NanakSar
Confused.ORG · 15 Oct 2004
This Singh in chitaa Chola.. a Nanaksari (im not labelling him but thats what he called himself did some Vichar with me.
The talk turned to why Langar isnt prepared at Nanaksari Gurdawareh, im woundering if someone can explain to me why not. His story went along something 'Vadeh Mahapursh used to go 'mang' for parshadAA' and then something happened and 'Vadeh Mahapursh' said to the singhs, not to beg anymore, if parshdAA comes then accept it.. Hence why Langar is accepted when bought from houses. I dont understand it! I dont know much about NanakSar but i find it hard to accpet it to be right.
Re: NanakSar
strange/pakhand/reasons? · 15 Oct 2004
if any one can also answer the following ?s abt nanaksar of why they do the following:
1. no nishan sahib is at "nanaksar Gurdwaras"
2. a gate is made around SGGSJ and no one is allowed to do parkarma (this one needs to be explained)
3. picture if baba nand singh ji is placed next to Sat Guru Ji and in the evening it is covered with a curtain and "baba ji is asleep" and also a daatan and bowl of water is placed so "baba ji may brush his teeth"
4. stuffed animals (tigers and lions) are placed in front of Guru Ji
5. as asked above no langar is made
6. large portaits of Guru Nanak Dev Ji (similar to one that bab nand singh had made after he had partak darshan) are surrouding the tabeya
one good note i did notice tho was that someone was always in hajoori doing chaur sahib/ reading from SGGSJ
but can sum1 give the reason for the above poionts? esp why parkarma of Guru Ji is not allowed (how does someone get married in "nanaksar Gurdwara?)
not tryna rile anyone but jst wondering.............................................
Re: NanakSar
Gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 17 Oct 2004
"2. a gate is made around SGGSJ and no one is allowed to do parkarma (this one needs to be explained)"
i asked my dad about this one and he said that doing parkarma isn't a mandatory thing to do...
as for anand karajaa, he said that in the olden days gursikhs didnt do parkarma at all... they just sat their in front of guru jee and listened to teh laavan and just matha tekked at the end of each one.
he said that doing parkarma around guru jee is just 'rees' (copying) of hindus, who walk around a fire when getting married
Re: NanakSar
strange/pakhand/reasons? · 17 Oct 2004
i think 5th Guru Jee do parkarma around SGGSi read that someplace...?
Re: NanakSar
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
The "reasons" and "explanations" look suspiciously like "reverse engineering" !!!
When we refer to "parkrma" of SGGS...it is "rees" ??? but when we refer to "copy cat aartee".....it is not ??
Dhan Dhan Guur Granth Ji is our Living GURU...and parkarma is one way of paying our respects besides matha tek....both are "not mandatory"...if one doesnt want to then no body can force it. GURU JI certainly DOESNT FORCE us to mandatory matha tek or parkarma ???
The practises at Nanaksar ar not those GURU NANAK ji would apprve of...NO NISHAN SAHIB, NO LANGGAR/PANGAT, NO KIRPAN, Not GURDWRA but THAATH !!! PICTURES as IDOLS, real IDOLS also ( disguised as potraying Living Ardass etc, Guru Ji on a Horse, baab banda Singh Ji on a horse etc ).unnecessary "sarovars" added to thaath buildings, chaur of pictures , putting pictures to sleep, bathing them dattan brushing teethetc...what a load of XXXXX. DID GURU JI sit on a Throne that is WALLED OFF from the sangat ?? Isnt this a SUBTLE PSYCHOLOGICAL WAY of putting barriers bewtween the snagat and the GURU to PROMOTE the BABAS ?? Putting the babas pictures where they HAVE to be MATHA TEK is one NEAT TRICK !!!
Bottom line is present nanaksar is not SIKHI/GURMATT....not by a long shot. It is full of manmatt/babamatt. IF one is a nanksari... work toward making the place more in line with gurmatt.
Not one to mince words where gurmatt is concerned.
dass jarnail Singh
Re: NanakSar
Baba ji da kukar · 28 Oct 2004
Have you read Life story of Babaji if not please read it and your questions will be answered. And i am postive you will questionless after reading booksof Mahan Babaji's Jeevenie.
you can also visit these sites:
BabaNandsinghji.org
nanaksarthaath
nanaksar
Re: NanakSar
Santam Singh Sidhu · 31 Oct 2004
1. At Nanaksar Gurdwaras the rehat maryada is same as in hazoor sahib. I have seen at Gurdwaras in North America most of people go to eat langar on sunday at Gurdwara because they dont want to cook at home. Very few people go to listen keertan. All Ragis are professional, they like to do keertan if sangat comes. if sangat does not come they wont do keertan for Guru Sahib.If u go to Golden Temple , langar is eaten by all tourists, as it is meant for tourists only not by local people. All gurdwaras have their own maryada, like at Golden Temple you can not get married. You can get married at other gurdwaras around Golden Temple. You cannot say jakara at golden temple either. There is no Nishan Sahib at Golden Temple, it is at Akal Takht.
2. At Nanaksar langar is served , which is shabad langar. Every Nanaksar Gurdwara has 8 hour keertan everyday so that people can come and get food for their soul.
3. All gurdwaras are same, so if u want to listen Keertan evryday u can go to Nanaksar, if u want to get married or want to eat langar, u can go to regular Sunday gurdwara.
4. At hazoor sahib u can see Portrait of Guru Gobind Singh jee and Guru Nanak dev jee at Sachkhand. Also u canot get married at Sachkhand at hazoor sahib.
5. Nanaksar is basically bhagti da ghar, where all Paaths and keertan is done for sikh panth. At other places it is done for people who pay money.
Re: NanakSar
sangat dee dhoor · 31 Oct 2004
Before accusing Nanaksar of not promoting Gurmat, I'd suggest that the concerned individuals should read/understand Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee's and Sant Baba Isher Singh Jee's Jeevan, Bhagti, Kamaee and respect for Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj. They should appreciate the amazing spiritual status reached by these Mahaan Gursikhs. They always told the Sangat to follow the Guru's path.
If subsequent 'Babas' from Nanaksar or followers thereof have not followed Gurmat, then this does not detract from the Jeevnee and Bhagti of Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee and Sant Baba Isher Singh Jee. Please do not seek to malign Nanaksar across the board!!!
Re: NanakSar
Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 31 Oct 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
dear baba ji de kookar ji,
you may be content to be kookar of baba ji...BUT GURU NANAK teaches us to be KOOKAR of WAHEGURU.
"life" of baba ji is written by his own chelas and chamchas. I have several in my library...all full of fantastic "miracles" and all that type of utter rubbish. Sikhi and Gurmatt of GURU JI refers to miracles as kehr. Not a single line of GURBANI is explained, nor practical methods of gurmatt explained...all babji did this and babaji did that and see how wonderful baba ji was????
Our GURU is PARAS that makes others PARAS. Ordinary Paras make others "gold".... Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh ji was another PARAS that makes his readers Paras as well......sadly the books by babji followers are jsut empty shells that wont even make anyone iron...let alone gold and making them paras is impossible....because the baba ji himself is NOT PARAS.
Read the books of Bhai Sahib bhai Randheer Singh Ji on GURMATT/SIKHI/ITIHAS etc and compare these with the "lifestories of babajis"...you will notice that while Bhai Sahib Jee gives PRACTICAL methods of attaining Naam Bhiyaas, gurmatt path etc..the life stories lead you up the garden path in a fairy tale...Alice in Wonderland is the same as baba ji in wonderland.
Guuru Nanank ate Waheguru da kookar.
Jarnail Singh
Re: NanakSar
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Nov 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
First of all I have NOT seen anyone "criticising" ANY of those sants mentioned above ( me included)...IF you read my mails carefully you will see what I am saying. All of them did massive bhagtee, parchaar, gurmat rehnee, karnee kamaii, chakaa amrit to millions...and they DID NOT cheat , rape, molest, eat Guru Ki Golak, did wehlee sleeping around and making their chelas ghutt therir godas...lattaan etc or did anything even remotely "criminal" or anti maryada/sikhi/gurmatt.
THAT settled and out of the way....now to the books. First point is that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji's books are ALL written by HIMSELF, His own Personal Experiences with GURBANI and GURMATT. Yes there is the "miracle" of making gold mentioned By Bhai Sahib Jee, BUT that is NOT to "prove" how Godly/saintly/Mahapurashist he was. And secondly Bhai Sahib Jee DESTROYED the Formula immediately...showing he was not remotely interested in enriching himself....or making his "dera" chelas stick to him in the hope they would make gold also. IN Fact bhai Sahib jee established NO DERA or SUCCESSOR !!! and REFUSED to be called SANT. ALL the FOUR TAKHATS honoured Bhai Sahib Jee...but he has no DERA and nO SANT title. NO other person - in SIKH HISTORY....living or dead has been so HONOURED by ALL the Takhats. That is a major achievement.
The other books i have read are ALL by CHELAS. It is an established fact that a CHELA is always ONE EYED in favour of his "MASTER". None of the SANTS ever wrote a single line regarding their experiences gurmatt rehni. And most of them have appointed SUCCESSORS and have deras. And the so called MIRACLES related in these books are meant to PROVE how their MASTER was SAINT/GODLY etc to impress the public. The miracles in the Bible are meant to PROVE that Jesus was the SON OF GOD. The miracles of the sants in these books have the SAME reason.....to "pull" in the readers to beleive in that particualr sant. Why should a sant need to perform miracles when Guru Gobind Singh ji calls all this Naatak chetak....jugglery of magicians to fool the world....ridhian sidhian are NOT the GOAL of GURMATT. This si NOt the same as saying the Sants did NOT have ridhian sidhian ( anyone as immersed in Gurbani as they will get these naturally..BUT they WONT SHOW it and will Never do it to impress the chelas...unless to impress the chelas is the main motive. If we then compare this and say the janamsakhis also mention about miracles of the Gurus.... well the GURUS have written SO MUCH ILAHI GURBANI that there is enough GURBANI for us to learn from ( no one really "needs" the miracles of the janamsakhis to believe in Guru Ji) but in the case of the sants there is "NO GURBANI"/ or even SANTBANI ( Sant Parvachan ) for us to learn from...ONLY and ONLY miracles.....
That said IF I were to meet any of the sants mentioned above - sant Attra singh, kartar singh, jarnail singh, nand singh isher singh...I would be BLESSED, i would eearn from them, feel really good inside to be in their company, and benefit from their massive bhagtee naam simran ...AND yet NOT beleive in the miracles as these miracles are superflous.
That veer jis is my position on Sants. Bhul Chuk Maaf.
Dass jarnail singh.
Re: NanakSar
Respect the Panth · 02 Nov 2004
Bhai randhir Singh and Baba Attar singh did seva together in Panch Khalsa divan. This organisation helped to free Gurdwaras. Baba Attar and Bhai Sahib both did seva in the Panj Pyares. They had alot of love. baba Attar singh also did a rainsbhai every month and loved akhand keertan. Both were perfect Gursikhs.
I am not sure how this topic got from nanaksar maryada on to them. But they have nothing to do with its maryada. Neither does baba nand singh. He never even let anyone build a Gurdwara in his name. he was just absorbed in naam.
Stop using these Great sikhs names to fight your maryada battles. nanaksar maryada is in many cases in direct conflict with the very things that baba Attar singh eradicated in the Panch khalsa Divan.
Only modern Nanaksar leaders can answer for that. It is nothing to do with old great gursikhs who always put Panth first.