Re: Khalsa Dress??
Midwestern Singh · 04 Nov 2004
maathay thilak hathh maalaa baanaa logan raam khilonaa jaanaa...
Sikh fashion?
respectfully · 05 Nov 2004
If by Bana one means wearing the 5 kakaars and a dastar - we can say with some confidence that is bana ordained by Guru ji and every Sikh should wear it or strive to wear it.
If by bana we mean some other uniform or dress, then the most we can appeal to is our own choice in wearing that clothing. You will find that 'bana' when it refers to clothing differs among different jathebandis. In short, it is clothing advocated by tradition in some groups, by military heritage in other organizations, by simplicity by yet others. For example, the bana worn by some Nihang jathebandis adopts the form of clothing worn by soldiers in around the time of Guru Gobind Singh ji; keep in mind, that non-Sikh soldiers wore similar clothing.
Moreover, when the Singhs were living in jungles in the post-Banda Singh Bahadur period, I doubt if there was much uniformity to their uniforms.
At the end of the day, clothing is simply that, clothing - it means next to nothing when it comes to adherence to Sikh principles.
Yet, it must be said, if by wearing 'bana' (whether that is the Nanaksari bana, the Taksali bana, American-Sikh bana etc.) you find it helps keep your mind from ego and aids you in these first steps of your journey in Sikhi, then by all means wear that particular fashion of clothing. Of course, this clothing doesn't need to serve a purpose for you to wear it - it's a free country - wear whatever you feel like wearing and if it happens to be Taksali bana - so be it, Nanaksari bana - so be it.
Just don't automatically assume that the brother wearing the Versace jeans, Diesel shirt and Prada shoes or the sister in the Dolce&Gabana pant-suit and Gucci heels is 'lesser' for not wearing what you think is traditional Sikh dress. That brother or sister may be leagues ahead of you in both knowledge and practice of Sikhi and may be at a point where they are as comfortable in a nihang-style chola as they are in Italian haute couture.
respectfully, Respectfully
Re: Khalsa Dress??
respectfully · 05 Nov 2004
lol - Actually, I didn't know that heels made the backside stick out - if that is the motivation for wearing heels, than that would be improper but is that true of all heels? Is that the only motivation women have for wearing heels? Being a guy, I honestly wouldn't know; I always thought they wore them in order to look taller. Funny stuff though - I had a good laugh.
However, while you may have a point with the below, you completely ignored the heart of that paragraph and chose to make a shallow, albeit funny, criticism/comment.
Wearing western clothing, even fashionable western clothing does not in any way indicate where one is in Sikhi. Likewise, the same can be said for the different types of 'bana' worn by Sikh men and women.
Dhan Gursikhi! Dhan Gursikhi! Gursikhi is dhan my friend and even 'dhan' cannot do it justice!
Dhan Gursikhi is not a stamp one puts on oneself with the clothes they choose to wear; dhan Gursikhi is, above everything else, Guru ji's kirpa and that kirpa has very little do with whether a Gursikh wears a chola made in India by Amrik or a dress shirt made in Italy by Armani.
respectfully,
Respectfully.
caa caa wrote:
> "...and Gucci heels is 'lesser' for not wearing what you think
> is traditional Sikh dress."
>
> Ofcourse not, the "sister" can't be any less. She can only be
> "higher" literally, and not in terms of sikhi.
>
> The only reason a "sister" would want to wear heels is for her
> back side to stick out, so her thinking must be way higher.
> Dhan Gursikhi!
>
Re: Khalsa Dress??
everpresentdevils · 05 Nov 2004
everpresent devil no.2 & 3 says:
we c high heels everywhere,
we c high egos here n there;
we c babas everywhere,
we c banas here n there
we c hockey fans n Toronto Blue Jays everywhere
we c emotional attachement here n there
says the everpresent girls,
we c hockey devils everywhere!!
everpresent devil no.1 says (upon hearing the whispers of Anand Sahib):
O' my eyes, the Lord has infused His light into you, do not look upon any other than the Lord;
Do not look upon any other than the Lord, He alone is worthy of beholding;
This whole world you see is the Image of the Lord, only the Image of the Lord is seen;
By Guru's grace, I understand, I see only the One Lord, there is no one except the Lord;
Says Nanak, these eyes were blind, but meeting the True Guru, they became All-seeing. [[Pauri 36]]
vjjkvjkffromtheeverprsentdevilsbusywatchingBlueJayslosingasalways!!
Re: Khalsa Dress??
respectfully · 06 Nov 2004
Beautifully stated - see Waheguru in everything, Waheguru in everything...
respectfully,
Respectfully
everpresentdevils wrote:
> everpresent devil no.2 & 3 says:
> we c high heels everywhere,
> we c high egos here n there;
> we c babas everywhere,
> we c banas here n there
> we c hockey fans n Toronto Blue Jays everywhere
> we c emotional attachement here n there
> says the everpresent girls,
> we c hockey devils everywhere!!
>
> everpresent devil no.1 says (upon hearing the whispers of Anand
> Sahib):
>
> O' my eyes, the Lord has infused His light into you, do not
> look upon any other than the Lord;
> Do not look upon any other than the Lord, He alone is worthy of
> beholding;
> This whole world you see is the Image of the Lord, only the
> Image of the Lord is seen;
> By Guru's grace, I understand, I see only the One Lord, there
> is no one except the Lord;
> Says Nanak, these eyes were blind, but meeting the True Guru,
> they became All-seeing. [[Pauri 36]]
>
> vjjkvjkffromtheeverprsentdevilsbusywatchingBlueJayslosingasalways!!
Re: Khalsa Dress??
Quest_4_The_Timeless_One · 09 Nov 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh!
This is my first time posting. Here is my view. Wearing bana is an amazing feeling. I know when i wear it i get this feeling of pride and i feel more accountable to Guru ji. I mean to wear bana all the time would be amazing and i have thought about it. Honestly it doesn't bother me about what people would think or say. I would feel proud of wearing it infront of non- sikhs and explaing to them what it means. Also aside from so many beniets there is a hidden benfeit that not many people think about.
The fact is most fashionable clothes are made in sweat shops in third world countries where child labour is a huge problem. When i did some research on this i thought about all those bana wearing sikhs. And i thought WOW by not buying fashionable clothes their doing their own part for this problem and not even realizing it. And then i thought about myself and other singhs who buy nike and stuff thinking we're not doing anything wrong. We are contributing to a huge problem without even knowing it. I'm not sure but i think we will be held accountable for our part in the next life even if we didnt know where the clothes were coming from.
Having said all this there is one problem with me wearing bana. I find myself getting a lot of respect at the gurdwara which i do not deserve. I'm not even close to a gurmukh and hankar creeps in. How do i fend this off?
Re: Khalsa Dress??
respectfully · 09 Nov 2004
Dear "idiot!",
I wonder if your correction would not have been more helpful without the sarcasm? Personally, I think sarcasm can be a great tool but your's was directed at one individual and more designed to put him/her down than anything else. Moreover, while Daas may have been technically incorrect, his/her heart was in the right place - all he/she said was success in Sikhi is due to Guru ji's kirpa - why insult him/her for saying that?
respectfully,
Respectfully