Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Amandeep · 15 Oct 2004

Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by Radio 4 15th October, 2004 On the 20th anniversary of the storming of the Golden Temple by Indian government forces, a dramatic controversy over the restoration of the holy shrine still remains. In a documentary on Radio 4 next week, the BBC's Navdip Dhariwal explores the strange story of conflict between a Birmingham based group and professional conservationists in India. When Indira Gandhi sent the military into the Golden Temple in 1984, many parts in and around the shrine were damaged. An extensive restoration drive, which is now nearly completed, had been led by volunteers from the biggest Gurudwara (Sikh temple) 8,000 miles away - here in Birmingham, UK. However, their well meaning actions have run into a barrage of criticism from professional conservationists in India. With the Golden Temple now being considered for World Heritage status, the issue has become much more topical. For the programme, Navdip Dhariwal, the BBC's new South Asia correspondent, travelled to the holy city of Amritsar Punjab where she met a leading conservation architect, Gurmeet Rai. Rai is highly critical of the work that has been carried out and is now overseeing a complete architectural survey of the Golden Temple site as part of the bid to get World Heritage status. "I came hear and saw the sort of work they were doing I tried to get it stopped but no-one was listening. It's crass and if you are going to decorate the house of our Lord with plastic stickers then I think it is appalling." "The Harmandir Sahib (Golden Temple) is the history of the Sikh faith for over 400 years and to replace this with modern material which is historically unsympathetic is criminal," she added. Rai's criticism is backed by the Sikh historian Patwant Singh, who told the BBC that the Birmingham group has been over-zealous in the determination to serve the faith. "Generosity is fine. Voluntary service or kar seva is brilliant. But it doesn't mean ignoring principles of conservation, then it becomes an ego trip: I'll do it but on my terms. When I saw the Golden Temple finally emerge from the scaffolding and I was shocked." The Birmingham based group in charge of the restoration however hits back at criticism. Mohinder Singh, the Chairman of the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sevak Jatha, said: "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding. My conscience is clear. This is the 400th anniversary of our holy book, a very important anniversary. But, for people who made objections for nothing, the Golden Temple remains un-cleaned inside. This is the damage that was done." Gold Service: Radio 4 at 11am, on Monday 25th October. Produced by Ashok Ahir & Jeremy Davies. Presented by Navdip Dhariwal.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ns · 15 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh This article is true on every word apart from what Mohinder Singh says "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding" sure history will have this record, but also has the record that you are saying the word ""I"" , however Maharaja Ranjjit Singh who was not even amritdhari had a plate visible to this day on the at Harmandir Sahib saying that it was "Guru Ramdas Ji who made the sevak of this Gurdwara", now that is what Mohinder Singh should be saying, I even remember when the sewa was happpening and I was at Amritsar, there were massive banners that Baba from Birmingham is doing the sewa nothing about Guru Ji at all onthose banners, I can't beleive the panth didn't have the strentgh to preevent this happenning the way it did, even to this day the Harmindar Sahib Ji is sipping with water from the inside so I hear..

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Disturbed · 16 Oct 2004

I am deeply disturbed by "Bhai Sahib Jee's" arogance. If thats what he said then he should be pulled-up on it. Has "Nishkaam Sevak" now been replaced by "I Did It and I want the Glory!!"

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

help · 17 Oct 2004

before anyone else says anything i think it would be more progressive to sit down and ask bhai sahib in what context he meant that under. If you look at the article itself its one directional. Im sure sometimes you have come across a critic, now you go and say something but could have meant something else by it and next thing you know someone has taken it the wrong way entirely. I could turn around and say to you i am responsible myself for a wall being painted in your house. TO you that may mean hes so arrogant and boasting about what hes done. But from my view i could have meant that if anything is wrong or anything messes up then i take responsibility as i am the one who did it. I would request anyone else just take a trip down soho rd birmingham and meet bhai sahib face to face and ask him what he meant by that as without that you cant exactly judge his comments. Someone else has first vocied their opinion (bbc) as well as patwant sing followed by this. "History will record that I was responsible for doing the gold gilding. My conscience is clear."

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

a singh · 18 Oct 2004

well said, Help Ji. rather than assuming things and slandering bhai sahib on the internet, this issue can be discussed and resolved with bhai sahib himself. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Amandeep · 18 Oct 2004

In their zeal to re-guild the Harimandir what they did was to seal the buildings original lime plast and stopped the building from venting the moisture from the brickwork. As a result there is waterlogging inside the brickwork and the marbleis quickly greying inside the building - soon this will be irepairable. they also plastered over valuable wallpaintings that were on the original Harimandir (underneath the guilding carried out by Maharaja Ranjti Singh). these would have been valuable insights into the original building as enviged by the Guru - alas they exist no more. Finally, the GNNSJ tore off most of the old guilded copper panels that Ranjti Singh had commisioned for the HArimandir and had them remade ! the new ones (that are now on the building) are shoddy copies of the originals and are ina garish yellow gold. No one has adequalty answered the question of what happened to the priceless originals. Aman

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ns · 18 Oct 2004

A singh, the truth is the truth is what I saw with my own eyes, whether you or anyone likes or not, this is not slandering or nindyia dom't twist it that way it's a serious issue , comments by Amandeep Singh Ji are 100% correct perr word, if not go and see there for your self.........

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Das · 18 Oct 2004

>>Mohinder Singh, the Chairman of the Guru Nanak Nishkam Sevak Jatha, said: ........... ... This is the 400th anniversary of our holy book, Sadh Sangat Ji , excuse my ignorance but are we supposed to refer to Guru Ji as a book? Or is the usage of word 'book' when referring to Guru Ji reserved and acceptable for those who reside at the Guru Ghar? Bhul Chuk Maaf /Das

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

S Singh · 18 Oct 2004

A Singh The core issue is not the comments by Bhai Sahib but the unwarranted destruction of OUR heritage by their unplanned seva. If they had planned properly and consulted experts rather than doing the seva as if it was a 100metre race has meant that we are now faced with a damaged Darbar Sahib (structure wise). They can still do a u turn, consult experts and put right the rash job that was done.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

a singh · 18 Oct 2004

NS Ji, please dont take my post as 'pointing the finger' and saying that Amandeep Singh Ji is doing nidyia. i 100% believe that he is not and has simply bought the matter to the attention of the sangat on this forum. i was just trying to put across the fact that the opportunity/possibility to speak directly with bhai sahib does exist to establish further details and clarification. please accept my apologies for 'twisting it that way'. kind regards. VaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Bundha · 18 Oct 2004

Guys, I think everyones heart is in the right place. I suggest that these valid questions should be taken to Bhai Sahib Ji. An interview should be requested and all the points put to them. And then report back to the Sangat here as to what Bhai ji had to say. The issues raised are very serious and I cannot understand why the Sangat of Soho Road would not have sat down and discussed all these things first, they all seem to be very learned people. I hope someone will listen to the Radio 4 program and report here what it had to say, as it is aired during the day when most sangat will be at work. The banners depicting who is doing the sewa I do not agree with, Gupt sewa is the best.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ONE · 18 Oct 2004

GurFateh ! It may not be too late - if you click on this link ; http://www.sikhifm.net/PHOTOS/2004/india04/index/dsc_4318.htm it appears as if the priceless originals have not thankfully gone missing, been melted down or given out as souvenirs - but are in "storage" - We may even see them back in their rightful place soon ????? or am I being a little naive ?

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ns · 18 Oct 2004

a singh Ji, apology accepted no problem, I wonder can it really be resovled by speaking to Bhai Sahib, Amandeep Ji, do you think it's possible to speak to Bhai Mohinder Singh Ji,I 'am sure your probably aware of this communication anyway, it would help to enlighten the cyber sangat here. Has there been any communication with Bhai Mohinder Singh since the discovery of the wrong doings??

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Amandeep · 19 Oct 2004

The picture is useful. Its interesting to see this becuase during the 98-99 project the GNNSJ asserted quite strongly that the old panels were being buried ! I heard this directly from them on numerous occasions (although not from Bhai MOhinder Singh). However, a store room is completely the worng place for these extremelly precious objects. Why on earth are they not on the building that they were so expertly made for ? why on earth were they torn off in the first place? what kind of damage was done to them in ripping them off? have they been inventoried? what are the security arrnagement? Shoudl the SGPC find out the value to any collecotr of these plates I am certain that they will slowly start to be ferreted away from this room - its incredibly dangerous to have these things stacked in a storgae room in Amritsar. I doubt whether there is the foresight or the will to replace the shoddy garish modern reproductions that are on the Harimandir now with the originals - I hope that brave women like Gurmeet Rai will break through the Cabal of the SGPC and kar sev Babas and restore the Harimandir somehow. Aman

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

member · 19 Oct 2004

As Amandeep Singh Ji knows very well - the destruction of Sikh History does not stop at Harmindhar Sahib. Gurmeet Rai has worked on several conservation projects and has also been threatened due to her outspoken nature. Before the run up to the 300th Anniversary of the Khalsa, a new Road was built through Anandpur. She had tried to prevent this new build as it destroyed many historical landmarks of the town. In a talk at the V&A she also pointed out that the size of the Fort (Anandgarh) has been reduced significantly over the years. Her slides showed the real boundary of the orginal fort. After the attack in '84 many over enthusiastic Sikhs tore down the Akal Takht which was far from complete destruction. Through this act alone we have lost forever any old frescos and artwork. The infamous bathroom tiles at Baba Atal is another case in point. Although Gurmeet Kaur did not specifically point out that this was a concerted organised effort by GOI to wipe Sikh History, it was clear that this is what she was implying.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Harbhajan Singh · 20 Oct 2004

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!! When I saw the Sri Harimander Sahib completed, It took my breath away. It was soo shiny and beautiful that one was dazed and had to sit down to take in the beauty. However there were reports that the the Gold was turning darker in colour and there were black marks appearing. There was also a suggestion that it had to be cleaned reguarly to keep the Gold effect. However we all must be aware of Sikh politics in India. Even though SGPC is the supreme body there are many rich Sikh Organisations in the World and GNNJ is one of the most wealthiest. In the Sikh mindset money can get you the best thing in life. the seva for the Harimander Sahib was a great honour for anyone to be blessed with. However the SGPC should have taken care of the seva themselves and asked the Sikh Sangat worldwide to contribute to it. The reason behind this is that when one organisation gets seva they do it to the best of their abilities, however being based outside India does not help. Now their is contreversy over both the Sri Harimander Sahib and also the leaking of water in the Akal Thakt which is the reason why SGPC even though there is many question marks over them aswell should have a commitee of learned architects who know the history of the construction of these Gurdwaras. Bhai Mohinder Singh probably was mis qouted and if he wasn't then his statement is out of line. He is head of a large organisation and should know better to use I in his statement. His supporters will say that you should meet him face to face and get the answers. However if he has said what he has said then we do not need answers. No one should slander him on the Internet as thats not right, but I suggest he has a Media person assigned to him to make sure that he does not say the wrong things, they definatley have the money to employ some one. However if the damage is as Amandeep Singh says then GNNJ should make sure that it has been rectified by any means necessary. If the BBC is investigating then it is not damaging to GNNJ but to the Sikh panth as the Panth could not even stop what seems to be not a restoration but a botched job. Hopefully NO organisation will be given the seva but given the oppertunity to raise funds instead. Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

....... · 22 Oct 2004

Does anyone have any pictures of the harminder sahib after the new gold was put on it????

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Amandeep · 22 Oct 2004

This "issue" has been going on for years - I attach below an article that appeared in The Independant (London) back in 1999. Even after this the GNNSJ remained characteristically tight lipped - maybe this radio documentary will make them listen - quite honestly I doubt it Headline: Brummies bodge Sikhs’ holy shrine Journalist: Peter Popham Date: 25 September 1999 Source: The Independent Story: IN THE middle of an artificial lake gleams a golden pavilion. It is the holy of holies of the Sikh religion, and an architectural masterpiece to rival the Taj Mahal. But unlike the latter, this is a shrine throbbing with life. Day and night, plangent Sikh hymns roll across the water. Every day thousands of Sikh pilgrims from all over the world stream through, bathing in the holy waters and prostrating themselves before the holy book. Outsiders are welcomed: two years ago the Queen and Prince Philip were given a tour of the complex, and a model of it to take home as a souvenir. But despite all the love and attention, the Golden Temple in the northern Indian city of Amritsar is under dire threat - ironically, from pious Sikhs who devote all their spare time and money to the shrine. In the name of renovation and improvement, groups of karsevaks, or volunteers, throw themselves into doing their bit for the temple. Prominent among them is a group of British Sikhs from Birmingham, the Guru Nanak Nishkam Jatha. But nobody in the temple exercises informed control over the renovation work that gets done, with the result that this 200-year-old masterpiece is being steadily defaced, distorted and vulgarised. In an octagonal nine-storey tower erected 200 years ago in memory of a nine-year-old martyr, 19th century frescoes depicting the life of Guru Nanak, the religion's founder, have been scraped off the walls and replaced by avocado green bathroom tiles. The holiest spot in the complex is the Harimandir Sahib, the Abode of God, in the centre of the lake, reached by a 200-yard causeway. This is where the holy men sit continuously singing hymns, while devotees troop in and out. The upper part of the Harimandir gleams golden: the copper plates it is made of are thickly covered in gold leaf. The entire roof has recently been renovated by the Sikhs from Birmingham, a work that took four years to complete. But experts in Sikh architecture charge that, in their zeal, the craftsmen hired by the Birmingham devotees have done irreparable damage to the roof, plastering cement over paintings which lay underneath the original copper sheets, thereby destroying them. The Akal Takht is the other holy spot in the complex, the building to which the holy book, the Granth Sahib, is ritually carried every day. The original structure, a delicate brick pavilion, was blown apart by Indian army tanks in 1984, when Indira Gandhi demanded that secessionist Sikh terrorists who had seized it should be killed. Afterwards the pavilion was razed to the ground and rebuilt - but the replacement is a hulking ferro-concrete building with none of the grace of the original. The stream of believers and the singing of hymns ensure a serene mood inside. But the canopy suspended over the holy book, garish pink and fringed like a bedcover, alerts one to the fact that Sikh aesthetics are not what they once were. Upstairs on scaffolding, Harbhajan Singh and his sons, local artisans, are painting the ceiling. Their work is precise and highly detailed, but the colours they use - cream and orange and blue and yellow and pink - would look more at home on a carousel in a fairground. "Did you have this colour scheme approved by the temple authorities?" I asked him. "No, no, I chose it myself," he replied. "I don't have to get permission from anyone. I've been painting here since 1955. Nobody tells me what to do." For many years, educated Sikhs have kept quiet about the stealthy, well-intentioned desecration that is overtaking the Golden Temple and other of Sikhism's historical treasures. But now they are making their indignation known. "These people are showing utter lack of sensitivity towards our heritage," says Patwant Singh, a noted authority on Sikh art and architecture. "Despite the resoluteness with which Sikhs have risen to every challenge, our generation has not been able to face the challenge of conserving its heritage." Gurmeet Rai, an architectural historian who has made a systematic study of the historic buildings of Punjab for Unesco, said: "They are killing the essence of what the religion is. People are concerned - believers are concerned about it - but nobody is organised to make their voices heard." The crux of the problem is the way the Golden Temple and all other historical gurudwaras - or temples - are run. The controlling body is an organisation called the Shiromani Gurudwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC). But it is said to be riven by factional politics, and has no conservation experts to guide its policy. Patwant Singh said: "The SGPC has more money than they know what to do with. They must stop all physical intervention by outside bodies like the Birmingham group. They have to establish that no historical gurudwaras will be touched unless the work is vetted by them." Most of the Birmingham Sikhs have left Punjab now. One who remains, an elder named Mehnga Singh with a kindly face and a magnificent long white beard, complains of false accusations. "It was quite wrong to blame us for putting bathroom tiles in the Babar Atal," he said. "That was nothing to do with us. We only did the gold leaf work in the Haramandir. And we have nothing whatever to do with the SGPC." Both SGPC spokesmen were out of town and unavailable for comment.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ns · 22 Oct 2004

Amandeep Ji, Many Thanks for putting this article out, it is of great importance, I commend Gurmeet Rai Ji's ,efforts lets' hope she gets through the SGPC one day. We the sikhs sitting here like myself typing on the keyboard need to support her and others who really are making the effort. I can, without any doubt say that there is probably a whole generation of Sikhs out in the western world who are not aware of the truthful points rasied above.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

ONE · 25 Oct 2004

Gurfateh ! you can listen to this BBC Radio 4 programme at their website click on this link ; http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/atoz/index.shtml#g Then click on the programme name "Gold Service"

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

sikh · 25 Oct 2004

admins probably wont let this post go through but i got to say this... nishkam sevak jatha has a lot of power and influence in many places! the actions of there baba/spiritual leader (i thought Guru Ji was our spiritual leader/teacher/guide etc.) border on the arrogant towards other sikhs. they seem to think they are the only true sikhs in the world. its interesting to note that in the radio peice it says that the birmingham gurdwara looks towards harmandair sahib for guidance i dont see that in their langar halls where u sit to eat. listen to the radio peice and the words of the baba and make ur own judgements, lets all pray that sesne is seen quickly and that these people stop destroying our heritage and history.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

kaur · 25 Oct 2004

dear sikh whilst i agree with most that this topic is of grave concern and needs to be taken up immedietly with the project holders, u have no right to accuse someone of being arrogant until you clarify with bhai sahib exactly what context he made that comment under. Its only fair you talk to him and ask him. other gurdwaras which include singh sabhas also have a section for tables and chairs and other parts for seating on the floor. That gurdwara just happens to be bigger and has its main langar area on the floor, and other rooms for larger occasions. I suggest you dont use this opportunity as a pot shot. The akhal takhat also says you cant eat halal yet we also say we support the akhal takhat but in what context? thats it ji we want ekta in the panth and look to akhal takht for guidance, if someone uses that as a potshot against us its not nice. Dont accuse bhai sahib of things without first a face to face meet. U cant draw conclusions like that from a radio interview i suggest you go down soho rd and ask for a meeting and dialogue ji. For the better we should look fwd, we have a problem, and here is an organisation that can still rectify matters so why point fingers when we can still solve matters? Before you ask im not a follower of any group i dont believe in santhood.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

GurrooVaah · 25 Oct 2004

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/factual/rams/mon1102.ram

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

sikh · 26 Oct 2004

kaur ji pls i have no intention of ever wanting to speak to the baba and i hope i am never in the vicinity where my path may cross his. i have had 1st hand experience of the baba and his followers/assistants/chelas and derive my conclusions of there arrogance from my 1st hand experiences and not from a radio interview. and other singh sabhas have 1 or 2 tables not 40 or 50 tables and chairs. anyway i dont want to get into any type of debate about this baba i really couldn't give a toss i just wish the wider path would wake up and take notice that maintaining our heritage and history is the responsibility of every sikh and not some personality led cult which thinks it is above any sikh and sikh institution. and my guru/teacher/spiritual guide is guru granth sahib ji

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

kaur · 26 Oct 2004

then sikh ji as you wish, u have your own views. the gurdwara has a very large sangat that is amritdhari, non amritdhari compared to most singh sabhas. weddings also take place there, although i dont see eye to eye with everything there BUT i dont see why u or anyone else shud use this as an opportunity to take side shots at different rehets. The topic itself is about darbar sahib. If that gurdwara is guilty of tables and chairs then so is every other singh sabha gurdwara where we hold samagams and rensbhais that also have tables and chairs. the quantity is not the issue whether its two rows or ten rows as that is determined by numbers. The issue would then be tables and chairs which would apply to every singh sabha we hold smaagam or resnbhai in. i think thats a bit harsh saying i dont give a toss, his name is bhai mohinder singh and if you have a problem then talk face to face why hide behind a computer? no need to make up excuses. i also share your concerns about darbar sahib and believe sikhs should collectively hold a dialigue rather than accuse him of being arrogant thats just twisted and remarks like that just wont progress this matter of concern. personality cult? isnt that what nihungs say jatha is about? are we any better than those who accuse us? bhai mohinder did not found nanak nishkam jatha. Instead of taking cheap shots i suggest you talk face to face.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

sikh · 26 Oct 2004

kaur ji what on earth are you talking about, are you even reading my posts or are you just replying blindly? i am not going to enage u futher in this post, as its a waste of time and i dont want it to detract from the main issue this post was started on. but i will say a few things in reply to your previous post. i have said throughout and since my first post, i dont need to speak to him nor do i want to, as i have constantly said my comments and thoughts are based on 1st hand experiences, what are yours founded on or do we have another blind chela follower in our midsts? the actions of this group speak for themselves if you care to stop, listen and view! and i was not taking side shots as you said i was stating fact, and its not the only gurdwara which holds weddings etc! read through the lines carefully and keeping in view that Guru Granth Sahib Ji is your Guru its plain to see that this personality led cult/group are effectively promoting there baba as the leader of sikhi in the western hemisphere. is it gurmat to have articles associated with previous figures heads of this group revered to the extent that people pay there respects to these articles by bowing down to them? i'm sorry if the above is rather harsh or agressive. but i can't stand it when we have people who think they own the religion and know best. as i keep saying to you i have had a very revealing 1st hand experience of this baba, and what is projected to the wider community is not what i experienced myself. respect is earned not given you may call him bhai mohinder singh but to me he is mohinder singh. sorry admins if i have pushed the limits with this post.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Anon Singh · 26 Oct 2004

"sikh" please share with us your experiences with Bhai Mohinder Singh and his followers. I am sure the Admin will have no problem you putting it up providing it is just truthful and there is no unneccesary attacks on him. So please do share what happened with the Sangat.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

uk singh · 26 Oct 2004

this was a reply to the last post of Amandeep Singh by Datta Singh Khalsa During her university years Awtar Kaur Khalsa was a student of Lloyd Reynolds, a renowned American calligrapher at Reed College. At Siri Harimander Sahib she admired the workmanship of a hand lettered original copy of the Siri Guru Granth Sahib, from which a pathi was reading on the roof of the Golden Temple. Her wonderment quickly turned to dismay, she noticed several areas of the manuscript had been taped and next to the reader lay a roll of scotch tape. Dismay turned to horror - as only a student of hand lettered works of antiquity can experience - as the pathi began to scribble with a ball point pen, intentionally defacing and obliterating the original wording of the manuscript. He added something to the margin and then, changing his mind, scribbled over this and wrote something else. Several sections of this once beautiful original manuscript seemed to have been so mistreated, or had been altered with the use of a "White-out" product, scotch-tape and paper. Such originals deserve to receive appropriate consideration as a part of Sikh heritage, to be treated with great care. It is indeed advisable that those in positions of responsibility promulgate policies for the protection and preservation of such assets, lest these priceless relics be lost to the random acts of well-meaning sevadars. Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru,

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

kaur · 26 Oct 2004

i can see where this post is now heading im not taking part in this. all the best and just to confirm this so called "blind follower" does not believe in santhood never has never will. Im really shocked how you can accuse me of being a follower, is that what ur sikhi is based on judging others? if you do any justice to the name sikh then talk directly like a normal sikh would. carry on please If you are genuine about *the darbar sahib issue as others you would take it up directly than spread things on here.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Amandeep · 27 Oct 2004

I have been posting about the BBC radio program on quite a few message boards and also on my email lists. In none of these emails/message baords did I make an derogatory references to Bhai Mohinder Singh. However, I found the reaction of his followers really interesting. I recieved quite a few anonymous menacing emails reminding me just how influential that he is especially in India ! Also, in other, less threatening emails, they all say that I shoudl take up the issue directly with him. This is exactly the same argument that "kaur" takes up. What is interesting about this is that the followers of GNNSJ really dotn have the strength of their own convictions they always defer responsibility and responses to Bhai Mohinder Singh. I think it's clear that the GNNSJ have bodged badly the work at the Darbar Sahib but rather than try to put this right they are doggedly defending the indefensible. I for one, am relly happy that they were not allowed to get their hands on the inside of the Harimandir. Had they done so and carried out such a poorly thought our restoration geenrations to come woud regret that . What the GNNSJ and Bhai Mohinder Singh can do is to humbly take some expert advise from people like Gurmeet Rai and other workd experts and reverse some of the interventions that they have made. Aman

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

kaur · 27 Oct 2004

amandeep singh i havent accuised you of anything. My history is more anti sant than most of you would know, i have come to the conclusion that sikhs shoulkd work together when faced with problems such as this and just accept their different. I do not wish to get drawn into debates and have repeated myself over, there is a problem so lets solve it rather than sitting on our pcs using words like arrogant etc. why create a dividing line when the issue is not even solved? my argument? i am not a follower for the third time. If you like others want to keep crucifieing me for my own viewpoint than i cant take no more of these attacks your being intolerant. My strentgh i draw from Guru Granth Sahib Ji and that who is who i am responsible to. Im getting sick of these accusations. the work is dodgy. There are you happy? now that group still have the resources and finances to correct matters exactly why i am saying go and have a meeting with them to let them know and ask them what theyr doing to put it right? Now why dont you and sikh go to soho rd and talk face to face with bhai mohinder singh about this? and finally i am sick of being verbally attacked as a follower directly or indirectly.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

sikh · 27 Oct 2004

kaur bhenji sorry if i painted you as a sant/baba follower but you kinda of imply that you are by the way you write, ok its unintentional but thats how others percieve it. anyway peace ok. ok my experiences :- well i was privy to an insight into mohinder singhs inner circle recently when i was a guest of other sikhs who were meeting mohinder singh on some sikh business thing. what i witnessed was mohinder singh allowing openly other sikhs who had come especially to see him to touch his feet, he was sitting on a sofa and these sikhs came up got on their knees and touched his feet some just bowed very low, and he placed his hand on there heads. not once did he try to refrain them from doing this. he was actually enjoying it. two of his assistants if you may call them that, were attneding to him like say a Sikh would serve guruji! i was shocked that these people could not see anything else but him. when these two guys had nothing to do they sat infront of him totally silent their hands clasped and pointing towards him. others were videoing and photographing him to the extent that i thought this must be his last day on this earth. words which were said during meeting :- throughout this entire meeting mohinder singh was a active member in the discussions which took place so he was hearing and talking in the meeting, i say this as some people may say he did not hear anything which was being said, i.e he is not at fault many times his people would say in the meeting that only if bhai sahib takes full control of the venture which was being propsed could success be achieved, it became so blatant that it was frankly embrassing and insulting to the other sikhs who had come to this meeting, what they wanted was the other sikhs to come under the banner of gnnsj eitherwsie they did not want to do business, no compromise nothing total control and ignorance and non-recognition of other peoples efforts. and then the biggest shock for me was when he made mohinder singh a disparaging remark about the singhs who fought during the troubles in the 80 and 90s effectively calling them troublemakers, after which he went on to glorify the success of his organisation and how it was the only sikh organisation which could do what it wanted in india and not be troubled by the authorities. before this meeting i had respect for him as a sikh but after experiencing this i was just thankful that guruji showed me what they had so that i can stay clear of people and organisations like these. i could get into the nitty gritty but there is no need, you can make your own judgements from this.

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Tony Singhprano · 27 Oct 2004

kaur i thought you weren't "taking part in this"......but you continue to post. your quote "there are you happy?" stinks of arrogance the fact is they butchered the job, did they even consult anyone (historians, engineers, architects) it seems like a group of them went down to the local Home Depot, bought some supplies and went to work. if you want to see how things are done right look no further then the Vatican. just goes to show that they have more money then brains. Tony Singhprano

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

kaur · 27 Oct 2004

singhprano why are you twisting this around to attack me further? i tried gracefully to leave this topic, while anotehr person came back accusing me indirectly of being a follower when i have no such beliefs. When you get tired of being attacked on a gurmat site you respond. ok maybe theres a communication problem, this is a gurmat forum, not a place to attack, hide behind a pc spit a few words of venom. are you a sikh? then what is the role of a sikh after dutifully informing the sangat? take action, so what action has been taken or will be? Thats why i didnt get involved too much and still feel theres no answers in moaning here but to hold a meeting if i wreak of arrogance im sorry, but dont try reverse pschology on me. Thats why i suggested gursikhs from here go to that gurdwara and meet the party responsible for the repairs. Now please can i leave this topic without being attacked further?

Re: Golden Temple restoration controversy investigated by BBC

Admin · 27 Oct 2004

Unless someone has something constructive to add to this debate, this thread is closed.