Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 25 Oct 2004

Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani Tribune News Service Amritsar, October 24 History of sorts would be created in the world of music when legendry ghazal singer of Pakistan, Ghulam Ali, and hazoori raagi, Bhai Nirmal Singh, would cut a joint album of shabad kirtan to mark the golden jubilee celebrations of singing of the former. This would be the first-ever joint album of the 'ustad-shagirad' (teacher-disciple) duo even as Bhai Nirmal Singh considers Ghulam Ali his teacher in the field of music. No other hazoori raagi has ever sung Gurbani with the ghazal maestro so far. Talking to TNS here today, Ghulam Ali said golden jubilee of his singing was being celebrated in Pakistan and other countries by holding grand functions. He said though he had produced more than 200 CDs, yet joint cassette with his 'disciple' would be a unique experiment in the field of classic music. Lauding the contribution of Shiv Kumar Batalvi, the ghazal maestro said he would pay him a tribute by producing a CD of his songs which were never sung by any singer, as part of year-long celebrations of his singing.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

disgusting · 25 Oct 2004

Disgusting, Kirtan is becoming like entertainment. We are already having cases where recording rights r being sold to companies for personal profit. We already have the situation where on an average day theres 10 ppl at the gurdwara unless theres some FAMOUR SANT SANT SINGH SAHIB BABA BABA there in which case theres a thousand ppl. Im afraid we will 1 day see kirtan being used and abused in the mainstream spotlight. Could you imagine it, the latest punyabi MC doing a 'kirtan track' on top of the pops! Is'nt this where things are leading to? what can we do about it? what are we going to do about it?

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 25 Oct 2004

It's already happened with Dya Singh in Australia...they've broken through to the mainstream with their mix of hippy-pop kirtan, that's "so good for kids, as it brings them to the Gurdwara"... ...for what??? To aspire to what??? Singing Anand Sahib in rap???!!!

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

i dont think so · 25 Oct 2004

yah and we even have situation where kids are offered cash to learn bani

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

unknown · 25 Oct 2004

Ragi Nirmal Singh is a full corrupt Ragi and should be banned to perform keertan in Gurughars. He was in Texas a year ago and performed keertan in a Mandir, with Aarti in front of idols. He is only after money and has no respect for Guru Jee. If someone wants more details of this event, i can write in more details.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

gkd · 26 Oct 2004

wait a second.......... gurbani cant' be sung to modern instruments is that whatur saying "a singh"

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ · 28 Oct 2004

gkd A Singh didnt say that you couldnt do kirtan without modern instruments. As a matter of fact, he didnt even mention modern instruments.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

sikh · 28 Oct 2004

recently on a local punjabi radio station here in the uk, they have been playing supposed shabads done to dance beats when i first heard it i could not believe it, gurbani being sung to the beat of a dance track so to me i treat these tracks as songs plain and simple it is not gurbani just a song, not even that actually.. its a sad shame sometimes i listen to bhai balbir singh who does kirtan in raag, and many times i find it hard to understand it most definetly has an effect on my and my psyche and that was why guru ji ordered kirtan to be done in raag funny old story, if you go and listen to rangila he is now always going on about a shcool he has started in india where they teach proper raag kirtan, and you kow what happenes next sangat jumps up and donates £££££!!!! but funnily enough he still uses baja! hypocrit

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Thank you "$ÍÑGHZ "®" |<|ÑGZ "! I have never said anything against modern instruments, of course I would say that it would be better to have more preservation of our traditional vidiya (Taos, Saranda etc), however that does not exclude other instruments from being used PROVIDED they lend themselves to raag kirtan...so instruments like electronic keyboards and vajas are the best bet, the use of the violin, cello etc are far more flexible... My problem with Dya Singh is the not use of various instruments or even non-Sikh musicians, which is to me personally fine, it's the end result: hipppy-pop kirtan, which sounds at times like a nusery rhyme or the type of music one expects from an new age American Christian cult. Sorry to offend anyone, but I see no benefit in attracting children to Gurbani through Anand Sahib in a rap format or shabads sung to Michael Jackson's 'you are not alone' -all this does is degrade bani (essentially all those who sing Shabads like this out of raag are effectively indicating themselves to be smarter than Guru Sahib who has indicated raag, time cycles etc in their compositions) and moreover, it serves to further disillusion Sikh children from the richness of their authentic heritage by feeding them this hippy-pop music for their souls. We hear so much about Bibek and how important it is to one's jeevan and soul, how about we also apply the same concept to what we listen to and see -we are fed not only through our mouths but through our ears and eyes as well.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 28 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Fits in perfectly with what i am trying to say on another topic regarding BEADBI ROKO SQUADS... We SIKHS do BEADBI of GURU GRANTH JI daily in our Gurdwaras....but no one is the least bit bothered...except that if such beadbi happens in a banquet hall we must take immediate action... BEADBI of KIRTAN/ Commercilisation of Sacred GURBANI has been going on in OUR GURDWARAS/SGPC/Golden Temple etc.....and we close BOTH EYES all this while.... and now it is going out of control...with others non sikhs etc coming in for a piece of the action.... OBVIOUSLY there is MONEY and lots of it to be made Next are we going to have beadbi roko squads shutting down DJs in pubs and hotel bars discos etc where such rap kirtan is being played ?? It is only a matter of time before such rap kirtan is played in a bar/ disco ??? Will there be singhs doing Chaupaii sahib paaths outside discos ??? Lets STOP this BEADBI and COMMERCILISATION of KIRTAN in our GURDWARAS FIRST and NOW. STOP patronising professional raagis who sell gurbani...STOP all Shabad BHET in Gurdwaras....to raagis who sell us nothing but bollywood tunes under the guise of kirtan....LOOK and see how it all happens....FIRST a unknown raagi takes up a paid raagi post in a GURDWARA.... promotes himself to HAZOORI RAAGI.. then uses that title to sell himself abroad...collects money by the bORI-FULL...and graduates to CDs Tapes cassettes and then Video Cds.... etc etc. IT is all huge racket from day one...and then also collects money by promotng bogus schools and pure raags while calling himself "rangilla" ( Aurengzeb was a rangilla)... The ROT begins at home..in our GURDWARAS STAGES....and we PAY for it. dass jarnail singh

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

TYPO Correction to my earlier post: ...so instruments like electronic keyboards and vajas are NOT the best bet, the use of the violin, cello etc are far more flexible...

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Mohan Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I am in agreement that "poppy keertan" is a complete beadbi however in some ways the "modern" Keertan as sung by Akhand Keertanee Jatha this is also becoming a problem with Bollywood tunes being used on the Vajja, overuse of loud table, etc. This is just a bad beadbi in some ways, depending on how you look at it. My personal belief on why Bhai Sahib promoted Akhand Keertan is because a) obviously unbroken Keertan is the proper way but also b) it is very easy to learn the vajja, etc. so the entire sangat is able to participate more easily in keertan and emphasis can be put on the WORD. Providing traditional raags are still used I think the vajja is more than fine, however we must be careful that modern Jatha keertan, in an attempt to appeal to the youth, is not going down the same route. Nowadays you can find Keertanees who recite the Bani so quickly the words cannot be heard properly as they try to fit it into a particular tune - the emphasis on the WORD has thus been lost, negating the entire point of why Akhand Keertan was originally promoted. The older Akhand Keertan tapes are a good example of how it should be done. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

S Singh · 28 Oct 2004

I myself have seen a few AKJ Singhs almost with a super star status doing kirtan using bollywood tunes. That seems like Beadbi to me. It should stop.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

AKJ kirtan is rearely found in raags, bar the contribution of Bhai Mohinder Singh, instead we have "G T Road" and other such tunes used and pathetic excuses like it is easier for people to contribute -why is it that on one hand we claim Sikhi elevates us and on the other hand we want to dumb ourselves down? Why is it that we can go to extreme lengths to preserve our diet (as the flue jab thread shows) and sarabloh bibek, but when it comes to learning a real instrument and raag vidiya, we shy away, oh no it's too complex! Gyani Ji is correct in his points concerning the Beadbi Rokho team in this instance -seeing that I even know some of this team personally, it's hardly surprising they shy away from this thread as many of them dispute the need for raag kirtan even!

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 28 Oct 2004

KOEE GAAVAE RAAGEE, NAADEE BEDEE BAHU BHAANTY KAR NAHI HAR HAR BHEEJAY RAAM RAAJAY|| The quoted baani pankiti clearly states that one does not have to sing in hardcore raags to please Vaheguru. Everything that we sing is in some raag or the other . What is Raag? Raag is just a sequence of keyboard keys (in case of a vaaja, a different frequencies in case of string instruments) There are 12 keys and every Raag falls in one of these 12 keys. And every tune of kirtan that is sung is sung using the same 12 keys. This means that every tune is in some raag or the other. It is wrong to criticize AKJ for singing simple tunes. Jatha tunes are the best in the world (my opinion). Some of the tunes that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to sing and are popular in Jatha today, are sweeter than honey e.g. Har Simree Din Sabh Rayen. I agree that many kirtaniyaas today are singing chanchal tunes and I think Jatha as a whole should take some action against this and we should not mind when other gursikhs out of Jatha, criticise us for singing chanchal tunes. We should not encourage kirtaniyaas who sing chanchal tunes. Singing simple tunes is one thing and singing chanchal tunes is totally wrong. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 28 Oct 2004

Kulbir Singh, Thanks for your post, however again this falls in the camp of the other excuses one hears from those who cannot maintain the simple matter of learning Raag. Comments like "hardcore" raag clearly show that many people feel raags = complex. Singing in raag need not be complex, raag is a composition, in our cases many of our Gurus (in fact this has so much more evidence supporting it than other maryadas such as Sarabloh Bibek, Methods of Ishnaan, Gurmukhi Dastaars and such like -it's Guru Sahib!!!) Raag can be sung in folk tunes and melodies, bhajans and soft thumris and of course heavy dhrupad and khyal styles, this is what the Gurbani quote refers to, not an excuse to start singing and frankly disrespecting Shabads by singing them to Chamkila or Bollywood tunes and such like -which is what has been happening with "kirtan" for the past 100 years!

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

hey · 28 Oct 2004

leave chamkila alone, i aint heard any kirtan done by jatha that imitates chamkila. lal chand yamla jatt is another breed, he did his folk in rag and his songs were mostly dharmic or moral tales that kills all the modern stuff.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

gkd · 29 Oct 2004

chamkilla wuz a mahaa retard. dont' bring him into this ocnvo...singhs put him on a one way train ride 2 deaths house. gurbani doesnt say that a muslim can't singh gurbani... i think..that bhai mardana ji's relatvies should have full khull...

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

q · 29 Oct 2004

yeh but was it singhs or his brother in laws who he would mention in his songs and challange them for taking their sister? ive heard conflicting versions.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

A Singh · 29 Oct 2004

The issue of Chamkila is nothing to do with "singhs", he is a case of a so-called 'low-caste' man who married a another techinically 'sudra' caste women (I belive she was a Jatti, although others have told me that she from a Tarkhan background), in any event, her brother and pindoos disapproved of her marrying Amar Chamkila for he was a Choora. His songs are clearly a socio-political albeit at the same time jovial rebellion against the caste-based biases he experienced from other 'sudras' -which is why it always makes me laugh to see Jatts, Tarkhans, Lohars, CHooras, Chamars etc argue about who is higher and lower, when in the grand scheme of things, according to the Caste System propagated by Manu they all qualify as Sudras!!!

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

ji · 29 Oct 2004

well it may not be part of this topic but as its bein discussed ive also heard different theories some claim another singer paid off some dakus dressed as kharkus to take him out as chamkila took off with half a band. the other theories are kharkus had him dusted for the vulgarity but then the question arises why him and not malkit singh? caste isnt an issue for most of us, and i think chamkila could have done very well in the ranks of ustaad lal chand yamla jat if he did dharmic, itihaas, and legend geets. Vulgar songs were bang out of order but then a lot of people claim thats the reality, but regardless singing that automicatically promotes it more to the next generation where the arrest of such corrupt development shud have taken place.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

.... · 30 Oct 2004

Author: ji Date: 10-29-04 12:35 well it may not be part of this topic but as its bein discussed ive also heard different theories some claim another singer paid off some dakus dressed as kharkus to take him out as chamkila took off with half a band. hence why gill surjit may have been shot dead too. If it were a brother wife husband dispute they wouldnt kill an innocent guy who had nothing to do with it, the killing of gill adds weight to a rival singer paying chamkila back.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

gkd · 30 Oct 2004

ji, why him and not malkit singh? have u heard malkit singsh songs? how are they vulgur? chamcha (chamkilla) sang sexually progotive songs....ie "gongloo patloo" gangloo being a type of fruit, but the line naturally has a different meaning. while malkit singh juss talks maybe about romance but never ne thing 2wards that end of the spectrum. the kharkoo mahaan singhs killed chamcha because of this vulgurarity. and a job well done.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

j. bhogal · 30 Oct 2004

did any kharku go to jail for killing chamkila? so how do we know it was kharkus when different theories exist.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

.. · 30 Oct 2004

from what i remember malkit singh was threatened to stop singing songs like "tootika tootika tutiya aja milyeh khu teh" etc and then he came to the west. some khakrus apparently told him come meet under the tree near the khu and he crappd it. chamkila was loud in the rude sense, and was warned to stop then he reinevnted his new image singing religious songs only to go back to his old style of vulgar singing. But until theres evidence to show kharkus killed him i wont believe it. If they wanted him for his lyrics they wouldnt be heartless to murder a woman, and an insrumentalist, other singers have sang songs of a lesser nature mutiyar, pabi lakh hila etc , now thats just as bad, kharku singhs wouldnt just hit one and leave others. Chamkila had success and fame that was built on the shoulders of other singers, when he set up his own, he didnt walk away by himself but took another bands woman singer with him as wel as the leading instrumentalist leaving a succesful singer in the lurch with half his group gone. Rumours had it gangsters went in to settle old scores after a hefty payout from another leading singer.

Re: Ghulam Ali to sing Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004

going to jail or staying out of it ??? in INDIA that has absolutely nothing to do with any crime..... Look at HKL Bhagat, Tytler....they are NOT in JAIL. Look at the 50,000 or SO Sikh Youths, ex-Faujis etc IN JAIL Many "kharkoos" had prizes on their heads..BUT didnt do anything wrong... Many THOUSANDS ended up being cremated as UNCLAIMED BODIES....also didnt do anything wrong.. Many hundreds got MEDALS, got PROMOTIONS, became MINISTERS and Assemblyment, Parliamentarians..... BUT they KILLED and MURDERED and RAPED, Hijacked Aeroplanes...etc .. So the "different" theories are just theories ??? Jarnail singh