like bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: I just feel that...

Sant Ka Marag Dharam Ki Paurhi · 08 Nov 2004

>>>Those who seek guidance from humans rather than their Guru will obviously not be victorious.<<< One thing to note here is that sants are not ordinary humans. Bhai Fauja Singh Shaheed one time asked Baba Harnam Singh to pass on a message to Guru Gobind Singh and received the reply through Baba Harnam Singh. Bhai Fauja Singh were victorious through their life. Bhai Fauja Singh Amar Rahae. Waheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fathei. Sant Ram Hai Eko||

Re: I just feel that...

rain drop · 08 Nov 2004

Certainly, Singh Ji; we should never hurt one's feelings. Gursikhs need to be respected, as a rehat and not for diplomacy. Earlier (before 1984) in Punjab, AKJ singhs used to attend Mehta programmes on the anniversary of Sant ji.

Re: I just feel that...

R Singh · 08 Nov 2004

Khalistani said.. >i got some good friends of mine who are "akj"< but everything else he has said shows his immaturity and attachment to his jatha. Who cares if you have friends in another jatha? This statement was only only made to show others that u r not narrow minded.. khalistanis writings have only shown me how much he lacks in love for gursikhs outside of DDT jatha. Maybe u should step away from the keyboard and meditate on Vaheguru.. this creates love.

Re: I just feel that...

sikh · 08 Nov 2004

mkhalsa you have summoned it up prefectly alot of youth today are very mis-directed and are more interested in outer appearances than inner wealth