CANADIAN LAWYER HELD IN SOLITARY CONFINEMENT IN AMERICAN JAIL
sevadar1699 · 03 Oct 2004
Canadian Sikh lawyer held in solitary confinement in American jail URGENT UPDATE on Kuldip Singh Chaggar An excerpt from: W!N Correspondents Monday, 4th October 2004 SEATTLE, WASHINGTON - Two weeks after his arrest based on allegations of witness tampering, Mr. Kuldip Singh Chaggar’s lawyer as of Sunday evening (Oct 3) informed his wife that Mr. Chaggar was still in solitary confinement and was not given his medication and informed his lawyer that he does not feel well. He was put there on Wednesday evening because his wife received a phone call from a Canadian lawyer on another phone while she was speaking with Mr. Chaggar. As a result, without explanation, Mr. Chaggar is not able to call out and remains in his 5th day of solitary confinement. Background The allegations against Mr. Chaggar are ‘tampering with a witness”. These allegations come from an inmate held in U.S. jail who is facing charges for smuggling 110 pounds of cocaine. She told prison officials that Mr. Chaggar had pressured her to change her statement against Mr. Chaggar’s client charged in Canada and she said Mr. Chaggar further threatened her family if she did not change it. If she did make these allegations, normally authorities might question her credibility as a cocaine smuggler, they may think that she’s saying this because of choices US authorities may provided between signing statements put before her which could get her killed in the world of drug smugglers on one hand and spending most of her adult life in a U.S. jail on the other hand. However, after the allegations, U.S. authorities had this woman phone Mr. Chaggar from prison and recorded this conversation. The most damning things released are of no substance. It would have taken little to have the woman make a clear reference to the previous alleged conversation and have Mr. Chaggar respond to it and release it. Instead Mr. Chaggar was entrapped and arrested without a warrant on September 16, 2004 and there is weak piecemeal innuendo reported form the recorded conversation and conveyed in a manner that appears to be a desperate attempt to attach enough blame to design damning sound bytes to media.outlets. At his bail hearing a US Govt. attorney suggested that Mr. Chaggar had a history of witness tampering because he was called before the court after writing an article on the Canadian Air India trial. If this represents the honest intelligence skills of the US Govt. then we are in much trouble. Background to this is as follows: Others called before the Canadian court in the Air India trial include Canada’s National paper The Globe and Mail, Vancouver’s largest city paper, The Vancouver Sun, Apna Roots (a “moderate” anti-sikh paper) for things such as having a picture of the witness, printing her name etc. Mr. Chaggar repeated information from a mainstream paper and was very quickly cleared of any wrongdoing by the court. Also at his bail hearing US Govt attorney innuendo suggested that Mr. Chaggar uses his position as a lawyer to aid criminal gangs. Outrageous baseless innuendo like this toward an officer of the Canadian court should cause serious concern and indicates something very wrong and strange about this case. Mr. Chaggar has a well established law practice with 4 or 5 full time staff. He has been extremely involved in the local community, has a 10 year old son. It is outrageous to suggest that he is a flight risk upon crossing the border back into Canada. If Mr. Chaggar is a flight risk, they may as well presume all guilty till proven innocent and do away with bail hearings. The judge granted bail upon $50,000 US cash but allowed a stay pending an appeal which meant Mr. Chaggar was taken back to jail. If he is released upon bail, the Govt Attorney has suggested he may be detained further upon related allegations of US Immigration officials. American authorities have a despicable record lately in unfairly targeting people who represent the devil in their psyche. (see links below) Mr. Chaggar is unshaven and has a dastar. He is their war on drugs and war on terrorism in one. Unanswered to date is what information did the Canadian RCMP provide to U.S. authorities? Mr. Chaggar has butted heads with the RCMP throughout his career, fearlessly and respectfully questioning their actions whenever necessary. He is an intelligent, articulate and fearless advocate who will not sell out his community to kiss white ass. It was RCMP lawyers who vigorously persisted in court against Mr. Chaggar knowing full well what the National and local Canadian media had printed. Surely the RCMP is working with U.S. authorities in a case where those charged are detained in both countries. (one need not look far to be extremely concerned – see http://www.ararcommission.ca/eng/). For the mere word of a detained cocaine smuggler to result in jailing a lawyer is outrageous. NO OTHER EVIDENCE, not even the recorded conversations have been disclosed to reveal any substance to the charges. Why don’t the authorities release the whole recording to Mr. Chaggar’s lawyers if there is anything of substance? Why did they present the same sound bytes released to media instead of anything of substance from the recordings at the bail hearing at which they needed to be otherwise so sensationalistic? Why did they not release something in the recording which simply had the woman refer back to the allegations she made? Mr. Chaggar relates to vulnerable and marginalized clients with extreme respect that one can guess arises from the challenges he himself faces as a identifiable Sikh. Mr. Chaggar has sacrificed a great deal in standing his ground. He is a shining example of the role of a defence lawyer where one hopes for a democracy with a progressive justice system where we believe that people are innocent till proven guilty, where we will claim that we go to great lengths to ensure that an innocent person is not wrongly convicted. No one is asking for anything more than due process in this case. A sad irony of Mr. Chaggar’s incarceration is that in a case like this in Canada it is Mr. Chaggar who would have come to the aid of someone. He is one of few remaining pillars in a largely intimidated, sold out to self interest, or oblivious local community when it comes to what amounts to racist propaganda against Sikhs. We have feel-good indo news and magazines selling us the notion of how proud we are. We have indo politicians flashing smiles for they shake white hands. We talk about indo money and power. But in reality we are slaves! Slaves to our inferiority complexes in the West and dulled by fair skinned bollywood fantasies. We want the freedom to visit Disneyland, we want to be able to shop across the border, we want to get the next house or SUV and look young, all quickly before we die. So when it comes to speaking our mind, we have conveniently convinced ourselves that there must be some sensible reason or there’s not much we can do, to absolve ourselves from being part of any collective responsibility for matters such as this, while Mr. Chaggar now sits in solitary confinement in a Seattle jail cell. Shame on us! Wake up! Speak up! PLEASE SEE Petition in Support of Kuldip Singh http://www.petitiononline.com/ksc2004 Links to just a few stories: Brandon Mayfield http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5092810/site/newsweek/ Abdallah Higazy http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/ny-bc-ny--attacks-aviationr1001sep30,0,2709078.story?coll=ny-ap-regional-wire Maher (Mike) Hawash http://www.aclu.org/SafeandFree/SafeandFree.cfm?ID=12309&c=206 Maher Arar http://www.maherarar.ca/ James Ujaama http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/ujaamastatement.asp All submissions to W!N News, unless otherwise stated, are news commentaries from excerpts of articles with anti-racist, anti-gurmat, and/or biased statements removed. Corrective comments are made by editors in brackets. The original article is sourced and W!N takes no credit or responsibility for the original article.