Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nankana Sahib incident overblown, says eyewitness

Nankana Sahib incident overblown, says eyewitness

Kulbir Singh · 04 Oct 2004

if it is true that the attack on Siri Nanakana Sahib was exaggerated, then we should be more cautious in the future. It is not in our interest to start any enmity with Pakistanis. It seems like India and Pakistan will witness an unprecedented era of friendship and open trade. Borders will open and people of both sides will freely mingle with each other. Punjab will benefit immensely by this. Daas, Kulbir Singh Nankana Sahib incident overblown, says eyewitness A.S.Prashar Tribune News Service Chandigarh, October 4 The reports of an “attack” on Nankana Sahib gurdwara in Pakistan have been grossly exaggerated and blown out of all proportions by the Indian media, complains an Indian Sikh religious group leader who happened to be on the spot when the incident took place on September 25. “It was a group of less than 100 students who came to the gurdwara and threw stones at it in protest against the Pakistan Government’s abrupt decision to hand over the building housing their college to the gurdwara management for setting up an inn for the pilgrims in view of the increasing number of visitors to the gurdwara”, says Mr M. S. Mianwal, convener of the International Kamboj Brotherhood who returned here from Pakistan a few days ago. In an interview with TNS, he said: “I was at the gurdwara for a couple of hours along with my Pakistani hosts and I could see no damage the gurdwara might have suffered due to the stone pelting by the demonstrators”. It was life as usual at the gurdwara, asserts Mr Mianwal who also took certain photographs to back up his claim. As a matter of fact, the only unusual sight was a 50-strong posse of Pakistani policemen posted near the main gate of the gurdwara which did not allow the demonstrators to come anywhere near it. “Another contingent of policemen dealt with the demonstrators elsewhere. From what I learnt from Pakistani shopkeepers around the gurdwara, the Pakistani police was quite tough with the demonstrators and chased them away in no time”. Therefore, says Mr Mianwal, he was quite bewildered to find on his return here that the Indian press and others were making quite a big issue out of the small incident. Mr Mianwal says that that he also went round the gurdwara and found that “paath” was continuing uninterrupted as usual in the sanctum sanctorum. He himself was given “parshad” readily by sewadar Prem Singh and later, he had langar also which indicated that all the activities of the gurdwara were continuing normally despite the so-called “attack”. In the “sukhasan room”, air conditioner was on and he found a female disciple reciting gurbani along with her baby. He says that there are certain mischievous elements in Pakistan who are not happy with the thaw taking place in relations between India and Pakistan. The demonstration could be their handiwork to somehow stall the process. It was, therefore, for the people of the two countries to make sure that their machinations did not succeed. The reaction of certain Indian leaders and bodies to the incident was “unwarranted and exaggerated”. There were some demonstrations in Delhi. Given the facts of the incident, these were not really called for, he says. Also, the move by the SGPC and the Delhi Akali Dal to send a delegation to Pakistan to “investigate” is also an overreaction because this betrays a lack of trust in the Pakistan Government. “They are welcome to go there any time they want, but not for ‘investigation’,” he says.