Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

:s · 29 Sep 2004

I found the below story. It's disturbing. But I'm wondering whether anyone can confirm it's true or not? It just seems too horrific to be real. ______________ A true account of what happened to a girl in Pakistan. A tale of truth and is upsetting. First of all before I start telling you what happened with me, I would like to thank my paa ji who showed me how my sorrow could be someone elses relief. Thank you paa ji. My story started when I was 16 years old living in Handsworth, we had just finished our last GCSE exams. To celebrate, we all decided to go to a "bhangra gig" during the day, as we knew we would not have been allowed to go in the night. There were 4 of us, best of friends, we decided to go, although we knew we would get into trouble if are parents found out, but we thought that we "only live once" and as it was a special occasion, so we went. This was the first time any one of us had done something like this, it was an experience. When we got there we could not believe how many people our age were there from all over Birmingham, all Asian! I was shocked more than my friends, there were people drunk, boys/girls smoking, this was the new generation of Asians enjoying the western world freedoms. I remember saying to my friends, "We need to stick together, no matter what happens", we honestly did not know what was going to happen once we were inside. Once we got in, they were playing some old bhangra tune? The whole place was packed with "apnaay". Everyone was just so chilled out, it was unbelievable. We got to a side of the club, and just stood there staring at every one  dancing, flirting and of course fighting. About an hour later, we were approached by this really nice looking guy, came over to my mate and started chatting, we then noticed the "Kara" on his arm so we assumed it was ok to chat to him, his name was "Mick". We were then introduced to his mates, all of them were really smart and good looking. And we were enjoying this mingling with boys for the first time, we felt both scared and excited, because we had never done this before. They brought us drinks, and encouraged us to have some alcohol  something we all strongly at that time refused, but once we paired up and went our separate ways everything changed (I never saw my friends again until a couple hours later, dancing with some strangers, and they were not themselves. I could not believe it, they were drunk! We justified dancing the way we were as we always danced at wedding parties.)  I went over to them to see what had happened, they totally ignored me and encouraged me to drink  which I then did. My dad would drink a lot so I assumed it be ok). We left the club at the end, it was about 4 o' clock, I remember thinking how the hell are we going to get home? We were giggling, And we were late and drunk. I knew my gran would, phone my mum at work if I did not get home in the next 20mins, (I was normally home about 3:50pm, and it was already ten past four, I was in the middle of Birmingham City centre, 40mins away from home by bus!! I was so scared, I knew I was going to get into serious trouble once I got home, and I smelt strongly of smoke and alcohol. My dad was going to kill me. We did not know what to do? Then the guys, who we were dancing in the club, came over and asked us if we were alright? or if we needed anything?, i.e. a lift home, because we were so desperate, we said yes. They dropped us home, we exchanged numbers and they went. I got slapped that day, my dad went absolutely mad, because I had lied, went to a club, danced with boys and got drunk! The whole family was really upset. I remember thinking I will never do anything like this again. My friends got the same treatment. It was not until a couple of weeks later, that some one kept ringing my house number, anonymous caller, and my gran, bless her, would go over to answer the phone, but no reply. Then one day, as my gran was cooking my roti, the phone rang and I answered, it was that guy from the club. I didn't know what to do. I was scared and yet anxious to what might happen. He wanted us to meet up again, he wanted to know how we were?  This was going to be my first relationship. I got to know "Abs" over the next couple of months, we would arrange, the best times for him to call me, it was exciting, no one knew about him, I felt needed and loved. He was 18 at the time, and I had just turned 16. He drove a really nice car and worked for his uncle, in I.T. It got to a stage were we would meet up in the middle of the night, I would sneak out of my house, he would pick me up at the bottom of my street, and we would go everywhere together  I was loving every minute of it  and every time we would not see each other, I felt like dying  I was truly in love with him. I did notice that he was not Punjabi, he dressed different to normal Punjabi boys that age, and he didn't drink and smoke. He knew a lot of Muslims, but I decide to ignore that fact, as I was having the time of my life. I had a funny feeling he was Muslim, but he wore a Kara? and I never had the courage to ask him, because I didnt want to ruin anything between us. But finally that day came when he revealed that he must go to the mosque, I was taken back, I didnt know how to respond, my boyfriend was a Muslim, and I loved him too much to let him go. I asked him about his name, his nickname was Abs. he had told me his name was Harbinder, but in fact his name was Yasseen. This was a distressing situation, he had lied to me and led me on to believe he was Sikh, but was in fact a Muslim. I confronted him, I asked him, you knew I was a Sikh, then why did you get into this relationship with me? He answered my question with a question, does it matter? And I remember replying "No" after a few minutes, I thought to myself he's not your typical Muslim, and he has treated me with respect. It was a hard time, I felt like breaking up with him, he was a Muslim, it wouldn't work? But I could not help it, he loved me, I loved him, and I kept reminding myself, he was different, and all those good times we had during the start of our relationship. So we decided to give it a shot, (what fool I was), we would spend a lot of time together, he got me job at his uncles firm, they all treated me with respect although I was a Sikh, and all of them were Muslim, they were so nice to me. I felt wanted and at home with me boyfriends family. We saw each other for over 2 year's (all through collage) and then came the time for me to leave my home and go to university, I went out of town a good few hours away, I wanted to live as far as away from my family as possible, as they were the obstacle, in my life from him. I had stopped wearing my Kara and my gold khanda necklace. I also stopped going to the Gurdwara, because I did not want to offend him, and I would use that time instead to be with him. I loved him and would do anything for him, anything. At university. Things got a bit serious, I lived in halls first, but everyone would look at me and call me names to my face and behind my back, they even trashed my flat twice!! All because I was going out with a Muslim, I would try to explain to them, he was different and he loved me, they would not have none of it, I felt so bad, he had to go through a lot because of me. This was a really bad experience for me, and I felt vulnerable and weak. Things started to change a lot during the first few weeks at my university. I quit uni, and moved into a flat with him, he got me another job, and again his cousin helped us financially. I never told my parents that I had done this, they would phone me, I would say everything was going excellent, and I would lie to them. During this time, I started to stop going home, I would say that I had too much uni work to do, and so I couldnt come home. Then, I stopped answering my phone from my family and friends, because I knew all they would say is to stop seeing him, and come home etc. so I changed my number, that's not the only thing I changed, a few months later I changed my name! We were happy together, we were in love, we were made for each other!! A few months later I even changed my faith, I became a Muslim, I was happy then to finally be apart of something that was so great, everyone loved me, and I was finally at home and peace. Islam then offered everything to me, it made sense and was the truth, Sikhism had to many flaws in it, or that is what I was told, and I believed everything he said, it all made sense, Sikhism was a man-made religion, it believed in caste (we had Gurdwara made on caste) we would make our women dance half naked on bhangra video's, while Islam would teach us to cover the women because she is so precious, like an diamond. I was duped, I knew nothing about Sikhism, my parents never told me, and I never learnt anything at the Gurdwara, never understood what the Granthi's were saying. And as a result I believed everything he told me. We then decided to get married, but he said we should go to Pakistan to that, because his sisters were there, and they were all dying to meet me! So I agreed, we went. The year was 1994, I was 19 years old. What I am about to tell you now, is the most disturbing part of my life, I have had to receive medical treatment from Doctor's on a regular basis for a long period, due to this. I would like to say something before I continue, what I am about to tell you, is no exaggeration in any way, this is exactly how it happened, and the metropolitan police are well aware of it. Whilst I was on the flight over to Pakistan, I was so excited, I was finally going to get married to the love of my Life, I never thought about my family or friends, as I had everything I ever needed through him. And because I was taught to believe that they were the devil, they will take me to hell, and I did not want to go there. When we reached Pakistan, there were a few people there to greet us, I had worn the hi-jab, as a sign of respect to my new in-laws and faith. They were so happy to see me. We were then herded into a 4x4, and then of we went to meet the rest of Yasseen's family. We were driving for a few hours, and I was absolutely worn out. We then stopped at what seemed to be a police station or the local sheriff's office, the luggage was taken out of the jeep, and these men came and took the luggage away, Yasseen came over and took my personal belongings, everything, my passport, money even my toothbrush, he said the police wanted to check our things, in case we were smuggling drugs, I remember laughing at first, but when I looked at his face, he was deadly serious, I gave him everything and then I was taken to a room, where I was told to wait. They asked Yasseen questions. It seemed like ages, while I waited in that room, on my own. I was getting very worried for Yasseen. During this time, two more cars and a jeep had come to this police station. Finally, a middle aged man came over and started to ask me personal questions. I had trouble understanding what he was saying, he spoke so fast, in Urdu. I kept asking him to take me to Yasseen. He said "Yasseen has gone", those three words stopped my heart beating, I was alone in a remote village in Pakistan, with no belongings and locked up a room. I did not know what to think? What was happening? This was not supposed to happen? Where had Yasseen gone? I cried, and pleaded with the men there to take me to Lahore, they would simply laugh at me and beat me. For a few days, I did not eat or sleep, I was disorientated, and I did not know what to do? I became ill, I was very weak, a doctor was called, he gave me some medicine, with which all I did was sleep. The next thing I remember was, when I woke up in a room, with a small barred window, and a small door. This door was locked from the outside, I started to scream, a women cam rushing over. I was relieved for a moment that women had come over to my aid, until she started to shout at me and curse me. I didn't know what was going on. I just sat there in that small, cold room, with blank mind. They would give some bread and water three times a day. I was allowed to go to the toilet only once a day. By now I had realized, I was not going home and Yasseen was not coming to my rescue. The building I stayed at was 3 storeys, and was very big. It must have had more than 30 rooms. It was the only building there, there was nothing anywhere around this building, just fields and 1 tarmac road. It was a brothel. I was not a lone there were 3 other girls (Sikh) that were in the same situation as me. We were all kept on the top floor, we were all given one room each. The other girls had been there longer than me, we would get a chance to speak during the night. They told me of their stories and how they got here, they sounded familiar. It would be very cold during the night. They told me, on the 3rd day, what happens here. This where, the locals came to enjoy themselves. I was very frightened. This is where they would come to quench their desires. I remember how they treated us, they would treat us like animals, they would rape us, and then spit on our faces after they were done. It was a living nightmare, with no escape. I spent 15 months here, over that period of time, I have seen 36 more girls been brought here, I have seen 7 commit suicide, by jumping of the building and 20 odd taken away by rich businessmen who would use them in their own brothels. I saw and lived in HELL, I saw young girls being raped, I herd the screams of these girls and their frustration, that no one would help them. When I first saw the police approach the building, I thought that we had been saved, was I proved wrong, they beat a girl to death right in front of us all, to show us who was in charge, and what would happen if we didnt co-operate. If you think for a second, that what I am saying is lies, go and approach the Scotland Yard, they have the full details of who the girls were and where they were from. I saw this with my own eyes, and no-one ever helped us. A time came when me and another girl, got the opportunity to escape, we had been taken to a local tribesmans house, a fight had broken out, in his house, in the confusion Guru ji gave us an opportunity to escape, we took a jeep, and set out on the roads, we didnt know where we were going, we just went, where ever the road took us. We got close to a town Called Eminabad, here we informed the police of what had happened to us, they helped us, we were handed over to the British embassy and sent back to the UK. Once back in the UK, the police tried to hand us back to our families, OUR OWN families had disowned us, my family told me to go away, that I had brought shame to the family name, I tried to apologise, and they would not accept it. I even tried to get help form the Gurdwara, they said they could not help us. We had to go back to the police, who then put us in a witness protection programme. The year is 1996, I was then 21. We both were given a new chance to start a fresh, the police helped us a great deal. In the programme we were given a place to stay and they gave us new jobs, to rebuild our lives. I am now 29, married and a 3 year old girl. I re-initiated into Sikhism in 1998, me and my friend, we took Amrit and took an active role to combat what had happened to us and help others in the same situation. There is not a single second that goes by, without me thinking about those poor girls locked up in Pakistan. I have been scared for life. But I must do everything I can to try to create awareness to help those girls that scream every night and go through that abuse. I am thankful to the Police who are trying to help those girls, but I think we as a community need to do much more. We must come out of hiding, and face the danger these girls now face. But what we find is a really negative attitude employed by all parties, the families, Gurdwara and the girls, to do anything about this. I know what happened to me and what is still happening to those that are in Pakistan. Accordingly to the latest figures, there are 300 girls there right now, facing constant abuse, who are getting drugged up everyday and then raped. One of them is your relative!! Just keep that I mind, your cousin who you have not seen for over 3 years, went to university and never came back! When you ask your uncle and auntie, where is your cousin who you nor your family have seen for so long, you get the reply, that she has brought a house there and she has found herself a good job, and so she is constantly busy. I beg you please stop these lies, please help my sisters' in Pakistan, who no-one helps, their families are too scared, or they don't know where she is? We must put a stop to this, I saw what is happening there, believe me, I do not even wish this to happen my enemies, when you see a young girl being raped by savages, who beat her and then spit on her  you remember God, believe me  when all you can hear is her screams to stop and her cry for help  all you can do is watch. Those girls need your help! I pray all the time to Guru, to please help, those girls, every time I get the chance. We must make sure not a single girl goes to that living Hell from today. We must educate every one of our girls and boys about our religion. We must take it upon our selves to educate ourselves and our own families about Sikhism and the dangers it faces constantly. We must thrive to make sure this never happens to any girl, irrelevant of her religion ever again. I hope Guru Ji helps us. I hope you at least help your self and your own family. I would like to thank both the Pakistan and British police that are trying to combat this increasing trend, I hope all those that took those poor girls over to Pakistan, realise that God is within us all, and not just in the heavens, I wish they could just imagine for 1 single second, that one of those girls was their own sister! No one would ever want this to happen to anyone, believe me. We have altered the above account to safe guard our source. The name and locations have been changed and how our penji escaped has been changed dramatically for the simple reason not to jepordise any other girls opportunity to escape. Please note this is not racial incitement as it was MUSLIMS that finally got penji back into Britain. We would like to thank penji for giving us this account, we can only appreciate how hard it must have been to write this or what she went through! I would also like to say, please do not discriminate a whole race because of a small minority. This is against the principles Sikhi PLEASE EDUCATE OUR BROTHERS AND SISTERS ON OUR BEAUTIFUL HISTORY, LEARN ABOUT YOUR RELIGON SO THIS WILL NOT HAPPEN TO OUR FELLOW BROTHERS AND SISTERS AGAIN.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

mast · 29 Sep 2004

happens all the time but it takes two to tango im a mundah i been asked out by muslim women who make their personalities appear better when they talk to you, and look pretty, but wheres the sikhi in dating in the first place? if we can hold back why cant girls? you only get duped when you allow yourself to. every punjabi girl knows a story like this in england. so called sikh boys also on the hunt for sikh girls do the same things its not just muslims soon there will be another popular reaction like mass dating white or black people to get away from everything asian. You will be surprised to learn some of the local pimps dealers gangsters in this area are born from sikh families and trap girls into the "game" too. Its not one way traffic. Who do you think the local pimpsters are in west london? punjabis. who do you think most of the girls are? where and how do you think these girls end up in such a situation? people want to date and find their ideal partner but its landing them in strife.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

jk · 29 Sep 2004

That was a very touching story - thank you kindly for sharing it. It surely is a wake-up call for many of us of what is happening in our community. We obviously are failing our youth somewhere along the line. Bhen Ji quite rightly mentioned the responsibility of the Sikh community as well as that of the parents in educating and guiding our youth. I studied at Aston Uni in Birmingham in the early 90's, and was astounded to see so many intelligent Sikh girls in relationships with Muslims who then went on to convert to Islam. At that time I was the only Amritdhari girl at the University and many of them would approach me in confidence. What used to strike me was the desperation in them, as if they wanted me to confront them. There was an inner urge to know more about Sikhism but were too frightenened to come out of the relationship to ' a loving, caring guy' and then be married off to 'the typical outgoing Sikh Jat who would rather spend his time at a pub or club.' We as a society need to educate our kids about Sikhism at every level so THEY know what they are talking about. Just as important is for us to act as role models and strive to ban the prejudice of women in our families, and live our life according to Gurmat.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

GurSikh wannabe · 30 Sep 2004

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji KI Fateh! In the Gurdwara parents, children do not get katha on how one can and should bring Gurmat into their lives, how it will help them, how it is able to make a human being mentally strong and independent. My young brothers and sisters, who do not lead a 'Sikh Way of Life', can't see how Gurmat is relevent today, how it help them in their life. When they are shown this then they will see the Beauty of Gurmat and sacrifice their egos (i.e. start walking this enriching path). This world is a place where most people (not all) are ego-centric (to whatever degree), we only do something when we can see our benefit in it or there is a NEED, a main need being wanting to be happy, so show them how they can be happy , according to Guru Granth Sahib Ji - the Universal wealth of guidance! I have passed through that same Nagar of a disillusioned youngsters, thats why I say this.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

JhelThaara · 02 Oct 2004

there are no doubt muslim males who prey on sikh girls. But in my college and uni experiences i have also seen it the other way round. Xmount of sikh girls also fancied muslim guys and openly approach the guys. I studied with one bengali muslim guy who looked half gora. He had 8 girls ask him out in the first 2 weeks and surprise surprise 5 of them were sikh girls. Most of the clubs are filled with sikh and muslim girls. There is this fusion thing called "asian". Sikhs and muslims freely mix in clubs, if they didnt want that they wudnt be in clubs in the first place with asian gigs. Have you seen any gig that solely sikh? how is that possible when the majority of the asian population in britain is muslim. These girls get used blatently and then come running back saying the sob story. Then why do it? Whats the point saying it was religion after youve just allowed yourself to be used as meat? If you have a sister or daughter, how do you feel about her wearing clothes that reveal these shapes? why do you feel that way? because you know guys are gonna get on their cases. No offence to women wear what you want, but you know the consequences and having guys chasing after u in that wiodfe nasty world if you go round flashing your shapes in colleges. One sikh girl down the rd was fair, light eyed, loaded, from a good family. guess what? she was in a relationship with a bengali from a council flat for one year. My pakistani mate is the one who was shocked and told me what was going on. She approached the family to marry him and offered herself to be converted so she could marry the guy and be with him in a scummy part of twon in a council flat with no future. Guess what? his dad told her where to go, she would not fit in with the family because she is not even a muslim. She had to leave him. Now why an earth did a good looking sikh girl who could have been with a handsome Sikh choose a bengali in a run down area? its not as if its one case, its one after the next. Its not just muslims its big tyme with gorey and kaley too now. But you see when its a white man we accept it. i been asked out by bare gals in hijaabs, and if they were singhanis with dastaars i would bet you they would stand out as some of the prettiest. Dont you think us mans get it? is our test any easier than yours? Sikhs need to get their house in order. One of the biggest problems that leads to this is the way women are treated. Akhand kirtan jatha as a paracharak group has done well to give a woman an equal place in sikh society wher others have relapsed. back to this point, in my heart i have remorse for this girl only as far as sikhi jeevan and values go. why clubs? why date? what diff is dating a sikh male to a muslim male? would it help if i told you the gravesend case? a sikh man got friendly with a sikh girl half his age for a reason. To get back at someone. He took her away and raped her. Now thats sikh on sikh. He got jailed 4 years for that 3 years ago. If that was a muslim it would be screaming headlines in every sikh newspaper. yes muslim chapter on girls need solving. But coming out with these sob stories wont do anything. These stories have gone round for like 10 years and u got even more girls converting via dating. So why not take the problem at its root. First thing is to understand a lot of these sikh girls are not sikh in practice. How could sikh parents enshrine into their childrens hearts that they should at least keep in mind when adult marry a sikh with poora sikhi saroop. half the problem lies in the nafrat for the roop. then every clean cut guy is a potential. Sikhs are very limited by choices at the moment. If your a kid your mum says no you have to marry a jatt when your older. but all the jatts you know in uni wanna drink or mess around. Whats going on inside you? your worried for a crap future, but u wanna be happy. u see where im going. we gotto make m,assive changes not jus a bit. this is year 2004. paks will always harrass a sikh girl now cos they work on points . We have to tighten up on our ends so we dont let our girls fall prey. awareness is just one thing we gotto do practical things that will secure us long term answers and brainstorm this properly

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Rashminder Singh Oz · 04 Oct 2004

Vaheguru ji its been a very sad story............... may vaheguru bless u and all other girls suffering from all this and i would say it is mistake of parents not being a parchark for thier kids. Gurbaani Baanaa Sevaaa Simran Amrit di daat is the solution for these problems Vaheguru Fateh

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 04 Oct 2004

The gigmania is a product of bhangra groups capitalising on the punjabi identity third generation sikhs were trying to find in the 1980s. During this time the gigs had heavy "punjabi" presence even up north. This trend hit waves with loads of kids missing school to go to gigs, college students and at night uni students. A very large number of punjabi/sikh girls would attend. in the last 15 years muslims have muscled their way into gigs taking over. Roughly ten years ago they have been dominating most clubs in nearly every part of the country where asians are a majority except for west london where punjabis clearly are heavily concentrated. This has happened through targetted attacks specifically on sikh males that look visibly sikh. Then the muslims would get a sikh girl to dance with them, purposely kick off with sikh males, then in large numbers attack the sikh group showing no mercy. this was a strong message to sikh males this is what will happen to you we are the boss now. The sikh females attend as "asians out for a chill out time" with their muslim female friends. The muslim male and females together tell the sikh females different stories that sikh males are being racist and not letting us get on as asians should. These attacks are run in thousands not dozens. Some of trhem have resulted in brutal murders of teenaged males who hadnt even seen life. Neither the media or sikh outlets have reported them due to their lax sikh muslim vibe. One of the attacks by a bengali gang in 1994 left a 15 year old sikh boy from hounslow disabled for life in a wheelchair all because the bengali gang were fighting with the sp over a sikh girl that was purposely hanging round with bengalis to pee the sikhs off. The 15 year old boy came by himself and danced alone was targetted due to his ghooti. 2 sikh males from east london were brutally killed in a different incident. One was stabbed in the body at least 17 times at lescter square on christmas eve after these so called bhangra gigs he was only 19 in year 1999. his best friend was murdered after a gig in derby the muslim gang crashed their car into his and squashed him to death in the year 2001. has any of this stopped sikh girls attending bhangra gigs? NO! the 90s reached a ridiculous stage where muslim males started wearing karras to attract the sikh girls their way. The shere punjab a voluntary group helping women at the time notified e groups, put up notices in gurdwaras and told them of this situation. The sangats and punjabis in general have been made aware on numerous occasions through noticeboards since 1995. The muslim groups from slough would also wear karras to decieve sikh males into thinking they were sikh and then ambush them using large karras on their heads. The facts are theres too much to write we could sit here all day. Now most gigs are entitled something along the line of "punjabi virsa" "vasakhi gig" "diwali gig" "punjabi boom" etc. In the uk there are approx 2 million muslims around half of them are pakistani. Most of pakistan is punjab. There are about 700 000 sikhs. 350 000 hindu punjabis in uk. these events are simply titled punjabi so so. So would these gigs only attract sikhs? In society itself how easy is it to differentiate between a sikh male and a muslim male if both are clean shaven when both come from punjabi stocks? Having knowledge that muslim males wear karras to attract sikh females, with large presence at most gigs besides west london would a girl seriously think shes going to find either the love of her life, or a sikh male with values at a bhangra gig? Some sikhs bought up in the 80s parents fresh from pinds ready to die for their honour believeing it was their duty to protect sikh women would attend these gigs at young ages and find themselves in a fight with the muslim gangs and locked in jail with criminal records, there were no sikh orgamnisations that would help them. Did this stop sikh females attending gigs? NO. sikh guys and these sp groups after sacrificing a lot have learnt that you cant stop every single sikh girl out there from checking a muslim male. There are about 200 cases of sikh girls lured the same way to pakistan, some of them have made it back most havent. Has this had any effect on girls attending clubs now? How do most of these girls identity themself? sikh or asian? I offer my apology to every single sikh on this website as this information is not gurmat and will not help your sikhi but sheds light on the current topic.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 04 Oct 2004

one of the biggest embarrasments and shock to me was when i was talking to a female sikh colleague who claimed she was heavily into khalistan. Her father did seva and was a real anakhwala, yet this same female on one hand talking about khalistan would attend bhangra gigs with muslim males and called them her friends like brothers hence absolute no guilt factor. her brother didnt like it but couldnt do anything about it. Her parents didnt know but being the only daughter she would have got away with it. she knew more about sikhi and 84 than i ever did.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 04 Oct 2004

bul chug maaf karna i offer my apologies if i offended anyone. I have seen the lives robbed away from sikh boys. Nobody has ever recognised the sacrifices of sikh boys who have tried to fight for what was right in the uk , or even help them while they stood in jails while they had families and kids to feed, then coming ouit of jail with noone giving them a job. Nobody in the world cared to listen to the cries of the mothers who will never see their sons again. One of them her youngest son replays his birthday video of him when he was just 5, she was very close to loosing the plot. The father sat and stared at empty space. I dont know what the other mother went through that was her only son. These men are nobodies martyrs. The sikh boys of yesterday who tried to stand their ground had mud smeared in their face and called "indian agents trying to cause trouble between sikhs and paks". One of my ex work colleagues lost his eldest daughter aged 28 from kidney failure. Due to the stress of the death he and his wife ended up with blood pressure and heart problems. he had two remaining daughters left. This man struggled hard working 11 hours a day to feed his kids and keep his family together. One of his daughters decided to convert to islam and marry her bf. the father already lost a daughter he couldnt face loosing another so he was forced to accept it. The daughter being very "missyfied" announced it loud and clear to my friends wife ( both amritdhari) at a different wedding " auntie ji dont take this the wrong way but im now a muslim and my new name is ....... happily married". I mean lets forget about being sikh a second, any human being on the earth who has seen their parents suffer to this level would they push their parents through hell again? wouldnt their be an ounce of remorse in the heart? wouldnt make you think twice? has the world gone crazy that your own mother and father mean nothing? bul chug maaf karna but when its sikh girls the whole world feels sympathy, when its yesterdays sikh boys nobody gave a crap. Well it has worked out the way people wanted it , young lads fed up of going to jails, sikh girls now free to do what they want. Now they have to live with the consequences of that freedom, however good or bad.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

YoungerBabbarKhalsa · 04 Oct 2004

Never trust a sullah dumb broads u are not sikhs HSV

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Singh jee · 04 Oct 2004

Very informative posts by hmmm. The situation on the ground is very bad in UK. Our girls are just so badly ill-informed and blind with their youth. They don't listen to anyone and don't even care about their parents. The guys too are losers. Only if our youth follows teachings of Dashmesh jee, they can live with honour. Otherwise, they will get dishonoured by Pakistanis and Bengalis. I am surprised to hear that even Bengalis are intimidating Sikhs in UK. What a pitiful situation.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Umm · 04 Oct 2004

Maybe the girl truly felt Islam was the path she should follow? Would our Guru's have condemned her?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 04 Oct 2004

Bengalis live in their own quarters generally not a squeek. where the 15 year old boy was battered from hounslow and left for crippled happened at drummond street (bengali quarters). The event was partially family politics. The sikh girl dancing with the bengalis started hanging around with muslims ( both pak and bengali) in her college in a different part of london. She was on her way to conversion and still went out gigs. Her cousin brother was one of the sp lads in west london he came to hear of her new company warned her off she didnt listen and informed some sikhs to go down. About 30 lads went, to their surprise the gig was filled with sikh girls in a bengali part of london. She saw the lads, to tease them more she went to the dancefloor with the bengalis, to whom she was their new piece of meat shared out. A fracus erupted, bouncers kicked half the bengali group out. The bengalis left inside battered the lone sikh boy with the ghooti while the bouncers kicked both parties out. The sikhs outside were outnumbered by 70 bengali youths gathered with weopons they had hidden outside and picked up under bins and cars . Out of 30 sikhs that went only 15 had the bottle to stand up and put up a brave fight that ended up with the police coming and everyone scattered. The sikhs had no weopons exept for karrey, a lucozade bottle and a kurri who gave a small kirpan from her neck. Sikhs by population far outnumber bengalis, but they walk in groups of 20 30 males. At gigs your talking about hefty numbers as one party knows another putting up a united front in seconds. sikhs dont get on with each other. Paks and bengalis culturally hate each other but put up a united front in front of sikhs to intimidate so outnumbered. To them they want to intimidate sikhs as much as they can away from clubs and entice sikh girls towards clubs with the "asian tag". the 15 year old boy was totally innocent who came of his own accord to have a day out for fun and it cost him his future. He cant work, nobody will marry him, he cant walk, what did all this mean to the girl? Nothing! what did this mean to other sikh girls who go to clubs? nothing! Everything is changing fast. there is this new pan islamic wave where nations dont mean anything. Altough culturally paks and bengalis dont get on, religiously muslim groups like the khalifa and hut global islamic ideologies have largescale recruits from bengs and paks and hold regular meetings on how to bring more sikhs to their fold. A large number of sikh girls are with bengalis, this is where the problem starts. Otherwise sikhs dont have problems with anyone. There are so many things happening everyday that would make you sick with disbelief how our sisters have spat at their own heritage and made a mockery of their forefathers. If we lined up 200 sikhs to die for something here it makes me wonder if any of these sisters would stop their activities.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 04 Oct 2004

"Umm Date: 10-04-04 13:22 Maybe the girl truly felt Islam was the path she should follow? Would our Guru's have condemned her?" which girl?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Umm · 04 Oct 2004

Well, the girl you mentioned in your story Hmm. The one who's mother died?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 05 Oct 2004

Singh jee Date: 10-04-04 12:50 "Only if our youth follows teachings of Dashmesh jee, they can live with honour. Otherwise, they will get dishonoured by Pakistanis and Bengalis. I am surprised to hear that even Bengalis are intimidating Sikhs in UK. What a pitiful situation" The gig organisers and bhangra groups then were all sikh but nowdays muslim 2. Without them these gigs are not possible. In one gig one of the most famous uk punjabi singers spotted his own sahkki niece dancing with men and stopped the gig. But what about every other girl? shes just a number paying 10 quid to get through the door. There were enough youth then ready to avenge dishonours and fought hard from the 1980s through the 90s and re emerged temporarily again. But it has reached the point where the mundai have understood how many sikh girls can you stop when girls themselves are willing to walk into every next muslim mans arms? if you look inside your local area tonnes of sikh girls are with a muslim out of choice, can you count the numbers on your hands? You batter up every one you go to jail for what? for her and him its bollywood love. whos gonna give you a job when you come out of jail? how many sikh girls learn from that? i can count 4 murderous deaths on my hands two of which i havent even talked about these girls will still walk into a club looking for their ranjha. It reached the climax again where singhs were being attacked in the late 90s and this century and these paks recieved a reaction that was out of their measure and if it comes to such a dishonour again there will be a lot of people rising all the time. The gigs were going to be closed down at one point due to the amount of trouble they cause. But as far as girls go they can marry muslims its their life now they chose to walk down that road. To me these girls are nothing, forget about dishonours ive seen two boys lie in coffins because of these.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 05 Oct 2004

Umm Date: 10-04-04 15:47 "Well, the girl you mentioned in your story Hmm. The one who's mother died?" " Maybe the girl truly felt Islam was the path she should follow? Would our Guru's have condemned her?" id leave it upto the sangat here to answer how the Gurus would have felt about this girl as my knowledge on gurmat is very limited but no one in their sane mind would make their parents suffering from heart diseases in their late 50s go through mental pain all over again after loosing their first kid. Pyarey ji this is not my story its a real life family fact in london, if you wish i can get a respected jatha singh who frequents here to confirm this as he also knows of this case. Maybe at the time she felt islam was the path while she dated her muslim bf, she wore the boorkha for while at his family residence. He did tell her how rich he was and they wouldnt have any financial probs when they marry. After shes married to him, pop along two kids his family kick him and his wife n kids out of his average 3 bedroom house as they didnt have enough space for his new family, next thing everyone knows their in a council flat scraping on state benefits. He wasnt quite the milllionaire he made himself out to be he was unemployed and had to sell his flash car to pay debts off. Now the girl a mother of two young children wasnt so happy she doesnt have enough money and doesnt know where she is going in life anymore. Lucky for her, her father and mother have been supportive and offered her assistance, she now realises where her jwaani landed her. That grandfather has taken responsibility for bringing up her kids while the childrens father flexes out his youth. the million dollar question is how does she feel about islam being the path now?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Umm · 05 Oct 2004

Well you said before that she was saying to your auntie that she was happily married? No need to be so defensive, maybe I misinterpreted your post.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

hmmm · 05 Oct 2004

Author: Umm Date: 10-05-04 09:12 "Well you said before that she was saying to your auntie that she was happily married? No need to be so defensive, maybe I misinterpreted your post." hanji thats exactly what happened bhai sahib/bhenji. She approached my friends wife 1 and a half years ago at a wedding and said she was happily married but that was then this is now. Times and situations change. defensive? Ji I apologise if i appear to have given you the wrong impression maaf karna.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 06 Oct 2004

look the fundamental problems are 1st within our gurdwara we have so many manmat things going on true gursikhi vachaar is not being done so we are losing out on guru sahibs message 2nd managements dont want to upset the 'paying' sangat! 3 parents dont give a toss anymore about religion. money is the new god 4 in many ways these girls youth they dont think with there brains 5 so essentailly they are not sikh they are just indian/punjabis 6 no path can save them apart from guru jis path 7 if someone began harrassing dastaar wearing amritdharee bibian the wave of protection would be overwhelming! these girls what are they what do they belong to? weak punjabis! weak punjabis to which guru sahib gave the route to power but they have forsaken it and now are lost to be looted again by the same enemies of 500 yrs ago!

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 06 Oct 2004

sikh i agree with most of what you say but i beg you dont drag punjabiat into this the majority of sikh girls i know here and now prefer to b british asian girls than punjabi indian mainly because the environment around them is predominatly asian with a western attitude rather than punjabi in colege and uniiversity. London is a fast paced lifestyle, what punjabiat existed yesterday is replaced with modern new asian now,, tomorow it could be a blend of something else. If you was to talk about sikh muslim issues to them they would be like " but we are all asians". A lot of girls wont even wear karrey no more or speak punjabi, the anglo european sangats are generally cold towards asiatic groups hence leaving asians forming their own melting pot of different asiatic cultures that exist out there. This is the year 2004 we are not talking about when these bhangra club cult started 25 years ago. Ask an elder how things change in time. I dont know how to say this but there are some things in the uk you maybe not aware of. Some ( not all) dastarvali kurris have been seen at gigs too, now if some guy danced or tried to approach them who would you blame?remember this is an atmosphere of drink drugs and loose conduct a place where mature adults have decided to enter out of their choice. you would be further surprised to know few amritdhari ( weak in rehet non dastarvali ) women have run off and left their husbands and children and eloped with muslims never to return one of them had 4 children. One single bibi dastarvali non amritdhari up north england has left home and run off with a pakistani a few years back. In one year alone 5 amritdhari women had converted to islam 3 were dastarvalis in the birmingham region. Another amridhari woman from east london left her family to live with a muslim male in university campus she has not returned since. That was mentioned on this site last year sometime, and another singh came fwd from birmingham and also told he knew knew another similar case, but you cant openly talk about these things due to the sensitivities of the families involved and the ultimate besti on the sikh quam. It would be debateble how a gurdwara would affect a woman depending on what strategies the gurdwara committee adopted for family support, representation of women, etc. You dont have to be amritdhari in order to not go out with a muslim that is an individual choice the person takes, although amrit is a vital stage for every sikh. I know non amritdhari individuals who have never dated. Finally punjabis are not weak, the shera panjab alone has been representing sikhs in many parts of the uk, at one time in 1992 its membership stood at 2000. If sikh women seek muslim males what do you expect the sp to do? what is the moral tale today if a bunch of sikhs beat up a muslim sikh couple living in metro city? the girls want a muslim so why should the sp do someones dirty work? Its not exactly the honourable thing to do to be in a club in the first place girl or boy is it worth fighting for? Times and perception of what we should be are changing. Sikhism will replace punjabiat no doubt because you cant hold what you was in india here. Sikhi is the answer i agree. Its filtered out in stages, these women are not being harrassed they make the concious decision of what they wear, where they go, who their sangat is. I know plenty of mans and girls who are punjabi and never dated in their life.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 06 Oct 2004

'................. ji' asain/punjabi/indian they are the same to me but i understand what you mean. i went throught he whole gig culture guru kirpa i didn't get involved in it although at the time i was a mona as well and the bibi i refer to are rock solid in there rehit! anybody firm in rehit is as powerful as steel and i firmly believe that if we (or should i say the gurdwarae) invested in social programs to educate and help our community we would be able to reverse all the bad stuff which is affecting us at present, rather than blowing 17million pounds on a concrete eye sore. but what can we do it is sad to see the cracks in our kaum and slowly they are widening but nobody cares?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

kkaur · 06 Oct 2004

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh. We need to look at these situations and think why they are happening. The problem lies with Sikh boys as well as Sikh girls. Sikh kids in our families are treated differently, that is probably why it is more common with the girls. How many families have you seen where as little kids the son will have full kes (also dastaar) , and the daughter will have cut hair, ears pierced and be wearing revealing clothes? What kind of up bringing is this for the girls? I'm talking about really young kids, say under 5, where it is the parents making these decisions. How many Amritdhari guys do you know that want a 'trendy' wife? Unfortunately this is true, the guy will have Guru Ji's bannaa and he will marry a girl who doesn't cover her kes, wears the latest fashions and will do all sorts to her eye brows and facial hair. This is the guys fault, this is what they want. Again what's the girl supposed to do? Generally girls are classed as second class citizens. You go to the Gurdwara and the Granthi is doing Ardaas so that a family have a boy. What is this? Then you wonder what is happening to our Sikh girls! I am not making excuses for what is happening, but I think we all need to look at the bigger picture. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 06 Oct 2004

i think sangat and exposure to foreign cultures says a lot. in East ham college london at the height of muslim fanaticism when a nigerian christian was hacked to death by the fanatics some years back , the next targets were sikhs. A muslim gang supported by criminal connections announced in the canteen that every sikh better take their karrey off or die. This 2 lines of oppression against sikh religion started a new branch of punjabi sikhs fighting against oppression, united sikhs from different areas, year later everything died down. So to say punjabis are weak is definatly not the case. After the west thames incident that involved the chalvey fanatics it was 3 weak punjabis who single handedly took on over 40 fanatic muslim men in the later incident following. After a boy had his head battered by the pakistani panthers two years ago who took his dastar off, it was line after line of punjabis outside the doorstep of the singhs house for 4 days offering to help the family and teach the pp . So please dont say weak punjabis. When it comes down to its punjabis that kick it. + 2000 pakistanis came to southall after annual preperations and ransacked 2 gurdwaras in 1996 , 300 sikhs gathered to avenge them the police formed barricades. It was weak punjabis who not only stood up and made sure this doesnt happen again but taught the troublemaklers a good lesson in time to come. But like anything else people rise for valuable reasons, when sikh girls themselves willingly choose muslims its their own ishkq mamla. After their muslim partners have had enough of their fun these girls come running back crying the muslims done soething to them, but at the time they checked the muslims their "asian" now they suddenly become sikh.This is what sikh men boys laid kurbaniya for decade after decade and nobody heard them, these girls never cared that someone lost their education, career hopes, limbs, life, financial situations. Next time they jump on that dancefloor maybe they wanna think about the blood that was split there to stop things like this happening in the first place.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 06 Oct 2004

k kaur and sikh i agree with you both and yours is a very valuable contribution to this thread for we need to look at the whole picture and opening up the chapter of how sikh women are treated at home is important and understanding why? At this juncture i do not feel that inequality is the only reason for everyone of thousands upon thousands of women eloping with muslims but do feel that is a part of the problem. Trust me in college and university its that type of strong culture that influences people whatever their family situation is. I have seen girls from perfect equal families end up getting ripped apart too because they thought they found the love of their life. Punjabi families have come to the uk in different waves , some from second world war, others 60s, then the kenya refujees, and some post 84 and now. These include pro moderate, some backward, inbetween, pakhai panjabi but mostly progressive. Now if it was a case of women being treated bad that would mean this problem would affect a/ or few similar certain segments of our community as we have entered the uk in different times with prevailing conditions. Strangely its affected every single group. Take for example the ex patriot kenyan sikh diaspora in the uk. They are percieved to be modern, equal in dealing with their women or thats how they make out. Now how comes they have the same problem we do? why would their girls do the same when they have equality? This means that theres gotto be more than one reason.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

.... · 06 Oct 2004

does shere punjab exist in uk today? if so how can we contact them?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 06 Oct 2004

the same problem extends to white english females, hindu punjabi females, hindu gujrati females, etc, dating muslim males then convert or dumped as used wet tissues. Are white males and hindus treating their women any less than sikhs are? so why is it happening to them too? surely hindu gujratis (also ex kenyan and ugandan refujis) are famed for giving their women above equal status. one of the amritdhari married women who eloped with a muslim, her husband never married again and bought up his 4 children alone, if he was a womaniser or didnt value female equality im sure he would have remarried, yet her youngest sister did the same thing. This singhs children are now fully grown he has 2 daughters who do seva in panthic circles. The amritdhari female from london who run up north to live with her muslim bf used to organise and run a sikhi workshop in college, i knew her mum and dad and i can honestly say they loved their children to bits, they only had 2 daughters so wheres the inequality here? The bnp ( white supremacist group) are taking advantage of this situation and stirring communal trouble between muslims and whites over white females dating muslims. The sikhi tohr is not to blame muslims as i myself a male have been approached by muslim women of different nationalities hence if i can reject them why cant these streams of sikh women? if its equality they want then surely they can elope with any community why specifically muslims?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 06 Oct 2004

and if it were a case of inequality then you would expect sikh females in canada also to elope with different communities on a big scale thats equivelent in the uk with muslim if sikhs are so backward. but is it as bad as here? if we were to study the largest scale of inequality then im sure we would arrive at the conclusion of honour living amongst pakistani and bangladeshi communities in the uk. Hence the largest potential revolutionary reaction against gender inequality would be from muslimah females within muslim community itself. So why arent muslimah girls en masse either reverting from islam or dumping their families for a sikh ranjha? considering muslim females have access to the same education sikh women do, and spend bout 7 8 hours a day as students in the same environments as sikh women. Cant they easily rebel too and change religions and run off with non muslims? surely then their community must either suffer from the same prob at the same level as us or worse. but do they? and why would sikh females go into the lions den? ( already suffering from inequality and now walking into the worst kind that ever exists)? a sikh woman expects to find equality in an islamic community of pakistanis famed for honour living? a sikh female is all game to wear a hijaab as a sign of searching for equality? im not sure about that? to the person who asks if sp exists. Right now everythings dead. If the muslim gangs start attacking sikhs, sikhs will gather up whether sp exist or not, yesterday the whites oppressed it was holy smokes then the paks came it was sp. people come n go names individuals change but oppression always leads to a cause according to the time and condition.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

................... · 07 Oct 2004

im sorry if i have offended the good name of sikh women. In fact if the canadian/american diaspora had some exposure to what goes on here, or even talked to some practicing sikh females living here in the uk they would blatently tell you how these "clubber type girls"/ or " shopping in town on the hunt for a boyfriend kurris " treat their heritage the asli rehetvan sikh women know what happens in front of their face. I find it hard to digest what possible reasons there are for an obvious pattern of reverting out of a faith that stands so glorious with karbania laid down fresh in recent decades in front of our faces on the streets of britain. Our ( sikh ) families used to be physically attacked, verbally abused, in the 70s 80s by white supremacists, on the streets of southall birmingham. Some formed vigalante groups like holy smokes and fought everyday on different streets of southall, one singh had his eye taken out, and replaced with a glass one, stab wounds to a point where he can no longer work, another singh lost the use of his hand, countless more but the efforts led to an environment where a sikh could finally walk down the street without getting attacked. Someone somewhere has given up something so we could be free here. The 80s saw muslim gangs used to kidnap sikh schoolgirls in vans, take photos of them naked, threaten or comply then drug them up in handsworth thats what led to vulanteer group sp. years inside jails, left everything behind to fight against this. Sikh girls who use islamic conversions as an excuse of " inequality at home " how could they forget their own sikh sisters were kidnapped and raped from the streets of birmingham just 18 years ago by these muslim gangs? Our uncles brothers fought for members of every communitee to walk free, do we cherish that to a point where we take a musalmaans hand all over again? i could never understand why or how these girls throw away everything our gurus, shaheeds, singhs, and now our own relatives fought for us. If you dont value your own people fgighting for you at least remember what your gurus fought for.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

.:( · 08 Oct 2004

if sikh kuria were being unfairly treated at home 1) would they have the equal chances as singhs to higher and intermediate education? 2) would they be allowed to follow their dreams and pursue top career positions? 3) would they be allowed to wear what they want? 4) would they be allowed out all hours of the night going to disco? 5) would they even be allowed out of their homes with friends of different ethnic origins? 6) would they be at the forefront organising sikh events? Sikhs from both genders in england can verify the symptons themselves. The problem lies in abusing the new found freedom and crossing all limits and giving into temptation when it arises. It hardly existed before, now families have modernised we are faced with a plague of conversions. Hardly no pakistani muslim would give up islam, their family values are far more outdated than ours which involve beating up women.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

:- · 09 Oct 2004

to raise the next generation of sikh women the right way we need power in our gurdwaras and put our panthic strategies into operation. We better start working together and kick the masands out of engaldn gurdwaras and become living ambassadors of sikhi to the external world too. How about implementing projects like a "khalsa town" where our kids wont have to face this forced intermixing with muslim youths. A few roads to start with exclusive sikh. Highlighting the dangers of islamic tactics is vital there are muslims with fake sikh ids approaching sikh girls on the net, theyve already launched their battle to wipe us out by trying to take our women from us. We can only offer help and guidance to our community who want it but the next generation will be all ears open wide to learn so when their older they know how to cope better. We do need to learn ghatka in every pind man woman and child. We need marriage guidance councillors in gurdwaras, womens right groups, stress councilling, drug rehab and complete equality within gurdwaras why not make a woman a pardhan of a gurdwara? If sikhs become sikhs we represent it on a scale where others will look at us and respect it and not shun sikhi. there are way too many sikhs in england to be wiped out we need reorganising. We cannot afford to let the days pass by and say let bhagti do it, people have been doing bhagti from day one, that dont mean we let issues build up. We have to become political too as well as do our bhagti in order to seek power that will be instrumental in looking after our future generations. we do need a support panel that can help sikh girls in trouble maybe a 24 hours helpline where we can all contribute in shifts. If possible in future secure a council grant for womens centre like starting with a safehouse where abused women can take shelter and if they have any kids with them too if their totally abondoned by their own or by muslims. Yes talk is cheap without action, we need a team now how many sevedars can we get? a helpline project can be a ground start, does anyone know how much it will cost to set up a helpline? or who to approach?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Help · 09 Oct 2004

I need to speak to someone about a problem related to this topic, can someone please help me, please. My email is [address removed].

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Canadian Munda · 01 Nov 2004

If This was happening in canada...the pakistani gangs would get bashed up and wouldnt even dare do anything.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

ashamed of england · 01 Nov 2004

sad as it is, the young sikhs in england are wimpish wear body tops look like clean shaven women their only hobby is going to a club pull a girl have a glassy pull another girl enjoy life, then freak out when they find their sister is doing the same. Theres no anakh, no zest to keep their culture let alone sikhi. England youth within sikhi are good but majority outside dont give a toss about anything but enjoyment. england valey feel they are more english than desi, their ways are not desi, they lost their own traditions in just one generation. in canada you guys keep your anakh and traditions alive from one generation to the next.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

mnm · 02 Nov 2004

"Author: Canadian Munda Date: 11-01-04 12:33 If This was happening in canada...the pakistani gangs would get bashed up and wouldnt even dare do anything." Sikh girl go college muslim guy go college, both chit chat and then start liking each other. how can you stop that? the sikh girl feels attracted to him and his personality. its not about pakistani or indian gangs. An attractive male gives her attension, religion becomes no bar to her or him. Reasons are many, seeking romance/happiness, adventure, jwani, rebelling, looking for something. Sometimes even religious minded sikh girls end up in the hands of muslims because what their parents teach their kids is not put to practice, but they see it more when they look into muslims and think they have found a golden egg and get sick of sikhs infighting and culture, look for long term and get themselves ready to wear hijaab. One of my school class colleagues who used to have uncut kes, poli as anything, went gurdwara, and was very well cultured and dharm minded always kept her eyes on the ground is today sitting in another side of london with 3 muslim children and a hijaab that covers her face and head. Her younger sister has run off with a hindu and had a half caste baby, both keep in touch with each other but never see their brothers and parents. Their mother became diagnosed with depression. Its not only muslims, but this thing called attraction and its ruining families well before kids are mature enough to settle down, but the mistakes they make cannot be rectified easily. Beating up a pakistani gang doesnt stop attraction between different genders of different religions. Today there is an influx of east europeans and african migrants who are fast taking over, pakistanis dont have the upper hand in anything anymore. its just a matter of time before sikh girls end up in new situations unless we sit down and talk about this. Sikh women and girls of the uk need to give their input and not remain silent. The ratios of sikh women in punjab has gone down , it might just be a matter of time before that starts happening here in 10 years from now.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

mnm · 02 Nov 2004

about the two sisters, i know their brothers personally from school till now and their parents who worked hard to provide for the family, they were not in any way indifferent towards the daughters it was in both cases a sign of attraction and sangat that led things the way it did.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

.... · 02 Nov 2004

This is another sad event connected to this thread. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/3974179.stm

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

mnm · 02 Nov 2004

places where pakistanis used to harrass sikhs are now dominated by a new influx of tamil gangs who harras pakistanis, its no longer sikh v pakistani much. the new african natives are going to university to get educated. East europeans r in many fields, who arent ugly men and pull women of all nationalities including sikh. Most of the new wave of immigrants are single and youthful who have left family behind in their native lands. When i look at the sikh punjabi community declining i am filled with sorrow. We dont tend to answer problems straight on. We let things just happen, then start blaming each other when we are led by fate. there is no active collective aims to help our people bloom and develop. Due to that, in my estimation if we leave scenarios like this it may be too late to change in 10 years. Then once the imbalance sets in , time also changes people. there isnt much left of a sikh community. Most already either adress themself as a jatt or terkhan, the gurdwaras are empty exept for park avenue and soho rd. the new religion seems to be money and power. Sikhs think they can escape multicultarism by getting rich moving to a posh area live their lives in seclusion. But your kids still get educated in the same places, you still do shopping in the same places,theres no gaurantee kids wont date peeps of different religions. The mixed marriages that already have happened with sikh males and muslim or white females tends to change the identity and culture of the family and offspring being more english than punjabi. Its not canada here,there is no punjabi pride. Because of this if in time to come sikh women decline , sikh males already influenced by multirace society with most of their identity gone then marry women of different races will totally dilute their future. the future of sikh community will then dwindle there will be barely pockets left of a few amritdharis and that too the very few who stay strong in this society grip its going to get harder,just look at each year passing by how sikhs get affected more and more. everybody knows how the face of southall is changing everyday, sre getting richer moving out to scattered locations , new people move in, same in handsworth. The little punjabs will cease to exist and replaced by new immigrants. Sikhs have to get off their backsides and get their women and daughters to talk about issues affecting them and the future now before its too late. I very much doubt sikh males will think in ten years " we treated sikh women wrong" their answer will be one of convenience find any other woman. the biggest loosers will be our kids in ten years from now. If we approach this properly with women and try to solve it at least we try than let things slip. in canada you have density of sikhs in two or 3 main large parts that keeps your identity alive in society , in uk there were many small settlements that quickly get overtaken by new people.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Ek_Aor_Sikh · 02 Nov 2004

>> Author: Canadian Munda : If This was happening in canada...the pakistani gangs would get bashed up and wouldnt even dare do anything." Possible that you may go beat up the Pakistani if exactly the same situation happened. But from what I saw recently in Canada is even worse. The Sikh girls marrying whites and Gujrati boys with the blessing of their parents. It may not be happening in your neighbourhood but definitely happening in Canada. If you think it is not happening yet you wait an other few years. The difference is that you guys have still got extended family structures due to newly arriving folks. This tends to keep a check on things. Guys blaming each others and putting others down is not going to stop this. We need collective and forward thiknig on this.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

bs_singh · 02 Nov 2004

mnm I have seen these Tamil gangs. They are ruff fighters and have seem them give these sulleh gangs a good beating plenty of times. One of them bit off the one of the pakistani guys eyebrow! They are crazy. B.S Singh

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

learning · 03 Nov 2004

this thing about sikh girls is really out of hand. I just found out something thats stabbing the pits of my heart. years ago i knew a brother and sister, half the family went abroad, half remained, all amritdhari and keski. I being in my strict mode distanced totally from most people and wanted to progress spiritually on my own. The sister of my friend, was very lonely and missed her family, she tried to contact me on numerous occasions for support and help she was only 16 then. At times when i was down previously she told me to be a brave sikh and face everything in life. When you say that to yourself it doesnt mean as much when your khalsa family members say that it means a lot in many ways. We lost contact for ages then she tried to contact me through her friend, and seemed very distant from her family, i think just needed support advice maybe a friend to chat to , but i had too many other commitments. then when i sent email when i was free there was no response. I have just found out that 16 year old kid i have failed. She has converted to islam, disowned by her family and living with her pakistani husband with a child. Even the husbands family disowned him three live out. If i had been there to help our sister she might not have ended up that way. This is one hell of a crazy world we are in. I cant get over this, i remember her in a dastar, i remember when she took amrit, how could i forget that i was supposed to support and listen to our sisters? give them the strentgh that we are one? Please, for the sake of the panth we have to not just unite, but really help each other, pull through, make stronger sikhs of ourselves and stand strong with every other member of the khalsa family and all sikh sisters whether amritdhari or not. Dont turn your back as i have, the guilt will take you over. Put petty politics, squabbles, aside otherwise we are gonna die out. A lot of things in this world seem fake as it is.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

learning · 03 Nov 2004

this thing about sikh girls is really out of hand. I just found out something thats stabbing the pits of my heart. years ago i knew a brother and sister, half the family went abroad, half remained, all amritdhari and keski. I being in my strict mode distanced totally from most people and wanted to progress spiritually on my own. The sister of my friend, was very lonely and missed her family, she tried to contact me on numerous occasions for support and help she was only 16 then. At times when i was down previously she told me to be a brave sikh and face everything in life. When you say that to yourself it doesnt mean as much when your khalsa family members say that it means a lot in many ways. We lost contact for ages then she tried to contact me through her friend, and seemed very distant from her family, i think just needed support advice maybe a friend to chat to , but i had too many other commitments. then when i sent email when i was free there was no response. I have just found out that 16 year old kid i have failed. She has converted to islam, disowned by her family and living with her pakistani husband with a child. Even the husbands family disowned him three live out. If i had been there to help our sister she might not have ended up that way. This is one hell of a crazy world we are in. I cant get over this, i remember her in a dastar, i remember when she took amrit, how could i forget that i was supposed to support and listen to our sisters? give them the strentgh that we are one? Please, for the sake of the panth we have to not just unite, but really help each other, pull through, make stronger sikhs of ourselves and stand strong with every other member of the khalsa family and all sikh sisters whether amritdhari or not. Dont turn your back as i have, the guilt will take you over. Put petty politics, squabbles, aside otherwise we are gonna die out. A lot of things in this world seem fake as it is.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

singhni · 03 Nov 2004

its really really sad that this happens and so hard to take in. from my own experiences, i've seen at college that punjabi 'sikh' girls are startin to become really really tarty. they're not all like that but the most outgoing, pretty and sociable girls are obsessed with bhangra etc and some of the girls i knew would openly admit that pakistani guys were better looking ! there is a new thing now about seeing black guys and thats probably going to escalate soon. to be honest, i fully blame the parents. its mainly the mona parents. the majority (that i know of of) dont know ANYTHING about sikhi, only family honour and money. and honour only applies to women from personal experiences, i have aunts with kids by different fathers who are completely disowned but any uncles are fully accepted and the whole 'scandal' hushed up and they see thier kids on weekends etc. then if the girls make a mistake, they're upset and the whole family suffers etc etc whereas the guys go clubbing with thier parents full consent. Obviously, this isnt always the case but these parents dont know what they are doing. this is the generation that have abandoned sikhi and if anything, its thier children that are teachiing sikhi to them, again ive seen this in a few families too. the children convert and then the parents convert many years later when they finally start to understand sikhi. a lot of these girls are jus sick of being treated as second class citizens, eg ladoo on the birh of a boy and tears on the birth of a girl. Muslim guys can make very very convincing arguements for muslim being 'woman friendly' i had a guy trying to convert me in college. i listend to his arguements but it did nothing for me ! im perfectly happy with my sikhi, purely cos i understand. anything he could say or ask me, i knew the answer or if i didnt, i knew where to find out. most girls dont have these resources and cant ask anyone. these guys can answer these questions, make them feel special and draw the girls in. I imagine that punjabi 'sikh' guys use the same methods

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

learning · 03 Nov 2004

the girl is now 22 years old with her kes cut upto her shoulders and dons hijaab at times. Some of you know who i am talking about but singho singhnia dont be silent because of sharm on the quam. Dont be taken in by false pride or ego that we are any better or higher no. How hard is it for me and those of you who knew her as a pank kakari singhni and think of her current condition to a hijaban with no more connection to sikhi? we cannot come out with emotional outbursts like " sikhi isnt for everyone" or " shes given into maya" "shes not one of us anymore". Youve all got sisters, there have to be answers to this , i want our sisters to speak if they dont more and more will dissapear and we as sikhs have failed on very important issue.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

learning · 03 Nov 2004

singhani thank you for your response i appreciate where your coming from as a sikh woman. and its very true the way women are treated its sick scandelous and outright inhumane. Wats so special in a boy? girls are condemned from the start. It really burns my heart to think what the future holds, i hope more and more sikh kids learn about themselves and spread sikhi. I despise this punjabi culture, but also feel we need the strentgh of this quam ( sikh women) to speak about issues so that the rest of us may take note and try to look for ways to overcome a large vacuam that is looming ahead of us. To all sikh females please speak freely its your birthright as equals to talk about what affects you so that we can make this quam strong.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 04 Nov 2004

if this bibi has converted to islam then what is done is done, but she is still a bibi and sister! just like the sikhs in the past treated every woman other than their wife as their sister or mother! look at all the sangat who are gurmat minded they are all involved in some shape or forum in a sub-culture some believe in doing things one way some believe in a sant etc etc. and everyone thinks there way is the right way! going to the gurdwara is a ritual, the management commitees have made it impossible for gursikhi to flourish and grow due to the manmat ideas and policies in place and these policies and manmat ideas and actions have an effect on sangat which replicate themselves in the home, which has devastating effects in families. dasvandh from the gurdwara is spent paying of loans and no money is being ploughed into the community for education or regeneration of any sort. is it any wonder the panth is in the pits!

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

learning · 04 Nov 2004

sikh ji what do we do from here please? the committees will always be in the hands of robbers as long as their rishte are their to support them in election, but are there other things we can do? the singhnis last words i remember were in an email " i miss my brother and father so much , i dont know what to do please help me, im very confused, i have no other friends to talk to your the only one i can talk to". This has been echoing inside my head all day and night. I wasnt there to help her and when i replied it was too late. This is really depressing me i failed one of our sisters and now shes gone forever into another quam.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 04 Nov 2004

learning ji look you me everyone we are just human and prone to making faults etc. just do ardas to guru ji to help you through what you are going through the bibi who has now gone into another quam, its not the end of her life she is still on the path towards meeting waheguru, tell her to keep that goal in her mind and be a good muslim the only real advice i can offer is to do ardas to the only person who can make things better and change things guru ji and waheguru my answer to the problem is sangat guru minded sangat takes back the guru ghars and run them according to the principles of sarbat khalsa and gurmat we are such a rich community that we can do anything but we need to wake up and take a stand but sadly nobody seems to tackle the internal forces which are slowly but surely killing us our own people, no external force has ever been able to harm the panth all the harm that we have and are suffering from is internal from sikhs! its a sad fact but it is true. i wish i could help more but i am limited in what i can do i'm only a measly human, but i will do ardas to guru ji to help you and the bibi if you want to talk more we can exchange emails?

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

UK Singh · 06 Nov 2004

Sikh How exactly is this girl who to converted to Islam still on the path to Waheguru? If anything she has left that path and trying to rationalise her decision in an attempt to comfort her is not a very good idea. She as well as others have made their decisions, no doubt we will read more stories about these types of girls ending up in brothels, but leave them to their fate. They made the decisions and now they have to live with the consequences. Telling her to be a 'good Muslim' is the height of naivette. If someone could not be a good Sikh it is highly unlikely they will ever be a good Muslim. I don't know anything about her personally but from some girls that I have met I can say that the decision she took has had a negative impact on her parents, hers brothers and sisters as well as her friends. It is manmat that makes people give up their own families in order to gain a few accolades from Muslims who see this step as another nail in Sikhi's coffin. Such people are not concerned with who they hurt and think that their future life will be happy. From the few girls I have met all are unhappy! Once the 'celebrity status' of a convert wears off and the so-called 'sisters' and 'brothers' move onto the next unfortunate victim these girls then realise what they left behind and start to regret their decisions. When they start to get on which living their lives as a Muslim girl and having to fast for a month and then donning a tent because it 'protects' them then they realise their mistakes. But by then it's too late and they have probably married with a kids. Most of these marriages end in divorce. The three girls I know about are all divorced. These girls, the ones who think they are in love and their Muslim boyfriends will love them forever and soon disillusioned. There's a thing called Karma, if you break the hearts of your parents, bring disgrace on your family and throw back the love of your friends to convert to Islam then Karma has a way of hitting back at you. Learning Paji, help the ones that ask for help. There are tens of thousands of Singhs and Singhnias in the next generation who need our help to show them what Sikhi really is. It is they that we should be focussed on. It is useless to dwell on those who gave into manmat.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

umm · 06 Nov 2004

I nearly converted, but something happened, even though Im not quite there...Guru Ji showed me the way, just nudged me along.. The problem is..and I speak from experience, Sikh guys dont know how to treat their women at all..

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 07 Nov 2004

uk singh please tell me what path she is on? being a muslim, hindu or christian etc. all paths lead to waheguru or are you one of those 'sikhs' which thinks only sikhs go to waheguru? shall we tell her that now she is a muslim and no longer a sikh we dont care at all and as far as we sikhs are concerend she might as well become a prostitue? and so what if she wasn't a good sikh? maybe she wasn't meant to be? who knows what waheguru has planned for her? but i would rather her still remember waheguru than not and give up everything she has. your words smack of racist stereotyped views. i wonder what advice guru ji would give her now, but ever advice it was i'm sure they would not talk her down. this bibi has gone through a very bad time she has left guru jis path (making a massive mistake) and gone somewhere else (who knows what torments she is suffering in her mind), she don't need anybody slagging her of she needs support, i would rather her be a good muslim now than be nothing at all and just roam this world lost until she died. no matter what anybody has done i think the highest quality in any human being is compassion and an appreciation of others pain and their predicament. our guru sahibs glowed with these qualities and thats why so many flocked to their house! and they forgive us for our mistakes everyday! if they didn't we wouldn't get anywhere. things like this do destroy families and the decisions these girls and boys take have very far reaching effects but what is the point to criticise? let us try and help. let us try and stop this before it happens in the first place. but alas we hindered by our own elitist views and opinions. listen i'm sorry if i came over harshly. i just get very upset by people constantly having a dig at those who are in less fortunate positions than ourselves. let us see beyond the mistakes like guru ji does and see the good qualities that can be worked on and which will aid those people to make their lives better.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

UK Singh · 08 Nov 2004

Sikh >>are you one of those 'sikhs' which thinks only sikhs go to waheguru?<< I must bow towards you since you appear to be able to decide who is and who isn't a Sikh. Henceforthe I need not look at the Sikh Rehat Maryada and shall contact you. You asked what Guruji's reaction is to someone who has made the conscious decision to leave the Guru. In Gurbani the words Bemukh is used, those who turn their faces away from the Guru. saakat nar satgur nahee kee-aa tay baymukh har bharmaavaigo. ( SGGS Ang 1311 ) The faithless cynic does not submit to the True Guru; the Lord makes the non-believer wander in confusion. jan kaa raakhaa aap su-aamee baymukh ka-o aa-ay pahoochee meech ( SGGS Ang 1224 ) Our Lord and Master is the Saving Grace, the Protector of His humble servants; those who have turned their backs on the Guru are overtaken by death. I'm not sure what your defination for a Bemukh is but i'm pretty sure that someone who left their Guru to join Islam and thereby destroyed their families is a Bemukh. Maybe you could care to enlighten us what your defination is? If you would care to re-read my post I have never said that we should not help those who seek our help. But going around saying we should be telling those Bemukhs that they should be good Muslims shows just how politically correct some Sikhs have become. Do you know the situation in the UK? Do you know that those whose convert putting their families through hell are then used to lure other Sikhs into the same path? Anyone who has left Sikhi and realised their mistakes and wish to return deserve the full help and support of Sikhs, but those who have left and then are used in an attempt to lure other Sikhs do not deserve Sikhs wishing them well and urging them to be good Muslims. If you wish I can send you a list of the few former Sikhs I know who are now being used to lure other Sikhs into Islam. You might wish to send them your regards and tell them how happy you are that they are now good Muslims! Could I ask what you reaction of a young Sikh contemplating converting would be if after all you attempts to show them what a great faith they are abandoning, if they answer each of your points by saying ' Yes, but surely by being a Muslim I will still be on the path to Waheguru'

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

sikh · 08 Nov 2004

uk singh listen you carry on doing what you do and guru kirpa on your efforts i'm not going to carry this on any further as you have your views and i have mine no need to send me any lists i am fully aware of what is happening and going on i'm not politically correct nor do i subscribe to that view point nor was i saying that we become a support network for anybody who has left guru jis path but i also dont want to turn my back on anybody if they ask for my help, but within reason, but i'm not going to shout them down or spit on them

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Zayed · 12 Nov 2004

I was really sad after reading the story of the girl who went through hell in pakistan. It bothers me everytime I think about it... It's disturbing that things like that even happen today. I'm a muslim, an Indian muslim and who's married to a sikh girl who I love and respect alot.. she is still a practicing sikh and I a practicing muslim.. We've recieved alota bad treatment from ppl of my and her religion, but we made it somehow and now live a happy life.. Some of the people reading this would wonder why's a muslim guy on this site and why is he going on about his "bollywood type" love story.. Well it's just that being married to a sikh girl I have tried learning her religion for which I have alota respect for... I just came across this site while searching for something regarding sikhism. I'm not really concerned about her understanding my religion or not, nor have I ever tried converting her although I'm a true muslim.. Islam doesn't permit people being forced to convert.. It's just some pakistani's and now I understand bengali's too who're just doing as they wish. It's obvious that they're just using religion to fight their personal war... and god knows why they do it.. I mean after all it's just a bunch of drunk guys fighting at clubs and using religion as an excuse.. I don't really know the situation in the UK but over here in Canada things are pretty much similar to what I've read in posts above. Alot of my wifes family members are really hostile towards me and so are mine towards my wife.. This is pretty much crazy... I mean why hate someone just because they were born off another religion?? I just wanna let you all know that people from different religious beliefs can live together.. we're expecting our first kid in a few months and we've decided we're gonna make it choose it's religion and not put any pressure as to what religion our kids should follow. I'm really ashamed for what some muslims have done and I apologise on behalf of all muslims for these crimes commited against sikhs. Please do realise that these people aren't true muslims and are just Pakistani's,Bengali's or other stereotypes fighting their own war... I was pleased that the amount of rasict comments on this post were far fewer than those you find in other site.. Think about it, this world would be a far better place if people learned to co-exist

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Luckvear · 13 Nov 2004

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji KI Fateh! I am happy you are able to come forward and tell you story. I hope this raises the awareness of today's reality in the UK! I am supprised that the members in the Gurdwara was not of supportive. Again, this is something as a community we need to develop in order to offer help, support and provide trust to those such as you in the time of need. From you experience, i hope sikhs girls which are in a difficult situation can take something positive from this. Regards.

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Bijla Singh · 14 Nov 2004

Sikhs are supposed to marry Sikhs only. a couple should follow only one way of life otherwise there is no balance. Gursikhs like Bijjay Singh in 18th century wouldn't even dream of marrying a muslim woman. wife of Mir Mannu offered herself at the feet of this Gursikh and throne of Lahore, but Gursikh turned it all away. rehatnamas clearly state that a Sikh must marry a Sikh and children must be raised in Gursikhi lifestyle. Marriage in Sikhi is encouraged and this is not out of hatred toward other religions. a Sikh teaching her kid about Guru Nanak Dev Ji and her husband teaching the same kid that Mohammad is the "last" prophet and all other all false. I wonder how that kid will handle all this confusion having his/her parents contradicting each other and going against each other's religion. Zayed, provide quotes from Quran showing that Islam doesn't permit forcing religion onto others and marrying a non-muslim is accepted in Islam. Should I believe you or my history of 18th century? Thousands of Sikhs were killed everyday because they refused to convert to Islam. Story of "Shaheeds of 1947 in Rawalpindi" was posted on this site a while ago and many Sikhs were killed because they refused to convert. You do not represent your muslim community so why should those victim girls accept your apology since those criminals are still not punished. it is not that easy. looking forward to your response. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Manas Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bijla Singh Zayed is not following his own religion. The Koran allows Muslims to marry Christian and Jewish wowen who do not need to convert to Islam but the children have to be brought up as Muslims. Women of other religions have to convert. I don't know whether his story is true but given that lying is permitted in Islam in order to advance their cause I take would take his post with a pinch of salt GurFateh Manas Singh

Re: Sikh Women in Pak Brothels??

Bijla Singh · 15 Nov 2004

Yeah you may be right but correct me if I am wrong. I do not think Muslim women are allowed to marry non-muslim men. Only muslim men can marry non-muslim women and children to be raised in Islam. right? A true Sikh man/woman would never marry a non-sikh. period. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh