Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

want to ask a serious question

want to ask a serious question

moorakh · 16 Oct 2004

i am NOT here to debate dhunee or saas graas, gupt simran or public simran i just want to ask a serious question i was at a smagam and soooooooooo much simran was done... every shabad was about 25 minutes long and 10 minutes were just simran and hundreds of people very passionately with sharda and pyaar doing the simran with lots of energy and so many people got so much anand from it and based on that i'm wondering how one would go about living without this? isn't it difficult ? is the urge to do dhunee simran just a "man ka chaao" ? ? even though so much anand comes from it ?

Re: want to ask a serious question

- · 17 Oct 2004

I personally don't think that the urge to do any type of Simran could be man ka chaao. Bani specifically talks about remembering God. REMEMBERING God. There are different ways that people connect to that.

Re: want to ask a serious question

M Singh · 18 Oct 2004

Anand Anand Sab Ko Kahe Anand Guru Te Janeyaa.

Re: want to ask a serious question

Rain drop · 25 Oct 2004

The topic, gets poor response, on the board. Wonder why?

Re: want to ask a serious question

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 25 Oct 2004

rain drops are falling on my head !!!...sikhs dont like serious topics bro.. just start a frivolous everyday topic and see the Baltiaan pouring....everyone joins in.....but write a serious topic..and the baltiaan become empty and the rain becomes a sprinkle... rain drops keep falling on my head...elton john. jarnail singh

Re: want to ask a serious question

jagjit singh · 25 Oct 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, simran is just a "Mun ka Choa" for those who do infrequently. This could be Amritdhari or non. For those who progress and do it regularly especially for many hours on a daily occurance at Amrit vela. For them it is no longer a "mun ka Cha", but it becomes a Rass. A state of calm descends on them, and they feel a hunger for this taste of sweetness. it is know no longer a "mun ka Chao" but a neccessity. Hence, they wish to do it as often as possible. They may obtain spiritual powers or fame, but the focussed Gursikhs realise its insignificance in front of spiritual magic that they experience in every emotion that is fed by Gurbani. Can you ask someone who has felt the phenomenon of Parenthood, to give up their child, and replace it with a barbie doll/teddy bear. Then ask them if playing with that teddy bear is a "Mun ka Chao"? They will say no, experince parenthood, and experience the magic that exists every day playing with your own child. Watch that child grow, and develop into an amazing individual. That is what your sprituality is. Watch it grow, and see its magic, and enjoy the experience. It is beyond words. A "Mun ka chao" is buying a new car, or new clothes, etc. It is not simran, especially if you do it properly. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: want to ask a serious question

rain drop · 28 Oct 2004

I do not go after the term " Man ka Chao", yet I agree not with Simran during Kirtan. I find serious "problems" arising in AKJ due to this practice. That is against Gurmat ( God ----forgive me). I have an alternative suggestion. Every Kirtania who starts Dhuni in Kirtan, shoud be asked to spend a proportionately bigger time in Simran in isolation. Say------ Two minutes Simran during Kirtan should be linked with Twenty hours simran in isolation. And then let them do, what they like.

Re: want to ask a serious question

Rain drop · 18 Nov 2004

No body agreed with me, I am alone with my views. That stands heavy on my heart. I apologise for my harsh talk.

Re: want to ask a serious question

khalistani · 19 Nov 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! i also do not agree in dhuni in keertan the meaning of AKHAND keertan means unbroken keertan ive heard bhai randheer singh je himself never ever did simran in their keertan bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: want to ask a serious question

Mkhalsa · 20 Nov 2004

i agree and disagree. I agree that it shouldnt be done. Because the vast majority of akj does it because 1) they think they are supposed to 2) they feel that without it, their keertan seems incomplete 3) it sounds cool 4) it hypes up the keertan and the sangat 5) without it, they are just doing keertan and its over.. theres a whole number of reasons.. but there are others who do it (i will cite dr pritam singh anjaan here) who do it with such love and gain such rass from it, that there is no falsehood in it, it is entirely from their heart, pure simran, that in no way can be against gurmat. These singhs dont do it for any of the above reasons. I know a number of singhs that fall into this category. On the other hand I know a lot more who fall into the above category. So, Yes simran should be done in keertan, and No simran should not be done in keertan. :)

Re: want to ask a serious question

Singh · 20 Nov 2004

rain drop jee, I agree with you completely. Dhuni breaks the attention from the shabad.

Re: want to ask a serious question

ms · 20 Nov 2004

i think there is nothign wrong with doing simran during keertan because its just remembering Waheguru during your shabad, but yet i believe in rain drops suggestion taht they should spend 20 hours doing simran in isolation if they spend 2 minutes doing it during a shabad...and some people should jsut stop worrying about other peoples faults and worry about their own

Re: want to ask a serious question

maybe · 21 Nov 2004

what does raindrop specifically mean about this?!

Re: want to ask a serious question

ManjitKaur · 21 Nov 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa wahegurun ji ki fateh. You are not alone rain drop ji. Adding simran to a shabad means we are trying to "improve" Gurbani...some just add a lone WAHEGURU here and there....some add more...and more...and then it becomes SIMRAN of 5 minutes in the shabad and then the shabad continues... I also beleive it shouldnt be done. Either do a solid SIMRAN only or KIRTAN only..not a MIXTURE. IF Guru ji wanted us to "remeber" Waheguru during every shabd they would have written down WAHEGURU all over the shabads...BUT they DIDNT. Are we so "?????" to think that we are "remeembering" Waheguru by INSERTING the word....and by IMPLICATION we are telling that GURU JI "FORGOT" Waheguru when they didnt INSERT the word in every shabad ??? IF Waheguru is in the shabd say it..if it is not dont. By the way I DONT DO any Kirtan as I dont have GURU JI's KIRPA on me ..I am tone deaf !!! and cant even Sing along in TUNE. Dassree Manjit Kaur

Re: want to ask a serious question

ms · 21 Nov 2004

but think of it this way...should we only believe what we read because we can read so many things and you wont know what to believe sometimes you have to your own perspective into these kinds of things, like teh issue of raagmala, you have to add your own perspective and opinion

Re: want to ask a serious question

mrsinghsahib · 22 Nov 2004

I agree with MKhalsa jee - the most important thing in whether deciding whether there should be Simran in a shabad is the "Bhaavnaa" with which it is done - if it is just done becos it seems the cool AKJ thing to do, rather than pyaar for Shabad/Gurbani, then it seems to be wrong. Without meaning in anyway to disrespect some AKJ keertaniyas, it seems that sometimes that simran is added just for the sake of it. But on the other hand, it is tricky, becos there's some Youth I know that only go to AKJ programs becos of the Dhuni of "Waheguru, Waheguru" - they initially found it a novelty how people in the Sangat could be so captured by chanting Waheguru, Waheguru. But having entered the Sangat, and seeing SikhitotheMax English translations of Gurbani, they actually became interested in Gurbani and its meanings - this would never have occurred had it not been for the initial distinct Simran in the Keertan. Also, when there's loads of simran in a Shabad or Smaagam - when you leave, you sometimes walk away with the Simran of Waheguru in your mind or the shabad sticks in your memory - that is surely a good thing. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: want to ask a serious question

LostPrincess · 22 Nov 2004

I agree with Mkhalsa, because ever since i have started going to rainsabyees, etc, I have noticed that majority of it is simran. Not a bad thing. There may be really chardi kala ones into the simran when its done with josh, that's coz they have probabally experienced the ras. They know the real ras, but what is real ras. Even I dont know. That's why a person like me just keeps repeating waheguru, and I admit, 90 % of the time it's just mechanically. And afterwards I feel really bad about it when I realize what's the point when I didn't do it with the heart. LIke Mkhalsa said, I think people have thought of it as a necessity to do simran during keertan at rainsabyees, otherwise it's not a rainsabyee. I think that simran should be done, but with pyaar. And If it brings pyaar in you by doing simran for only a limited amount of time, say 1 or 2 min, even that's enough. Waheguru jee ka khalsa Waheguru jee ki fateh!

Re: want to ask a serious question

Rain drop · 23 Nov 2004

So, I am not alone with my views. I feel light- weight and thankful fo contibuters. The first post, said, he did not want to start a debate, but it started. He says, Anand is there with Dhuni sometimes and why say no to Anand ? Some posts also say Anand and other benfits are there of "Dhuni in Kirtan". I also enjoy seeing the faces of those Gursikhs, who look enjoying. That gives anand and inspiration. Sometimes, Simran also gets some kick-start; but generally not. and often I come back "empty handed". If brothers are enjoying it, that is OK. Certainly, there is somthing wrong with me. I try find fault in me. This is happening for years. I have no much Simran in my "Bank Balance". I know Kirtananias are must to be respected. They need our love. They are a special lot. Guru speaks through them.