Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

East Punjab Vs West Punjab

East Punjab Vs West Punjab

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2004

Could anyone who has been to Pakistani Punjab and East Punjab shed light on whether this statement by a Pakistani minister is true. According to this minister, East Punjab is far ahead of Pakistani Punjab. If this is true, then all credit goes to the Sikhs of Punjab who managed to make Punjab so prosperous despite step-motherly treatment of Punjab by the Centre govt. Daas, Kulbir Singh Punjab bowls over Pakistani minister Tuesday October 12 2004 00:00 IST IANS CHANDIGARH: A Pakistani minister is so impressed with Indian Punjab's progress and prosperity that he wants to replicate it in his country. "The farmers here have really worked hard and are progressive. There is not even a single 'kucha' (semi-permanent) house in any of the villages," Pakistan Punjab's Agriculture Minister Rana Mohammed Qasim Noon told reporters here Monday. Noon is heading the first delegation from Pakistan in the field of agriculture. The team has already visited Himachal Pradesh to study agricultural practices there. Noon said he was particularly impressed by the farmers' cooperatives for marketing produce that had restricted the role of the middlemen and ensured greater benefit for Punjab's farmers. After his meetings here with officials of the agriculture and other departments, Noon felt there was ample scope for the two Punjab's to share a lot. He said he would be interested in the opening up the Wagah border, the only land crossing between the two countries, for better trade ties. "The land route for trade is always economical. But the final decision on such an issue is with the governments of both countries," he added.

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

me · 11 Oct 2004

"If this is true, then all credit goes to the Sikhs of Punjab who managed to make Punjab so prosperous despite step-motherly treatment of Punjab by the Centre govt." Nice term!!! -- "step-motherly treatment"

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

:- · 12 Oct 2004

well lookling at the gov policies towards farmers it cant be that good if they make our people commit suicide. I have also seen how a number of sikhs as well as farmers do have newer homes, bearing in mind we have large families, 3 4 sons, 2 sons would be sent abroad to earn at the pound or dollar rate and help the family advance thats how we make bigger houses. The same rule is not applicable for every farmer in fact the state policies are cunning, there are small time farmers big timers, not everyone will have the luxeries. I think the minister should at least sit down and talk to the greeb farmers first and see their conditions first. I dont fully trust the india or pak medias. Pakistans line will soon change too their trying to shed their old image and want to build ties with india now. If it ws that good then why are many families packing up and coming to the west?

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 12 Oct 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I would agree. EAST PUNJAB is a much less fertile territory, less in size, water resources fertility of soil etc... BUT the Economic indicators...Yield per Hectare etc are FAR more in East Punjab. And just as a comparison.... when the WEST PUNJAB was under SIKH cultivation as example the Baar districts whre SIKH Farm Holdings were in the hundreds of acres given out by the British to make fertile fields out of JUNGLE Lands.... the YIELD per hectare was similar to the oes in east Punjab today....AT that time EAST PUNJAB was a barren desert type of area.. When the SIKH REFUGEES from West punajb were driven out of their homes and settled in EAST PUNJAB on much smaller farms....the YIELDS began to Grow...and PUNJAB sowed the seeds of the GREEn REVOLOUTIOn that FED India and overturned the DEFICIT BEGGAR bowl in hand INDIA into a self sufficient nation EXPORTING Grains... WEST PUNJAB is equally GURUAN DI DHARTEE but when the SIKHS were driven out...it became barren.... Jarnails singh

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

S Singh · 12 Oct 2004

Been to both sides of Punjab and as soon as you cross the border you are struck by how impoverished west Punjab is. From what I saw there is a very large economic gap between the two sides. The Pakistanis are more than 20 years behind East Punjab. You see very few signs of properity. Most the houses we saw looked like of small brick so date prior to partition.

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

.......... · 12 Oct 2004

what do you expect - they are no post offices to give them giros...no income support... no fake disability benefits..... no housing benefits....... no credit card fraud....... look at pakistanis in Uk, many are on benefits, do no work, chase sikh and white girls, 20 years old hanging outside schools chasing 14 year old girls... anyone walk around chalvey in slough, luton, bradford, oldham, and parts of birmingham. Enuff said!

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

Kulbir Singh · 12 Oct 2004

I hope the Centre govt. opens up trade between two Punjabs. Both Punjabs will benefit from it. Daas, Kulbir Singh Pakistani team keen on agriculture tie-ups Tribune News Service Chandigarh, October 12 A top-level delegation headed by Pakistan’s Agriculture and Marketing Minister Rana Mohammad Qasim Noon, which is on a 12-day visit to India to study agri-marketing, has expressed willingness to explore options for increasing trade avenues between the two countries in agricultural produce. Appreciating the prosperity of Punjab which has been fuelled by agricultural revolution, the Pakistani team showed keen interest in tie-ups with various agricultural organisations in Punjab for cooperation and transfer of expertise in various fields, during a visit to Punjab Markfed. During its interaction with Markfed officials, the delegation said that it was impressed by Punjab’s success in cooperative agriculture revolution. The team was particularly keen to know more about the cooperatives set-up which are helping millions of farmers in Punjab in selling their farm produce. The minister revealed that their country was influenced by the cooperative structure in Punjab as cooperatives movement had made rapid strides in all the areas of socio-economic activities. The cooperative concept had worked wonders and its networking and reach was so vast that they covered 100% of the total villages and 85% of the rural households. The minister said that Pakistan needed huge quantities of agricultural products and was very keen to import 100 MT metric tonne of tomatoes per month from Punjab Markfed through the Wagah border. Earlier, Pakistan had shown interest in importing 20 lakh metric tonnes of wheat and other produce like cotton from Punjab through Wagah border. The Chief Minister of Punjab had written to the Minister of Food, Government of India, to open the Wagah border for bilateral trade. But till now this issue was under consideration of the Central Government. The Pakistani delegation extended an invitation to the Markfed’s Managing Director to visit Pakistan and get a first hand knowledge about the Pakistanis engaged in agriculture. Mr S.S. Channy, Managing Director, Markfed, said that Punjab’s proven expertise and skills in bringing the green revolution in Punjab could now be utilised for green export revolution. As the bilateral ties between India and Pakistan were improving fast, this could be the harbinger of new revolution and organisations like Markfed would have a very important role to play in this scheme of things.

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

------- · 14 Oct 2004

Oh yeah they are definitely behind about 20 years I'd say also. There are so many kucha homes, no big kothis like you see everywhere in east punjab, even the city Lahore there aren't very many huge mansions like you see rising in jalandher etc. The one good thing there are no human pulled rickshai there just motorized ones.

Re: East Punjab Vs West Punjab

Manas Singh · 16 Oct 2004

I don't think East Panjab should have any tie up with West Panjab. East Panjab doesn't need anything from a tie up, it is already advanced, it will be West Panjab that will get all the benefits. I agree with Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani, the West Panjab has pretty much gone downhill since the Sikhs had to migrate from there. The East Panjab in 1947 apart from a few areas was barren especially the areas south of Satluj, it was these migrating Sikh farmers that were settled in these areas that made them bloom. My father's family migrated from Khanewal in Multan district and they lost their fertile land and were given poorer almost barren land full of sandunes ( Tibbay ) that Muslims left behind in Ludhiana district. All the migrating farmers cleared these Tibbay and made the land fertile through the sweat of their brows. Meanwhile the land my father's family left behind is probably turned from fertile land into tibbay because the Muslims who migrated from East Panjab were pretty much layabouts! This isn't my opinion all the elders who remember those days always say that the Muslim farmers were useless and because they didn't allow their womenfolk to take food to them in the fields they wasted two hours a day going home, eating dinner. They mostly over ate and then spent a few hours sleeping off the lethargy. Whereas the Sikh farners' wives would bring them food in the fields and they only needed half an hour to eat and then start work again. A Sikh farmer could plough more acres in a day than a Muslim farmer in a week!