Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ban the Patka!

Ban the Patka!

news · 27 Sep 2004

I support Prof. Badungar's stand 100%. A patka is not a dastaar and is not acceptable for Sikhs. A Patka is a new invention that looks really really weird and takes all the dignity away from the Sikh appearance. People who see a dastaar can understand its signifcance and it doesn't look all that weird. A patka looks like some kind of growth on the head that is being treated. Like a mushroom sprouting or something. Once when I was younger and went to a convenience store with my mother, the Korean owner looked at me and then addressed my mother with a frown, "Oh....head injury?" I couldn't blame her for thinking that. PM's claim on turban row an eyewash, says Badungar Tribune Correspondent http://www.tribuneindia.com/2004/20040927/punjab1.htm#9 Phagwara, September 26 Former SGPC president and a co-opted SGPC member Prof Kirpal Singh Badungar Prof today said that nine minister PM Dr Manmohan Singh's claim that the turban now in France was resolved was an eye wash. He made this claims in New York yesterday. Prof Badungar said that the French Government had allowed Sikh students to wear a particular type of headgear in place of turban. He said he had verified today from France and Germany about it and was told by Sikhs there that the issue stood still unresolved, he claimed. Talking to mediapersons here this afternoon, Prof Badungar asserted that the so-called discreet patqa, as the French authorities call it, can not be a substitute for turban. Turban was an integral part of the religious symbol, dress code and maryada of Sikhs, he asserted. The Gurus had ordained Sikhs to be "sabat soorat dastar sira" (to have unshorn hair and turbans on heads), he continued. The patqa was not acceptable, as it violated the Sikh ethos and maryada, he asserted.

Re: Ban the Patka!

A Singh · 27 Sep 2004

Wholly agree, the Patka is a recent adaption of a small keski (i.e. that used under one's turban), it most certainly is not acceptable as a replacement of a Dastaar. One thing that really makes me laugh are those men with full beards and such like wearing a Patka!!! It's one thing wearing it during sport or swimming and such activities (or under one's dastaar), but for daily outdoor wear it is frankly insulting to our Maryada and dignity, as indicated above. A Singh.

Re: Ban the Patka!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 27 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. The jathedar Akal takhat should have taken out a Hukmnama banning the Patka long ago. Lets petition the Akal Takhat to do this immediately before more harm is done to Sikhi. The patka wearers look utterly stupid and ridiculous.....it is just an attempt to blend in with the crowd as many other races also wear such bandanas on their heads..especailly the rowdy unruly types such as the motocycle gangs and gang leaders...so what does this make for sikhi respect - NONE. A small child may be excused for wearing a patka or cover on his small joora...BUT grown up men in SUITS and Ties, flowing beards...etc wearing patkas look weird. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: Ban the Patka!

A Singh · 27 Sep 2004

Jarnail Singh Bhaji, What's even funnier is those grown men, who find all the time and trouble to tie their long beards up, yet cannot get around to tying a Dastaar on top of their Patkas!!! (p.s. this is not intended to bring a discussion on tying beards, simply a observation).

Re: Ban the Patka!

1 · 27 Sep 2004

i agree with the above argument. I know it is mainly the society's fault at large, but if someone wants to see how much the indian government and other influences have tampered with the izzat of sikhi is through the patka for the guys and the lack of dastaar for the girls. In India, is it not an old kahaavat that if you have shamed someone badly to say "Ohdee pug laatee" or "ohdee pug te daag lag giyaa". Now, you can put two and two together and see what the above situation implies, where these kahaavats have happened LITERALLY.

Re: Ban the Patka!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 27 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The desire to "blend" in has not only stopped at patka PROMOTION by the "society"... Look at How the NEELA BANA of the Panj Piyaras has universally DISAPPEARED all over the World....the SAFFRON ( also used by BJP Brigade hindutva brigades) has Taken over 100%..... I used to see Neela Bana long long time ago...in Nishan sahibs, panj piayaras...BUT not NOW...a blue qamarkasa now and then but thats it... These are all small signs of how Hindutva etc is taking its toll ( some may argue it is not that way...but i bleeive it is..) Jarnail singh

Re: Ban the Patka!

gkd · 27 Sep 2004

no doubt grown men look stoopid, but can u really expect kids of teh age 5 going to kindergarden wearing a damala/pug?

Re: Ban the Patka!

A Singh · 28 Sep 2004

Jarnail Singh Bhaji, The 'Neela' Bana has indeed disappeared, ironically, it is the more zealous of Sikhs who seem to try and promote the 'Saffron' Kesri colour as the authentic Sikh Colour over and above the Blue. It is quite amusing, I recall an incidence in the UK once between a group of Khalistani Singhs arguing with a Hindu Punjabi trying to convey the argument that the "Saffron" of the Sikhs is different to the "Saffron" of the Hindus!!! It's a 'different shade'!!! How ridiculous! There they were adorned in their large "Kesri" Dastaars and flowing beards and arguing over traditions that they themselves clearly have lack of understanding about. I do hope we see a return to the authentic Sikh traditions and culture going forward...be it in music (Raag Kirtan and no more Pakandi nonsense), art (no more white washing of Historical Gurdwara Frescos), Santiya, Bana, Diet, Poetry, Martial Arts and so on...

Re: Ban the Patka!

:-o · 28 Sep 2004

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani Bro, Don't you think something should be done about it then? Its easy to say 'hindutva' this and that whilst posting online; but the fact of the matter is, Panj Piyaras will still be dressed in saffron unless something is done about it... No offence intended towards anyone, but what exactly is being done about these so-called 'anti-Sikhi' going's on?? (In this I am also referring to Hazoor Sahib being run by GOI and other comments made by various members...) [%sig%]

Re: Ban the Patka!

hm · 28 Sep 2004

ban the samosa pagh and white blue sgpcfied pijamis too and wear proper bana chola with gol blue dumalas.

Re: Ban the Patka!

1 · 28 Sep 2004

>no doubt grown men look stoopid, but can u really expect kids of teh age 5 going to kindergarden wearing a damala/pug?< What do you think they did when there was no patka? And yes, I have seen kids that are much younger than that go to school with dastaar on.

Re: Ban the Patka!

gkd · 28 Sep 2004

okie tha's coo no. 1...... somosa pug??? u mean patiala shahi? ban a pug??? wuts wrong iwth u?

Re: Ban the Patka!

. · 28 May 2006

ok could gyals get away with wearing pagh as they have just started to cover their head?

Re: Ban the Patka!

help · 28 May 2006

gkd kids shudnt wear patka either wear a keski much better

Re: Ban the Patka!

PTE SINGH · 30 May 2006

Agreed that grown men in every day situations should not wear a patka, however their are many situations where it is not possible to wear a dastaar and a Patka is the best option.

Re: Ban the Patka!

wa!!!!!!!!!!! · 30 May 2006

pte singh no ur quite rong patka is neva the best option if guru ji says wear keski, we wear a keski, there is no situation which wud require us to go against guru jis hukam

Re: Ban the Patka!

not so sure · 30 May 2006

Sangat ji i wear a patka, then tie my pug on top. What is your view on that. Secondly i wear a patka when playing hockey. I dont want to do my pug beisty if it ends up on the floor.

Re: Ban the Patka!

PTE SINGH · 31 May 2006

WA!!!!!! I would be happy to hear sugestions on what i could practically wear when swiming, during contact sports and under my combat helmet when on army manouvers.

Re: Ban the Patka!

Singh · 31 May 2006

wats the difference between a dastaar and a patka, isnt a pakta basically a dastaar just with one lar

Re: Ban the Patka!

DDT · 31 May 2006

i wear a patka sometimes when for w/e reason i cant tie a dastaar. Ive hurt my hands and my wrist before and it helps to be able tot tie a patka sometimes because i cant tie a dastaar

Re: Ban the Patka!

Sanjo · 01 Jun 2006

so kesri aint a sikh colour? what about the infamous orange dastars that aprently symbolise shaheedi where has that tradition come from. many great gursikhs hve worn kesri dastars or was the above just concerned with baneh

Re: Ban the Patka!

Singh · 01 Jun 2006

this is ridicoulous, if we should ban the patka because its a "newer" invention, then we should ban the tuti pag (triangler one) becase this wasnt aroudn during our gurus times, the british invented this because they said it looks more professional

Re: Ban the Patka!

... · 01 Jun 2006

but what about little kids, like around 3 and 5 . Wouldnt it be hard and look odd for them to wear a dastaar?

Re: Ban the Patka!

... · 01 Jun 2006

i forgot to add, i saw some guys at a recent samagam. You know how a dastar is usually round..well not ROUND...but you know, and you tie your hair on top........well these guys had there turban kinda of towards the back of there head.like it semed convienent but it was different.. im sure most of yall seen this before. The dastaar kinda of extended to the back of the head. Has anybody else even seen it?

Re: Ban the Patka!

Oz Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Author: hm "ban the samosa pagh and white blue sgpcfied pijamis too and wear proper bana chola with gol blue dumalas." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ahh this 'somasa pagh' was worn by many great sikhs, such as bhai randhir singh.... so next time u might wanna think twice before u insult those sikhs who have tied it on their heads with love for Guru Sahib.

Re: Ban the Patka!

no1 · 02 Jun 2006

some people cant wear a dastaar like me hopefully one day with guru jis kirpa i will, but at the moment im not allowed (family probs) n i dont know how to. as soon as i learn i will start tying one. i wear a patka so that i can respectfully do simran, or paath etc wherever n whenever i want. as long as u intend to replace the patka with a dastaar its all good.

Re: Ban the Patka!

Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Oz singh, by saying ban the patka, its no difference then saying ban the samsoa pug, just because gursikhs like bhai sahib randeer singh wore won, doesnt make it any better than a patka, non were worn in guru jis time

Re: Ban the Patka!

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee is not the only one who used to wear that kind of dastaar. Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwalay and Sant Ishar Singh Rarewalay used to wear this dastaar. And the dastaar that these Gurmukhs used to wear is not the "Samosa" pagg but the Gurmukhi Dastaara. Samosa Pagg is that where the pagg is sewn in the middle to make it wider and where the nok is made in the middle of the forehead. This pagg is also called Patialashaahi pagg. Gurmukhi dastara is different. First of of all it's not sewn in the middle. Secondly, there is no nok on the forehead and thirdly there is no laR in the back. When wearing this Dastaar, the first laR is not put in mouth. So in short, Samosa pagg is different from the Gurmukhi Dastara that Bhai Sahib and other great gurmukhs used to wear. Kulbir Singh

Re: Ban the Patka!

Dastarwala · 02 Jun 2006

Bhai Randhir Singh did not wear a Samosa Pag. From what I know, the Samosa Pag is the kind of Pag the east African Sikhs wear which is also popular amongst the UK Sikh youth. They call it Samosa Pag because to some people it resembles a Samosa. Bhai Randhir Singh Jee wore a Gurmukhi Dastara as Kulbir Singh Jee mentioned, a Gurmukhi Dastara does not have a Nokh on the forhead nor does it have a laRh in the back of the Pag. Furthermore, each LaRh is tied Chinkay as done during puraatan times not like modern times where people have begun folding each laRh several times just to make it look slick looking.

Re: Ban the Patka!

* · 03 Jun 2006

''so kesri aint a sikh colour? what about the infamous orange dastars that aprently symbolise shaheedi where has that tradition come from. many great gursikhs hve worn kesri dastars or was the above just concerned with baneh ''