Sikh shrine defaced by bunglers
Sunday Mercury · 02 Nov 2004
Sunday, 31st October 2004 Birmingham - Midland Sikh volunteers have been accused of defacing their holiest shrine in India - by turning it into an 'ungodly and gaudy showpiece.' The unholy row erupted after devotees from a Birmingham Sikh association were chosen to carry out restoration work 8,000 miles away on the Golden Temple in Amritsar. For the last nine years teams of untrained worshippers from the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sewak Jatha in Soho Road, in Handsworth in Birmingham, have made regular trips to the Punjab to help regild the temple's renowned 200 year-old golden dome. Hundreds of Midland Sikhs donated family gold and jewel-lery which was melted down and used for the gold-leaf coating which covers the temple complex. But one of India's leading conservation architects claims the well-meaning volunteers have damaged the fragile temple, which is covered in more than 300kg of Indian gold. Gurmeet Rai warned that the 'incompetent' restoration work had jeopardised plans for the temple, known as Harimandir (Abode of God), to be granted World Heritage status. Speaking from Delhi, Mrs Rai outlined a catalogue of blunders which included devotees covering priceless wall paintings of Sikh Gurus with 'avocado green bathroom tiles and plastic stickers.' Walls which were originally made of limestone have been plastered with cement leaving the temple, which sits in the middle of a lake, susceptible to damp, she said. Mrs Rai added: "I have had several confrontations with the Birmingham Sikhs over their methods in trying to renovate such an important and delicate structure. "Original materials have been replaced by enamel paints and resins and the whole complex now has the appearance of an ungodly and gaudy showpiece. "The colours used to repaint some of the interior are more suited to a fairground carousel than our holiest shrine. "But it is difficult to lay the entire blame on the volunteers as they feel they are doing a service to their community which plays a big part in Sikhism. "But it's like asking a normal painter and decorator to renovate the Sistine Chapel." Rai's criticism was backed by Sikh historian Patwant Singh, who said: "Generosity is fine and sewa [voluntary service] is brilliant. "But it doesn't mean you can ignore principles of conservation because then it becomes an ego trip." The allegations were refuted by Guru Nanak Nishkam Sewak Jatha chairman and civil engineer Mohinder Singh who said: "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding and my conscience is clear." The Golden Temple complex was founded in the 16th century by the fifth Sikh Guru Arjun Dev. Its gold leaf and ornate artwork was completed during the reign of Punjab's Maharajah Ranjit Singh in the early 1800s.