Re: Need help about my sister
............... · 20 Oct 2004
Sometimes the more you restrict someone the more they rebel.
Usually best thing is to get other young Gursikh bibian to be part of her sangat. let them persuade her on what is right and wrong.
Re: Need help about my sister
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Oct 2004
Reading through the posts on this issue, I would like to share my views also. A Singh states he has many friends from different religions and backgrounds who respect the Gurdwara 'protocol' fully. Mr Singh must be very lucky to be blessed with such great friends. I agree that most (I would say 70%) of the sangat in UK Gurdwaras do 'natter' during religious services and especially during Anand Karaj ceremonies when the Gurdwara is treated like some kind of community centre hosting a fashion show- and these are the Sikhs! I have seen also 'English' guests (goreh) who come to Anand Karaj at the Gurdwara and take karah parshad, don't like the taste and throw it in the toilets on their way out. So, first of all, if we are attending a place of worship which belongs to a different faith than our own, it is important to show the utmost respect, as we would expect from others.
However, the matter of going going to mandir, mosque etc I think is fine if you are attending as a guest etc and do not engage in any anti-gurmat activity, but I know lots of Sikhs who go to Mandir regularly for pooja etc. I found out from one of my aunts, who has a relative who was blessed with a grandson after 3 grand-daughters. This woman had done a 'sukh' that she would do one of these all night ceremonies at the Mandir if she was blessed with a grandson. This, I disagree with- I mean we can't just change our religion to suit us, like some item of clothing. For example, we could be Christians one day of the week because we feel like a drink (as drinking is not forbidden in Christianity), be a Muslim the next day so it's ok to have a cigarette and a Hindu the next so we can cut our hair. As Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale told us- if you are a Hindu- be a firm Hindu, if a Muslim- be a firm Muslim and if you are a Sikh, be a firm Sikh. I mean, look at Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj- his entire family was wiped out, but he didn't go running to the local Mandir and start waving about an arti tray and worshipping idols so he could get the mughals off his back.
All I am saying is we should all have faith in Sikhi- let Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj be our guiding light.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, sri Waheguru ji ki fateh.