Re: SachKhand
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
how sad that we begin to "see" things that are not there.. Bhen gkd ji, there is nothing wrong in ik maansa ki jath etc..BUT that doesnt disprove the arguments put up about GURMATT.
It is an undeniable fact that ALL Pths lead SOMEWHERE....BUT some PATHS are MORE DIRECT than others...some lead to Oasis and some lead to deserts...some are mountain paaths that allow crawling, some are AutuBahns that allow speeds up to 300KMh...some are two seater planes some are concords and rockets....
IF everything was the SAME....what reason for GURU NANAK Ji to come here and start a NIRMAL PANTH ?? were there no panths already there and werent they "nirmal"..what possible reason for GURU JYOT to spend over 250 YEARS to turn man into KHALSA ??? Is this a sheer waste of time and resources...since Jewish/Buddhist/Christian/Islamic "PATHS" were already there and the SAME ??? Why the need to MAAKHEE te MAKHEE Maarni by the GURUS by "repeating" what Buddha/Moses/jesus etc has already DONE ???
Read GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's BANI to see why he is telling us for the need for a KHALSA.
Just as an example.. there are millions of doctors, engineers etc out there. ALL doctors are HUMAN BEINGS...IK JAAT....BUT would you consider them all the SAME in their education achievements/specialisations etc. So if I say Dr. jasvir Thind is the BEST Neurosurgeon....am I saying His MAANNAS JAAT is being put down or up by saying Dr so and so will kill you on the operating table.
If a simple thing like a worldy education can produce so much variety...out of the SAME MANAAS JATT...dont you think GURMATT has ways of producing better results/different results ?? Were those who HAPPILY and CHEERFULLY had their limbs cut bit by bit, had their scalps removed, had themselves BOILED ROASTED and still said Tera Bhaana meetha lageh...the SAME mannas jaat as the next...or did their GURMATT had something to do with their DIFFERENCE in behaviour ??? Surely there is something there??
WHY has SIKHISM produced the LARGEST NUMBER of WILLING MARTYRS ( NOT those Forcebily KILLED - like the Christians in Rome who were NOT GIVEN a CHOICE to REPENT and change religion to live)...surely it is GURMATT.
The answer is GURMATT puts in something different.....it is essentislly DIFFERENT from all those that came before and thats why GURU NANAK JI had to come..Jagat Jalanda Raakh le aapni Kirpa Dhaar....the previous relighions had failed to keep jagat jalanda.
having said all that I would be the First one to "condemn' any so called sikh who pumps up his ego to declare that he is better than anyone else because he does "massive" paaths, bhagtee, etc... the truth is such a massive bhagrtee singh would be totally SECRET....as well as Totally HUMBLE...a KOOKAR lying submissively and shaking his pooch....and NOT a BARKING Rottewiller growling and jumping at people to tear them apart.
Dass jarnail Singh.
Re: SachKhand
jhail sura jartha · 29 Oct 2004
what about bhagat prahlad and gunka didnt they get liberated? was sach khand around in that age?
Re: SachKhand
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
>>>>>em, does that mean no one went to sachkand before sikhi was created by gur nanak dev ji. like all other humans got to different levels of heavens but then got reborn, but no one actually got to sachkand?<<<<<
Could be. entirely possible. because IF everyone could go to Sach Khand BEFORE Guur nanak ji came along....WHY did GURU JI come ??
Some years ago I went to my Pind...at that time Aircraft travel had just begun...and people used to go by sea. In my Pind I met my great great Taiya Ji who was about 104 years old or so... the soles of his feet were about two inches THICK from all that walking about barefooted. When he asked me how I came I pointed to the sky and said..in that airplane flying near the clouds....He burst out laughing....mainuu chaardeh oi ulu dia pathiyah ? how can any one climb up so high and that thing is too tiny by the way ?? This man who had spent his entire life walking...could NEVER imagine being in an air plane....in his GENERATION no one had been in an airplane..... of Course many many had been in airplanes...fighter pilots in First World war Second World war etc...BUT not the EASY WAY we all can FLY now adays....Similalry BEFORE GURU NANAK JI came along there was no possibility of anyone going to sach khand..the EASY WAY...some ( maybe many ) may have gone to Sach Khand by doing bhagtee...BUT GURU NANAK JI came to make this available to the MASSES and made it all so EASY.
dass jarnail singh
Re: SachKhand
AnotherSingh · 30 Oct 2004
In his autobiography, Bachiter Natuk (in Dasam Granth Sahib), Guru Gobind Singh ji writes that in a past life he did massive bhagti and as the ages passed he eventually became one with God. This was before Sikhi.
It is possible to reach sachkhand without sikhi. However sikhi is the fastest and easiest way. For example, hatha yog, a technique used in earlier ages could not be used by most now b/c 999 out of 1000 people trying it would go mad according to baba isher singh ji. in a past age people's bodies and discipline were stronger.
That being said, it is clear that many other religions, such as islam, aim for heaven. A state lower than Sach Khand. If you don't believe me than read Japji Sahib. It states that sach khand is beyond description. However, the koran describes heaven as being filled with hooris and so on and so forth.
As for whether or not the follower of another religion could reach such a stage while remaining a follower of that faith.....I am not sure.
Re: SachKhand
Santam Singh Sidhu · 31 Oct 2004
Hey Guys, all religions lead to Sachkhand but any body who goes to Sachkhand has a life style like a pure sikh. Like Bhagat Kabeer ji, Bhagat Namdev jee, Bhagat Farid jee. Bhai Nand lal jee. All these Bhagats were from diffrent religions but if u read their life, it was a pure sikhi life. They all had kesh and beard, all were vegetarians, all were following the rules told by Guru Nanak Jee.
Re: SachKhand
GurMukh_wannabe · 04 Nov 2004
Dear Sangat,
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh!
>>the bhagats were actually all sikhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev JI<<
- Bhagat Jaidev Ji - He is said to have flourished in the reign of Raja Karnarnav (CE 1142-56) and Rãjã Purshottam Dev (CE 1170-80) - Orissa.
- Bhagat Namdev Ji - CE 1270 - 1350
They were physically on earth before Guru Nanak Dev ji. The bani of these Bhagats is also in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, which must mean they achieved oneness with the formless lord - Sach Khand, otherwise why would the Gurus select their bani?