Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Kulbir Singh · 22 Sep 2004

Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy Tripti Nath Tribune News Service New Delhi, September 22 Taking serious note of the resistance of the Sikh community to the ban on wearing ostentatious religious symbols in public primary and high schools in France, the French government has decided to allow Sikh boys enrolled in these schools to wear discreet ‘patka’. Ambassador of France to India dominique Girard told TNS here on Wednesday that the Ministry of National Education of France has proposed that the Sikh boys enrolled in these schools wear ‘discreet patka’ instead of turbans or study the same syllabus by correspondence. They can even choose to study in a private school. Mr Girard said the French government is willing to lend financial support to Sikh boys who are poor and cannot afford to study in a private school. “There are less than 200 Sikh boys in public schools in France,’’ he said. The ambassador however clarified that the proposals made by the French government are neither options nor relaxation in the law. “In France, the law is the law. These measures are aimed at ensuring easy and smooth implementation of the law. We are helping the Sikh boys abide by the law in the best possible circumstances. We want to ensure tolerance and secularism in our schools but also to ensure that they get education.’’ Mr Girard who has received numerous representations from the National Commission for Minorities, the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, World Punjabi Organisation, the Delhi Sikh Forum and Sikh Parliamentarians regarding the ban on turban told TNS, “I love the Sikhs because they are interesting people. I perfectly understand their anxieties but I think they were misled to believe that they would be targeted. It is important for the Sikhs to keep their hair long and bind them’’.

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

sikh · 22 Sep 2004

these stupid french people who the hell do they think they are? its ok for sikhs to die defending their country but they then strangle them with their racist policies just shows once again how the west view people from the indian sub continent, as dogs

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Guldeep Singh · 22 Sep 2004

This "discreet patka" business doesn't seem to be anything new. The French as we can recall also allowed Sikh boys to wear shower caps. I don't think we will like the French "discreet patka" when we actually find out what it means.

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Jagjitsingh · 23 Sep 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh pyare jio, everyone should help the United sikhs group in their campaign as much as possible. These french statements are just playing mind games with the issue. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 24 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. It has been said : we reap what we sow !!! and this is what the SIKHS are getting. 1. There is NO SUCH THING AS A PATKA in Sikhi/Gurmat. Patka and CHUNNI are both OUT as far as Sikhi is concerned. Can anyone "imagine" GURU JI Guru hargobind Ji / GURU GOBIND SINGH JI in a PATKA ?? SO having DEVIATED from TRUE SIKHI...by wearing patkas and downgrading the DASTAAR that GURU JI gave us as an HONOUR..... we now see the PATKA being downgraded to a small patch of "handkerchief" on a JOORA and FORCED down our throats by the French....soon others will follow suit. A PATKA is like a Bikini-G string combination which a 2 year old kid may reasonably wear BUT a MAJOR SHAME for a Grown UP to wear in public When the Patka began its journey some decades ago due to being popularised by the Cricket Players of India and then picked up by Bollywood Movies....not much furore was raised by any SIKH Organisation that this was Anti-Sikh... 2. What answer do we Sikhs have in case the French ask us : IF DASTAAR is so IMPORTANT to your RELIGION how do you explain that ONLY MALES wear it ?? Cant you all wear CHUNNIS ??? Dassra jarnail Singh

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Kulbir Singh · 24 Sep 2004

Excellent post Arshee jee. It is time that all Sikh bibiyaan adopted dastaar. Let us all first agree that all bibiyaan must wear dastaar and not quarrel over whether dastaar is a kakaar or not. The bottomline is that dastaar is a must. Whether you believe it to be kakaar or not is not important at this time. What is important is to have all bibiyaan wear dastaar. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Anon Singh · 24 Sep 2004

Bhai Jarnail Singh has made an extremely, EXTREMELY good point. Well done Bhai Sahib that is an excellent observation. We are essentially to blame - and perhaps we should stop blaming others and be more introspective.

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

1 · 25 Sep 2004

I agree with the above posts. How are we as a panth to achieve success when abut half of the members of the panth refuse to wear their crown and accept their role in the panth?

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 26 Sep 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. a personal story in connection with this. In malaysia some decades ago when the Sikhs protested to the Govt that they CANNOT wear Crash helmets when riding motorbikes..... the Malaysian Govt passed a LAW in Parliament that EXEMPTED MALE SIKHS from wearing Crash Helmets...BUT NOT SIKH FEMALES....becasue the SIKHS never asked for this. My late mother Gurcharan kaur Gyani rode a bike as a passenger once in a while...and she would wear a dastraar. One fine day an overzealous malay policeman deemd it fit to give my mum a Summons as LADIES are not exempted from the Law. My mum went to see the Officer and after an explanation he cancelled the summons BUT also advised that HIS MAN was also techincally RIGHT in issuing the summons and COULD do it again. When that cop saw his summons cancelled he took it upon himslef to pass by our house many times a day waiting for an opportun ity to issue a summons if he caught my mum.....and this ca and mouse game went on for many years until the cop got transferrd out. MOST malaysian SIKH FEMALES take the easy way out and wear a CRASH HELMET. The whole of Kuala Lumpur has I think only ONE female SIKH dastarr wearer. After the SIKHS got exemption....the Muslim HAJIS who normally wear a SKULL CAP also demanded and got the same EXEMPTION basing their demand on the exemption given to SIKHS. The SKULL CAP hardly covers the top of the head...but they are exempted anyway. Thus the SIKHS themselves LOST a valuable opportunity to GET Exemption to ALL SIKHS - if DASTAAR had been specified for BOTH sexes. If this had been done...any Sikh Lady even if she wrapped her chunni around her ehad as a DASTAAR would have been exempted ( achunni is defintely bigger than a skull cap) A FULL DASTAAR would be nice...but until this is adopted a "chunni dastaar" would have served its purpose IF such exemption had been sought. A SIKH is totally BANNED from wearing a Hat/helmet of any sort... Now its too late. Jarnail Singh

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Kulbir Singh · 26 Sep 2004

Excellent statement by Professor Kirpal Singh Badungar - Ex President of SGPC. I wish he had headed SGPC instead of Bibi Jagir Kaur. Professor Badungar would have been the best choice for this position. Daas, Kulbir Singh PM’s claim on turban row an eyewash, says Badungar Our Correspondent Phagwara, September 26 Former SGPC president and a co-opted SGPC member Prof Kirpal Singh Badungar Prof today said that nine minister PM Dr Manmohan Singh’s claim that the turban now in France was resolved was an eye wash. He made this claims in New York yesterday. Prof Badungar said that the French Government had allowed Sikh students to wear a particular type of headgear in place of turban. He said he had verified today from France and Germany about it and was told by Sikhs there that the issue stood still unresolved, he claimed. Talking to mediapersons here this afternoon, Prof Badungar asserted that the so-called discreet patqa, as the French authorities call it, can not be a substitute for turban. Turban was an integral part of the religious symbol, dress code and maryada of Sikhs, he asserted. The Gurus had ordained Sikhs to be “sabat soorat dastar sira” (to have unshorn hair and turbans on heads), he continued. The patqa was not acceptable, as it violated the Sikh ethos and maryada, he asserted.

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 26 Sep 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. SIKHS have no one on their side. This should be clear by now. many had fat hopes on Manmohan Singh "SIKH" PM of India.....others relied on Tarlochan Singh "SIKH" minority Commission Chairman India...yet others relied on Jogender Singh vedanti/Akal Takhat/SGPC/Badal etc to come to their aid that thye be allowed to wear the DASTAAR as per Sikh Rehat maryada.....ALL HOPES have been dashed. ALL have wept "crocodile tears", put dhoor into our eyes...lulled us into a false sense of security that all problems will be solved....in the West to people like Rajwant Singh, many others highly placed came to France to "solve" the problem..some said lets not stress on "religious" grounds but call Dsataar SOCIAL necessity and this will "escape" the religious intent of the French law.....all these were straws in the wind...in the end nothing materialised. I agree with veer Kulbir Singh Ji that Prof> bandunagar has made a correct stand....BUT lets not forget that he is NOT in a position of POWER ( SGPC President etc..)...His RESPONSE may substantially differ IF he is in POWER !!! A man or woman OUT of OFFICE can say and do many things which he/she will NEVER say or do if elected. This is essentially the reason why the AKALIS talk "DIFFERENTLY" when they are in GOVT and "differently" when they lose power and are in opposition....IN OPPOSITION they will shout: We will FREE all innocent Sikh Youths in jails, We will STAMP out all corruption, We will introduce Punjabi everywehere...We will never let a single drop of Punjab Water go out, we will NOT ...this.... we will NOT...this and that...BUT let them WIN and form the GOVT and not a peep out of them about all these demands until FIVE years are over and they LOSE...then they will suddenly get back their MEMORY !! I can bet my last bottom dollar bandunagar wouldnt have given this statement IF he was SGPC President.....this statement would have come from Bibi Ji "jagir kaur.... The ONLY solutuion is For the Guru Khalsa panth to do SELF SUDHAAR, instead of saying "Hum Hindu nahin" we should be asking: hum SIKH HAIN ??" I dont think the Dastaaar "problem" would ahve surfaced IF every SIKH had made thsi an essential part of his religion. Once people realise we have our values..they will respect them. Dass jarnail singh

Re: Sikh students can wear patka, says French envoy

Kulbir Singh · 27 Sep 2004

I am glad that SNO has taken a rigid stand on the issue of Sikhs' right to wear Dastaar. As I mentioned before, the Sikhs from France should emigrate to countries like Canada and UK and apply for political assylum (refugee status) for harrassment they are facing in France. This will really hurt the ego of France that claims to be a champion of human rights. And your points in the last post under this thread are well taken. Daas, Kulbir Singh Sikh body stays put on turban issue Our Correspondent Patiala, September 27 The Sikh Nation Organisation (SNO) today refused to accept any compromise on the right to wear turban and religious symbols and decided to intensify its stir against turban ban by the French Government. The organisation urged the French Sikhs to refuse any concession by the French Government to fund education of their children in private schools and offered to fund their education with the help of Sikh saints and voluntary organisations. The president of the SNO, Dr Manjit Singh Randhawa, said the SNO would leave no stone unturned to restore the right to wear turban, religious dress and symbols of French Sikh students. In a petition submitted to Mr Jean Ping, president of the, 59th UN General Assembly and Mr Valeriy P. Kuchinsky, Chairman, Social Humantarian and Cultural Committee for UN General Assembly’s 59th session, the UNO requested for urgent intervention of the UN to protect the human rights of school-going children in France