Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

dassre · 10 Oct 2004

Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane. Nanakshahi Jantri Sammat 531 corresponding to the year 1999-2000 published by the SGPC spells out briefly the salient features of the Nanakshai Calendar. But in doing so it gives rise to more questions than clarifying the issue or satisfactorily answering to the points at issue. The opening lines of the Jantri start with a question, "nwnkSwhI kYlMfr - smyN dI mMg[ nwnkSwhI kYlMfr nUM lwgI krn dI loV hY?". And then it goes on to explain that every Nation has its own calendar. Muslims have Hijri, Christians have Isavi (eIsvI), Hindus have Bikarami, and so on. The Sikh Nation did not have its own calendar. The Nanakshahi Samvat which was given in the Jantris was in fact the copy of the Bikrami Sammat and it had only the name Nanakshahi. One of the reasons which is being given in favour of the Nanakshahi Jantri is that it will help establish the Sikhs their individual entity. If this be real intention then this is not going to help at all. Because the Hindu terminology like Har ki Pauri, Har Mandir, Athsath Tirath etc. and the extensive usage of Hindu reference were adopted by Guruji. Then are we going to omit all these. In fact these reference were used as a carrier and medium and not an end. In fact the issues which are really going to help establish the Sikhs' separate identity like Article 25 of the Constitution, the separate personal law for the Sikhs, the Hindu Marriage Act, forcing the Sikhs to declare them as Hindus under the Indian law etc. etc. have been dumped deep in the archives. May be to retrieve the issues, as always, to be utilised when being out of power? In fact what has been done in the name of the Nanakshahi Calendar is that instead of following the Bikrami Calendar it has simply adopted the Christian Calendar, but of course the name Nanakshahi has been given to it. It is pertinent to note that any era starts with some event of history. Christian era starts from the birth of Christ, Hijri Calendar dates from the Hijrat (migration) of Mohammed from Mecca to Madina and so on. In the middle of the 18th century when the Sikhs had avenged and reversed the Moghul onslaughts, contemporary writer Dil Mohammed Pasruri had even suggested that a new era be started from this day naming it jhwny Krwb Sud, means the world has been ransacked. But in the case of Nanakshahi Calendar it has no relevance with any date from the life of Guru Nanak Dev ji. It is thus a Christian calendar with the name Nanakshahi. The Christian Era started with the advent of Christ and came with it the Julien Calendar. This Calendar was modified by Pope Gregory the IIIrd vide his ecclesiastical edict. This Christian Era calendar was adopted by the British Parliament and was imposed upon its subjects. Even though, like the English language this AD Calendar is prevalent all over the world, but the Nations having any sense of pride and consideration of heritage have not discarded their own calendars for their National days. Even this Christian calendar which is being called a common or current calendar is not without defects. Reforms to this calendar are being suggested in the form of International Fixed Calendar and the World Calendar to fix the days of festivals and rest as was in the original Julian calendar besides fixing the length of the months. So much so that even the length of a week of seven days is also being given a thought. It may not be surprising that this whole calendar is further reformed. In that case will be again adjusting our calendar to the reformed Christian calendar. Although this calendar is being called the common calendar but the Muslims, Hindus, Budhists, Jains, Jews or even certain orthodox sects of Christians like Ukranian Christians have not disowned their traditional calendars for their national days. It is thus seen that the reason and purpose for which the Nanakshahi Calendar was sought to be introduced gets defeated because the Sikhs will be subjected to the yoke of Christianity. Is it not a fact then that the Christian Calendar has been made a standard and the Sikhs and their traditions have been asked to adjust according to it. Whereas the English Calendar in vogue is undoubtedly a Christian Calendar because it was corrected and imposed by an edict of the Pope. On the other hand the Bikrami Calendar is not a Hindu Calendar as the genesis of this Calendar is not from any scripture like Vedas, Puranas or like. This era started by Bikramaditya who happened to be a Hindu king, after he attained victory over Shak. However, this calendar is based on the law of nature as has been noted in Guru Granth Sahib at so many places. This has been adopted by the Guru Sahibs and has its roots in Gurbani. Discarding the Bikrami Calendar thus will be an act against the Gurbani. Broadly speaking the proponents of this Christian Nanakshahi Calendar openly admit that they are not all bothered and concerned about the science of calendar or anything else but they have been allured and feel excited by one single point that the dates of the Gurpurabs will be fixed as per the English Calendar. This exactly is the reason which has been given in the Jantri for adopting it. It promises, hux ieh sm`isAw nhIN hovygI[ But in realty what we have seen is that the Sikhs have entered new millenium with intense confusion and contradictions. The birth day of Guru Gobind Singh ji is been celebrated by the SGPC and different organisations on different dates. The common Sikh is baffled and feels ridiculed even. The calendar instead of solving the problem has helped divide the Sikhs. In the light of this it can be asked, was this exercise needed at this particular juncture. Or should it have priority over the more compelling and serious problem of apostasy, which is damaging and cutting the roots of Sikhism. It is no denial that the roots of this apostasy are in the houses of the Panthik leaders and Sikh intellectuals who do not want to address this problem. Or is it that to divert the attention of the Sikhs from this real danger they have subjected the Qaum to this avoidable problem. Another argument is given that if we adopt the modern calendar to celebrate our birth days then why to adopt an obsolete system for Gurpurabs. If this really is the reason for discarding then why to give even an obsolete name of Nanakshahi to it. It is said in the Nanakshahi Jantry that the present form to the Nanakshahi Jantri has been given by the Institute of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh after many meetings of the intellectuals. But, • The names of the intellectuals have not been given. • It is not known whether any of them was an expert in the field of the astronomy or calendar making. • The proceedings or recommendations of the meetings were never made public. The Nanakshahi Calendar is not according to the Gurbani and the Sikh traditions. There is no denial that as per Gurbani no particular day is auspicious or inauspicious. Twelve months, the seasons, the thitis, the days are all good if these help in meeting with the Lord. by ds mwh ruqI iQqI vwr Bly] GVI mUrq pl swcy Awey shij imly] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 1109) The months, seasons etc. are created by Him. These are for practical convenience. But by mere calculation of these one will gain nothing. Rather these changes of nature should be used to gather for His praise. mwhw ruqI sB qUM GVI mUrq vIcwrw] qUM gxqY iknY n pwieE scY AlK Apwrw] piVAw mUrKu AwKIAY ijsu lbu loBu AhMkwrw] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 140) This phenomenon of nature is an unending process. The fifteen thitis, seven vars, the rutis, the days, nights and the months come again and again. pMdRh iQqˆØI qY sq vwr ] mwhw ruqI Awvih vwr vwr ] idnsu rYix iqvY sMswru ] Awvw gauxu kIAw krqwir ] inhclu swcu rihAw kl Dwir ] nwnk gurmuiK bUJY ko sbdu vIcwir ]10]1] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 842) However, it was seen that people on the days when the nature's phenomenon was visible to them i.e. full moon day or the day of the eclipse of the moon i.e. Purnima and Amavasya used to run to the ponds, rivers and reservoirs to take a dip. Guruji used this occasion as a medium to arrange special gathering to propagate the Gurbani. Bhai Nand Lal says about this, rUiz jumAw momnwin pwkbwz igrd mI AwieMd Az bihih inmwz]19] hmcunW dr mzhib mw swiD sMg kz muh`bq bw-^udw dwrMd rMg]20] igrd mI AwieMd dr mwhy do bwr bihir izkir ^wswie prvrdgwr]21] Sukrvwr vwly idn pwk prhyzgwr muslmwn, r`b dI nmwz leI iek`Ty huMdy hn[ iesy qrW swfy Drm ivc swD sMgiq ivc r`b dy ipAwry juVdy hn Aqy vwihgurU dy pRym ivc rMg mwxdy hn[ mhIny ivc do vwr aus prvrdgwr dI aucycI Xwd leI iek`Ty huMdy hn[ SANGRAND Now a word about Sangrand. The Nanakshahi Jantri has very honestly detailed the purpose and modus of observing Sangrand in the Gurdwaras. It says, • sMgRWd dy kI ArQ hY Aqy ieh gurduAwirAW ivc ikaN mnweI jWdI hY? • ibkRmI kYlMfr iv`c sMgRWdW dw sMbMD rwSIAW nwl hY[ ijs idn sUrj iek rwSI 'coN inkl ky AglI rwSI iv`c pRvyS krdw hY aus idn sMgRWd huMdI hY[ nwnkSwhI kYlMfr iv`c mwh ArMBqw dw rwSIAW nwl koeI sMbMD nhIN hY[……………ijs smyN AMgRyzI kYlMfr bhuq pRclq nhIN sI, qwrIKW sMgRWd dy idn qoN igxIAW jwx kwrn Aqy sMgRWd gurduAwirAW iv`c mnwaux kwrn, Awm nokW nUM vI pqw rihMdw sI ik mhInw ikMny idn igAw hY Aqy nwl hI G`to-G`t iek idn gurU-Gr hwzrI vI l`g jWdI sI[ Now the above statement is true and the following points emerge from this explanation. That Sangrand is not observed arbitrarily but it is based on the law of nature that when the Sun moves from one house to another. And it had a purpose by which the people used to know the days of the month and gave an occasion for the gathering of the Sangat. In fact the word Sankrant itself mean 'to depart'. The Nanakshahi Jantri has no mention of Sangrand in it. Does it mean that in the name of giving a new calendar the decision to do away with Sangrand has been taken. This is a major deviation from the tradition. If at all it is to be decided to stop the special congregations on the day of Sangrand then it should not be done in a clandestine manner but must be clearly told as such. It is said that in the Nanakshai calendar the beginning of the month has got nothing to do with the transition of the Sun. If this be the case then how can the Sangrand be observed when there is no Sangrand, i.e. transition of Sun from one house or the other. By this constant process after day of the Amavasia, the day of the eclipse of the moon, it comes out again on the first day with a very thin line. This is known as the Vadi First. On the fifteenth day it is full moon's day. Thereafter it starts receding and it is known as the Sudi first, second and so on. Again on the last day it hides itself. This process goes on uninterruptedly. By this the tithis, vaars, months are created. There is nothing Hindu, Muslim or any such thing in it. This is purely the nature's law. This has used by Guruji to write Ruti Saloks, Baramahes, Vars etc. The pioneer work of Guru Nanak Dev ji to write Baramah Tukhari was followed by Guru Arjan Dev ji who wrote another Baramah in Raag Majh. After this, Punjabi literature saw more than 300 Baramahes. So this calculation of months is based on Gurbani, Punabi literature and the folk lore, which are very strong ingredients for the growth of any community. This phenomenon is noted by Guru Nanak Dev ji in Raag Bilawal in his composition titled Thiti iQ`qI that on the day of Amavasia the moon hides itself. The seeker has to get a message from this phenomenon of the Creator that this is the cycle of creativity of the Lord. AmwvisAw cMdu gupqu gYxwir ] bUJhu igAwnI sbdu bIcwir ] ssIAru ggin joiq iqhu loeI ] kir kir vyKY krqw soeI ] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 840) This is the process of calculation of the months and years. ivsuey cisAw GVIAw phrw iQqI vwrI mwhu hoAw] sUrju eyko rUiq Anyk ] nwnk krqy ky kyqy vys] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 13) Now to discard Thitis, Vaars, Baramahes is nothing but giving a back to the Gurbani, Sikh literature and heritage. It would prove to be disastrous for the Sikhs. The basic point which much be answered is that the Nanakshahi calendar by not mentioning of the Sangrand wants the practice of gathering on the days of the Sangrand to be stopped arbitrarily and without taking the community in confidence. By this it even exceeds the purpose for which it is being said to be brought about. Contrary to this, if it is decided to observe the Sangrand on the First day of the new Christian Nanakshahi Calendar by calling it Pravishte, then undoubtedly this is not Sangrand. mwhw mwh mumwrKI ciVAw sdw bsMq] pr&q icq smwil soie sdw sdw goibMd] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 1168) And reciting of the Shabads as above and Barahmah on such days is nothing but deceitful. Hence the new proposed calendar is anti gurbani. The stars and planets thus create the Pakh (half month) and the month. By this it should be understood that the truth also never gets obsolete. So the talk of modernisation is nothing but against this basic principle of nature mwhu pKu ikhu clY nwhI GVI muhqu ikCu hMFY] scu purwxw hovY nwhI sIqw kdy n pwtY] nwnk swihbu sco scw iqcru jwpI jwhY] (gurU gRMQ swihb, pMnw: 956) To sum up, Guruji used Sangrand to detatch the Sikhs from Hindu ritualism and bring them in Sadh Sangat. Freeing them on the days of the Sangrand by adopting the Nanakshahi calendar will give them an opportunity to relapse back into the sea of ritualism. GURPURABS. The Gurpurabs at present are being celebrated according to Sudi and Wadis, like Poh Sudi Sapatmi and Katak Purnima. It is on the basis of the situation of the sky and the moon on the night of the Parkash of Guru Nank Dev ji and Guru Gobind Singh ji, It will remain so for the time to come. However, if this system is dicarded the situation of the sky will be different. The birth day of Guru Nanak Dev ji which was on full moon day may be on the day of even the Amavasia. In this situation can one recite the Bani, kwrqk mws ruiq srd pUrnmwsI AwT jwm swiT GrI Awju qyrI bwrI hY [ Moreover, the Poh Sudi Satami, Katak Purnima will never be a Katak Purnima and Poh Sudi Satmi. This is thus against Gurbani, Traditions and heritage. DIWALI Another contentious point in the Nanakshahi Jantri is the Diwali. It says that the Diwali day in the form of Bandi Chhorh Diwas bMdI CoV idvs according to the Nanakshahi calendar will some time be on the day of the Diwali or sometime it may be a month later. This will create nothing but a ridiculous situation for the Sikhs. A Sikh who lights candles on the Diwali day do so because of the bMdI CoV idvs. Now de-linking it from the Diwali day in reality will push them back into the purely Hindu festival of Diwali. Hence, this is nothing but a very retrogressive act. Diwali and Baisakhi got added significance for the reason that the Sikhs used to assemble at Sri Akal Takhat Sahib as Khalsa common wealth to take stock of the past decide about the future. HOLI There is no denial that the Sikhs have got nothing to do from Holi but here again the occasion was used by Guru Gobind Singh ji to inculcate the martial spirit in the Sikhs. In the Christian Nanakshahi Jantri this too has been de-linked from Holi. Thus the basic purpose of Hola gets defeated. In the light of this if any adjustments are made by way of compromise on certain dates, it will then neither be a Nanakshahi as is being proposed nor the traditional calendar. As such if at all any change is required to be made, it should be done only after releasing the draft calendar to the sangat seeking its opinion. Then only anything should be done. Otherwise we have seen, it would create un-necessary dissensions in the Sikhs and will do more harm than any good. In the end, a word of caution from Dr. Balbir Singh ji, bwvjUd aus swrI Koj dy ijsny vYswK hI gurU nwnk dw jnm idn isD kIqw; koeI vI gurpurb mMnwaux dI iQq nhIN bdl sikAw[ BwvyN nnkwxw vI hQoN clw igAw hY pr ieh vwk Atl hY:-'kqk kI pUrxmwsI mylw nnkwxy ho[' swry gurdvwry, swrIAW sMsQwvW, skUl, kwlj, XUnIvrstIAW Aqy swry KojI gurU nwnk swihb dI pMj sO swlw jnm SqwbdI kqk dI pUrxmwSI nUM hI mu`K rKky mMnw rhy hn[ ieqhws-kwrW nUM vI hux ieh smJ pY rhI hY ik auh mnOqW jo iek kOm dy rg rySy ivc rc geIAW hn qy ausdI ijMd nwl rs rUp ho geIAW hn aunWH nUM pVcol dI nzr bdl nhIN skdI[ aunWH nUM bdlx leI iksy kRWqIkwrI qwkq dI loV hY[ aunWH nUM bdlx leI iksy gurU pIr dI kurbwnI dy KUn dI loV huMdI hY[ In the light of the above it can be derived that the calendar which is being projected as Nanakshahi is in fact a Christian Calendar. However, the larger interest of the Panth demand that let this Calendar should not become an issue to make a vertical split in the Panth. The gains and losses from this contentious issue must be weighed. The Calendar has to be adopted and not imposed on the Panth. © GURCHARANJIT SINGH LAMBA, ADVOCATE. 24, SHAHEED UDHAM SINGH NAGAR, JALANDHAR CITY 144001. PHONE : (0181)227665. e-mail: [address removed]

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Singh · 11 Oct 2004

Very informative reading, against the new calendar. So called Nanakshahi Calendar is an outcome of Popularity of Christian Calendar and has nothing to do with GURMAT. It is against that. Some leaders wanted to give something "new" to the community (may be a bag of stones). We sikhs had to have it.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

A Singh · 11 Oct 2004

GURCHARANJIT SINGH LAMBA, Very well written, this is the truth behind the Nanakshahi motives, it is a total farce. The real issues for Sikh Identity such as the constitution are ignored and lesser meaningless matters like this raised and indeed another attempt to have this aligned with the Christian modality left in Punjab by the Raj.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Singh · 11 Oct 2004

Well done Gurcharanjit Singh. At last someone else saying exactly what i have been saying for months. It amazes me though how quickly vertually all of the Gurdwarae have adopted this fake calendar. Saturday was a prime example when it was Jot Jot Divas of Guru Nanak Dev Ji according to the true calendar but instead of remebering thier teachings we had deve and lights adorning Sri Harimandhar Sahib to celebrate Guru Ram Das Ji's avtar purb. Please continue to propogate the truth. Hopefully soon people will begin to sense.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

khalistani · 11 Oct 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! also, theres a video on gursikhijeevan which also shows y nanaksahi shud not be the panthic calander its really good bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

jagjit singh · 11 Oct 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, if I am not wrong, this is written by Veer ji, who edits Sant Siphaahi magazine. I am not a mathematician and scientist, but since this has started, I have read completely different versions and opinions from anti-lobby such as this, and pro-lobby, IOSS, sikh missionary, Spokesman,etc. It seems everyone has a completely different version, mainly complaints with no constructive programme for how to come to a correct conclusion. I see no harm in the Panth holding a World Sikh Smellaan, where this issue, dasam granth, hazoor sahib practices, drugs awareness issues, female birth killings, education to Wanjara sikhs into mainstream, and many others issues are discussed. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2004

All the issues that have been raised in this article have been addressed by scholars. As SGPC has stated and many other scholars have stated, we just cannot continue to use the Bikrami calender and we must move to separate ourselves from the Hindus. We cannot do this if we use their calender. It is quite possible that the Nanakshahi calender in its present form may need some amendments but that does not mean that we should totally reject it. We must not fall in the trap of fake sants who are very upset because Khalsa Panth has decided to move away from the other Hindu calender. Someone please post the logic behind Nanakshahi calender so that all these allegations against the Nanakshahi calender can be dispelled. --------- One of the reasons which is being given in favour of the Nanakshahi Jantri is that it will help establish the Sikhs their individual entity. If this be real intention then this is not going to help at all. Because the Hindu terminology like Har ki Pauri, Har Mandir, Athsath Tirath etc. and the extensive usage of Hindu reference were adopted by Guruji. Then are we going to omit all these. ----------- This is pretty dumb argument. The use of the above stated words are not same as Hindus use them for. Siri Guru jee redefined these words and their present use in Sikh Dharam does not negatively affect us. On the other hand, it is disgusting to wait for Pandits of Hardwaar to finalise their calender before SGPC can decide on Gurpurabs. We had to move away from this dependency. ----------- Whereas the English Calendar in vogue is undoubtedly a Christian Calendar because it was corrected and imposed by an edict of the Pope. On the other hand the Bikrami Calendar is not a Hindu Calendar as the genesis of this Calendar is not from any scripture like Vedas, Puranas or like. This era started by Bikramaditya who happened to be a Hindu king, after he attained victory over Shak. ---------- The reason why we are adopting the new Nanakshahi calender is because it is more accurate as opposed to the old calender. We have no problem with Vikramaditya or Jesus Christ. The problem is that if we don't adopt the new calender, the great baanis like Siri Baramaaha Sahib will lose their meanings in the future. How will they lose meanings? As an example the month of "AsaaR" in Siri Baramaaha has been described as a very hot month but if we continue to follow the Bikrami Calender, many years from now, the month of Asaar will fall in winter. The Sikhs of that time (future) will wonder why Guru Sahib has written AsaaR as a hot month. They will not understand as this month in their time would be a month of winter. I have a lot of respect for Lamba jee who has spearheaded many campaigns for Sikhs and in this article too he has raised some very good points that should be considered by all Sikhs. But by the same token, it is now impossible to give up the Nanakshahi calender. We will have to make the necessary amendments in this calender to accomodate for some genuine issues raised by Lamba jee and other Gursikhs. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

A Singh · 12 Oct 2004

Kulbir Singh, what makes the Bikrami Calendar "Hindu"? It is a solar calander and Sikhs have traditionally used both the Solar (Bikrami) and Lunar (Nanakshahi) together, this SGPC induced move is just a means to divert attention from the real issues attacking the Panth...like the constitution, the Dasam Granth issue, female-infanticide and the high rates of apostasy across Punjab. IOSS are Kala-Afghana supporters however much they try to hide this fact, their stance on the Dasam Granth is well known as is theirs on other matters, the fact that they are also involved in this pro-Nanakshahi calender move is hardly surprising.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Harpartap Singh · 12 Oct 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! The traditional Sikh calendar is not simply a Hindu one - it is a combination of the lunar i.e. used in Islam and a star based one. Kulbir Singh - the fact that the characteristics of certain Sikh practices conicide with that of another faith is no reason to discard it. Simply aligning the Sikh calendar to the Gregorian one is just as indefensible using your logic. The primary charge leveled against the traditional calendar is that the seasons are slowly changing at the rate of approximately one day per hundred years. The reason behind this is simple, the sidereal year (used in the Sikh calendar) is very slightly longer than the solar year. What is wrong with that? It is simply another way to measure the passing of time... As for seasons, these vary from location to location and from one era to another, from one hemisphere to another.. Also the fact that not many 'Sikhs' do not know how to calculate dates per the traditional calendar is no reason to discard it - this is akin to saying that because not many Sikhs cannot read Gurbani properly in Gurmukhi letters, we should adjust the form to make it easier. As with everything, a little effort to learn works wonders. The onus should be on those who seek to change the traditional approach to justify why - not the other way round. Guru Gobind Singh ji clearly mentions sudhi's etc in His bani, we should be wary of making hasty changes when there are far more important issues that need to be addressed within our Panth. H

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

:- · 12 Oct 2004

we all agree raj karega khalsa! unity oneness and breaking apart from both hindu and muslim cultures. the lapse into hinduism is going to far both points of lamba and kulbir singh are valid. its besti to look towards a hindu pandit to celebrate our holy days. But equally to break apart from hindu influences we need to first loads of bhai fauja singhs bhai jarnail singhs who are dedicated to parchar in pinds in india. Once we have numb ers united under the kesri flag we achieve the seperation from hinduism and work towards our own independance and at that stage we as one are in a position to say your a sikh you know what your identity is now fwd with nanakshahi calender and every other rightful just sikh demand. If we cant tackle apostacy at this point how mnany sikhs do we intend to rally behind the nanakshahi calender? out of 24 million sikhs how many are amritdhari? how many would abide by the new calender? a lot of khattri sikhs celebrate alongside their hindu khattris with family alliances, how many families are going to break their family loyalties? Now how many gurdwaras implemented the huikamnama for langar? we get our own besti done when people wont follow it. the first step is dedicated parchar to create enough numbers without numbers we are made to look like a silly joke and pushed around. Enough qquality over quantity talk. If theres enough sikhs all following one rehet you havent got a prob our slavery is a result of division and now we need to get back together. we can only unite when we take amrit follow one path and get ready for the future. At this point nanakshahi implementation is not strategic until a time comes when we are in the position. That time depends on us working together as one creating unity and doing parchar in where its needed to keep sikhi safe in punjab. Or if we lack on that side at least foster a strong sikh identity in the future youth no matter how westernised they are.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

:- · 12 Oct 2004

bhai jarnail singh ji can we have your input on this matter please?

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

:- · 13 Oct 2004

how are sikhs counted on a census? by having singh in their name, ticking a box claiming theyr sikh in punjab? First you got sant samajs and their supporters will they back a independant sikh calender? they need sanatan sikh philosophy for their own causes. After that you got new followers in radaswamis, namdharis, nirankaris who were sikh but have now converted to external pathsways but because many of them were sikhs just 1 generation back they refer themselfs as sikh offocially. BUt ideologiccally they wouldnt follow a sikh calander when their leaders would be aligned with sarkari. theres a lot of people walking with the sikh tag but are they sikh? My own radaswami relatives still claim to be sikh but if another 84 i can gaurantee you they would never back the khalsa or any kind of distinct move. these movements have mushroomed in punjab which means they have large numbers. I went to the beas headquarters out of interest 2 years ago and noticed most of the sangats in thousands roaming around were not hindus but kesdhari sikhs from pinds in orange pind style dastara. Thats how sad the situation is getting more and more sikhs are getting brainwashed into rs. Now you got the sanatan sikh nihungs themselves some of whom marry hindu women, would their ideology allow them and their supporters to break from hinduism? Then we have around 1 third sikhs khattri, lubana, saini, gumara sikhs who share family allegiences with their hindu counterparts living in small hubs secluded from mainstream sikhs celebrating more so with their own. You go to Ramgharia gurdwaras just out of interest and youl soon find parchar of ramayan and mahabharat . A perfect example in recent history was the backing of gianni zail singh in 84. Then the Nishan sahib procession supporting the hindu demolision of babri masjid with ramgharia reps in 1992 claiming their support will always extend to hindus in their time of trouble and giving the famous line of we are the extended military arm of hindus. Now What kind of number would we have left out of that who will be supporting the new calender? It could be half the numbers we expect or even less. the sikh diaspora is even less in numbers divided across the world. The only point im making is the divisions will get stronger, this is the peak of people following their own minds than gurmat. I cant see people breaking the ropes that binds them unless they first get in touch with gurbani, and know who they are and act upon it. Sikh identity on its own will have limited impact unless we know who and what we are and practice it. [%sig%]

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

A Singh · 13 Oct 2004

Dear :- You stated: "You go to Ramgharia gurdwaras just out of interest and youl soon find parchar of ramayan and mahabharat . A perfect example in recent history was the backing of gianni zail singh in 84. Then the Nishan sahib procession supporting the hindu demolision of babri masjid with ramgharia reps in 1992 claiming their support will always extend to hindus in their time of trouble and giving the famous line of we are the extended military arm of hindus." This is interesting. Please could you tell us which Ramgharia Gurdwara(s) did the parchar of Ramayan and Mahabharat? Ramgharia Slough are linked with the Jatha and often hold many Ransubais, most others are linked in some way with key Babas like Baba Nand Singh, Baba Puran Singh and Baba Isher Singh. Most Ramgharia Gurdwaras I have attended usually function in accordance with the same Maryada observed by Singh Sabha Gurdwaras, i.e. that of the Akal Thakt, so please do let us more about this aspect, as it is something new for me at least. Also on the Babri Masjid incident, who were the “Ramgharia Reps” that you refer to? Please could you post up some information on this front as well.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

:- · 13 Oct 2004

sure A singh ji a gianni from india did the kahtha of ramayan and mahabharat took place at Nevill Rd Gurdwara in 1997 during a season of 12 days observance of an event which i cannot recall fully but every other gurdwara did gurbani recitation that i attended locally. What i do recall is the day was sunday and the divan was ram packed. i got upset got up and left after i didnt understand why the divaan was being given parchar that didnt have relevance to sikhi. The same thing happened again at another ramgharia gurdwara which i cant remember this all happened many years ago. vishwakarmis ( hindu wing of ramgharias) were present on the board of some ramgharia gurdwaras. Nevill rd gurdwara appeared on National TV on the aftermath of the babri masjid riots. Did a small nagar kirtan in favour of the rss zeolots led by their panj pyarey on the road . I dont remember the guys name but he was the main representative of the ramgharia committee who was interviewd. In the speech he told the media which later went on air, that sikhs fully backed the hindus and vowed to protect hindus living in the uk as they are the military wing of hindus. The panj pyarey were shown in orange patiala dastars with their kirpaans drawn out. Then more ramgharia sikhs were interviewed on tv who said the hindus were right to attack the babri masjid and reclaiming their site. Now straight after this there was 2 sikhs protesting against the nevill rd incident and saying keep the sikhs out of this muslim hindu friction. Next thing we hear gurdwara up bimringham was attacked. Muslims attacking the gurdwara are not going to look at whos ramgharia to them any gurdwara with a nishan sahib was a target. Speak to elders about the backing of gianni zail singh in this country and india it happens maybne not in public stage but ramgharia sikh circles privately who start blaming akali dal and bring their caste into the matter its not one off events they have insecurity complex and take it out on others. I dont want to go too much into that because this is a gurmat site and you would find the comments very childish. Waht is astonishing is 50 year old amritdhari men in respectable positions talking like that, in front of children who are being educated in this country and then trying to spread stuff saying 84 could have been avoided. This is a clever way to bring jaat paat into it. The only problems with slough ramgharia gurdwara i have is their statue on a horse outside, their constititution which bars people on basis of caste including their name, and holding shraab and meat functions next door. I am not sure what their parchar is maybe i should have clarified from th estart exactly what ramgharia gurdwaras do the ramayan and mahabharat parchar. That constitution is enough to protest every part of it, the welfare section does not promote the welfare of sikhism but of the ramgharia community. The entrants can only come from the ramgharia jaat. Another noteworthy incident from nevill rd ramgharia gurdwara 15 years ago was a new amritdhari sikh serving degh to the sangat. A lady shouts out loud "tu choorah haga tu sadey gurdwarey vich kio degh vand dah? apney vich jah". That singh stormed out came back with his hair cut from his head and face holding them fresh in his hands and says " eh lah apni sikhi too sambhal" and threw his kes into her face and never came back. This can be verified by older sangats who used to attend there, my source is my friends amritdhari mother who doesnt lie. Now these ramgharia gurdwara constitutions state only ramgharias can participtate in the running of their gurdwaras so what kind of product are they breeding? and what damage are they doing to the unity of sikhism here? I myself have been at the butt end of similar treatment when i worked at a ramgharias house the elderly lady assuming im from her community asked me my surname when i told her she wouldnt even talk to me after that and pushed her head away. If thats a mona unpar person you can understand but an amrtidhari how can that experience leave me? I know the jatha holds smagams and rensbhais at the slough branch and maybe its diff, but check their constitution nex tyme paaji. personally now i would keep to singh sabha because of the activities th eramgharia one allow in their adjoining building. But on the good note there is kirtan, bani and blessing of sangat that arrives that gives exposure to local people there. Once i went to an akhand paat there 3 years ago, in the adjoining building theres a wedding boys girls drunk shouting , bhangra, then sikh bibia had to walk out quietly from the akhand paat and face this drama on a saturday. I wouldnt want my young siblings to grow up watching this and thinking its partt of a gurdwara or sikh way of life. I dont want to bring the good name of sants down who do good work for sikhi, but its also well known when you get a good personality up there you get thousands of followers who make up their own ballony to make you go their way, one of the things i was told by a singh associated with one of these gurdwaras was so so baba was present in sat yug with rama as so so personality. The queen ( british) was some reincarnation of a mata in sat yug who rama blessed her descendants with beauty because she fed him well. I donmt want to bring the name of this person down because i know him personally and understood his reason was to steer me that way. In my own way ive given the message back im not interested and cut off. This kind of parchar links sikhi back into hinduism. The Bhagat namdev gurdwara is just as bad and sends out letters claiming they are a "kshattriya sabha". Ravidas gurdwaras blatently have hindus on their board. So if we want a sikh nation, and to follow Akhal Takhat we need to take steps to become one. If we cant break through divisions we cant even get up let alone walk. We need to look realistically at what goes on and what we would like to have as one quam and measure how were going to get to our destination then raj karega khalsa till then we r slaves.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

umm · 13 Oct 2004

people who are so against the nanakshahee calendar.... why don't you then mark all dates using the bikrami calendar... for example, barshees, shaheedee purbs and major events like june 84 gallugharaa, why don't you make these according to the bikramee calendar too? most of sant smajj, etc, celebrate and mark the days for their modern babay using the gregorian calendar, but make such a noise over adoption of the nanakshahee calendar. If bikramee calendar is as per gurmat, than all dates, including modern ones, should be marked using this calendar. otherwise, it's a hypocritical stance.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

A Singh · 13 Oct 2004

Dear "-", Thanks for your response, I agree that we should avoid issues of 'jaat-paat' however here I feel the need to make a few comments in view of your closing statements, which I hope the moderators will allow in the interests to keeping matters clear and for the wider aim of unification. Gurdwaras such as Ramgharia, Ravi Dasia, Bhagat Namdev exist because of one particular jaat, and that is "Jats". Following their prosperous position after the collapse of the Misls and with the Raj of Ranjeet Singh and then the British, Jats have for a long time held themselves as superior to all other Sikhs and many instances exist where non-Jats were not permitted to sit on the boards of Gurdwaras which they had helped fund and build collectively...as the old saying goes, when times are hard, then everyone is your friend, but with money and power...well...we can see it all around us today... The instances you describe at Nevill Road, do in the large part appear to be limited to Nevill Road -which is something that needs investigation and addressing. As per the matter with the old Amritdhari lady referring to the young man as a “churra”, this is something that hardly surprises me today. I have witnessed in my 25 years this same action occur many times in a Singh Sabha Gurdwara, also from a Amritdhari Person, however in most instances from a Jat with reference to any non-Jat, which in fact underlies the existence of the above mentioned Gurdwara Boards. I’ve had it said to me to my face, “since when did you *****’s become Sikhs?” by Jat “Amritdharis”. It is sad to see the same thing now creeping into Ramgharia and Ravidasia circles as they have become more economically successfully and in the process more exclusive to themselves, much in the same way that Jats have been doing for the past 200 years and Khatris for even longer. Funny how people forget who they are so soon...afterall, let's look at this carefully:- We have these folks priding themselves on being "Farmers", "Carpenters", "Water-Carriers", "Money-Lenders", "Bards", "Palmist"...have a re-read of this list, it's hardly the cream of the crop when it comes to being high-class, as those who argue about this seem to think!!! As per the practices you describe, I wouldn’t limit them to anyone caste or group, look a little closer to what happens in most circles and you’ll be surprised how many so-called Amritdhari Sikhs of all backgrounds observe practices such as Karvachaut, Not washing your kesh on this or that day and so on. This is, as your earlier post indicated an issue affecting all Sikhs. I thank you for coming back to me on the Nevill Road aspect, I’m not from that area, however shall bear this mind when next visiting (and of course, will make a point of taking this matter up with their reps!).

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

A Singh · 13 Oct 2004

Is Gurmat really anything to do with "dates" ???

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Singh · 15 Oct 2004

Guru Nanak Sahib used Bikrmi Calenadar in Gurbani, in Babarwani. Awan Athere Jawan Satanwen ( they came in 78 and left in 97) With Naakshai calendar, these dates and Gurbani about "Thhits" in "Thhits and Vaars", will need extra explanations.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

satnam · 03 May 2006

This calendar was approved by People like Badal , Bibi Jageero and some fake anti sikh Budhi jeevi's in India and abroad. If these people are behind Nanakshahi calender that means this calender is WRONG. Bhai Gurdas jee has written in his bani that Guru Nanak dev Jee was born on Katak Pooranmassi. If you go with Nanakshahi calendar, Guru Nanak Dev jee's Birthday comes on wrong date.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Satnam · 05 Jun 2006

After Guru Nanak Dev jee left to Sachkhand, Guru Angad dev jee, and after 2nd Guru all Gurus upto 10 th Guru used to celebrate all Gur purabs with old calendar. After Guru Gobind Singh jee Bhai Mani Singh Jee, Bhai Daya Singh Jee, Baba Deep singh jee never changed calendar, they celebrated all Gurpurabs according to real calendar. In this century all Mahapurakhs including Bhai Randhir Singh jee celebrated Gur purabs according to Old calendar. Who are these Fake Giani's or Bhudijeevis to change calendar.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Harmeet Singh · 05 Jun 2006

vaheguru jee ka khalsa || vaheguru jee kee fateh || can someone please post up the REAL OLD calendar then? or where to get or see one? this seva would be greatly appreciated as it would sorten out a lot. vaheguru jee ka khalsa || vaheguru jee kee fateh ||

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Satnam · 06 Jun 2006

Old calendar is Bikarmi Calendar, you can get it from Taksal Gurdwaras , or any other genuine samparda who still follow the right Calendar.

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

S.S.F · 18 Jun 2006

wat does Gurbani say about dates and that?? like does it say anything in bara Mahaa(n)

Re: Nanakshahi Calendar-Boon or Bane.

Satnam · 25 Jun 2006

This Sakhi tells that Bhai Saab Bhai Randhir Singh Jee used to celebrate Gur Gobind Singh Jee's Birthday on Poh Sudee Satmee. If you change the calendar, Day or GurPurab will change . So it is better to keep original calendar. http://www.tapoban.org/Puraatan%20Narangvaal%20Smaagams.pdf Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh jee's Puraatan Narangvaal Smaagams At Poh Sudee Satmee, during Guru Dashmesh jee's birth Gurpurab, an amazing and wonderful smaagam used to take place at Narangvaal. Remembering those smaagams even today fills one with a sweet sensation. Trying to describe the divine colours of the those smaagams is like "Kaho Kabeer goongai guR khaaiyaa poochhay tay kiyaa kaheeai" (333) Many days before Poh Sudee Satmee, Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh jee used to, by hand, write loving invitations and send them off. Those letters were examples of the deep love Bhai Sahib felt for Gursikhs. His excitement to celebrate the Gurpurab with lovers of naam and his close friends burst forth from the lines of the invitations.