Simran
*no-knowledge* · 03 Apr 2003
Many AKJ people do simran with a technique known as saas-giraas. More of a breathing technique from what I have seen, with them inhaling "Wahe" and exhaling "Guru". (To give a crude description)
I have no problem with how ANYONE does Simran. I think it doesn't matter as long as you're doing it!
However, if possible, could I have some Gurbani quotes or other strong evidence to tell me why many AKJ (and perhaps other) people use this method for simran?
Again, just a quest for knowledge more than anything else. That's all....
Thank you.
Re: Simran
*no-knowledge* · 03 Apr 2003
my question was not about Simran. I too do simran at Amrit Vela...NAAM simran as you call it. Basically repeating "Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru". But, I don't use the same method as many people from AKJ. Just wondering why the use of that method is taught?
Re: Simran
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2003
What to write about the mehima of Naam with Saas Giraas? Mehima of Naam with Saas Giraas is impossible to state. The Saas Giraas technique of Naam abhyaas was started by Guru Nanak Dev jee himself. There are several pankitis in Gurbani to prove this.
SAAS SAAS SIMRHO GOBIND||
MAN ANTAR KEE UTRAI CHIND||
The sihaari at the end of Saas Saas means that we should simmar (japp) the naam of Gobind through saas saas technique. Guru Sahib further states that doing naam with this technique, removes all worries from our mind.
Here is another pankiti from Gurbani:
Parbaateh kareh ishnaa, Gur pooja, bidh sahit karang||
They (Gursikhs) do ishnaan at the early hours and then do naam abhyaas (Gur pooja) with the technique (bidh sahit). Here too it is stated that only if we do naam with a technique of Guru, we can get the maximum out of naam.
Many old texts contain this reference to this technique of Naam. Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed, clearly writes in "Sikhaan dee Bhagat Maala" book, that how naam is to be recited and he writes this technique of saas giraas.
Sant Attar Singh jee used to do the updesh of this technique and also Bhai Vir Singh jee has written about it. Bhai Raghbir Singh Bir too has written about this technique.
In short, there is no doubt that this is the gurmat technique of Naam abhyaas. Unfortunately today, most amrit sinchaars don't teach the technique of Naam to the seekers. Akhand Kirtani Jatha is one of the few organizations of the world that teach this technique of Naam.
In the amrit sinchaar held at Tapoban Sahib Gurdwara, amrit sinchaar is done according to this puratan maryada of Amrit Sinchaar and Naam dee technique and Keski Kakaar is done drirh.
I have seen many non-akj gursikhs going around, begging in front of the so called sants to teach them Naam. Why do they do so, when they can learn Naam Abhyaas from Punj Pyaare?
Getting Naam from Punj Pyaare but not learning the technique from them is like buying a new car but not knowing how to drive the car. What good is that car if you can't drive it?
We urge everyone who have not taken amrit to come to Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib on April 19th and become part of the Khalsa Panth. On this date an amrit sinchaar has been arranged and I urge all seekers to call the Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib for more details.
We have no time left. Life is getting wasted so fast that it is hard to keep track of it. Let us take amrit from Guru and then quickly walk on the path to our Pritam Pyaara Vaheguru. Without Vaheguru, this life is worse than death.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Simran
*no-knowledge* · 04 Apr 2003
Saas Saas Simroh Gobind...
couldn't this also mean to do simran with every breath that Waheguru has granted you? Perhaps "saas saas" doesn't refer to technique but rather to the fact that one should spend his/her every breath repeating Waheguru..
Re: Simran
Kulbir Singh · 04 Apr 2003
*no-knowledge* wrote:
> Saas Saas Simroh Gobind...
>
> couldn't this also mean to do simran with every breath that
> Waheguru has granted you? Perhaps "saas saas" doesn't refer to
> technique but rather to the fact that one should spend his/her
> every breath repeating Waheguru..
You write that the above pankiti could mean that one should every breath on repeating Vaheguru. What else is the technique of Naam? It is the technique that involves our breath.
As I stated above, all great gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Mani Singh jee shaheed, Sant Attar Singh jee Mastuanawaale, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, Bhai Vir Singh jee, and Bhai Raghbir Singh jee Bir have advocated this style of naam abhyaas.
There is no other way to do naam abhyaas all the time unless we make it part of our swaas. We take swaas all the time, whether we are sleeping or awake. So to do abhyaas with swaas is the best thing to do.
As for the meaning of the pankiti, I already stated that the word "saas" has a sihaari in the end making this noun a "Karan Kaarak" noun. I don't know the English for "Karan kaarak" but it means "Saas Saas naal". or "Saas Saas raahee" i.e. through saas saas.
If it was to mean that we should cover every saas with Vaheguru naam, then the word saas would have had an "aunkad" in the end. Please read Gurbani viyaakaran for more details. They are going to be teaching Gurbani Viyaakaran at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. You can call them for more details.
I will be writing an article on the greatness of Gurbani Viyaakaran very soon.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Simran
*no-knowledge* · 04 Apr 2003
Kulbir Singh Jee,
Are you trying to say that if I do naam abhyaas using a technique other than saas giraas that somehow it is inferior? I was always under the impression that if I say Waheguru all the time it was all that mattered.
If I don't practice this saas-giraas method/technique am I doing something wrong? I know of the Gursikhs that you have mentioned that have advocated this "style" of naam abhyaas. But isn't that just the point? Isn't it just a style when it comes down to it?
I'm sure there have been many OTHER great Guru Pyaaray that have not implemented this technique and have achieved higher states of being.
Whether I say "wahe" while inhaling and "guru" while exhaling
OR....
If I say "Waheguru" all in one breath, isn't it all the same????
Please enlighten me!
Re: Simran
*no-knowledge* · 05 Apr 2003
Mkhalsa Ji,
In fact I have seen many people cry, vibrate, become motionless, etc while just saying Waheguru.
Is no one willing to accept that two different methods of doing Simran can bear the same fruit?
I will be the first to admit that I have no problems with those who do saas giraas simran and those who simply say waheguru. To me it is the same thing.
To simran seva sacrfice,
"best thing to do is if you are already amrit dhaari and have not recieved gurmanter then go do pesh in front of panj next amrit sinchaar (held by the jatha) and ask for naam"
...Why the AKJ?
Re: Simran
Kulbir Singh · 05 Apr 2003
Dear "no-Knowledge",
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Kulbir Singh Jee,
Are you trying to say that if I do naam abhyaas using a technique other than saas giraas that somehow it is inferior?
>>>>>>>>>>
I don't know what is inferior or superior but all I know is that the way to do simran is by swaas swaas. As M Khalsa put it, you will have to experience it yourself. There is no other way. When your time will come, Guru Sahib will bring you to the punj pyaare who will teach you this technique. Until that time you will never understand.
>>>>>>>>>>
I was always under the impression that if I say Waheguru all the time it was all that mattered.
>>>>>>
It is good to say naam as you please and it will have some effect. If you want optimal level results or the maximum out of Naam, then you will have to do naam according to Gurmat technique.
As far as benefit is concerned, you can do Raam Raam or Vaasdev Vaasdev and still get benefit out of it. The question is if you can reach the ultimate by doing naam with your own matt (intelligence). Naam is not learned through intelligence but by kirpa of Guru and through Guru.
>>>>>>>>
If I don't practice this saas-giraas method/technique am I doing something wrong?
>>>>>>
It is better than nothing but if you want to do Gurmat way, I have full faith that there is only one Naam and only one Technique. Rest is all matt of this mann i.e. manmatt.
>>>>>>>
I know of the Gursikhs that you have mentioned that have advocated this "style" of naam abhyaas. But isn't that just the point? Isn't it just a style when it comes down to it?
>>>>>>
If you believe Bhai Mani Singh jee Shaheed, he writes that Guru Nanak Dev jee taught this technique. Same this has been mentioned by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. What more proof do you need?
>>>>>>>>>
I'm sure there have been many OTHER great Guru Pyaaray that have not implemented this technique and have achieved higher states of being.
>>>>>>>>>
Please mention some examples.
>>>>>>>>>>
Whether I say "wahe" while inhaling and "guru" while exhaling
OR....
If I say "Waheguru" all in one breath, isn't it all the same????
>>>>>>>>>>>
No way!! It is not the same. You cannot compare the techniques of your mind with the Gurmat Technique taught by Guru Nanak Dev jee as stated by Bhai Mani Singh jee Shaheed.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh