Re: CHAND-TORA?
Gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 01 Oct 2004
weird... i was JUST talking to a singh about this... and he said that other people have told him it's not really 'acceptable' as opposed to a khanda
Re: CHAND-TORA?
Sikh Scholar · 01 Oct 2004
I have seen the khanda stamped on sikh coins which are from 1710-11 during Banda Singh Bahadar,s time.
Before the establishment of a mint the Khanda was imprinted on top of Mughal coins.
Re: CHAND-TORA?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 02 Oct 2004
I'm not sure if it's right or wrong
but the Khanda is not a "divine symbol" made by Guru sahib or anything of the sort.
The Khanda as we know it today, consists of the Bhagauti sword (khanda), the miri piri kirpans, and the chakar.
All of these were a part of the shastars used by Sikhs in Guru jee's time.
Many of these shastars were worn in this manner on the head of nihung singhs. They actually wore shakars around and on the front of their dumalas, as well as small kirpans and small double-edged swords.
Somewhere along the line that usage of armour became a symbol or emblem.
It represents a lot and it always did - but just because it is new does not mean it is less significant or unimportant.
As far as I know, all nishaan sahibs during the time of the gurus had Ik Onkar on them and they were blue.
Also is it possible that because the aad-chand is a symbol of Islam, and the shiv-ling a symbol of Hinduism, the Bhagauti sword is a symbol of the one infinite creator of all - that the combination emblem, which Gursikhs now adorn their dastaars with, is a representation that there is IK ONKAR above all other religions?
Essentially this is the meaning of IKONKAR too..
IK = one
O, A, NG = Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva
Kaar = Creator
One Creator of the Destroyers, the Preservers, and the Creators
saadh sangat jee please share you thoughts
stay in chardee kalaa
please forgive my mistakes
Re: CHAND-TORA?
BirRaas Singh · 04 Oct 2004
Also is it possible that because the aad-chand is a symbol of Islam, and the shiv-ling a symbol of Hinduism, the Bhagauti sword is a symbol of the one infinite creator of all - that the combination emblem, which Gursikhs now adorn their dastaars with, is a representation that there is IK ONKAR above all other religions?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
this is absolutly true, the khalsa bana is a representation which is recognised by both muslims and hindus aswell as sikhs
in the times of guru gobind singh ji the hindus made moortis of gods and goddesses, to guru gobind singh ji goddess chandi wasnt a idol, the power of chandi is in the sword, chandi rides a tiger (singh), rather then making people bow infront of a idol and wish that something happens, maharaj gave us the power to learn how to use shastar, so a singh with a shastar in his hand (Chandi) is the power to destroy evil in itself
the blue bana can be seen as the colour of shiv ji, the farla is a representation of devine knowledge as depicted in pictures of shiv ji with the ganga sprouting from their head, shiv ji in hindu mythology is the destroyer, so he has a considerable about of rudra rass (essense of fury), so the moon (chand) on his head cools this rage - curled moustashes can be seen as the tarshool of shiv ji
on the islamic side, the moon is a symbol of their faith, the blue bana can be contrasted with the 5 khalasi (who are described to wear blue clothes and turbans) that will arrive with medhi avtar
so to these 2 major faiths the khalsa bana has something familiar with their own, and brings harmony and recognition amongst them, hence bringing ppl of both faiths together through our identity and roop, just as bani brings all faiths together, so does bana
Re: CHAND-TORA?
not shant raas · 05 Oct 2004
well spoken both amandeep singh and bir raas singh. you both spoke with full evidence supporting your enquiries.
____________________________________________________________so he has a considerable about of rudra rass (essense of fury), so the moon (chand) on his head cools this rage - curled moustashes can be seen as the tarshool of shiv ji
____________________________________________________________
that is why akaali's who followed the Kyshatriya way wore the aad chand (half moon crescent signifying that he the warrior represents 'Shiv-Swaroop' (i.e., the very form of Shiva) to symbolize them keeping cool even when in battle.
Re: CHAND-TORA?
singhdicate · 08 Oct 2004
extremely informative topic..... it doesn't hurt when you have a great author and researcher such as Amandeep on this thread.
he's done a wonderful job in answering the questions...you won't believe me but, he's even nicer in person
i'm so jealous about him owning one of the Sikh battle flags.
can't wait for the new book to be released.....
singhdicate
Re: CHAND-TORA?
Chand-tora SIngh · 11 Dec 2004
hmm
SO the Chan dis actually a hindu thingy
so why do Jatha Singhs wear it then????
so it had nothing to do with Sikhi???
if it's brahmanical then wy do Jatha Singsh wear Chands?
Re: CHAND-TORA?
Mohan Singh · 12 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
One does not have to associate everything with a remotely "Hindu" background as being "Brahmanical" and wrong. There is plenty of mention of "Hindu" Gods and concepts in Bani. This doesnt mean Sikhs are "Hindu" it just means there are similarities and overlaps in places.
Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh Ji wore an Aad Chand. As did Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji. And so has Shaheed Jathedar Bhai Sukhdev Singh Ji Babbar I believe.
We do not reject the doctrine of Karma and Reincarnation (although they do differ slightly in Sikhe) just because it is a "Hindu" concept also. There may be different connotations attached to the Aad Chand, as are being discussed here.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: CHAND-TORA?
Naridner S Sall · 12 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Very Interesting debate , learning loads here, and Veer Amandeep Ji may Guru Ji keep you motivated with your works, looking forward to the release of the book soon.
With regards to the Guru Ji's Kalgi, I posted on this forum a while back , some replies mentioned it being in Canada Abbotsford. I wonder if anyone has seen it or has pictures of it , if so please post your comments. Here is the link of when I posted on this forum::
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=16880&t=16845#reply_16880
Also the one mentioned at Hazoor Sahib, was there more than one if not which is authentic?
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: CHAND-TORA?
respectfully · 13 Dec 2004
Dear Amandeep Singh -
In finding out more about the aad-chand, it would be ideal to find out its history, particularly references to who used it and when - when were non-Sikhs using this symbol and when did Sikhs start using this symbol?
Since you have put forth that this symbol is an ancient fertility symbol, I am hoping you can provide references to that effect and hopefully provide more details as to when this symbol came into usage with Sikhs. I am not asking this in any form of a challenge or critique but simply because I wish to know more details and think the forum would likewise benefit in learning more about this symbol.
If the symbol is what you state it to be, and it is something Sikhs started wearing later on in our history - then we need to reflect on this and consider whether we want to be wearing such a symbol (depicting genitalia) on our dastaars. More information is needed, ideally in the form of references.
Thank you.
respectfully,
Respectfully