Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
AnotherSingh · 25 Oct 2004
The Guru DID actually outline a rehat. Over time confusion has arisen among Sikhs as to what the actual rehat is. Damdami Taksaal claims that their rehat is proper as it comes direct from the Guru. SGPC says theirs is right as it was made by panthic consensus (it's not, by the way) and so on.... each group claims theirs is right.
Do your own research and find out what you believe to be correct. You can learn about rehat by reading articles and listening to katha. Articles on this website, katha by sant Kartar Singh, Giani Takhur Singh, and a book called Gurmat Rehat Maryada and so on..........
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Sher.B.Singh · 25 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa! Waheguru JI Ki Fateh!!!
i donno anything but i ill suggest to READ AND UNDERSTAND GURBAANI. YOU ILL GET THE ANSWER OF EVERY QUESTION FROM GURBAANI.
GURU JI WILL LOOK AFTER U :
"APNE SEWAK KI AAPE RAKHAI, AAPE NAAM JAPAWAI"
BHUL CHUK MAAF
GURU RAKHA
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa! Waheguru JI Ki Fateh!!!
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Jaspal Singh · 25 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah.
"SGPC says theirs is right as it was made by panthic consensus (it's not, by the way)"
The above statement shows pure ignorance about the Sikh Rehat Maryada. For your information the only Maryada which has the approval of the Guru Panth is the Sikh Rehat Maryada, which involved almost every single panthic organisation of the time. People confuse (on purpose) the fact that it was the Guru Panth (which Guru Sahib also gave Guruship to) which after years of consultation and debate which involved Gurbani and other Rehat/Hukamnamay reached the Sikh Rehat Maryada. People like Bhai Vir Singh, Giani Gyan Singh, Sant Teja Singh and even Bhai Randhir Singh were involved as well as numerous others as the Guru Panth got together to finalise a standard Rehat for the Panth. Some people ie Ranhdir Singh may have left half way through but the final version was the decision of the Panth (people who can’t accept this use the term SGPC instead of Guru Panth) which is greater than any individual. The majority is greater than any person, therefor if Bhai Rahdhir Singh or any one else did not agree on the final version and decided to leave becouse they could not convince the rest it does not mean the greater decision of the Panth does not hold, especially when mahan vidvan Sikhs ie Bhai Vir Singh, Giani Gyan Singh, Sant Teja Singh were involved. It is impossible to get every single person in the Panth to agree, but the Sikh Rehat Maryada is the closest thing, and just because our own personal Sants or whatever decided to leave and could not convince the majority does not mean the decision of the Panth should collapse.
I took Amrit from the Jatha but do not believe in most aspects ie egg being a kreht etc. We should stay within the lines of the Guru Panth (if we claim to be part of the Panth) and not contradict the Rehat issued by the Guru Panth (like I said people who can’t accept this use the term SGPC). If one wishes to keep Sarbloh etc that’s up to them but no group or individual has the right to change the Guru Panths Rehat Maryada ie claim there own kekars and Kurehts as and when they wish.
.
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Search for Tat · 25 Oct 2004
AnotherSingh wrote:
Damdami Taksaal claims that their rehat is proper as it comes direct
> from the Guru.
The Taksal is a great jathebandie just like many others in the Panth, but its rehat did not come from Guru ji. The only people who believe this is taksalis themselves. Like they are the only ones who believe Bindrawale is still alive! So many holes can be made in this maryada, but it will only offend taksalis, so I will not.
The answer is to follow the rehat that most corresponds to Gurbani. If you already believe in keskee, bibek, etc, then you are close. I respect the Panthik maryada as it brings the whole Panth together on one Platform. But on a personal level, my own rehit seeks more than Panthik unity, its seeks personal purification, and protection. Hence I follow AKJ maryada because it is logically Guru Sahibs Tat Gurmat Maryada. I do not force it on others, anyone who folows the Panthik Maryada is a Sikh. But if you want deep spiritual experinces and Pure Gurmat, follow a strict, pure maryada.
Obviously Naam is the Ultimate maryada, why compromise on it!
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Caprice Sun · 26 Oct 2004
Their is a popular saying, a rule of thumb if you will, which can help us decide what the right thing to do is in most cases.
The right way is the way that's harder. It really is.
Khalsa rehit will require you to break wordly bonds. Khalsa rehit will bring you closer to other Khalsa. Khalsa rehit will require you to get up at Amritvela and do naam abhyaas. Khalsa rehit will help you build yourself up so that you are constantly driven to do more paath and naam abhyaas.
Khalsa rehit will help you focus on Gurbani throughout the day. KHalsa rehit will require you to stand for your beliefs. Khalsa rehit will lead to you God.
I could be wrong but this thought just popped into my head:
If Amrit can not be made at an amrit sanchar without SArbloh that how can be get naam raas (amrit) without sarbloh in our jeeven after the amrit sanchar?
I think Sarbloh is a must. Ofcouse it goes without saying that a strong amritvela and a strong nitnem is the ultimate rehit.
guru sada dayal hai. just ask him what to do. if you are genuine in your query you will not be led astray. you've already given your head to guru sahib ... all your mat, you gave up so now adopt GURmat.
DO ARDAAS and all will be well.
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 26 Oct 2004
i just have on request for you
you have joined the khalsa panth
now there is NO NEED to join any "groups"
you can go to akj smagams, learn from akali / sgpc maryada, and study at the taksal.. but DON'T become a "part" of a group - it's not worth it
stay neutral
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 26 Oct 2004
i didn't mean neutral as far as "just go with anything"
of course you have to take a stand
but gurmat agrees with and disagrees with different things in different groups
some things happening in different groups are good, and some things are bad
only gurmat is right - the groups are all temporary, only the guru panth is immortal
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Search for Tat · 26 Oct 2004
You are a young boy, take the time to read your history. There is no reference to taksal in any Purataan texts. Only DT`s own text speak of this apparent lineage. It is a modern concept to brainwash the next generation like yourselves. To make you think Taksal is everything. I have a tree of the Panth which was really started by Guru Gobind Singh in 1699, do you wish to compare?
You said its bhramgianis have led the Panth more than anyone. So have they led it more than Banda Singh Bahadhur, Mata Sahib kaur, Baba Karak Singh, Bhai Gurbaksh Singh, Bhai Jassa Singh Aluwalia, Bhai Jasssa Singh Ramgarhia, Bhai Boota Singh & Bhai Garja Singh, Nawab Kapur Singh, Sardar Baghel Singh, etc. The list is endless. Even Baba Deep Singh ji and Bhai Mani singh ji`s links to Taksal are disputed by mainstream sikhs. The Taksal has many great sikhs in modern times, but like every other group, they are insignificant before the Guru Khalsa Panth.
AKJ have never claimed it can be traced back to Guru ji. Only nihangs and taksals have, as they fight over maryadas. It is not about the group, but about the assols. By the way, Akhand keertan can be traced back to Guru Nanak Dev ji and Bhai Mardana Ji, if that makes any difference to you.
Everything every jathebandie does can be clarified with Gurbani. If not then they are not sikhs. I think you will find your rule applies to everyone.
Nothing personal against DT. Just answering your points.
khalistani wrote:
> Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
> damdamitaksal can trace its lienage back to guru gobind singh
> je, i even have a tree line which shows which jathedar, etc.
>
> its brahm gianis have led the panth more than anybody else
> its not a jatha, its a samparda
>
> can akj be traced back to guru je??
> yes, some very chardi kala in akj, tru, like bhai randheer
> singh je
>
> and evey single thing damdami taksal says can be backed by bani
> ive checked on this peronally
> bhula chuka maf
>
> Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Gurpreet Singh · 26 Oct 2004
best advice is to jus read gurbani.....and then address these different maryadas with the manmat/gurmat concept in mind...
figure out wot is gurmat....understand all the implications of wot ur rehit mite mean for other ppl around you..
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Kulbir Singh · 26 Oct 2004
Bhain “Singhanee” jee,
Vadhaayee to you on taking amrit. You are certainly a blessed person because you are eager and anxious to follow the strict maryada of Guru Sahib. Unless we follow all hukams of Guru Sahib, we can never get full khushi (mehar, kirpa) of Guru Sahib.
-------------
i seem to be moving towards the ajk marayada because it appeals to me most due to its orthodox way and because i am reading an autobiography on Bhai Randhir Singh. i want to follow Guru ji's way and need to learn strict rehat....
--------------
Bhain jeeo, you are on the right track. Continue to read the books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. In my opinion, Bhai Sahib’s books are next to only Bhai Gurdaas jee’s Vaars and Bhai Nandlal jee’s ghazals. Reading Bhai Sahib’s books gives us greater understanding of Gurbani.
Continue your tilt towards AKJ but I urge you to not follow the example of dhillay (ones who don’t follow rehit) akj members. Follow Gursikhs like Bhai Fauja Singh jee who used to keep strict amritvela and Sarbloh Bibeki Rehit. You can’t go wrong following examples of Mahapurakhs like Bhai Fauja Singh jee.
Never mark any rehit small or big. All rehits for us should be same and we should make earnest effort to follow every hukam of Guru Sahib. Do crazy paath, especially of Siri Jap jee Sahib and Siri Sukhmani Sahib. Also, it would be a good idea if you got darshan of Guru Sahib. One of the ways to get darshan of Guru Sahib is to do Sehaj Paath. Gurbani is Guru Sahib himself. To do Gurbani Paath is also classified as one of the Darshans of Guru Sahib. Of course there are Jyot Vigaaasi Darshans of Guru Sahib too, that only very fortunate ones get.
It is the duty of every Gursikh to do Sehaj Paath of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Such gursikhs who have taken amrit but have not yet done darshan of Guru Sahib by doing complete paath (sehaj) of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee are being very reckless.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Search for Tat · 27 Oct 2004
F.A.O Bhain Jee Singhanee;
A Gurmukh sees sikhi in everyone. For the 3 groups you have mentioned, 95% of the rehit is exactly the same. The other 5% is very close aswell Whether you call keskee a kakkar or not, today all bibian wear one, whether you agree with meat or not, today most do not eat it. The banis are set by the Panth, the rest just read more, no harm in that. As far as ragmala, whether we believe in it or not, very few of us regularly do sehaj paths, so in the end it is just talk. So just follow the rehat which you find logically representing Gurbani. If find it to be AKJ, but you are free to do your research. The Panth is always superior above all beings.
F.A.O Kaur and khalistani:
Why are you so offended? Everytime a discussion happens on rehit, somones comes up with taksal is started by Guru Gobind Singh. No it was not. The Khalsa Panth was started by Guru ji in 1699. This rumour was only started by taksal about 50 years ago, and it is pumped into youth. What makes you the choosen people? You are offended when we disagree. But do you not think we are offended when you keeping repeating this nonsense.
All groups debate their views on rehit. Taksal just says we are started by Guru Gobind singh, or our leaders were mahapurshs. Why cannot you debate your rehit without coming up with usual lines. No-one believes it! Debate your rehit based on Gurbani. Your own youth, when they question some of the contents of taksali rehit, are just brainwashed, "started by Guru Gobind singh, started by Guru Gobind Singh". It is like some kind of mantar.
AKJ youth have always respected taksal,and their jathedars, so do not turn this into we are putting Taksal down. It is usually the other way round where you usually put down AKJ singhs. Most of youth today are mature enough to respect everyone.
Just do not come here with this " we were started by Guru Gobind singh, so everything we say is right, and our way is the only way." Sorry, we are not naive youth, we do not accept this fake argument, and will openly challenge it. Also I will not be bullied into accepting everything you say, because disagreeing with you is like dissing Taksal. If this is the case, then everything you said is dissing the Panth.
Previous Age Comment: this way down unintentionally. Apology to khalistani if he was offended.
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Harpartap Singh · 27 Oct 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
This website has good resources for hard core AKJ maryada.
The Panthic Maryada can be found at :http://allaboutsikhs.com/rehat/index_01.htm
The Gurmat Rehat Maryada is at:
http://www.damdamitaksal.com/lit_rehat.htm
The bottom line is, go to Guru ji for any advice you need. Do Paath, do Ardaasan, do Naam Simran, do Sangat of GurSikhs and Guru ji will bless you with real Gian or knowledge (not earthly/wordly knowledge which we all fight over - look at the postings above!)
Stay on the Path Bhenji :o)
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Mohan Singh · 27 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
I would say all the Rehat Maryadas that Harpartap Singh has mentioned are "Gurmat" and are considered "Gurmat" by those who follow it so I would personally disagree with calling only one of them "Gurmat".
Although we should study all Rehats and take elements from all of them which help us become a better person. Also we should read old Rehatnamas because they have a lot of interesting smaller Rehats we can take on board.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Tut, Tut, tut · 27 Oct 2004
Can harpratap singh elaborate what makes the Damdami Taksal maryada more "Gurmat" than the others?
Was this just a sub-concious sales technique?
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Search for Tat · 28 Oct 2004
[b]******** Admin Note: this is the Last message allowed under this thread**********[/b]
nowhere did I disrespect Taksal. I used the words assols, which means principles as pointed out. Please read what is written, and read without predjudice.
I think an apology is required to admins. This messageboard is far more open than many of others on websites that can be mentioned.
Khalistani - the modern taksal was started by Sant Sundar Singh according to sikh history accepted by mainstream Panthik sources. The only place any mention of it being started by Guru Gobind Singh is in Taksals own books or websites. If you diagree start a new thread and justify it. But do not call people liars. Let your facts speak for you.
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Harpartap Singh · 28 Oct 2004
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
If the admin will allow my post, I used the terminology of the document which is called 'Gurmat Rehat Maryada' (from the Damdami Taksal website) and called the SGPC one the 'Panthic' one because the majority of people regard it as such.
The links were to allow everybody including the bibi starting the thread to have access to different view points. I did not express a preference. In view of many people asking why I used these words, please allow this post.
Re: Which rehat maryada to follow?
Harpartap Singh · 28 Oct 2004
PS by 'hard core AKJ Maryada' I meant that Tapoban propagate a Maryada which is stricter than that espoused by those who call themselves 'AKJ' today.
Again, the words were meant to differentiate with 'mainstream' AKJ who do not believe certain rehats to be compulsory for all Sikhs i.e. sarb loh food, Laarrivaar saroop.
Bhul chuk maaf karni Sangat jio