Forum
taksal
taksal
khalistani · 28 Oct 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!
people have questioned taksal a lot on this site
they say taksal, metha, was started by sant sundar singh je khalsa
that is WRONG
taksal was clearly started by guru je
go to gurmatveechar.com literature
it has a tree of jathedars
ill also find another even more accurate taksal leinage tree
ill get that for u
but i have to find it, i got in a book from metha, but i lost the book
ill ask a singh from taskal to bring it
taksal WAS started by guru je
thas for sure
and by the way, all taksals like bhindrie taksal, the one in moga, there all under METHA taksal
the metha taksal is the headquarters for taksal
so taksal wasnt started by sant sundar singh je
they were jathedar after sant baba bishan singh je
taksal was started by guru je
heres the history
The tenth King Sri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji was at Sri Anandpur Sahib delivering His Sikhs to Sachkhand. A Gursikh who would complete his daily prayer of the Panj Granthi (a collection of prayers from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji) with love and respect made a mistake. The Gursikh was made to realise that Gurbani is an ang (limb) of Guru Ji, and making a mistake while reciting Gurbani is like hurting Guru Ji. Following this Pyare Bhai Daya Singh, along with other respected Gursikhs requested the following to Guru Ji. "Oh keeper of the poor! Bless us with the understanding of Gurbani. Without an understanding we don't whether what we do is correct or incorrect."
Satguru Ji would never return the request of a Gursikh. After all the battles where He sacrificed all His family. Upon leaving Muktsar Sahib and arriving at Sabo ki Talwandi. Guru Ji gave the following command to his Gursikhs. "Go to Dhir Mal (he was the elder brother of Sri Guru Har Rai Sahib Ji and grandson to Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji) who is at Kartarpur Sahib.
The fifth King Sri Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Ji who has compiled the Aad Granth has left room for the inclusion of the ninth Kings Bani. I will do that and bless you with the understanding of Gurbani." Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji along with 24 other Singhs were turned away by Dhir Mal with the following message. "If your Guru is the same roop (form) as the first and fifth Kings, then why doesn't he fashion Gurbani from memory?"
Guru Ji answered this taunt of Dhir Mal in the following way. The true King Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave a great honour to Guru ki Kanshi, Takhat Sri Damdama Sahib, Sabo ki Talwandi. Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh was the scribe as Guru Sahib Ji compiled Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji from his sacred tongue. There were such great blessings that Jap(u) Ji Sahib, Rehraas Sahib and Kirtan Sohila were written on the first morning. On that evening the Gursikh Sangat listened to the meanings of the completed Gurbani. The understanding of the Gurbani that was written at amrit vela (ambrosial hours of the morning) would be explained in the evening to the 48 Singhs and the rest of the Gursikh Sangat. Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji with firm faith would complete the seva of providing the paper, pens and ink. In this way within 9 months and 9 days, on the full moon of Katak, Samat 1762, till until 1763 Bikrami 23 Savan, the understanding of Gurbani was taught. With the inclusion of the ninth Kings Bani, from Ik Oa(n)kaar to At(h)arah Das Bees, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was completed. A great benevolence was done to the world.
After seeing and listening to this limitless, powerful knowledge, the Gursikh Sangat as well the atheists were astonished. By listening to Guru Sahib Ji, the Gursikh Sangat were given the opportunity to rectify their lives. The 48 Singhs gained Brahm Gianta (the knowledge of God) and were liberated while living. The Singhs reached such spiritual states that they lost all care of the world. Seeing this Satguru Ji ordered Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Ji not to lose care, but to continue in selfless service teaching others what he had learnt. Guru Ji said that he would not forget a thing even if he were to get cut piece by piece. Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji was also given this command and was told that he wouldn't forget a thing even if his head were separated from his body.
Both Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Ji and Baba Deep Singh Ji stayed with Guru Sahib Ji (when They went to Takhat Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib) teaching the understanding of Gurbani to other Gursikhs. Just before Guru Ji ascended to Sachkhand He sent Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh JI to Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar, and Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji to Takhat Sri Damdama Sahib to continue teaching the understanding of Gurbani. Damdami Taksal has been operating under the leadership of Brahm Gianis until now, and will forever more.
courtesy: www.damdamitaksal.com
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!
Re: taksal
S Singh · 29 Oct 2004
Can the admins please lock this topic. It' s just going to cause controversy for no reason. Whether Taksalis put pro-Taksali lineage arguments, or whether non-Taksalis put arguments against Taksals lineage will not make any difference. This wont solve anything. So lets just leave at that.
Re: taksal
freshy munda · 29 Oct 2004
Lets promote ekta, than worry about where taksal comes from. The essence is to jap nam and leade sikhi life. Khalistani veer quick question who is Baba mohan singh?
Re: taksal
A Singh · 29 Oct 2004
Dear Admin,
Please don't lock this thread, just monitor it carefully -this is a subject that keeps coming up again and again on other treads, let's discuss it openly here and keep it coming...
Re: taksal
Frustrated Singh · 29 Oct 2004
Whats the point of fighting over such small matters.
Re: taksal
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
I second that. Topics like taksaal is from Guru Gobind Singh/is NOT from GGS, sant jarnail singh is alive/not alive, nanksar is a sect/is not a sect etc are just divisive and serve no purpose. NO one is going to change his mindset one way or other. Just when we all finish "arguing" each other to "death !!" some one posts the same old query all over again... No offense to anyone - living or dead.
bhul chuk maaf
jarnail singh
Re: taksal
Search For Tat · 29 Oct 2004
i am happy to debate this subject with khalistani. This messageboard has a very good reputation as a spiritual board. If the admins or sangat feel this will ruin this atmosphere, then khalistani and me can find another forum to debate this subject on.
It is purely up to admins. I do not want to cause problems between AKJ and taksal youth. I think they are backbone of Panth. They need unity, as they are the ones who make the Panth strong.
Re: taksal
Frustrated Singh · 29 Oct 2004
It is purely up to admins. I do not want to cause problems between AKJ and taksal youth. I think they are backbone of Panth. They need unity, as they are the ones who make the Panth strong.
I am so fed up with these comments, every web forum, you goto always AKJ or Taksal. Why can't you ever think of the other Singhs who have no affiliations, I have never seen an AKJ or a Taksal youth and I live in a densely populated place filled with Sikhs. Get Real. Theres only one group, thats being a Sikh. I am out.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 30 Oct 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
this isnt about being taksalis or akj
its about people making lies and thinking their higher than damdami taksal mahapurshes like sant jarnail singh je
i guess u must think they lied too eh
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
Re: taksal
Niranjan Singh · 30 Oct 2004
[i]>>> i guess u must think they lied too eh[/i]
Its not that simple khalistani jee. No one is accusing Sant Jarnail Singh of lying. Just because we have differences of opinion does not mean we are insulting each other.
For example, Bhai Fauja Singh beleived that Keski was a Kakkar, but Sant Jarnail Singh believed that Kes was.
So if you (khalistani) said that Kes was a Kakkar, does that mean you are calling Fauja Singh a liar ?
No, it just means that we have differences of opinion. Learn to accept that and refrain from throwing accusations such as doubting a brahmgiani or "calling them a liar", etc.
Its just too amateurish of a reaction.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 30 Oct 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
has bhai randheer singh je in any writing said taksal wasnt started from guru je
did bhai fauja singh je??
did they?
please let me know, i dont know if they did
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
Re: taksal
gkd · 30 Oct 2004
one thing iis fo shizzle
Bhai Sahib Bhai Fauja Singh ji, and Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji, where tiight, and shared such massive love for each toher (even tho differnece of the kakkar dispute).
who are we 2 argue with each other over such meger issues....both parties still believe that wiethout kesh there is ntn.
Re: taksal
GSC · 30 Oct 2004
VJKK VJKF
I dont think this has anything to do with disputes over kakkars or anything like that, its about the massive that is thrown around by some people that DDT wasnt started by guru ji. Gyani Sant GUrbachan Singh Bhindranwale said that the lineage of DDT is from Guru Gobind Singh Ji than went down to Baba Deep Singh, to Baba Gurbaksh all the way to Sant Sundar Singh and than to Gyani Gurbahan Singh Ji. To say that he is lying is soooo disrespctful??? do u thin Sant Jarnail SIngh would be lying?????
Saying that DDT doesnt have lineage to Guru Gobind Singh Ji is sooooo disrespectful
VJKK VJKF
Re: taksal
manmukh · 30 Oct 2004
I think on AKJ websites it's easy for people to diss the Taksal, whereas most people don't dare do such things in real life.
It's about RESPECT. Lets have RESPECT for each other and RESPECT for Brahm Gianis Bachans.
>>>I do not want to cause problems between AKJ and taksal youth. I think they are backbone of Panth. They need unity, as they are the ones who make the Panth strong.<<<
Whoever said that, I agree with you Jeeo
Re: taksal
manmukh · 30 Oct 2004
I just wish we could stop fighting. When people start defending their Jatha or whatever group they support, sometimes they get extremely nasty and don't even think about how their brothers and sisters could feel about what they're saying. I mean like, deliberately saying silly comments about the Taksal or making silly threads, just to make the Taksal look bad? That's pathetic and hurtful.
Things like that turn people away from these forums, even though it's not the fault of the forum itself. I'm not sure what it is, but it should stop happening.
Re: taksal
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 30 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
It is futile and amateurish...even foolish to look for...what khalistani is looking for.
I have read over 40 books by Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji and not in a single one has he written that TAKSAL is founded by Guru Gobind Singh Ji...anyway WHY should He ?? Bhai Sahib Jee was writing about GURMATT and Sikhi and Amrit and stuff...
And so following the same argument would Bhai Gurbachan Singh Khalsa or any of the Taksalis write anywhere that Bhai Sahib bhai Randheer Singh Ji is a direct lineage from Guru Gobind Singh Ji ??? Obviously not ?? why should they ??
We can follow these leaders like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji, Bhai Gurbachan Singh Ji, Bhai Fauja Singh JI and Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji and have LOVE and RESPECT for each other instead of sticking to petty arguments like : I will scratch your back if you scratch mine ?? silly really.
The FACT is ONLY taksali books will write about Taksal being from Guru Ji...NOT a SINGLE Non-Taksali writer/historian etc has written any such thing or even Mentioned it.
Dass jarnail singh.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 30 Oct 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
ask bhai mani singh jes taksal
it was started along side with baba deep singh jes damdami taksal
i think bhai mani singh jes taksal is in amritsar right now
its not about which jatha is better
its about people not knowing wat they talking bout and making lies like taksal wasnt started by guru je
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
Re: taksal
manmukh · 30 Oct 2004
I agree 100% with khalistani.
Re: taksal
AnotherSingh · 30 Oct 2004
bsb randhir singh used to do prachaar with taksaal.
Re: taksal
Singh Santaali · 31 Oct 2004
Khalistani, you get way to emotional. Anyway, why start another debate here on this Tapoban forum, when you or anyone else has not been able to disprove my points on the Sikh Sangat forum in the following link:
http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=23&t=1035&hl=takshal&s=50f039a793314cb73654d012fb2519dc
Re: taksal
j. k. Thind · 01 Nov 2004
I have read the comments on the web site given by Singh santaali.
It is 100% TRUE the Taksalis have no proof to offer.
IT is the work of a blindfolded blind man to create web sites, linking ones self to Guru Gobind Singh and even can link to WAHEGURU... whats the harm ?? Same thing goes for books etc...the Glaring Fact si NO HISTORY BOOK says the same thing as the Taksalis...
Go ask the Bhai Mani singh taksaal is the same as JESUS asking people to go read the Bible.... The argument goes like this: Ask Jesus : WHO says you are Song Of GOD ?? Answer: The BIBLE. And WHO says the BIBLE is Word of GOD ?: Answer; JESUS.
So here we hvae bahi mani singh taksaal and sundar singhtaksaal mehta taksaal bindra etc backing each others stories....wonderful.
For a few Dollars I can hire a web writer to design a web site for ME linking me to Raam Chander of Ayudhiya/Raja janak/Dusarth/Krishan /even Guru Gobind Singh even before he was dusht daman... NO PROBLEM at all.
The BJP have been barking for the Raam mandir at the place of the bari masjid ?? Any proof..NONE except GOONDA GARDEE and majortiy rules !!!
ALL Fundamentalist use the same tactics.... Dropping famous names is a time tried tactic used by weaklings to make themselves big.... the Taksalis should argue for their maryada on its OWN MERITS....and PROVE it is according to GURBANI. GURU JI did not start any taksaal and did not give gurgadhi to any sant baba mahapurash but the KHALSA PANTH.
jk thind Daughter of Guru Gobind Singh and Massi of Singh1984.
Re: taksal
seeker · 01 Nov 2004
i am not a taksali, but i object to anyone here or anywhere indirectly saying taksalis fundamentalists. akj and taksalis have been at the forefront of the panth in the last 30 years bhau fauja singh has been called a fundamentalist too on the sanatan websites, i request the admin please do not allow posts that attack others.
If possible try to stick to the point without putting the other person down please. We are trying hard to become one why dont we let these walls break down for the sake and unity of the panth?
let khalistani believe they are from guru gobind singh, in fact all jatha samperday anyone who has taken amrit from Guru ji are from anandpur sahib so why worry about lineages? The biggest thing is acceptance of each others differences.
Its going to make our jeevans any better by stressing over issues like this.
look where sikhi started Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh, 1699, we were one with love for each other, this love and oneness bought us together, 10 000 khalsa here 50 000 there. Look as time passes, one group from the next, even jatha and taksal havent escaped the offshoots coming. We are very divided as it is, we give no encouragement to our youth, we are failing others through debates and consequences that follow. All of you know what usually happens.
Re: taksal
possible · 01 Nov 2004
a lot of those who have read many historical books say taksal only starts getting mentioned at the start of century (or something).
for this reason they say taksal was started then and not guru since no other historical document mentions them.
personally i feel that this may be the true but... i feel that the santhia school (taksal) may not have had an official name until the turn of the century (or whenever it was). i think the sangataa just knew where to go to get santhia. the preceding brahmgyanis or babajis or santjis (which ever one it was at the time ,,, my history and memory is bad) probably just had sangataa coming to them for santhia and no published material/adverts/ names of the school etc were distributed.
since printing press became available, thats probably when damdami taksal gave itself the name.
this is all probablity so all i'm saying is that it is a possibilty.
so those that discount taksal's claim cos of no historical proof should consider this and not reject those singh's claims. if you don't believe it, fine, but you dont have to slap them in the face by rejecting it.
the santhia and katha services offered are so great! the arguemnt of the origin of taksal must stop because it will have no bearing on your gurbani knowledge.
i think if taksali's just preached what the Santji's preached (gurbani, gursikhi etc) and NOT preach 'we are so and so' and 'we were started by so and so' then the panth would have more chardiaan kalaa.
if 'non taksalis' have issues with a way katha is done or gurbani is interpreted, then THESE are the points to raise. and if a 'taksali' wants to answer these points, they should be answered with gurmat reasonings and NOT with 'this is what taksal says and taksal started by guru'. just stick to the gurmat. then taksali's and all singh's (sangtaa) stay happy and in chardiakala.
there wouldn't be arguemnt, but discussions... and discussion of gurbani (guru) becomes gurbani vichaar and is something that is blessed and encouraged amongst sikhs. so says the guru.
and then everyone's kla wud be chardi and hore chardi. chardi chardi kala in the khalsa panth.
Re: taksal
AnotherSingh · 01 Nov 2004
orally passed down history is still valid. much of sikh history is passed down orally. having it passed down within a single school just means that there is less chance of a mistake happening.
Re: taksal
? · 01 Nov 2004
I agree that orally passed down history is valid. However, it shouldn't be blindly accepted. The oral history for Taksal only seems to be contained within Taksaal and nowhere else. Why is this? Also, it's not only about Taksaal not being mentioned anywhere in history, it's also about their own literature. Taksal is supposed to be a university and we know Baba Deep Singh Jee produced Saroops of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. But is there any 'taksali' literature from before the time of Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee? Since Taksal says they have the original maradyaa from the time of Guru Gobind Singh Jee AND they are a University within the panth, you'd expect them to have the greatest amount of purattan literature available. So many sikhs wrote rehitnamay, etc, did anyone in Taksaal ever do this? Or is it all just part of Damdami Taksal's oral tradition, until the time of Sant Gurbachan Singh, who produced a fair amount of literature?
Re: taksal
khalistani · 01 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
not everything is passed down in history in writing
look at our athias
as another singh je said, its a lot of history that is passed dwon orally
also
so ure comparing the likes of rss, etc. to sant giani baba jarnail singh je khalsa bhindrwale
wa wa
dont people have no more sharm any more
and singh santali
that thread was messed up
go ahead and post it here
im down to debate
just post ure arguments if u want, if not, stay of this thread
jk thind
are u saying sant je was lying or something
u need to watch wat u say
wat moorcha did u start??
sant je did enough for the panth
in ure post it sounds like ure saying that
sant je was lying or something
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
ashamed of england · 01 Nov 2004
does it really matter if taksal from guru ji time or not? hell i love taksal no matta wat its origins dont matter to me its what it gives great sikhs and service for sikhism jst like akj
Re: taksal
Singh Santaali · 02 Nov 2004
Khalistani, surely you should some reference from any puraatan sources such as Prachin Panth Prakash, Suraj Prakash, Gurbilaas Patshari Dasvee, Mehma Prakash or even Mahan Kosh?
Non of these Granths even mention the Damdami Taksal of Mehta or even Bhinderkala.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 02 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
i told u ashamed of england
its not about how much i love taksal
but i dont like our hostory being distorted and people think they know more than sant je
people try to make lies
and i dont like it
no taksali in the world likes it
we dont like people talking crap, even though something is true
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
khalistani · 02 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
i doubt it will have bhindran kalan, thats pretty recent, with the start of sant sundar singh je
they just calling them bhindranwale sant
and how do u know ure great grandpas name
do u ask ure gandpa for documents when they tell u their name??
no
u just listen to them cause they knew
if ure saying one of the taksal sants was lying about their leinage, say it
and wat about all the purataan saroops damdami taksal has
wat about the purataan saroop of dasam granth taksal has?
how do u think it got that saroop
cause its been passed dow from mukhi to mukhi
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
Babber Jatt · 02 Nov 2004
many people have puraatan suroops what does having a puraatan suroop prove? what do u mean history distorted what are you some scholar that actually did some research?
Re: taksal
Caprice Sun · 02 Nov 2004
Please consider the following story:
There were 3 singhs.
1st was a TAksali.
2nd was AKJ.
3rd didn't know what AKJ OR TAKSAL was but knew guru sahib's rehit.
Taksali Singh passed away and went to dharam khand. Dharam raj said, "you haven't done any bhagti"
The Taksali Singh said, "well but I'm a taksali. baba jarnail singh was a brahmgiani. taksal was started by guru gobind singh ji"
dharam raj said, "you haven't done any bhagti. your going back this time don't waste your time on trivial things"
The Jatha Singh passed away. He also went to dharam khand like everyone else and dharam raj said, "you haven't done any bhagti"
jatha singh said, "but i went to so many ransabiee's"
dharam raja laughed and said, "sitting in the langar hall and talking to your friends isn't considered bhagti"
Then the 3rd singh died. He also went to dharam khand. Dharam RAj got up from his seat and bowed down to the Singh. Dhram RAj said, "I am blessed to have your darshan."
The singh said nothing because he was absorbed in naam.
Dharam raj said, "you have kept guru's rehit. You have respected your guru and gave up your mind to adopt his rehit. YOu have stood up for your guru and have been blessed with bhagti. Please give me the honor of your company for a few more minutes"
So, which Singh do you think you are?
I personally want to be the third one.
Re: taksal
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
We shouldnt have a problem with t he word "fundamentalist". I would love to call myself a fundamentalist...IF ONLY I could Really FOLLOW the Fundamentalist Reahat maryada which is massive Bhagtee, paaths of so many extra banis, sarbloh so strict that it makes me "sweat" even thinking about it.... YES ...Fundamentalist is not a bad word. Only the "press" has made it out to be.....and the OPPOSITE of it that is "modern" sikhs means a GHONA MONA DHILLAR...I would RUN MILES away from such a MODERN SIKH. I may not be fully fundamentalist but I love it...and i admire those who are.
Taksalis and AKJ are real "fundamentalists" - I admire them for that. My point ( and someone else has made it above...mail by POSSIBLE JI i think ) is that the TAKSALIS should defend their MARYADA traditions on their MERIT based on Gurbani and STOP dropping names like Guru Gobind Singh ji baba deep singh Bhai mani Singh etc to BOLSTER and INFLATE their case. Everytime i accost a taksali as to WHY this ?? he will by hook or crook come to Because Guru ji/baba Ji/ deep singh ji/mani singh Ji...SAID SO (ORALLY) so thats that..YOU MUST BELIEVE ME. This is flawed argument.
The second grouse is : like what Khalsitani says: ARE YOU LYING ? Are YOU saying Jarnail singh ji is LYING ?? Sant kartar singh is LYING ?? at the drop of a hat these people come out with these arguments ?? These are NOT arguments or reasons...this is confrontation..WRONG. Why cant we LEAVE sant jarnail singh etc out of it ?? Dont we have a leg to stand on ourselves.
Dass jarnail singh
Re: taksal
gkd · 02 Nov 2004
lack of pyaar
Re: taksal
um · 02 Nov 2004
khalistani just wanted to let you know, dont worry about what these people say. Guru Jee knows the truth. Veerji I'm gona email you and tell you whats going on. Some posts arent going through. People are just biased these days, dont worry about it... The Taksal was started by Guru Jee, everyone should respect that without getting all defensive and worried.
I'll email you bro.
Re: taksal
Search For Tat · 02 Nov 2004
no-one has diised taksal, no-one has called any jathedar a liar. Khalistani - you are not answering the questions, just getting emtional. You started this topic on a previous thread. I have not even started contributing, but already your stuck. You maintain your belief that Guru Gobind Singh started Taksal with such conviction then back it up with facts!
I do wish neutrals would calm down. No one is having a scrap! We are just analysing a belief that is pushed into many youths minds to convince one group and its rehit is everything. We reject that stating that group is the same as everyone else, not higher, and not The Panth. Why have neutrals got a problem with this?
If Guru Gobind Singh started the taksal - then it would have been a momentus event, like 1699 was. Yet 1699 is mentioned in so many sources, but no mention of taksal. Baba Deep Singh and Bhai Mani singh are mentioned, but no mention of taksal. Why? If they really were jathedars, then why not mention it? After all it was a school started by Guru Ji?
Where is the Dasam Granth does it mention taksal? This was written By Guru ji, surely he would have mentioned it. He mentioned everything else.
Where in Bhai Nand lal ji rehitnamas does it mention taksal?
Where in Sooraj parkash? Panth Parkash? Gurbalias patshahi? There are so many documents? but no mention of taksal? How can this be for the only school started by Guru ji? The only place where people learn the "real katha"?
The arguments for oral tradition are so fake it is unbelievable. Oral history can be anything. Think about it. Oral history could say Guru Arjan dev ji was not tortured by Moghuls, but commited suicide. Are you going to believe it? No. We have so many real resources, many of which need greater analysis. We do not need a sikh version of what RSS are doing to Indian history. i.e. changing it to suit it own propoganda purpose.
Taksal is just another group, just like AKJ, nanaksar, SGPC, etc. If you dispute this khalistani, then stop putting out emtional blackmail about calling jathedars liars, or dissing taksal. Just present your sources of evidence.
Bhul chuk maff karne
Re: taksal
ashemed of england · 02 Nov 2004
khaistani im very sorry if i hurt your feelings, i hope waheguru makes me understand to be more considerate in future. Its just i dont like seeing singhs with bana reciting from bani and their argueing over one thing or the next, perhaps the weakness was mine bul chug maaf.
You have some great potential and youve started young, singh these debates will affect your bhagti at some point, and people will sometimes hurt you. Let the duniya say what they want they wont ever stop, once they take their eyes off bani and naam they have something to fight over, that energy they get ccould be used for positive things seva helping others doing things for the youth.
Singh truthfully these debates were around 10 years ago, it just leaves onbe side walkin away with their views the other same. Nobody will change leaving people divided. Nobody is supreme in front of the Guru be it tyaksal jatha nanaksar waheguru loves everyone. No matter how peed off you get about the lineage issue will it change someone elses view?
bul chug maaf singh i wish you the best but debates have been going on years in endless pit.
Re: taksal
.... · 02 Nov 2004
The one issue I have is the use of the word "Brahmgiani" and how this status seems to blast any logic/commen sense that people have of their own into deep space. I often hear people make completely illogocal baseless claims with the only backing being "the guy's a Brahmgianni and he said it".
Sometime ago I listened to Baba Kartar Singh's katha on Raagmala. In it he said (translating as accurately as poss) "up until today no puratan bir has been seen that does not have ragmala in it". Now I am not in the business of calling Gursikhs liars etc. but clearly this is an outright innaccuracy? Slight lack in the Brahm Gian there?
Re: taksal
Harpartap Singh · 02 Nov 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
I think the soundest post on this thread was by 'possible' Bhaji/Bhenji.
Take the gun, 'virtues' where you can and discard the rest.
Learn Santhia and Katha of Gurbani - the more the better. Damdami Taksal is a good place to learn - I know of a number of AKJ Singhs who have taken Santhia from Damdami Taksal students..
As for backing up matters of Rehat with Gurbani - this is the essence of the Maryada. From personal experience, all the Damdami Taksali's (those who are or were students of Damdami Taksal) I know personally are more than happy to expound on Gurmat principles on points of contention regarding Rehat. Why don't the 'anti's' actually read the literature produced by Damdami Taksal? i.e. 'Gurmat Rehat Maryada' - looking at this, it makes extensive reference to Gurbani for its points...
Re: taksal
A Singh · 02 Nov 2004
Dear "...."
There is no error in Baba Katar Singh's statement, plenty of visual and other evidence is available on the net let alone elsewhere on Raagmala being part of puratan birs. End of Discussion on this point.
<>
Re: taksal
Singh Santaali · 02 Nov 2004
I request the Admins please allow this post up, because my previous post was not approved.
Khalistan besides Taksal not having any references to the puraatan sources, it also has a lot of holes in its lineage. Taksal claims that Sant Sundar Singh Jee was the successor to Baba Bishan Singh Jee Muralay walay. But I don’t understand how this can be true since Baba Bishan Singh Jee Muralaywalay was the 2nd Jathadar of Dera Murala Sahib Sampradhah and NOT the 10 Jathadar of the Damdami Taksal Sampradah.
Baba Bishan Singh Jee Muralawalay was the successor of Sant Amir Singh Jee the founder of Dera Murala Sahib and NOT the successor to Sant Harnam Singh Ji Bedi (whom Taksal also falsely claims as one of its Jathadars).
Before Baba Bishan Singh Jee passed away, he made Baba Prem Singh Jee his successor and NOT Sant Sundar Singh Jee as Taksal claims. Taksal as we know it, is about a 100 years old. It was started by Sant Sundar Singh Jee. It currently has two factions, one in Mehta under the Jathadari of Sant Jernail Singh Jee Bindrawalay and the other one still in Bhinderkala under the Jathadari of Sant Mohan Singh Jee.
Khalistani, I am not attacking Taksal in any shape or form. You have to realize that not everyone is going to agree 100% with Taksal, and just because they don’t, doesn’t me they hate it, or that they are calling anyone a liar.
Re: taksal
e · 02 Nov 2004
all I have to say is, read Giani Gurdit Singhs book, Mundavni, no need to say more
Re: taksal
khalistani · 02 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
just cause they were jathedar of more than one thing dont mean that they werent jathedar of taksal too
baba deep singh je was jathedar of both nihangs AND damdami taksal
they named their succersor for each of the groups
same with sant baba bishan singh je
ive met sant mohan singh je peronally by the way, good singh
oh ya, and the reason for sant mohan singh being bhindrie taksal is this
after sant baba gurbachan singh je, sant kartar singh je were given mukhi of taksal
but then sant je knew some of his family wud fight over the jathedari
so they told sant kartar singh je not to fight and go to metha and just make ure headquarters there too
thas y the one in metha is the real taksal
and guru je didnt go writing down every little sentence they said, or everything they did
guru je DID start taksal
and this IS NOT about which is techniaclly the better jatha
its about the truth
sachiae
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
Babber Jatt · 03 Nov 2004
ok but wheres the evidence other then wat ur sayin?
Re: taksal
PD · 03 Nov 2004
VJKK VJKF
Chill Khalistani( i no who u r no need to hide it from me i go to ur school)
first of all lets get this cleared up y does it matter if taksal was or was not started by guru jee or not al that matters now is that we clear all our differences unite as one to terminated porblems facing and are in sikhiand become a better and strong force under the name of Khalsa.
Secondly, there is no need to think that taksal r the best or if AKJs r the best Guru gobind Singh Jee said every Singh and Bibi is to looked upon as equal no better or worse. so just stop making a fuse about this and ask questions that will not rise up huge debates and go on for years.
VJKK VJKF
Re: taksal
gkd · 03 Nov 2004
ppl are sad, dissing baba kartar singh ji, dissing taksaal, saying htey have holes in their lineage, i'm sure every1 here has constructed the taksaals image just so they can check it.
its not akj vs taksaal
its ffreaking idiots vs freaking idiots.
Re: taksal
futile cycle · 03 Nov 2004
Khalistani, I have been following your posts, on this forum and others.
I have a comment. I don't know if other readers have noticed this as well, but Khalistani you don't seem to have a good understanding of when someone presents facts to you. Instead of thinking about the facts logically, you seem to go back to typical close minded thinking...about how "sant jee said so" and how "everyone else is lying". How about for once you stop and think about it.
Just let go of the keyboard and think. You have been abusing the poor thing for too long. Leave it alone. Unplug it for a while. Let it cool.
It's not you against the world. If you think that taksal is a lineage from Guru Gobind Singh ji's time, it doesn't make it a fact. If you wish to believe this, go for it. Why are you so adamant on making others believe this as well? Please don't respond by saying, "people are distorting history" because the same can be said about you. Those that don't believe in the taksal lineage dating back to Guru Gobind Singh ji, are they any less of a Sikh? Will it affect their bhagti and rehit? I doubt it.
So please do yourself a favor and take a breather and give it a rest will you? Stop trying to use your useless arguments.
I have honestly been trying to see both sides of the story, but after seeing your posts I have been entirely turned off of the idea of existance of taksal's lineage and totally see no truth in it. The other side makes more sense now. So you are actually doing more damage for taksal than good by coming out of nowhere and saying " this is how it is, and everyone else is wrong".
Re: taksal
...... · 03 Nov 2004
Guru Gobind Singh started a school, which was led by Baba Deep Singh to teach sikhs how to read shudh gurbani and various other aspects of gurmat. Today that school is known as DamDami Taksal.
Re: taksal
seeker · 03 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Ji
i have full respect towards AKJ, and other Jathay in the Panth. They together collectively make up the PANTH.
A Khalsa is PURE....we cannot go around saying anything or thinking anything negative about anybody.
I have utmost respect for DDT. Its a fact that they are from GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's TIME. and i know ppl dont like it when this point is used, but yea, all the Jathedars....they stand behind truth, they wouldn't preach wrong facts to the Sangat.
By not having lineage from GURU SAHIB's time, it doesnt make any Jatha any less....AKJ is not less.....there are countless amazing GurSikhs from AKJ.
Taksal isnt going to be mentioned in Granths...before it was a mobile university....there was no major institute before...around Baba Deep Singh Ji's time...where there DDT headquarters??? no...everything was just the headquarters its was the SANTHIA, the KATHA, the KIRTAN teachings which was the Taksal....Taksal wasn't anything separate from the PANTH..it wasn't even recognized as a diff Jatha....
over time, certain Jathedars of DDT settled at certain Gurdwaray to do Parchar and to continue the teaching GURMAT. then the following Jathedars did the same...over time headquarters you can say were made.
basically it was a Gurdwara where Taksal was centered.
even today, Taksal has a big school in Anandpur Sahib too....where approx 400 GurSikhs are being trained, there are several Gurdwaray around Punjab too where students are being taught.
over time as other Jathay formed, their views were diff....and Taksal became noticed as a separate university with sepearte beliefs cause the other Jathay had diff beliefs. (which arent wrong)
my point is...Taksal can be proven that its that old. they have handwritten Saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji, written by Baba Deep Singh Ji and other Singhs after them too...they are maintained there.
othery Samparda such as Rara Sahib, Nihang Singhs keep close with DDT cause they have lineage from Guru Sahib's time too...
it doesnt make Taksal better than other Jathay....but benti to others....pllease please do not say "Taksal is not from Guru Ji's time"
it hurts those who have respect and Sharda for Taksal...i didnt want to post....but it just hurts when i read posts again and again.
i could be wrong Sat Sangat Jeeo....but please lets not talk about such issues.
its Guru Sahib's Panth....in it is DDT, AKJ, others...and guess what...the PANTH is from GURU JI's time!! :)
thast all the faith you need.....Taksal is the Panth....AKJ is the Panth....Panth is the GURU's....Panth is Akaal Purkhs....end of story...no fighting, no arguing, no debates...
less talk....more Veechar of Bani, of Gurmat.....
i apologies for any mistakes..
Re: taksal
erm... · 03 Nov 2004
wot happened to guru ka sikh?? ppl are so stuck in , oh im an AKJ and im a taksali, bt wot about guru??these groups are man made...they will end...
Re: taksal
Search For Tat · 03 Nov 2004
Considering khalistani and fellow hardcore taksalis have asked for this debate, you have completely failed to present any evidence.
This has always happened when this debate occurs. There is no evidence to back up your claim. Only "we say so, if you do not accept then you are dissing or disrepecting taksal."
In this debate you have called us liars, sant ke nindaks, taksal dissers, and everything else. We have not fallen into provocation and just asked the key question which you have no answer for. Instead you have dodged, and just made emotional side comments. No-one has put down taksal, and this is not akj vs taksal. This was clear from the beginning.
It is about you guys spreading false propoganda into youth. Now khalistani either put forward clear evidence, or accept your mistake, and lets all move on. Stop this falseness.
also GKD, read the debate, and do not make silly comments of us fighting against each other. This is a clear debate according to Gurmat. We all agreed at the beginning the AKJ and taksal are the spine of the Panth and need to stick together. No one is fighting! Just asking them to back up what they say. Chill dude!
Re: taksal
A Singh · 03 Nov 2004
Mundavani is a book full of propaganda by the likes of Gyani Ditt Singh -before someone comes back with a string of 'modern' references about how he was a pioneer in the Singh Sabha movement and what not, have a closer look at some of the ideals he preached following on from his "Gulab Dasia" background, including amongst others caste restrictions to Gurdwara Services for so-called "lower castes", despite himself being from such a background.
Mundavani and others like it are not but the "Teja Singh Bhasauria" philosophy of what doesn't fit nicely into my blinkered vision we will cut away no matter what 'beadbi' occurs.
Re: taksal
Singh · 03 Nov 2004
I am a more or less neutral observer of this debate and decided that there was one fool-proof method of seeing if Taskal was a puraatan jathebandi.
Mahan Kosh is the most comprehensive encyclopaedia on Sikhism, with every jathebandi covered, including Nihang, Nirmala, Udasi, Namdhari, and even some Sant Deras. It is a book from the early part of the 1900s. I looked up Damdami Taksal and Taksal. No mention of any Damdami Taksal can be found. Taksal is defined as a generic place of learning (a schol) or a mint to make coins.
If this was such a puraatan jatha, why wouldn't it be covered in something as detailed as Mahan Kosh?
Re: taksal
khalistani · 03 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
can anyone give me any proof it wasnt started by guru je???
and as i said
guru je didnt go writing down every little thing
and taksal wasnt started as a jatha, just as a school
for learning santhia, gurbani ucharaan, gatka, etc.
thas wat taksal was started as
but as jathas just popped out of nowhere, taksal stood behind its maryada, so now someone who follows taksali maryada is a "taksali"
but taksal is actually a school
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
khalistani · 03 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
by the way ask rara sahib as well
the likes of sant attar singh je, sant ishar singh je, were all very close wit taksal
theyll also back up taksal on this
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
khalistani · 03 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
and ive already shown how it is connected to guru je
lookat gurmatveechars literature
it will show u the line of mukhis
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
Singh · 03 Nov 2004
You miss the point khalistani. No one has to proove it WASN'T started by Guru Sahib, you have to proove it WAS.
Mahan Kosh mentions nothing. And if it was indeed a school started by Guru Sahib, it would have been known, wouldn't it? I mean, if little sant deras like that of Baba Narayan Singh and others get a mention, why wouldn't the school started by Guru Sahib be listed?
Also, Taksali uchaaran also shows it is not puraatan. A lot of places, a "ha-ha" is to be pronounced as a kunna. For example, Zafarnama is written "Zafarnameh", but we all pronounce the ha-ha as a kunna. This is because in Persian, the ha-ha gets prounounced as a kunna in certain cases and this rule also applies in Gurmukhi for some words. But for all other words like Dargah, Choudaah (14), etc. Taksali pronunciation is Dargeh and Choudeh, which is wrong. If it was a puraatan Jatha with puraatan vidiya, it would know this.
Same with Sh and S. Old Punjabi didn't have the bindis at the feet and the reader has to know when to put them in, just like in Persian, Sanskrit, etc. For example, Shah Mohammed wrote a vaar on the battle between English and Singhs. He writes his name in each verse as "Saah Mohammadaa" but we all know it is pronounced "Shah". So how about Shabad? or Sharam? Why don't these get prounounced this way in Taksali Ucharan? These are things that are known by old Singhs who took Santhya from different deras and gyanis, but why not Taksal?
Even the Taksali Rehras has changed. I have looked at old gutkaas printed by Bhindar Kalan and those start Rehraas Sahib at "Dukh Daroo", but modern gutkas by Jatha Bhindran start at "har jug jug". Why would Rehras change??
Jatha Bhindran is for sure an amazing Jatha. But it is not from the times of Guru Sahib. Why the insecurity over this? It's not mentioned anywhere, until after Sant Sundar Singh. Why?
This debate cannot be won by saying "well X BAba jee says so!!!" Because that's not proof. And just showing a lineage also isn't proof. Back up the lineage with sources. I could make up a lineage for myself going back to Bhai Taru Singh, but it wouldn't hold water if I couldn't proove it.
Please, proove to me that Taksal is puraatan. And don't go on about how I'm challenging Brahmgyanis, or I'm going to hell. Just show me it's puraatan.
Re: taksal
(((:))) · 03 Nov 2004
having numerous schools in different places proves nothing. Sikh missionary teaches more youth katha than DT. It has over 100 schools in punjab, with almost 2000 students. It is now building a university of Gurbani in Chandigarh on a 40 acre plot.
Khalistani admit your argument is not fact and has no basis.
As far a mobile university. If that is the case then Sant Singh Maskeen must be a mobile university? Or is he a sampardaya? Maybe in 50 years, people will say he was 15th or 16th Jathedars of someother group?
Re: taksal
! · 03 Nov 2004
Rara Sahib was once just a Dera, and the old books like Roohani Sandesh and Gumat Rehit Maryada by Rara Sahib do not mention any lineage. All of a sudden Rara Sahib is now linked with Bhai Daya Singh!
Why can't a dera just stay a dera? Like Baba Harnam Singh Rampur Kehray Valay. Next thing you know, it'll be linked to Bhai Dharam Singh or something.
If these lineages are true, then they should be mentioned in some history or some puratan text.
Re: taksal
Singh Santaali · 03 Nov 2004
Khalistani, when I proved that Baba Bishan Singh Jee was not part of the Damdami Taksal but a part of the Murala Sahib Sampradah, and that his true and historical successor was Baba Prem Singh Jee and not Sant Sundar Singh Jee, NOW you are claiming that Baba Bishan Singh Jee was the Jathadar of ‘two’ separate Sampradahs! How can this be? Historically, no one has been the Jathadar of two separate Sampradahs, but all of a sudden all the Sants associated with the Damdami Taksal prior to Sant Sundar Singh jee are now part of two separate Sampradahs? Wow, I guess DDT Sants are an historical exception (sarcasm).
You mentioned Baba Deep Singh Jee being the Jathadar of two separate Sampradahs. That is not accurate either. To begin with, back then during the times of Baba Deep Singh Jee Sikhs were not divided into Sampradahs. Sikhs were divided into 12 Misls. Religiously, they were not different from one another. The Shaheed or Nihang Misl was one of the 12 Misls, and Baba Deep Singh jee was the Jathadar of it. The Shaheed Misl was NOT a Sampradah but a Misl.
The Taksal that Baba Deep Singh Jee ran was a school, and not a ‘Sampradah’ like the DDT of Mehta. Furthermore, that Taksal is known to have died off to the last man during the Jathadari of Baba Gurbaksh Singh Jee during the invasion of Abdali. No one was left to pass on the Jathadari.
'seeker' Jee, Sant Sundar Singh Jee was the originator of the Damdami Taksal. Is it any wonder that Taksal has no historical reference to back up its claim to lineage? It has no reference from the puraatan sources such as Prachin Panth Prakash, Suraj Prakash, Gurbilaas Patshari Dasvee, Mehma Prakash or even Mahan Kosh.
Re: taksal
4ever · 03 Nov 2004
I always thought taksal was statred by Guru Sahib, but have done no research on the topic so cannot argue for or against it. One thing which is for sure is that its older than the AKJ which has only been around since a few years back, and is an entirely modern sect.
Re: taksal
S. Singh · 03 Nov 2004
4ever Jee, the AKJ has been around since the Singh Sabha movment. They were part of the Singh Sabha movment. Read Ranglay Sajjan, alot of the Gursikhs who were Sathis of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee mentioned in that book are from the Singh Sabha period. In other words, they were contemporaries of Sant Baba Sunder Singh Jee.
Re: taksal
ddt · 03 Nov 2004
Guru Jee knows the truth. Thats all that matters to me.
Guru Jee knows the truth...
Re: taksal
khalistani · 03 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
proof
how does taksal have soooo many shastars of baba deep singh e, a purartaan saroop of baba deep singh jes hand written dasam granth and many many saroops of guru je
how do they have sooo many
u think its a coincindence
but now someones prob gonna say it was a conspiracy by the bhindranwale sants to make it look like taksal is made by guru je'
and taksal is a SCHOOL of bani
thas wat it does
teach u bani, gatka, etc.
y wud guru je write the name of a school in dasam granth or something
they wrote about god, and the maryada, etc.
and baba deep singh je was still leader of 2 things, nihangs and taksal
they were still two groups
and they appointed a different leader for each of them
and do u have any proof that taksal died off at baba gurbaksh singh je?
do u have any proof at all
u keep on asking me for some, but ure not giving any birth certificates either
if u in toronto it wud be best for u to ask singhs like singh sahib je, ex malton granthi
but if u dont wanna, keep on posting
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
seeker · 03 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
wow...ppl cant just stop eh.....saying "i proved this...i proved that...i proved Taksal is not from Guru Ji's time...i proved Sant Bishan Singh Ji was not DDT's Jathedar..."
plzz....stop it...you didnt prove anything...go stand beside Baba Takhur Singh Ji and say that. that is a DIRECT contradiction of what is said in Sant Jarnail Singh Ji's Katha. I'm not saying you have to believe everything Taksal says. You can have your own views. But NOBODYYY is ganna beleive you when you contradict what Sant Jarnail Singh Ji and Sant Kartar Singh Ji said. If you want i can give you an audio sample recordings of them explaining how DDT was originated.
what good will arise when you make these false and useless, & hurtful assumptions on other Jathay??? Waheguru.
DDT is not higher than AKJ and vise versa. to make a Jathay look good or to raise its respect...let's make the Jeevan of each person associated with that Jatha better. Let's not put other Jathay down and tell them their history is wrong. plzzzzz this is really hurting...ppl dont realize how much it hurts when you say "DDT isnt from Guru Sahib, Sant Ji only says that cause theyre Jathedar of DDT...I proved this...i proved that..."
thats not ganna do any good...
if you care about the feelings of other GurSikhs...plz stop this nonsense. dont make assumptions and say its PROOF.
Re: taksal
Time for Conclusion · 03 Nov 2004
veer ji akj is not a sect, otherwise every group is! It is Gurmat organisation just like Taksal and many others.
Age is of no real meaning, it is Asools and principles. Both of them have had high Asools. They are the same. But one does not make up stories to get people to follow its maryada. AKJ clearly accepts it started 100 years ago, but follows Praatan Gurmat Rehit. The other also follows Gurmat rehit, but has created stories making it something it is not. No evidence has ever been submitted to its lineage. The argument has been lost overwhelmingly.
Khalistani and co now need to stop propogating these falsehoods. Otherwise justify them. As they have not been able to. The Gurmat solution is they go back to other taksali youth and ask them to stop aswell. That would be a real show of True Khalsa character.
4ever wrote:
> I always thought taksal was statred by Guru Sahib, but have
> done no research on the topic so cannot argue for or against
> it. One thing which is for sure is that its older than the AKJ
> which has only been around since a few years back, and is an
> entirely modern sect.
Re: taksal
wat a waste of time · 03 Nov 2004
who CARES if it is "original" or not it seems like a bunch of people use this so called lineage to always prove their point on controversial issues. is that all anyone these days falls back on? how SAD!
my bhram gyani was wiser than your, his words are true blah blah blah that is why you should do what WE say.
lets totally ignore that fact on building a PERSONAL JEEVAN and getting answer my GURU JI HIMSELF rather than take what someperson said whom we have never met and all we know abt them is stories by their CLOSE ASSOCIATES
even if taksaal was original do you ppl think that the original maryada is still followed? I THINK NOT!
again stop trying to prove the validity of your viewpoints with half baked evidence and hearsay and get answers from GURU JI himself
these type of discussions keep going around and around winding up at the same arguement my JATHEDAR/BABA/SAINT said it was so..so there can be no other way
GROW UP and get outta your little box that you have placed your self in
MAKE YOUR OWN JEEVAN BY DOING YOUR OWN SIMRAN AND STOP WASTING YOUR TIME ON PHORUM TRYING TO PROVE THAT YOU ARE ORIGINAL AND EVERYONE ELSE NEEDS TO BE JUST LIKE YOU WITHOUT ANY HARD EVIDENCE RELYING ON WHAT YOU THINK OR HEARD IS RITE
GET OVER YOUR FALSE EGO. NO ONE CARES WHO YOU THINK YOU ARE!
p.s. sorry if i sound angry but these kinda talks get no one anywhere and just create animosity between Gursikhs which is something we could really do without. everyone just cool it and make your own chardikala and let Guru Ji tell you himself.
Re: taksal
sarp jaisay · 03 Nov 2004
4ever ji, regardless of whether or not the AKJ has been around for ever doesn't hold any importance. Khalsa who is a naam abhiyaasi and keeps full Khalsa Rehit can not be a part of a sect, so please don't trash Guru Sahib's Singh's and Singhni's by calling these Gursikh's a part of a sect.
Here is Taksal fighting to hold on to a story that it dates back to the times of Guru Gobind Singh ji because the only thing their popularity is riding on is this "fact" alone. These people have produced a pretty little lineage which means nothing because there is no proof of it. The names of the Gursikh's in that lineage have been heard of before they were amazing Gursikh's, but that doesn't mean you can just incorporate them into a lineage and then point everyone to go read that lineage as proof of their story. Any one with half a brain would know that that isn't sufficient evidence. There has actually been sufficient evidence against the existance of this lineage.
The Akhand Kirtani Jatha, I don't believe has ever argued their "lineage" (because there is none) or debated about when the "kirtani jatha" was formed. I have seen that serious "members" of this jatha are solely concerned about holding onto Rehit that was started by Guru Sahib themselves, and not by any kind of lineage.
Ideally, this is what we should all be striving to do, keeping the Khalsa Rehit we have been blessed with. That is the best lineage you can think of, Gursikh's passing on the message generation after generation, Rehit and Amrit Naam being passed on through Amrit Sinchaar's to new Gursikh's and those Gursikh's doing sangat with the older ones, learning more and then again passing Rehit and Amrit naam on to new abhilakhee's...proof of this "lineage" is the presence today of Naam abhyaasi, Sarblohi Khalsa, tyaar bar tyaar with all of their kakaars and Bana fighting to maintain Rehit's of the Khalsa.
Deleting important Khalsa rehits is not maintaining what we were blessed with by Guru Sahib. I am still amazed to see why these same people would argue to be called the successors of a lineage started by Guru Sahib after having done so much damage. One thing that gets me the most is the parchaar done to young taksali's about how they shouldn't use their matt/logic too much because they aren't brahmgiani's and what brahmgiani's say is the final truth, I think this is a reason people like khalistani keep on saying "are you questioning a brahmgiani and calling them a liar??" it's not his fault. that is just their method of parchaar done by taksal so when a rehit is deleted none of their students will question it. kinda like turning them into zombies.
Re: taksal
get it right! · 03 Nov 2004
khalistani,
I'm not sure what puraatan birs and shastar Taksal have. Where are they kept?
But even if they do, collectors like Suresh Bhalla and hundreds of others have saroops and shastar. Does that link them to Guru Sahib also?
Re: taksal
to answer · 03 Nov 2004
so far these are the facts:
Proof Against Taksali Being started by Guru Sahib:
-Taksal isn't mentioned anywhere in any old source. Not even in the early 1900s in Mahan Kosh (which has a mention of every major Jatha) is Taksal mentioned.
-Baba Bishan Singh's line is different than Taksal's
-Taksal's uchaaran is not puraatan.
-Rehraas of Jatha Bhindran has changed over the years.
Proof for Taksalbeing started by Guru Sahib:
-they have many puratan shastar and birs.
Is there any other proof out there?
Re: taksal
Bijla Singh · 04 Nov 2004
I do not want to argue whether Taksal was started by Guru Ji or not but just want to clear some things up.
"Taksal isn't mentioned anywhere in any old source."
Until Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji there were always less than 20 Sikhs in the Jatha. So I do not think any granth would mention anything about a group that has only some 20 people. no old granth has mentioned Baba Deep Singh Ji teaching Gurbani and Gatka at Damdama Sahib. does it mean Baba Ji never taught anything there? how many puratan granths mention Baba Ji writing four old saroops? Those four saroops still exist. how many puratan granths mention Bhai Gurbakash Singh Ji (Raam Kaur Ji) doing katha at Darbar Sahib? there are many things but just because something is not mentioned doesn't mean it is not true. no puratan granths mention who, when and how raag maala was added after Gurbani. I can say I respect AKJ but their argument is just a plain lie. and there is a big flaw in it. not a good way to argue.
"Not even in the early 1900s in Mahan Kosh (which has a mention of every major Jatha) is Taksal mentioned."
so Mahaan Kosh is complete? many things about Sikhi are missing from it. should I say everything Mahaan Kosh includes is true and everything it doesn't include is not true.
"Baba Bishan Singh's line is different than Taksal's"
good argument. Taksal or Taksalis must answer this one. I look forward to it.
"Taksal's uchaaran is not puraatan"
which one do you call puratan? do you know puratan uchaaran? if not then how do you know what is puratan? if yes then where did you learn it and from who? any school?
"Rehraas of Jatha Bhindran has changed over the years"
I have noticed few changes in Bani as far as grammar is concerned. These changes were made by checking Baba Deep Singh Ji's Gutka Sahib which is still at Damdama Sahib. Rehat has changed at Akaal Takhat Sahib over the years so it wasn't built by Guru Ji. right? not a good argument.
As far as I know Guru Ji told Baba Deep Singh Ji to teach Gurbani at Damdama Sahib so Baba Ji stayed. later on other gursikhs took this seva and as more people came in it took the form of a school. Sant Kartar Singh Ji decided to build a place for students to stay because it was hard to handle 150 or more students and go from place to place.
Argue with good reasoning. both sides. think why puratan granths do not mention this school. just a note, puratan granths mention many things that are not true, what about that? best way would be to trace back the linage. Taksal should provide this info.
avoid attacks. if Taksalis could provide the info it would enlighten everyone. I am sure everyone respects Taksal and Shaheed Gursikhs who came from Taksal. no one means any disrespect. keep the topic strictly to the linage because some people are not doing that. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: taksal
harpreet singh · 04 Nov 2004
"Bijla Singh" no offence to 'khalistani' but u did alot better job than he did. Your information made a lot more sense. Everything was really well put, you didnt put anyone down, good job still.
Re: taksal
to answer · 04 Nov 2004
Bijla Singh,
Your post lacks any research whatsoever. Guru Sahib having taught Baba Deep Singh and him having taught other Gursikhs after that is mentioned In Gurbilas P: 10 by Bhai Sukha Singh on p. 488. It talks about this being a place of learning in Gurbilas P: 6 as well. Rattan Singh Bhangoo also mentions this as a place of learning and Singhs being taught there. So there are lots of sources.
Bhai Ram Kaur Ji doing Katha is also something you can find written in old texts. Gurbilas P:10 mentions this fact as does Kavi Santokh Singh.
Although this isn’t about Ragmala, no source writes how things like “jit dar lakh muhamadaa†and “rattanmala†were added either. But they were still removed by the Panth. Unless you want to start reading them again…
But here’s my most important point: [b] Mahan Kosh mentions some of the Singhs in the Taksal lineage, but doesn’t call them heads of any “Damdami Taksalâ€. Take the example of Bhai Sant Singh ji. He is called the fifth head of Taksal. He is found in Mahan Kosh but just as a respected gyani. If he were the head of an institution started by Guru Sahib, you would find that listed wouldn’t you? And furthermore, Kavi Santokh Singh, it says, was a student of Bhai Sant Singh. So I guess he was a Taksali eh? Funny how he wrote that Ragmala isn’t bani!! [/b]
This “lineage†is a bunch of names strung together. IF there was a Damdami Taksal from Guru Sahib’s time, it would be mentioned that these Singhs were the head in Mahan Kosh. But it is not found ANYWHERE. Baba Deep Singh is mentioned as the head of Misal Shaheedan (but NOT of anything called Damdami Taksal). Baba Gurbaksh Singh is also listed but only as a Shahid and having received amrit from Bhai Mani Singh.
Taksali Ucharan: Do you even bother reading posts??? The ucharan argument is presented in earlier posts like Sh vs. S and Dargeh vs. Dargah. Also, if Taksal has vidya from Guru Sahib, why don’t they know and teach Gurbani Grammar/Viaakran?
Rehraas Changes: if this were a puraatan Jatha from Guru Sahib’s time, that has come with an unbroken lineage, how could they change Rehraas? How could it have gotten wrong? If Rehraas had to be changed, then other rehits too could easily be changed in Taksal. How could an unbroken lineage have allowed Rehraas to change and then change it back later? It makes no sense. Your Akal Takhat analogy works AGAINST your argument. No one is claiming Akal Takhat maryada has an unbroken link to Guru Sahib. It has many breakages and pollutions in it. But still we don't doubt Guru Sahib created it. In the same way, Guru Sahib did give vidiya and create Gyanis, but the "Damdami Taksal" is not directly linked to it. It has many breakages in it as well.
Let me put this clearly: DDT is a good Jatha. But it does not have an unbroken link to Guru Sahib. It is relatively new. Guru Sahib did teach Singhs at Damdama Sahib and there was a school there, but to claim that the present DDT has a link to it is misguided.
Re: taksal
umm · 04 Nov 2004
DDT is not a jatha. It's a school.
Jatha Bhindra is a jatha.
DDT is a school. AKJ's can learn from DDT because it's a school.
Re: taksal
Bijla Singh · 04 Nov 2004
"to answer"
thanks for the info. will look into that but purpose of my post was not to prove that Taksal comes from Guru Ji. I actually wrote that Taksal or Taksalis should provide the info to enlighten everyone on this topic.
regarding ucharan, Gurbani has many meanings which means different ucharans give different meanings. Bhai Veer Singh Ji's work is a good example. and Kavi Ji had no idea abt raag maala. no research and no reasoning is provided. and kartarpuri bir sahib does not have anything after raag maala unless you can provide the picture. bhai banno ji's bir sahib does but still raag maala comes before rattan maala and other kachi bani. anyways, don't wanna argue on anything like that. I have firm belief on this one. you keep yours.
thanks anyways. and last question for you. what happened to the school of Damdama Sahib then? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: taksal
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 04 Nov 2004
KANSHI - the Taksaal of SANSKRIT..... the DDT concept seesm to be copied from this.
The story goes that Guuru Gobind Singh ji sent some SINGHS to KANSHI to learn SANSKRIT ( an out and out lie because Guru Ji would KNOW beter sanskrit...the earlier Guurs have written SANSKRIT in Gurbani as well)...and they WERE REJECTED by the Brahmins as SHUDAARS....and so the story goes that GURU JI then Sent the Singhs back DISGUISED as Brahmins ( now they make our GURU JI a CHEAT and a LIAR DECEPTOR etc). Apparently these singhs came back as sanskrti PANDITS....
This story as is atall tale as far as i am concerned...but thepoint i am making is :
There is ONLY ONE KANSHI....from time immemeroial..IF you wanted to learn sanskrti you WENT to KANSHI...
BUT in our case there is NOTHING at DAMDAMA SAHIB.....the Taksaal established there as well as the "wur" blessing given by Guur Ji that whoever begins his education at Damdama Sahib will be blessed with a very good education... is NOT there but at other places...
WHY ?? Because of the simple reason that Damdama sahib is a TAKHAT and Historical gurdwara and Officially under the control of SGPC/Akal Takhat ( the Guru Khalsa Panth...and therefore follows its SRMaryada...)
So the Jatha taksalis moved out ?? to have their own place to have their own versions of maryada ?? perhaps. ALL the PURATAN sroops, gutkas etc BELONG to TAKHAT DAMDAMA as that was started by Baba deep Singh Ji and therefore should be there...but these sroops are in Mehta Parkash ?? The FOUR SAROOPS written by Baba deep Singh Ji were to be sent to the FOUR TAKHATS..... what happened and how did all four end up in DDT Mehta...surely ONE msut be in takhat damdama sahib ??
more questions but no answers ??
jarnail singh
Re: taksal
weird · 04 Nov 2004
is this about one side saying come and learn gurbani from us we r the lineage , the other side saying you have no lineage? now whats the big fuss about a lineage if all you wanna do is leanr bani the right way?
spend your time and energy for saving the panth.
Re: taksal
(((:>>>>> · 04 Nov 2004
The argument presented by Bijli singh about the Taksal only having 20 singhs is well written, but does not make sense.
1st: how do you know this? Another story?
2nd: How come individual singhs have been mentioned, but a 20 Singh jatha started by Guru Ji is not mentioned? Boota Singh, Garja Singh, Shabaz Singh, Shebeg Singh, Bhai Taru Singh, and many more. Boota Singh/Garja singh`s 2 member jatha got a mention, why not 20 chardi kala singhs? Some misls were very small aswell, but they were all mentioned.
Clearly as everyone has concluded including Bijli singh. There is no evidence of Taksal lineage back to Guru ji. Clearly some clever person has just picked famous names at random, and created a lineage to push his group agenda.
Also I have heard from Uk nihangs, that a few of these jathedars were not even Amritdharis, but nirmalas. If this is true, then how can non-amritdharis become head of the Taksal. Also if they were not Amritdhari, then how is it an unbroken lineage of Pure Rehit? How can a non-Amritdhari give Amrit to others?
Re: taksal
A Singh · 04 Nov 2004
Gyani Jee,
The Kanshi story cannot be dismissed so easily as a fairy tale. Yes the Gurus knew Sanskrit, however they do had teachers from whom they learnt.
The whole process of translating ancients texts and further expanding upon them begun with Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib and was propagated in full by Guru Gobing Singh (as we now find in his writings), this along with many other initiatives was a drive by Guru Sahib to push for the Singhs to be master of both Shaster and Shastra.
The notion of seeking Brahmins from Kanshi to teach these fives Sikhs was to (a) test them and (b) prove that even a 'sudra' can be a man of great learning.
In the end, when they refused (as Guru Sahib had suspected all along) he outlined his prophercy, that "my Sikhs will learn Sanskrit and your future generations will come to learn from them". I have seen this for myself in pictures of the Nirmala Hospital and Ashram in Patiala, where Brahmin students are all taught by Sikh Nirmalas (many of whom, contrary to what the UK Nihangs may preach, are nowadays Amritdhari) and are also required to take part in the Sangat where many can be observed doing seva and learning Gurbani. It actually looked as if the Brahmins were almost subordinated to the Singhs.
The Taksal is one such institution with historical links to Nihangs and Nirmalas from what I have managed to diciper from all the material publically available. In their present state, they would appear to be more akin to what Guru Gobind Singh would have wanted from this "Nirmala" Sampradya, i.e. a body of scholarly Singhs to impart Gurmat teachings brought parchar and amrit sanchars whilst at the same time be knowledgeable enough to engage in full debate with other intellectuals to defend the Panth from any malicious propaganda (e.g. RSS, Missionaries, Teja Singh Bhausaurias etc).
The only thing I would personally like to add is that a Taksal is a school, hence a Taksali Singh a Scholarly Singh, unfortunately many of those whom I frequently encounter calling themselves "Taksalis" are far from being Scholarly, but refer to themselves as such purely because they share the pro-Khalistani views of Sant Jarnail Singh Jee.
Re: taksal
okok · 04 Nov 2004
so basically somebody please answer this question.....those of you that believe that DDT is not started by GURU JI and that the liniage is basicallly not true....
you must be implying that the Book "Damdami Taksal de Mahapurkh" which can be read in the literature section on gurmatveechar.com, so that book which has a tree of the Jathedars....it is wrong ????
and that Sant Jarnail Singh Ji, Sant Kartar Singh Ji, Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji were MISLEADING the Panth by saying DDT was started by Guru Gobind Singh Ji?? just reply to the question ok.
i dont want to hear...."they're just saying that cause they are the Jathedar of DDT".....no....true Sikhs stand behind truth and do not do Parchar of false facts...
so please provide an answer to the question.
Re: taksal
anon · 04 Nov 2004
if everything above is true, then are the real Taksal singhs or scholarly singhs, the Sikh missionary Gianis? They are the only ones who debate properly and can debate against RSS and anti-Panthic forces, etc. For example, in UK, Dr Gurdeep Singh Jagbir from Punjab radio is a Sikh missionary singh. He does more parchaar than probably all Uk taksalis put together. I agree modern day taksalis do not seem scholarly to me, most elders are just sant baba followers.
Re: taksal
to answer · 04 Nov 2004
Yes, that lineage is wrong. It is a collection of actual Gianis but to connect them to eachother in sequence is not correct.
The Jathedars of DDT were not willfully misleading anyone. The gyanis they mention all existed. But to say that the rehit has been passed down through a lineage is not correct. If this is what they were preaching, then they were incorrect.
I HATE it when debates go down to "ARe you calling my Baba a liar????" because that's not a debate. It's not based on facts and arguments. Just a cheap appeal to emotion and usually signals a defeat.
Let me give you an example: I respect Baba Jarnail Singh with all my heart. I have his pictures up in my bedroom. But I feel keski is a kakaar, ragmala is not bani and that women can do seva in punj pyaaray. All these things are in contrast to what he believe. I can still love and respect a Singh despite differences of opinion.
Re: taksal
Harpartap Singh · 04 Nov 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
The historical record in terms of documentary evidence for the 18th century is incomplete. The absence of a named group does not mean that the organised teaching of shudh Gurbani ucharran and katha did not take place at Damdam Sahib and other places subsequently.
In this context, there are no contemporaneous sources which detail the events of the original Vaisakhi in 1699. The earliest references are from the late 1700's. The absence of the mention of the panj kakkars and panj bani's until the late 19th century is another example. Following the same logic, these two must be recent innovations. This conclusion is wrong. The list could go on and on...
As ever, each side seeks to use simplistic arguments to put across their viewpoints. Those facts which are inconvenient are ignored i.e. difficulties in providing documentary sources for major parts of contemporary Sikh Rehat from the 18th and 19th century.
As regards Viakaran etc. Modern scholars have started to distance themselves from the current Sikh Missionary/Prof Sahib Singh school of pronunciation i.e. reading in different sounds into GUrbani i.e sh and z. In addition, the idea that there is one system of Gurbani grammar is laughable. A cursory reading of the sources on languages/linguistics shows that multiple systems of grammar were used in Gurbani and in some places Guru ji does not even follow those rules! The shabad references can be found if required.
To conclude, the Damdami Taksal lineage is based on real life personalities. The differences of opinion arise as to whether the seva of carrying on the teaching of Gurbani santhia and Katha was passed one Jathedar to another. Some of the claimed breakages in lineage stated above use simplistic reasoning i.e. all of Baba Deep Singh and Baba Gurbakh Singhs ji's students being shaheed and thus unable to carry on the seva.
Bhul chuk maaf karni
Re: taksal
Admin · 04 Nov 2004
This debate is tentatively closed. No new facts are coming forward and we do not want to make this into an emotional fight about who is lying, etc. If someone has something constructive to add, it may be considered.
To be honest, the Admin did not want this discussion to take place. We had asked the original poster whether he really wanted his post up and when he insisted, we agreed.
In the future no debate like this will be allowed unless there are extenuating and unique circumstances. Let's move on.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 05 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh
one more thing admin
please let this post go up
about murale wale
i asked taksalis
and i may write it a bit wrong
but this is wat they said
sant baba bishan singh je stayed murale for a little while, and taksal was based there for a little while
in the beginning taksal was at damdama sahib under baba deep singh je, then baba gurbaksh singh je moved it to darbar sahib, then i think after that taksal moved to murale under sant baba bishan singh je, then to bhindran under sant sundar singh je, then to metha under sant baba kartaar singh je
baba bishan singh je did not make baba premm singh je leader of a jatha or of taksal
baba prem singh je was just the sewedar of murale wale gurughar thas it
jagir kaur is another story, i dont wanna get into that topic
also, many of those collectors have SOME but not as much as purataan groups do
look at nihangs
they have all of guru je shastars
some collector always says its guru je,but its just a purataan shastar, or just one that look purataan
taksal has authentic handwritten saroops of guru je by baba deep singh je, handwritten saroop of dasam granth by baba deep singh je, and maaaany of his shastars
lots of baba jes shastars
they didnt buy these or anything veer jes
they got it down from their leinage
and if u wanna attack damdaami taksals santhia too, then please open a new thread
if u have an new points aside from baba bishan singh je, go ahead and post it please
but if its the same thing give me proof, ive told u taksal has COUNTLESS ancinet articles from purtaan times, they just didnt drop out of the air or something
and by countless i mean not like collector wise, but like nihangs who still have guru jes shastar
it was passed down by leinage
and the leinage on damdami taksal is very clear
the thing that some pajis did was try to say baba bishan singh je was murale wale jathedar
as i said, thas not tru, i wrote y
now people might say baba gurbaksh singh je
but
baba je didi get shaheed
but he didnt take all of taksal wit him
if i was goin to war, i wud right my will etc. before i go
its just a smart thing to do
dont u think baba je wud have know to name the next jathedar?
admin, pleeease, put this post up
let taksal defend itself
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
??? · 05 Nov 2004
Harpartap Singh Jee,
Your attempt to link the historical ambiguities concerning the kakkars and banis to the question of a taksal lineage is misleading. There may be some uncertainty and the title of 'kakkar' may not appear until later but there are in fact contemporary sources which describe the events of 1699. There are in fact various sources. They may not all agree and may have inaccuracies, but they are there. In the case of the taksal lineage, there is in fact absolutely no mention of a Damdami Taksal anywhere in history. You can try minimizing this point by attempting to link this with other ambiguities and gaps in the sphere of literary Sikh history, but these attemtps are feeble at best. Even Taksal itself has no exclusively 'taksali' literature until the time of Sant Giani Gurbachan Singh Jee.
As far as gurbani ucharan and viakarn go, I think that these topics should be taken up in a new thread. However, I do have to make the comment that your assertions are once again, misleading. Exactly how many 'modern scholars' are distancing themselves from the 'Dr. Saahib Singh school of pronunciation?' Harkirat Singh's book is the main book promoting this idea. Even a simple critique of his work reveals exactly how weak his arguments are.
You're correct in stating that the Taksal lineage is based on real life personalities. But so what? I can take a group of real life personalities and claim a lineage, but it doesn't make it factual. In addition to having real life personalities, show us the real life connections between these personalities and the real life connection of these personalities to the present day taksal.
The reason that this lineage question arises over and over is that certain individuals in present day taksal use this supposed lineage to try and suppress any view contrary to their own. When they have no answer to a question, they simply resort to attacking the other view as 'manmat' and use this lineage as a weapon to beat the other view into submission. They are trying to monopolise Guru Jee's rehit and trying to legitimise their views by connecting them to Guru Jee through a made up lineage, rather than debating and discussing their points on the merits of the points themselves.
We could also have a discussion on how various other groups also claim lineages to Guru Gobind Singh Jee (Nihangs, Rara Saahib, etc) and then compare and contrast their beliefs and rehits. We would undoubtedly find many differences, including some that would be difficult to explain even taking into account slight drifts and changes caused by time and intrepretation by different personalities. Basically, it would be very difficult to accept that these different groups could have arisen from the same source (Guru Gobind Singh Jee) and continued passing down their beliefs and rehits without any alterations. If, however, we do accept the single source and lineages, then we will have to accept that somewhere along the way, things changed (which they naturally would). If we accept this, then what exactly is the point of using this lineage to promote a certain rehit? It changed, so it's not 'puratan.'
I want to make clear that I'm not personally against Taksal. They have done a great service to the panth and many great singhs have come from this group. However, rather than trying to make themselves great by using some mythical lineage, they should focus on the jeevan's of singh's like Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee and on the work Taksal does presently. Trying to always justify your view by falling back to this lineage only shows the lack of strength in your views.
Khalistani,
You're just stating the same stuff again. "Taksal Singh's say this, they say that...." That's not evidence. They say baba Prem singh wasn't a jathedar, but the Muralay walay say he was. What reason can you give for us to believe the Taksali Singh's over them? And what reason would Sant Sunder Singh Jee have to shift base from Murale? Also, where was Taksal based from the time of Baba Gurbaksh Singh Jee to Baba Bishan Singh Jee?
Taksal doesn't have the amount of Puratan artifacts and granths as they would if they were as old as they claim. The handwritten granths that some people claim that Taksal has have never been verified and authenticated. Once again, it's purely based on blind faith. If that's all you require, great. But please don't expect everyone else to accept it.
Re: taksal
Niranjan Singh · 05 Nov 2004
I wanted to present something related to the information "khalistani" veer mentioned in his most recent post. I am not trying to start an argument, but state information as presented by Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji. I hope the admin will print them :
"Khalistani" veer stated that he had talked to some Taksali Singhs and they stated:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
baba bishan singh je did not make baba premm singh je leader of a jatha or of taksal baba prem singh je was just the sewedar of murale wale gurughar thas it...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"khalistani" Ji, in Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji's "Guru Granth Sahib Steek" pothi no. 1 published by Baba Kartar Singh Ji (1974 Hardas Printing Press), on panna 12 in the section called "Semperdai Parlaanee", it is clearly detailed by Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji that after Baba Bishan Singh Ji, three (3) branches of this "Taksal - Damdama Sahib" emerged : One headed by Baba Sundar Singh Ji, another by Baba Bhag Singh of Ttatay Tibay, and the third by Baba Prem Singh Muralaywaley followed by Bawa Harnam Singh of Kapurthala (Begowal).
This is all documented in the above pothee. It is interesting to note that the third offshoot is currently headed by the infamous Bibi Jagir Kaur.
Re: taksal
khalistani · 05 Nov 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh
i dont think murale has ever claimed to be the original damdami taksal
if it does, please let me know if they told u they are the original damdami taksal
bhindran taksal is still there due to a fight, and sant gurbachan singh je told sant kartaar singh to mve to metha
so according to u guys
the split in taksal
is murale
bhindran and metha
ive alreadt explained y bhindran is a split
if murale also claimes to be the original damdami taksal, then please post that
because never in my whole life have i even heard of them claiming that
i think people are confused
murale is a seperate dehra sort of thing
its not taksal
after baba bidhan singh je left,they gave the sewa of parchaar to baba prem singh je to do at murale gurughar
so ive explained that murale and bhindra are not the real taksal and y they are not
so the only one left is metha, which is the real taksal
and ive given enough proof, im not going cause taksal says this
and fine, if u wanna go and examine the saroops, GO AHEAD
if u wanna examine the shastars, GO AHEAD
no ones stopping u
im telling u right now,there by baba deep singh je
but even if u dont think they arent, which they are, that really dont matter
cause according to most people on this thread the split was murale, bhindran, metha
one of them HAS to be the real one
so i told u y not bhindran, y not murale, so its metha
and im not doing this to prove taksal is the best or something
if i did,this topic really wudnt matter
even if murale or bhindran was the real taksal( IF) they all still got the same maryada
but this HAS NOTHING to do with maryada
or whos better
its just gotta do with the facts
no taksali like it when people talk lies about taksal
ive talked to singhs from metha who literally do bani all the time, even off of lareedar, theyre always reading bani
event hey were like these guys are confused
taksal was started by guru je
if u dont belive me, the best thing for u to do is this
go to sant baba thakur singh je and say this tot hem and the singhs in the their jatha
or since most of us here live in toronto, come to missausaga and just talk to the taksalis there
ask em ure doubts on taksali leiange
i have no doubts they will remove it
if u have any questions for the taksali, ill ask em for u
give me ure questions
ive alreay showed y murale is not taksal
and y bhindran is not taksal, orignial one
its metha
but if u STILL
got some doubts
chalo
likh do
write em down
and i do benti to admin to please post this
it takes at least
and veer je, taksal has A LOT of ancient artifiacts
i though i made that clear
if u think they dont, have u actually been to metha and asked them to look at the purataan saroops and the purataan shastars??
and admin
please post this
taksalis wanna defend metha aginst lies, which may be intentional or not
bhula chuka maf
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh
Re: taksal
to answer · 06 Nov 2004
I hope admin lets this up:
taksali there are so many questions left to answer like why mahan kosh lists some of the mukhis of taksal but doesn't say anything about them being head of anythign called Damdami Taksal. It doesn't mention Taksal at all, even though it lists smaller deras and sampardas like nirmala, udasi, Baba Narayan Singh...And Kavi Santokh Singh was a student of Bhai Sant Singh so why did he write against Ragmala and not mention Taksal anywhere in his books either?
-why is taksali ucharan not puratan (no bindis, dargeh vs. dargah, etc.)? Why do they not know about viakaran? Why is Taksal, if it's from Guru Sahib's time, not a centre for puratan raag vidya?
-having puratan shastar doesn't prove much either. SGPC has the most puratan stuff so are they also started by Guru Sahib? There are no saroops written by Baba Deep Singh that can be found today. If there were, we'd have a lot of answers. No scholar has been able to find even one. Bhai Talwara spent his life researching, and you're saying he didn't know about it? But this makes even LESS sense that Taksal would have them passed on. First you said that Taksal was very small so didn't get noticed...so how did they carry around all the birs and shastars? Or did they just collect them afterwards?
Re: taksal
Niranjan Singh · 06 Nov 2004
The later Bhai Joginder Singh Ji Talwara and (Jathedar) Joginder Singh Vendanti spent over thirty years doing research on Puratan Saroops of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and verifying shudh printing of Gurbani. They have had darshan and have examined more saroops than almost anyone out there. Thier conclusion was that no original saroops exist.
Vedanti is a student of the Taksal, surely he would have known about any saroop wirtten by Guru Sahib during his research.
There is no document anywhere that mentions that a saroop was ever written by Guru Sahib Ji. The original writers include : Bhai Gurdas Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji, and Baba Deep Singh Ji.
Re: taksal
gurpreetKAUR · 06 Nov 2004
Even if a Taksal/University was started by Guru Gobind Singh, so what? So what if Guru Sahib appointed a leader to head a specific Taksaal? What does that even mean? Guru Sahib also appointed masands as well - which didn't neccesarily mean that they'd be pure forever and always.
Its not a big deal. Guru Gobind Singh started the Khalsa as well and judging from his baanee, that's the only institution that he blesses.
Re: taksal
Harjinder Singh · 06 Nov 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki Fateh
You can go on forever arguing and I don't think any message board debate will fulfill anyones desires of winning the argument (although some progress can be made). What shocks me is that we can have 80+ posts on a debate about internal controversies or proving our point right or wrong, yet when we have a topic about Jeevans of Shaheed Singhs or requests about their Jeevan we have a meagre 7/8 responses if that (a part from the few cases of Jathedar Sukhdev Singh & Bhai Anokh Singh Jee).
My point is have we looked at or looked after our current history of the last 20 years - so many Singhs & Singhnees have lost their lives, yet how much do we know about their Jeevans that can be presevered for our history and to inspire or inform future generations. I'll give you one example - Bhai Raminderjeet Singh Tainee & Bibi Manjeet Kaur were jointly shaheed on a bus whilst doing seva in the recent sangarash - yet I have read 3 different accounts of their Shaheedi & have been told by their close associates that all 3 accounts are wrong in the manner that they attained Shaheedi (this includes Bhai Amardeep Singh Amars account in Tay Deeva Jagda Raheyga). We can't be conclusive for the last 20 years, how the hell are we going to prove or disprove Taksal's lineage?
History of the Sikhs was written many a year after events and printing press was only available to the wealthy, giving the argument of Mahan Kosh doesn't stand up as the author may have simply disliked Taksal thus didn't want to give them credit.
I believe Taksal's lineage is authentic - I BELIEVE IT, I don't need someone coming to me and showing me a history book proving this. I don't belive Sikhs can eat meat, yet every meat eater in the Sikh world could quote probably every historical source mentioned in the above debate that says Sikhs ate meat frequently (yet in my understanding Gurbani striclty prohibits its consumption). Where does all of this lead us, nowhere. I hope we would all spend our time more constructively and just agree to disagree.
If you look at the videos of Sant Jarnail Singh and actually talk to people who spent time with him, you'll realise that Sant Jee and even Baba Jee now, work extremely hard at keeping different Jathebandhis working together in harmony and try their best to steer clear of debating contoversy. If only we could take this teaching from them our Sikhi would flourish.
I am one of the co-administrators of www.damdamitaksal.com and felt the need to come on and try closing the issue. Just stop arguing and get on with practising - this was the main reason for not putting a message board on the website as we knew it would lead to futile debates.
Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna
Harjinder Singh
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki Fateh
Re: taksal
??? · 06 Nov 2004
"giving the argument of Mahan Kosh doesn't stand up as the author may have simply disliked Taksal thus didn't want to give them credit."
He disliked Taksal so that's why he didn't mention it??? He mentioned everything else, but he just had a special dislike for Taksal and only Taksal? Highly unlikely. Also, most earlier saroops and historical documents relating to sikhi weren't produced using printing presses, but they were produced in sufficient quantity and were fairly comprehensive.
Additionally, comparing particular incidents in the last 20 years to something like taksal lineage makes no sense. One incident among thousands, even if it's a significant shaheedi, may be incorrectly recorded or even missed but the history of a group supposedly started by Guru Saahib
and claiming to have some of the most prominent sikhs in history as it's heads, is not so easily overlooked.
"I believe Taksal's lineage is authentic - I BELIEVE IT, I don't need someone coming to me and showing me a history book proving this."
That's acceptable. If you have faith in it, that's good. The problem arises when people try to force their beliefs, which are based on personal faith and nothing else, on others. I agree though, that we should focus on other issues rather than issues like this. Whether one believes taksal to be purattan or not, shouldn't become a stumbling block in our panthic relations. Even if you don't believe taksal to be purattan, you can still respect the singhs in it and the work they've done in recent times.
Re: taksal
Admin · 06 Nov 2004
We tried closing this thread earlier, but received requests to allow a few more posts. However, there is no point in continuing this any further. Topic closed.