Re: Accepting Blood
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Oct 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
IMHO, BLOOD is BLOOD.
Why are we so "egotistical" that anyone else ( for example smoker, womaniser, paapi, drugaddict, prostitute etc etc ) would be willing to "accept" an "amrtidharees' vegetarian blood"...some of these people may also very well REJECT that kind of blood..
WE eat VEGETABLES...BUT our BODY in the Infinite Wisdom of WAHEGURU turns all that into BLOOD, MIJH, BONE, MAAS.... so who is to say "my blood" is BETTER/PURER than say the blood of a womaniser/Paapi/smoker/ etc
GIVING BLOOD is an act of sacrifice and love. Lets leave it at that. Dont "judge" people by their "blood" ???
dass jarnail singh.
Re: Accepting Blood
Niranjan Singh · 03 Oct 2004
>>> Dont "judge" people by their "blood" ???
Don't you mean to say don't judge BLOOD by their PEOPLE ?
Re: Accepting Blood
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Oct 2004
niranjan singh ji:
YES. ALL blood is RED and except for diseased persons, its composition is the same. That is why only blood of diseased persons is rejected by the blood banks.
jarnail singh.
Re: Accepting Blood
Archie Bunker · 04 Oct 2004
we should not accept blood from......JEWS....NATIVES...CHINESE...
.... REPUBLICANS...THE IRISH........PEOPLE WITH BIG ELBOWS.... AND ESPECIALLY LIGHT AND DARK SKINNED BLACKS
that's how most of you come off with your "maryada" argument.
Archie Bunker
Re: Accepting Blood
Archie Bunker · 06 Oct 2004
just let me know plain and simple...... would you let your mother die or give her the blood transfusion.
Archie Bunker
Re: Accepting Blood
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Oct 2004
Jss has answered the question put to me. The Blood collection Services simply DO NOT accept tainted blood. An alcoholic ( drunk) would not be able to donate blood under any circumstances.
Dass jarnail singh.
Re: Accepting Blood
Harjas Kaur · 09 May 2006
[quote]blood contains no sin[/quote]
Unfortunately this is not true.
http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/hcai-iamss/tti-it/ttdi_e.html
[%sig%]
Re: Accepting Blood
Juggy Double D · 18 May 2006
"Bundha" wrote in his post
<< "Maryadha says that an amritdhari should not take in Alcohol, meat, grugs and smoking. That is the maryadha set down by Guru sahib Ji, whether you like it or not.
Alcohol - When a person has drunk himself silly what is it that the police check ? To make absolutely sure they want a BLOOD test.
Meat - The nutrients from maas enters the BLOOD stream to reach all parts of the body" >>
Could you provide some names of these nutrients that get absorbed into the blood that makes the blood impure for a Amritdhari to take for transfusion??
Your lack of answer to that single question would expose the failure of your argument.
Re: Accepting Blood
*supersingh* · 29 May 2006
"Amritdhari Sikhs are becoming un-touchable. They are full of ego "hankar". They can be contaminated with any particle, which has not come from amrit prepared by their own jatha. Guru ji gave kirpan to his Sikh to protect people who could not defend themselves, but today's Sikh will not use their kirpan to protect some body because it will be contaminated with a non-amritdhari's blood. How pathetic these Sikh are. Will they use their kirpan only to bhog lawo to krah parshad or kill only amritdhari person. My post has nothing to do with giving blood, but look at how stupid this argument is. Sikhi has become a religion but not a true way to live this life."
That is the best post I have read on here in a long time.
[%sig%]
Re: Accepting Blood
Harjas Kaur · 09 Jun 2006
"who are you to judge someone for giving something that they are not forced to do...because they want to help you? save your life?"
I am a registered nurse, and am exposed to many diseases. It is not a judgement, but a presentation of unpleasant facts that diseases and sins of the lifestyle are carried in the blood. While not desirable, this is the genuine risk. If life is threatened, you have a choice. But accepting the blood is accepting the risk.
There are many things which cannot be tested in the blood donation process, and others which would be too costly. The blood supply is generally considered "safe" as is drinking local tap water. But to make an argument that blood has no impurities which can affect you is denial of the obvious. If anyone is likely to be contaminated with disease by unclean people, it is me because of the contact and job I do. I don't sit in judgement, I expose myself. But honestly, I warn you, the blood supply contains contaminants. It isn't desirable to want a blood transfusion. Unfortunately in some cases it may be a necessity. If you have an injured child, it's best to get either autotransfusion, or have family or Gursikhs donate the blood. I'm sorry, this is the truth, even if unpopular opinion.
[quote]Public health officials are claiming that the blood supply is safer than ever, and that probably is true, said Richard K. Spence, MD. Nevertheless, blood transfusions can have a number of deleterious consequences, cautioned Dr. Spence, Chief of Surgery at St. Agnes HealthCare in Baltimore. Perhaps the best way to think about transfusions, he added, is as “liquid organ transplants.”
The current estimated incidence of transfusion-related HIV infection, for example, is one or two in one million. However, other infections, including malaria, hepatitis B or C, and West Nile virus may be transmitted through transfusion; there have also been reports of bacteria, parasites, and prions being transmitted through blood.
Infection may be the least of the risks associated with allogenic transfusions, though. Many well-performed studies have linked such transfusions to higher rates of disease recurrence and decreased survival in cancer patients, pointed out Dr. Spence. Blood recipients may also develop transfusion-related acute lung injury (TRALI), a rare condition involving dyspnea, hypotension, pulmonary edema, and fever. The development of TRALI has been linked with white blood cell antibodies in donor plasma and with biologically active lipids that accumulate in stored red blood cells and platelets.
Immunomodulation is another possible effect of blood transfusions. The transfusions may trigger the systemic inflammatory response syndrome or even multiorgan failure if they increase the circulation of inflammatory cytokines. For example, interleukin-8 accumulates in stored blood as the leukocytes break down; it is also released by the body in response to free hemoglobin in transfused blood.
Some researchers believe that transfusion can lead to microchimerism, a condition in which the blood recipient harbors small amounts of the donor’s genetic material. Microchimerism has been implicated in the development of autoimmune disease and may possibly increase the risk of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma and chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
http://www.pulmonaryreviews.com/feb04/pr_feb04_transfusion.html[/quote]
[quote]Infectious Risks of Transfusion
Currently, the risk of transmission of infectious diseases through transfusion in Canada is minimal, because effective preventive strategies, including new laboratory tests, have been implemented. Nevertheless, many infectious agents, including viruses, bacteria, and parasites, can be transmitted through blood transfusion. Well-recognized viruses include hepatitis A virus (HAV), hepatitis B virus (HBV), hepatitis C virus (HCV), hepatitis D virus (HDV), hepatitis G virus/GB-C virus (HGV/GBV-C), human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2 (HIV-1/2), human T-cell lymphotropic virus types I and II (HTLV-I/II), cytomegalovirus (CMV), Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), TT virus (TTV), human herpesvirus type 6 (HHV-6), SEN virus (SEN-V), and human parvovirus (HPV-B19). Bacteria such as Treponema pallidum (the agent of syphilis), Yersinia enterocolitica, and Staphylococcus and Streptococcus species (common agents of bacterial contamination), and parasites such as Plasmodium species (the agent of malaria), Trypanosoma cruzi (agent of Chagas' disease), and Babesia microti (agent of babesiosis) have also been reported to be transmitted through blood transfusion. In addition, emerging blood-borne pathogens such as hepatitis E virus (HEV), human herpesvirus type 8 (HHV-8), Borrelia burgdorferi (agent of Lyme disease), and the unknown agent of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) and variant CJD (vCJD) may pose a threat to the safety of blood.
http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/hcai-iamss/tti-it/risks_e.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Accepting Blood
let me know · 24 Jul 2006
Then we should not also get treated from non-amritdhari doctors. They are not pure as they might smoke, eat meat and drink alcohol.
And Harjas, risks of transfusions are not related to amritdhari or non amritdhari. There are many individuals who have smoked, ate meat, took drugs and then adopted sikhism.
By taking amrit, we can not assume that biologically blood would get purest of all. What we pledge is to keep ourselves pure for the God.
There are diseases that leaves dormant strains of pathogens in blood and they would remain forever. Taking amrit would not change that.
These posts has reminded me of an incident where my amritdhari friend was in the queue ahead of me for a blood donation camp and while discussing the donation he just left because he thought that the blood donated by him might be given to a person of schedule caste.
It hurts listening or seeing such incidents.
I think others should also stop taking blood from us otherwise they can suffer from hard headedness, ego and fundamentalism and this is a valid risk of transfusion.
Re: Accepting Blood
jagroop singh · 24 Jul 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
i don't mind giving blood but i don't think i would take it for myself if i were in a situation where i'd need to take someone's blood...
but maybe i'd get so scared and take someone's blood even if i couldn't check they were a smoker etc. i guess only Guru Sahib knows how i'd react in such a situation.
Re: Accepting Blood
Harjas Kaur · 24 Jul 2006
[quote]And Harjas, risks of transfusions are not related to amritdhari or non amritdhari.[/quote]
I never said they were. I said, in answer to statements that blood transfusions were without disease that this was not entirely fact. All blood transfusions are a risk. At least be informed. As for amritdhari's, generally you do not run the lifestyle risks of a public bloodbank, which have been documented to purchase blood. And the populations with highest desire to sell blood have traditionally been drug addicts and alcoholics. Everything in life is a risk. Take your risk. But to deny the risks to others on a public forum is to do a public disservice. It's not about religion, or belief, or opinion, or intent, or emotion...its about risk plain and simple. You can interpret the facts as you see fit. Personally, I have no idea why people come to an AKJ board just to bash AKJ principles like keeping bibek. It just derails intelligent discussions to a forum to voice petty grievances. If someone's life is in danger, the risk may be worthwhile. But there is still a risk.
[quote] he just left because he thought that the blood donated by him might be given to a person of schedule caste.
It hurts listening or seeing such incidents.
I think others should also stop taking blood from us otherwise they can suffer from hard headedness, ego and fundamentalism and this is a valid risk of transfusion.[/quote]
You did not prove the point that blood transfusions are without risk when coming from the general public which does not even have a rehit to live by. Nor did you prove that people have no right to make a choice either to donate or receive blood. It hurts watching people die from complications of things like blood transfusions too. One of the biggest scandals was the blood bank business which prior to the AIDS epidemic, set up shop in prisons, bowery's and skid rows pandering to the sickest most debached populations as blood donors to make maximum profit, and without informing either hospitals or recipients. Thousands were infected with AIDS this way. This is documented history. Autologous blood donation is still the best choice, as despite public safeguards, corruption continues and new diseases emerge.
(Does this have anything specifically to do with amritdharis? No. Then again, as a lifestyle choice amritdharis who are vegetarian, do not drink, smoke or take drugs, or behave in promiscuous ways, are less likely than the general population to spread disease. Is it a factor to consider? I think it is. Are all amritdharis free from risk factors? No. I used myself as an example since I work with high risk populations and am continually exposed to diseases.)
[quote]THE bad news came with the death of an elderly patient in Britain two years ago. While seemingly unremarkable, this was automatically the subject of an autopsy because the patient had a blood transfusion in 1999 from a donor who had died later from the human form of mad cow disease: variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD).
In Britain, paranoia is rife about human-to-human vCJD transmission via blood. This disease is the newest type of prion disease in a group that includes bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE). This automatic look-back policy on British blood product recipients proved a grim genetic revelation, as well as the first solid indication of what experts had feared: that the BSE epidemic that has wiped out millions of cows was entering a new phase - secondary transmission through humans.
http://www.smh.com.au/news/world/too-late-to-shut-the-gate-on-this-killer/2006/05/14/1147545210765.html[/quote]
[quote]The risk of HIV transmission in the USA by blood screened negative for HIV antibody was recently estimated at one in 440,000-660,000 donations. Despite this low risk, continued public concern has compelled blood collection agencies and policy makers to continue to search for more sensitive HIV screening tests. Genome amplification techniques are receiving increased attention and are being piloted in Germany. HIV-1 p24 antigen testing was implemented in the USA in March 1996. In the first 18 months of p24 antigen testing, an estimated 18 million blood donations were tested at a cost of US$90 million to detect three antigen-positive, antibody-negative donations. However, in many developing countries where severe anemia is widespread and the prevalence of HIV infection among blood donors is orders of magnitude greater than in industrialized countries, the blood supply is either incompletely screened or not screened at all for HIV antibody. Although the contribution of transfusion-transmitted infection to the HIV epidemic has not been accurately assessed, an estimated 5-10% of HIV infections in developing countries are due to blood transfusion.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=9632988&dopt=Abstract[/quote]
[quote]In 2002, transfusion-associated transmission (TAT) of West Nile virus (WNV) infection acquired through blood transfusion marked the emergence of a new threat to the U.S. blood supply (1). Although mosquito-borne transmission remains the predominant mode of WNV transmission (2), identification of TAT underscored the need for WNV screening of donated blood. In June 2003, blood-collection agencies (BCAs) implemented investigational WNV nucleic acid--amplification tests (NATs) to screen all blood donations and identify potentially infectious donations for quarantine and retrieval. This screening was performed on approximately 6 million units during June--December 2003, resulting in the removal of at least 818 viremic blood donations from the blood supply. This report summarizes the results of blood-donation screening tests conducted during 2003 and describes six cases of WNV TAT that occurred because of transfusion of components containing low levels of virus not detected by the testing algorithm. These data indicate that blood screening for WNV has improved blood safety. However, a small risk of WNV transfusion-associated transmission remains.
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5313a1.htm[/quote]
Re: Accepting Blood
domalla premee · 24 Jul 2006
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
For many reasons and not necessarily because of discrimination, many people set their own blood aside (autologous transfusion) in the case of major planned surgery. It is a smart sensible thing to do for many people.
There is nothing wrong with being hesitant accepting someone else's blood especially in the light of many diseases that are transmitted that way.
Even if the blood is screened for major bloodborne diseases there are others that are likely not screened for. Given increasing globalization and population shifts it is likely one can be exposed to donors that have exotic blood borne diseases not native to our shores.
dass