Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Guru Khalsa Panth · 27 Oct 2004
Khalistani .... please check your facts!
The Rehit maryada is PanthiK, and does over rule every one else.
Baba Gurbachan singh and the other jathedars of Taksal may not have signed it, but all did respect it. The majority of the Panthik sevadaars, i.e. Jathedars and head granthis, etc, come from 3 main areas, AKJ, Damdami Taksal and Sikh Missionary. AKJ and DT maryadas vary slightly from panthik one, but they do accept and do Satkar of it.
Sant Jarnail Singh beat his nephew when he went against Akal tahkat maryada in the case of raagmala. Babu Mal Singh ji of AKJ was also peshed at akal thakt from with questions. All accept supremecy of Akal Thakt maryada.
The Akal thakht maryada took over 30 years of debate, and examining all texts. Some were rejected as fakes, others were accepted to compile one overall marydadas. before this the Panth was divided into over 30 different maryadas. The elders realised the need to unity. Todays we only have 4 marydas that vary from it. AKJ, Taksal, Sant Samaj, Nanaksar. This is much better than 30. So it was a good thing and should be respected.
AKJ does not put down Akal thakht maryada, instead they have points of contention, which they suggest the Panth needs to debate. The others generally reject it for their own ones. Over the last 50 years all the leaders of these groups have had whole hearted respect for the supremacy of this maryada. But their modern preachers and youth are rejecting it, to create or maintain their separate identities. This is very dangerous.
Youth need to read the maryada in its complete form, and they will realise they do not even follow half of it. It is actually very strict. If you as an individual wish to follow Pure Gurmat, then have more strictness, such as Bibek, Keskee, More banis. But the Akal thakht maryada is the minimum level for any sikh.
P.s. Jasbir singh Rode was not selected by the Panth, he became a so-called leader by force of bullet. Many Panthik bodies did not recognise him. It was Prof Darshan Singh who was selected by the Panth. For your information, the last jathedar to be selected by the Panth was Bhai Ranjit Singh.
Bhul Chuk Maff Karna
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
10th regiment · 28 Oct 2004
whilst rode was elected as jathedar during the sarbat khalsa of 1986, rode was actually a weak jathedar who recanted on his stance of khalistan and instead asked for 'puran azadi' in india.
even the taksal has disowned him.
he was released from jodhpur jail on the premise that he reign in the militants but was only supported by avtar singh brahma
all the other militant groups disowned him
that is why now all rode does is edit a newspaper from jullunder
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Jaspal Singh · 28 Oct 2004
Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah.
The Sikh Rehat Maryada is basically what most sikhs dream of, a single Maryada formed by the Guru Panth. Views of different Sikh organizations, eminent Sikhs and Sikh bodies on Sikh Maryada were considered. Below is a list of Sikhs and Panthic orgs which gave their opinions on the draft in 1932 (after every draft was made it was openly published to invite members of the panth to comment and contribute). The whole Maryada involved many more people in the select committee through out the years of debate and consolidation within the Panth.
The names of the individuals who sent their opinions as to the draft of the Code of Conduct and Conventions and its contents:
1. Bhai Sajjan Singh, Custodian of the office of Gurdwara Sri Hazur Sahib, Nander;
2. S. Hazara Singh, Patiala, Government Contractor, Bhawanigarh;
3. Giani Hira Singh Dard, Lahore;
4. Bhai Harnam Singh Naacheez, Village Naushehra Soon Sakesar, District Shahpur;
5. Bhai Pratap Singh, Publisher and Book-seller, Amritsar;
6. Bhai Ram Singh, Dera Baba Mishra Singh, Chowk Lachhmansar, Amritsar;
7. Giani Nahar Singh of Asli Qaumi Dard, Amritsar;
8. Giani Nahar Singh of Asli Qaumi Dard, Amritsar (Reacting to the second draft);
9. S. Ganda Singh V.C.O. (Retd.), Examiner Persian Writings Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Jalandhar City;
10. Vaid Naurang Singh, Gurbachan Singh Tanghi, Amritsar;
11. Bhai Mala Singh, Gurdwara Churasti Attari, Amritsar;
12. Sardar Bahadur Bhai Sahib Kahn Singh, Nabha;
13. Anonymous devotee;
14. Anonymous devotee;
15. Sant Tehl Singh Ji, Majitha, Amritsar;
16. Bhai Narain Singh, Masit Palkot, P.O. Garhdiwala (Hoshiarpur);
17. Bhai Uttam Singh Chittagong (Bengal), P.O., Railway Building, Chittangong;
18. Editors, The Khalsa and The Khalsa Advocate, Amritsar;
19. Bhai Amrik Singh, Lime Merchant, Gujranwala;
20. Sant Gulab Singh, Khalsa Anand Bhawan, Moga (Ferozepur);
21. Giani Hira Singh, Dhudial, Jhelum;
22. Bhai Nand Singh Engineer c/o Baba Bakhtawar Lal Sharma, Bathinda;
23. Master Bachan Singh 'Bachan', Sidhwan Kalan (Ludhiana);
24. Bhai Bishan Singh Suhana, G.D. Khalsa High School Jalandhar;
25. Bhai Nazam Singh Sadhaar, Dinapur (Patna);
26. Sant Gulab Singh Gholiya, Moga;
27. Ganda Singh Jaachak, Amritsar;
28. Master Puran Singh Anandpuri, Chowk Karori, Amritsar;
29. Giani Bachittar Singh C/o Khalsa Trading Agency, Calcutta;
30. Bhai Tripat Singh, Nagoki Sarli (Amritsar);
31. Giani Ran Singh, Gurdwara Damdama Sahib, Mirpur (via Jhelum);
32. Bhai Chattar Singh, Gurdwara Saranban City, Malayasia;
33. Bhai Thakar Singh Sansaar, Village Fatehgarh Ghanayian, P.O. Gurdaspur;
34. Pandit Kartar Singh, Dakha (Ludhiana);
35. Bhai Prem Singh Giani, Khalsa High School, Kalar (Rawalpindi);
36. Bhai Gurdit Singh Dars, Chak No. 132, P.O. Multan;
37. Bhai Sunder Singh Duberan (Rawalpindi);
38. Giani Bhagat Singh, Khalsa High School, Baba Bakala, Amritsar;
39. Bhai Saran Singh, Granthi, Gurdwara Ratan Tala, Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Karachi;
40. Bhai Chhehbar Singh, Head Master, Khalsa Updeshak College, Orphanage Gharjakh (Gujranwala);
41. Bhai Mal Singh Khosla, Kashmir State;
42. Dr. Teja Singh Giani, Fateh Chak (Tarn Taran);
43. Bhai Gurmukh Singh, Granthi, Barhundi (Ludhiana);
44. Bhai Mohan Singh Vaid, Tarn Taran (Amritsar);
45. Bhai Jodh Singh, Kripan Bahadar, Alowal, (Malay State);
46. Bhai Prem Singh, Govt. Pensioner, Mangat (Gujrat);
47. Bhai Mahan Balbir Singh Akali, Village Patto Singh Wali P.O. Ferozepur;
48. Bhai Manohar Singh First Head Clerk, Local Gurdwara Committee, Amritsar;
49. Bhai Mahinder Singh, President, Gurdwara Committee Samadh Bhai, Village Anuke (Ferozepur);
50. Bhai Gurbachan Singh (Ketrygess M.P. nett Jormun'e B.Sc.).
Opinions as to the draft of the Code of Conduct and Conventions and its contents were received from the following Panthic associations:
1. Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, Khadoor Sahib (Amritsar);
2. Khalsa Committee (School), Hoti;
3. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Gujranwala;
4. Sikh Women's Educational Committee, Shaankar (Jalandhar);
5. Sangat Takhat Sri Kesgarh Sahib, Anandpur;
6. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Gujarkhan;
7. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Chak Jhumra Mandi (Lyallpur);
8. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Kuntrila (Rawalpindi);
9. Akali Jatha Amritsar City;
10. Sikh Teachers' Association, Khalsa School, Khaaria (Gujrat)
11. Khalsa Central Diwan, Shromani Panth, Malouni Jatha, Majha;
12. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Dhudial (Jhelum);
13. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Bombay;
14. Guru Nanak Khalsa Mission School, Dehra Sahib, Jama Rai;
15. Khalsa Diwan Lahore Cantt.;
16. Central Sikh Naujuwan Sabha, Burma Jaunji (S.S.S.) and Khalsa Diwan Burma;
17. Secretary, Akali Jatha, Tehsil Ambala;
18. Sri Guru Singh Sabha, Khushab (Sargodha);
19. Pacific Coast Khalsa Diwan, Stockton (America)
20. Gurdwara Committee, Momeo (Burma);
21. Jathedar Budha Dal Nihang Singh Chalda Vehir, Dhobi Mandi, Lahore.
The Sikh Reht Maryada was finally approved by resolution No: 97 on February 3, 1945. It was in 1945 after deliberations with different Sikh Individuals and representatives of different organizations. It is the only Maryada endorsed by Akal Takt and the only Maryada which openly involved the Guru Khalsa Panth.
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Just read the preceeding pages of the AKAL TAKHAT approved and SGPC issued Sikh Rehat Maryada for all the information on how LONG and WHO participated in its preparation.
The SIKHS of the 1920-1940s who participated in this Maryada preparation were Good Panthic Singhs and not the corrupt/tohra/badal/jagirkaur touts that are in the sgpc today. It is not fair to look at the sgpc today and blame its ills on the Sikh Rehat Maryada.
This Maryada is the One and Only UMBRELLA maryada that covers ALL other maryadas...This was prepared by the Guru Khalsa Panth ( spread all over the WORLD) and is therefore PANTHIC, it is Based on GURBANI and is therefore GURMATT..and it is accepted MORE WIDELY by SIKHS all over the world more than any other maryada.
The only "shortcoming" i can perceive is that this is the BAREST MINIMUM so as to accommodate all sikhs. I see no problem at all if some sikhs want to add to its strictness on a personal level...on this aspect if one keeps a keski on all the time it can only do good, if a person wants to read more banis..again it can only do good, and if ladies want to tie dastaar....better...and if one wants to keep sarblohi/bibeki rehat/vegetarianism etc...whats the harm as long as you DONT IMPOSE or FORCE this aspect on ALL Sikhs and try to "subjugate"/humiliate.. them by saying MY Rehat is Guru Gobind Singh Ji direct and yours is dhillehee mathee sgpc type. Whoever keeps the MINIMUM Sikh Rehat is a SIKH and a respected member of the GURU KHALSA PANTH.
I have nothing agaisnt anyone...but their hype about Guru Gobind Singh Ji direct/tree line /geneology/ etc is just hype. Guru Ji Gave Gurgadhi to the GURU KHALSA PANTH .
I started off with the Sikh rehat maryada and have progressed to soemthing more stricter and i find it uplifting to say the least...BUT i would be the last person to put someone else down just because he is where i was 30 years ago. Personally i come across those who do the most hype about their maryada etc are actually quite hollow inside and have very little real knowledge of Gurbani...all they know are sakhis and tall tales their baba ji taught them with no gurbani based grounding and their FIRST and LAST line of DEFENCE is MY MARYADA is DIRECT FROM GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...so shut up. Sorry not everyone is easily cowed.
dass jarnail singh
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Sardar Saab · 28 Oct 2004
Dear "Author: Singh Date: 10-28-04 09:53"
I think you are a retard who has put up very s**adminCut** arguments. SGPC maryadha is considered a bare minimum by all rehetvaan people. The Jatha rehet only adds to the SGPC rehet, it doesn’t take anything from it. And why should some bibi mind wearing a keski for doing kirtan? does she have that much allergy from Keski that she would feel offended wearing it?
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
AnotherSingh · 28 Oct 2004
Rehat Marayda
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/index.php
A panthik rehat maryada made without the agreement of the entire panth?
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
gurvahhhhhhhh · 29 Oct 2004
i think if they cud push other groups to come to the akhal takhat they wud but they also know that the akhal takhat has been made a mockery of ie if some sakht jathedar came in and said " no meat" how many sikhs would actually follow it? or " dont cut kes" how many people follow that? " eat on floor langar" people eat on chairs still at most gurdwaras and on floor when they want but the chairs still remain. u can go on n on. Its about numbers and how people will react, if they had everyone behind one rehet they cud push groups to summon them but they wont unless they become one.
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Iminder Singh · 30 Oct 2004
Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh!
Khalsa Jeeo,
I think one Rehit that we are all forgetting about, which should at the top of all our Rehits, is NAAM DI REHIT. Without discipline of Naam we are nothing. Without Amritvela we are nothing. This is what we have to realise and then most difficult of all ACT upon.
Naam is the one and only thing which will carry us through this life, not the "type" of Rehit we follow. With Rehit of Naam, all other practiced Rehits become stronger.
Everyone is right in their own way. If someone follows the Panthic Rehit Maryada, then great. Equally, if someone follows the Akhand Kirtani Jatha or Taksal Maryada then its also great. My point being, we should be solid in whatever we follow, and at the same time think of ourselves as being lower than everyone else. Also, we should never downgrade another Jahebandee's Rehit, or downgrade another person because they have different views on the controversial points in the Rehit Maryada.
I personally believe that the Panthic Rehit Maryada is the umbrella for all other Rehits, and unity in this will most definitely help in the unity of the Panth. Other additional Rehits are even better, but only if they are in Hukam with the Panth.
Everything written above I have realised. The only thing left for me, is to put these realisations into practice.
May Vaheguroo Jee bless us all.
Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh!
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004
ummm jee,
by the same measurements...WHICH MARYADA...consulted ALL WOMENS GROUPS, ALL NON-ETHNIC SIKHS and ALL SIKHS in ALL COUNTRIES ??
Please provide solid PROOFS of your answers and not just "drop the name of Guru Gobind Singh baba deep Singh Ji etc..."
If you do care to READ the Post by Bhai Jaspal Sin gh which is based on the First few pages of the SGPC's AKAL TAKHAT APPROVED Maryada you will notice that places ALL over India from Rawalpindi-Lahore to Calcutta Chittagong, Bombay madras etc are emntioned as well as MALAY STATES, Malaya, AMERICA etc are mentioned. in the 1920-1030s THESE are Where the MAJORITY of SIKHS were concentrated and in those HARD TIMES OPINIONS as Far flung as all that were CONSULTED and the people SACRIFICED their time and MONEY ( postage) to send in their opinions.
Some people can never be satisfied....tomorrow IF a "sarbatt Khalsa" ( I dont think it is possible because IF TWO Sikhs living in the SAME TOWN in CANADA - one Taksali and the other akj - cant see eye to eye..how can they BOTH go to a "sarbatt khalsa" and AGREE???on what ???) but just say a sarbatt khalsa is held.....will NOT a few thousand get up and say "we were NOT invited??? WE DIDNT go ??? WE never SIGNED any of it ???...
Isnt this the SAME OLD ARGUMENT against the sgpc ??? THAT baba Gurbachan Singh walked out and Never signed the maryada ( because HE couldnt GET everyone to agree to His version of MAAS.... Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji also walked out of the Final meetings because he also couldnt get the rest to agree to his views on Keski as a Kakaar. These men were GREAT - they had their views, they STUCK to them and walked out BUT didnt attempt to FORCE their views on ALL....
TODAY i am not so sure....people are NOT so GREAT at all.....they form "Roko this and Roko That Squads"...and go forcing their views on everybody by intimidation and scare tactics. There is not a single record that Bhai Sahib Jees above went back and incited their followers to form "Maryada di beadbi roko" squads and go demonstrate in front of the sgpc/akal takhat to STOP the maryada being formulated. This type of behaviour is only in Great Men....
How many Sarbatt Khalsas were called in the last 20 years?? How many SIKHS support all of them ?? The latest in Mohali last year was also a "sarbatt Khalsa" !!! I am afraid there will be many such sarbatt khalsas and just as many who dont bleeive in them..one way or other ... a 100% SIKH SUPPORTED Sarbatt Khalsa.... That is a PIPE DREAM. And the way the SIKHS are now spread all over the World, no one can get all of them in one place.....and anyway our "democracy" is not the Greek Democracy of Socrates where EACH SIKH has one vote and MUST be counted.... Can you make sure EACH SIKH will VOTE, and EACH VOTE will be same value as Everyone elses ?? MY VOTE for example will NEVER go to a TAKSALI MARYADA ??? Will my vote equal that of a taksali BABA JI/Maharaj Ji ?? so what am I ?? a NON-SIKH ?? Not Panthic ?? not Gurmattic ?? Only a taksali can be Panthic, Sikh, Gurmattic ?? NO WAY....and this same argument applies to sgpc/akj/nanksar etc etc..a SIKH and HIS GURU are private thread. Panthic/Gurmattic/Sikhs can be found in ALL denominations and in all jathas..no one has his own private monopoly on SIKHI/Gurmatt.
Dass jarnail Singh.
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
passionate dog · 31 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki fateh
Panthic marayda? What panth? The Khalsa Panth?And do you know what the Khalsa is? What it should be. Pure! One who has full control over their indrian and 5 vickhars. What do we have today? people full of ego representing the "Panth." I've seen photos of our so-called leaders and they sure don't look pure. They have alcohol and meat infront of them. They play political games, all for their own fame and fortune. Right know we have a person who is accussed of murdering her own daugher and grandchild as a leader. Yeah we sure are lead by khalsa jeevani folks. Once i spoke to a gursikh and he told me that one time he was at the Darbar Sahib and it was 10:30am. The head granthi had just woken up. So much for Amrit vela and the rehit. He asked the granthi and this granthi used the same stupid excuse, that is: "this whole life is amrit vela" And then the "panth" in their infinte wisdom has cut the nitnem Banis from 5 to 3. Rather than increasing naam, they actually thought it wise to reduce it. The same for Rehiras Sahib. Yes, so wise they are. Guru Ji says meditate day and night, with your every breath and these mannukhs say ok, reduce the Banis. Great leaders they are. And can you imagine all the money the sgpc collects. Where is it used for the betterment of the panth? In the guise of "guru panth" stating that Guru Ji has given them the staus of Guru, they do all of this and yet they are certainly far from being the khalsa as Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj created. I have no problem if they were truly Khalsa, but they aren't. They back stab and play power games with each other and yes, fight. Actual physical fights often take place where the people involved lose their dastars in the ensuing melee and all to often this happens in front of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Awhile back i saw on aplha news a fight right outside Harminder Sahib where a sikh was hit with a sword by another Sikh, for being on the opposing side. So much for panthic untiy. And on the issue of guruship. How egotistical we are! Do we really think that we as the collective panth are more powerful than Guru Ji? Are we true Khalsa? yes, if we were than Guru Ji would hear our benti and listen to us as they did at Anandpur Sahib and Chamkaur Sahib. Our Guru is Guru Grant Sahib Ji and no one else. When Guru Ji said Khalsa mero roop hai khas and said that khalsa is my Satgur poora did they mean any tom dick and harry or did they mean "Khalsa" the pure. One who has defeated his 5 vickars and has control of his indrian. Every where we look Guru Ji tells us that without the Guru we can not attain mukti. So do we take it that without the guru panth we have no mukti, regraedless of the fact that the so-called guru panth does not live according to Guru Ji's hukam. Course not! It is without Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that we are lost. And as Guru Gobind Singh Ji says, "jab lag khalsa rehay nayara tab lag tej deo main sara. jab eh gaye bipran ki reet mein nah karo in ke perteet." That's exactly what has happened to us. One time in a battle Guru Ji and his Sikhs were pushing back the enemy and were on the verge of victory. Guru Ji stayed his horse but in their zeal the Sikhs overtook Guru ji and continued on. Soon the batlle turned against the Sikhs, and then one Sikh said, where is the Guru? A Sikh went running back towards Guru Ji and said please help oh Lord, king of Kings. And Guru Ji said, I just wanted to let you know that without the Guru you are nothing. ( This sakhi is a rough verison. I can't recall exactly the whole sakhi but the message is clear. If required I can post a thorough version later.) The issue of meat is one that is very contentious within the panth and yet all mahapurkhs and samradias agree that it is against Sikhi and yet the so-called "panthic rehit maryada" says that it is ok if it's khuta. No wonder great Sikhs like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji and Sant gurbachan Singh Ji withdrew. You know why? coz they knew the truth. They didn't need to read and analyize books and suff to get their knowledege. Gursikhs know the truth by the grace of Guru Ji because of all the kamai they do. They didn't get their knowledge from reading books and considering themselves as academics and shcolors. Countless great Sikh mahapurks all agree one more things together than they do with the "panthic maryada. I'd rather place my life in their hands than a bunch of power hungry egotisical acedemics who claim to represent Sikhi.
Bhul chuk muaaf!
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki fateh
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
Searching for Tat · 04 Nov 2004
When people say SRM is minimum level, they are not disrespecting it, but just following a stricter rehit for their personal jeevan.
i.e. keski - wearing one does not diminish importance of kesh, it emphasizes it by covering it properly.
Meat - not eating meat, does not mean we are against SRM. It just means we prefer in our jeevans to be vegetarian.
Baanis - reading 5 instead of 3, does not mean we are against the 3. We still read them. We just read 2 more to improve our jeevan.
I wish those who keep putting down jathas like AKJ would stop. We are not against SRM, we respect it. We push it in gurdwaras to bring everyone to one platform. However in our personal rehits, we seek more to make our jeevans better. Jathas help those Sikhs who want more on a personal level and search for Tat Gurmat. This can only be good for the Panth. No one is forcing anything on anyone. We are just trying to be the best sikhs we can. We all accept the Panth comes first.
Re: Panthic Rehit Maryada (SGPC)
respectfully · 04 Nov 2004
This has been a refresher course in rehit maryada history and development.
In my humble opinion, Singh's posts on the topic have been on the mark; they are devoid of many of the assumptions made by some, and put forth logical sense as opposed to blind emotional appeal.
It makes little sense to say that "we are simply building on the Rehit Maryada" when, in fact, any such 'building' necessarily chips away and weakens the foundation of the Rehit Maryada. As an example, no offense to my AKJ friends, but when keski is pushed as a kakkaar over kes, it is not building on the Panthic Rehit Maryada but undermining it.
Moreover, as Singh has pointed out repeatedly, the reason decades of debate went into the Panthic Rehit Maryada was to establish a singular, unified rehit. If the Khalsa Panth had intended on this rehit being simply a 'basement' rehit, and had found it acceptable to allow others to build on it, what was the point in establishing a singular, unified rehit? If you have 10, 20, 30 individual groups 'building' on the rehit by introducing their own kurehits, rehits etc, we end up in the same situation as we had before the Panthic Rehit Maryada was established: a situation where we have 30 rehit maryadas and not one.
I know and accept that amongst us, we have differing views on many aspects of Sikhi and the Sikh lifestyle - the thing is, it is more than likely that the eminents sants and scholars who designed the Panthic Rehit Maryada also probably disagreed on many aspects. However, they recognized that for the Khalsa Panth to exist, to move forward, to stay unified and grow, one unified rehit was necessary.
There are some things I don't agree with regarding the established Rehit Maryada; however, it is not my place to splinter off from what the Panth has estbalished and replace it's strictures or allowances with my own rules and 'rehits'. By all means, do more bani, keep keski (my family does), eat only from sarbloh, wear only the color orange, but please don't push this across as rehit because by doing so, a new and different rehit is established - a rehit which undermines the Rehit Maryada established by the Khalsa Panth.
Even our Guru, Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji subjected himself to the Khalsa Panth. At Chamkaur Sahib, our Guru wanted to stay and conduct war, His thoughts were on staying the course of the battle, His heart desired to fight; however, even He had to bow to the command of the Khalsa Panth. None of us, none of our organizations, none of our religious leaders are greater than our Guru Sahib - we should follow His example.
respectfully,
Respectfully.